Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Conduct and Behaviour As Determinants For The Afterlife - A Comparison of The Judgments of The Dead in Ancient Egypt+ancient Greece
Conduct and Behaviour As Determinants For The Afterlife - A Comparison of The Judgments of The Dead in Ancient Egypt+ancient Greece
ISBN: 1-58112-107-5
DISSERTATION.COM
USA 2000
By
GARY A. STILWELL
Degree Awarded:
Summer Semester, 2000
Copyright 2000
Gary A. Stilwell
All Rights Reserved
ii
To my Father
Russell Steven Stilwell
Who lived in Justice and Moderation
And faced death with Wisdom and Courage
iii
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
2.
18
19
19
27
39
49
53
3.
1
4
5
9
11
12
58
61
62
65
66
76
79
THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE AFTERLIFE CONCEPTS IN PREPLATONIC GREECE: THE DRAMATISTS.................. 108
Aeschylus, Sophocles, Euripides
and Aristophanes ...............................
Aeschylus ..................................
Afterlife affirming....................
Denying an afterlife ..................
Sophocles ..................................
Afterlife affirming....................
Denying an afterlife ..................
Euripides ..................................
Afterlife affirming....................
Denying an afterlife ..................
Aristophanes ...............................
Summary .........................................
5.
108
108
110
113
115
117
120
121
122
124
127
131
CONCLUSIONS ON THE GREEK AUTHORS: THE PREPLATONICS INFLUENCE ON PLATOS MYTHS ........... 137
Introduction ....................................
Eschatology .....................................
Ethics ..........................................
The Cardinal Virtues .......................
The Unwritten Laws of the Gods .............
6.
81
87
89
89
91
92
94
95
97
99
100
101
105
137
138
143
145
154
Introduction ....................................
Religious Texts ............................
Historical Framework .......................
Types of Judgment ..........................
Elements of the Person: ba, ka, akh ........
The Questions ...................................
The Entity Being Judged .........................
Pre-History ................................
The Spiritual Afterlife ....................
The Blessed Afterlife for Everyone ..............
The Classical Egyptian Judgment of the Dead .....
The Book of the Dead .......................
Conduct and Behavior in the Book
of the Dead ..............................
The Negative Conduct ..................
Analysis of the Declarations ..........
A Comparison of the Two Declarations ..
The Positive Conduct ..................
7.
187
187
193
194
195
8.
157
157
161
163
165
167
168
169
174
176
181
183
198
198
205
206
206
218
226
227
228
230
233
233
236
vi
239
242
244
246
248
250
251
253
254
255
255
256
257
258
261
262
262
265
270
275
278
299
308
310
313
320
326
328
345
347
351
354
356
358
369
viii
LIST OF TABLES
Table
Page
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
ix
ABSTRACT
However, it is in
The third part deals with the connection between conduct and
the afterlife in ancient Egypt up to the time of the Book of
the Dead.
xi
INTRODUCTION
Introductory Comments
His
particulars.5
In light of these examples, we see that many have
written about both societies separately, and sometimes even
together in the same work.
However, I have
S.G.F. Brandon, The Judgment of the Dead: The Idea of Life After
Death in the Major Religions (New York: Charles Scribners Sons, 1967).
5
The first
However, it is in
After
However,
Hesiod,
these newer ideas in their poetry and thereby set the stage
for Plato, who will incorporate them into his own
eschatological teachings.
7
The Eleusinian mysteries, contrary to the testimony of the
intellectuals, did appear to offer some differentiation, which will be
investigated in chapters 3,4 and 8.
We will
investigate this issue in this chapter by examining the socalled Orphic tablets of Olbia.
Chapter 4 discusses the Dramatists.
Aeschylus and
This probably
At
Into
An
2.
persons?
3.
dead?
Here, it should be noted that the question of the
judgment of the dead is nuanced by such factors as: who has
an afterlife and who is being judged (King vs. non-royal
commoners) and what type of judgment is involved (judicial
vs. general).
More specifically, is it
punished in an afterlife.
General Conclusion
Many