Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Test Pumping Test in Fractured Reservoirs
Test Pumping Test in Fractured Reservoirs
,.. ~
gq 5i5C!JTs:Ji
ABSTRACT: In this paper methods and techniques for the diagnosis of pumping tests in fractured aquifers
are reviewed and extended. These techniques, which include the comparison of drawdown and recovery data,
straight-line analysis, special plotS, derivatives, and pseudo-skin analysis are demonstrated on a continuous
fractured model (double porosity case) and a discontinuous model (single fracture case) using theoretical and
practical examples.
1 INTRODUCTION
2 THEORY
2.1 Double porosity models
The concept of double porosity introduced by
8arenblatt et al. (1960) considers homogenous dislributed conductive fractures embedded in a homogenous distributed matrix. Two matrix types are
. 81
it,
E
..
9lOO
10.'
10"
I (mini
Figure 1. Drawdown
in slab-shaped
double porosity
and transient block to fissure flow, A = fracture/formation
skin-factor ofO.
factor of 5. B = fracture/formation
aquifer
skin-
[-]
~.
I (minI
Figure 2, Drawdown
diagnoses
ferent relative conductivity
Cr.
for vertical
fractures
with dif-
The characteristic slopes found for a single horizontal fracture with infinite conductivity (Gringarten
& Ramey 1974) are depending on the dimensionless
formation thickness h.Jdefined as
(1)
h.J = h ' Kr I(re Kv) [-]
where:
Kr = conductivity of the fracture [lit]
w - fracture'swidth[I]
Km - conductivity of the matrix [I/t]
Xr .. holf-Iength of the frneture [I]
(2)
where:
h = reservoir thickness [I]
rr ...fractureradius[I]
Kr .. radial Crncture
conductivity [1/1]
Ky '" wrliclIl f(mnnlionconductivity [1/11
Cll1co-LtlY& Snll1nnlcgo(l97K) dol1H1nMlrnlcd
that for nil practical purposesa single vertical frae.
When hi.< 1, the following characteristicnow
ture with Cr ~ 100could be regardedas an infinite phasesareobservedin a log-logplot:
conductive fracture that coincides with the GringarVery early time data shows a slope of 1 that inten et nl. (\ 974) Infinite nux model fOf Infinite con.
dicntcsfmct\l\'Cstorn~cnow
dudlvl! tfnctures.
Ent'ly time lIntn showstI slope ot' 0,5 tOr IIn@l\t
IfCf < \00. then the fracture has finite conductivnow
\~. 1\\,,-'t""\.~ \\\t'lM~ thnt ro"!1.\t'~~ tht t~\\\~
l'1.""
t.J=T.tI(S'x()
(3)
[-]
where:
t =Real time [t]
T =Formation transmissivity [l2/t]
S =Formation storage coefficient [-]
Only after the radial~acting flow phase is reached
can the common analysis methods for primary aquifers be applied to determine the transmissivity T,
e.g. Jacob or Thcis. The storage coefficient S can be
estimated with equation (3), if the fracture halflength Xc is known. Figure 3 illustrates the extremely large error made in the calculation of S
when the Jacob straight-line method for time drawdown data is applied to.the data measured in an observation well located near an infinite conductive
vertical fracture with uniform flux. The straight-line
method is only applicable when the distance of the
observation well is at least 5 times that of the fracture half-length (which is in fact the REV of such a
system).
However, Figure 3 can also be used to either determine the correct storage coefficient if the relative
position of the observation well to the fracture is
known or to determine the fracture half-length if the
storage coefficient is known.
The influence of the fracture storage can be de. scribedwith the
,...
..
. curves show
,..'2LFa__""",
,,,"
1...0
.'.0-1
1Iopo0.5
1.0-4
1.0-$
to
,
i
(4)
Figure 4 shows the drawdown in a vertical fracture with infmite conductivi~ and infinite flux with
COf between 10-0and IQ-IO.All curves commence
with linear flow (slope 0.5). All curves with
COf < 10-4describe the drawdown in high storage
capacity fractures and their behavior is' significantly
different to that of well bore storage. In these curves
the slope of 0.5 indicates linear fracture flow and not
linear formation flow and indicates that all discharged water is provided solely by the fracture. The
100
:!:
relativestoragecapacityCOf after
-'f/
'.""..1'.""""'.0-4'.""."".."".0'.."'...2
.......
-....---
10
.....
.. ......
Id 1.1
- . .
0
2
0
Dlm
lonl...
3
dllWlCl If'"
. the
fu~:
voir)
Two perpendicularsclosedboundaryquadruples
the slopeof the radial-actingflowstraight-line. .
(5)
4 FIELD EXAMPLES
phase will plot on a straight line starting at the origin. The drawdown data of a spherical flow will plot
on a straight line that commences in the origin in the
thirdplot.
10
0.1
0.01
3.5 Derivatives
10
100
1000
10000
100000
11"*'1
All characteristic
straight-line
nite conductive fracture with uniform flux results: T = 0.0007; xf=.460 m; sf= 1.78.
200 m2/d; S
same
Radial-acting flow phase is plotted as a horizontal fuie, which eases the identification for the
human eye
Unfortunately, derivatives applied to real data ofreo show too much noise. Smoothing of the derivatives would overcome this problem, but it cannot be
ensured that the applied mathematical algorithm
would not produce misleading artifacts. However,
recovery data are usually less noisy as they are not
iDfluenced by variations in the discharge rate and
can be used. Nevertheless, with some experience
even noisy derivative curves can be interpreted.
!
85
300.0
10.0
20.0
troleum Engineers.
'
t~(mInJ~
using the linear flow period
5 CONCLUSION
It is demonstrated that pumping tests can provide
various types of useful information regarding the
reservoir behavior of fractured rock aquifers, if reliable data and principal structural geological
information are available. Furthermore, it is shown
that only a detailed data analysis can produce
reliable results, using a combination of diagnostic
methods and tools. Some of the most important
functions are assuring data quality by comparing
drawdownand recoverydata.
Use pseqqo-skin analysis to overcome masking
or coinciilentaleffects
Identify different flow regimes with detailed
straight-line diagnosis Obtain skin effects with application of special
plots
Use derivatives from real data. This requires
much experience. Nevertheless, they are especially useful to identify radial-acting flow, because they are not affected by skin effects.
However, further investigations are necessary,
especially for the Cjvaluationof data from pumping
tests performed in discontinuous aquifers below the
representative elementary volume (REV).
REFERENCES
Bardenhagen, J. 1999. Skin Localization at Wells Drilled in a
Vertical Fault Zone. GROUND WATER, Vol. 37, No 5:
764.769.
Barenblatt, G.I., Zheltov, Yu.P., & Kochina, I.N. 1960. Basic
concepts in the theory of seepage of homogeneous liquids
in fISsured rocks. In Tatiana D. Streltsova (eds), Well TestIng In Heterogeneous Formations:, 370-373. An EJexon
Monography. 1988. New York: John Wi/ey & Sons, Inc.
Birsoy, Y.K. & Summers, W.K. 1980. Detennination ofaquifer parameters from step tests and intermittent pumping
data. GROUND WATER. Vol. 18: 137-146
Boehmer, W.K. & Boonstra, J. 1986. Flow to wells in intrusive
dikes. Ph.D. Thesis, Free University, Amsterdam: 262pp.
Wei, L., Hadwin, I., Chaput, E.,. & Swaby, P. 1998. Discriminating J;racture Patterns in Fractured Reservoirs by Pressure
Transient Tests. Prepared for presentation
at the annual SPE
Annual Technical Conference
and exhibition
held in New
Orleans, Louisana,
ciety of Petroleum
86
27-30 September
1998. SPE 49233.
Engineers, Inc.: 609-618.
Sa-,