Engr180 Communication PDF

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 35

11/6/2015

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Engineering 180
System Engineering
Dr. John D. Olsen, PE
Thales-Raytheon Systems LLC
jdolsen@raytheon.com
(Cell) 714.402.3395
Copyright
Copyright2015
2015John
JohnOlsen
Olsen- All
- AllRights
RightsReserved
Reserved

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Lecture 1
Case Study: Communication Systems

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

John Olsen Introduction

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Retired from Raytheon Corporation. Last Position:


Technical Director, Thales-Raytheon Systems LLC.
The U.S. operations of the Raytheon-Thales
trans-Atlantic joint venture company.
40 years of engineering and business leadership experience spanning
Communications, Command and Control and Radar systems.
UCLA, Anderson School, Executive Management Program Graduate,
January 1997.
USC, Ph.D., Electrical Engineering, June 1978.
USC, Engineer, Electrical Engineering, June 1976.
USC, MS, Electrical Engineering, January 1975.
Newark College of Engineering, BSEE (Summa Cum Laude), June 1973.
BoD INCOSE 1995-1996
President, Greater Los Angeles Chapter, AUSA 2002-2004
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

Question?
SYSTEM ENGINEERING

What comes to your mind with the words


Communications System?

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

21st Century Communication System


Examples

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Cell Phones
Satellite Radio (XM and Sirius)
Satellite TV/HDTV (e.g., DirecTV, DishNet)
Internet/World-Wide Web
Blackberry & Smartphones
Voice over IP (VoIP)

Google images

Fiber Optics
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Comm Segment Overview

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Objectives:
Illustrate principles of complex system design
through communications example
Direct Broadcast Satellite Television (e.g.,
DirecTV, DishNet)

Learn about Communications Technologies that


are familiar to you

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

Outline Communications Case Study

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Lecture 1 Communication System Introduction and


Basics

Evolution of Communications in defense and commercial


applications
Communications System Definition
Communications Modes
Electromagnetic Spectrum & Radio Frequency Spectrum
Radio Wave Propagation Loss, Rain Loss, Terrain Loss
Antennas
Data Rate and Bandwidth
Analog and Digital Signals

Lecture 2-4 Communications System Engineering


Example Direct Broadcast Satellite Television
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Communications Systems Definition


SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Definition of Communications System

Provide the capability to transfer


Information(1) between sender(s)
and a distant receiver(s) at the speed
of light(2)
1. Information may be voice, text, facsimile, video,
computer-to-computer, sensors, etc.
2. Speed of light = 186,000 miles per second or 3 x 108
meters per second
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Communications System Chronology


SYSTEM ENGINEERING

1838
1876
1895
1900s
1920
1948
1954
1960
1960s
1963
1969
1970s
System
1977
1982

Time Line for Communication System

Telegraph (Samuel Morse) Wired


Telephone (Alexander Gram Bell) Wired
Marconi Wireless Telegraph
Telephones in Cities with Patch Panel
Switchboards
Broadcast AM Radio
Television, Black and White
Television, Color (NTSC)
LASER
Broadcast FM Radio
Geo-Synchronous Satellite (SYNCOM)
ARPA Net (UCLA, Leonard Klienrock)
PCM Telephone System, Electronic Switching
Fiber Optic Communications
International Maritime Satellite (INMARSAT)

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

Communications System Chronology (Contd)

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

1980s-1995

Global Positioning System (GPS)

1983

Analog Cell Phones (AMPS)

1994

DirecTVTM

1990s

Digital Cell Phones (TDMA, CDMA)

1998

Iridium Satellite Phones

2001

Global Packet Radio System (i.e., Blackberry)

2001-2002

XM and Sirius Satellite radio

2002

Broadcast HD Radio and Broadcast HD TV

2004

HD DirecTV

2000s

VoIP (VonageTM, EarthlinkTM, SkypeTM, etc.)

2009

Only Digital Broadcast Television (DTV)

2011

4G (Long Term Evolution) Cellular System

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Military Communications Evolution

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

1861-1865 Flag Signaling in Civil War (Birth of Army Signal Corps)


1880s

Field Telegraph Keys with Rolls of Wire

1900s

High Frequency (HF) Radio (Long Distance Morse Code and voice)

1920s

Ground to Ground VHF Radios

1940s

Airborne UHF radio service

1950s

Defense Switched Network

1970s

Defense Satellite Communications System (DSCS)

1980s

MilStar EHF

1994

Tactical Internet

1990s

UHF Follow-on

1990s

Global Information GIG; Defense version of WWW

2008

Wideband Gap-Filler Satellite System

2012

Mobile User Objective System (MUOS)

2020+?

Tactical Satellite System

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Question?
SYSTEM ENGINEERING

What would you think would be unique


requirements of a Military or Defense
Communications System?

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

Example Military Communication System


Requirements

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

System requirements for military communication systems

Confidentiality (secrecy, protection from Eavesdropping)


Authentication of source and non-alterable message content
(protection from spoofing)
Operate without Infrastructure (e.g., Cell towers)
Covert (hid the signal from interception; e.g., Special Op units)
Protection from Direction Finding and Location
Protection from Brut-Force Jamming (Electronic Warfare)
Protection from Sophisticated Attacks Just like Internet Hackers
(called Information Warfare)
Redundancy (no single point of failure)
Are These Requirements Really Unique to the Military vs Commercial?
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Communication Evolution Drivers

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Bell Laboratories through 1983


Breakup of ATT
Defense Department (in particular
Defense Advanced Research Agency
DARPA)
Telecom and Dot-Com Boom 1980s
and 1990s
Bell Labs and the Defense Department led the developments
In Communications up to the 1980, but now the Commercial
Telecommunications Industry far out invests the DoD
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Radio Frequency and Wave Length

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Wave Length and Radio Frequency

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

Electromagnetic Spectrum
SYSTEM ENGINEERING

700

600

500

400

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

The Radio Frequency (RF) Spectrum


SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Radio Frequency (DirecTV)

Broadcast
TV

AM
Radio

Cell
Services GPS

FM
Radio

XM Radio
DirecTV

0.3

3
LF

30

300

HF

3,000

VHF

UHF

30,000
SHF

300,000
EHF

Mega-Cycles per Second (Mega-Hertz, MHz)

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Radio Wave Propagation

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Equations for Radio Wave Propagation

PTX = Transmitter Power in Watts


AEff = Effective Antenna Area in m2
dm = Distance (radius) in meters
= Wavelength in meters
G = Antenna Gain

AEff
dm
PTX

PAVE =

PRX = PAVE AEff


= PTX

4dm

Free Space Propagation loss = L =

G =
2

PTX
4d2m

Watts/m2

4AEff
2

G
2

4dm

C
F

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

Free Space Propagation Loss


Free Space Propagation loss = L

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

4dm

C
F

Signal Power Levels are expressed in deci-Bells or dBs;


PdB = 10 Log (P)
Propagation Loss in dB = 32.4 + 20Log(dKm) + 20Log (FMHz)

Example: Using the equations above compute the free space


propagation loss for a radio signal at 12.5 GHz and for a distance
of 40,000 Km. Compute as both a loss number in scientific
notation and in deci-Bells
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Exploded View of Broadcast TV Spectrum

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

Economic Value of Spectrum

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Economic Value of Spectrum

United States 2008 wireless spectrum auction From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
The United States 700 MHz FCC wireless spectrum auction, officially known as Auction
73,[1] was started by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) on January 24,
2008 for the rights to operate the 700 MHz frequency band in the United States.
Original usage The 700 MHz spectrum was previously used for analog television
broadcasting, specifically UHF channels 52 through 69. The FCC has ruled that the
switch to digital television has made these frequencies no longer necessary for
broadcasters, due to the improved spectral efficiency of digital broadcasts
Results of the auction
Auction 73 generally went as planned by telecommunications analysts. In total, Auction 73
raised $19.592 billion. Notably, Verizon Wireless and AT&T Mobility together
accounted for $16.3 billion of the total revenue.

$>$100 Billion in federal revenues generated


since 1993 by FCC spectrum license auctions
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Communications Modes 1

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Communication Model 1

Ground Wave
Examples:
CB Radio
PRS

Radio Waves
Refracted Back
to Earth

Sky Wave

Ionosphere

Examples:
Amateur
Ham Radio
Voice of America
Broadcast Radio
AM Broadcast
Clear Channels

Earth

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Communications Modes 2
SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Communication Model 2

Airborne
Radio

Antenna
Tower

Line-of-Sight
Microwave

Mobile Radio
Scattering
Environment
Cell Base
Station
Tower

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

Communications Modes 3

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Communication Mode 3

Satellite Communications
SATCOM

Telecommunications
DirecTVTM
XM RadioTM
IridiumTM

Co-Axial Cable

Twisted Wire Pair

Cable Television
Telephone Local Loop
Digital Subscriber Line (DSL)

Fiber Optic Cable


Backbone of WWW
Coming to Homes (FTTH)

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Key Terms

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

F = Carrier Frequency of the Signal


B = Bandwidth of the Signal
Note Bandwidth of Signal Generally < 10% of Carrier Frequency
Information Rate (ie, Data Rate) ~ Bandwidth
Examples
AM Radio @ 1 MHz
VHF Radio @ 88 MHz
UHF Radio at 300 MHz
FM Radio (88-108 MHz)
Broadcast Television (49- 960 MHz)
Coaxial Cable (e.g., cable TV)
Fiber cable of Laser Comm

3 KHz Bandwidth
25 KHz Bandwidth
50 KHz Bandwidth
180 KHz Bandwidth
6 MHz Bandwidth
~ 2 GHz Bandwidth
10 Giga Bits per Second (OC-192)

Note the Radio Frequency Spectrum is a Very Valuable Resource; FCC


auctions of Spectrum for Cell service in Major markets have gone for
100s of Million to 10s of Billions of Dollars
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Antenna Gain Concept

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Ideal
3.6
3.6
Pencil Beam
100 x 50 = 104/2= 37 dB Gain

Real World
Antenna Gain refers to the
ability to focus the energy in
a direction and it is measured
by the Gain G relative to an
Isotropic antenna

Main Lobe
35 dB Gain

1st Side Lobes


Down 25 dB;
< 1:200th

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

Antenna Examples
SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Whip

Parabolic Dish
Feed Active Element
Reflector

Yagi TV
Antenna

Definition of Parabola
Example DirecTV
Elevation BW 3
Azimuth BW 3

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Atmospheric Attenuation of Radio WavesSYSTEM ENGINEERING

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Frequency Selection Trade-Space


SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Propagation Loss ( Increased Range)

Bandwidth (Information Carrying Capacity)

Gain and Directivity for fixed Aperture Area

Electronics (Historically)

Lower Frequency
favored

Higher Frequency
favored

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

10

11/6/2015

Analog Comm Signals


SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Analog Modulation Information is embedded onto the


carrier signal with a continuous range of values
Amplitude Modulation (AM)
AM - Information is Carried
in the Amplitude of the
Signal
Examples:
Broadcast AM Radio
Television Video

Frequency Modulation (FM)


FM - Information is Carried
in the Frequency of the
Signal
Examples:
FM Broadcast Radio
Television Audio
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Digital Comm Signals

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Information is Digital from a fixed and limited Alphabet


Binary (0,1 or -1,+1)
Octal (0 to 7 or 000, 001, 111)

Frequency-Shift Keying (FSK)

0
RF Carrier
Frequency

Phase-Shift Keying (PSK)

0
- Delta F

+ Delta F

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Advantages of Digital Comm

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Perfect Recovery of Signal


(noise is not additive with repeaters)
For sufficient Signal-to-Noise Ration (SNR)
Powerful Error Control Coding can be utilized

Can Exploit Sophisticated Source Encoding


(e.g., MP3, MPEG, JPEG, etc.)
Digital does not degrade slowly like analog
it either works or does not ( steep receiver
operating curve) Example DirecTV
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11

11/6/2015

Why is FM Radio Superior to AM Radio?

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Higher Information Bandwidth (20 KHz vs 3


KHz) High Fidelity
Higher Carrier Bandwidth (200 KHz vs 10
KHz)
FM is more noise immune Noise Signal
Amplitude can be eliminated as only the
signals frequency variations carry the
information
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

References

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

1. Radio Wikipedia
2. Radio System Design for
Telecommunications (1 100 GHz) Roger L.
Freeman, John Wiley & Sons, 1987

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

READING ASSIGNMENTS
SYSTEM ENGINEERING

For Session 2
1. Review Course Briefings on System
Engineering (Dr Kung, Weeks 1-3)
2. Review Communications Background in
Comm Lecture 1
3. Web search (eg, Google) and read, DirecTV
- Wikipedia

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

12

11/6/2015

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Engineering 180
System Engineering
Lecture 2
Dr. John D. Olsen, PE
Thales-Raytheon Systems LLC
jdolsen@raytheon.com
(Office) 714.446.4299
(Cell) 714.402.3395
Copyright
Copyright2015
2015John
JohnOlsen
Olsen- All
- AllRights
RightsReserved

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Lectures 2
Case Study: Communication Systems

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Outline Communications Case Study

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Lecture 1 Communication System Introduction and Basics

Lecture 2 Communications System Engineering


Example Direct Broadcast Satellite Television
Operational Architecture View (OV-1)
Gate Briefings for Management Go-ahead
Solving the Key Technical Challenges
Complex Systems Engineering Lessons Learned

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

Conceptualizing a Direct Broadcast Satellite


Television Service Operational View (OV-1)
200 Channels of High
Quality Digital
Television

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Geo-Stationary Orbit
High Power Satellite Bus
DBS Transponders

100 Channels Pay-perView

Full CONUS Coverage


Higher Reliability than
Cable TV
Advanced Anti-Piracy
Security
Growth to HDTV

Small Customer
Receiving Antenna

Satellite UpLink &


Program Facility

Pay per View Billing Link

Affordable, User Friendly


User Receiver/Terminal

Telephone

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Top System Engineering Challenges of DBS


Television
SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Link Power-Bandwidth Budget from GeoOrbit Satellite to Small User Receiver


Antenna
High Data Rate of Digital Television
Electronics Complexity and Cost of User
Equipment
How did the team develop a Balanced and
Economically Viable System Design?
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Recall from Dr Pao


What is System Engineering?

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

System Engineering is an interdisciplinary,


comprehensive approach to solving complex
problems and satisfying stakeholder
requirements.
Interdisciplinary: team approach (concurrent
engineering, integrated product team), broad
knowledge
Approach: Not an exact science
Stakeholder requirements: Who are the
stakeholders? The requirements are multidimensional
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

SE Concepts to be demonstrated by DBS Case Study


SYSTEM ENGINEERING

New Concept Visualization from the Convergence of


Multiple Enabling Technologies
Need for Systems Engineers & Architects to Rapidly
Assess Broad Input Data into Tradeoffs and Alternative
Decisions
Systems-of-Systems Engineering
Iterative Process of Systems Engineering

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

What is a Senior Systems Engineer? Architect?


Technical Director?
SYSTEM ENGINEERING
Johns View An Individual with Broad Engineering, Management and Creative
Skills High Depth X Breadth Product
Engineering Skills
Depth and Breadth of Technical Skills
Engineering, Science or Math formal education
Significant understanding of many disciplines (analysis, hardware, software,
electrical design, mechanical design, Industrial engineering/production
engineering, specialty engineering, human factors)
Management Skills
Leadership
Communications
Customer Understanding
Marketing
Governement and Public Relations
Business and Finance
Visionary Creativity Visualize the Possibilities
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Nationwide Subscription Television Service


Functional Baseline
SYSTEM ENGINEERING
Programming

Distribution

User/Home
Receiving
and Decoding

Logging
Subscriber
Management
and Billing

Usage
Reporting
Potential Physical Architectures

1. Cable
2. DBS
3. Aerostat Fleet
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

DBS Management Proposal Gate 1 (Hypothetical)

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

circa early 1991

Johns 3 Questions to Address


What Direct Broadcast Satellite Television Service

System Developer and Service Provider (ie, a New Line of Business)

How

Leverage HS-601 High Power Satellite Bus, Military Global


Broadcast Service (GBS) Experience and Worlds Leading Provider of
Communications Satellites Capabilities
Obtain Pioneer Preference License for the Orbital Slots and Frequency
Allocations
Estimated 3 Years to Initial Service Capability; $500M Development
Costs

Why ROI Project >$1B Business within 3 Years of


Operation
This is the type of Proposal that gets our interest. Proceed to Gate 2.
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Gate 2 (Pursue) Direct Broadcast Satellite Television


Business Proposition circa 1991
SYSTEM ENGINEERING

1. Concept Overview, OV-1


2. Top Level Stakeholder Requirements
3. Initial Business Assessment
4. Investment Cash Flow
5. Risk Assessment
6. Recommendation

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Conceptualizing a Direct Broadcast Satellite


Television Service Operational View (OV-1)
200 Channels of High
Quality Digital
Television

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Geo-Stationary Orbit
High Power Satellite Bus
DBS Transponders

100 Channels Pay-perView

Full CONUS Coverage


Higher Reliability than
Cable TV
Advanced Anti-Piracy
Security
Growth to HDTV

Small Customer
Receiving Antenna

Satellite UpLink &


Program Facility

Pay per View Billing Link

Affordable, User Friendly


User Receiver/Terminal

Telephone

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

Initial Top Level Stakeholder Requirements


SYSTEM ENGINEERING

HS-601 High Power Satellite Bus


200 Channels of High Quality Digital Television

From 10 Ft Dia.

100 Channels Pay-per-View

Full CONUS Coverage


Dazzling Picture Quality
Small User/Home Antenna Size (<= 18 inches)
Small VCR Size Television Top Box, Receiver
User Receiver Cost Initial Less than $500
Can be Installed by Homeowner
Higher Reliability than Cable TV
Advanced Anti-Piracy Security
Growth to HDTV
Leverage GBS Experience in IIS Division
<= 3 years to Develop and IOC (Initial Operational
Capability)
Cost to Implement < $2B
Maximum Cash Required of $1B

To 18 Inch Dia

*Note - hypothetical

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Gate 2 Aside
Commercial Business Perspective - ROI

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Expected Cash Flow*

($M)
SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Expenditures and Revenue


DBS Payload Development (Qty =2)
Satellite Bus Builds (Qty =2)
Satellite Launch (Qty =2)
Facilities and Business Sytems
Operations
Calendar Year Expenditures
Cummulative Expenditures
Revenue
Cummulative Revenue
Net Cash Flow

Cash Flow
1991

1992

1993

1994

1995

1996

1997

1998

1999

50
50
10
50
0
160
160
0
0
-160

200
200
40
100
0
540
700
0
0
-700

200
200
60
100
20
580
1280
0
0
-1280

50
50
40
50
50
240
1520
150
150
-1370

75
75
1595
300
450
-1145

100
100
1695
600
1050
-645

125
125
1820
1200
2250
430

125
125
1945
2400
4650
2705

125
125
2070
4800
9450
7380

0.25

0.5

Subscribers by Year

*Note - hypothetical
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

DBS Television Business - Risk Assessment


RISK

Current Risk
Assessment

Satellite Orbit Slot


and Frequencies
200 Channel
Capacity
Satellite Prime
Power
Satellite Weight
Anti- Piracy
Security
User Receiver/
Decoder Cost
User Installation
Capable

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Mitigation Strategy

Expected
Closure Date

Submit Pioneer Preference License in 60 Days


Engage WDC HQ Office in Lobbying Campaign
Create Compression Technology Laboratory
Engage Motion Pictures Experts Group (MPEG)
Develop and Track Detailed Power Budget & Forecast
Form Multidiscipline 6-Sigma Team to Work Budget
Develop and Track Detailed Weight Budget & Forecast
Form Multidiscipline 6-Sigma Team to Work Budget
Leverage Expertise in Defense Sector of Company
Hire Information Security Experts and Consultants
Partner with Commercial Electronics Companies
Moores Law
Design Built-in Set-up Tools
Conduct User Installation Trials

12 Months
30 Months
9 Months
18 Months
24 Months
12 Months
18 Months

*Note - hypothetical
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Gate 2 Direct Broadcast Satellite Television Business


Proposition - Recommendations
SYSTEM ENGINEERING
Continue to Preliminary Design Review and Market & Business Plan Dev.
Assign Key Engineering Team to Address Technical Challenges and
Alternatives
Assign Key Team to Develop Plan, including schedule, costs, key staffing and risk
identification and mitigation plans

Decisions and Action Items


Decision to Go-Forward through PDR and Business Plan Development
John Smith will be re-assigned immediately to full time as Program Manager; Dr
Bill Jones reassigned full time as Technical Director
Specifically Address Strategic Partnering Plan for Programming and User
Equipment
Engineering and functional manager are directed that this project has highest
priority and all support requests from Mr. Smith and Dr. Jones are to be honored
Budget is $5M; Report back in 3 months
VP Marketing to Enlist Outside Marketing Firm to Independently Assess DBS TV
Price & Feature elasticity Market Size & Revenue Projections
Government Relations Director and Staff in Washington DC is directed to give
highest priority to resolving any FCC issues wrt to the DBS Pioneer Preference
License
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Geo Stationary Satellite

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

DirecTV Satellite is
Geo-Stationary at
101 West Longitude

Axis
Equator
Sun
Geo-Stationary
Orbital Plane
22,250
Miles

Orbital height is computed


using Keplers laws of
Orbital Motion

Earths Orbit of Sun

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

Homework Assignment
SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Technical Performance Measures (TPM)


Define one TPM for each of:
DTV System Level
Satellite Subsystem
Receiver Decoder Unit

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

References

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

1. Direct Broadcast Satellite Communications,


An MPEG Enabled service, Donald C. Mead.
Addison-Wesley Wireless Communications
Series, Upper Saddle River, NJ 2000
2. DirecTV - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
3. Radio System Design for
Telecommunications (1 100 GHz), Roger L.
Freeman, John Wiley & Sons, 1987

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Engineering 180
System Engineering
Lecture 3
Dr. John D. Olsen, PE
Thales-Raytheon Systems LLC
jdolsen@raytheon.com
(Office) 714.446.4299
Copyright
2015
Copyright
2015John
JohnOlsen
Olsen- All
- AllRights
RightsReserved
Reserved (Cell) 714.402.3395

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Lecture 3
Case Study: Communication Systems

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Outline Communications Case Study

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Lecture 1 Communication System Introduction and Basics

Lecture 2-4 Communications System Engineering


Example Direct Broadcast Satellite Television
Operational Architecture View (OV-1)
Gate Briefings for Management Go-ahead
Solving the Key Technical Challenges
Complex Systems Engineering Lessons Learned

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

DBS Radio Frequencies and Orbital Slots

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

WARC and RARCs Determine RF Frequency Spectrum Allocations Major


meetings every 5 Years
WARC World Administrative Radio Council
RARC Regional Administrative Radio Council (eg, Western Hemisphere is
Region 2)

1977 WARC Allocated Frequencies and Orbital Slots to DBS


Orbital Spacing of 9 degrees between Orbital Slot Clusters

1983 RARC Confirmed Allocation for Region 2

Eight Orbital Positions (Full CONUS - 101, 110 and 119 degrees West Longitude)
Frequency Allocation 17.3 17.8 GHz Uplink; 12.2 12.7 GHz Downlink
32 Frequency Channels for each orbital slot @ 24 MHz
EIRP maximum 57 dBW

Note Vision in 1977 and 1983 was each 24 MHz Frequency Channel would
support 1 Color Television Channel for total of 32 Color Channels
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Communications Satellite and Transponders


SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Solar Power
Arrays

Payload Transponders
Bent Pipe
Frequency
Translator

Downlink

Uplink

17.317.8 GHz

12.212.7 GHz

Uplink has High Signal Power and Gain


Downlink Determines the Received SNR
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Frequency Division Multiple Access

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Transponders cover one Channel


16 Channels each of 24 Mhz bandwidth times 2 Polarizations

Guard
Band
Frequency
Frequency Allocation = 500 MHz

Guard band used to control & reduce interference between channels

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

Radio Wave Propagation encore

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

PTX = Transmitter Power in Watts


AEff = Effective Antenna Area in m2
dm = Distance (radius) in meters
= Wavelength in meters
G = Antenna Gain

AEff
dm
PTX

PAVE =

PRX = PAVE AEff


= PTX

4dm

Free Space Propagation loss = L =

G =
2

PTX
4d2m

Watts/m2

4AEff
2

G
2

4dm

C
F

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Distance to DBS Satellite*

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Satellite to Equator 22,250 Miles or 37,200 Km


Slant Range from Satellite to Receiver for
CONUS
@ Minimum Elevation (27 degrees North Latitude)
= 38,257 Km
@ Maximum Elevation (54 degrees North Latitude)
= 40,324 Km

*Reference 1, Page 35
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Propagation Loss Example CalculationSYSTEM ENGINEERING


Using the equations below compute the free space
propagation loss for a radio signal at 12.45 GHz and
for a distance of 40,324 Km. Compute the
propagation loss as a number and in deciBells
Propagation loss = L
=

4dm

C
F

Propagation Loss in dB = 32.4 + 20Log(dKm) + 20Log (FMHz)

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

Communications Range

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

If the Signal Propagates Forever in Free Space, then what limits the range?
Propagation Loss LP

GTX

Noise = Thermal Noise (K T B)


Where:
K = Boltzmans Constant
(1.38 X 10-23 Joules/Degree Kelvin)
T = Temperature in Degrees Kelvin
B = Bandwidth

GRX
LRX
PRX , NRX

PTX
Transmitter

Noise

Receiver

Interference

In dB

PRX = PTX + GTX LP + GRX - LRX

Noise Power Received = NRX = 10 Log (KTB) + Pinterference


Received Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) Power Ratio Determines the Quality of the
Received Signal
SNR = PRX - NRX = PTX + GTX - LP + GRX - LRX - 10 Log (KTB) - PInterference

Receiver Operating Curve Determine Performance for a Given SNR (depends on


signal modulation technique, including analog or digital)

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

DBS to Home Receiver Link Analysis


Link Element

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Value Units Comments

EIRP

53

dBw

Path Loss at 12.45 GHz

-206.45

dB

Power at Receiver Antenna

-153.45

dBw

Gain of Receiver Dish Antenna

32.355

dB

Power at Receiver

-121.1

dBw

KT @ 125 degrees Kelvin

-207.6 dBW /Hz

B @ 24 MHz

73.8

KTB

-133.8

Signal Power to Noise Power Ratio

12.7

EIRP maximum 57 dBW by Regional


Administrative Radio Council (RARC)
to Continental US (per earlier
calculation)

See reference 1, page 37

Boltzman' Constant, 125 degreee Kelvin


Sky Temperature

dB-Hz
dBw
dB

Note: +3 dB or 15.7 dB for 56 dBw


Power Transmitter

What Data Rate and Error Rate Would this SNR Provide?
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Receiver Operating Curves

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

DTV
Coding Gain

QPSK Modulation and Error. Correcting Codes. By: Michael DeLucca. Temple University. For : EE 551 Prof James A Brennan. May 7, 2003 ...

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

Need for Link Margin for Rain Attenuation

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Reference 1, page 46

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

DBS Broadcast Antenna Design


Multi-disciplinary Engineering Elegance

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Reference 1, page 45

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Basic Digital Communication Link Elements

Demod- Channel Information


ulator Decoder Decoder

Source Channel
Encoder Encoder Modulator
RF
e.g.,
e.g.,
MPEG
RS
Encoder Encoder

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

e.g.,
FSK,
QPSK

Noise

RF

Interference

Digital Communications Systems Utilize Powerful


Source and Channel Coding Technologies

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

Source Channel Coding

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Objective to Most Efficiently Represent the Information


(Information Theory addresses how to measure the actual
information content and theoretical minimum data rate to
perfectly represent the data)
Eliminate Redundancy
Example - Usually not much has changed from one frame of Video to the next

No Data Periods (speech pauses, between Bursts of Data)

Huffman Coding Variable length Code-words are used so


that the Information which occurs more frequently are assigned
the shorter code words
Morse Code Examples
e is assigned .
i is . .
s is . . .
h is . . . .

t is a is . o is - - b is - . . .

n is - .

m is - -

x is - . . -

q is - - . -

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Source Coding continued

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Discussion Questions
Is Morse Code optimized for every language that uses the
alphabet?
How about Hawaiian?

Run-length Coding
Code the length of a string of 1s or 0s
1111111100111111111 would be 8 2 9
Very effective for facsimile

Discussion
Advantages of variable length code-words?
Disadvantages of variable length code-words?
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Digital Video Encoding

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Analog TV
4.2 MHz BW
30 Frames per Second
Color Red, Green & Blue Frames

500 X 480 Pixels/Frame


times

8 Bits Per Pixel

500 PIXELs per Scan Line

times

3 Color Frames
480 Active Lines
per Frame
Raster Scan or
CCD Readout

times

30 Frames Per Second


=
172.8 MBPS!!!!!

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

Digital Video Compression

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

30 Frames per Second


Color Red, Green & Blue Frames

Exploit
Spatial Redundancy
Inter-frame Redundancy

500 PIXELs per Scan Line

480 Active Lines


per Frame
Raster Scan or
CCD Readout

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

MPEG Video Coding

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

30 Frames per Second


Color Red, Green & Blue Frames

500 PIXELs per Scan Line

Color Transform R, G, B Y, Cr, Cb


Every 15th I - Frame
Intra-Frame Coding - Discrete Cosine
Transform (8 X 8 blocks)
Quantizer, run-length coding, Huffman
Coding
Intermediate P and B Frames Predictive
Coded Motion Compensation
Compression Ratios 40-60 !!!!

480 Active Lines


per Frame
Raster Scan or
CCD Readout

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

References

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

1. Direct Broadcast Satellite Communications,


An MPEG Enabled service, Donald C. Mead.
Addison-Wesley Wireless Communications
Series, Upper Saddle River, NJ 2000
2. DirecTV - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
3. Radio System Design for
Telecommunications (1 100 GHz), Roger L.
Freeman, John Wiley & Sons, 1987

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Engineering 180
System Engineering
Lecture 4
Dr. John D. Olsen, PE
Thales-Raytheon Systems LLC
jdolsen@raytheon.com
(Office) 714.446.4299
Copyright
2015
John
Olsen
- All
Rights
Reserved
Copyright
2015
John
Olsen
- All
Rights
Reserved (Cell) 714.402.3395

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Lecture 4
Case Study: Communication Systems

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Outline Communications Case Study

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Lecture 1 Communication System Introduction and Basics

Lecture 2-4 Communications System Engineering


Example Direct Broadcast Satellite Television
Operational Architecture View (OV-1)
Gate Briefings for Management Go-ahead
Solving the Key Technical Challenges
Complex Systems Engineering Lessons Learned

Lecture 4 Comm Case Study Review


Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

Channel Error Control Coding


SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Add Redundancy to Detect and Correct Errors


Error Detection Code
Parity Check Code 0110101 0
Detects all single errors and odd number or errors,
but cannot detect even number of errors nor correct
any errors

Error Correction Code


Add more redundancy so that you can detect and
correct errors
Example Hamming Codes
Single error 7,4 Hamming code adds 3 bits of
redundancy to every 4 bits of information
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Sophisticated Error Correction Codes

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Reed- Solomon Codes (non binary channel


information)
Example 31,15 RS Code: 15 32-ary Symbols + 16 32-ary
Redundancy Symbols
Can correct any pattern of 7 errors or any pattern where 2 x erasures +
# errors < 15

Convolutional Codes
Concatenated Codes codes applied on top of one
another
Typically Data is First Encoded by Reed Solomon Code
Then Interleaving or spreading-out of the symbols from the
same RS code word to mitigate burst errors
Then Typically a Convolutional Code is applied before being
sent over the channel
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Receiver Operating Curve for DirecTV


SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Coding Gain > 6 dB

DTV
Coding Gain

Reference 1, page 92

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

DBS Vision Technology Brought Together


to Make the Vision Realizable
High Power Satellite Bus

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

3800 Watts Prime Power

+
Efficient TWTs and LNAs

Close Link to 18 Antenna

+
Powerful Error Correction

6 dB Margin for Rain


(but 5-6 transponders for 1 Digital Channel)
6-7 Digital Channels per
Transponder
200+ Digital Channel DBS
Television System

+
MPEG 2 Compression

32 Transponders

Economically Viable System!


Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

What might be the Major Subsystem Elements and IPTs


to Perform the Detailed Design of DBS TV?
SYSTEM ENGINEERING
DBS TV
System
Launch
Services

Satellite
Bus

DBS
Payload

Comm
Analysis

Facilities

Antennas

Solar Cells

Propulsion

Transponders

Station
Keeping

Mechanical

Stabalization

Digital

Uplink

Compression

Ground Station

Programming

Reliability

Mechanical

Partnering &
Licensing

Security

Marketing

User Receiver
Decoder

Regulatory
Liaison

Software

TT&C

Antennas

Power
Mngmnt

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

DBS Case Study SE Lessons Learned


SYSTEM ENGINEERING

The Power of the Breadth of Knowledge Brought to


bear by the Experienced SEs and Multi-disciplinary
Teams
Business Case Presentation to Executive Management
Complex Systems Engineering Requires Domain
Knowledge, SE Discipline and Creativity
SE Leaders must possess Technical Knowledge,
Customer Understanding, Business Acumen and
Leadership Skills
Power of Back-of-the Envelope Analyses (rapid
analysis, synthesis, evaluation spirals)
Must have Experience to be an Effective Senior SE
Moores Law Whats cheaper comm or processing?
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Comm Case Study Recap and Expected Learnings

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

References

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

1. Direct Broadcast Satellite Communications,


An MPEG Enabled service, Donald C. Mead.
Addison-Wesley Wireless Communications
Series, Upper Saddle River, NJ 2000
2. DirecTV - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
3. Radio System Design for
Telecommunications (1 100 GHz), Roger L.
Freeman, John Wiley & Sons, 1987

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Engineering 180
System Engineering
Lecture 4
Dr. John D. Olsen, PE
Thales-Raytheon Systems LLC
jdolsen@raytheon.com
(Office) 714.446.4299
Copyright
2015
John
Olsen
- All
Rights
Reserved
Copyright
2015
John
Olsen
- All
Rights
Reserved (Cell) 714.402.3395

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Lecture 4
Case Study: Communication Systems

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Outline Communications Case Study

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Lecture 1 Communication System Introduction and Basics

Lecture 2-4 Communications System Engineering


Example Direct Broadcast Satellite Television
Operational Architecture View (OV-1)
Gate Briefings for Management Go-ahead
Solving the Key Technical Challenges
Complex Systems Engineering Lessons Learned

Lecture 4 Comm Case Study Review


Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

Channel Error Control Coding


SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Add Redundancy to Detect and Correct Errors


Error Detection Code
Parity Check Code 0110101 0
Detects all single errors and odd number or errors,
but cannot detect even number of errors nor correct
any errors

Error Correction Code


Add more redundancy so that you can detect and
correct errors
Example Hamming Codes
Single error 7,4 Hamming code adds 3 bits of
redundancy to every 4 bits of information
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Sophisticated Error Correction Codes

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Reed- Solomon Codes (non binary channel


information)
Example 31,15 RS Code: 15 32-ary Symbols + 16 32-ary
Redundancy Symbols
Can correct any pattern of 7 errors or any pattern where 2 x erasures +
# errors < 15

Convolutional Codes
Concatenated Codes codes applied on top of one
another
Typically Data is First Encoded by Reed Solomon Code
Then Interleaving or spreading-out of the symbols from the
same RS code word to mitigate burst errors
Then Typically a Convolutional Code is applied before being
sent over the channel
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

Receiver Operating Curve for DirecTV


SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Coding Gain > 6 dB

DTV
Coding Gain

Reference 1, page 92

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

DBS Vision Technology Brought Together


to Make the Vision Realizable
High Power Satellite Bus

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

3800 Watts Prime Power

+
Efficient TWTs and LNAs

Close Link to 18 Antenna

+
Powerful Error Correction

6 dB Margin for Rain


(but 5-6 transponders for 1 Digital Channel)
6-7 Digital Channels per
Transponder
200+ Digital Channel DBS
Television System

+
MPEG 2 Compression

32 Transponders

Economically Viable System!


Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

TPMs encore Flow-down of 200 Channel TPM


SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Satellite Level
Power Available to Transmitter, Watts
TWT Transmit Power
Transmitter/Antenna Loss

System Level
200 Channels
Full CONUS Coverage
600 MBPS @ 10-12 BER
Picture Compression Ratio
@ Picture Quality
Availability/Rain Margin

User Terminal Level


Antenna Gain
Amplifier Gain and
Noise Figure
Receiver Losses
Processing Power,
GFLOPs
Unit Cost
Development Time

Satellite UpLink & Program Facility


Content for 200 Channels
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

What might be the Major Subsystem Elements and IPTs


to Perform the Detailed Design of DBS TV?
SYSTEM ENGINEERING
DBS TV
System
Launch
Services

Satellite
Bus

DBS
Payload

Comm
Analysis

Facilities

Antennas

Solar Cells

Propulsion

Transponders

Station
Keeping

Mechanical

Stabalization

Digital

Uplink

Compression

Ground Station

Programming

Reliability

Mechanical

Partnering &
Licensing

Security

Marketing

User Receiver
Decoder

Regulatory
Liaison

Software

TT&C

Antennas

Power
Mngmnt

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

11/6/2015

DBS Case Study SE Lessons Learned


SYSTEM ENGINEERING

The Power of the Breadth of Knowledge Brought to


bear by the Experienced SEs and Multi-disciplinary
Teams
Business Case Presentation to Executive Management
Complex Systems Engineering Requires Domain
Knowledge, SE Discipline and Creativity
SE Leaders must possess Technical Knowledge,
Customer Understanding, Business Acumen and
Leadership Skills
Power of Back-of-the Envelope Analyses (rapid
analysis, synthesis, evaluation spirals)
Must have Experience to be an Effective Senior SE
Moores Law Whats cheaper comm or processing?
Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

Comm Case Study Recap and Expected Learnings

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

References

SYSTEM ENGINEERING

1. Direct Broadcast Satellite Communications,


An MPEG Enabled service, Donald C. Mead.
Addison-Wesley Wireless Communications
Series, Upper Saddle River, NJ 2000
2. DirecTV - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
3. Radio System Design for
Telecommunications (1 100 GHz), Roger L.
Freeman, John Wiley & Sons, 1987

Copyright 2015 John Olsen - All Rights Reserved

You might also like