23/11/13

Thors Facelift: Norse Mythology in the Marvel Universe | Sequart Research & Literacy Organization

Thors Facelift:

Norse Mythology in the Marvel Universe

by Stuart Warren | in Articles | Thu, 7 November 2013

In 2011, Marvel added the highly anticipated super-human alien, Thor, to their cinematic universe, and was largely
considered a success. Kenneth Branaghs direction of the film conjured an old world Shakespearean atmosphere
that allowed for the best possible insertion of skeptical elements, like magic and alien technology, into what had
already been established as a world founded on reasonable realism. What most are not aware of, however, is the fine
level of integration and energy spent on distilling a working Asgardian cosmology that the film could manage for a
largely pagan-illiterate film audience. The film attempts to show the fabled gods in their native habitats, as well as their
personalities and relationships with one another, and is effective in doing so. In order to understand how and why
Branagh was so successful in his mission requires a foundational grasp on Nordic mythology.
Contrary to any religious tradition, Nordic mythology stands out as one of the most isolated and esotric. Despite
having influenced western philosophy, literature, and traditional holidays, Nordic paganism derives its corpus of
sacred texts from second hand sources that had only partial exposure to the original pagan milieu. Most of what can
be gleaned from the worshipers of Wotan (the Germanic Odin), Tr, and Thor are subject to speculation and
anthropological reconstruction from remnants of pagan civilizations along the Rhine and the inner fjords of Sweden
and Norway. According to the late H.R. Ellis Davidson, the most reliable accounts of this religious tradition derive
from the writings of Snorri Sturluson.

sequart.org/magazine/30319/thors-facelift-norse-mythology-in-the-marvel-universe/

1/10

23/11/13

Thors Facelift: Norse Mythology in the Marvel Universe | Sequart Research & Literacy Organization

Sturluson was an Icelandic literary scholar who made his home in the most ideal setting for culturally preserving the
lost tales of the ancient vikings. By the 13th century, Iceland was already so isolated that much of the authority of the
Roman Catholic Church was present but not wholly supported on the small island nation. While it was still heresy to
glamorize pagan tradition, Snorris project, veiled under the pretenses of teaching the poetic traditions of the Viking
Sagas, remained largely unopposed when he compiled it in 1220 AD. Even though the sources of the tales he
consulted were based on primarily Christian poets and scribes, no attempts were made of moralizing the content or
presenting an overtly Christian bent in the recounting of the Asgardians. It is problematic whether or not the tales
themselves were influenced by theological developments in the Medieval Catholic Church. However, Iceland, being
so far removed from mainland Europe, offered a prime environment for the tales to be reclaimed in. For those who
are unaware, modern Icelandic is more or less equivalent to Old Norse, and those who speak the language can still
read the Sagas in their original forms. Today in 2013, Iceland still retains a vibrant, geographically preserved
language. One can only imagine how much of the viking lore was still intact when Sturluson compiled the Prose Edda,
the authoritative source of extant viking mythology. The only other extant source derives from Saxo Grammaticus, a
Danish historian, who a hundred years before compiled his own collection of tales. Davidson, however, criticizes
Grammaticus moralistic agenda, stating, His stories are badly told in complex, pompous Latin, and are frequently
sequart.org/magazine/30319/thors-facelift-norse-mythology-in-the-marvel-universe/

2/10

23/11/13

Thors Facelift: Norse Mythology in the Marvel Universe | Sequart Research & Literacy Organization

muddled, repetitive, and spoiled by moralizing. They have none of the charm of Snorris work, but they contain
material of much interest and value.

Sturluson begins his work with a prologue explaining the origin of the pagan tales within the context and theological
framework of the Late Medieval christian period. Here he delicately and gently addresses the value of the tales and
why they should be preserved, connecting Thor to the tradition of antiquity as the grandson of King Priam of Troy.
Sturlusons thesis and hypothesis was that the original Aesir were the descendants of Thor (this being a historical
reconstruction), a historical figure mistaken for godhood whose son Odin the Wise, along with his wife Frigg, planted
the nacent kingdoms of northern Europe with their offspring. Having forgotten the sovereignty of God and walked
away from his will, Mankind started over, looking for evidences of the divine in the created world. Here the philosophy
is very much influenced by Thomas Aquinas Summa Theologica, which, in turn, is rooted in Aristotelian philosophy
and a groundbreaking departure from Platonic conceptions of God. After the prologue has finished, Sturluson details
the sojourning of Odin, Thors son, as settling into Sweden and providing infrastructure and laws. Odins offspring are
named the Aesir, who settle to live in a place called Asgard.
sequart.org/magazine/30319/thors-facelift-norse-mythology-in-the-marvel-universe/

3/10

23/11/13

Thors Facelift: Norse Mythology in the Marvel Universe | Sequart Research & Literacy Organization

Sturlusons prologue provides the historical origin of these viking myths, first grounded in the context of Greek
heroics, which segues to the King of Swedens journey to Asgard to meet with the Aesir. The tale Gylfaginning
(translated, The Deluding of Gylfi) is saturated with irony; King Gylfi disguises himself as an old man to learn their
secrets and test their knowledge, when he is about to be duped by Odin, the All-Father himself. The All-Father here
appears in three forms each enthroned above one another as High-One, Just-as-High, and Third. (Whether or not this
detail was influenced by Trinitarian Theology is debatable.) Using the encounter as a narrative device, the three
chieftains proceed to delude Gylfi by telling him about the exploits of the Asgardians, thus saving Sturluson from
accusations of heresy.
Considering the film Thor in light of the origination of the myth, Sturlusons tales as dictated through the conversation
of Gylfi and the All-Father, much has been done to preserve the conceptual framework of the tales in the film. The
Cosmology of the universe places Midgard, the realm of Man, around a great cosmic tree named Yggdrasil, which is
mentioned in the Thor film as a galaxy-like cluster of stars. The Bifrost, which in Nordic mythology has been
described as a rainbow, pole, tree, or the Milky Way Galaxy, acts as a faster than light warp system between
designated realms. The imagery from the film preserves Jack Kirbys style, while also borrowing from the Boom
Tube of the DC comics Fourth World fantasy, also created by Kirby. In the after credits crescendo, the camera, after
swooping through a host of galaxies, finally pulls out to see the Yggdrasil formation in full with a system of spiraling
roots and limbs. In Nordic mythology, Yggdrasil is the center of all life in the created order, and invokes the spirit of
Earth-based religions by subjecting its denizens to the whims of natures command. Asgard and Midgard both wrap
around its base, forming a disk world cosmology while other realms are placed underneath the roots of the World
Tree in darker places. In Thor, the space travel aspect of the universe takes precedence, placing these other worlds
far across space and time, thereby removing the immediacy of Asgards proximity to Midgard, or Earth. In doing so,
Thor has transitioned from being a fantasy epic to a work of science fiction, while retaining much of the conceptual
analogues.

sequart.org/magazine/30319/thors-facelift-norse-mythology-in-the-marvel-universe/

4/10

23/11/13

Thors Facelift: Norse Mythology in the Marvel Universe | Sequart Research & Literacy Organization

The inner politics of Sturlusons recounting is preserved thinly by Branagh, exchanging the conflict between the
Asgardians and the Vanir with that of the frost giants of Jotunheim. In the Prose Edda, the Vanir/Asgardian conflict
mirrors the conflict between earth and sky deities respectively. After Asgard won victory over the Vanir, hostages
were taken from their realm and placed among the ruling class of Asgard. Njord and Freyr were those taken hostage,
Freyr being a god of fertility from Sweden and Njord a god of the sea. The conflict having long been fought and put
behind them symbolized the sovereignty of fate and the divine over the powers of the earth. Though Freyr is
welcomed into the inner circle of chieftains, his power is never equated to that of Tr, God of Storms, and Odin, AllFather. This conflict between realms in the Thor film is adapted to an ongoing, unsteady truce between Laufey, king
of Jotunheim and Odin, who takes Loki as a war hostage. Laufey in Sturlusons recounting is actually the mother of
Loki, the father being Frbauti. Why the names were switched is likely to be chalked up to one name being easier to
pronounce or refer to. Even so, King Laufeys limited screen time makes the change in subject material the only
dubious change to the core mythos.
The dynamic shared between Odin and Thor is more or less similar, but there are a few notable changes to consider.
Odin has been markedly retooled to convey a far more Christian emphasis, than the darker, mysterious Odin that
Sturluson conveys. Thomas DuBois in his book Nordic Religions in the Viking Age accurately describes the power
and weight of the deity:
sequart.org/magazine/30319/thors-facelift-norse-mythology-in-the-marvel-universe/

5/10

23/11/13

Thors Facelift: Norse Mythology in the Marvel Universe | Sequart Research & Literacy Organization

Odin stands as the uncontested ruler of all, the All-Father, who counts Thor as a son and leads the other
gods in counsel at Asgard. His missing eye (ransomed for wisdom), attendant ravens, and eight-legged
horse make him easily recognizable in iconographic as well as narrative descriptions. Although
presiding as the leader of the Aesir as well as dead warriors, he also seems to have subsumed older
aspects of both Vanir magic and shamanic tradition into himself, figuring as an ever-present and
resourceful deity, one always behind the corner, waiting to enlist the dying hero in the afterlife wonders
of Valhalla or plotting to gain a new type of magic or wisdom.

Odin in Branaghs film is much older and less vibrant. He is still sovereign and powerful, but hindered by age. His eye
is lost in battle as a cost of war, and not given to gain arcane wisdom from the stream of Mimir. Odins realm would
not have been a large kingdom filled with tens of thousands of constituents but rather a small tribe of superhuman
lords and ladies with a contingency of lesser creatures like Dwarves and Giants answering to them. What is
preserved, however, is his relationship to Thor. Despite Thors lack of beard, red hair, and sizable figure, the on
screen Father-Son relationship is accurate to the legends, if not slightly updated with easier to understand language.
Thors quest for maturity is far removed from the original material that describes him (in the words of H.R. Davidson)
as being, bearded, outspoken, indomitable, [and] filled with vigor and gusto. She continues to say that, Thors
delight in eating and drinking was in accordance with his great vitality and physical strength. His progress through the
realms of gods and giants was marked by the continual overthrowing of adversaries and overcoming of obstacles.
While Thor in Branaghs interpretation is certainly indomitable his subordinates, notably Volstagg, embody more the
traditional view of who Thor was and the purity of his character. Branaghs Thor is specifically wielded as a product of
character development, showing a young man becoming a matured king.
sequart.org/magazine/30319/thors-facelift-norse-mythology-in-the-marvel-universe/

6/10

23/11/13

Thors Facelift: Norse Mythology in the Marvel Universe | Sequart Research & Literacy Organization

Loki, who now drives the inertia of the Marvel cinematic universe, is perhaps one of the most interesting adaptations
of all. Scholars are divided on the true identity of Loki in his original Northern European context. From what has been
discovered through archeology and works of cultural reclamation, there has yet to be a cult to Loki discovered where
men offered sacrifices in tribute to him. In Sturlusons Prose Edda Loki is neither good nor evil, but acts as an
antagonist shrouded in ambivalence. He is a friend to Thor in the mythos, often traveling with him on Thors journeys,
and often saves the Asgardians from trouble in a variety of tales. Yet he is also associated with Balders death, as
well as a forerunner to the Nordic apocalypse Ragnarok, where he and his children Fenrir and the Midgard Serpent
bring global destruction. Loki in the film matches the same level of animosity of his mythic origin, albeit with a
fabricated premise to make his vengeance take logical shape. In the mythology it is unexplained why he hates Balder
so much, but the severity of this response could be attributed to Lokis affiliation with the Medieval devil of Christianity,
if not at least explain the expansion made upon his evil characteristics. In Thor 2: The Dark World, Thor and Loki will
resume their partnership. How it will compare to the Prose Edda remains to be seen, but given that Lokis key
distinguishing aspect from the Aesir, according to Sturluson, is his flirtatious socialization with all aspects of the Norse
pantheon from creation to Ragnarok, his relationships with the dark elves may bring some interesting details to his
nature.

sequart.org/magazine/30319/thors-facelift-norse-mythology-in-the-marvel-universe/

7/10

23/11/13

Thors Facelift: Norse Mythology in the Marvel Universe | Sequart Research & Literacy Organization

Heimdall, lastly, is Thors most anachronistic, yet intriguing change made to the core mythos. What is so peculiar
about this character is that Branagh preserved nearly the entirety of his conceptual origin, with one exception: hes
black. Acting as both guardian and sentry to the realm of Asgard, Heimdall protects the Bifrost from frost giants and
invaders alike. Like Sturlusons account, Heimdall possesses incredible sight and hearing, as described by Davidson;
he needs no sleep, and can see by night as by day, his ear is perpetually alert for the tiniest sound and the faintest
threat to Asgards safety. All of these details are tenaciously accounted for by Branagh other than his race. In
Sturlusons recounting he is described very particularly: Heimdall is one. He is called the white god and is powerful
and sacred. Nine maidens, all sisters, gave birth to him as their son. In other stories he is described as being the
fairest of the Aesir. After the announcement that Idris Elba was to star as the role of Heimdall, several white
supremacy groups decried the decision to the casting. Penny-Arcade, an online webcomic notable for their
commentary on the video game industry, made light of the situation in comic form, suggesting that the movie was all
about white supremacy, featuring a blonde-haired, blue-eyed savior as the lead protagonist. Having a black Heimdall
would be a minor change in what otherwise was already an egotistical advancement in white superheroes. That being
said, Jerry Holkins (otherwise known as Tycho Brahe on Penny-Arcade) expressed his befuddlement at the whole
situation because he couldnt help but understand the claim the groups were making. He expresses through the
character Gabe, Werent the Norse Gods white, though? I mean, even a racist clock is right twice a day. The comic
otherwise brings up a good point, though Jerry was speaking in jest. Despite all of this, however, the change did little
to effect the movie, and offered a caveat that allowed Branagh to distance Thors earthy anthropological origins to
being an alien from another planet. The change is a guarantee that Branagh is departing for more modern cinematic
and mythological territory.

Considering all the movie has to offer, Thor does an adequate job at bringing to life the cosmology and atmosphere
of Sturlusons original contribution to cultural history. The gods are intact, with a colorful retinue of supporting
characters that exemplify the authenticity of Sturlusons findings. Branaghs work conveyed Thors classical roots,
while retrofitting the cosmology with 21st Century flair. With the next movie nearly released, what comes of the
franchise awaits to be seen. Now that the groundwork has been laid, Thor has worlds still to explore.
Sources:
Byock, Jesse L.. The Prose Edda: Norse mythology. London: Penguin Books, 2005.
DuBois, Thomas A.. Nordic religions in the Viking Age. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1999.
Davidson, Hilda Roderick Ellis. Gods and myths of Northern Europe. London [etc.: Penguin, 1990.
12

Me gusta

13

11

Tagged Kenneth Branagh, Marvel movies, mythology, Thor, Thor Week. Bookmark the permalink.

sequart.org/magazine/30319/thors-facelift-norse-mythology-in-the-marvel-universe/

8/10

23/11/13

Thors Facelift: Norse Mythology in the Marvel Universe | Sequart Research & Literacy Organization

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

RSS feed for Stuart

Warren

Stuart Warren is a self-taught literary historian who posts bi-weekly on his blog, Through the Eyes of Fjlne, where he
teaches prospective writers the art of story crafting and character development for fiction titles. In 2010 he graduated from
the University of California Santa Barbara with a B.A. in English, with special emphasis on Early Modern texts. There he
reviewed and analyzed major works in the corpus of Shakespeare, presenting cases for theological polemics against
Catholic dogmas in Macbeth and Hamlet as foundation subtexts. Though he enjoyed Tottel's Miscellany and the witty prose
of the ballad poets that succeeded him, he soon discovered his love for Satire in the Early Modern cannon, in such works as
More's Utopia and Voltaire's Candid, especially Swift's Gullivers Travels. Since college Stuart has undertaken studies in
Patrology, Nordic Mythology, Deconstruction criticism, Medieval and Old English texts, and is self-taught in the Norwegian
language. Currently, Stuart is in the process of submitting his first novel, Spirit of Orn, which he hopes to publish in the fall of
2014.
See more, including free online content, on Stuart Warren's author page.

4 Comments
David Whittaker says:
7 November 2013 at 10:33am

Im already struggling to express how amazing this article is to me, and ivebbarely started reading it.
Out. Stand. Ing.
Log in to Reply

David Whittaker says:

7 November 2013 at 10:34am

Im already struggling to express how amazing this article is to me, and Ive barely started reading it.
Out. Stand. Ing.
Log in to Reply

Stuart Warren says:

7 November 2013 at 12:17pm

Thanks! Im glad you like it. It was nice being able to write something that I felt competent discussing. Haha. Norse mythology
is my forte.
Log in to Reply

David Whittaker says:

8 November 2013 at 6:48am

You know the fourteenth: Ifyou talk of the gods

before the folk, you can speak of Ases
and elves. Few of the unlearned
know these things.
*winks*

RELATED PRODUCTS

sequart.org/magazine/30319/thors-facelift-norse-mythology-in-the-marvel-universe/

9/10

23/11/13

Thors Facelift: Norse Mythology in the Marvel Universe | Sequart Research & Literacy Organization

Mutant Cinema: The X-Men Trilogy

from Comics to Screen

RELATED MAGAZINE CONTENT

The Marvel Cinematic

Universe is About to
Become the Marvel TV
Universe
18 Nov 2013

Who is Don Blake?

9 Nov 2013

Thors Early Identity

Crisis
8 Nov 2013

Colloquium #5: Norse

Cosmology Jason
Aaron on Thor: God of
Thunder
6 Nov 2013

Better off Dead

Ennis and Fabrys
Thor: Vikings
6 Nov 2013

If They Be Worthy,
They Shall Possess
the Power of Thor!
5 Nov 2013

How Tales of Asgard

Changed Everything
4 Nov 2013

Its Thor Week on

Sequart!
3 Nov 2013

Id Need a Lobotomy
to Enjoy Thor: The
Dark World
2 Nov 2013

A Smarter World:
Hickmans Avengers
#1-3
31 Aug 2013

The Wolverine is a
Cut Above the Rest
3 Aug 2013

Half Action Movie, Half

Art Film, The
Wolverine Delivers
29 Jul 2013

Sequart Research & Literacy Organization

advancing comics as art

sequart.org/magazine/30319/thors-facelift-norse-mythology-in-the-marvel-universe/

10/10