Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Η Γνώση Και η Αλήθεια Στον Πλάτωνα
Η Γνώση Και η Αλήθεια Στον Πλάτωνα
Η Γνώση Και η Αλήθεια Στον Πλάτωνα
2012
3
5
I.
........5
II.
...8
III.
12
IV.
.....15
V.
.....19
......23
I.
......25
....33
I.
....34
II.
.....38
III.
..41
IV.
1.
....41
2.
.....51
3.
.54
.59
.61
.....64
.
.
; ;.
, ,
.
, ,
. , ,
. , ,
.
, (
). ,
, ,
,
.
.
. ,
, . , ,
.
(
).
,
,
,
. :
,
.
, ,
.
1
.
, ,
2
,
.
. ,
3 . , ,
.
. , '
' , .
,
4.
.
I.
(70a1-2).
.
1 . . .
2
.
.
3
: , , ,
, , , , , ..
4
The Principle of the Priority of Knowledge What (PKW): Gail Fine. Inquiry in the Meno,
Plato on Knowledge and Forms, Oxford Selected Essays, Oxford University Press, USA, 2003, . 44
. 1.
( ) (71b3-4).
5. ,
,
:
. Gail Fine
()6. Nicholas White
. , ,
7 ,
8.
,
. H Fine White
.
: ,
. Fine
:
) , -
.
. , ,
, .
:
.
.
, ,
. ,
.
. Gregory Vlastos. Socrates Disavowal of Knowledge, Plato 1. Metaphysics and
Epistemology, Gail Fine (.), Oxford University Press, 1999,. 64 -92.
6
. Gail Fine ,Inquiry in the Meno, p. 45.
7
(11a -b).
8
Nicholas White. Plato on Knowledge and Reality, Indianapolis, Hackett, 1976, . 36.
) ,
.
,
, ,
.
, , , Fine,
:
) ,
.
,
.
,
. Fine
) ) ,
, 9.
,
,
:
.
, , ,
.
White,
,
.
, .
, .
, , .
9
Fine
, . . Gail Fine. Inquiry in the Meno, . 45-47.
White
.
-
.
10.
' . White ,
,
. , ,
: )
)
. 11.
II.
,
.
, .
, ,
. ,
.
: , ,
.. 12:
10
. , ,
;
; ,
; (80d5-8)
. , , .
; ,
, ,
13 (80e1-6).
:
1.
2.
3.
, . Taylor
,
14. ,
,
. , ,
.
, '
,
.
(the Paradox of Inquiry)Nicholas White. Plato on Knowledge and Reality,
. 43.
13
. , . , , 2008.
14
C. C. W. Taylor,Platos Epistemology, The Oxford Handbook of Plato, G. Fine (.), Oxford
University Press, 2008, . 169.
Taylor ,
(specify) , ..
;
. , ,
(specification),
;. Taylor , ,
15.
. Fine ,
16:
1. , .
2. , .
3. , .
4. , ,
.
2.
, .
, Fine,
.
- ,
17.
Fine 2. 3.
.
2.,
,
.
15
10
, 2. . , , , Fine,
3.,
.
18.
() ,
I,
. Fine 3.
. 2.
, . 3.
, , 19.
, .
Taylor White
. White
. , ,
,
. ,
'
20.
White
.
.
(definition) (specification) .
18
11
' 80d
. , White,
21.
White
,
..
( , .
2-5)
. .
( , . 2-5)
( )
, .
III.
:
.
- -
(81a10-b6).
, .
-
.
21
12
,
- ,
.
. (81c5-d5)22
23,
()
. ,
.
.
,
. ,
, White Taylor,
,
24.
, Fine
. , Fine
, ,
,
25. ,
.
,
. , Fine,
. (elenctic reply)26.
. ,
22
. , . , , 2008.
, a,
. ,
.
24
. Nicholas White. Plato on Knowledge and Reality, . 47 C. C. W. Taylor. Platos
Epistemology, . 169-170.
25
. Gail Fine. Inquiry in the Meno, . 54-55.
26
. Gail Fine. Inquiry in the Meno, . 54.
23
13
,
(84d-85b).
Dominic Scott
:
1. (84a2).
2. H ,
, (84d3 -85b7).
3. .
,
(98a 4). Scott
27.
. , ,
. To
: . ,
Fine,
. ,
, ,
. ,
,
, 28.
, White
, ,
. , ,
, 29. ,
. White Fine
2.
27
Dominic Scott, Platonic Recollection, Plato 1, Metaphysics and Epistemology, ed. by Gail Fine,
University Press, 1999, . 99.
28
. Gail Fine. Inquiry in the Meno, . 55-56.
29
. Nicholas White. Plato on Knowledge and Reality, . 47.
14
V.
,
.
,
(85c2-8). ,
. Fine
,
.
.
.
, ,
, . White, ,
,
,
30. Taylor Fine31.
Taylor, ,
(inferential knowledge) (serial reminding).
-
, ,
(81d).
.
32.
.
. ,
,
30
15
33. Taylor
.
. , ,
Taylor , ,
.
,
, . ' ,
, 34.
Scott
.
(81d4-5) ,
,
.
85e2-3
.
. 35
,
36 . , ,
,
Fine
- .
, Fine
(81c6-7)
(81c8)
33
16
37.
.
(
) (,
). White, o ,
. White
38. '
,
,
.
39.
Fine White ,
,
. , Fine,
,
.
Fine
.40.
White
Fine , ,
41. Taylor,
(86a6-9) .
,
42.
37
17
,
. White,
,
. , Fine
.
, (97a-98c) o
.
.
,
( (98a)) Fine
(explanatory account)
43
44 .
,
Fine, 45.
,
.
, Taylor ,
,
. ,
, . ,
.
. ,
. Taylor , (perceptual
43
18
knowledge), .
,
.
.
,
,
, Taylor 46.
,
.
Fine
.
,
.
.
47.
White, ,
(feeling)
48.
.
White, , .
IV.
White,
,
. .
.
.
46
19
White
49 . White
:
,
, White
(feeling)
. ,
. ,
,
.
.50.
,
, White ,
. ,
.
,
, .
,
, White,
51.
, Fine
, , 3. .
'
,
49
20
52.
Fine,
,
.
53 .
, Fine ,
,
.
,
, ,
(99c). ,
, ,
(98b 1-5)
Fine54.
Taylor, White,
, .
,
, . ,
55.
,
,
.
, ,
,
56. ,
52
21
. , ,
,
,
, .
22
,
,
, .
.
57.
, . ,
,
,
58 .
(331d1).
, ,
, ,
,
.
471c3 .
.
(471c4) .
,
,
.
8 9
57
,
.
58
.
23
.
.
,
.
,
,
' .
24
I.
(473ce).
, ,
.
, .
,
, (476d-480a).
. Fine
(75d)
,
. Fine () (dialectic requirement DR)
,
59.
(477a -480a5) :
, , ,
, ,
; (477a1 -4).
,
; (477a6-9)
, ,
: , ,
, ,
, ; (477a10-b1) .
59
Gail Fine. Knowledge and Belief in Republic V-VII, in S. Everson, ed., Companions to Ancient
Thought 1: Epistemology, Cambridge , 1990, . 87.
25
()
. .
:
, . ( )
(477b7-10).
.
.
,
(477c9-d5).
.
.
. , ,
, ( 477d7 -478b6).
, .
, .
. . , ,
( 478d2).
,
.
.
,
(478e1-4).
. , ,
,
(479b1-2).
,
, .
.
26
(479d7-9). ,
,
(479e1-5).
, ,
, .
.
(479e6 -7).
(480a).
60 .
:
1. ( ) ( 477b9 -10).
2. (478d2).
, . Taylor Fine 61:
1.() , 62.
() (.. ).
() .
:
2.() .
() -.
() .
Tailor Fine
63. () ()
60
27
() ,
64. Fine
() ()
(). Fine,
. ,
65.
Fine 1.()
.
(98a)
. 2.(), , .
. Fine
.
.
. Fine.
2.()
. Fine
()
.
66.
477b 478b
67
.
63
Taylor ,
Fine Knowledge and Belief in Republic V. ,
Fine ,
. . C. C. W. Taylor. Platos Epistemology, . 176.
64
. C. C. W. Taylor. Platos Epistemology, . 177 Gail Fine. Knowledge and Belief in
Republic V-VII, . 88.
65
. Gail Fine. Knowledge and Belief in Republic V-VII, . 87-88.
66
. Gail Fine. Knowledge and Belief in Republic V-VII, . 89-90.
67
. ..
.
(477 c1-4).
28
(477c6 d5). Fine,
. , .
Fine . ,
.
( () ()), Fine,
(. 3) . , ,
( ()
) 68.
(, 477e6-7). Fine
. , ,
.
()
,
.
.
69.
, 478a12-b2
. Fine,
,
70.
, (479a) , ,
:
68
29
3.
.
Fine,
,
. , ()
,
, ,
, ...
. Fine
. ,
. ' , o
( )
(479a4)71.
479d3480a5
72. :
4. , (479d 3-5).
5. , , (479 e15).
6. .
7. .
8. .
9.
.
10.
.
Fine .
4.
.
71
30
, , .
(98a) 73., Fine,
, ' ,
74. ,
,
75. Fine
. ,
76.
6. , Fine,
. 7.
. 8.
. 9.
. 10.
,
. Fine ,
77.
Fine
, ,
, 78.
,
.
,
,
73
(76b) (531e, 534b).
74
,
.
75
(71b).
76
. Gail Fine. Knowledge and Belief in Republic V-VII, . 92 -93.
77
. Gail Fine. Knowledge and Belief in Republic V-VII, . 93 -94.
78
. Gail Fine. Knowledge and Belief in Republic V-VII, . 95.
31
.
: )
, )
.
,
, ,
. ,
,
.
,
.
.
,
.
32
. ,
,
, , . , ,
,
.
. White
. '
.
,
.
-
.
79.
,
. ,
.
,
(146c-d).
.
.
(148c).
.
79
33
,
80 .
186a12 ,
, 187a1
81.
.
.
( (98a)). , ,
,
.
I.
(151a).
,
, (152 a 2-4).
,
. .
, ,
(157b).
.
.
80
81
34
.
(160 c).
'
. ,
:
1. .
2. .
.
3.
, .
.
4.
.
. , ,
.
(170 c). ,
.
,
.
, ,
(170a3-4),
.
.
. , ,
35
82.
,
, . ,
' , ,
.
.
, , .
, ,
,
..
(181d ).
.
,
,
. ,
.
.
, , .
(182a1 -183c3).
, ,
.
82
(176a -177a).
,
.
36
.
(184c d). ,
, ,
83, (185be).
, , :
,
.
, , .
,
,
, .
.
. , ,
(186c-d).
.
,
.
.
.
83
( , , ,
) .
37
II.
(187d), , .
,
.
:
.
.
(188b).
:
. (188c1-5).
,
. , ,
(188c6 d1).
:
.
,
.
. ,
. ,
(188d2- 189b2).
:
, ..
.
. , ,
. ,
,
(190b-190d5).
38
'
.
: , ,
.
, .
.
.
.
,
.
(195c-d).
, ,
.
.. .
,
, (195 e).
.
,
. ,
,
(196c-d).
, ,
.
. , ,
.
(197 b-d).
,
39
. .
.
.
.
.
,
() (198 a-b).
.
,
.
:
' .
(199c).
.
.
, ,
,
.
(200a-d). .
40
III.
1.
. ,
,
,
(200e 4-6).
. ,
.
, ,
.
.
(201 b-c)84.
White
: )
)
.
, White
85. ,
200d5-210d4, ,
,
.
,
, .
(201c9-d1) , ,
. Fine White
.
84
,
, .
85
. Nicholas White. Plato on Knowledge and Reality, . 176.
41
( ),
( ). White,
,
. , ,
86 . , Fine, White
(misleading)87.
,
,
.
. ,
88. ,
.
,
. , Fine,
,
. , ,
.
.
89.
(201d5), .
:
86
42
.: .
,
, .
, , , ,
. ,
,
.
, ,
.
,
. ,
, , .
. , ,
. , ,
, ,
. . ,
, , .
.
,
, .
, .
, ,
(201d8-202c4).
,
, . Bostock
.
43
90. Burnyeat , ,
. , , 91.
:
1.
2.
92.
.
.
. .
(statementsentence). Fine
, ()
,
, ,
93.
Bostock ,
,
.
,
.
, . , ,
, 94.
-, Bostock Fine
Ryle . Fine
Ryle
-:
90
44
1.
,
.
2.
, .
(202b6-7).
,
.
, . ,
.
3.
, ()
, (261d4).
. , ,
95.
Bostock
, Ryle,
-
.
. ,
. ,
96.
Fine -
, , ,
. . ,
. Fine, ,
, , ,
,
. , ,
95
96
45
,
,
97 .
Bostock Fine White
. Bostock
,
, . , ,
98 .
, Bostock,
,
. , White, Bostock
Fine :
1.
. , , , ,
99.
2.
,
(206e6-207a1).
.
.
(201b6-8). Bostock,
, .
(203a-b).
97
.
Bostoc, , ,
. . David Bostock. Platos Theaetetus, . 205.
98
. David Bostock. Platos Theaetetus, . 205-206.
99
. David Bostock. Platos Theaetetus, . 206 Nicholas White. Plato on Knowledge and Reality,
. 177-178.
46
100.
3.
202b8-5
.
.
(206d-e)101.
, ,
. White
(206e-207a). White
,
102.
Bostock Fine
, ,
. Fine
(account) 103 .
Bostock
, ,
104 .
.
Fine,
,
.
100
. David Bostock. Platos Theaetetus, . 207 Nicholas White. Plato on Knowledge and
Reality, . 177-178.
101
. Gail Fine. Knowledge and Logos in the Theaetetus, . 231 David Bostock. Platos
Theaetetus, . 206-207.
102
. Nicholas White. Plato on Knowledge and Reality, . 177.
103
(. 17). . Gail Fine.
Knowledge and Logos in the Theaetetus, . 231.
104
. David Bostock. Platos Theaetetus, . 208.
47
. ,
,
. Fine
. ,
, .
105.
,
, ,
106.
.
. ,
Fine
Bostock
107 . Fine
,
108.
Fine, ,
,
(206d-e). , ,
. ,
,
(206e6-207a1). Fine,
,
105
48
109 .
Bostock ,
.
110.
Fine, '
. .
-
,
, .
-, , Fine,
.
.
. ,
111.
Fine , ,
Russell Descartes, ,
. Russell
. Descartes
.
,
,
.
Descartes, , Russell,
109
49
.
, , .
.
, Russell Descartes
112.
Fine
.
. , ,
. Bostock
113. ,
, ,
(
) . , ,
, .
Fine Bostock ,
114.
.
,
115.
. , ,
,
.
. ,
()
112
50
116. ,
-.
.
:
Fine Bostock .
Bostock
account Fine. ,
, White,
. , Bostock
, ( 22),
. , ,
,
, .
2.
. , ,
, :
,
, (202d 10-e1). White
200d5-210d4
. ,
,
.
116
51
52
(205a1-7)
(205a8-9)
.
Bostock
.
.
,
. ,
120.
(206a-b)
. Bostock
.
.
: )
)
, ,
. ..
.
, Bostoc,
121.
Bostock , , . ,
: )
.
. ,
.
120
121
53
,
(206e-208b). ) ,
,
. Bostock. )
122.
Fine , ,
, ,
123 . Bostock, ,
.
.
,
124.
,
. ,
, ,
. ,
) )
.
White125.
3.
,
,
.
.
,
122
, Bostock, Fine,
. . David Bostock. Platos Theaetetus, .220.
123
Gail Fine. Knowledge and Logos in the Theaetetus, . 226.
124
. David Bostock. Platos Theaetetus, .220.
125
. . Nicholas White. Plato on Knowledge and
Reality, . 176.
54
(206d1-5). , , ,
.
. 126.
: ,
(206e6-207a1).
.
.
Fine
127. White,
,
.
. ,
128. Fine ,
,
(constituents)
129. Bostock
White Fine
130 .
. Fine
(interrelation model of knowledge)131. White
,
126
, .
127
. Gail Fine. Knowledge and Logos in the Theaetetus, . 243.
128
. Nicholas White. Plato on Knowledge and Reality, . 178-179.
129
. Gail Fine. Knowledge and Logos in the Theaetetus, . 243.
130
. David Bostock. Platos Theaetetus, . 223.
131
. Gail Fine. Knowledge and Logos in the Theaetetus, . 244.
55
132.
, .
(208c7-8).
.
.
133. White
. , ,
, ,
'
134 . Bostock
.
. 135.
. ,
. ,
(209d4e4). White
209a1-c9 136 . Fine Bostock
:
(209d5), White
132
White
. . Nicholas White. Plato on
Knowledge and Reality, . 178-179.
133
. Nicholas White. Plato on Knowledge and Reality, . 180.
134
. Nicholas White. Plato on Knowledge and Reality, . 180.
135
. David Bostock. Platos Theaetetus, . 223.
136
. Nicholas White. Plato on Knowledge and Reality, . 180.
56
(209e6-210a9)137. Fine,
.
138.
:
) , ,
.
(209b8).
)
, .
' , .
) 209c4-9 o :
,
.
.
, Fine,
. Fine
. .
.
, ,
139 . Bostock
Fine
, ,
,
. , ,
140.
137
. Gail Fine. Knowledge and Logos in the Theaetetus, . 244 David Bostock. Platos
Theaetetus, . 236.
138
. Gail Fine. Knowledge and Logos in the Theaetetus, . 244.
139
. Gail Fine. Knowledge and Logos in the Theaetetus, . 246-47.
140
. David Bostock. Platos Theaetetus, . 231 -232.
57
,
,
,
, .
White .
.
.
, .
.
.141.
Fine, ,
,
.
,
(209d3-e4)142.
-
.
Fine,
.
. Fine
(interrelation model of knowledge, 30)
:
.
141
142
58
( 31)
. ,
.
Fine
.
143. Bostock
(209e6-210a9) ,
Fine
savoir connatre (. 23).
144.
Bostock Fine
,
, .
, , ( )
. , . 145 .
, Bostock
.
, ,
146.
IV.
, ( 210a9-b2).
143
59
. White ,
.
, ( )
. ,
.
147.
,
. White
. ,
.
,
, .
. ,
.
. ,
, .. .
,
.
147
60
.
.
, ,
,
, .
.
,
.
.
. Fine
, .
,
.
,
. .
)
) . ,
.
.
.
, .
,
.
61
.
.
,
.
.
.
,
,
.
.
,
. .
.
,
, .
.
.
, ,
.
,
,
. ,
.
62
63
I.
II.
, . . . , ,
, 1980.
64
. , . . , . , . ,
.
. , . , . , 2008.
. , . .. , . , 2003.
. , . . , . , . , .
. , . , . ,
2004.
65