d "

Lf1JJ. Lra. Fll'1:Uf1'l!

~ '" '" c!

lJl1n'VlUl"Ul~ll'Vlm

,.

~ X...;c.....,_ ~ t? ...M ..D do

I ' ,',.. ~ lflS£lll18\1Glmi:t 1

ChangeFuslon aas. ~ VoluntoGrSllirlt NetLlJor~

~Ll'l"mio,,~.1'u OpenB,se ~m""""'"""".iffllfll""'ljfll". Creot",e Commons Attrlbution-Noncomrnercal-Share Alike ~3.0 Unported license "lU~llJ'''"lIlLi'ia''''1n1iultll"lf''."'''ULL ... ""al'' 'l~U.,a~iiH1i~IL".~i'ilJl ";11J1I11tl1"lfLwa f111li-r1' lLi!I:::ri il..,l,r~ ft1 fln i1ltf1:11 ffi1fUr;'J Li?! 01 fiuaw a LJ..S U LLWIIi...,'U H~ r;'J uil ih' L-)lJLLGl ~~l.I dh.LU rJ1..:15'U

msu tJa: 1 ft'l"UfI'UQJ1I'liJlnU1ti'"

,

IJ .......... d IJ

McGraw-Hill, Inc. LiJ1Uflla'iU\'t1fiUill

Copyright © 1964 by McGraw-Hili, Inc.

"\ "" t! ~""

llWlJWflHVI en W.f1. IiDd'Gll'l

v "'" ,v, oJ

R"~aU~~n~"ft"DRal~all

~ ~ ~

..

v <\ .,. 0' ~.,J .,J

'U 'U 'VI fl fl11 'W mH3) 'HYI t'l

v <\ .,. 6' ~.,J

'UU'Vlflfl1'J'W:JJ'VH<11~'YIS11:JJ ...

v<\ ,,0'~.J

'U U nn fl11'W~'Wfl1 ~ 'Vl~ClL.

v <!l v AI

'U'U'YIf)eJbl.1J~

'II V

Bl'nJdl1J'YI •••

o

@. 1J'YIUl

""

(9Je/. ~eNb~1;'lmeHl

·~c:i:.~~161j... ...

,

6' (0)'0. C1~bbf1:tb 'UClHl

/ 'II

j/@.:V. 1,Ub f1f1... ...

"" 0'

<O)r;t. b 'U1HI,D:JJI.I.~~~J~l;1

tlV 6'

~ ~ ;/:JJ 1 fl 'If ...

""

lno." b~U'U ...

k"J1Q).' rl~hh&'l;u~tJ 1.1.~1:t~~fIJJ"l51~timJ

v
VlUl
(10))
(lm)
(G,) )
(~)
(ci )
0)
0)~
wI:
r-~.··'··'--
,-'0~ .
/
Gf"lm
G)IO)@
0)(nG'1
(9)'0c>:'
@r;;{Gf
ootP)<t'
···5
... "lm'0Gf /
"lmGfiu
G'11ID.:V
"...., '0)m
___ .
G'1GfG'1
e: lID lID
c>:'G.!Gf
... ~r:nJGf
<t'ow
... . .. rr~G1 Qj '" 41!!1" ~.d.d

11 U 'tin n 11'tUI'WrJ 11 'tid

" ,~ L!I L!I ,,y ,

~lU~~fialHw~~nUlaal~Ul1

" uai,lWU

QJ ~ ~ ~ ~ d

UtA't1 nn 11'WJJ'W il1 ~'t1 "'UI

... v ~

~TI11Halau611~~ld~1

u "" ooI!!I ~ ~.d

tJU't1 0 011'W 3I'W rl1,uUtiH

QJ ""l v

UU't1nNutla

'1J

~ " "'" ~ "

il m ::1! rl ldVl1 a.I 'Vi 1'J't1 i.I1iUI fi 1 Ulrl ldVl1

UJilltJU 1.,&G>0

9J

f) 1 'UUl 1.1 '1

fl ~ ~

Lf)~. ,Ul ~l'1~f)U (M. Judd Harmon)

/: rtll

o

(9) UVlU 1

~ ~ "'l vi"'l "" "'l

~ bbGl~'W'U _J1'U "lJf)~'a ~1J1Jfi1'H ~eJ~ fl fl f) fl'J1~fl ~'Vll~ fl1'ab ~eJ~

eJ1'"ltl m ~!'.J~flQ.l'U1~.J 1 ~~'Wv'U D .fl1'Wbb'(;l:t fl1'atJD1J~'Vl1~ nTH ~El ~ ~~iil~1rltlJ~l'V!r1J'UrJI"lGl Lb~

9

"" "'l ::1 ' "" ,t: .,"" """ 0 Q.I v' t:"! v'

FI'J1~fl~'Vl1~ mn ~eJ~ bm fl~~flb 9i'U 'U 'U fl1'a1J~ 1J~ eJ1'"lfld:t'Vl1fl uu fl:t'6ltl11J'U El1'"lflEl~~"lJ'U u Gl:tbbm1

q "'l '1'1./"" Q.I "! ~ 'V"" Q.I '''l v "" 'V .,,,, """ v,

'Vl~'I1tl fl1dUJeJ~ '"l:t ~ ~I"l~f) 'U"lI'UL 'WE) eJ1~eJ ~~'U 1J~~ 'U u \91 b ~I'.m 'Vl'"l'Hbb fl 'Jfl1'a 1J{]1J\91bU1:t~tl11J 'U b'l-lGl1

~d "1" '1 % <!i. q "'l 'V ~v, q "'l dI

'U 'Ufl":tb~m~El~ b 'a "lJmnL fl!'.Jbl~ '"l:t"lJ1~'Vl~tl tl fl1'aL ue ~ \911 ~b VI~ eJt'I '?l1'U 'U El1'1'J 1 'Vl~'I1.o fl1'n~El ~b 1J'U

,.

...... v Vi! «>I ... ... ... '1 v v'" vV.I'" v

'J'U 'l~ tlfl~lGjfl fl1'Jf1 fl'l:J'lfl'J1~I"l"Yl1~f11'JL~el~rI'J'H'~eJ'U b ~'U flf1 f)1:J'l'J'lf)1J'J~b~'U Ylfl~eJLI 'VI1'l!'U~"lJeJ~

'U

l1Ub6~ lJv'UI"l~'J'l~L~U ~.i'J::1lJ"li~ ~~tJ~fJ~!'b~-~~;yj ~bnflrl'Jl~~fl~I'UYll~fl1n~eJ~ b ~eJ'-l~

1t.10 ~'" Q.,I I .q

flYllf11'~'U 'l~~Eltll~m VI~CJ~ , .:'

LJ'J~b~[J~ b 'Jl'l~1~.w'l1·HU 1flU ~~ 'b'lfi'lj-t\u~'U1~mh~~ fl'UU 1!''el1fl'J1~~f1YlI ~fl1'Jb~€mJ1L:U

b

S)o

•

'" Ernest Barker, Greek Political Theory: Plato and His Predecessors, 4th ed., Barnes Noble, Inc.,

..,

New York, 1951. mil d

"

*. Gustave Glotz, The Greek City and Its Institutions, Alfred A. Knopi, Inc., New York, 1930. 11141 G)

'" George H. Sabine, A History of Political Theory, 3d., Holt, Rinehart and Winston, Inc., New v

York, 1961. ran d.

• .,,, " t ~ '" tI

Glotz l11HfftltlHL~iJL~tl1fll! lHIl J..bo

koo

"" ..\ '1V'1V v .1 "'.11 V !.I "i "';'1' '1vv

1t'IJ'IJ'Vl1fl1Lj,Hl L'WEl ~VI ~"tiVlb'lfifi1'a1Jd':l:59.lTo1J ~tJfi'Uf1'Jl~·lJ'Jl~"U'U "U1J'J'Um'aL1'lfi'VITb'ib:JJLl"1tJbl91d''Ufi1':i

... v , .(, "" .J i!! '" "I I v .J.I.(, v v

'U tJ:JJ1'1'U 'IJ'~~ 'Ubbfl 'lJtjJVll'Vll~l"! 1'l'On:JJ'VItl fi"U'U l"1~b m:l:5fi 'U b 91"1 'U; 'U Vl1'l ~ I 'Vl1J'J:l:51'1'IJ'lJtjJVlll"1b'l1tJ I nu

~.J"" ~ .J1,'1 ,0 v v Cif I , ..t1 ~

'VJ~'Vl:JJ"ti'U"ti'U 'Vl :JJ "tid'J'l1Dd''"ll'U 'J'U:JJlfi:JJ1tJbLfil:l:5"UtJ'U "U'W,LL "U~EltJ bbfl11'1'l'D'H 'IJ'U"ti'U"Ii'U

ov~'" ",..t1..\.J<i\ ,",vv ~,

flI11"1 tjJ"l1 ~fi9 f11d' ~1'ULb t'1:l:5¥J'J 'l:JJ ril91l, 'IJ'Ub 1 El ~'Vl9:l:51'l1 fiW1LLfil :l:5¥Jl91ri'U fi 'U b 11fl0~LI, usu tJfil"1'Jl:JJVI:JJ1tJ"U ~H

flIm'W,:l:5d'l'l1Dd'''UEl~I,ElI, 'Vl'U ~l,bfl:l:5tl'9~'lJv'U ~1V11~d l'l1D ':i"U0~~1:l:5L 'YI1'l1~d':l:5"lil;~1\9mt'1:JJfJi. VI~ 1'1~lm~

:'i ' 10) ,..t1 ~ ~::"I ' ""l <i\..t1 ""'" '" , ~ v 1 '

11'1'l'Dd' b~tJflI'JU b VltjJb 'lJUj,H"l1~b:JJL91~9~~ril"lfilriElVl:JJltJmb 'IJ'Um1:JJ~'VI'O'\J1~EltJl~ OU~'J' 3 :JJB1"'l

""l "'* v v' I "'l V V""Q.I

1,1, nmu 61H VI'n)'lW; ~'\J1filri:JJrid'El~\9l0fi1'Hb 'Vld'f1bb 9.l ~"U0~fit'1 :JJbElfi"li'U VI'JElI, 91'Vi'U 1'V1'J' ~'U11'l 111:1 D'J'

"'" 9 9 ...

V ~ V dI '" V V 6' 6' "'*:1 , .. '" Q.I V 6' "\' v Q.I q

flI:JJ~J'U:JJm 'IJ'U t'l:JJ1"tifiCJfi'WU n'IJEl~rJf11d'Vl1'l1tJEl~I"If11d'''l1 ~b:JJ:JJfl9md':JJ~:JJ'W'U '0 bl91tJfl'J'~mJd':ii' ml'l1 Dd'

91 .tl

1,.J VI 10.110)"'.1 :1.1 "" ..t1 ~ V

:JJf1I"l 'UL "lJ1'.i'J :JJLb "U~ "U'U b 'U f1 9fl1d'1J fil"ld'El ~ 'U en b 1J 91fiEl0 mfll tJ ~~~ l"1:l:5bL 'U 'Ub 'IJ'W 'lJl~I"I'H'lJl~rid' 1'J 'J' 3-

"\' '1 <V ",..t1 ~ "* , ..t1.J", I <!j .1 ' <>I 10)

'\J1b'l b\91tJbQ 'Wl:l:5 b 'W d't\91'IJ"li'W] b 'lJ'U flI ~'H u ~ m ~Vllfi El19b '\J1J nu tJ:JJtJfitJEl~ Vld' Elflll1Jbb"li ~b 'WtJ~ ru 31'U:l:5

..t1, ~ 0 I , "" .,. ~ , ~.J ""'" '" .J Cif :'I 'V"\'

L 'lJ'U VI'U 'JiH1'U "l1 ~ 'VI 1 f11d'El~'Vll~ 1 L6 b'l:l:5:JJL 'WtJ~'\J1 ~ rid' ~ '\J1 ~1"Id' l'Jb 'VJl'W 'U 'VI9t:JJ El'Vl'il 'W1'l'VlL VI 'U b 191 b \9ltJWl'H

L ~'Wci'J'U fl--S~El~1 \9l"UEl~ '.i1'l1 Dd' Lb~ ~lm siln rid'0~flI:JJfJi. VI~9t~CJb'lL VI~Vlb'l'J ~~ Eln9f)n:JJ"UEl~~d'~ d'1'l1D'.i 1,\'~I"1'Wd 'J'W mfi\9l~;'W'19 ~~'lJ~ ~1'U ~d't91 'Jv'U I,Lb'lt bLt'l'J ~ VII ml:JJ '~l'nT;jJ "UEl~ (9)'U 1M1~ i'0~

<i\ OJ <!j v V V ~ v ""l OJ "'12.1 V v Cif~1

'Wtd~tl~'a 3'\J1b'l'Vl'.iElflld'1,1, 'Vld' nu elH "U0 ~d' 3't.l1fil'W n 'W 'W 'il:l:5"l1 ~CJfi'W1J 'Wb'lI,:JJeJ ~"lJ 0~d' 3"lil\9l 'Jmtlfi 'U fl:tJ

I v I V I V OJ v.,-.,) "" 'II .J "" I .J ... wi 'V <!j

flI tll'U:l:5'J'l11 D 'J'd' 'J ~Jf1 'U d''J:JJ El tJ\9l 'JtJ u fltJ ~ I"I'J 1:JJ'b'l :JJ'W'U fiEl 'U El nsn n 'VltlltJ 'VJ :JJ flI 'J 'Ub fitJ 'Jb 'W tJ ~ L b'l nu 0tJ VI d' 0

'II

1,.J vvv""l ""l

:JJb fit! 'J nu fi'\J'l3 VI';i eJ f)1';jb:JJ eJ{l b 1'l tl

o v 6'

\Ii l'Vl'J''UfI'Ub ell '\~ ,\H'l

AI' .... ""\ ,t ~I ., 4 til 1"\ ""'" '"' .... 0

", ] fl" 11 U "g; ~ J lJ flll f1 ') llJ , J lJ YI ~ 1J J ~ 'U eJ ~ 11lY l4'lU 'U (t' J U , llJ 'lI ~ lJ lJ 111 ~ 1) ~ 11 ff lJ 1 'll' fl 'U iJ ~, 1l1l g; 111 fl1 1

"" '" , ... ~" ... t "'~ '" t "" "'.. "" ", .. I , 'l '"

m'CllJ{)~i11mH)f1'U{)~'.lI II'l ~~lHj'll'11'l{t'~1)lJ'I1~H1J~ 1){)'ll'11'lf11HlJeJ~ lJNYI'ilG;LU1-HW'1:i;11 lIUm,]"

"''''' .!( t " '"' ~ AI' ,~I..., ' ,,*

'lill'lf1lll:W{)~ I~HJU'l1ilH1H'f11.Jtllg; 11J'U{t'~1)lJ lJ1flf111'UeJ~Ll1

" Charles Howard McIlwain The Growth of Politcal Thought in the West, The Macmillan Company, "

New York, 1932. 111~ 1 ci

---'--~-~--------------'--'-- --~

... -14 11 '. ~., 91

"Sabine tllH'cl'tlt)HL{llJLl'ltJ1f11~ l1Ul G)",

~'1.~1;~1M~BOLm nu ~ ~ 'rlB~~~U '111~"mti~ I'" ri Bii---"~~t "'~'""B~~'~

6'..... v...... V I <>l v<3...:1. v

I, "'l\9l'U1'nl~lH)UbI, 'VI~'H"IJeJ~ 0l\9lb 1'1~eJ.fllfl bbm 1beJfl.fll'W 0l'J 1~mUlb fl1iH'J'Jbbfil~01'Jlm 'b'1 m 1J'U "IJeJ~ n 'U

. ~ ~ ~

bb ~~fl""''U eJl"'l1J11fil ~ ~1 ~t'!'ll11~"'llflfl'J1~b 'b'1~€l.fl1fJ u ~ fJ'J l~b 1'1~ eJ.fll01d ~b 'b'1~~n ~b eJfl.fll'W~0'U 1"l{)1, 'U

9

..... ~ I V Q.I ~

'U fl11 ~ ~ fl111,1, usunrrm ~'b'1 ~ I"l~bb fil~ 1 ~\9I1J"U'U"U'U

~J, I~ I (ly~

b 'W11~'b'1\9l1JtlJ qjlbb ~~eJfil{) 1 'U "IJeJ{j b "IJ 1\91 an 'OJ fl111'11'B1nl!~~'1 fl rn lb 'W;i 1~ 3' l'U~ dJ ~ 01 ~ "IJeJ~ \9l1~~ 'G'I"IJeJ {)b "IJ1

fl'JldJ b t1dJeJ .fl1fll, 'U fl~ belb 'VI'U ~ ~ml~ 'Mmt'!~ 1 ~ flv1J1 'U'll'a~"ul1i ~1 Wit'! b'ldJ'1J1 'M~ "'l~ {)EltJ

'IJ

v <3. ... I V I ~ <>l ... <>l I I

~'U 'M:J.Jll'JtHl"l'JldJbb'l dJeJ.fl1fl'VIl ~fll1bmH bb\91 tN:J.Jlfl rmu usn I"lElA'Jld-.1blildJel.fl101"IJ El,:jfl11~'b'1'J 'U 'a 'JdJ

* Alfred Zirnmern, The Greek Commonwealth, 5th rev. ed., Oxford University Press Fair Lawn,

.,

N.J. 1931. nu: <!if,

'" Francis D. Wormuth, The Origins of Modern Constitutionalism, Harper Row Publishers, Incorporated, "

New York, 1949. l1U 1 b-Glo

.., ""I ..,

aOl'lJ'lHll~UHHtJ£HUrl'l1g

~~ ~fl11ri!' 'VI1~fl11b~eJ ~I.UU:~~ f1a.II.I. 'U'U~~~"lJ1TI~1~fJ "lJ M IllQ~_'n'l1 ~YI U~1.1. 'Ml{j sen

L 'U ~~fll'~"'l~';l~1. ~mJIll~l'tJL''U ~f1I")'H)~"UB~\?m 171f.JbQ 'Wl~ ~eJfl11fieJo/l t'lil1tln~;l"lJ'U / ~;eJL€Jm flt'l-

.. ~ .. .: "l.1 v <J _4 .. 12,j :'l

1."ti!1 (Ecclesia) ~ UYil~'YI~'I1 iJ eJ~rtfld'U lJ~tfleJ'Ufl'J!1~l'11 Dd"lJl£1'Y1~~~ ~1. nu klo 'U"lJ1H Ll

i. .I~ OA .. , , v V I .1 ,dGO'l 0 ~~ I c:c1 v

'U'YI1~lJU'UVlfl~ ~bb~ fl'Wt'l'J'W 'U Elm "lJl1'J:lJlJ~~"lJ:IJ 1.1.19lfl!, 'U'U ~lU 'J'U:lJlflVleJ~ IJ, t'l~&'Im'U ~eJ'J11. 'U'UeJ

9 'U 'IJ

o .1 0.1 v ~"I .. I <!\ I ::'1 wf ..

~1.'YI'U('~19l~1'U\j~~~71"lJeJ~lJ1~"l!1"u'U e1mfl1Vl'U~lJ~~~:l-lfl'U ~o fl'J'l ~'U'UVl'lH "1 eJtJ1\j~~fl\9l

".1 ~ 0 ~ v v.. . I v' 2,j.. • I v <J4 ..,

fl11 b 1£1 fllJ'J~"lJ~'W b rJ'I1'V11 b Vl \?l €l ~ :lJflTJ lJ'Jt"lJ:lJfl 'W 'UElfJ"U'U bb ~ ~ :IJ'Ul~"'tJ ill.te1.f11lJ'J~"lJ~fl'W ~tI \j nr 81 ~'U

, , , 9

v r;iq v 0 V I I V ~ 0 q~ v ~

'J'U fl :IJ \?lIm ,S'u11:IJ'W qj e 1'W 1~~Hm\9l4.J B'l1 :.j~ 'J 'W:J.J1 flB fJ nu ern flB Ell'U 1'"1'W VI 'Uqjqj~ fll'J!il'J 'Ufl:IJ

---- '\I 'IJ .. "" 'Il "- ..•. ~ ,

'; '.1 ,I ~ I "IVO I 142.1 I , ::'1.1

'U ~mJ1fJ\?ll~lJ1 ~b W(li fl1J'fl'J'Ufl:IJeJlfJ'U'J'V! 1':i I.b~ fli'J b "ti€ll'U 1'Oi1. Vllill'U \9l €l~'VlfJf)'U 'U fl 1'1'J 6{j b lJb 'W'a 1~

,

'1 ''; <Jc:c1 oJ, <Jvv .. "1 'v .. ~v OA v-" .1 vii

"ll'U l~H Vl tlJ b \9l"U'f)\j'i.'lfn 'U b 'U'U 'Uq)'V! 1'Y1'J n 'U \9l b 'U Vl:IJ'U fI'IHl'Uq)qj\9l1.1. t'l~'U flr1 fl'l11 nl'JlJflrl'J eJ ~ 'VIfl'J'U 'W

'll '\I ,

* ... "'" '" , '"'... II

Sabine lHIH1tJtJHltUJL;JtllflU I1Ul ~o

alO

bmmbb6'Ubbcl~€Jcil,'U~lbb'VIU~~I~ S) ou€J~r~1~

~ 1 ~

o ''''''0 ~:1VV 0 46)

19l1bb 'VI'll ~'Wb Yli'ttbb t'l~lJ61'U l~mfl'W'J nnu ~ 6~fl'U'U 111'Wt'li'l'V!I'a~I'U 1'U eo 'U 111 "Ii ~ b 'U i'l1~

... c;!J 0 , '6) .1"'oA<v<tl v 0 6)' ""i v

'V1~'ij ~b 'U'UfllbL 'VI'll sm ~i'lVil'J u \9l ru i'l1 ~'U{l 'U\9l11 ~b 'U'U 'Urll"lfl CJi'l'Hfll'U 1'"l b 'VIqji'll~ fl11b lJ €J~mtl

, ~ c;!J 0 'v ,..J 0 ~,,,,,'II V v ""i ~ ,

U 111'W~i'l'VI11b Vi~ 1m 'U'U\9l1bb 'VI'HOU6~'J]'1 'U 'Un~lllJfl\9llbb W1J{li'l1~'J'UL~6fWl~ 1tltl\9l1~ 1~tJ1~

v 6) v .. .,. <u ~ .,."" ""1v <V ""i ~ 'lI 0 , v .,..

I9l eHl b"lf'J u~'UIi!~ 1mbt'l~ i'l~ ~~'V1u 19l'J'Ub t'l €J flWJ"Ii 1\9lllJ fl~ 'VimfJ mu I~OU€J~'U ltJ'Wt'lb 'YI1fl 'U Vla.!I9lLb 'G1~a.!

, 0 v.,J 4 ""6) v "" v v ,<'0'.,. 4 .,J <V ""i IV d\ v V ,

rnsu mfll'U 1~'VI'U li'lb 'lima.! b 'VIb fl 19l~ I'll "Ii El 'U n 'U bb I9lfla.! 'U ltl'Wfl 'U ltJ'V!'U ~i'llJ nnsn 'Ub 'U'U 'V!1Vi'U l€Jtll ~

1'''' v.,..... ""i6) , v '6)"'* "i

lJb 'U'U i'l1~m'J usesm ~eJ'V1u'W'G1b 'VI'U €J 6 'U flt'llJfl1'Hl'U OUEl~m'J'fIl'U ltJ'Wt'l u ~~~€JtJ 6 'Ub 'J€J~'U btJ'Ultl

, '" 0 v ,<'0' ~ <!I ~ v v..,J ~ IV .J.,..

~11~l.l'J~b i'lYlibb ~&::i'l'VI1'Jb 'U'U ~ lrlqJ u \9l flOUtJltJrll.'l ~11.ltl~L 1 €J~fl1'Jrlt'l eu t'l~~m mJ'JOUEl~fl 'U'U 1 tJ'U'1tl'V1l-J

. -.-. , ." -

..... c;!J 6) "i v , 0 ~~ I V "" V v

t'l fl'ijW~b 'U'U fl'l~ mtJ 6'U bl9ltlbli! 'Wl~mtl OU€J'UOUltJOU€J~€Jl'U 'l'"l'U "lI'U €JtJf1'U'UI"lt'l fl"U€J~ 'V!'J'VI'U lLb t'l~~.fll'W

6' v .. 4V 4 v 0 ~ '\I , ~ V OJ ""

fl1'JWbb 'J~£'l €J~ ~t'I €J~'"l'Um'J~1i! m Ii! 'U "Ii ~Bl~b 'W€Ji. "IiBl'U 1~~1 f1"l1'U f)'J 1i'l€J1G1tJ€J~'1 Vi fI 'UI, 'U lJl:.J'llfl\9l

b ~'Ub 'Jt11~~~'Vi~ ~ b l.l;rl~~ I"l~bb 'Jfl'1 'U m'a~I'U ltJ'W£'l~:.J1J"U6~\9l'U L~'UeJ m ~€ii'l;'WI.'li, 'U 'UL£J'Ult:J

'Il

6' <!I c;!J v ""i r s> v"" I -:1 '.1

"lIB~L m nu b'1 'U lEJ'WI.'l~~1. 'U'U 'U fI fl1~b:.J€J~ u \9l\9l El~'J'UCJ'fI"Ii€J'U\9l1.'l €Jl9lb 'Jfll~€Jttfn u tl&::'"l~ b :.Jll'a~~ 'UCJfl

~lb ~'"lb ~11 ':ib~tJm"ll1I9lrl'Jl:.J11'Jl~1, ~"lJ€J~€J~~flJ~ J1U~OUE)~fI~'m! ltl'WI.'lLIi!'W1~€J~I~~~\9I"S'VI"S'Vi\rl

, v v <!I v v .,. .::, :1;;1 I .,. v

rl€J'U "lI1~ rll.'lltJfl~ en 'U'U ltJfld 3l-J'U \9111, 'U 'J~'U'Ul.lflfl1 €J~bb 'U'UflW~ 13'1l1tl rlUb 'V!I.'lTIWlJ 'U b~ tl'Jfl 'U

'U ltlmv]~ti\Fj; E)19b ;EJfll.l~~"Iil-Jbb ~~~'U"Ue)bel'U6~El~.fl1 €J~I~h~~ fl1'a~TH" 11,1, 'VIU ~~I'U 1~~€J~J

~ IV v ' ... v c;!J <II I

"lI'U €JtJf1'U fl1'J~ 'U 'Ub'1'U 'U "liE) ~b'1 rn LL'(;l~ rl~bb 'U 'U bel tJ~rll'U Bl~b 'U'U ~'G1 m~i'l'U m~b nau \FjB'J 1'J&:: fl1'a

'\I ,

o I ""i V v.,."" :'1 V" ~.... v ""i ~ V 0

rl1 €J~\9l1bb 'Vi U ~ 'V!'J€lbb :.Jm~'VI~ "Ii'J \FjOU€J~ \9l 'U 6 'PI 'W'-l1'J WI b 'PIfJCJ'Jb~'Ubbl-Jfl1'Jb t'l€Jfl\91 ~CJ'U '),}l1~i'lViT~

'II

.1 ""i V.I "".11 "":"1.1<'0' I V""

"lI€J~ u'a~"Iil"1i 'U €Jl~ 'PI~ ~tl6'V11.'l flll'J&::OU rsu \9ltJ9'Ub fl'U b 'Uf1 ml-J Lb\9l WJ1l-J'J'U~\9l"llfl'IJ"lI6~m1o/lIU lEJ'Vjt'l

I a:;: ~ .. oA v v I cv I "",v V V 0 I v

\9l€J~.fll'U 'U (;1mtl€Jl.l{l'U~mrl'U€JtJl~m~"U'U ~'U1l-J~CJ 1,I9l\9l6~fI1'J b "lJlmrl'J €J~mbb Vi'U ~ m'V!'lfl"Ul'f1

'V 0 V14 ... cv 'Uv .. ~

rl'Jl~'a rl'J 1l-J "Ii 1 'J ') qJbL fl~ Vi 'J,)fIVi'J 'U \91 €leJtib ~ fll-Jb 11 £J€J 'U €l1'Ol mL fl ~ "lI'U

'U

<l v .. 0' v ... 1 .J OJ v I V to' I ~ 6) v ..

91ml1\9l€lu'U1rJl-Jl,h~fl'U fi~98::b 'IJ'U'VI"tJ~LL'OJ~'J1 t'1tl1'U'U"lI€J~L€Jb 'VI'U11tHbt'l'JlJ b 'VI:.Jfl1~

€Jiil.l'altJ'VI1;B'VI1~f11'.jL~€J~6fJI~b1'1;bLt'l8::~~~'Ol~ i'l~~.fl11"l.fl~1, ~i, ~ 'U~~~~El~~~€l~ fi'UL€lb 'YI'U~t:J~

r--- ---------------- 'U

.. I v C V I IV

lJJ ~fl eJ'UI?l'J ~f)l'Hn'J {j ~ 'U o/l1:!.J'UQJ"tilbl. 'I,H'VI G1 f)J.'}1~CJa fll'J

(01 'J l:).J~l?lbb a~f11'Jfl'J~VilM~ ~'JlJ~ U ~Q~flcv'U ~f.J:).J1(91'J S1'U

.*

Gl A.E, Taylor, Socrates: The Man and His Thought, Anchor Books, Doubleday Company, Inc,

Garden City, N.Y., 1954. lnI'1 Glcnlm-G1Q1,J

... ~ tI' I -\ to' "

"I., Sabine 11lHffeHlHlmJLI'HJ"Jf1U 1m] en,"

c;nb

flt]'111J1tJ (Law) 'U~'U bu~1~1~bflmb~\9l~lJ1LbWJb'Ub;B~ alvliJt (Apology) f}~PJ1PJ (Crito) 1 V'lP71 fJa~ n (Protagorus) an f1 (Phaedo) I,I,~ti. 'U 1J'Ylm'U'Yl'U 1~'U I 1,1,~'U'Ylt'1'U'Yl'U 11, 'Vl~ l~hl7ltJ/'

~ v '1 "I~ .1.... <!I ") I ~ 1.1 Gil v") ~ .:

~l'jt:I.J~ f)'l;'tutb 1) b 'U 'Yl1~1).[] L~ ti fl eJ b \91!']'I,lj'J 'U b'Vl qJ 'LId ~fleJ'Ub tJ'U"UB b ~:I.J~!~_'l.l,:U"UeJ~L Bb 'Yl'U f,1 fl'Jl:I.J

I 0 OJ Vq t ~ IV

bb\9lfl'J1JJ'b'llflqJtJ~:I.J:I.J1f1:I.JlfJm1'U'U omn v

, '"

~~l'jtu l~~f)T~~fi~';;'1, 1'll'J'l;' 3n'OJ 'lhv"lltjJlti'J'J:I.J 'tl'J~'J~'i'll'1,lj~~ bb~~~lm;~bbWJ'J'J:I.J(9ll.lfl\911, ;rJ~"uB~

r;' I -i ~ I' 0 V I .., q ") ~.... v '1 I I I ~ ..J."J ~

:I.J'U 'l;'fJ~ 'J'U :I.J1fl"li ~:I.J~ 'J'U t'11flqJ~Bfl'Jl:I.J1, 'OJ'JqJl, ~'U b ~"UeJ~"li 'J WltHfl:I.J :I.J'U 1m~'Vl~ 1\91 b ~'Yll, 'JB~'Yl~'Vl ~JI'l

,

I, 'Vl~l~U l:I.Jl.w~l'Jtu 1eJ~.f)lfJl, 'U "UeJ'UL "UWlI, ~eJ~'Jl'J"uB~'J1 ;1'Vl1f1'1~Wl'Jt'Vl'Unl, 'U~n'tJ tutfl'JB'Uflbi:I.J

~ ,

o V V ~.,J I 0 ~ V ~ v .... "'>1 "'>I v

l,l, t1t61'U l'"1"UB ~'U fln ~ fl'Jl:I.J'Wtl'ltJl:I.J'b'l:I.J tJ'U 'Vl~t:I.J~~\9l'Vl:l.J1tl'Vll'U eJ~b \9llJd n uuse b"ll 'JUbI, 'U'UI, \91fJ'J nu

.01 9 ,

'" The Republic of Plato (UVUUUl1'11'eH Benjamin Jowett) 4th ed., Oxford University Press, Fair Lawn,

" " ., " ... "i "".1 • .1" Ii

N.J., 1953. bk. I l1Ullmo 'U'1)fl11)JI'lI'l'1lHtHfl~ "'1)llllJ'j" Ill() i lJUllJl1l1f1~lUUlJl1UUUU

•

do

r!J

'\AJi;'l~"lJeJ{jfl'J 1~1J~ 'I ~ nu 1'V!;e

I

jl'U~~~'V!'Jl~n~l~ ~)

v .,. % G):1!l ~ v v 0 <i1 .Ii v v f{' .1

'~jb fWl"lJ'U 6 'Ub useu 1m 'YJeJ~'U e~ fl'J 1~i91 eJ ~ fll1 eJ'U vu 'U'U"lHfl 'UbI, i;'l~ fl 'U e"flfl1~1J':i ~"IiI'i'1 ~

.,j I V v.,j I ..,. ~v I I ~ <i1 v I "" v ",1 .,jv

6 Vl~I~t'l~J'jIj~~B81"m 'Ol{j"Ii~'VI'OJ~tHb ~1~ b 'V!'U~~i;'l'"l~~~'V!m~b"Ii'U 'U 'U 1,1J'U\9l'U '.11 -' ~'Ul"llb 'U'U 'VImN

fl11~I'V!r'U~~1J1fl b\,i;'l~~J111n'"l~~lb ~'U 'U1{j~~1{j9~~~\9l~{j~~'U~ b ~B{j91fl1J~fl'U ~~'U~{j1'U 'U'H

I ::1 v.,.. l.;j d .1"' """ ~ I 0 .,j 0 ::1v"".,j

eWl{jb~~mlfl'UeJ'U I b "lJlfl flnlJfj'UlilbQ 'Wl~'lI'U 'U 'U I b\'\9lb'l~fl'U 'VI1~rl'U 'VI(9l'lJ 'YI16~~'VI~~lbbtl~fl1~

• .... .J.\ ')I , "'" u ')I

* Sabine 11lH(l'1JilH~"lJlIilVlf114 11141 eX&

--.--.---.-----~~~-

dGn

l :'~eJ~li1~~~r1Jl:lJ;;'Y11~~~~'Ylf.ll~~1J' ~~bb;S b ~'U1~~1 mru D~~vq)"l11~q)lrubb~%::ml6-1

~ -

<t1 ,I ')V <t1 ~:l,j v oA v

L'11~1d'~"UeJ~fl'UEleJflb 'U'U~'UJ"UeJ~b 1I~ h~b 'IJ'Ub d'e~~l'U ~ fl'ijtu~fltu~'J.J'IJ~fl'Jl'J.J\)'U7\bb~%::fldl6-1bi1mdt1

. ~

"U~H fl ti1~€ll~bb!:Jfl1~fl~1~'lio/1b ~'Ub ~'U 'Ug;'U I.b~~~fmcnf1~l~ b 'W 'Wla;E1~l~t~' 'U~11'U fl'Jl~t'l1md'\)'Yll~

d-1 ' "1' ,."J .1 4", J; v,."J .". ') "':1 v ~ <01 v d , v

~{~fl~fl dJ'J.J lf1 mtJ b 'Vlq)'Vl ~ J ~E1tJl~'Ylb 11 ~ L ~fl\91 (:J'UUl1 !pm'li 'U 'YlEld't'l h!9lb ~HH Wli b ~b ~'U \9lEl:J.Jl.flltJ'Vl a ~

~d~Gi'Ufl11Q; ~b ~'Ua ~d lflvtjJ~fhn'U!P\bb 1J 'J fl'Jlmh~'W~~"UEI~:JJ~ 'ij~~Jm ~~ ~eJ'U flv'U bb1il~b ~'U msmn

.,J 0 , , "i': <!\ .1 6' cl~, v 0 ,

'Y1"l~ fl1'Vl'U'7lt'l'J 'W flU! 1"l1"UeJ ~Ll'n~ bWli'U "lHH flld'1<i n'ijl~b~a;ud'~~'U flTH]! 'Yl ~\91eJt'l ~I"l~ fl1dfl1'Vl'U\9IEltJl~

9

o "1 .1 ~v v 61 s> '61 ~ ~ ~ ~"i ~ v , ~

eJlb.flElb~~iJEI~bll'G1b\9l '"lip) b~I"l'UflrJ b'U'li'W'W'W"li'U'W b\9l11\)€l\91Tj,Jr1'Jl~t1'W\9Ii;1'J'W'lJflfl1il"U€l~b"Ul'U'W

~ q

v 0 q V I 0 v.:::l" ~ vt1 "1 ~" 9...1 ~ <\ Q.I ~

tJil'Y11~lm ~d .fl1'WmfJ "l11~'Yl1'Hm 'Yl1'Yl b fl\9lb 'IJ'W blPltJD'n"~"li1\9l \)'l'Vllm~:J.J'"ld'~all>j"U\9IbfleJ~

~€lflld~m 'Yl~~\9l"UeJ ~~l'U'1 ~bb ~ri\J~l'U€ll;'W'W~'W bb ~~E11'-l'"l~¥~ fl E1\91'Yl'W1 ~1 'Vl'J~Gf1fi7\flvm}€lfl"llf1

9 'IJ 'IJ

"" , ."J.J v 0"" % "" <t1 % v

fl '1 fld"d ~'Y1 fl E1tJ lWlb n tJ'J fl 'Ufl1d'Wlb 'W 1Hl'U "U EI (j~ 'J ~"l11mj17\tJ~ 'Ub "li ~ 'fl'U rJ'19b 'IJ 'U a "U"U'U 7\dtJ~~\9lEl'IJ

9 9

v .J v V:1V v q .J ">I v.. d g; 4 .". d .1 .. 1 .

u v\'U'Yll~'Jo/l~'Y1'W€ltJ~~ mb"Ul\"7\d'IJb\lld'm'W'Yl~%::'J.J"U€lI"lip)b 'Vl'U'W'U~1 "li~'ell~'"l~(:Jip)flm~ lId~"U1TItJ \9ltJ

1'1V<!l' g; v q I I 0 "i v') I q v

'J.J \9l\)eJ'Jll"l'W 'Yl~'Vl:JJ'7l'"l~\91€l~'J.Jt1 'J1Ul €lfl1d'fll'Vl'Uml~ 'W b tJ'lJ1t1"U'el~d j blPlm 'Y11b 'YlmJfl 'U 'Vllflb t'l'U el

l. ~tJ~~l A'U~'J'U:J.Jlfl~'lJ1~~~m~€l~l~' ~b ~1'Wg;'U bL~b Ll1illJld'~b fi~'"l;Elbgl'UeJEI~l~~

cU ..

db

'U~fl<V'Ui, ~Yilfl11'JfnnflU1 ~WI~'U'V1'Uv1lJ'Ul'Uf)~~lVl'Jv'U~~l~~1J~btU~;f)!Jfl~1 "l U ~IU f)~L ~fnf)~~

v v 6) 1 .1 6'~ 0 .1 :'1 .1 "" Q{ -! v ",.t.-

~ 3'IJnleJ~lm'Jf;l 6 U Vl~'J1'U1'U'J1'Ut)J'"l~fld~'V11f11d'Uf)¥l'HN 61Jm~rl'Jl~fl~b VlU 'U ~f)lfHJel~'Ut)J1:I.llbbt1~

~ ~ ~ '\I

~I v::1 1 v vilv v _"j V v V I

fI1'JeJf)f)'U'JWlJf)~ ~Ub eJ ~ u ~~'Ol~\9l f)~ b ~tl fI 'U{lfl'IJ Vlflt'l f)tlm~'U'V1 fI~ Vlmt]'V1~ 1~~ mb'f\~~€ltlm 1

~ .1

mm '~\9lti fIl'J~ mn~~b ~m ;eJ~~lflvt)Ji, U 0 YI JJr y b u~1~ei1\l~~~~'JldW®fj'1~ilJ~€lci i, U

, ~ q '\I

I ~.I "* I 0 il,v '16) 0 I ,..,j I '1 Q./ V ~

fI1'Jf)eJ\9l\l'U'J~'Ulfl~ 'U~bb\9llil~flUf;lflfllVlUo/l Vl€ltl 6umbbVlU~bbVl~'V1\9l1\i 1 6Uel~¥l~eJU\9lUL'UU

'\I '\I ----_

I <\a..q V .cJ ~ IV 41 ~ ~

~'JU VlU \l I,bfil~U{)'U\9l~lUi, Vl\9l1~'V1\9lmJfl'Jl~f;lU~bbfil&;fi1'J eJfleJm~'V1b VldJ1~~~ 'J~'IJ'lJfl'l'Jl'l!fl'ti,

i, U 0; JJ-tfi"UeJ ~b 'llt'l1~~t'\lfll'J'"l~'J~b Dt]'Ub ~U ~'U~Hel~fl~ b 'UU 'J~'U'U~'JtI~{jb e1;~~l:V(L fi~fl1'Jbb ~{l

, ""

Vlu1'tQ 'vrl~bb :,'l~i, ~ m'Jt'l Q \l fl'J 1 ~ tJ\9l 'D 'J'J ~ nl~fl'ti ,'TuiJivlJJ?i' tJ~~ ~ ~ ~-~lli1'J ~'J~'ti It'1~ fl J.J \9l 'UJ

- q q ~ '" ,

, -----=--~ '~------------------ d

~~~bbGl~fi 1VlU~1~bb\9lbo/l~<?l'J£J b 'W€l'Olo/ll1 {lVl~lrJ.uf)U ~~1~ i, ~~'J~'U'U\9l'J'J'"lfl'J'Ufl~LLGlt~lU l'"lbo/l~'Ulo/l

- -q ~ ~

'Uf)~CJ~ f) fl 'J €l \l flU ~~ i> '"lb 'i.1? U tI ~€l, '"l'"l~ 1~bL ~ ~ fl1'J ~~ 'J ~-~TU-I"1~ bb ~~i.W~-rut m?Fliel1Ul~ flQ./U 'U~ ~ f)

- 'II - y- -----

U~~tJi, 'U~-1~fI'\'I'UeJ~b 'llGl1~ fll'J~fl'til'i.1~1Ji, VI~b ~tJ'J1tJ~1o/l£Ji, fI~~o/lfl~.fl~bb 'IJ'U

'll~~;~1\9ltJ \9l'J~f)Q.J'Um~ i, 'U amri'v I, ~a1~tlfl.uEl1'"l~~u'J~'Ul;~1\9ltl ~b~'U;;f.)~b ~a1~~

, '"

<!j I ~ V 0 0 "" ~.,. V.I ... 1 ~ 6'.1 v cv Q./ I

fl eJ'J lfl1'J1'l! fl'til'"l~\9l s ~ fl1 VI U mb Gl~711b U'U fl1'Jb 'W€lf) '?lfl'U 1J'J~'U I'D'll \9l tI'U ~ fl €l'J 1Jo/l'JtlU flt'l~¥l'Jb Gl uu Gl~

<V '1 ,.,J.I -i OJ "'l .1,)v.J '1..J

l:lfl'tHU~ ~ 'j,1lJ'Yl'Gi~1Jd&;fI1dVl'H"U~~ a~Ujfj f\~ t,t,eJ'lJ. f1'Id"UeJ~b 1J~ b~\'mJ1nm~'\J'\JI"IB~~

/ 9 f <3 . '. •

~';1111:1~'l~ VI~"U~J "li~~ ~r b ~m~tJ':lfIVLJfI11~fl'tll ~~'ULJti ~~lifltJI:11'J&;b ~Ell11'J~':ifl1:}1~Jll'WL~~

'II 'II ~

JeJifl~f111tilflEl~~';l'U'b1~"U~~b ll~ l~~'"l~lJ'~'V!mtJl~b VI~El~ f1tJ~ ~lf)~bb ~~~O'b1~ fnJ'Utl~'b13J"iJ'l VI~ ~~~~

~ 9 9

...,:"] 'Lv, c!\.1 v .1 <>I ""':'1 'Lv"! v v AI ~ , 0 V, .J'1 V

lJ~blJ ~lJ{lb'W61JdLJ1J':i~lJl~'JS1Ufl1B~"li'W 3JUblJ ~ b"lif)'U1J1~"ull"13J'Vl{l'V!~~ bb~t'l1"'1':iLJt'I'dU'Vl b"li

9 ~ "_

u ~ ~~~fn'tru~f\':iB'\Jf1t'l3Jmflfl?lb 'W'J 1~"U£J1tJ~~El\91\, ~ ~{lI"l'J El'\Jfl':i"Sbb~~'Vl{'Wbau 19!'dtl :~~'\J'\Jflfl~-

. 9'

" .". 6' I "l V q, '1 9/ "'l "'l "" I ""... I ') V V'1 4

mu 'b1W1"UeJ{l\' 1J~ b ~ ~'Oj~lJ~Vlmt] ~ U\9l1U fl1'JblJEl~VI'H)I'lI(,'\'01nJmfmlb\"l-a'\1,j fI'Oj b 1J§1 blflb "Ul b'"lfJ{l

'Wtl~bb\9lmbtJf)I, Uh'l~rJlJ6VUb fi~'"llfl fI1':i "UllbbtNb ~b ;6~fll'Jfl~ie)~'Vlr'W~aU tl11~6~ ellU l'"lfl11b~~{l

'IJ

<l 0 c!\ A I ') 6' .,. "I "" ,I:'l' "" til .J V "" ,0 V" I ') V

( "li ~eJl'"l 'YIlb 'WEl1J 'J~ b tl"liU 'Vll {l b 1'll'J'tI ~ n 'OJ) ':i ~VI'J 1{l CJ ltl3J u ~~ (;lIt] ~lJ ~ ru U 'VI ~ o/l ElfHrlVl1 tJL 1J~ b\9l

.. OJ 'IJ

tllV11mJ~eJt]I, ~~fl1'J~'J{l~~r1't'W~au rtuI, U r~eJV~'b1~'U'H~bl.~ ~'OJ%::y'hl, ~b;tJflt'i~e)""UVl~m VI~~{l

"'" 'IJ 9 •

AI ')V '" V ~ ') '" V V V "~ sJ, V'1V' :1V V '" V

b 1J'Gl b \9l'WtJ1t.11~f1~h'l 'J 1\l"U~ ~ \9ltJ b3J\9l B ~ h'l~t'I fJ flU m 1m "liU 'J l1J U Bl'OJ LJB {lfl 'U b 'J fl6Ub~ \9ldtl fll'HI.'l fll.'ll ~

'VIr'W~a ~bElfl'\JUb;tl 'Vld<V'W~ a~ b€! n-uu 1~ ~~ b~ mf'~ 1111.o/ltl ~U b;U ~ VI;€! blt "U-ol~111 I, U VI~ dl't1 ~P'

'\)

~, AI "" 6'~ wi! 0 .J 4 , "IV,," """''''':-1v

-UU"li 'U "lil{l1J':i ~fl'tl J "U ~b LJ ~ 'OJ lU 'J 'U mn'VI~~'jII~'tJt'l0tJ ~ VllJ 'VI'J 'Wtlel U b~ b t~~ 1~"li~

bl1~1~' . ;{lB~mt1I,~l-'jci~nd%::~U"uB{l\"1'Jl~JEWlf)~mJ1~t<11mdtlyhfl1'j1~1~£JtJ~1f1~1fl'Vld~t;U.\

- 'tJ ~ .

, 0..., ~ -4 6 I G)v"" 0 ....

~b~t'll~~'U'\Jd'J~I"liU "liUf! ~ "li {l€Jl'a~ruElI'J1f1BtJflltJ b~"uElWlGl ~"UB{lb ~~CJl.'lbbt'i&m 1.~"U'J~ ';i ~LJLJ

"" .. 6' wi! '1 .11'1..1 ~ 0 dI 'V 0 v ~ '~v J,... I

flBllll'JU ~m m.n 1J mU'l~'Vl~'Ojlb 'J'UmfJ~1~1LJ"liU "liUb 'VlGllU BU\9I'Jltl"UEl{l'\J~.b 'OJ nuuustneu ~{j

~{lI>j~'Vl1~'U1, 'W'Jl~fl'Jlm 'Vl~BlJ~11, U fll'Jfl'JB~'Vl1v'W~atJ ~El3J'"I~b '\J1'\J1~t'l{)1 ~ ~~1~~ rnsu ~{l~

~ 0 "'l ~ ,,,,, ~ v '" 'V G)OU

I, 'WEl6iU1'OJfI1db~B{l b u ~:IJ'b1~n"Ufl"UB~"liU 'llU ~flA1B~bb 'Gl~'VI'V!1'J BO~J Elll>jbf)\9l91flflJ1~\9HN ms b °U

'\)

o I I ~ ~ 0 ~ .:::1 I V Q./ ~ v 6'q

mu 1 'OJ I, °HU 'J1U ~ b 'WEl"UfJlt'J 01~ 19'Vll{)1, 1"i1'lt 3' fl9'b1 {l~ eJl, I>j~ll fll"I';iB ~ Bm u El~3Jl"l1 fl'Vl'J'\AltJf! U I, Elf)"liU I, U

£) ~ ~ v ~ :1 A 1'1 v ..., "'l

'l'l1{l b~'Vll{lViti ~ I>j~L 'U'U BU Vlll~ su b 1J b U B~lJ'J ~ B'U flt'l ~f11.'l U

9 "'"

B~1~h~\9l13J l.fl'Hfl1'JfleJlJ~'Jtiel~1, ti ClPJUr fj 1~~lflVmQ'Wl~I, Ub ;€!{l'Vl'JY~~;m arruu

. '"

:-1 .14 v v 6' ._, G) , a:; V "" G) , a:;

Vl1mHJ1tJ\9I~€!~b 11m 31U~t'I:IJ'W'Uu'VI1~l"IdElLJfld'd b U'V!~·ln~"litJ ~ ()\9l'dtJ "Uillbb ~~'V!tjJ~ b U VI ~"u1~"u'U

.1 '1 '1V CU G) V 0 ~ Iq I Q...I V 6' I q ~

u fll"l'JB~bb t'l~'VlVl 11 '"l~ b ~J ~ 'J'\J8U qj1\9l b VI'V11fl11t'1 m~VI'J esun u 'J J lJfl UQ 'U 'Vlf1 ~111JlddtJll. \9l8'J

q ~ ~

. .., ~ II.... 1 ~., 91

'" Sabine lHHffVtlHrNl'1lIJ11'ltJlfHl i1Ul <'1<:1 une Ernest Barker, Greek Political Theory: Plato and His

..

Perdecessors, 4 thed .. Barnes Noble, Inc., New York, 1951. i1Ul kGl"'-!..Gla

"

v ~

en bbill 'U1 'U b 'Hl 'U

'II

&'0

~ ~ (j 0 V IV 6'<\ V ~ ... I '1 v 0 IV ~ Q..I I

d~'U'Ufle1:l-l m 1.1 'b'lWlt<! 'l'l1d 'U'Vld 'W!T~'Ubb ~~fld0'Ufld~ "lJ {jl, 1J~ b ~b 'b'l '1Hlt<! 'lVld'U"lJU "lJ'UI,H£J{j~ {j

'" 0 V -"'I «J V .. V V 1 OJ .-... OJ ~ 6' ~

b 'W0u 'l'Hd fl'tJ 'lrJ'J'l:J-Jf] ~~jflGl 'U 'Vl\9l0 {j fi'ld Bnmtl b tJGl1 ~Vl :lntJl"l'J 'lm 'l'Vld 'WfJt<! m en "lJ'UbbGl&;e1 ~'W'U u'Vl'l{j

..... d1.,J <I '" ,I ~ ~ v.1 v.. <J V '" 1

fld0'Ufld'J b uin fldE){jbbb'1<fl {jtNudd~J~j'l\9l~'lfJ\9l1"UB{jfl'U "lJ.:J~1Jnflde1.:J'Oj~Wl B.:J'VlGl m GH'J{jtl19~fl\9I'Vl~b 'Vl

. ~

~Gl /'

V

o V .;i 6' , '" V V 6'''> <J v'"

me eu 'j ~~Ll~ ~ ~ 'Ub 'WelfJ'd l~j'b'l"U'bli~J1J'HU "U ~ ~~j ~"IJ1 mJ u VI mn 1'1 flfl ~Vl j''WtI\.'1 'lib el n-rumrm '"l~1J ~b v®

9 9J

'" v 0 '1 ,I r;i , v'l V

c:J1il!l~fl1JVl1~1tJfl'J1lJ bm 'Vl1;!bb flm b®

~

~gu'nt

~ q

a::: OJ dI v"''''' ,I '1 V "i .v 1 ...

Vl~ ~1~~Y bba~ F7[j71JJW L1J'U(;JtH1'UVleJ'U'Vla~"Uel~"IJ'd~blJflbVl b®fJVl'J ~ 'jJ1!~Y

'" 'V "" dI ,I'" oJ., 6' , ,I "",11 v , <J '1 .., v' v1 '

u 'bli®Hl~'YII'l!'U I"WIL 1JU lJ[)1Jfl'ij\9lellJ7~"IJl'BlJ \9l£JU~fJfl ~m1'Y1~'j1fl[) b U ~f/J 1J~J bbm 1'"l~£J~ lJL 1J11J1 ~

~ v.=J v ~ ~ u ~ q~1

a~b'VIlJf.l'UVlI'll'U~'YI~Lt1®~L'UVielUVI'U 1 "U€l~b7el~ F7[j'Jf1JW L'H)~ j 1lf,~Y 1J1~'YIeJ1'"lb"UfJU"U'Uf)eJ'U

* v dI <J.", <oi Q./ ,r;i '1' v.J <!j ,

fl[j'P/1J7tJ G) onus» b 'U'U'd'j'HUfl':i'j:l.J'YI®m1~1Ub "Utlu'VIa~ G11 bb\9lb 'VI'U'"l:::;b~tlfl\9leJ~'YI'"l~tlel'J1

, ~ 9J

tv '" eli ~ 0 v ,I '1'1.1*\.0 '1 '~,I :"jV

'] lU,~Y bbfl~ fltJ1fJJ7CJ bb\.1®~t\~fl'J1~b\.'1f.llJflfl1t1 b'Uf)11'1!J\.1~Jel\l"UEl\lblJ~bVl b'Ubb\l'VI'U\lblJab(9]

dI Q./ 6'''' ~ 'ki ...j Q./' ::'1,11' .J ,I"" v q .J, v

f)~1m 1JU eJ~ 1f)'Ii'U fJlJtI\lj "U'ULlJ eJ'dtlfl ';] ~ b lJ ~b fltlb fltJ'YIb "U1'"l~lJ[)b'bli'ii "UEltl fib tlfJ\l"UeJ\lb "U1'Y1,;]1 ~f?11Jj 1

-_._ _,--, ~

• .. ~ II , -\., t.I

G) Barker mHff'f)'flNL"lJL~HI'"lfHj mn 1.odGl

., ... II , ~.. "

*!., Sabine l1tl~ff!l'flH1{llJLVlfJlml 11\.11 bal

SI ~ ",I ~ 0 )

( m 1lJl 'll ~1L IHHVi)f) l~tlfl~l1lJ HJLVU 'YHI eu 1

'" ~ "I ., SI

c). 11'll11i1J II'1IJ i'lt!f111tJflmV~tlWl!ll]Jfl'HJf1t.:ll1lJll'J

.... ..I" "" .... -i

i~tlf1tl '1 L~!J1 LVU'Jjllfllla'~

.

'" '" i "" v SI

1.,. t!ll'l!!.ll1iU ~V flt! f111tJf)mtNtlW"tllJ~1t1f1t.:l-

, SI ",I ... -i .... "" 1 0 ...

I1lJl1JifltlflU'C1'llIUtltJ L1JUlil'll~Y1a'fl Umfl1l'l'HN

~ .

(YHi~u 1 i91tl'YHlfl mL~t'J';lfir11~tlf)~1nJ1t1)

"., " ~ , SI

e : n'jl1'l1tJfHlf11~tlf1mtl-ltlU llJ'lItl1J'il1t1flt.:ll1lJltJ l'i1u

.... ",I... -i -l

nu '1 L~tl1 mU'JlV1Lmtl~~

... ~ -'I v ~ , SI

l.o. tl1'UU1l1U L~tI flt) flllUnmtl'H)U UJ'lItl1J'il1tJ

i 'SI .. I., "" ... '1 "

ntl\1lJltl 'iltlf1Ua'11.lUtltl LVUl.l!lltl'il U~lm.i

4 ~

l'lL{l11la'fl

.1 '" 'u" -\ 'I I, • ., " -'I

",. lJlt'jjl1i l~tI 'll~ lJtltlflltllmj!1illlJ1.l\)j fltlf1l'

~ u

tlflmtl~i~tI'I'I~f1l'LL~t !L1Jmuul~hHJ flUil'U11.l

",I "", SI' t.... "',

urn iuun 'lJ'ljtl1Jfl1t1f1tll1lJlt1lL{ltlltUH~~LlJU

.. ...\ I Gf vi CLI tI 1 r!

'.i I'll m LL ~tI~L uunu l'1'ltlU eurrrneuums l'jjtl

\1;'I)111'l1Ulntl'1"tI

v n I ~ I ~ "l v Iii .1.,) .1 61 v I .... n I "l v

fl1~'"l~lJ'Jg;;LJl'VI b VllJ'WLLM1~ b 'VlL VI'W flTJ'b lJ~WmL lJfl~ b 'W 'V1f1,~g;;bbm~lJ"lJ6~b us b~ Ll'JG;;"U1-

" "

il.£)'lnIUI

oJ , " "

'i ~ U u 1JfHI H 11 f) .!J n a'lun tJ

"1 ti f)tJlfJJ7EJ \9l~~~'Ub u ~mnl I, ~fl1~ b~~TI~Mn~;3I,b 'U'UeJ~1~~ti':t3Vl~{j I, ~iJl

I v iQ ~ I I"" ~~ I rj.,J J v <'j

b t'1 tiel'J 11 ~ti ~n ~ ~ eJ tJ'Util.bt:J 1J o/l U 9J 'U ru Vll ~ ~'1 n 'YI~ I, m 'WtJ~ 'W eJ'YI'"l:t 'U eJ~ f1 'U flln m 1 'U 'YI1 ~ b 'Hlbb~&;

~ ~ 9

b ~eJ'U~ti'YIeJ'U f11~'Wlru9Jt i,hW~1Jb ~ti1~ illu l'Oj'YIVllJ'YI'l~b; €l~tJf1~1f1eJ~'Yl~'VI1'l'lJfl bl,m;;6Jf1'"l&;

o~v "".,J vo '"l ~ ",,,;vv "" ~<D) v.J, 0iO)V ";';'LI

'VI'l b Vl·lil~I'YleJ')fHm 'ru 1'"l'YI'1~b ~m~ S:J.J'YId '1:J.J ~];!,~J1LfiJ.1LflmlJ.lli~litLk.1!.1LeJ,}l]J,__nlh,1'J,:Yll'.lJID.ik.J.L

'V v 4~'I'l '0) 0:1": I v.,; <t "' ~ ~"'

\9l'J£ICJI"J'U "IH ~CJ ~bb\9i b 'UCJ~f11b 'H1~m'1VlU '1'Y1~fiH,:J.JS'l lJ~~"t11~ml 'OJ&;L 'Uti lJd~"till"1:J.J1, f)'\1\9i1bbfl&;

~

&b

f;) v q V 6' q :ci v ~ v V I

t 'W fl1:i"'l\9'i'j~b 'U£J'U'Yl:iWtl~'W "lJB~ no rJJJ7 £J L ~t'I b~'Y1~VI'blflfl1'a "\J0~ ~ifI JJ1j I,bl'l fIHW1-

v 6' Q.I 1 ~:'Iv v v 1 :I!j.,J ",,1 1 1 v

!'J1~1fl'ijl!''"l\WW1:i:wru''lJa~Vltlf1f1l:ib ~Hn'U 'WI, 'J'U1-:J j SI,I, mb 'W El'YlEl am 'U'U ~,o(i!o t1'J'UL'Y11 sl flU

1 4 0 v 4 VI _,J", dI 1 V 1 0 <!.I ~ V

~ 'J U VlU ~t11~~j 'U11'!t []1 fl'U VIti ~ 1,1, m 1'Y1 ~U '"l~b 'U'W "UeJ~~'J U m 11'!t []'a'I.L \91G'l~fl'U '"l~Clf1fll"lJ'U b'Vi'

\9I'a'~VI'Un' u "'l~~n!'~l ~~L ~a~~fl~"lJEl~'Y1jv'W~~ ti ~1,~~1'J:JJ~ lV1r1J11'!t []'a''U~ 1f1flGJGlCJ~\9I"\Ja '~~~U

.,J"" 1 9 OJ V l.,;j 1 1 V e 0 V"

'Y1~'U1:JJen~1a'U fl Ub 'J'Ubb\9ll,~ulll1J'Ylltll'YlbV~~1 :JJB1~l,b ueu un ~~'U 'U ~1'U 'J'U 'Jl'!t []j61~\9leJ~ fl~b~~J

v ~ '1 Iq V "" .s:O)v 1 .!J v ~

m'JTI::l []1fl'U b~b~J:W'Y11ulYl b "lJ161~eJ-:Jtlf1m'jd-J\,'1'Y1'O "l 'Vi!,L fl1Jflj"lJEl~fl'UeJ'U m~'a~°tllmTVnJ

9

~lU'J'ULfi'U fl~lM{Jfl1j~en~' !jj~;fl1jflmllL 1J~'Vl;eJ"lJtJluBltu lUfl:JJ1, ~ElGl~~j~"lJ,)fl'HH m~j~-

o 4d1 .,J vd dI v 1 0 v

G~lm-tJ~~lU 'J'U G'l-:J'IHb1J'U 'Y11{J'Ylb ~(;l1m 0v'f'U ~~I, 'U'U1 ,j1<n3J1fl fl'Jl 'j~lJ'U61~' "'lI.Lt'I~fll'Vl'l.w,l 'Yl't''''l~mn

c ~ v ~ ..: 0 ~ G'v1v V.,J 6' 1 1 1 <0) q <0) 'lJ .,J", v

'UleJeJfl b"lJb'WElL'W:JJ91U'Jl1"lJ'U L'Vi 'fIn~'U'YlIll:wmtu ml b'Ufldtu b~ fl1jfljeJ'Ufl'Je~'Y1~'U~~\9IEl~

'lJ

't ~~L ~') I flv'U

'VI r'W~,~'U~'U 'iH)fl~lfl~~'U1 ~;El~1,1, ~~il. ~I, ~'lflvm ~ 'U 'U~'U I,I,~I, ~'b11.~'"ltb t'i 'U ElI,I, 'Ut~lf1'Jl2-1

, ... ~ v 6'" 1 <1.>1.1 dI ~ ... , .1 lvd v, 01'" ""'1 'Lv .J

bt'i6JElb 'V111, 'YIt!6J h'U'Vl1'V'itJ!,'l'U h\9ltJ'YI'J 1J1, 'U'U!,'l~~ 1,1,\9l1,1J~ b\9lfl tJeJm'U'J l1Jfj'U\9l ~ ~\9l1~!,'l.flTW'YIf1'U1, 11

",1 , ':1 d<i v 0) Va a V "'" V 6"" ~ ':'1 V V

L U U EltJ eJtJl ~ b'J fl ~ 'J 3 b"lj Ell'U 1~f1'J'U f1~!,'l1f1 t1Jl, 'VIU El'Vl1'WtJ!,'l'U 'J ~eJ'i'\ "1 'Jl'tJ' [lnb \9l'b1tf1U'b~1'U

'\J 9 '\J 1

"I V'" V 6"", , V LV <i\ , , .J.. V ~ V V 6~ , V <i ,

eJU tjJl~) h'VI :W'Vl1 'WtJ!,'l U l:1'J U \9l'J ~ "'I U () ~ Gd 'V11"UeJ ~f11 'Vl~ U"U eJ~ \9l u ~ 'JtJb 'VI\9l '!J 1,1, ~'Vl1 'WtJt'1 U!,'l'J 'U \9l'J '"lt6J €It!

~ 9 '\J

l' ,q tV Id~ ;;r---r-~ O{'J ~ .c::-J OVq ou

:J.J1,t'i:WeJL'YI11, 'VltJ:lJflU I,I,\9lflb 'U'Uf1'Jl:lJ1, 'VI~enJiil1'Vl()fl'Ollflfll,l,i,'l~tJ'J~b 'UtJUf1'J'UmJ f)1d'"llfl~:Wf1'J16J'b'l1f1tjJ

, '\J 9

~ ,.J r;i i1V "I ~ V':1" <i .} V '" "I V ~ ~ ,I "I ~ V 6" "'" "':'1 • I

tJ~ml'Vlb 'VIU ~ b 'U "lj'U1,1, sn uu :W~b :W1,1,\9lb 'Wt!~'UeJ~fl U:W b 'VII, fl~f1'Jl:W h~ 6 m deJ~'Vl1'Wt!a:W'U\9l'"l'UL fl'Ub 1J

9 •

b ~lU~- bb~I~~I,~Ubf1~~_~_:lJ'U~_~~;eJeJ~I,I,i,'l~fll~~~1'"lfl1db~eJ~bUdV3m~_ll1~

~m'JU~'Jd-n 'U fl1d~flfl1fl~eJ~rl~'cil;~'"l~ ~eJ'VI~fm ~~l,l,tJfld~;~-D;;eJm~'U &' ~b~VlU~\9l1:W

a '" -{01 V 6'", 'V'101 ~ ~ <i V 6"", , V a ~ ~

i,j'lUt'"llU'JUfld1:W!,'l'Vlu 6'U'VI'J'WtJ!,'lUI,L\9lfl\9l1~f)'U 1J "lj'U'VIU~ "1 '"l&::W'Vld'Wt!!,'l'U!,'l'JU\9l'J"'Il'U'J'U"U'U\9l1t'1~

~ 1 9

~ ~ ... V 6"... a ".J... 'V a v-:1.1 0

I,l,at"lj'UeJu I '"It:W'Vld'WtJt'i'U~l'U'J'U 1m, (l)1,1,~&: rs_' b'YI1"UeJ~fll'VlmH~'J'U\9l'J"UeJ~\9l'U\9l1:W~1~'Ub1J '"l1'U'J'U

a "",.J ~ <4 ..., (;;'1 i1.1 ' V 0 V 6'~ , v.J ...

EllUl~fl1'Jb :WEl~'Vld1li[ld"lj'U'VI'U~ "1 :wmlb 'U'U 1J\9l1:J.J'b'l'J'lib'!~"UeJ~'"l1'U'JU'Vl1'WtJt<l'U!,'l'J'Um'Vl\9l'U:W

1 9)

Q..J ~~~~ b ~.q OJ t/q <i 0 V OJ 6' ~ ~ ~

\'J~:J,J'J ut'l'U "'1 b m deJ~dtb 'UtJ'Ufl'J'U~~'Vl1'WtJt'i'U 'Vl'U lWJI, "lj 'Vl1'WtJ'b'l:J.J'U\9l'YI~'VI:W~'YI11'tJ'[ld

f1LtlWll~6Jll, fl U fl~l ~ b 'VIT'UeJ~~1'Y11~~~~U ~~U "'I&:;eJ~tJfll, ~I,b n 1Vi,j' bQ 'W1&;f1'U~1~1,1,~'U 'U~UL~'U¥

~ ~

~11, ti 'U f1'"lfl11'W1W "lj~ 'VIlml,~eJ~dl1tn~1tb ~tJ'Uf1'J'Uflmf1-i ~fli~ 'a~'U'UI,~'U\9l':nil. -if ~l'VIdV'Uiil£Jb 'U

'\J 9 '

;eJ~~'VI~~'UI,bti&:L ~~dlli[l1f)Uil.~1~d\JeJ'U tjJl\9lb ~~'VleJ~'VI;m~ 'U 'al'tJ' [laeJ~b ~~1~I,~tJ~;'W'"llfl~~'U

9

, V '" ~ «>1 v, <J", .J V ~

'Jl'tJ' [J'Jl :J.J\9leJ~~~I,L 'H~'"'t'tH flul tl b U eJ~~lfl'V11!:l1, 'UU~'VI'J l'Ulmm'U I,l,fI~'jl'tJ' £1'ab f)tJ'J"U€l~I,Q 'W1tl,~tl~

'\J

"" "I V .1 ci '1' V "1 V '" V ~ ,I <ill <iI:'1 ' 0 "1 V1 , ...

"lj'W\9lm eJ~ b 'U 'j~~'U1Jl'U fliill ~ "lj ~ "'I~ urn 'jt\9l 'U b'VI b fl ~fl'Jl:W\9l eJ~ fl1'Jt'i ~'W:lJb 'WeltJ 'VI'jeJ'"ltb :W'Vl1 6 Vl :W:W

9 ~

b 'J'b1rJ~l'V1'jDI, ;El~'VIU1~'UeJ ~'Wi;'ll, ~eJ~ I, ~G'l1;( 'WtlltJ'1:lJ'j'J:lJ b'1()l'UvU 'YIrV'l~~'U ~'JU\9l"SflV'U'jtl, ~tJ'Ufl'J'Ufl6J

~

V 6 ~ V v, ... v.J dI ,0 V ~ .1 !"1'-' ...

eJU t'i:J.J'U1 tul, 'WeJ~ 'Jl~ !,'ldl1'Wl,b 'Jo/l~ B:Wb "ljUb ~£I'Jfl'U'VJ1, 'U'U eJtJt<l1'V1'l''U''lj 'U "lj U un fi1 eJ~ rnn b \9l ~ ~'UB'Uf1eJ :wm-

'\J '\J

.. 661 v V '" v"" dI , '" V ~, v'~ V 6.. «>1 ... '"

1.I!,'l'n 'U ~ mn f1 'UfJ!,'l}J:l,j \9l] 1lHl1 ~a~ I,'U 'Ub "lj 'Ub ~tJ'J f) 'UfleJ'J l~'Jl:W'I'J~'J ~ n 'Ub 'j BiJ 'Vl'j'WtJ!,'l'Ub 'U ti eJ'VJ'j)

'W(;1I,;a:Wb ~tl bl,iilt"'l~~va ~~o/lfl1~"1 ~b 1fJ'U1mJ1 ~'YI1~il.~'Vll~'VI~ ~ a 1'1 J.rtfJ 'VJ1~eJeJfl"UeJ~~ ~~ 1~ ~eJ

, ."

"" V </6""" , V '''1 ol,)v"Iv,,\q q ~

fll'Jb(;1fl~:W'VJ'j'Wtlt<l'Ua'J'U\9l'J 1,1,~1 iu ntJ11JJW b1Ji;'lb\9l b"lj'Ju'Jl~'jtl,'UtJ'Ufl'J'lJflm~'VJ'U 'j'lli£1'j'Vl~'VI:Wo/l

,

, U {~bl, 'IJ'UeJ~l~'UeJ~ n tJ 'IUIW ~'.i~flB'Ub ~'U "lj'U "lj~'U il flfl'jeJ~eJ~l~'VI~ ~ I, "Ulb Vl~l~~~'W'ojlfl~~'U bb~ fl'Jl:J.J~ 'U"l '"l ~l;~·UeJ~b "U1eJ ~~fl1'.i~ flfl'jeJ ~ *

'\J

_I Ii) v , " "

nl1Un~'~~tU'J"~~~~1~U~~ n~~~l~

i l.mCJ'Ufl15oJflfl'Hl~ b oJ~1~bb~'J{}WI~~~fl~ bb~~~£J1\J1~J·l~1~~:~mn~

.1 .[, oj I cj oj oj I "'l v 0 ~ .1 ' .1 .J OJ V "'l

1J'ltt11'U 'U'ij"Wfl1~ I 'Ylb6 'l{j~o/l o/l{}6 "]j'U b 'U "UeJb6 'U&::'U 16 a{j;,1:j,j~~ ~1Jm'a1Jf1fl~eJ{j'Y1W1'Hfl'U "U1d-JfleJ

flU! 1TItl1 ~mLt'ltoJ5g;"]j1TItl1 mJ 1~~~i'lo/l~t1 ~'U~1~~tb ~'U fl1'ltl~~f111'U "U~N'atlfl1~t1f1f1'l ~N'Y1~

~ 9 ~ ~

bo

a'al

,

~ cv "'4 I ... "

Barker 'I11HfftHJHl"JJLl'ltJ1fl1.l 'I11.l1 <ndGl

bd

19.1 .. ~ I t: <1 '" v') v ~ I t: VAl "'.11 d'U .. v 0

~ b fl~"I.I'U 'UeWfl1 ~b VI G1E1b mHl1bba d ~ 'U til ~~"I.IeJ ~b 11b E1~ ~ ~ m l'U 'U u ~1J1~ "lflU1J ~HJb eJ~fl\91 eJ ~ ~eJ'U 1

'\I

V <'l v il "* q I I ') A I .,\ 11 d I

u seu fl mn ~€l ~b ~1r111 ~~ ~ 'OJ"tj ~ ~€l~ 'YIflVl 'U 'Ylflbb 'Vl~ ~ 'U 'Jt'lleJ'lI1J1 t"lf~IU1J ~t1 fl'VHJ1~I~eJm tII~€lbb ~t

'\I " , 9 'II

o d t:.,J t: "'" va."Jv I I volt Q./" ~ I

tIIlb 1'"l'l.l1~fl'H'Yl "I~fl~~'Ub 'lI'U~'U lbb 'Yl'U 'Yl1 3m']! bb\9l'Yldl'Yll~bb f)'lIq)VlleJ'Ub f)WlJ'Ub 'W':11~fldl~rmnfl

1l 9 9 9

"I.I€l~~1t"lfl;~1~w 1~ I, ~eJ~~'"ltt~b ~ m~~':1t"tjl;~1(9J~ ~':1 t"lflfi~1(9Ji'lfl'J'J~lbb n fl1 ~ ~ ~'J'U 1vm'll

'II 'II

19.1 V .. v <1\ ~ AI "1 v"' v v I I ~ I

'J bb at mi'leJtHI 'U ~~fl 'U fl11 ~fl'rllbbat€l'U I b 1J~ b (9J b 'Vl"UflLlil'U eu ueirnem su fib ':11 "tj ~€lI"'1"lf'Ji'l

I, ~~~'J'U.ym'lI~':1~"lf'l;~1\9lfJl~ 1~

.,.j 6' vvwil 0 Q./ ... 0 ~... '" 0 OJ

'I'll, ElL 'Vl tit'll, tJfl1~ t:Jb 'U'U ,jn~:lJ"Ufi! Iti f)EllflIL~:lJ 'Vl1n1'J 'J'J'U'j'J:lJb 'JEl~L "UtJti ~lti "i1tifi!ll"lq)

'IJ ~

~~mlJ ~El ntJ1!JJ7fJ Lbfl~IJ~1.ln~f)B'Ufl~~ti I ~£J tiElfl~If)'U;"n'jfl~f11;i"UB~~I'Ufi~mtlLb~

.,1 "iv~ I OJ v..." ~ v"" .. .". 6' '1 'i.......J v OJ ~ '1v I ~ v

b II Gl b \9l:lJfi! 'J u 'W'J 'Wtifl fl"li ~ nun 'Olfl1;i"UEl su fl~ "Ij'j lfl'Jt'l u fl~ b~ b eu "Iif) t'l'Yl lID fl'J 1:lJ'W'J'W u 'U '"I~b f1fl6 b '\.1

~

bb

,.1 d" I 0 ... tJ 4 "

* IL'IH'ltLlJUfI11LmHl1tHlUH1l1fll'l I'lWl'llH "fl~l1lJltJ" 'IJ'Il~LU'fl1W1hllH1Yl Q) HUl bo-~o

~

f

! (, (e (' V-,'

i 1/ I

f11 su 11 o/l ~ 1"1 'Jl~~o/l'YnH111b~ eJ ~"lJeJ~eJ;~ 1 ~b ~ ~~ eJ~1~11~'ln~ t1l1 ~'Wo/l~ ~1;f1'l'J"lJeJ ~ f.)1 e-

'\I '\I

1 rlb~b'l~l~ eJ1111 ~b~t1eJ191~~~lqjleJ~1~b ~~m~11~11b~'W 'Wvfl5 ~rl71Y Pl51"1mb 'afl eJ; 111 m~ flb ~'U WJtlf1D

-~-'-"-.--- ----_ .• --._-._ .. "_-.---- .. ,,.- ... , .. _-

-_ .. _---_- __ ._- ~--

*" .. "'t " ~ I ....., -i

Sabine l11Hil'VfllHHllllJll'l!J1f1H lHHl &

v v ~ q 6' ."j v !,I ~"' "i 6' I", r;i.., ~ <V

(Ul1 ~'Ojg;:b 'U'U d~L 'UtJ'U~~~f11'J'Vl~'U 'iil'J 'N"U'Ub 'WB1J'Jg;: btJ'li'U "lJ€l~~'Ub €l~ bb\il1 ~mm 'U'U'i.'lQ1'U'U

""q v <V ~ ~ <I ~ 6' ~ <V I <V ~ ...,:."j ,

'ii d';i~'lil\il€lf1f1dU d jb 'U'Ub~d~{j~~~fI{jtl{j"lJ'U 'i.'1l-1mw, "lJ€l ~~dl~L 'U'U ~,)Yl,)~~.~_~]_'U I.b\9l';i 31. 'U'U~ ~'Vl.ll7n au

v q 6' f) v I I <V ~ I 0 Q.I ""

n 'U';i g;:b 'UU'U€l ~~f)1d ~ 'U 'Jg;:fI'UtJ€ltJf1'J ') 'J 31. 'U 'UbI. 'PHil ~'W,)'U f1'D';i d~'lil\il

"lJ€l~~'Jll-1~1{j~U11 ~ci~,)lJJ~lJ'U';iru 'Yl1~~\il' 'OJ

9 ~ ~

~o

"I V.,J ":1 I V "" V "" v''1"1 ~ Q/ dl

~ 1J"lJ~~'a j'Vl"llmj6a.J~~~a.J'a S~d'am; ~bb~~L\9l_~~_'W_6_1J'V!!'l:'_lJ~_ 'a j1i1da.J~ qjb tJ'W f1~vrmtJ

dlf131 'Wfll'Vl1Hlf11dbb ~~~ddB1'W lZlmm 'W -rS'a'J~'V1~~'\'1fibb~~eJ1;'l~l eJtJbb '\'1'U ci,J'tm tJtJ"lJeJ{jrj1idd~~ \lJ

~ IV "" ~ V ~ 0 rHf V 1!l IVI I

"lJ'U ~tJf1tJ"ll 'W ~bb ~~flUUl1'W"lJB ~d 1'lt .[:)'H 'U d ~'U 'U 61 fl'Jl~t'll\' d'OJ"lJeJ ~d :s Zl~"u'U sun tJ'J 1 mru m t'ld'a~11~

'\J 9 "" I .4 'Ii

v ~ v V '" 1 :'1 V"" "" ::'1 "" ..., rHf1 I

1 ~'Ddd~ 'U f{I'U 'OJ~~d en tJGl f1'11U!~i;1 '.J'U 1Jd~f1~tJ"lJ~{ld l'1:1.[:)d 6~m 'WtJ{I b d fl'.J l'l-ltJ~ 1i1d~eJ 'l.H tJ'W 'OJ~a.J{jvrd.ntJ

... '\J , 9 9

"lJ~~~~'llf1l'n~~{I'OJ~mdGl~~Hl m'Vllf1f11dLL ~{I~ddeJ~~m.l\,I, 'V1'Ubb~~f11di, =tit1TU l'OJb~'U1 ,j(9)l'l-lci'J'U ~

9 -

Bl'U 'JtJ'll'a~1 tJ"ll~i, ~bb fi'lld~OjJ1¥l~ 1~tJ 'Vlfl~~~a.J ~ci'J'Ui, ~1 ~b ~1\' ~tJ~n~ f11d~l :U~1'U l'lb\,f;'l~fl1d

,~ Francis D. Warmuth, "Aristotle on Law, lu Essays in Political Theory, Presented to George H. Sabine., nlJn2J1~tJ Miltion R. Konvitz wm: Arthur E. Murphy, Cornell University Press, Ithica, "

N.Y., 1948. l1U1 <id.-bG>

~ I Q/ I ,~ .. 4 - ~ al "'" .0\ '"- "" e] e..,

"'iNU'U'lII'l'Jl L'lHHI'lV1f1UYl111.JflWlI'lU1il~lJ'lIlI'lL11WL~l fl'lHIW '11i'HJllnlJ'lJl~L1J\mlrr LLm~C1111nJ

v ,,1.,1 t .."

111ffLHn II nZ~JtH fJ1 U.JLlJ'W Ylln L 11 14 VI .Jf}1l1LL l:)g:rJl'lln, lJ

•

~ v

(nnWf)v 'VI'Ul <OlGt)

__.-'------

~ I V"" <J ..

ul~~1~Un~fil'~'~11~~

TI~1fH'J~b~tJd

~I

'lU m~'YI~L ~~eJl"l'Ub ~f'J~~~flUf'ld~fl:W81'U 1"1 'l~neJ' ~b fl\9lfl'Jl:w1~~~'WElb ~1, U~~

, ~

~'~~l .. tJ U n ~1'J1 ~tJ ~eJ 'YI1-:Jflv:WL ~ fl'J"lJfJ~'j~~'j~~lTI~'l rJtJ~~flf1t1l1TI~1 rJtJ;~b ~e~ ~11~ln€lv'U ~'j1U

9J

~-Jl ,~'~,~~~~1 1.11 flfl:Wim f1u19,J ~eJ~lf\m'j~,r 1bm'V!flnm'j~ni.!G'V!'Uvfl1 1.1 1, 'UWH'V!~ ~'YII{j

9J 9J

i.~b n Ultl'U"'-''Ub tl {j

~ :WlfiOUU

v v <oj

1S~TI1S~~U1J~~U~U

~7Ei~ ._.

"liU "IlUUb 'Uti31U'H)~1'lJ

~o

o eI v

n 115 1 Huhl i11111'Wtlf)!J1! 51'iSJU 'l!

'11

v 0

"Um\, 'U~'Ul

6' 'lJ'Jbll\'\' 'lJ'U

'U

c:c"1 ~ <:~ 0 I ~ 9.-1 ~ qoC:\ c:l~~ ~..::r ~ q G 9...JV~' ~

b 'UU ~ ~~1Blti d tJb1 ~b (,'j'Jdtl 1nJ d'H1 ',;11 'll d Wl 'Y\\i] 'U"u tl1 t1 b I?]b 0/1 Bl ~ n:\;1nmn'li 'V~ l 'VIm ~ "U8\'J1 1 uuu tJ'IIl b ~ U

, 9J

<;('1 ~:1 I~q~ 4;:1' <\ ~ I~ Q~ , ~ cii ~ V I ~ ! ~ e' I

I. 'U"u~% ~~I'U d ~9\l b dIA'J~ wf;jm~ '\HI, 'f1&;fI')'J'UD'Um 'Uti u m 'UU fl1'j w71'H£1 fl'iJ 'J d:W eJfJ 'H IN 'Vrlb \,'Wt'lbb 'VI'l

")jIm <tiI'1BU AU ~~~b~fJ 'dflO/U fltL ~bi1~ B1~~ 'I ;sti~tJlfl~ lY'l11J'UCJ~l,'l~mJ b fl0/191 f) msu ~'l'G1'J'J~~"u

~

'1 ' , q 0/ .,. ~ .,. ~ v v v v ~''1 '''' .: q ,<J ",1 0 6] v '" 4

6 ~b l11b 'I'1mJfl "u 'B'J g1 b ~lb Iil 'Ill b Iil u tJ ~'UCJ'B 1 ~ U d 'I b ~J 'Ud 'U d j,1J :w lrtllLJeJ tll'l'l'1b 'Um 'VI 0/1'1'11 6 vi b fl 0/1 A'J 1~'U U

,I v d\ '" , ,9J v f/", v 'V 9 \ , q v v

'U'J'U'l U ~d~'Ulfl~ rru 'U"u fl'JIdJ9'H'J1m Gl'll'U1 dJ'Y'let'l9b 'Y'l11~'Yld'Y'llJIilU 'Ol1'11'1d'Jl 'VI1~Jb l11b 'YltJdlfl 'Wbbtl'J

~ I q v

11 'Ub 'Vl1b 'VImJ fl 'U

El ~~{i ~ 6 ~ G1 £J~ 'l ~ 6 ~ 'U \9ld£] flv'U6 ~t11 ~ ~ 1,1j'U1J f1 'U 'U B 1 'U 1"1 iln fl'a El q "J Cl ~1J 'U 1J~'W 11 1 u ~~ 'VI Dfl ~ ~

____ ---S __ . . .. .

o ,I d <'l. <OJ €I <OJ OJ.'f <OJ

Ell'U 1 OJ u flfl 'de ~ 'U eJ ~ fl.[l1~ :WltJ 'a~'UeJ'Ub(:J\91 'OJ f11'n~ mtlm f11'J~ 'DJ 61,1j tJ'UEl ~'.l 11:1.[l'.l b'UL 1:1'd m Yi6b ~ ~r1 fHlf'l'.l

'UEl ~ 'U 1'11'1 ~ ~ '1 \91 flU ~ JJ1Ub ~'U a ~11 ~ 1,1j Ql flU ~ Ell"1ll fl ~ flfl'J eJ~1 \91 tlfl'd lJJ~ 1~ tl eJJJ 'UEl ~Vl 'U b El ~l ~ ~ 'l I9l

, 'U , 'II

'" ,I r <OJ "" €I "" "-' 0 v <{ ~ v

L(:JI9l'Oj rrnu fl fl'JB ~ 1'1 U tl 8~J b'l D 16 1,1j tJ fl'd 1 ~JL ~ JJB.fllfl'VIl ~ "1 ~ b 'OJbb 'G1 ~il '.l '.J ~~1J 11'1 eJ 'U i!l11"1 '0 1 tl ~ tJ 'd\9l 1J ~ 9gj~ El'~

~ w ~

· ~"", ~"" "" 6') " .J f5' oJ v a5 ~

mnuen i 1'L~'1l"U a ~ 'a 1 ~ flJeJ 31, Gl ~~ ~ \'l"U El ~ 'OJ fl 1.'Oj ~l"1flGl 'YI~"U e ~~ 'jbIJ!,!, Gl ~~J1.H'I~ 1'1 e ~ fl1'j 'YI '1 t11~B£J1~

~ b\'~'oj~mq~l'U~~~~11J'VI1~ 1m.Jfl su 'VIGl~bbb1~1"1'J1JJ~ 1flvLjJt1v~.wu ~~ €lfl"-'U'l ~b 'VI ~1~t1~ fI'J'1~n ~ b 'OJ m fI"'lUl,fl u1 ~fl1Jci ~~mfJU elfl ~ 'lEl;b11 \'Ib~\5l11 mLJ~'l~ ~"UeJ'l~~lt\U~U Yilt, ~~wtl. '1;UI,I, ~'j1 ~ eJ£1Yil

~

'U el~ l,;'tJ 'JflU el19 flGl'111 ~~ 1'}1 rLJ fi'j ill "U a'l, "a ~~9J El ~~ 1 ~ flltJ" 'VI; ell"l'J1lJ 'l'l~'J 'l1:J8 r1tJt1.f1'-1 'W11~ flltJ

,,~"" .". "l" c;;J ~ 0 "-' "-' OJ '" n I c;;J n I ~ f5' I .".

j;H rl"U eJ \j '"l91 b~9 >-----::_b LJ::_'W:::.:I,:..::'J.:B~~iil::.l~1"1:;::,QJiL::a~1J~!,I,"-'y.J_o,-"d_,_~-,,-1J-,,-,'j ~~fic:..:El~LJ:.:b':::'U":':'U-"i-9.:..:..:I'l~lltJ1J ~1LJ'YI1 ~ "U Cl ~ b ';j f:l~ ~~ 'l:l tJ b"l 'J 'U 'bH

t~ 'Vl~'VI~I'l'"l~b~u~'j2:51\'J"U~ 'VI;a1~'W~Ub'll'lb!'~~1~~'J'U~ ~bt1;l-l1ij\'91'V1m£J'V11~~'VI;a1~ rtl '5'J'j~ '!.\ qJ ~

~ ~ .. 'lJ

... '" Q_J.- Q_J "i OJ .J<~ a 0 "-' I V <~ J, V 6')

'1HHUD1'1'JU "l'iH.I bo/luElllllJdJlv) d @1'U'U d ~'V1'1l f1l'VIU 1'l'J 1~Gn71LJfI eu 'VI fH b 'WCJ~~ fleJ~'VI~ fl1ln~ ~ 'U

J .. 'lJ

db

"" :'1 I V 0 I ~

LJJeH 'VllbJJbbSl'J'Ojl'U'J'lH'lUb'VlSll'U

~ 'U 'U)