Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Integrated Core-Log Petrofacies Analysis in The Construction of A Reservoir Geomodel A Case Study of A Mature Mississippian Carbonate Reservoir Using Limited Data
Integrated Core-Log Petrofacies Analysis in The Construction of A Reservoir Geomodel A Case Study of A Mature Mississippian Carbonate Reservoir Using Limited Data
AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Small independent operators produce most of the Mississippian
carbonate fields in the United States mid-continent, where a lack
of integrated characterization studies precludes maximization of
hydrocarbon recovery. This study uses integrative techniques to
leverage extant data in an Osagian and Meramecian (Mississippian)
cherty carbonate reservoir in Kansas. Available data include petrophysical logs of varying vintages, limited number of cores, and production histories from each well. A consistent set of assumptions
were used to extract well-level porosity and initial saturations,
from logs of different types and vintages, to build a geomodel. Lacking regularly recorded well shut-in pressures, an iterative technique,
based on material balance formulations, was used to estimate average reservoir-pressure decline that matched available drillstem test
data and validated log-analysis assumptions.
Core plugs representing the principal reservoir petrofacies provide critical inputs for characterization and simulation studies. However, assigning plugs among multiple reservoir petrofacies is difficult in complex (carbonate) reservoirs. In a bottom-up approach,
raw capillary pressure (P c) data were plotted on the Super-Pickett
plot, and log- and core-derived saturation-height distributions were
reconciled to group plugs by facies, to identify core plugs representative of the principal reservoir facies, and to discriminate facies
Copyright #2005. The American Association of Petroleum Geologists. All rights reserved.
Manuscript received December 22, 2004; provisional acceptance March 22, 2005; revised manuscript
received May 27, 2005; final acceptance June 3, 2005.
DOI:10.1306/06030504144
1257
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors acknowledge the financial assistance received from U.S. Department of Energy
(Grants DE-PC22-93BC14987 and DE-FC2601BC15276) to carry out this study.
1258
E&P Notes
OVERVIEW
Independent producers form a significant component of the petroleum industry, drilling 90% of the wells (IPAA, 2005) in the United
States. They produce 65% and 85% (Gratton, 2005) of the nations
oil and natural gas, respectively, in the lower 48 states and operated
77% of the wells drilled in the federal Gulf of Mexico waters in 2000
(PTCC, 2002). Mississippian carbonate reservoirs account for nearly
17% of the 6 billion bbl (0.954 billion m3) of oil produced in Kansas
(as of 2003). With declining production in other age reservoirs, the
contribution of Mississippian reservoirs to the states oil production
has increased to 33% over the past decade. Mississippian production
is distributed over a large number of small- and medium-size reservoirs that are predominantly operated by independent producers
(90% having fewer than 20 employees) with limited resources.
The objective of this study was to define techniques that can
be used to identify areas with recoverable reserves in the Osagian
and Meramecian (Mississippian) carbonate reservoirs in western
Kansas. The goal was to tailor existing advanced technology to the
scale appropriate for operations in the mid-continent and demonstrate incremental recovery through a field application. As part of
the effort, inexpensive techniques were used to analyze and leverage available geologic, petrophysical, production, and pressure
data. This article demonstrates an integrated application of costeffective tools to characterize the Schaben field (Ness County,
Kansas), a Mississippian carbonate and chert reservoir located in
central Kansas, using limited available data.
In the Schaben field, available petrophysical logs are of varied
types and vintages as in many other mature mid-continent fields.
A consistent set of assumptions had to be developed by integrating available core data and petrophysical logs to estimate porosity
and S w (initial water saturation) at each well to construct a threedimensional (3-D) volumetric model of the reservoir. Assumptions made during log analyses were validated using an independent method based on material balance formulations and tailored
to limited reservoir-pressure data. Critical inputs to any reservoirsimulation study include relative permeability, capillary-pressure
data, and permeability-porosity correlations. These data are commonly obtained from special core analyses on core plugs from
the reservoir interval or from a rock catalog. However, in a complex and heterogeneous reservoir such as the Mississippian in the
Schaben field, it is important to identify core plugs representative
GEOLOGIC SETTING
Most of the Mississippian production in Kansas occurs
at or near the top of the Mississippian strata located
below the regional sub-Pennsylvanian unconformity.
On the basis of current geologic interpretation (Montgomery et al., 2000), the upper surface of the Mississippian is an erosional karst terrain. The combination
of the karsted erosional surface, original depositional
facies, and subsequent diagenesis has had a significant
control on the development and preservation of reservoir quality. Consequently, Mississippian (Osagian and
Meramecian) reservoirs, principally shallow-marine,
cherty, dolomitic limestone such as those present in
the study area are extremely heterogeneous. Carr et al.
(1998, 1999) reported that the dipping Mississippian
strata, deposited on a shallow-marine ramp environment, were structurally uplifted, and differential erosion at the post-Mississippian unconformity resulted
SCHABEN FIELD
The Schaben field, Ness County, Kansas, is located in
the upper shelf of the Hugoton embayment of the
Anadarko basin (Figure 1). The field produces oil from
dolostones and limestones of the lower Meramecian
Warsaw Limestone and Osagian Keokuk Limestone
(Mississippian). The Schaben field was selected as representative of many mature Mississippian oil fields in
Kansas. The productive Meramecian and Osagian dolomites lie beneath the sub-Pennsylvanian unconformity. Sedimentologic and diagenetic studies (Carr et al.,
1998, 1999; Montgomery et al., 2000) conducted on
three cores from and around the Schaben field study
area indicate that the Mississippian interval is made
up of two flow units. The basal unit is interpreted
to have been deposited in a normal to somewhat restricted marine environment and contains an abundance of echinoderm-rich intervals with a diverse faunal assemblage. The upper flow unit consists of sponge
spicule-rich facies containing silicified replacements of
original evaporite minerals. A subaerial exposure horizon (internal unconformity) separates the upper reservoir flow unit from the lower, with the post-Mississippian
unconformity capping the entire sequence. The productive Mississippian reservoir interval lies within the
upper sponge spicule-rich wackestone-packstone facies. Most of the porosity resides as molds of spicules,
vugs, and intercrystalline pores in a dolospar matrix.
Bhattacharya et al.
1259
E&P Notes
2
1261
1262
E&P Notes
Figure 2. Mississippian isopach map (above oil-water contact) in Schaben field, Kansas, highlighting well locations and leases comprising the study area. The original Schaben
wells are shown by black circles, whereas red circles indicate the locations of infill wells drilled as a result of this study.
Figure 3. The Super-Pickett plot of Ritchie Exploration 2P Lyle Schaben well, located in Section 31, T19S, R21W, Ness County,
Kansas, displaying neutron-density porosity and deep resistivity (ILD) from the interval 4390 4423 ft (1338 1348 m). Plotted points
are 0.5 ft (0.15 m) apart and colored according to depth. The black diamonds mark the transition from one depth interval (color) to
the next, whereas the line joining the plotted points enable pattern recognition by tracing their depth sequence. Tight clustering of
plotted points may conceal the black diamonds and the connecting line. Capillary-pressure data from core plugs L10, L15, L22, and
L42 are plotted as height (feet) above oil-water contact contours and are shown by red lines. The perforated interval extends from
4400 to 4404 ft (1341 to 1342 m). Water saturation (S w) contours are shown in blue. The arrows indicate the expected shift in
location of the green and blue points if they belonged to the same petrofacies as the red points and is discussed under the section
Identification of Core Plugs Representative of Reservoir Petrofacies.
However, no records of R mf and R os that can be considered representative were available for wells in the
Schaben field. Porosity and S w derived from whole
core analysis from Ritchie Exploration 1D Moore well
were found to approximate porosity and S w values
calculated from the MLL data using R mf = 0.065 ohm
m and R os = 37%. The use of these R mf and R os values
resulted in similar matches in wells with MLL and core
analysis data, and they were used consistently to analyze the remaining microlaterologs. A Super-Pickett
plot (Figure 4) was constructed for Ritchie Exploration 1D Moore well using the above values of R mf and
R os with the producing zone 4388 4394 ft (1337
1339 m) represented in red. For the producing zone,
the plot indicates an average log-derived porosity of
16.7% and an average S w of 59.5%.
At each well, the initial production test data and
fluid production history during the initial few years
1263
Figure 4. The Super-Pickett plot of Ritchie Exploration 1D Moore well, located in Section 30, T19S, R21W, Ness County, Kansas,
displaying porosity from microlaterologs and deep resistivity data from the interval 4388 4407 ft (1337.51343.3 m). Plotted points
are 0.5 ft (0.15 m) apart and colored according to depth. The black diamonds mark the transition from one depth interval (color) to
the next, whereas the line joining the plotted points enables pattern recognition by tracing their depth sequence. Tight clustering of
plotted points may conceal the black diamonds and the connecting line. Capillary-pressure data from core plugs L10, L15, L22, L42,
and F16 are plotted as height (feet) above oil-water contact contours and are shown by red lines. The perforated interval extends
from 4388 to 4394 ft (1337 to 1339 m). Water saturation contours are shown in blue.
E&P Notes
VOLUMETRIC ESTIMATION
OF ORIGINAL RESERVES
After completion of log analysis at individual wells, a
volumetric 3-D model was developed for the Schaben
field. Drillstem test and initial production test data were
integrated to establish the fieldwide oil-water contact,
estimated between 2145 and 2148 ft ( 653.8 and
654.7 m) subsea. Average porosity, S w, and Mississippian pay thickness above the oil-water contact were
mapped using grid cell sizes of 220 220 ft (67.1
67.1 m). The map grids were imported into spreadsheets to carry out grid-cell by grid-cell volumetric
VALIDATION OF VOLUMETRICS:
MATERIAL BALANCE CALCULATIONS
Material balance serves as a powerful tool to validate a
reservoir geomodel before using it as a basis for simulation study. Dake (1994) cautions that simulation
studies will not remedy a geomodel that cannot be
validated by material balance. Irrespective of geometrical considerations (geologic model), material balance
applies physical laws to confirm if the volumetric original oil in place acting under a specified drive mechanism is capable of producing the recorded (surface)
fluid volumes while undergoing an average pressure
decline similar to that recorded historically in the field.
Standard inputs to material balance calculations in-
1265
E&P Notes
1960; Dake, 1994) was used for water influx calculations, where the aquifer petrophysical properties and
the average reservoir pressure were used to calculate
W e /E. Starting with 1450 psi (9997 kPa) in 1963, the
average annual reservoir pressure for 1964 was iterated until the calculated N (= F/E W e /E ) was within
10% of the volumetric original oil in place. Similarly,
the average annual pressure for 1965 was iterated
until the calculated N, using the calculated average
reservoir pressure for 1964 and the fluid production
volumes of 1965, varied within 10% of volumetric
original oil in place. This exercise (obviously) resulted
in a unit slope plot of F/E versus W e /E, with a Y-axis
intercept indicating an original oil-in-place value of
34 MMSTB (5.41 million m3), the average of N values
for all the time steps (years). Figure 6 compares the
average reservoir-pressure profile, generated from the
material balance calculations, with available drillstem
test shut-in pressures from the Schaben field. The available drillstem test data match the pressure history developed by the material balance iterations, confirming
that the volumetrically calculated original oil in place,
in conjunction with an active water drive, was able
to support the reported field fluid (oil and water) production volumes by undergoing a decline in reservoir pressure consistent with recorded shut-in pressure data.
Material balance calculations also provided additional insights about reservoir performance. Thirtyfive out of 46 wells in the Schaben field were drilled
between 1963 and 1966, resulting in high withdrawal
volumes from the reservoir. The inability of the aquifer influx to compensate for the volumes withdrawn
the dotted line (Figure 7A). For a plug of same petrofacies but with an intermediate porosity F12 (between
F1 and F2), the general expectation is that its P c curve
will follow a trend (broken line, Figure 7A) that lies
between the respective curves for plugs with porosities
F1 and F2. Thus, the point with coordinates (F12,S w12)
is expected to lie along the P c contour trend (dotted
line in Figure 7B) established by the other three plugs
from the same petrofacies. Any other positioning of
the coordinates (F12,S w12) resulting in a break or disruption of the capillary-pressure (height above the oilwater contact) contour trend would indicate that the
corresponding plug (with F12 porosity) belongs to a
different petrofacies.
Doveton et al. (1996) demonstrated the concept
of plotting capillary-pressure (height above oil-water
contact) contours on the Super-Pickett plot, and Doveton (1999) applied published P c relationships to integrate pore network measures in standard log analyses. The use of raw reservoir core data introduces new
complexities, in that distinctions must be made between (1) plugs from different petrofacies and (2) the
principal petrofacies related to the reservoir profile
mapped out by the resistivity-porosity trajectory of
the logged section. Capillary-pressure contours plotted from plugs from a common petrofacies should
form coherent trends free of disruptions that would be
introduced by mingling plugs from other petrofacies.
The medium of the Pickett plot is therefore, in itself,
a pattern recognition device to discriminate separate
petrofacies. Finally, the conversion of capillary pressure to equivalent hydrocarbon column height means
that the reference depths of log data points can be
used as an independent check of column height surface. Incremental changes in depths in the logged section should be matched by corresponding column height
differences. Discrepancies must be resolved but can be
examined in a reconciliation process that reevaluates
core and log petrophysics. Because core plug data are
generally limited in number, the reconciliation of log
and core data on the Pickett plot in terms of water
saturation changes with height is a powerful integrative tool.
1267
E&P Notes
capillary-pressure measurements with the petrophysical log data to identify the plugs that represent the principal reservoir petrofacies.
Capillary-pressure data from the six available core
plugs were mapped on the Super-Pickett plot (Figure 9)
as contours (red lines) of equivalent hydrocarbon column height above the oil-water contact. The plotted
capillary-pressure data resulted in erratic (nonuniform)
contour lines with abrupt breaks that disrupt any consistent trend. However, restricting the plotted capillary
Figure 9. The Super-Pickett plot of Ritchie Exploration 2P Lyle Schaben well displaying neutron-density porosity and deep resistivity
data from the interval 4390 4423 ft (1338 1348 m). Plotted points are 0.5 ft (0.15 m) apart and colored according to depth. The
black diamonds mark the transition from one depth interval (color) to the next, whereas the line joining the plotted points enables
pattern recognition by tracing their depth sequence. Tight clustering of plotted points may conceal the black diamonds and the
connecting line. Capillary-pressure data from core plugs L10, L15, L17, L22, L27, and L42 are plotted as height (feet) above oil-water
contact contours and are shown by red lines. The perforated interval extends from 4400 to 4404 ft (1341 to 1342 m). Water
saturation lines are shown in blue.
Bhattacharya et al.
1269
interval is about 25 ft (7.62 m) above the oil-water contact. The P c data from the subset of four plugs, when
plotted on the Super-Pickett plot, show that the perforated zone is straddled by capillary-pressure contours (red
lines) equivalent to heights ranging between 24 and 32 ft
(7.32 and 9.75 m) above the oil-water contact. Agreement between log petrophysical data and available core
data indicates that plugs L10, L15, L22, and L42 represent the primary petrofacies of the reservoir rock in
the Ritchie Exploration 2P Lyle Schaben well.
The green and blue points in Figure 3 represent
average depths that are 17.5 and 7.5 ft (5.3 and 2.3 m),
respectively, above the oil-water contact. However, the
P c contour line representative of 23 ft (7 m) above the
oil-water contact passes through the cluster of both
the green and blue points, indicating that their respective principal petrofacies are different from that of the
perforated interval (red points). For their respective
porosities, the green and blue points would be shifted
horizontally to the left of their current positions (as
indicated by the arrows in Figure 3) to intersect the P c
contour lines representative of the 17.5 and 7.5 ft (5.3
and 2.3 m) above the oil-water contact if rocks between 4404 and 4424 ft (1342.3 and 1348.4 m) belonged to same facies as the reservoir interval (red
points). This technique of mapping P c data on wirelinelog data is effective to distinguish facies in the
logged interval, especially when such discrimination
is difficult or impossible given the resolution of the
available petrophysical log data.
Wire-line log data and special core analysis data
were available for the Ritchie Exploration Foos AP
Twin well, located just outside the study area, producing from the same Mississippian reservoir. This
core was visually inspected, and four plugs (F5, F26,
F11, and F16) were selected from the reservoir interval for measurement of the capillary-pressure data.
Capillary-pressure data measured on these Foos plugs
were plotted along with that from the Lyle plugs (L10,
L15, L22, and L42) representative of the reservoir
facies to identify if any of the Foos plugs also represented the Schaben reservoir facies. Upon plotting,
only P c data from F16 was found consistent with trends
of capillary-pressure and height contours of representative Lyle plugs. As a result of this exercise, a set of five
plugs (namely, L10, L15, L22, L42, and F16), out of
a total of 10 plugs taken from the reservoir interval,
were identified as representative of the principal reservoir facies in the Schaben field.
Figure 4 shows that capillary-pressure data from
these five core plugs plot as uniform trend lines when
1270
E&P Notes
plotted on the Super-Pickett plot of the Ritchie Exploration 1D Moore well, and that the perforated zone
is located between the relevant heights above the oilwater contact contour lines. The application of P c
contours on Super-Pickett plots to differentiate facies
in the logged interval is illustrated in Figure 4. At the
Ritchie Exploration 1D Moore well, the average depth
of the blue points is about 17.5 ft (5.3 m) above the
oil-water contact. Petrophysically, the rock in the interval between 4398 and 4407 ft (1340.5 and 1343.2 m)
(represented by the blue points) belongs to the same
facies as the perforated interval (red points) as the P c
curve representative of 16 ft (4.8 m) above the oilwater contact passes through the cluster of blue points.
This plot shows that the rock in the intervening interval between 4394 and 4398 ft (1339.3 and 1340.5 m)
(green points) belongs to a facies different from that of
the reservoir interval (red points).
The productive potential of a zone is better estimated when field-measured petrophysical log data are
reconciled with laboratory-measured capillary-pressure
data. In addition, this approach is a valuable tool to differentiate multiple petrofacies and flow units especially
in heterogeneous reservoirs. It is not uncommon in
the industry to characterize a field without available
cores. In such cases, it is customary to borrow petrophysical data, measured on plugs taken from analog
reservoir intervals, from rock catalogs (or other sources)
to conduct characterization and simulation studies.
The above-mentioned technique will be very useful
in such a situation (especially complex carbonate reservoirs), because it helps to confirm if the selected
analog plugs actually represent the principal reservoir
petrofacies. Finally, this technique is within the resource reach of small independent operators of the
mid-continent because capillary-pressure measurement
(on core plugs) is inexpensive.
Many investigators, such as Ward and Morrow
(1987), Omoregie (1988), Ruth and Chen (1995), and
Newsham et al. (2004) have compared capillary-pressure
data recorded by different techniques, namely, mercury injection, restored-state method, centrifuge, and
desorption isotherms, respectively. They report varying levels of congruence between P c data measured by
different techniques. In the mid-continent, two common techniques for obtaining capillary-pressure data
are centrifuge and mercury injection. Hence, it is
recommended that the data measured by centrifuge
and mercury-injection techniques should not be plotted
on the same Super-Pickett plot to identify core plugs
representative of the reservoir facies.
RESERVOIR SIMULATION
The material balance study confirmed that the volumetric description of the reservoir-aquifer system is
able to support the reported fluid production history
of the field while undergoing a pressure decline that
(closely) matched available drillstem test data. The volumetric 3-D model developed by integrating log analyses, production tests, and available core data served
as the basis for a fieldwide simulation study whose objective was to map residual reserves in the field to guide
independent operators in spotting successful infill
wells. Critical inputs to any reservoir-simulation study
include relative permeability and capillary-pressure
curves, including end-point saturations such as S wir
(irreducible water saturation) and S orw (irreducible oil
saturation) measured in the laboratory from core plugs
representative of the primary reservoir rock. Using the
Super-Pickett crossplot as a template, core plugs representing the principal facies in the Schaben field reservoir were identified by reconciling capillary-pressure
data with petrophysical log data. These representative
plugs provided a consistent set of petrophysical data
for porosity values ranging from 15.6 to 23.5%. The
identification of representative core plugs is important for simulation studies because they provide the
appropriate permeability-porosity trend to make the
initial estimate of effective permeability in the drainage area of each well. In addition, it enables the input
of S wir and S orw values in the relative permeability table,
which are consistent with the effective permeability
in the wells drainage area especially during the process
of history matching, when the effective permeability
is adjusted to match recorded fluid production.
A full-field simulation study of the Schaben field
was conducted using Department of Energys Boast98
simulator (Heemstra, 1998), a freeware. The reservoir was modeled as two layers with an analytical
Carter-Tracy aquifer using grid cells of 220 220 ft
(67.1 67.1 m). Details about different inputs, history matches on individual well performance, and output maps have been reported elsewhere (Bhattacharya
and Gerlach, 2000). For most wells, a reasonable match
was obtained between the simulation output and the
recorded production and pressure history. The simulation output was used to generate a map of the remaining reserves in the Schaben field. Based on this
remaining potential map, the various operators of the
Schaben field drilled 22 infill wells, resulting in an
incremental production of 100 bbl (16 m3) of oil per
day over the next 4 yr.
1271
Figure 10. Log-derived initial water saturation (S w) and average porosity over the perforated and production interval in productive
Schaben wells, where the average height of the reservoir ranges between 20 and 40 ft (6.1 and 12.2 m) above the oil-water-contact,
are plotted as triangles. The circles represent S w-porosity data at 31 ft (9.5 m) above the oil-water contact from capillary-pressure
(P c ) measurements on plugs representative of principal reservoir facies, whereas the squares represent irreducible water saturation
(S wir) and porosity obtained from the P c measurements at 105 ft (32 m) above the oil-water contact. The R 2 for the best fit lines
through P c data at 31 and 105 ft (9.5 and 32 m) above the oil-water contact are also shown.
E&P Notes
addition, this correlation can be used to identify waterproducing zones for squeeze cementation to reduce
water production from existing wells and to help identify potential pay zones previously bypassed because
of high log-derived S w values. Finally, many midcontinental Mississippian fields that lack core data are
considered analogs to the Schaben field. Infill programs initiated in such fields could benefit by the use
of S wir-porosity correlations developed on available
core data, such as from the Schaben field or any other
analog field, after confirming that the selected core
plugs represent the principal reservoir facies.
CONCLUSIONS
1. Petrophysical logs of various types and vintages
were analyzed using a consistent set of assumptions
to build a volumetric model of the reservoir.
2. Lacking regularly recorded shut-in pressures at each
well, an iterative technique was developed based on
standard material balance formulations, where the
volumetrically estimated original oil in place, annual
fluid production, and PVT data were used to estimate the average reservoir pressure. A match between the average reservoir-pressure history, estimated from material balance, and shut-in pressures
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
from available drillstem tests validated the volumetric model and the underlying assumptions made
in analyzing logs of different types and vintages.
Using a bottom-up strategy, raw capillary-pressure
(P c) data measured on several core plugs from the
reservoir interval were plotted on the Super-Pickett
plot to group the plugs by petrofacies characterized
by its distinctive uniform trend in the plotted
capillary-pressure (height above the oil-water contact) contours.
Log-derived water saturation (S w)-height profiles
were matched with those from capillary-pressure
curves over the Super-Pickett plot to identify a subset of core plugs representative of the principal reservoir petrofacies. For fields without core data, this
technique can be used to confirm if petrophysical
data obtained from a rock catalog or another analog
reservoir actually represent the principal petrofacies of the reservoir rock under study.
Reconciliation of P c- and log-derived S w-height data
on the Super-Pickett template also enabled discrimination between petrofacies in the logged interval.
This technique can be used to identify different
petrofacies in a well particularly when such distinctions are difficult using (visual) pattern recognition
of petrophysical log signatures.
Special core analyses on core plugs representative
of the principal reservoir facies provided critical
petrophysical inputs to a full-field simulation study.
Based on the results of the simulation study, 22
infill wells were drilled in this mature field, resulting in incremental production.
A close match was observed between log-derived
Sw-porosity data from 16 productive Schaben wells,
where the perforated and production zone ranged
between 20 and 40 ft (6.1 and 12.2 m) above the
oil-water contact, and that obtained from P c data,
at 31 ft (9.5 m) above oil-water contact, measured
on representative plugs, thus validating that the
selected core plugs represented the principal reservoir facies across the field.
P c data from core plugs representing the principal
reservoir facies were used to determine a relationship between irreducible water saturation (S wir) and
porosity for the Schaben field to provide a qualitative guide for estimating water cut from zones
completed in infill and existing wells. Such customized relationships will aid operators to conduct selective perforations to minimize water production.
In mature mid-continent fields, capillary-pressure
data are generally forthcoming. However, for effec-
REFERENCES CITED
Aguilera, R., 2002, Incorporating capillary pressure, pore aperture
radii, height above free-water table, and Winland r35 values on
Pickett plots: AAPG Bulletin, v. 86, no. 4, p. 605 624.
Aguilera, R., 2004, Integration of geology, petrophysics, and reservoir characterization of carbonate reservoirs through Pickett
plots: AAPG Bulletin, v. 88, no. 4, p. 433 446.
Aguilera, R., and M. S. Aguilera, 2002, The integration of capillary
pressures and Pickett plots for determination of flow units and
reservoir containers: Society of Petroleum Engineers Reservoir
Evaluation and Engineering, v. 5, no. 6, p. 465 471.
Archie, G. E., 1942, The electrical resistivity log as an aid in determining some reservoir characteristics: Transactions of the
American Institute of Mining and Metallurgical and Petroleum
Engineers, v. 146, p. 54 67.
Bhattacharya, S., and P. M. Gerlach, 2000, Results of 3 layer reservoir simulation study Schaben field, Ness County, Kansas:
Kansas Geological Survey Open-File Report 2000-78, 85 p.
Bhattacharya, S., W. L. Watney, J. H. Doveton, W. J. Guy, and G. C.
Bohling, 1999, From geomodels to engineering models
Opportunities in spreadsheet computing, in T. F. Hentz, ed.,
Advanced reservoir characterization for the 21st century:
SEPM Foundation 19th Annual Research Conference, p. 179
191.
Carr, T. R., D. W. Green, and G. P. Willhite, 1998, Improved oil
recovery in Mississippian carbonate reservoirs of Kansas, Near
Term-Class 2 annual report, September 18, 1994 to March 15,
1997: National Petroleum Technology Office, U.S. Department of Energy, Tulsa, Oklahoma, 168 p.
Carr, T. R., D. W. Green, and G. P. Willhite, 1999, Improved oil
recovery in Mississippian carbonate reservoirs of Kansas, Near
Term-Class 2 annual report, January 1, 1998 to December 31,
1998: National Petroleum Technology Office, U.S. Department of Energy, Tulsa, Oklahoma, 57 p.
Carter, R. D., and G. W. Tracy, 1960, An improved method for calculating water influx: Journal of Petroleum Technology, v. 12,
p. 58 60.
Dake, L. P., 1994, The practice of reservoir engineering: Amsterdam, Elsevier, 534 p.
Doveton, J. H., 1999, Integrated petrophysical methods for the
analysis of reservoir microarchitecture A Kansas Chester
Sandstone case study: AAPG Mid-Continent Section Meeting
Transactions, p. 91 101.
Doveton, J. H., W. J. Guy, W. L. Watney, G. C. Bohling, S. Ullah, and
D. Adkins-Heljeson, 1996, Log analysis of petrofacies and flowunits with microcomputer spreadsheet software: 1995 AAPG
Mid-Continent Section Meeting Transactions, p. 224 233.
Bhattacharya et al.
1273
1274
E&P Notes
proving performance in a Mississippian shallow-shelf carbonate: AAPG Bulletin, v. 84, p. 1069 1086.
Newsham, K. E., J. A. Rushing, P. M. Lasswell, J. C. Cox, and T. A.
Blasingame, 2004, A comparative study of laboratory techniques for measuring capillary pressures in tight gas sands:
Society of Petroleum Engineers Annual Technical Conference, Houston, SPE Paper 89866, 11 p.
Omoregie, Z. S., 1988, Factors affecting the equivalency of different
capillary pressure measurement techniques: SPE Formation
Evaluation, v. 3, no. 1, p. 147 155.
Pickett, G. R., 1973, Pattern recognition as a means of formation
evaluation: The Log Analyst, v. 14, no. 4, p. 3 11.
PTTC (Petroleum Technology Transfer Council), 2002. DOE continues its commitment to independent oil producers: www
.kgs.ku.edu/PTTC/News/2002/q02-2-4.html (accessed July 22,
2005)
Ruth, D. W., and Z. A. Chen, 1995, Measurement and interpretation of centrifuge capillary pressure curves The SCA survey data: The Log Analyst, v. 36, no. 5, p. 21 33.
Ward, J. S., and N. R. Morrow, 1987, Capillary pressures and gas
relative permeabilities of low-permeability sandstone: SPE
Formation Evaluation, v. 2, no. 3, p. 345 356.
Watney, W. L., W. J. Guy, S. Bhattacharya, P. M. Gerlach, G. C.
Bohling, and T. C. Carr, 1999, Petrofacies analysis A petrophysical tool for geologic/engineering reservoir characterization,
in R. Schatzinger and J. Jordan, eds., Reservoir characterization
Recent advances: AAPG Memoir 71, p. 73 90.
Wyllie, M. R. J., and W. D. Rose, 1950, Some theoretical considerations related to the quantitative evaluation of the physical characteristics of reservoir rock from electrical log data:
Journal of Petroleum Technology, v. 2, no. 4, p. 105 118.