Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Electrochemistry Encyclopedia - Industrial Organics
Electrochemistry Encyclopedia - Industrial Organics
Return to: Encyclopedia Home Page --- Table of Contents --- Author Index --- Subject Index --- Search --- Dictionary --- ESTIR Home
Page --- YCES Home Page
Electrochemistry Encyclopedia
(http://electrochem.cwru.edu/ed/encycl/)
reaching very high levels of product purity and selectivity; development of valuable intellectual property; and, in many instances,
considerably improved capital and operating costs over conventional methods.
Electrosynthesis certainly has disadvantages too. Electrosynthesis usually requires the use of a solvent to solubilize the reactants and
products. Water is the ideal solvent but too often organic solvents or co-solvents are required. In addition, supporting electrolytes to carry
the current are very often needed. The solvent/supporting electrolyte system can be too expensive or even the source of unacceptable
pollutants if not recovered and recycled. Electrolytic cells require stable electrode materials, separators and other components, which may
have limited lifetimes and can affect the economics adversely. Electricity is required in all electrochemical processing which may or may
not be a critical factor, depending on where the process is located. (Note, however, that the cost of electricity is not at all a deciding factor
where higher value added products such as pharmaceuticals are the products).
Considering the advantages, critics question why there are so few commercial scale organic electrosyntheses. Indeed, there are many
ongoing successful processes (See Tables I-III), but as in conventional processes, some have been discontinued or may never reach
commercial scale for various reasons, including:
The product became a pollutant (for example tetraalkyl lead from lead and alkyl halide);
The market for the product disappeared (for example 1,2-dihydrophthalic acid);
An established market for the products never existed (for example Philip's electrofluorination of hydrocarbons). A new process for
a new product is bound to have a tough upward battle to achieve market entry;
Toxic byproducts could not be eliminated (for example p-aminophenol produced from nitrobenzene is contaminated with
carcinogenic benzidine);
Improved methods of catalytic hydrogenation became more practical (for example sorbitol from glucose or aniline from
nitrobenzene);
Methods of catalytic oxidation became more practical (for example hydroquinone from benzene or phenol or propylene oxide from
propylene);
The capital cost is considered too high for the company in its present financial state.
Courage! For various reasons, the product or process has no upper level corporate "champion" willing to support it, despite the
promising opportunity and economics;
Politics! If the company manufactures this product, the company perceives it may lose an important customer or partner, who may
see this as competition.
It should not be surprising that the above list of reasons why electrochemical processes never reach commercialization or are discontinued
pertains to conventional processing as well.
The electrochemical literature, including patents on the electrosynthesis of the product and its nearest analogues.
For the most promising route, write the equations for the anode and cathode processes, including products and byproducts. Then
decide what needs to be demonstrated in the laboratory in a limited series of studies during small scale feasibility testing. Usually
some electroanalytical method such as cyclic voltammetry is useful to follow the electrooxidation or electroreduction of the
reactants. Calculate the cell voltage (if not indicated in the literature) and estimate the cell requirements, the electrode area and the
number of cells. And, do at least a first pass economic evaluation of capital and operating costs.
If not already performed, compare the economics of the most promising chemical route. Based on the economics, decide on what
variables, if any, are likely to be critical in the electrochemical route. Nothing can be done about certain factors like the number of
electrons required, the molecular weight of the starting material or products, but the economics may be influenced positively, for
example, by increasing the product yield, current efficiency and selectivity, or by lowering the cell voltage, and by the choice of
solvent, operating temperature and cell components like electrode and separator materials.
A limited number of the feasibility experiments are performed in the laboratory using a simple cell. Glass cells and small flow cells
are commercially available. Is the desired product formed? What are the yields and current efficiencies of the products and
byproducts? If the answers are found acceptable, a series of well designed experiments will normally follow, preferably in a small
flow cell with good flow characteristics to begin to optimize some of the critical variables of the early experiments. All along the
way, "go/no go" decisions will be made. Further work may be discontinued in a "no go" decision upon discovery of unacceptable
byproducts or the requirement of a too expensive solvent.
Recalculate the economics, based on the results to this point.
If still promising, the engineering team may come in to produce a preliminary process flow diagram and assist with advice and
design of the scale facility.
In many instances, especially for high value added products, pilot
scale may be the plant scale. Designing your own
electrochemical cell may be unnecessary. Modern cells are
highly engineered reactors and are commercially available in a
variety of sizes and with a range of cell components (Figure 1).
The following are a few companies that offer cells:
ElectroCell http://www.chematur.se/
IneosChlor http://www.ineoschlor.com/
Progenica http://www.electrosynthesis.com/
C-Tech http://www.capenhurst.com/
Engineering considerations
After successful R&D/preliminary economics, the optimization of the commercial process requires attention to:
Mass transfer
The rate of mass transfer of reactants and products across the boundary layer at the electrode can be improved by:
A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
F.
G.
The majority of commercial electrochemical cells are parallel plate designs with: (a) external electrolyte pumping, or (b) gas sparging
Heat transfer
Removal of heat generated within cells is usually required for maintaining the optimum electrolysis temperature. This is accomplished by:
A. Circulation of electrolyte through external heat exchangers: the most predominant method
B. Internal cooling of the cell via coils, jackets or tubes
C. Internal or external evaporative cooling
Factors in sizing the total heat removal load include calculation of:
A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
Power usage
The power usage is a function of cell voltage and current efficiency, but it will be also influenced by the current leakage in bipolar cells,
parasitic electrode reactions, pumping losses, and rectifier losses.
Electrode life
The corrosion, passivation, and fouling of both anodes and cathodes can only be evaluated after many months of testing. Electrode life
can be greatly affected by:
A.
B.
C.
D.
Separator life
The performance of separators, whether porous diaphragms or ion exchange membranes can only be evaluated after many months of
testing. Separator materials can be greatly affected by:
http://electrochem.cwru.edu/ed/encycl/art-o01-org-ind.htm (4 of 10)11/10/2007 20:50:16
A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
This is the first commercial example of a paired organic electrosynthesis (useful products are produced both on the anode
and on the cathode).
Methanol is both a reagent and a solvent: as much methanol is released from reduction of the diester as is consumed in
making t-butylbenzaldehyde.
Current density is 0.1 to 1 kA/m2 at a cell voltage of 4 to 7 volts.
Starting material
Company
Acetoin
Butanone
BASF
Acetylenedicarboxylic Acid
1,4-Butynediol
BASF
Cyclohexanone
BASF
Adiponitrile
Acrylonitrile
4-Aminomethylpyridine
4-Cyanopyridine
Reilly Tar
Anthraquinone
Anthracene
L. B. Holliday, ECRC
Azobenzene
Nitrobenzene
Hoechst
Calcium Gluconate
Glucose
Sandoz, India
Calcium lactobionate
Lactose
Sandoz, India
S-Carbomethoxymethylcysteine
Spain
L-Cysteine
L-Cystine
Several
Diacetone-2-ketogulonic Acid
Diacetone-L-sorbose
Hoffman-LaRoche
Dialdehyde Starch
Starch
India, Others
1,4-Dihydronaphthalene
Naphthalene
Hoechst
2,5-Dimethoxy-2,5-dihydrofuran
Furan
BASF
Furfuryl-1-ethanol
Otsuka
Dimethylsebacate
Monomethyladipate
Asahi Chemical
Gluconic Acid
Glucose
Sandoz, India
Hexafluoropropyleneoxide
Hexafluoropropylene
Hoechst
m-Hydroxybenzyl Alcohol
m-Hydroxybenzoic Acid
Otsuka
Mucic Acid
Galacturonic Acid
EDF
Perfluorinated hydrocarbons
Alkyl substrates
2,5-Dimethoxy-2,5-dihydrofuryl-1-ethanol
BASF
p-Methoxybenzaldehyde
p-Methoxytoluene
BASF
Polysilanes
Chlorosilanes
Osaka Gas
p-t-Butylbenzaldehyde
p-t-Butyltoluene
BASF, Givaudan
Salicylic Aldeyde
o-Hydroxybenzoic Acid
India
Succinic Acid
Maleic Acid
CERCI, India
3,4,5-Trimethoxybenzaldehyde
3,4,5-Trimethoxytoluene
Otsuka Chemical
3,4,5-Trimethoxytolyl Alcohol
3,4,5-Trimethoxytoluene
Otsuka Chemical
Starting material
Company
1-Acetoxynaphthalene
Naphthalene
BASF
Acetylenedicarboxylic Acid
2-Butyne-1,4-diol
BASF
2-Aminobenzyl Alcohol
Anthranilic Acid
BASF
Anthraquinone
Naphthalene, Butadiene
Hydro Quebec
Arabinose
Gluconate
Electrosynthesis Co.
Dimethyl Maleate
Monsanto
1,2,3,4-Butanetetracarboxylic Acid
Ceftibuten
Cephalosporin C
3,4,5,6-tetrachloro-picolinic Acid
3,6-Dichloropicolinic Acid
Dow
Ditolyliodonium Salts
p-Iodotoluene, Toluene
Ethylene Glycol
Formaldehyde
Electrosynthesis Co.
Glyoxylic Acid
Oxalic Acid
Hydroxymethylbenzoic Acid
Dimethyl Terephthalate
Hoechst
Monochloroacetic Acid
Hoechst
Nitrobenzene
p-Aminophenol
India, Monsanto
5-Nitronaphthoquinone
1-Nitronaphthalene
Hydro Quebec
Phillips Petroleum
Pinacol
Acetone
Propiolic Acid
Propargyl Alcohol
BASF
Propylene Oxide
Propylene
Kellog, Shell
Substituted Benzaldehydes
Substituted Toluenes
Future trends
Table III. Discontinued commercial processes
Product
1,2-Dihydrophthalic Acid
Starting material
Company
o-Phthalic Acid
BASF
L. B. Holliday, BASF
2-Methyldihydroindole
2-Methylindole
Hexahydrocarbazole
Tetrahydrocarbazole
L. B. Holliday, BASF
Piperidine
Pyridine
Robinson Bros.
Sorbitol
Glucose
Hercules
Tetraalkyl Lead
Nalco
been speculated that one day commercialization of an electroenzymatic process will occur. This would be based on the application of
enzymes as catalysts, dissolved in the electrolyte solution or fixed to a support, such as an electrode or separator. The goal would be to
harness the extraordinary abilities of enzymes to produce highly valuable, unusual products, perhaps having high stereoselectivity.
Realization of an industrial scale electroenzymatic process may take many years to fulfill, but work is already underway in a number of
laboratories worldwide to one day achieve this goal.
There are at this writing no academic institutions where courses in applied electrochemistry are taught. In the USA, the closest disciplines
taught are electroanalytical chemistry and electrochemical engineering. Fortunately, there is a large literature of resource materials,
including excellent books (see Bibliography). Electrochemical Society meetings (http://www.electrochem.org) and other international
symposia, such as the Annual International Forum on Applied Electrochemistry (http://www.electrosynthesis.com) are excellent meetings
to explore ideas and find assistance from experts in the field.
What is available also to help those interested in applied organic electrosynthesis are many commercial cells of flexible design; stable cell
components, including catalytic electrodes, highly selective membranes and a number of novel electrode/membrane composites; a sound
theoretical and practical knowledge base in electrochemistry and electrochemical engineering; and, experienced groups that can advise on
R&D, engineering, plant design, construction, and start-up.
Appendix
Electric power consumption
K = ( 100 Ko n F V ) / ( Mp Ec )
Cell costs
A = ( 1.12 103 n P ) / ( Mp i Ec )
where:
K =
Ko =
n =
F =
V =
Mp =
cell voltage, V
Ec =
current efficiency, %
Related articles
For other industrial electrolytic processes see:
Aluminum production
Brine electrolysis
Extracting metals from sulfide ores
Bibliography
Organic Electrochemistry (4th edition), H. Lund and O. Hammerich (editors), Marcel Dekker, New York, 2001.
Perspectives: The Last 15 Years and Beyond, N. L. Weinberg in "Proceedings of the 15th Annual Forum on Applied
Electrochemistry" Electrosynthesis Company, Lancaster NY, 2001.
Electrolytic ProcessesPresent and Future Prospects, Electrosynthesis Company and Dextra Associates, Report Number TR107022, EPRI, Palo Alto CA, 1997.
Principles of Electrochemical Engineering and Scaleup, D. E. Danly in "Proceedings of the 5th Annual Forum on Applied
Electrochemistry" Electrosynthesis Company, Lancaster NY, 1991.
Industrial Electrochemistry (2nd edition), D. Pletcher and F. C. Walsh, Chapman and Hall, London, 1990.
ElectrosynthesisFrom Laboratory to Pilot, to Production, J. D. Genders and D. Pletcher (editors), Electrosynthesis Company,
Lancaster NY, 1990.
Proceedings of the Annual Forum on Applied Electrochemistry (15 volumes), Electrosynthesis Company, Lancaster NY, since
1987.
Emerging Opportunities for Electroorganic Processes, D. E. Danly, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1984.
Techniques of Electroorganic Chemistry (Part III), N. L. Weinberg and B. V. Tilak (editors), Wiley Intersciene, New York, 1982.
Workshop on the Status of Industrial Organic Electrochemistry, SRI International, EPRI EM-2173, Project 1086-9, Research
Reports Center, Box 50490, Palo Alto CA, 1981.
A Survey of Organic Electrolytic Processes, T. R. Beck, R. Alkire, and N. L. Weinberg, DOE Contract Number 31-109-4209,
Report No. ANL/OEPM-79-5, Argonne National Laboratory, Argonne IL, 1979.
Listings of electrochemistry books, review chapters, and proceedings volumes are also available in the Electrochemistry Science and
Technology Information Resource (ESTIR). (http://electrochem.cwru.edu/estir/)
The Encyclopedia is hosted by the Ernest B. Yeager Center for Electrochemical Sciences (YCES) and the Chemical
Engineering Department, Case Western Reserve University , Cleveland, Ohio.
Copyright Notice.
Edited by Zoltan Nagy (nagy@anl.gov) The Center for Electrochemical Science and Engineering and Department of Chemical
and Environmental Engineering, Illinois Institute of Technology, Chicago, Illinois.
Return to: Top --- Encyclopedia Home Page --- Table of Contents --- Author Index --- Subject Index --- Search --- Dictionary --- ESTIR
Home Page --- YCES Home Page