Print Article: Alternative medicine crackdown

http://www.smh.com.au/action/printArticle?id=3124040

Print this article |

Close this window

Alternative medicine crackdown

Julia Medew
Published: March 14, 2012 - 10:21AM

Homeopaths are facing a fight to defend their practice in Australia after the National Health and Medical Research
Council flagged it might declare their work baseless and unethical.
A draft public statement seen by The Age concluded it was ''unethical for health practitioners to treat patients using
homeopathy, for the reason that homeopathy (as a medicine or procedure) has been shown not to be efficacious''.
The confidential statement, which was not meant to be distributed, is based on a 2010 evaluation of homeopathy by the
British House of Commons science and technology committee, which declared it was no more efficacious than a placebo.
Homeopathy is based on the principles of ''like-cures-like'' and ''ultra-dilutions''. The first says substances that can cause
symptoms can be used in diluted form to treat the same symptom in an illness, and the second says the more dilute a
substance is, the more potent it is.
While homeopathy continues to enjoy the support of Britain's royal family and is funded through the UK's National
Health Service, the House of Commons report found its principles were ''theoretically weak'' and ''scientifically
implausible''.
The draft statement by Australia's National Health and Medical Research Council said that although homeopathy was not
harmful in its own right, it might pose a risk to patients if safe and efficacious conventional treatments were delayed in
favour of homeopathic treatments.
It said homeopathy, which uses a large range of animal, plant and mineral products, should not be confused with herbal
remedies.
A council spokesman would not comment on the draft, but said it was reviewing the efficacy of complementary and
alternative medicines, including homeopathy, and would release its findings in due course.
Australian Medical Association president Steve Hambleton backed the council's draft statement. He said he hoped it
would force health insurers to reconsider their funding of homeopathy, as well as other ''questionable'' therapies such as
iridology and reflexology.
''I think it will put them in a very difficult situation If the NHMRC looks at the evidence and says this doesn't work,
we can't support it, you'd have to ask the insurers if they will continue to fund something that a very reputable body
disagrees with,'' he said.
The Australian Association of Professional Homeopaths Inc says 47 health insurers, including Medibank Private and
NIB, cover homeopathic consultations and medicines.
Australian Homeopathic Association president Greg Cope said there was strong evidence to support the practice,
including clinical trials that were now being submitted to the NHMRC for consideration.
He said there were about 700 registered homeopaths in Australia under a self-governed registration model, and they
worked to a code of conduct. Consultations typically cost $50 to $100, with medicines usually costing a further $10.
Mr Cope said he had been lobbying Canberra to set up a formal registration scheme, similar to those for doctors and
nurses. He said health insurers were wise to fund homeopathy, which was used by thousands of Australians. ''It's a very
popular therapy and I imagine it would reduce their expenses because it attracts people using low-cost healthcare,'' he
said.
Writing in the Journal of Law and Medicine this week, Melbourne barrister Ian Freckleton, SC, said several recent deaths
involving homeopaths highlighted the dangers involved when they steered people away from conventional medicine.

1 of 2

27/08/2015 8:52 AM

Print Article: Alternative medicine crackdown

http://www.smh.com.au/action/printArticle?id=3124040

Dr Freckleton cited the case of Perth woman Penelope Dingle, who died from bowel cancer in 2005 after spending about
$30,000 on unsuccessful homeopathic treatments, including extracts from the venus flytrap plant.
He also cited the death in 2009 of Gloria Thomas, age nine months, after her parents favoured homeopathy over
conventional medicine for severe eczema.
Dr Freckleton said although many aspects of Western medicine had not been able to stand up to full scientific analysis of
their underpinnings over time, there was an ''urgent need'' for the health sector, consumer protection authorities and
policymakers to protect the community from dangerous homeopathic practices.
He said homeopaths had used crushed-up pieces of the Berlin Wall to treat depression.
And in the latest edition of the journal Spectrum of Homeopathy, the authors detailed the use of wolf's milk for eczema
and bulimia, cheetah's blood for multiple sclerosis and tiger's blood for depression. ''It's quite remarkable,'' he said.
jmedew@theage.com.au
Follow the National Times on Twitter: @NationalTimesAU
This story was found at: http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/alternative-medicine-crackdown-20120313-1uyiw.html

2 of 2

27/08/2015 8:52 AM