Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Nigerian History and Culture
Nigerian History and Culture
Nigerian History and Culture
NIGERIAN
HISTORY AND CULTURE
ESSAYS IN MEMORY OF
PROFESSOR J.A. ATANDA
Create PDF files without this message by purchasing novaPDF printer (http://www.novapdf.com)
Contents
Chapter Fifteen
EVOLUTION AND CHANGE OF THE BALOGUN
INSTITUTION IN ILORIN EMIRATE 1827- 1960
S. Y. Omoiya
235
ii
Create PDF files without this message by purchasing novaPDF printer (http://www.novapdf.com)
Chapter Fifteen
EVOLUTION AND CHANGE OF THE BALOGUN
INSTITUTION IN ILORIN EMIRATE 1827- 1960
S. Y. Omoiya
Introduction
The existence and dominance of the Balogun institution in (he political
administration of llorin emirate has remain a historic point of note in the
general evaluation of the emirate system in Nigeria and the evaluation of
traditional African administration of a cosmopolitan community, llorin
community is a cosmopolitan polity that evolved a peculiar political system
that slums it s cultural diversity
Balogun is a Yoruba tit le for war commanders or war lords. Its existence
in an emirate political system which is northern-Nigerian oriented, and
commonly operated amongst the Hausa/Fulani is a peculiar organ of llorin
emirate system that has no equal in the other emirates of Sokoto Caliphate.
The discussion, which follows, would help elucidate the evolution of this
institution from the third decade of the nineteenth century up to Nigeria's
J
CZ 5
independence in 1960.
Create PDF files without this message by purchasing novaPDF printer (http://www.novapdf.com)
failure of the second attempt made on Aare Afonja's life by Alaafin Aole,
when he concluded with the Esos (palace guards) to trick the Aare to go on an
expedition he was traditionally bound to fail, worsened their relationship. By
Oyo tradition, the failure in a battle imposes death-penalty on the war
commander. - Iwere was a naturally fortified town and a forbidden area for
an Oyo army to attack because it was the material home of Alaafin Abiodun.'
Alaalin Aole deliberately designed to send the Aare (here to simply get rid of
him. Words reached the Aare on the plot before the arrival of the Esos to
deliver the Alaafin s message. On getting to the site of the expedition which
was confirmed to be Iwere. Aare Afonja ordered the massacre of the Hsos
and he sent a covered empty calabash to the Alaafin. 1 A demand for the
Alaafin s Head.
The death of Alaafin Aole naturally conferred victory on Aare Afonja on
the scheme to terminate each other's life. Aare Afonja immediately declared
independence for llonn and with himself as the supreme authority.'' Other
prouncial chiefs like the Onikoyi and the Opele of Gbogun also followed
suite, by declaring independence for their respecti v e l y areas.
Bv the extents that followed Aare Afonja's declaration of independence
for llorin, he certainly did not take chances. He recognised the limitation of
his army and he embarked on the recruitment of new hands. He sought for
spiritual support through his friend Sholagberu. The recruits into the Aares
army were the slaves that revolted against their masters in Oyo town and migrated to llorin town. For the spiritual support, the Aare was introduced to
an Islamic Cleric. Shehu Alimi. He Alimi was encouraged to migrate from
his settlement in Kuwo, a village not too far from llorin township to llorin in
about 1817.'"
It is important at this point to appreciate that most of the newly recruited
slaves into the Aare's army were Moslems by religion. The migration of
Shehu Alimi to llorin township therefore had a major implication on the
practice of their faith and the political future of an independent llorin.
The expressed trust and full support granted the slave soldiers recruited
by Aare Afonja. by implication, granting them an open license to operate.
made them behave without caution. They were called Aare's servants and
treated with high regard and fears. " The slave soldiers were fast to abuse
the liberty by unleashing terror on the people The rapacity was so much
236
Create PDF files without this message by purchasing novaPDF printer (http://www.novapdf.com)
that Fagbohun, the left wing commander of the Aare's army, had to formerly
call the attention of the Aare lo the dangers posed to his authority i t s by the
unlimited privileges given to the slave solders.
For the first time, the Aare was made to look inward to appreciate the
wide range of reports against the state soldiers. I le therefore began the moves to
reorganise the arm) with a view of checking the excesses of the slave
soldiers. The wind of the Aare s re-organisations plans got to the slaves
soldiers before its implementation. The were quick at railing themselves to
launch an attack against the Aare, to disalkm him ell eel his plans which
would have far reaching effects on their activities and being
237
Create PDF files without this message by purchasing novaPDF printer (http://www.novapdf.com)
political ambition into reality. With the tacit support of Abdulsalami, Shitta
was fast in rallying the support of the slave soldiers who had chosen the
mosque as then rallying point, to prosecute his aims.
A number of prominent and powerful individuals and groups were soon
accused of trying to plot against Abdulsalami's installation as the Amir.
They were attacked and killed one after the other Sholagberu, the renowned
Muslim trader in llorin and close friend of Shehu Alimi lost his life in such
plot An attack was also launched on the Muslim settlement of Oke Sunna.
where a good number of notable scholars were massacred. ''' This was the
strategy of eliminating actual and potential rivals in order to create a political
base.
With the elimination of notable and powerful individuals and groups
who could stand against the realisation of the political ambition of the children of
Shehu Alimi in llorm. Abdulsalami wrote to the caliph in Sokoto pledging his
loyalty and seeking support for the establishment of an emirate in llorin. llorin
was thereafter declared an emirate and Abdulsalami as the Emir.
The Transformation of Abdnlsalami from an Imam or Am:r. a religions
leader, by mere proclamation, to an emir, the political leader of the people
was indeed expected to be resisted even outside llorm In re-organising the
new emirate. Abdulsalami co-opted prominent group leaders into his council
For instance. Olufadi, the leader of the Olufadi Fulani group. Dose, the
leader of the Hausa group, and Usman the leader of the Yoruba group, were
all appointed as Amir al Jash (Head of the army) or Balogun and members
of the Emir's council '. The title was given out to leaders of the linguistic
group in anticipation of military hostility against the new political authority
in Ilorin led by the Fulanis
The political transition of Ilorin from a traditional Yoruba provincial setting
into an emirate, which was totally alien to the history and culture of the area,
was a product of the change in the military leadership. The Emir, being of
Fulani stock and full aware of the insignificant population of the of nonYoruba groups in Ilorin. appreciated the need to bring the varying linguistic
groups in the town on board in his administration This was a survival
strategy. Apart from this, the survival of the newly declared emirate depended
mainly on its military strength to withstand the contending power around
Ilorin at the time Therefore, the co-option of the leaders of the
238
Create PDF files without this message by purchasing novaPDF printer (http://www.novapdf.com)
major linguistic groups in llorin, as, Amir al Jash (war commanders) which
was later know n and called Baloguns, could better be regarded as an evolution
rather than the creation of the Bmir.
The involvement of the three major linguistic groups in the political
administration of llorin was essentially born out of the necessity for the
emirate system to survive, llorin, being Yoruba dominated community that
had been under the authority of the Alaafin of Oyo, could not be cash
changed to a foreign political system without some element of force. This
explains why full force and the totalitarian policy were used by the
rampaging soldiers led by the sons of Shehu Alimi (abdul-Salami anil Shilta).
The circumstances under which the Balogun institution emerged among
the various linguistic groups in llorin, gave the Balogun a dual role in the
Finn s council They just arrived at decisions on the political
administration of the emirate with the Emir, and also executed such decisions,
either in the administration of their respective wards within llorin township, or
in the battlefield and in the conquered areas. Being field officers, the
Balogun stood at vantage position to give information on issues to lie
deliberated upon in the Finn s council. In this way they led the council in
formulating polices and taking decisions.
The involvement of llorin emirate army in the nineteenth century warfares
that covered the entire Yorubaland naturally opened the Balogun and the
entire emirate army to various military encounters. The Balogun. or war
commanders, were the central ligures in the wars. The use of the Calvary
and diplomacy placed llorin army at victorious advantage in most of the
wars with the Yorubas, who were often divided and ready to betray one
another to settle old scores. The conquered areas automatically became the
territory of the war commander or the Balogun that led the contingent."
The enormous powers and influence of the four Balogun of llorin in the
administration of the emirate have remained a subject of controversy amoiiL1
scholars of the caliphate history. For instance, there are those who believe
that the position held by the Baloguns were mere expression of then respective
ambition. There are also those who consider the political institution to have
been a product of security situation in which llorin found itself before. during
and after it became an emirate. In all the other emirates of the Sokoto
caliphate the Emir was the supreme authority to whom war title
239
Create PDF files without this message by purchasing novaPDF printer (http://www.novapdf.com)
240
Create PDF files without this message by purchasing novaPDF printer (http://www.novapdf.com)
241
Create PDF files without this message by purchasing novaPDF printer (http://www.novapdf.com)
242
Create PDF files without this message by purchasing novaPDF printer (http://www.novapdf.com)
the British in their areas The reports of Mm in people's hostility towards the
British projects in the area, especially1 the eonstriietion ol telegraph line,
made the colonial army commander. Willcoek. stationed in Jebba to send a
warning notice to the Emir on the situation in llonn The Lmn s servant, to
whom Willcoek s letter was fust given, threyy it on the ground. The Hmir
himself warned the corporal and a feu soldiers sent that ifthey ever returned
to llonn. they would be killed ' Willcock was naturally angry and by 2S1'1 of
September. IS ( )X he sent another warning to the Knur of llorin. This time
fifty soldiers led b y an Luropcan ofhcci named Somcisct carried the
commander s letter to llorin. As it was the tradition, the Emir summoned a
general meeting of his Balogun for the formal presentation of Somersets
letter and in the presence ol The Baloguns and a jpiowd ol people, the Lmn
refused to take the letter from Somcise! By October I H l ' S . the llonn
Baloguns were preparing for another ciu.ounlcr with the Biitisli lorees
Instructions were uivcn to the people thai food should not be- sold to the
contingents led by Somerset and that li any of them ucrc found y\ i i l n n llonn
lownship they should be killed.' 1 "1
243
Create PDF files without this message by purchasing novaPDF printer (http://www.novapdf.com)
Balogun Agba. Buivuiim Karara had vowed undertake, never mattered to the
Balogun The firm was rather warned that if he did not stop his attempt to
dissuade the Balogun from his determined course to punish Offa, he (the
Emir) would be dethroned and replaced by his younger brother. Mama19 .
The realisation of the titular status of the Emir in the emirate system in
liorin made Aliyu's successor Emir Mama (I S() I -1 Xl)5) to chart a course of
friendship with the Colonial Governor in Lagos while the Baloguns were
veracious in their hostility Mama s attempt to outwit the Baloguns . by
aligning w i t h t h e colonial governor in Lagos considered superior to the
Baloguns, made the Baloguns to plot against him by mobilising his younger
brother to k i l l him." The then Balogun Agba, Balogun Inakoju Ah of
Alanamu uas identified as the nominator of Sulyman man, who succeeded
Mama in I895.
Emir Sulymna (1895-1915) remained a loyal and humble Emir to the
Balogun until the arrival of the Colonial Resident in llorin in June, 1900. The decision
of Emir Sulyman to be friendly with the Colonial Resident sent to llorin in
1900 could be examined from the main perspective In vicyy of the repeated
failures of the past traditional authority in llorm to resist the incursion ol the
British, the Linn must ha\ e decided to face the reality of the time by adopting
a friendly attitude to the colonial officers The second factor is the
unsatisfactory l i l u i a i status of the Emir in the operation of the emirate svslein
in llorm The m i l i t a r y powers at the disposal of the colonial officers made the
Lmir to see the possibility of regaining his lost powers to the Baloguns
While these two possible factors could be suggested for the Lmir s singular
support for the British government, it was indeed a betrayal of the traditional
political system and the l l o r in community to which he was the symbolic head
The friendly disposition of Emir Sulyman and the hostile stance of Balogun
and the people of llonn were promptly reported to Lord Lugard. as part of
the Resident's situation report on his arrival at Ilorin. The Resident
acknowledged the frequent at which the Emir paid him visits to guide him in
the handling of the people s resistance against the British rule, led by the
BaloiHin. The Resident concluded his report w i t h a number of suggestions
^
d} *'
on how to get o\er the problems Based on his assessment of the political
situation and the administration of lionn emirate, the Resident. David
244
Create PDF files without this message by purchasing novaPDF printer (http://www.novapdf.com)
P. Dwyer did not stop at reporting but he went further to suggest that
Balogun Alanamu should be arrested, deposed and deported out of llorin
emirate. He opined that the action will have so much effect on the other
Baloguns and their supporters that the hostile situation would be resolved1' .
He also stressed the advantages of backing the Emir by force and recognising
him alone as the authority in the emirate1'*. This he also opined would make
the people accept the colonial rule in llorin at the least cost to the colonial
government. In a reply to P. Dwyer, the High Commissioner, Lord Lugard.
did not only agree with all the suggestions made by the Resident but he also
urged that they tarry in then moves for the arrival of the forces from Asante
before they swung into action Lugard also advised Dwyer to constantly
monitor the .movement of Balogun Alanamu. to be able to charge him for an
offence and then provide rational grounds for his deposition and deportation.
By 1902 the stage was set, and Balogun Inakoju Ali, the Balogun Agba
(Alanamu) became the first victim of the colonial government s schemes to
subjugate the traditional authority1 in llorin emirate to the Limit As S. Hogben
puts it in his book The Mohammadan Emirates of Nigeria
... This Emir, finding himself backed up by the Resident,
broke away from the constraining hands of Alanamu
245
Create PDF files without this message by purchasing novaPDF printer (http://www.novapdf.com)
Hogben goes further to narrate how the Balogun Agba, Balogun Inakoju
Ali of Alanamu was snapped by traps set by the colonial government:
Alanamu's time had come. At an enormous meeting
outside the Emir's palace he was judged to have been
unfit lo hold his position, was publicly deposed and
stripped of his estate.51
The Balogun was immediately arrested and deported to Jebba, where a
contingent of the colonial army was already waiting in preparation for any
eventuality that could attend the deposition order. The exodus of people
from llorin to Jebba to see the Balogun and demonstrate their support for
his cause made the colonial government appreciate the fact that it was not an
issue they could control with mere presence of the army, without resorting to
.violence. To avoid unnecessary blood letting. Balogun Inakoju Ali was thus
move from Jebba to Lokoja a more distant place from llorin.
Apart from people's demonstration of support for Balogun Inakoju Ah.
the actions of the other Balogun and the people totally betrayed the
postulations of both the colonial Resident in llorin. P. Dwyer and Lord Lugard
that the great effect on the others not to give any further trouble. Reactions
to both the new status of the Emir, as the sole administrator in llorin emirate,
and the restrictions mounted on the traditional powers of the Baloguns
explain the continuous confrontational posture to the colonial policies, which
were often traced to the influence of the Baloguns. The hostility against the
Emir by his people became intense, forcing the colonial authorities to change
their policy in l02.
The height of hostility was so much against the Emir and the colonial
authorities that in 1902 the government changed its policy of recognising
the Emir as a sole authority in the llorin emirate The Baloguns too became
recognized; while the Emir was placed on Grade 1 position, the Baloguns
246
Create PDF files without this message by purchasing novaPDF printer (http://www.novapdf.com)
Even though the arrangement cached by the colonial government to review its
stance against the Balogun and the Emir on the operation or implementation of
colonial policies in Ilorin continued to register violent public reactions. For
instance, in 1907 when the hunters m llorin emirate were charged to pay special
levy for arms and other limiting implements, they mobilised themselves to
resist the policy. They assembled at Olofin Ganga to start with protest against
the newly introduced policy The mere fact that the Emir sent a warning
message to them in fu r i ated them and the protest turned violent. The I'.mir s
messenger wa^' k i l l e d and main of" the hnnlers lost their lives in a couiiK t
dclcnsi \ L ' b\ (he colonial <?ov eminent The hunter's not of Olofiuganga m
i l > 0 7 was doscK associated w i t h the inlliiciicc of Balogun Hiala of Ajikobi
the high casualty recorded in (he 'hunter 's revolt accounted tor the deposition
and deportation of Balognn Hiala \
As eaihei discussed llorin emnalc operates a system of government that
} \ K
' I
.,
, ] , .
. .T
...... ., .....
'
'
f.t
;"
i *,
<
an administrative unit \ \ i t h i n the touuslnp called waul and (he f'mii "s ward
administered In the Ma|agm dan At the terntoiial level, the areas captured
or acquired b\ each of the Balognns automatically tell within his authority
while the tcnitone* controlled by the Emirs were the ones given lo him as
gilts I I O I H the icspccmc Balogun lliaf led an condition lo acquire the area for
l l o r i n The Balogun or the Emir appointed their respective loyal
representatives to administer such c-aplmed area, either from among their
family members or trusted stress the act of appointing l i e f holders was
done independent!1 ! In the Emir and the Baloguns
Belxveeii I1'!).:' ami \' -> 0 /. seiious oppie>si\e measures were taken by the
loloiiia! go-i er ;i iu -. !i( to humiliate (he Baloguns and reduce their authority
and eonlioi in t i i e emirate at a l l costs. I he deposition and deportation of
fnikiiMin !!i;'k-.i|u , \ l i ol'Alanamu and Baiogun Biaia of Ajikobi were among (he
assa n i l on liu: Baiogun insiiiul ion \ \ i t i u n this peiiod These efforts of the
247
Create PDF files without this message by purchasing novaPDF printer (http://www.novapdf.com)
the territories under llorin emirate to meet their administrative desire. The
territories were grouped into eighteen ( I S ) units called districts The Districts
were Akanbi. Afon. Ovvode. Ajasse. Igbaja, Offa, Awtun. Oinu. Oso. Shonga.
Share. Iponrin. Lanwa. Li|idongan. Oloru. Paiye, Maleteand Omre . Since none
of the traditional authorities in llorm emirate was consulted, even Emir
Sulymaii. the strong proponent of colonial rule, was for the first time opposed to
the redefinition of llorin emirate territories into eighteen districts. Time had to
be taken by the colonial government to explain the advantages of the colonial
government s decision as a means of strengthening the influence of the Emir
over the Baloguns, who had hitherto shared in the control of the traditional
fiefs. To the Baiogun, it was another negative policy of the colonial government
aimed not only at reducing their powers and influence, but also meant to
subject them to the control of the Emir. Even with this knowledge, the
Baiogun could not readily organise any resistance against the British authority
at this time. The deposition and deportation of Baiogun Brala of Apkobi was
s t i l l very much fresh in their memories.
It was indeed an accident that some of the places grouped into districts
still fell within the influence of the respective Baloguns Some of their original
appointees were retained as District Heads of some of the newly created
districts. The appointed district heads were quickly made to know (hat they
were not officers of the colonial government but subjects of the Emir'' and
on no account could any of them relate directly with the Colonial Resident.
They were made to know that they were totally responsible to the Emir
either by appointment or by operation. The Baiogun had to console
themselves with the fact that some of their original appointees were s t i l l
retained as District Heads. But they were also fully aware of the fact that
their respective control and influences in the newly created districts were no
more
Because the Emir himself was not involved in the formulation of the
colonial policy on the new district arrangements, he was initially unhappy
about the reorganisation but with the explanation that the new arrangements
will favour his interest and grant him more powers, even in the fiefs, he
became disposed to the change.
By 1 9 7, the colonial government in llorin under Mr. Hennon-Hodge
248
Create PDF files without this message by purchasing novaPDF printer (http://www.novapdf.com)
had seen reasons to create more districts and re-organise the administrative
structure within the districts to accommodate the participation of those who
could not be appointed as districts of Oro. Ekan. lloffa and Share Yomba
were created'1''. Recognised individuals were appointed or recognised as village
heads of the constituted village areas'1". The tact that the appointees as village
head of the constituted village areas were placed on salary also confirmed
their recognition. They were specifically instructed to make their submissions to
the District Head who would in turn submit to the Emir With the
involvement of more people in the administration of the District, the growing
tension, especially large districts, was actually reduced to the bearest
minimum The administrative chain of operation created by the colonial
authority whereby the Emir was placed at the apex, followed by the Baloguns.
the District Heads, and Village Heads, was made functional.
Concluding Remarks
The Native Authority was the administrative machinery put in place by
the colonial authority in Ilorin as it were in other places to monitor and coordinate its activities. Even though the Emir was designated as the chief
administrative officer he was fully subjected to the Colonial Resident and he
operated only within the stipulated rules or polities of the colonial
administration. Like the contemporary government structure, the native
authority was made up of the three components: the Resident and the Emir
in Council represented the sources of instructions of laws; Area courts were
established to handle cases ranging from criminal to civil matter; while the
administrative arm of the native authority comprised the Treasury, revenue
officers and the Police The notable snag in the operation of the native
authority was the involvement of the Emir in the formulation of local policies,
the implementation of the policies and in the judicial interpretation of the
policies. Indeed, the Emir in Ilorin during the colonial period could simply be
said to have an absolute power. While the operation of the native authority in
the other parts of the caliphate, that is, in other emirates of the present dav
Northern Nigeria, could be regarded as normal because the Emirs were
traditionally absolute in power, the new powers conferred on the Emir of
Ilorin was totally strange and against the traditional setting in the emirate.
This situation explains the persistent crisis registered in florin emirate
249
Create PDF files without this message by purchasing novaPDF printer (http://www.novapdf.com)
throughout the period of colonial rule This is also linked with the high rate at
which the colonial government reviewed its policies in Ilorin emirate. For
instance, after the dethronement and deportation of Balogun Inakoju of
Alanamu in 1902 and that of Balogun Baale of Ajikobi in 1907. the colonial
government continued to witness resistance to its rules and policies in the
Ilorin emirate. The 1913 Palmer's review panel was set up by the colonial
government to fully digest the root of the reoccurring problems in Ilorin
emirate. By the Palmer s panel s report, the disproportionate representation
in the political arrangement imposed on Ilorin emirate by the colonial
government was identified as the key issue, which needed urgent attention to
achieve a peaceful administration The panel's report went further to
recommend that the Yorubas who were in the majority in the population of
Ilorin township and emirate should be more involved in the administration By
this, the panel recommended that the families of Aare Afonja and his younger
brother. Agoin. should be made members of the Emirate Council."-Even though
the 1 913 Palmer's report was not fully implemented until 19^6 when the Magaji
Aare and the Babalsale were effectively co-opted into the emirate council, the
persistence of the problem did not allow them to continue to ignore the report,
because the Emir did not like it to be implemented.
On the whole, the operation of the native authority in Ilorin emirate and
the Districts remained peculiar when compared to its operation in the other
emirates of the caliphate. The frequency at which the colonial government
changed policies shows that all was not well throughout the period of British
administration of Ilorin emirate.
Notes and References
1.
Samuel Johnson. The History oj the Ion/has, CMS Bookshop, Lagos. 1921
(reprinted) 1976pp. 185-197.
2. Ibid.
3. Ibid.
4 Ibi d
5. Ibid.
6. Ibid.
7. Ibid.
8.
250
Create PDF files without this message by purchasing novaPDF printer (http://www.novapdf.com)
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
32.
251
Create PDF files without this message by purchasing novaPDF printer (http://www.novapdf.com)
33.
34.
35.
36.
37.
38.
39.
40.
41.
42.
252
Create PDF files without this message by purchasing novaPDF printer (http://www.novapdf.com)