Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Non-Surgical Pocket Therapy Dental Oclusion
Non-Surgical Pocket Therapy Dental Oclusion
Non-Surgical
Therapy:
Dental Occlusion
Marlin E. Gher*
'Private practice, Carlsbad,
California
Question Set
Ann Penodontol
1996;1:567-580.
INTRODUCTION
The effects of occlusal forces on the progression of Periodontitis have been researched and debated for decades.1 36 Early
theories implicated traumatogenic occlusion
as the etiology of Periodontitis.13 When the
role of microorganisms as causative agents
in Periodontitis became evident, emphasis
switched to the evaluation of traumatogenic
occlusion as a cofactor in the progression of
Periodontitis.417 Glickman in the early
1960s proposed that a traumatogenic occlusion could produce a lesion of occlusal
trauma which could accelerate the progression of Periodontitis and direct the inflammatory process into the periodontal ligament.47 These early papers relied on
retrospective analysis of occlusal wear pat-
terns,
Girier
568
man
were
developed
Annals
of Periodontology
Review:
osseous
569
Burgett et al. reported results from a randomized clinical trial designed to test the effect of occlusal adjustment as a component
of the treatment of Periodontitis.56 Fifty patients with moderate to advanced Periodontitis were entered in the study. All patients
received initial periodontal therapy and were
randomly divided into two groups who received either occlusal adjustment or no occlusal adjustment prior to definitive periodontal therapy. The patients were then
treated, in a split mouth design, with modified Widman flap surgery or scaling and root
planing. Those patients who received occlusal adjustment had a statistically significant
mean probing attachment gain of 0.42 mm
when compared to the patients with no oc-
Gher
570
CO
c
lt)
ii
1-
to
II
CD
TD
CO
II
CD
0
CD
XI
>.
iL
CO
CO CO CO
5
&
nj 5
CO
CO
O
3
co
=1
'SCO
-S
O
e
d
CO
c
CO
CD
co
B e
*J
3
2
xi
CO
it=
CD
11
CO
2
3
E.
CO
^c
'
55 c
>..2>
0 o
03
0 E ZZ
>- 3
6
73
a>
CO
c=
CD
**
<=
x:
oo
73
0
CO
.0
cow
g
0
0
C
3 l_
x:
73 h
0 co
2Q.
"s e
co
5
zz\
73
0
o>
-i
o >
xl
co
15
23
1
C
0
o
CO
CO
A
"
S2
CO
.
CO
2 2
73 O
CO
11
E
CO
51^ 21
-a
CO
CO
0 2 to
x: 1 2
P B a
.e
xs
0
73
=
e
V-
I _>>CO
0
e q-
c=
co
73
'5
O
" =
0 CO XI
CO
CD
CL Q.
i_-
o to
co
>,
2 ^1
o
o XI XI
._
s
2
73
Q .2
as
CO
CO
Q '-a
0.
co
0 73
tn
c:
co
8-1
co
5z
i1
o
LO
o
to
^ B
CM LT.
CO
to
to
^=
t r
o co co
I ^ CM
"
CO
oj co
co
C CD
E
3
?
CD "=
d
0
>-
c C3 CO
-I
co
CD
>
CO
CD
8 II-135e
CD
2 ,co
73
x 0
I J^iz
3,
f-
co
co
o
o
to
CO
5
o w
o XI
0
>
c?5 V2
CO
co
P CO
o o
T-
LO
t-
LO
a>
<
O)
<
o_
6!3 &
c
cd
o
cd
(8
Annals
CO
g
^
co
3
of Periodontology
HI
J2
g
T-
co
Z>
CO
-52
a.
73
0
CO
CO
73
CO 73
0 o
co
IO a.
x:
<
CO
CO
jr &
io x
CD
73 73
_i -
CO
a. co
iS
s
O
CO
co
73
Q.
0
0
*>
*?
Ie
80
o 73
^0
CO
5 S
p co
CO
g
2
>
73
O
73
CO
CO
sz
lu
3
co
c
73
CD
ill
(3 Q 0
SB.
0- >
>-
1
2
c 2
S? <
o
O 0
_i 0 CO u
=
52 < e LL .
CO
CO
0
x3
0 co
<
73
d>
co
0 "O
'S
.2
CO
CO
2
3
CO
co
11e
11 b 2
e
co J2
5
10 CO
&
~
lo
x:
73
,-
*-
co
1B
o t-I
0
2 S
o
Hi
b
"
-g
co
xi
EH
O 73
co V
^ o
o. co
<o
co
x:
>
0
0 xl
>,
=
-3
<
c
.2 A
co
co x:
73
fZ
0 co
co 73
co
c
CO
.2= e
CD O
ra
>, 0
El
<3
CO
0
0
CO CD
o
if
to
oo
O
co > CO 73
0
O
co 'n
coj=e^co
-=
<=
CO
co
Q. C
0 0
8
.
*"
73
b
eg
0 0 C
0 3= .2
ten I 0 co
CD
2>i=
0 73
c:
co
LL Q.
XI
CO
CD
CD
o
.2-
fi'c 5
CO
=
co
i 1
> O)
2- 5
-
2>5 Qo .g
e
o
.2
d)
'
Q. C
CO
CO
CO
IS
.3
73
2
o
Review:
CO
CO
CD
.g
9
'co
JO
>
>>
.q
.g
'co
CO
CO
CL
CL
0_
=5 2
!fi
P
CD
"5
o
a
E
3CD
>co
o
">
|
O
c
co c
o-
CD
j=
2O
=1
CD
CD
73
t3
T3
J3> if o
S -i oo
g2<
CO
.
CO
CO
co co
CD
d "o
8 g 3CO jd>O
.2
xi
_
CD T>
q. 0
CD
o.r
X,
g-o
1 gg la
lu a.co
2 E
CO
) (0
a)
co
co "o
1S E-
ii)
_
co
>
OS CO
c
E
_o E
CO
Cl
E
to
xi
CD
CO
N
o
8 g
s
I1 Svs
o
q.
CO
CO
(I)
<N
CO Q.
TS
zs
0
73
>,
d
CO c
CO
JO
oil
2CO
*-
1 8
is
"gla.Q
2 0
Itoo
2
o
x:
lu
co
0- t
I
jo 73
-d
JMt
0
x:
0
2
co
0
[= 4=
a
d.
ZS
ll CO CO
"O
CO
ig,
0
-
x:
33
o co
0
CO CO
73
0 co
a
c
in cm
0 p
CO
o
iE s s
1=
ll
Sq.
o S
.2
a co
CO
JO
03
lu x3 13
=
-S
-8
E
CO
>,|
co
2
to
CO
CD
0
CO
'a
CO
co
S .2
E
p
0 3
p-i g II
Q
E s
= xz
CD
CL
B
0
a--a
8co 1so
>i
co o
0 -d
CO
o
CO
CD
>.
CL
"SCO Ic
I85 5
73 c
"o CO q_
CD
CO
co
TR
ffi
co 11
s
C CO o q. p
8 1CO
CO
CO
cd
0
q.
TS t3
0 c
2 5
s _ 1
a o E 5
CD
0 .hi
CL
CO CD
CO
-R
.1 E?
0 o
q. q.
co o
CD _l
s<
eCD 5E 2 2 3
o
- o
2 'S
=5 .2
CO t
SI
73 T3
CO
cr
II
I!
sl
>
II
J3
0
0
0 t3 o
T3
tj O
0 TS
-n
0
X3
co
3=
.11
-2
CO
2.
II
JD
CO
CO
E E
to
J2
o
to
CD CL
CD
...
CO
xi .!=
<o
CO
O 0 0
o 'S 3
CO
CO o
CD
C CD
CD >
q. >
X CD
Cl
m
CO
Si
CO
11
II
1o
CD
CD
o 3
0 o o
S >>
CD
CO
OL
CO
t Q
'co
a.
CD
X3
CO
<Q
0
CD
>>
'co
571
J2
!E 2
*8
CO
't
-g
o
9 S
1-
gr
If i
en z
73
|i
0
<
CD 7Z
CO xi
CD
I
.8 Si
8
lu
Si
2d
O
CO
Q. CO
0 1=
1
Iis
73
O O) "O
CD c O
0
"d
c
-5
>>
cm
CO
CO
CO
IZ
til
P
><
<
CT)
as
T-
H Q Q
< O 0- 0_
_i
Gher
572
clusal adjustment and a mean probing attachment gain of 0.02 mm. There was no
significant effect of occlusal adjustment on
the reduction of probing depth. While the
clinical attachment gain was considered statistically significant, this difference may be
of limited clinical importance to the clinician. The authors also stated that "Surprisingly, we did not find any significant
difference in reduction of tooth mobility between the adjusted and the not adjusted
groups."
In
previous
of Periodontology
COHORT OR LONGITUDINAL
STUDIES
ran-
Annals
Review:
ease
fied
mobility identi-
as a
amination
identified. After analyzing the data collected, the authors concluded that there was
no significant differences in probing depth,
clinical attachment level, or loss of alveolar
bone height when comparing teeth with and
without abnormal occlusal contacts. Teeth
with significant mobility, functional mobility, or radiographically widened periodontal
ligaments were associated with deeper probing depths, more attachment loss, and
greater bone loss. This study could not determine if tooth mobility and radiographically widened periodontal ligaments were
risk factors for the progression of Periodontitis or markers of the disease process.
Other studies have attempted to identify
"risk factors" for Periodontitis,60 62 attachment loss,63 67 bone loss,68 69 and tooth loss.70
Those factors reported as risk factors, listed
from the most commonly identified to the
least commonly identified by these studies,
included: age, race, tobacco use, increased
percent of sites with plaque, the presence of
Prevotella intermedius, Bactroides forsythus,
bleeding on probing, prior attachment loss,
probing depth, lower educational attainment,
were
gender (male), calculus, Porphyromonas gingivalis, positive BANA test, gingivitis, sociolevel, diabetes mellitus, systemic
disease, mobility, early loss of the first molar, and the lack of use of dental care. These
economic
Dental Occlusion
573
as
risk factor for Periodontitis; however, occlusal analysis and mobility measurements
were rarely included in the factors being
evaluated as risk factors.
In a series of papers on prognosis, McGuire and McGuire and Nunn reported on
their ability to accurately predict future
prognosis from commonly evaluated clinical
factors.7173 Mobility and parafunctional habits were identified as two of several "prognostic factors" that correlated with tooth
loss or with a worsening individual tooth
prognosis during a 5 to 8 year maintenance
period after treatment. In "well maintained"
patients, prognostic factors associated with
a worsening prognosis for individual teeth
included: deeper initial probing depths,
more severe furcation involvement, endodontic involvement, smoking, diabetes, malposed teeth, unsatisfactory root form, and
the presence of a parafunctional habit with
no biteguard.72 Initial tooth mobility was associated with a prognosis that was unlikely
to improve but was not associated with a
a
worsening prognosis.72
Prognostic factors associated with tooth
loss during the maintenance period included
initially greater: probing depths, furcation
involvement, mobility, and bone loss
as well
poor crown-to-root ratio, poor root form,
parafunctional habits without a bite guard,
and smoking.73 Tooth loss in this study was
due to periodontal disease, restorative purposes, endodontic involvement, and caries.
Unfortunately the authors could not associate initial prognostic factors with progressive attachment loss, the gold standard for
advancing Periodontitis. The inability to associate the prognostic factors of mobility and
parafunction with advancing attachment
loss; the inclusion of teeth lost due to nonperiodontal reasons; and the inability to
separate out other prognostic factors such
as furcation involvement, bone loss, and attachment loss inhibit our ability to draw conclusions about mobility or parafunction in
relation to progressive Periodontitis. The authors also noted that these findings relate to
well maintained patients and may not apply
when evaluating poorly maintained individuals.
as
Gher
574
diagnosed
as
Annals
of Periodontology
Review:
575
Gher
576
tory periodontal
disease.
SUMMARY
flammatory periodontal
cles reviewed clearly
Annals
of Periodontology
periodontal attachment level have been documented when occlusal adjustment was included as a component of periodontal
therapy.56 The extent to which this is clinically meaningful in the treatment of Perio-
FUTURE RESEARCH
plantitis.
Review:
GLOSSARY OF TERMS
Attachment
periodontal ligament,
brought into
contact.
inhibits the
achieving
Any
contact that
con-
tacts..
Occlusal trauma: An
as a
result of
ex-
by
apparatus.
Parafunction: abnormal
as in bruxism.
function,
support.
Secondary
REFERENCES
1. Stillman PR. The management of pyorrhea. Dent
Cosmos 1917;59:405-414.
2. Box HK. Experimental traumatogenic occlusion in
sheep. Oral Health 1935;29:9-15.
3. Leof M. Clamping and grinding habits: Their relation with severity of periodontal disease. J Am Dent
Assoc 1944;31:184-194.
4. Glickman I, Smulow JB. Alterations in the pathway
of gingival inflammation into the underlying tissues
induced by excessive occlusal forces. J Periodontol
1962;33:7-13.
1967;38:280-293.
7. Glickman I, Smulow JB. Adaptive alterations in the
periodontium of the rhesus monkey in chronic
trauma from occlusion. J Periodontol 1968;39:101-
105.
8.
Akiyoshi M, Mori K. Marginal Periodontitis A histological study of the incipient stage. J Periodontol
-
Occlusal interference:
from
577
or
perverted
1967;38:45-52.
9. Macapanpan LC, Weinmann JP. The influence of in-
jury
272.
10. Goldman HM. Gingival vascular supply in induced
occlusal traumatism. J Oral Surg 1956;9:939-941.
11. Ramfjord SP, Kohler CA. Periodontal reaction to
functional occlusal stress. J Periodontol 1959;30:
95-112.
12. Muhlemann H, Herzog H. Tooth mobility and microscopic tissue changes produced by experimental
occlusal trauma. Helv OdontolActa 1961;5:33-39.
13. Yuodelis RA, Mann WV. The prevalence and possible role of non-working contacts in periodontal disease. Periodontics 1965;3:219-223.
Gher
578
1986;13:923-927.
29. Poison AM, Kantor ME, Zander HE. Periodontal repair after reduction of inflammation. J Periodont
Res 1979;14:520-525.
30. Poison AM, Meitner SW, Zander HA. Trauma and
Annals
of Periodontology
iodontology; 1989:111/1.
1993;2:163-169.
43.
1993:163-169.
plants 1993;8:641-649.
Review:
50.
Ogata K,
66.
on
51.
52.
53.
54.
55.
56.
57.
58.
59.
60.
1992;63:297-302.
61. Locker D, Leake JL. Risk indicators and risk markers for periodontal disease experience in older
adults living independently in Ontario, Canada. J
Dent Res 1993;72:9-17.
62. Beck JD. Methods of assessing risk for Periodontitis and developing multifactorial models. J Penodontol 1994;65:468-478.
63. Kallestal C, Matsson L: Periodontal conditions in a
group of Swedish adolescents (II). Analysis of data.
J Clin Periodontol 1990; 17:609-612.
64. Beck JD, Koch GG, Rozier RG, Tudor GE. Prevalence and risk indicators for periodontal attachment loss in a population of older communitydwelling blacks and whites. J Periodontol 1990;61:
521-528.
65. Oliver RC, Brown LJ, Le H. Variations in the prevalence and extent of Periodontitis. J AmDentAssoc
1991;122:43-48.
67.
579
1991;18:117-125.
Grossi SG, Zambon JJ, HO AW, et al. Assessment
1994;65:68-78.
69. Grossi SG, Genco RJ, Machtei EE, et al. Assessment of risk for periodontal disease. II. Risk indicators for alveolar bone loss. J Periodontol 1995;66:
23-29.
70. Burt BA, Ismail AI, Morrison EC, Beltran ED. Risk
factors for tooth loss over a 28-year period. J Dent
Res 1990;69:1126-1130.
long-term
72.
73.
74.
75.
1991;11:49-57.
76. Ericsson I, Giargia M, Lindhe J, Neiderud AM. Progression of periodontal tissue destruction at
splinted/non-splinted teeth. An experimental study
in the dog. J Clin Periodontol 1993;20:693-698.
77. Neiderud A-M, Ericsson I, Lindhe J. Probing pocket
depth at mobile/nonmobile teeth. J Clin Periodontol
1992;19:754-759.
78.
Giargia M,
Ericsson I, Lindhe J, Berglindh T, Neiderud A-M. Tooth mobility and resolution of experimental Periodontitis. Am experimental study in the
dog. J Clin Periodontol 1994;21:457-464.
79. Kvinnsland S, Kristiansen AB, Kvinnsland I, Heyeraas KJ. Effect of experimental traumatic occlusion
on periodontal and pulpal blood flow. Acta Odontol
Scand 1992;50:211-219.
80. Wylie RS, Caputo AA. Fixed cantilever splints on
teeth with normal and reduced periodontal support.
J Prosthet Dent 1991;66:737-742.
81. Aydin AK, Tekkaya AE. Stresses induced by different loadings around weak abutments. J Prosthet
Dent 1992;68:879-884.
Gher
580
dentogingival junction.
JPeriodontol 1983;54:431-4.
Annals
of Periodontology