Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Victoria Dry Eye Etiology & Diagnosis 2015 (Abbrev) FINAL
Victoria Dry Eye Etiology & Diagnosis 2015 (Abbrev) FINAL
Victoria Dry Eye Etiology & Diagnosis 2015 (Abbrev) FINAL
7/23/2015
Proverb (Addendum)
A
Lecture Outline
WHAT IS DRY EYE?
ETIOLOGIC CLASSIFICATION
Aqueous deficient
Evaporative
CONTRIBUTIONS
Intrinsic/systemic
Extrinsic/ environmental
DELICATE BALANCE OF HEALTHY TEARS
Mucus, aqueous & lipid
7/23/2015
7/23/2015
Doctor
7/23/2015
The dry eye corner was a very lonely place for a long time
UNTIL
7/23/2015
7/23/2015
7/23/2015
Healthy Tears:
7/23/2015
7/23/2015
Intrinsic, e.g.
Extrinsic, e.g.
--increasing age
--topical meds
--hormone balance
--environmental stress
--systemic drugs
--refractive surgery
10
7/23/2015
6% on cyclosporine therapy
PROOF study
11
7/23/2015
Etiologic Classification of
Dry Eye
Aqueous Deficient
Evaporative
12
7/23/2015
Etiologic Classification of
Dry Eye
Aqueous Deficient
Sjogrens Syndrome
Primary
Secondary
Non-Sjogrens
Lacrimal
Reflex
gland deficit
Systemic
drugs
Etiologic Classification of
Dry Eye
Aqueous Deficient
Sjogrens
Syndrome
Primary
Secondary
SJO
testing
Finds
up to 30% of DED
patients may have
systemic disease
13
7/23/2015
SJO TESTING
New
Diagnostic!
Myths of Sjgrens
Sjgrens Syndrome does not have serious longterm consequences, it is just a nuisance
14
7/23/2015
Convergence of Facts
Impact of Sjgrens1
1. http://www.sjogrens.org/home/about-sjogrens-syndrome/symptoms.
15
7/23/2015
Sj Diagnostic Testing
16
7/23/2015
Sj Diagnostic Testing
Traditional testing
Sj Diagnostic Testing
New early detection testing
17
7/23/2015
Sj Diagnostic Test
Testing becoming
widely available by
local major
laboratories
Now covered by
insurance In many
cases
Turning to the
Most Common
Form of Dry Eye
18
7/23/2015
Etiologic Classification of
Dry Eye
Evaporative
19
7/23/2015
Etiologic Classification of
Dry Eye
Evaporativeexcessive water evaporation in
presence of normal aqueous production
blepharitis)
Most
common form
20
7/23/2015
Results:
TBUT
Fluorescein
MG
21
7/23/2015
Etiologic Classification of
Dry Eye
Evaporativeexcessive water evaporation in presence of normal aqueous production
common form
Consider
Recurrent
Disorders
Low
chalazia
of lid aperture
Drug
Etiologic Classification of
Dry Eye
Evaporative (cont)
oil deficiency
Wide
lid aperture
Conjunctivochalasis
Aging/
Systemic
drugs
22
7/23/2015
Etiologic Classification of
Dry Eye
Evaporative (cont)
Conjunctivochalasis:
Etiologic Classification of
Dry Eye
Evaporative (cont)
Conjunctivochalasis:
Repair surgically
23
7/23/2015
Etiologic Classification of
Dry Eye
Evaporative (cont)
Intrinsic conditions
Aging
Conjunctivochalasis
Low
androgen pool
Systemic
Etiologic Classification of
Dry Eye
Evaporative (cont)
A deficiency
Reduced
24
7/23/2015
Etiologic Classification of
Dry Eye
Evaporative (cont)
Extrinsic (cont)
Contact
(62%
lens wear
Etiologic Classification of
Dry Eye
Evaporative (cont)
Extrinsic (cont)
Ocular
e.g.
Topical
preservatives;
BAK
drugs
25
7/23/2015
Etiologic Classification of
Dry Eye
Evaporative (cont)
Glaucoma Drugs
Etiologic Classification of
Dry Eye
Evaporative (cont)
relative humidity
High
wind velocity
Occupational
Prolonged
environment
computer use
26
7/23/2015
Etiologic Classification of
Dry Eye
Evaporative (cont)
Occupational
Prolonged
environment
27
7/23/2015
by
meibomian glands
Transillumination of
meibomian glands
28
7/23/2015
Aqueous component a
complex mixture of
proteins, mucins,
electrolytes
Secreted
by main &
accessory lacrimal
glands
Similar
architecture for
main and
accessory glands
Androgens
important for
glandular
homeostasis
(Sullivan et al, 1998)
29
7/23/2015
viscosity &
stability during blink
cycle (gel-like)
Gel decreases in
density toward tear
film surface
Soluble mucins - essential for viscosity of the normal tear film--Helps resist
thin spots and tear break-up
30
7/23/2015
Healthy Tears
Antimicrobial proteins:
Lysozyme, lactoferrin
Lesser concentrations of
many proteins in CDE
Activated proteases
Increased electrolytes/
hyperosmolar
Image from Dry Eye and Ocular Surface Disorders, 2004
31
7/23/2015
1. Schaumberg et al. Am J Ophthalmol. 2003; 2. Schaumberg et al. JAMA. 2001; 3. Lemp. CLAO J. 1995.
Diagnosis of DES
32
7/23/2015
Diagnosis
Diagnosis:
Questionnaires
33
7/23/2015
Diagnosis
Osaka study (2015)
672 Japanese office VDT users
Diagnosis
Example symptom questionnaire:
OSDI for inflammatory dry eye
34
7/23/2015
Diagnosis
Example symptom questionnaire:
SPEED test
--for evaporative tear film insufficiency
Diagnosis
91 subject study of mild to moderate dry eye,
correlating symptoms and common tests
Aqueous deficiency tests (Phenol red thread, tear film
break up time, slit lamp evaluation and impression
cytology of goblet cells): no correlation with Dry Eye
Questionnaire (McMonnies)
Only lipid/ mucous deficiency tests correlated with
symptoms (MG pathology, reduced goblet cell
density and TBUT correlated with Dry eye
questionnaire)
Moore, Graham, Goodall et al BJO 2009:93:66-72
35
7/23/2015
Diagnosis Questionnaires
caveat
Recent
Using
36
7/23/2015
Fluorescein staining
Conjunctival
cases
Corneal
cases
staining in milder
Fluorescein staining
Deep
Evaluate
37
7/23/2015
Fluorescein staining
Look
Fluorescein
distribute
Do
Patient
blinking
38
7/23/2015
Dilution/
Disappearance
Measures
decrease of
fluorescence by production
of new tears
Drop
fluorescein instilled
and fluorescence measured
over time with stop watch or
photometer
Confounded
occlusion
by punctal
<10
seconds abnormal
39
7/23/2015
is more comfortable
40
7/23/2015
Otto Schirmer
Unanesthetized
Should
not be <10 mm
Secretion Test
Instill
41
7/23/2015
used
topical anesthetic
Rub
Measure
Wetting
Less invasive
9-20mm normal
42
7/23/2015
lysozyme
Tear lactoferrin
Impression cytology
(conjunctival)
Tear film osmolality
43
7/23/2015
MMP-9
MGD Analysis
Physical
inspection
Transillumination
Blink
Analysis--videography
Meibomography
MG
Tear
MMP-9
MGD Analysis
Physical
inspection
Transillumination
Blink
Analysis--videography
Meibomography
MG
Tear
44
7/23/2015
Film Osmolarity
Relatively
Tear
Lab
DEWSDefinitionofDryEyeDisease
Dryeyeisamultifactorialdiseaseofthetearsandocular
surfaceItisaccompaniedbyincreasedosmolarity ofthe
tearfilmandinflammationoftheocularsurface.
Testingforosmolarityisagood
placetostart
Note: the definition was updated 2 years prior to TearLab approval and
based on 40+ years of research using tear osmometers requiring 500 to 1000
times the volume now needed (50 nanoliter sample)
InternationalDryEyeWorkshop(DEWS).Thedefinition&classificationofdryeyedisease.Ocul Surf2007.
45
7/23/2015
TwoNumbersCrucialtoUnderstand
Osmolarity
TheMAXIMUMofthetwoeyes:
TheDIFFERENCEb/wtwoeyes:
Tearshigherthan300mOsm/L
demonstratelossofhomeostasisand
likelybecomepathogenic>308.
Thisshowsthestabilityofthetear
film.Normaltearsarestableand
<300mOsm/Lbilaterally.A
differenceof>8mOsm/L isa
hallmarkoftearinstability.
NonDEDPatientsareLowandStable DEDPatients
areElevatedandUnstable
KeechA,etal.CurrEyeRes2013Apr;38(4)42836
46
7/23/2015
LuoL,Cornea.2007May;26(4):45260.
Hyperosmolarity Upregulates
EMMPRIN/MMP9
47
7/23/2015
Hyperosmolarity Upregulates
inflammatorycytokines
e.g.interleukins,metalloproteinases
cycleofinflammationwithapoptosis,
Tcellinfiltration
symptomsofdryness,irritation
HuetEetal.AmJPathol.2011;179.
WhyMeasureTear
Osmolarity?
Measuringosmolarityallowsusto
evaluateanactualphysiologicmarker
ratherthanasignofthediseasesuch
asstainingortearbreakuptime.
LikeBPorserumglucose!
48
7/23/2015
Abstract Title: Measuring Tear Film Osmolarity in Dry Eye Disease: A Review of
the Literature
Christopher J. Rapuano , Rick Potvin (ASCRS 2015 Poster)
TearOsmolarity:variousstudies
49
7/23/2015
Results
Fluorescein staining and symptoms modest correlation
No correlation between change in OSM and symptoms
TearOsmolarity:variousstudies
RecentNHS(UK)study:
596patients
Osmhighestpositivepredictivevalue ofdry
eyediseasecomparedwithotherroutinediagnostic
tests(noSchirmerstesting)
%DEDbyOsm72.3%,ingoodagreementwith
DEWSscores(78%)
WongK,DinN,AnsariE,etal.TearosmolarityprevalenceingeneralNHSophthalmicclinicsandrelationtoclinical
examinationofdryeye.Posterpresentedat:XXXIICongressoftheESCRS,London,UK,Sept1317,2014
50
7/23/2015
Besidesthescience,whyMeasure
TearOsmolarity?
Patientsmaynotthinktheyhavedryeye
(e.g.downregulatednerves).
Osm =Objectivenumber
ThistestshowsthattheOsm ofyourtearfilm
isXXpointsabovenormalwhichindicatesyou
havedryeyeendofdiscussion
Patientsbecomeawareofthisnumberas
somethingtheywanttoworktolower,justlike
bloodpressureorcholesterollevels
Encouragescompliance
M.McDonald,MD
Confounding variables of
tear film osmolarity
Environmental conditions
Blepharitis average Osm approaches 305 cut off ---304 mOsm/L JAMA Ophthalmol 2015 Mar 26
51
7/23/2015
TearOsmolarityCanBeUsedToFollow
TheResponseToTreatment
DEDCanAffect
Surgical
Outcomes
52
7/23/2015
HyperosmolarityCanDecreaseVisual
Acuityand/orQualityofVision
includingpostoperatively
DEDfrequentcauseoffailureof
premiumlenses
53
7/23/2015
MMP-9
MGD Analysis
Physical
inspection
Transillumination
Blink
Analysis--videography
Meibomography
MG
Tear
O.C.T.
54
7/23/2015
MMP-9
MGD Analysis
Physical
inspection
Transillumination
Blink
Analysis--videography
Meibomography
MG
Tear
55
7/23/2015
[1] Chotikavanich S, de Paiva CS, Li de Q, et al. Production and activity of matrix metalloproteinase-9 on the ocular surface increase in dysfunctional tear
syndrome. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci. 2009 Jul;50(7):3203-9.
56
7/23/2015
Reflects
signs
57
7/23/2015
58
7/23/2015
InflammaDry Compared to
TearLab Osm
Osmolarity is associated
with variability1-3
MMP-9 is produced by
the entire lacrimal
system
[1] Yagci A, Gurdal C. The role and treatment of inflammation in dry eye disease. Int
Ophthalmol. 2014 Dec;34(6):1291-301. [2] Eldridge DC, Sullivan BD, Berg MD, et al.
(2010) Longitudinal variability of tear film osmolarity in normal and dry eye patients.
Investig Ophthalmol Vis Sci 51(5):33793381 [3] Fuerst N, Massaro-Giordano M, McCabe
B, et al. Variability of tear osmolarity in dry eye patients and controls. Abstract submitted for
publication (May 2014): The Association for Research in Vision and Ophthalmology. [4]
Chotiakavanich S, de Paiva CS, Li de Quan, et al. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2009; 50(7):
3203 3209
Of the 61% confirmed dry eye, InflammaDry was positive 81% of the
time
[1] Sambursky R, Davitt WF 3rd, Friedberg M, Tauber S. Prospective, multicenter, clinical evaluation of point-of-care matrix metalloproteinase-9 test for confirming dry eye
disease. Cornea. 2014 Aug;33(8):812-8.
59
7/23/2015
[1] Grdal C, Sara O, Gen, et al. Ocular surface and dry eye in Graves' disease. Curr Eye Res.2011;36:813.
Punctal Occlusion
PunctaI occlusion has been shown to improve
objective and subjective measures of dry eye to
and to exacerbate ocular surface inflammation in
subjects with overt clinical inflammation1
The Delphi treatment guidelines for ocular surface
disorders recommends that inflammatory conditions
be treated before punctal occlusion2
[1] Pflugfelder SC. Antiinflammatory therapy for dry eye. Am J Ophthalmol. 2004 Feb;137(2):337-42. [2] Behrens A, Doyle JJ, Stern L, et al. The Dysfunctional
Tear Syndrome Study Group. Dysfunctional tear syndrome: a Delphi approach to treatment recommendations. Cornea. 2006;25:900-907.
60
7/23/2015
Example: Importance of
Identifying MMP-9
Dry eye frequently leads to contact lens
intolerance
InflammaDry
Cyclosporine
Punctal occlusion
one should I
choose?
61
7/23/2015
Direct
MMP-9
MGD Analysis
Physical
inspection
Transillumination
Blink
Analysis--videography
Meibomography
MG
Tear
62
7/23/2015
Meibomian gland
analysis
63
7/23/2015
2 years to complete
1.
Lemp MA, Nichols KK. Blepharitis in the United States 2009: a survey-based perspective on prevalence
and treatment. Ocul Surf. 2009;7(2 suppl):S1-S14.
2.
Lemp MA, et al. Distribution of aqueous-deficient and evaporative dry eye in a clinic-based patient
cohort: a retrospective study. Cornea. 2012;31(5):472-478.
3.
Shimazaki J, et al. Ocular surface changes and discomfort in patients with meibomian gland
dysfunction. Arch Ophthalmol. 1995;113(10):1266-1270.
4.
Nichols KK, et al. The international workshop on meibomian gland dysfunction: executive summary.
Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci. 2011;52(4):1922-1929.
64
7/23/2015
23
Aqueous
deficient
79
MGD
14
%
50
%
57
MGD and
aqueous
deficient
36
%
Lemp MA, et al. Distribution of aqueous-deficient and evaporative dry eye in a clinic-based patient
cohort: a retrospective study. Cornea. 2012;31(5):472-478.
65
7/23/2015
Rounding
(OR 9.3)
Notching
(OR 3.9)
Posterior
Orifice
66
7/23/2015
Partial obstruction
Total obstruction
The Pendulum
has Swung!
67
7/23/2015
Meibomian Gland
Dysfunction
Disease Identification
68
7/23/2015
13
7
MMP-9
MGD Analysis
Physical
inspection
Transillumination
Blink
Analysis--videography
Meibomography
MG
Tear
69
7/23/2015
Evaluate Meibomian
Glands
Meibomian Gland
Evaluation
Normal Glands
70
7/23/2015
Ocular Rosacea
only
71
7/23/2015
Ocular Rosacea
Meibomian Gland
Evaluation
Normal glands
72
7/23/2015
Meibomian Gland
Evaluation
Meibomian Gland
Evaluation
Moderate clogging
73
7/23/2015
Meibomian Gland
Evaluation
Meibomian Gland
Evaluation
74
7/23/2015
Meibomian Gland
Evaluation
MMP-9
MGD Analysis
Physical
inspection
Transillumination
Blink
Analysis--videography
Meibomography
MG
Tear
75
7/23/2015
Meibomian Gland
Evaluation
Missing gland
Trans illumination
76
7/23/2015
Meibomian Gland
Evaluation
Meibomian Gland
Evaluation
77
7/23/2015
MMP-9
MGD Analysis
Physical
inspection
Transillumination
Blink
Analysis--videography
Meibomography
MG
Tear
Diagnosis: Lagophthalmos
--A common cause of dry eye
Lipiview instrument:
78
7/23/2015
Blink Analysis
Lipiview
Videography
Automated
result
Can
show
patients they
dont blink
properly
79
7/23/2015
MMP-9
MGD Analysis
Physical
inspection
Transillumination
Blink
Analysis--videography
Meibomography
MG
Tear
Meibomography
80
7/23/2015
Meibomography
Meiboscores
81
7/23/2015
SS
DMI
82
7/23/2015
MMP-9
MGD Analysis
Physical
inspection
Transillumination
Blink
Analysis--videography
Meibomography
MG
Tear
83
7/23/2015
MMP-9
MGD Analysis
Physical
inspection
Transillumination
Blink
Analysis--videography
Meibomography
MG
Tear
84
7/23/2015
Light source:
The Illuminator
Touch screen
control panel
Chin rest
Camera, computer
and drivers are
housed by the device
Device dimensions:
28 x 17 x 17
Measurement time:
20 seconds per eye
LipiView Interferometer
Mean 31 nm
Mean >100 nm
Finis, Geerling et al, Evaluation of Lipid Layer Thickness Measurement of the Tear Film
as a Diagnostic Tool for Meibomian Gland Dysfunction, Cornea 2013, Oct 3 E-pub
ahead of print
85
7/23/2015
LipiView Report
Results are displayed for
printout & patient education
Diagnosis: Lagophthalmos
--A common cause of dry eye
Lipiview instrument:
86
7/23/2015
87
7/23/2015
Symptoms:
Daily,
Recurrent
in eyes or:
Use
Signs
Look
Typical
Positive
Positive
88
7/23/2015
Signs
If
thickness
Incomplete
MGE:
lids
blinking analysis
Meiboscopy
89
7/23/2015
My Treatment Paradigm
In a nutshell
90
7/23/2015
TREATMENT
DES
Peter Cushing making a difference
91
7/23/2015
Prevent
potentially blinding
complications
Maintain
Inhibit
92
7/23/2015
Schirmer: variable
DEWS Workshop Report 2007; Ocular Surface Apr;5(2)
Environmental
Lid
OTC
lubricants
93
7/23/2015
OTC lubricants
A. DEAD CONTROL
B. LIVE CONTROL
D. LATANOPROST
E. HP-GUAR GELLABLE
LUBRICANT EYEDROP SOLUTION
94
7/23/2015
Alternative preservatives
Chlorbutanol
Polyquad
EDTA
PHMB
Gen
95
7/23/2015
an oxidizing preservative
Schirmer 10 mm
96
7/23/2015
steroids
Cyclosporine
Secretogogues
97
7/23/2015
Pilocarpine (Salagen)
Topical
Diquafasol (Prolacria-Phase III) (surface cell production of
mucin, fluid, lipid from MG)
Eicosanoid15-(S)-HETE (MUC1 mucus)
Ecabet sodium (goblet/ epithelial cell mucus)
Rebamipide (mucin)
98
7/23/2015
ASEDs
99
7/23/2015
Schirmer I: 2 mm
100
7/23/2015
Surgery
Lid
Summary
101
7/23/2015
Summary
Diagnostic tools
Questionnaires
Testing
Next Up
102
7/23/2015
103