Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Leadership Management and Co-Ordination
Leadership Management and Co-Ordination
Leadership Management and Co-Ordination
Title:
2. Content Page:
Front Page . 1
Abstract 3
Introduction 3 - 5
Analysis (using Warwick 6 Cs Framework) .......................... 5- 15
Leadership style
15
Appendix 21
3.0. Abstract
This report is about how the authors manager while on placement handled a
transition of taking over a home from another organisation. The organisation
that the author went to is based in South Wales although its headquarters are
in England. The names of organisations and names of people involved have
been withheld due the Data Protection Act 1998(Government UK (2015).
4.0. Introduction
4.1.1 This report is going to be about how a manager in a third sector based
in South Wales managed change situation that the student observed while
she was on a six-week placement. Managing change refers to a form of
management control which involves applying systematic management
interventions that require individuals to get involved in order to acquire desired
outcomes that are compliant with the strategy of the organisation (Hall, 2013).
This organisation had just taken over a home which another organisation had
lost in a contract because of not complying to requirement of Care Council
Wales. (The organisation where the student went for placement will be called
D and the one that lost the contract will be called R in this report). Change
goes on to continuously influence the management landscape as all
organisations respond to external and internal forces to offer what is expected
of them from the stakeholder. It can also be said
4.1.2 The organisation where the student went for placement offers services
that are evidence research-based, outcomes-focussed to people with a range
of learning disabilities and autism (D, 2016) (see appendix). They provide
supported living and outreach services in South Wales. Learning disability
4.1.3. In order to acquire the information used in this report the author referred
to the University website, clicked at Find it, then Article search then typed in
the key words such as leadership, learning disability, communication then
clicked at search. Several journals appeared on the screen but the author
limited them by selecting only peer reviewed journal articles that were less
than five years old. The author also got information from recent government
websites, books were used in collecting information.
Nevertheless, old
sources were also used when the author found them still relevant.
4.1.4. In this report the student will evaluate how the manager managed the
situation, meetings that were held, challenges that were met by staff from
organization R and the manager who led the change. Armstrong (2012), is of
the view that a manager is person who organises their junior employees time
within their work place to get the objectives of the organisation. While Gopee
and Galloway (2013) propose that a manager is someone employed
particularly to ensure that objectives of their organisation are successfully
reached. Leadership and management styles that the manager applied will be
discussed in details.
4.1.5. Although there are several leadership frame works such as Dunham
and Pierce's (1990) Leadership Process Model I am going to use Warwick
six c leadership framework as it is more applicable to this report (Hartley and
Benington, 2010 and Mind Tool, 2016). It is a framework that offers lens which
can be used to analyse the leadership literature and general review of main
elements that affect leadership process and after-effect. The framework is
able to categorise certain features of leadership together so that more light
can be shaded on acquiring an understanding of results that are theoretically
appealing and are useful in practical way. The six cs of the framework are
concepts, contexts, challenges, capabilities and consequences (Hartley and
Benington, 2010).
4.2 Analysis
Concepts
4.2.1. The Warwick leadership framework refers to conceptual approaches of
leaders that are about individual qualities of a leader, the position a leader
plays in an organisation and leadership as a social process (Hartley and
Benington, 2010). Some of the qualities of a leader that are referred to as
conceptual skills are vision, being able to motivate, being able to make
decisions, creative, being committed, determined and persistence, wisdom,
critical thinking and having a desire to lead (Ricketts and Ricketts, 2010).
Although there many definitions of leadership the author is will use the
definition of Goodwin, (2006) as it suits more into this assignment, which
states that leadership is a powerful process of going after a vision of change
where a leader has support from two major groups. The manager who was
leader in the situation, has been in the position for over 25 years. She was
able to motivate, make decisions, creative as she came up with some new
4.2.2. Hartley and Allison, (2000) also had an idea that leadership has three
perspectives which are person, position and process. Here leadership is not
seen on basis of a persons characteristics but what takes place between
leaders and the ones they influence. The three approaches that Hartley and
Allison, (2000) came up with about leadership are going to be detailed here.
In conceptual approach of qualities, a leader has been explained in terms of
an individuals characteristic and the way he or she behaves.
4.2.3.
the way they behave and their attitudes. It is about a persons qualities
or characteristics, skills one learns, abilities and about standards of
person effectiveness (Hartley and Benington, 2010). In the situation
described the manager had qualities and skills she had learnt and was
able to comply with the standards required as mentioned in the
previous paragraph.
4.2.4.
4. 3. Characteristics
4.3.1. Leadership characteristic are classified into formal, informal, direct,
indirect, clinical, non-clinical, individual and shared various bases of power.
The focus of characteristics is on power and resources. The characteristics of
a leader are influenced by the organisation or external networks, support
given
to
them
increase
or
decrease
their
leadership.
Leadership
characteristics are never the same, they just depend on ones roles. It is
necessary for the development of leadership activities to be organised
towards and resources of leaders. Before developing a person, it is necessary
to think about which person to developed, the potential part they can play for
the work place. Leaders are various sources and processes of influence, so it
is essential for the development to be done in suitable way (Hartley and
Benington, 2010).
4.3.2. Trait theory tries to list all remarkable characteristics leadership should
consist of, in order to be effective. This theory also tries to pinpoint some
characteristics that are linked to leadership effectiveness and associate those
traits to some effective criteria. According to the traits theory, some leaders
are born with traits of leadership. The traits that are linked to trait theory are
intelligence, personality, communication skills, physical and being able to
supervise (Bertocci, 2009).
4.3.3. The manager did not have all the traits mentioned in this theory but she
is intelligent, able to supervise and was able to communication effectively. She
demonstrated this by being able to find solutions to issues that were faced
during the change process, supervising staff to make sure that they provide
quality care and communicating to clients, staff and other agencies.
Communication between clients and practitioners is a concurrent two-way,
4.4. Contexts
4.4.1. Contexts involve addressing problems in the society and are linked to
policies (Hartley and Benington, 2010). It is necessary for people to divert
from considering that leaders are separate from their contexts to considering
about leadership within contexts that are always changing and able to adapt
to a system that is connected to each other (Hartley and Benington, (2011).
The context in this situation is that life span of people with learning disability
has increased. It is hoped that the population of people with learning disability
who are of age 50 or more who will be using social care services will rise by
30 percent by the year 2030. It is also hoped that the number of people who
are more than 80 years with learning disability who will be using social care
services will raise to 162 percent. People with learning disability have various
needs so this is a big change in the age profile of individuals and the services
they need. (British Institute of Learning Disabilities (BILD), 2014).
4.4.2. The Welsh Government is committed to making the lives of people with
learning disabilities better because they identified them to be vulnerable
(Welsh Government, 2011). Under the Equality Act 2010, those that provide
services have to offer equal access to people who have or have had a
disability (Government UK, 2013). According to the Statement on Policy &
Practice for Adults with a Learning Disability, the Welsh Government, seeks to
assist people to have full and inclusive lives. There is a need to pay attention
to maximising peoples ability to be independent and put away financial,
economic and social barriers (Welsh Government, 2011).
4.4.3. The organisation being discussed in the situation is one of the largest
non-profit organisation in the United Kingdom that supports people with
learning disabilities, autism, challenging behaviours and complex needs (D,
2016 a) (see appendix). So the organisation is assisting in meeting the needs
of people mentioned above. Some of services they provide include: personal
care, dressing, assist them to improve the skills such as cooking and assisting
service users to integrate in the community by independent and supported
living
4.4.4. The changing context places the community and governments with
complicated issues, so leadership cannot be limited to working in one agency
but has to work across other networks (Hartley and Benington, 2011). It is
necessary for leaders to have skills for mobilising hierarchies, markets and
different sectors that they work with, based on particular context and the crisis
(Benington 2011). Some principles have to be applied for an organization
change to be effective like thoughtful planning and sensitive implementation,
seeking information from individuals who will be affected by the changes and
giving them a chance to be part of the change process (Passenheim, 2010).
4.4.5. The manager who was leading the change followed these principles
because she planned how the change would take place, what her
organization wanted from the change and how it would be achieved. She also
implemented the changes by putting in place policies and procedures the staff
she had taken over had to follow. She also sought information from both
service users and support workers which illustrates her competence.
4. 5. Challenges
4.5.1. Though leadership is taken to be a vital activity on its own and right ,
more writers and those that make policies want to know the aims and purpose
for leadership. The difference between technical and adaptive issues is
influencing leadership literature (Heifetz, 1994). Heifetz characterisation of
leadership is based on what a leader or leadership is attempting to
accomplish. Technical issues are the ones that people have gone through
before, whose causes are well known, which already have a way of being
4.5.3. One of the challenges faced by the manager observed in the situation,
was that organisation R did not want to handover the paper work they were
using. This would make it very difficult for the organisation taking over. The
staff from organisation R did not want comply with the new policies and
procedures when they felt it was not suitable for them. The manager in the
situation observed felt stressed as she was not receiving enough support from
her seniors yet she was expected to make it work.
unfavourable reaction individuals get when they are under much pressure or
have too many demands (Health and Safety Executive, 2012).
4.5.4. All the above can be classified as adaptive issues that the manger had
to deal with. She dealt with first one by negotiating more with the former
organisation and involving her seniors. She had deal with the staff not wanting
to comply to the organisation Ds policies by informing them how important it
is to follow the policies and procedures. According to the Code Practice for
Social Care, employers have to put in place written policies and procedures
for their employees (Care Council Wales (2016). The manager was also
supervising staff in order for her to manage the change effectively, she deal
with their values, beliefs and the way they were working. As most of the
employees she had taken over had worked for that organisation for long they
had picked up some bad practice which they now believed was right but had
to be changed. An employer has to effectively manage and supervise
employees to work effectively, have good conduct and they have to be
supported to address areas where they are not working well (Care Council
Wales, 2016). In order to deal with the stress, she was going through, she
sought for supervision from her seniors in order to keep going.
4.6. Capabilities
4.6.1. The skills that make leadership to be effective or not include: mindsets
and behaviors (general competencies, emotional intelligence, leadership,
having knowledge politically) (Hartley and Benington, 2011). Emotional
intelligence refers to being able to establish, incorporate, understand and for
one to reflectively manage their own and others feelings.
4.6.2. Leadership and management skills are very important qualifications for
care professionals to have in whatever role they play. These skills are very
vital whilst providing care in addition to managing change (Gopee and
Galloway (2013). These are usually referred to as competencies though here
they are called capabilities. However, there is an argument that emotional
intelligence is narrow but it would be better to think about it as emotional labor
that leadership goes through (Askenasy and Humphrey, 2011). In the King
Fund report, the authors came up with other concepts of leadership
capabilities and competence that is learnt but not taught, qualities of practical
wisdom and making decision in a complicated situation (Hartley and
Benington, 2011).
4.6.3. Qualities of a good leader are: thinking ahead and thinking of ways in
which things would have been done in another way and how they could be
made better next time. By being a role model whom other people can follow.
one who focuses on client or patient which means that he or she involves
clients and respects their views. Takes responsibility unto themselves to
initiate change when there is an issue or challenge. Takes step to challenge
poor standards. Has to be able to solve problems and be resourceful. Has to
be good at communicating with patients and health and social care
professionals in order for care to go on and empower other people. Has to
take note and reward care that is good and give feedback that is positive
(Gopee and Galloway (2013). The manager observed, was able to lead by
example as she followed the policies of work place while at work place. She
involved clients views and respected their views at all times by
communicating to them or speaking to people who know them better. She
also worked with other professionals and support workers in order to meet the
needs of the clients.
4.6.4. The skills approach focuses on abilities and skills that a leader needs to
achieve as time goes on instead of personal traits that one is born with.
Robert Katz (1955) proposed that effective leadership requires personal skills,
technical skills and being able to work with individuals which is human skills
(Grout and Fisher, 2007; O'Brien and Hauser, 2015).
4.7. Consequences.
4.7. 1. Consequences of leadership illustrate its effect on individuals and
systems (Hartley and Benington, 2011). The manager leading the change
wanted the two individuals who are mobile to be more independent. Risk
assessment will be done to enable them to do more activities on their own.
She wants the lady who was hoisted by one person to be hoisted by two
people. All the above have been made come to reality and risk assessments
are in place to all that happen. So although the transition is still going on but
there are outcomes that have been achieved. She also contacted the
community occupational therapist and physiotherapist to go to the individuals
home and assess her for a new hoist that could take her to the bath room
without passing the corridor as she shares a house with men. They came and
assessed the situation of the individual and went to apply for funding in order
to make adaptations to the service users home. Scott and Spouse, (2013)
state that it is essential for an assessment to take place immediately in health
and social care environment to avoid putting clients to risk. Under the Social
Services and Well-being (Wales) Act 2014, the needs of an adult have to
assessed for the care and support (Welsh Assembly Government, 2014).
carer support needs of people in the community which enable them to find the
services required (Welsh Government, 2015).
4.7.3. The views and how effectiveness is measured are determined by what
people consider to be the cause, the consequence although at times it may
not be true. Goals are not easily achieved because various stakeholders may
also have various perceptions about the value and how effective the actions
have been (Hartley and Benington, 2011).
4.7.4. The leader of change has to monitor activities and outcomes achieved,
ensuring that the care provided is of quality standard or make changes if
necessary (Gopee and Galloway (2013). So this was in line with what the
manager did, so it can be concluded that she was effective she succeeded in
achieving the outcomes her organisation was interested in although one is still
in the process.
5.0. Conclusion
In this report, Warwick 6 Cs leadership framework has been used to evaluate
how a manager in a third sector organization managed a change in a home
that she took over . The observation was done while the author was on
placement. Management includes planning, directing or guiding and
supervising or monitoring work done or being done to achieve goals and
objectives (Gopee and Galloway, 2013). The manager that was observed in
the situation planned, directed, monitored and supervised what was done in
order the get the goals and objectives that were aimed for. She also evaluated
the work done. In health and social care, a manager has to use expert skill to
get clients outcomes such as managing and putting into practice person
centered packages of care or making sure high quality care is provided
(Gopee and Galloway, 2013). The manager also used expert skills to put in
place packages of care that centred around clients and made sure that the
care provided is line with policies and procedures of the organisation. The
author included that the skills, knowledge the manager used to handle the
situation. She also mentioned the challenges faced by the manager while
managing the change. As there are always challenges while managing
change, the student came to conclusion that the manager she observed used
a democratic leadership style as she got information from stuff, involved them
and made decisions with them at team meetings. She also treated support
workers individually and treated herself not more important than people she
delegated.
6.0. Recommendation
The professionals working with people with learning disabilities need to get
more training on how to meet the needs in this group of clients and service
users.
6.1 Although there are policies and legislation about people with learning
disabilities they are still being discriminated or not accessing services as other
people do. So policy makers need to include them more and even enforce
their inclusiveness so that the gaps are closed.
6.2. More work needs to be done on how to communicate to people with
learning disabilities more effectively as professionals rely on what the
individuals families or support worker tell them in cases where the individual
cannot talk. Some times what they say may not be what or how the individual
feels which may lead to wrong diagnosis.
References
with learning disabilities: a toolkit for health and social care commissioners.
Available at:
http://www.ndti.org.uk/uploads/files/9354_Supporting_Older_People_ST3.pdf
(Accessed: 20 March 2016).
6. Brownell, J. (1992), Hospitality manager's communication practices.
https://www.gov.uk/guidance/equality-act-2010-guidance (Accessed: 31
March 2016).
15. Grant, G. Ramcharan, P. Flynn, M. and Richardson M. (eds) (2010) Learning
London: Routledge.
18. Government UK (2015) The Data Protection Act. Available at:
https://www.gov.uk/data-protection/the-data-protection-act. (Accessed: 14
March 2016).
19. Grout, J and Fisher, L. (2007) What Do Leaders Really Do: Getting Under the
Skin of what Makes a Great Leader Tick. John Wiley & Sons.
20. Hafford-Letchfield, T. (2009), Management and Organisations in Social Work.
24. Hartley, J. and Benington, J. (2010) Leadership for Healthcare. Bristol: Policy
Press.
25. Lee, C. D. (2013) Commentary: Insightful Observations for Managing
http://www.hse.gov.uk/stress/furtheradvice/whatisstress.htm (Accessed: 30
March 2016).
28. Hodges, D. and Burchell N. (2003), Business graduate competencies:
Language Pathology and Audiology. 4th edn. Clifton Park: Cengage Learning
31. Morrison, J. L. (2012) A Review of Dressler, Gary. Supervision and
%40sessionmgr110&vid=2&hid=107&bdata=JnNpdGU9ZWhvc3QtbGl2ZQ
%3d%3d#AN=108105113&db=ccm. (Accessed: 15 March 2016).
33. Mind Tools (2016) Dunham and Pierce's Leadership Process Model. Available
at: https://www.mindtools.com/pages/article/leadership-process.htm
(Accessed: 17 March 2016).
34. NHS Leadership Academy (2011) Leadership Framework. Available at:
http://web.b.ebscohost.com.ergo.glam.ac.uk/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?
sid=6e276a92-ae42-4fc5-8189f8c9ca4a1296%40sessionmgr112&vid=1&hid=107(Accessed: 14 March
2016).
36. O'Brien, E. R. and Hauser, M. A. (eds.) (2015) Supervision and Agency
http://www.autism.org.uk/get-involved/companies/why-support-the-nas.aspx
(Accessed: 17 March 2016).
42. Welsh Assembly Government (2014) Social Services and Well-being (Wales)
43. Welsh Government (2015) Local authority registers of people with disabilities,
Available at:
http://gov.wales/docs/dhss/publications/160127socialservicesacten.pdf.
(Accessed: 24 March 2016).
Appendix