Primitive Brain Is 'Smarter' Than We Think, MIT Study Shows - ScienceDaily PDF

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 2

PrimitiveBrainIs'Smarter'ThanWeThink,MITStudyShows

Date:
Source:
Summary:

March14,2005
MassachusettsInstituteOfTechnology
Primitivestructuresdeepwithinthebrainmayhaveafargreaterroleinourhighlevel
everydaythinkingprocessesthanpreviouslybelieved,reportresearchersattheMIT
PicowerCenterforLearningandMemoryintheFeb.24issueofNature.

Share:

FULLSTORY

Primitivestructuresdeepwithinthebrainmayhaveafargreaterroleinourhigh
leveleverydaythinkingprocessesthanpreviouslybelieved,reportresearchersat
theMITPicowerCenterforLearningandMemoryintheFeb.24issueofNature.
TheresultsofthisstudyledbyEarlK.Miller,associatedirectorofthePicowerCenteratMIT,have
implicationsabouthowwelearn.Thenewknowledgealsomayleadtobetterunderstandingand
treatmentforautismandschizophrenia,whichcouldresultfromanimbalancebetweenprimitiveand
moreadvancedbrainsystems.
Ourbrainshaveevolvedafast,reliablewaytolearnrulessuchas"stopatred"and"goatgreen."
Dogmahasitthatthe"bigboss"lobesofthecerebralcortex,responsiblefordailyandlongterm
decisionmaking,learntherulesfirstandthentransfertheknowledgetothemoreprimitive,large
forebrainregionknownasthebasalganglia,buriedunderthecortex.
Althoughbothregionsareknowntobeinvolvedinlearningrulesthatbecomeautomaticenoughforusto
followwithoutmuchthought,noonehadeverdeterminedeachone'sspecificrole.
Inthisstudy,Miller,whoisthePicowerProfessorofNeuroscience,andpostdoctoralassociateAnitha
Pasupathyfoundthatinmonkeys,thestriatum(theinputstructureofthebasalganglia)showedmore
rapidchangeinthelearningprocessthanthemorehighlyevolvedprefrontalcortex.Theirresults
suggestthatthebasalgangliafirstidentifytherule,andthen"train"theprefrontalcortex,whichabsorbs
thelessonmoreslowly.

"Thesefindingssuggestnewwaysofthinkingaboutlearning,"Millersaid."Theysuggestthatnew
learningisn'tsimplythesmarterbitsofourbrainsuchasthecortex'figuringthingsout.'Instead,we
shouldthinkoflearningasinteractionbetweenourprimitivebrainstructuresandourmoreadvanced
cortex.Inotherwords,primitivebrainstructuresmightbetheenginedrivingevenourmostadvanced
highlevel,intelligentlearningabilities,"hesaid.
Thecortexthe"thinking"partofthebrainishighlydevelopedinhumans.Thisisespeciallytrueforthe
prefrontalcortex.Commonwisdomsuggeststhatwhenwelearnnewthings,theprefrontalcortexfigures
thingsoutfirst.Then,asourbehaviorsbecomefamiliarandhabitual,themoreprimitive,subcortical
basalgangliatakeoversothatthenowfamiliarroutinescanberunoffautomaticallyandoccupylessof
ourthoughts.
"Whatwefoundwasevidenceforsomethingverydifferent,"Pasupathysaid."Wefoundthatasmonkeys
learnnew,simplerulesassociationsanalogousto'stopatred,goatgreen'thestriatumofthebasal
gangliashowsevidenceoflearningmuchsoonerandfasterthantheprefrontalcortex.But,aninteresting
wrinkleisthatthethemonkeys'behaviorimprovedataslowrate,similartothatoftheslowerchanges
inprefrontalcortex."
Thissuggeststhatwhilethebasalganglia"learn"first,theiroutputforcestheprefrontalcortextochange,
albeitataslowerrate.
Theresearchersspeculatethatperhapsthefasterlearninginthebasalgangliaallowsus(andour
primitiveancestorswholackedaprefrontalcortex)toquicklypickupimportantinformationneededfor
survival.Theprefrontalcortexthenmonitorswhatthebasalgangliahavelearned.Itsslower,more
deliberatelearningmechanismsallowittogatheramorejudicious"bigpicture"ofwhatisgoingonby
takingintoaccountmorehistoryandtherebyexertexecutivecontroloverbehavior,Millersaid.
ThisworkwassupportedbytheNationalInstituteofNeurologicalDisordersandStrokeandthe
Tourette'sSyndromeAssociation.
AversionofthisarticleappearedintheMarch2,2005issueofMITTechTalk(Volume49,Number19).

You might also like