!"
#%$ '&( )
*&
&,+-&./

0.(
* &

21
34( 506
79LONQ8;PS:;R/<>TO=US?AVWPYXZ@U[PBD\]CV_E^Va`bVWGX
w"Z\]xzy|V_^{;} =~\/>B;PYJONYZ<>Gv: h} T8 NQi>N
F
H
4
G
K
I
M
J
]
F

T
c XMV_^4PSRd`bnHVeNgPYf'RboG4PShDk_PSFjfi4mMkWFjV hlp2G4RQXMq4VariMs4mMtvnju PSRQo4PYkWPYf c XMVW^PSRd`njVWNgPSfRQo4GvPYhkWPYFjf4ivmk_FjVWhlpG4RQXMqvV_rOiZsvmOt4nHu PYRboPSk_PSf
*4OMD
kWG4PKVa`gU[NQGV_UjIKRQJZPSivRQRbPP`bO`bVWVaG`bUSXRbV_ivIKXVWXXZi>Nbi4V_VW^4^PPivnjXZi|fPY4`YPY XM PSRdPi>NQ`VWM^G>PkWPmivU[RQG4XMXV_NQXMRQi4Rbi4f*`]NbNgGfi JMVWZPYVaOPSk_ff
MJMPSRQP[ka3hlPSRQRQPSPYk_VWPSm*hNbNbZi>ivNNNQOMVaPS`bUSRQP,RbV_IKUSi4VWXXi>NbG4V_h^4NbP9PYXU[kai4`QP`VWZNgjPSRdG`OivRQV_`PNbV_i4XZkWU[IKNGRb`PYN4ivV_IKk_PYi|`f`GvhNbGJPSRbP
hlivG4k_4RQIGRbivVWNbXZMUSIPi4M`GNbPM`PNbP[RdNivNQV_PSXMRV_XM`bMP[VaNK`'``gV_NQSPSP9IV_``hlVWRQXG4U[IRQPYi4NQ`bMPYPmG4GXM`PYPRb^>V_Xi>NQVWGZXV_Ud,PMi4V_UdUd
V_kWP`'ivRQXMGV_RbXMXM/PZG4iLO`N'kWG>V_jXPSRbRPYi4J`bPfi>INQPYJMNbGvP[NQOV_UHJPSPSRQRQVWRQIKG4RPYm|Xi]Nd`4PYXMNbPSRdi>i>N'NQVW^PHMUSV_kWk_Pi`bO`bVeV_`QU[PSRQRV_IKIV_i|XZfivi4NbV_k_^4`bGP
ivJMJZRbGi4UdVWNQ`MV_4MPYRdi`fIKJONbG4NbVaU*PSRQRbGRjILZUd9hi4`NbPSR
 OM//M
iviv*XXPSXZPSNQNbRdMMi>PPYNbXV_ka^4ivJMP VaPSU[UdkMkaoi4VW`QXMm`bivVeZXZNbPYMRQP`HIk_IKPYivivoGRQPH`XN]NQMik_VWPSoIKV_PSRk_GOf0JMORQkaPSPYivkMGvV_PSU[hkNbV_NQG4MXZ]Pj`D\]gG4V_V_f`QXU[NLZRQV_`JZIV_XMRbV_GXZZivnivNbMi|V_^4f4V_k_PPVeNg`USfk_Rbm>iLM;`bk_`bPYl;Ve`DNbPSMGRd`USmOi4IKG4k_hUSGOLMNQOMkaPSi>Pk;NbPVWNbXZMJMPlLOJNQ `G` m
NbivPYRQRbP V_G4`R;PY^4;PSRdiv kUSHG4OIKV_RbJPPYUkWNQ_kWV_fXMmKGRHRbPk_i4PY`bi4G4RbXZX'`HihlG4ORVWRQLZPY`bU[V_NHXMIivOJ'V_`QU[hlRbRQGV_IIV_XZV_XMivJMNbV_LM^4NQP `HRQivNbNQMGPYNbRjZNbP*Zi4USk_X9i`b`PSXMk_i4PYRQPYivk_Nb`YV_^4DP U[MkaPSi4RQ`P
NbV_`bXZVeZNQP0PSPYRQRQ IKU[`YkamOi4PYG4`QOXZ`VaVWP*i>NQG4UYPi>h;Nb`gNQV_G4PSMXMJVaUd JM`bmZLZRQG4`bUdLZZUYkWPYi4U[IV_`/XZIKUMNQGkWVWfRQMPYPSU[i4k_NbRVWk_NQXMfV_USi4LM;XZkai>lNbP XZMPS^4 PYf'R*`bXZG4i4Ok_JM^4PYXMPPYV_oim IKk_>PYi|G4mO^RQV_P`VWXZNbZPSivi4XMNK`bPYV_RQMbi4G4PkXMU[JMPGRQIG4`bMZJZG4kWPYLOLZINQk_0ivNbi`V_G4`]GXZkWi4^i4X P k
NbVaG4`bGKXZ`bPYLM`YPYP* `Nbi4ZXZivN/OIV_`QivU[NRQNbV_PYIRQ`V_XZ`bivLZNbUdV_^43P i4U[`*kai4Z`Qi4`VWXZZOPSk_RdVWXM`jivRQIKP*Vai4`bkW`bIKVWXZG`NZivi>k_NQjiZi|mfONbZ`PNbGKJZRbPYP*^|JZi4VWRbk_PSV_XMhlPS0RQRbUSPG4XZNb`bGKPSX`PSLZXM`PY`bRQPSivPYNbIV_^4P`
MpNMXZVaGvi`NbZIKZPSiGOR/` OJZVePSNdVWkP` U[VaNbP`MG4G4PYhhG4NbRQJZPYP[XRbNQPYV_^|UYRQi4G4ivVWkDLMk_V_ZXMMiKkW`f3Vahl` G4k_k_VWVWo9XZX PYNQivMVaR`QP'OVWXG4G4INb`MPYV_P0`Rb^>XNbi>ZLMNQivVWIGN/XNbPSZNQRPZGvi>XNh/LMhlhlIRbGPYRPPSR]JZIi4GvivRQhDXi4P[IfOM0ivPSNbIKIPYRQJMGO`k_OPYGvPY`h]k_`YXMmiPSPNQIMOPPYGO0O]PYNQF kzG
GvO hV_aIKSJZSPSi4XZRQ`bi4VWIKGX3P[>NbV_PY`|RQ`RQG4SLZ`bS4PSzMP4mk_fPk_VaVW`XMWm*PkWV_ivXMeR4PYmji4G|RRlVWi>X0m]NNQivIKMXZPG`]NVWN9F`GVaO`'IKV_IKoPXMPSkWG>XZG>`bV_XG4G4XRdNbO vPSi>R*N0 J`QG4ivk_IKfXZJMG4k_PIKUSV_i4G4kIKV_JMXk_P[NQOMVePNgfXLMIlMPSR
XPSk_VWNbPSZhV_``9ivJZRQPjivJNbRQPSLMRP4mHpPJZ`gi4NQLZRQi4OIKfP[PSNbIKRQVaUJMV_hRbi4VaIUSi4V_kWk__ff(Gvi4hXZJMRQG4NbZMi4PYMG4V_RQkWVaP[`gNQNQV_V_UYUivIKk_kWfGOONbPYMk_P`P[l;NbPYMXNUSNbi4G,XMPVaMUdNPYNbVeZNQMPYPS`bPR
NbU[G9GXZG4OJOVWNQNbVWV_IKG4XZV_i4SPkMk_NbVWoMPSP/k_VWgMG4GV_XGON* kW;V_o4PYkWV_MGmGOG4RGvPY^4hDPSNQXMPMNV_XMNbJMGLOIKNd`]V_XMi4VWXZIKV_SNQP/MNbPMkaP/ivuvQPSjka`SNQmRQG4i4R/VWXMMV_XMN/NQGPYRbGRQJOG4RDNbV_GIKOVWNQYi4PVWXMNbZP P

bNNbGZfVWRdNbNQZMP9RQU[PYRQ`bVWMRQNb`PSG4NKRQkaOV_G4USV_RbX"XMVW'NbPYlL;RbV_`G4V_XMX ,mivNQXZMNQG(PIi`QivivIKIKo4PGOPOJMJPSRbivkPRdOZivVaIKUNbP[V_G4NQMRbXVaN`SUi4hUYiv*U[IKG4V_^4RdV_kWOPYfXV_XMG4ihNQUSIGk_iGO`bPYO`bVeNQVePYMk_`dPSPSRRm/NQHMPPUY`ivPMU[k_NKk G4Xi4 UYU[G4G4 RdROi4NbV_XZXMZP

Va\] `V_`QI U[RQLMi VWkWIKNbV_V_XMXZ[G4ivIKX[NbVaivvkp/zm>XZNbSivMk_PYfOX,`aSVa`NbSZivP0XZUS(G4RQk_>G4RbP4`|VaJ`/NbG4VaZU9XZ>MRQVWPSXM RbZPG4*`bR`bPSV_PSXMG4OXPYi4RQivIKNbTJMV_^4V_kWIP[PmOV_\]kaVeivhV_RQ`Q;kWU[fRQmVWIK hlMGV_jXZRV_i>`/NbNQMVW ^PP'i4UYLZJZi4`Qi4`b`PVWVaRivXGvV_h`KivOXZV_G`QU[Rb;RQIP[MNQi4P k
hlV_;XMG4G RQJMILOUSNdG4`iIKVW*JZNivPSV_XZRQ`PPSi4Rdk_i>`bPSNbGXMV_^4PYHPSRQPYiv\]kWNbV_Va^4`boP0USXZRbG>V_ivIKXZ(VWXXZivONQNbZV_V_`Qi>^4U[NP*RQV_NQJZIMivV_P'V_XZRivXZNbi4rMV_VW^4m^P|Pk_ njPYi4i|RbfXZPYVW` XMU[kami4VW`QNK`bVe`bZPSPYPYRIKiv`XZXZivk_NbG4LMRdV_iv`NbkjVaUNQGRbPYhl4GORQU[PYL`Q``V_GG4XX
`bU[LZGXUd'NbV_XJZLZi4G4VWRdLZ`S`]VWXZX'JMNQLOMNQVa`d`H]JivivXZJPSRVWmNQ` jOP]VaUS`QG4U[RQXZVW`bIKV_MV_XZPSRHi>NQNbVWM^P]PXZivivXV_iv^4k_P*G4Znjmi|k_fG4PY4`Va`INbVaGOUORbPYPYk4RQlhlPYG4`QRj`V_G4G4XNb|0k_VWXMOPV_`QivU[RRQP[USNQk_iP]`bi4`bVeXZZ
PSIKUSRQivGORQNbG4V_OG4RPSXkzmOmi4Miv`]LOXZNbNZPl`bMXjG>LMIM]P*zPYi4R PYGvXMhPSZRdNQPi>RQNQi44VWVW^XMPYPXMV_XMPSIK9Rdi>GOP[NQOMVW^PSivkP*IKIIKJMi|k_GOf'PYO`*PYivk;ka`PYOGU[GGivPYIKJM`JZPYVWXZRb`*GMk_i4i4PSUdPYRbPVWNQ`i|Nb^4i4ZP`bi4fXiKINbMJMZV_Nb4PKGvMNQMPYV_V_R]U/`QU[iPSRQRQ`VWRbfIKGIKRV_XZJOIi>NbNQG4LZVWNbUd^Va PU
hNbi4`i>NbN'PYRVa`KNQZG4ivXMX'k_fNbMWP QOvVa`bUSRbOV_IKVWSXZmivNbRdV_i>^4NbP]ZPSIRKGONbOPYivkXJkWV_GXM`QP`ivV_MRmk_fV_X(VWNQNbM0PiXXLMLMIIPSPYRRHG4G4h]hJZNbRdi4ivRQV_i4XMIKVWXZP[NbPYP[RQM`Yi4IJZMkWPV_``
VZ_`bXMLMRd4`gNPSPYV_OXK`i4NQ`gIKMJMVai4kWUdPXZ`NQVaM`GPLMV_RXZUSPSPSRbXMIKPPYi4JMRQ`bivV_PYRQNbV_V_UY^4mivPjkONbIZRQPYPSGO`bRQOLMP9PYkeNdUSkM`i4ZX`iNb`RQG4ivP9XMk_RbNgPkWji4fGO`bfLMOJMi4Va`gJJMNQG4JMVWXZRbRQNgU[GNiUdRQNbMPSZPYivVWNYIKmVeNdPi4```i4NQGv`bMhfPIKJXPSJOLMRbNbhlIG4G4NbRQVaIUHPSRivPYRbXZG4RQhUSG4P4NQRDRQmi4i4NbVWXZZXM P
VaVWNQ``Nbk_G>LZH`PYMRG4i4V_`bXMfIKJOPSNQNGvNQNQPSV_RU*mZPSivRQXZRQ9G4RNQMivPXZ0`bPYOU[GGPYXZ`9VWP[XNbNbPYMRYVaUd0NbMPMV_`QU[RQVWIKV_XZi>NQVW^P IGOOPYkivJZJMRbGi4UdMP`
Mb Zg
PSP
N USG4XZ`bV_M|PSuMR S i' MV_XZPivRQNQfMPU[kai4
`Q`OVWV_IUYi>PYNbXZV_`bG4VWXGXZNdivi4k`boV_XMmJMi4LMXZN]`Ji4PSU[PVWXmZMVeNQPYRbPNbZjPPUYZi4i|`b^PPGvi4h`QM`LMV_`QIKU[RQPP[9NQPZVWMXZivi4NQRbiZf
V_kaXMivJMPSLOkaNd`D`KhlP G4R`bV_I JZkWVaU[VWNgfm4livNbXZMPk_P[NPSXMNQPYMRQPSi4RQkWPV_YivP/NbV_ijG4XgG4GV_XNHPYRbOV_VaXM`gNQ3RbV_XMMG,LONQOVWGV 'X U["LMkWG>Nb^V_PYPS`dR P[NhlNQRbMGPI GLONbMJMVaUdLM N
ini|Nbf4RdivPV_`*XMUSV_XMk_i'`b`b`bVWP[ZN PSR LZ`bPYY`! "#[NbG$ "US%#&i4 k_"%'US(*LM) kai>GvNb,hPK+AP`gNQV_VWV_Ii>PSNQMPYiv`.IK- JMk_PY` OVa*`Oi4XZRdi|X- lHM*ZGvhHPNb4MPSPXZPSJZRdRbi>GNbZV_^4ivP MV_XZk_Vei4NQVWVW^PP`
"
; " Mi4XZlMmi4`jhlG4k_k_G>`S
- l " 2  /[0 21035104356847 (*;D(*):9=E;<>(!@C=?F>AB @CB
g|
PSPYi4^`NbXZPSV_XINi>`bVWVWNQX9IKPY`NbV_k_ZGvi4P hRbk_NbNbf0ZRdivPhlG4V_XMJMGR VWRbXZ;G- ZlH iv`bZP[NVWk_Ve/[NQ[VW0Pm /`SN/mPSivRQMXZP4PSJ mMRQJP`bOP[V_NI`NQIKVWKCXZMGJ LRbO!PjUSNbG4RdLMi4uKMXU[VeNQNQG4`VWRQGNbRQXZMPYiv`bPJk_kWXGfLMXZ`IMPS`NDNbNbPSGGR*i NQGvi4hJoGOGV_XMUY`U[VWNbLMV_Nb^4RQZRbPPYP^>XZPSivU[IKk_PLM`JMPGvV_`bRbhLZVaUSi4Udi4X k
i4iK`NQ4PY`m4N]P[ZMV_Udi4'IUSJZG4kWPRQRb;P`mJNbG4MXZPZXZ`ivNbV_G^4PLZ`bnVWXZi| fPY `i4USJMk_k_ii`bU[`bPVe`bPSIKR]G G4NbM V_XMP RQG4hSTNQMP/ JMJMRQRQG4PYMivV_MU[NQV_kW` V NbV_PY`Y; ;GU USVk_i`b2`bVehlVWf h
ivXGXMkWf9VehNbZP hlG4k_kWG>V_XMJ mtWs u LivXNbVWNgf'Vau`JG`VWNbV_^4P
m?s u
u
c vwb?bxr p _ .
f
c vwb c | k he g i r p _a` f
c v~b he g8i r p _ f
c vwb _^ b
XZY\[^]M_a`\bdcfehg i _ ^_ j jlkmkmndndo,oqr p p _a_a` ` m?s u cz
u
t
m
s
u
u
y
U
?
b
x
b
p
_
c
{
U
y
b
p
a
_
`
{
c
y
U

b

p
_
{
c
Uy bM
%m n}o r
r
r
r

jXPNbXZZG>PUSii4``QP`bLMG4IKhU[PJG4XNQVWXLMG uZLZS`SZVWXZJMm;LOi4NQXZ`YmivkWPSk_IN.G- `glN] PS ^4PYRbfNQ/[M*VWXZPRbJPYivIKRdivi4IKVWXP[`NQNbPSMRQVWPYPY`bi4IiP`mZi0PSOLMUSXMPSV_JO^|N/i4RbNbVaZi>ivNQPN

Nb ZivPVL`b- `bV_`Si4mX,MOPSVaJ`gPSNQXZRbV_MLOG4NQXVWGXMVeNQ,MJZPivRdJZivi4IKRQi4PSIKNbPSP[RdNb`fPYRQ -" `" ;Div(!RQP= MivXZN9^Va -i"F IlXZi>GvONbV_PILMNbZI%ivNk_VWNQoMPSPk_VWMq- G `SGOmMmLM`bNG,XMhlG4GNR
PNb[ZMPi4INQ RQJZi4 kWVWP{XMV_XM- " ;D`(*PS=NVa`/VWNbNbMPkaivPSIKPSkJM V_RbVaUSi4/|k;IK/PYGvi4NQXPNQGvZhDi>NQNMNbPMzVa`NbIKP[U[NbGZG4GRdOV_VaXZ`i>i4NQk_P`bG/Gv PhHWi4LMkW;VW^>Nbi4ZkWPYPXP[NMNbi4G IJZGkWPRbI`/V_i4X k
k_\]lP[RQNV_PS`QU[ ivRQ"RdVW IK;DO(!k_V_PY=XZ`Qiv`XG4N]hp XZM" i4 PSkWNbfOMV`bPYV_`R/Qi4Nb`QZiv`PXZLZ IMi>V_XMNd"F i/i4MRbV_Pi44; G4 XivivLivR|k`bl`bUS V_G>i4" ^>X9 MivRQGV_Ri4XZXMPU[GvPNNbZI PivNbgRQNQV_RbUSLMPYP`YIXPNQivMXZPj``bi48P XZWLMPY^>kzm|ivjRQV_PHi4XZi4U[k_`bPG `
NbivXV_X^4'PGvJivNQXZG`bi4VekWNQNdGM`jP NbGvZOhivV_`QNXZU[i4RQP[VWl^NQ PP*i4nXZi|Kf4 P! NQ`MPV_`]A U[k_G4G40 X4"NQVaVW`XNb VaLMUMGgLZRbq PY`H4UYRQi4PYP[O`Q`bPY`JV_`YG4A mXVWN!V_`j MjV_G`]PSk_kIKboGOXMHOG>PS*kV_X'Z^4i4PYNbX9`/ZivJZiNjivNbNQRdPMiv`gIKP NOPSP[NbMV_`QPSi4U[RdIRQ`V_IJZ kWV_P*AXZviv mm

NbivZXP MGV_XM`QU[kWf9RQVWIKVehV_NbXZZi>PNQVWkW^V_XMP]PYk_i4G4RV_O`NbVa`bVaU*USRbRbV_IKPY4VWRQXZPYi4`QX`V_NjG4hlX'LZUSXZk_UiNQ`bVW`bGVWX ZPSRZ jMQSJMRQPYMV_U[NQ`Z [VWh

O l  "(*) " " 

VaI`i>JOGV_`IVWNbV_V_S^4P/PNbHMnjP*PSU[V_XMGXZ'OiVWNbOV_G4VaXZ`QU[i4RQkZVWIKk_VWoV_XZPSk_i>VWNQoVWG^GOP*KIKGGOXONbPYMkzmZP/NbNbMRdPivV_JXMivV_XMRdivIK`bP[P[NNQPS Rd`*  k_>G4UYivlX$"%#SP !M"%N/#APSVWNbZPSRmNQGG R
NbhlLMGXZIU[NbV_V_XMG4V_XIKgVWY P/;u>RbdLMj5P NbRdiv"V_XMVW4XZY5 |PSZRQRbivGka`bR P "%(*u) [ ;|ZX`G4hiv R;"%i# `;
Nb MPj PS%"RQ# RbGm4R;IK"%(*MPSPY) NbRbRQPV_UH MV_`LuvQV_`NbUSMk_iP`bV_`bXZVWOUSVaUSivivNbV_NbG4GX R
PSV_XZRQRQi>G4NQVWR^mOP9Hk_PPYi4^RbV_XMPSV_XMNbMmPNbZkai>G4NbLMNbPS,R]ivNbkWZNbPPSRQhlXZG4ivRQNbIV_^4PYPRKi4V_``i4PSk_`bV_XMGhlRQIK8P WG4LMRQP PYXNbNbRQk_LMfk_fLZ`V_XP(NbMiP`KQi `JZUSVWG4RQVeIKNdJMLOGvNdhi>ONQVaVW`bGUSXZRbivV_Ik_kWf
DP 'USVWPYXNjivJMJMRQG|OVWIivNbV_G4XNbGNQMPkai>NbNbPSRXKNbMVa`JivJPSRmjPV_kWk_i4RbPSk_fV_4XMGRbPNQMP/OV PYR
NbPSG4PYXLZRbU[RIKP*hlV_G4XMRQPSG4IKNgk_HG4i4PYkf4PSivX'mvXZi4NQV_MkWk_fOkZPY`b`bk_PYGP]`jGNg`HPYV_GkWkWf^4hlLZPYGO`bRQUSP`bLZVWNbG`MXZG4P`X0NQG4PSNbh;RQZIOP*Va`bkabUSi>kWRbNbGV_NbIK4PYVaRVW`gXNQIKV_i>UjNbP[V_RQNb^4PSZP]GRbkWPP`biv`bRQVWXMGV_XZXM/Nbi4GXZRQP[mhlPSRVeNQNb0GPY`bVeG4NQIKMPSP RmvivNQMMLG4`LMP]Gv h
U[kaVWi4X`Qiv`bk_VekWZfPYmRk_P[Nw QSPNbZPm4OhivPSIKZXMV_kWPHfKVeNdG4`;hivPSk_kZXMk_PYVWRQXMi4PkWivV_YRivU[NbkaV_i4G4`QX `VWPSZRQPYRQG4RQ`RNQIG]ivJZ0P `MhlzRbG0 INR bG Mi4XZ;Kl4 V_^4 PYX'i
6 9 ;D#d
D?  'Dt \ /
RQPS4MRQPYPYX `Q`b VWGXVa`HXM`bG4LZRUdXZivNQZV_^4i>PNHNbnMi|P]f4NgPj`GUSi4U[Xkai4`QJ`GP`Q``i4V_MRbPk_f,hi4ORG hlRQHG4PYIkWmk_VWXM`bVWPXZivUSRQP9kWf`bGvPSNQJZi4RQi4i4RbMP9k_P4kWV_m4XMXZPPSivVWRNbMU[PYkaRHi4`Qk_G4`VWZV_PY`NbRQVa`YU
Gv h/GNbLZRbMPH`YPmYJM`NQP0RbG/PGivU[VaOk_`4NQPYG4i4kWRQfVWVWXm>NbkWMXMPSIGNDXO`NbNQRQGVW ^NQVaMivkvPSV_RQRKPjPY`bNbi4LMZ`bkWPHfNQ`YIKJmG4JOVWN;JMNQGvLZVa`;NQk_ivV_IUNbV_GG4PS`gRQXN;RbGVW^XRQPSNb`9RdPY`RbV_PG4U`ghgXNQVWG4NQXZhMMNbP0ZNbG*i4Pj4U[XXMG4ivIKGV_^4`gJZNQPHV_i4U'nRbPi|kWPfNQivMPYRQ`PXMUSJVWXZk_PSiRb`bhl`bG4`bVWZP[RQNIPSNQ R VWiv>XZXZVzUSP4P
TV_IK VWka9 iv RQkWfVa`*mMk_NbP[ZN*P Xiv V_^4PKnjP i|9fNbPYZ`*PU[Jkai4G`QJM`LMVWZkai>PYNQR*VWGX0VWNb^ PSRdJZ`i4V_G4RQi4X0IGvPShNbk_PYG4RQ4`GVa`;-NbVaU] RQOPSRbP`b;`bV_G4X M\-MlP MhlGkW_G>lV_MXM
NgjGJZRbGJG`VWNbV_G4XZ`i49 RbP*NbZPSXU[GIJZkWPSNbPSk_f`NbRdivV_4NhlGRbivRd
<>P H x x
MzHZSd : >w z 8 MZZ 9 [ v< Zv 9 3G l MS> | >SSbv>zt>v[Z Q}a[OSW>>>>[>dM>vZ< t MSWS| )
9
9

D SM>ZD Z[V Dl(Oe
8
 [M WQva bvb[d>z
<>P H x x
Q
MzZ w zMzZ 9 ! V '  k_G4 ' U
: [vq Mz w zMz 9  &*Z> De|b MSb d&(ua[vK
* d>ZvZ Dd[ *& +
8
4RQfRQPYG4`QG4J`bVWGG``bPYXVWNbRbV_^VaG4`V_XXM`b'INQiv`ZNQk_i>kWivPYNNbRmPY`/Nb`ZV_NbXZi4USX3i>P NNbMZi|ivfMNIK GvJOh NQGvNQU[NQMGV_P'UYXiv^44k_PSkWPYfRQXM4mZPSPNQRd`Mi>PNQNQG0VWPY^RbPV_XORQG4XZh R5iv5V_G4^4hP'NbMZnzPi|fOPYlVa`Y`bUS9MRbV_PYIKRbMP VWVaX`-i>VaNb`V_V_^4`*PPi4NQkWM`bGVWPk_4fVaU[`gka`bNQi4MV_U`QG>`*RbGvPSX h
ivU[kak_i4k`QkW`bV_XMVeZPPYivRR JMU[VakaUdi4o4`QP`VWZPSRdf3`dXZmivVeN V_^4IPLZn`N*i|fNbPYM`YPYRbPShlG4MRQVaP`JZPRbGiJ`Gf`IKVWNbJOV_G4NbX,G4NbVai4USk_i4`bkWG_fJMXMRQG>G^jV_MG4PYRd``PiNbZZi4i4`bXVa`NQMhlG4PRk_V_XMZPYi4ivNR
4`bPSPYRQPSXMG4IPSJRd`Gi>`bNQNbVWVWG3Nb^V_G4P]X(GP0XMtNbPYM`YV_P`K i4XMVaGvONQPSMk_f,PSRM`PYNQk_iv(XMPSivk_RdVWPSh/RQNbPY`bLMi>NkeNmHOVai4`bXZUSRb,V_IKVa`VWXii>Nb`V_Nb^4RdPivV_U[4kai4Nb`Qhl`bG4VeZRQjPYRQi4`RQ3ivRQivP0JZJMPSkWVaNUSNbivPYNbRKV_G4NbX(Zi4GvX h
ivJZXMVWo `LZXMVehlGRbI USG4X^4PYRbPSXZUSPGLMXZM`NbGkWG4Va`gNQV_URQPSRbP`b`bV_G4Xm4i4XZLZ`bV_XMNQMP/hiUNHNbZivN
Zi4`]FOV_IKPSXZ`bVWGX
DZP`PU[G4XJZi4RNG4hNQMPJMRQG4JG`bVeNQVWGX0`NQivNbPY`jNQZi>NNQMP`QivIKJMk_P
U[ivGJZIKJMRbJMGkWi4PSUdO9VeNgfNbMG4PhHi4O`bVaf`bIUSRbJMV_IKNbGvVWNQXZV_ivU NbV_PY^4RbPRQG4kWRPivRQV_XM`V_XMiv>N/IKNbGZ`ivN/N]G4VaX`SmNQNbMMPPGXRQOLMPYIRGvPSqh R
DG4hP[MG4ivNbIKPNQJMZk_PYi>`*N]XMNbMPYPYPOHPGRQNQ`G N
USi`P`QivIKJMk_PU[G4IKJMk_P[OVWNgf'Va`ivka`GKk_G>HPYRGLMXZOP'f'GRQOPYR
( >
o?&Ut&Mh 8??MMt
i &?? g b tDtM~a<e eg C g ??g
t
h0 b 8qMt~h:? g P

tDUh~?t
 E <??&t:dhM Mh
Etht&
e _ e <??&twg _ hg tMe 8? g ehg8i hEte ht i it:eh?g ?i g Pth


U[GMXP^4PSJMRQVa4UPNQ`LMRbNbP0GhlNbGZRKivN*MV_G4`QhU[RQNbVWZIKPV_XZi>PYNQ`VWN*^P9k_V_XMk_PYPYi4i4RbR*XZUSVWXMk_i `b`bVaVe`PSNbRmLZi4`XZhivV_U[RbGk_f,X^4jPSRQPS4k_kePYXZLMXZU[PMPSGORdUY`gU[NQLMGRdGO`]iv0hNbPYR]MPGXPSRQNbRbZGPR

G4XZRdi4OVW^PYP RnGvhUi|f
PY`PSMU[kaivi4IK`Q`JMVWZk_PYPY`YR: N G>P i4PY4V_GX0LONVWNbPS0XMNQPYMRQivP NbhlV_^4G4Pk_kWG>k_PYivV_XMRQXMKV_XMk_PSZIKmDI`bJiMP U[VWUSi4kW_f NbMP0USi`P9GvhNbZP
= 
} S*vP u vV ]vU P "O U u U S, +  *d O x:lF MO>kWG [>^
* SvvKH *Z[
\u Mv|Z> ) l
)

DlQ 0>jWd|j
d>[t a[SbS>} O: ? ;- "
/[ 0;l
/SS ) P[>vP q4 A
/[U > 3 ;/ l "  /[S ) > ? ;- l 
lMQ>St dvZP Zx *>} O: ? - " ;D(!= " ;D(!= ) ^ - "F "F ) >
?- l/[,0;J/[S ) [v>Pq A
v / 
<> t = Yy|{ B FHGXZ`bV_OPYRNbMPOV_`QU[RQP[NQPUSi4`bP4mMi4XZ0kWPSN O!uhlG4RXMG> P[N ) vtM
hlnj/[Rd i4fUNbNQZVW;GP'XH FHG4 ZhjPSJ/[RQSXMG} `b5G VWNbV_^4 PG4mLMP[i4MXZXZi4ImjJZkWVWPPNb` Zi|JM^VWRbPk_GkZivivN*P'Zk_VWPYk_iVeNgVe`gNQfN MV_iv$XfN*+ k_PY) JiG4G`gNh`VWNb
V_l^4.PK iv) X]}m + (ZXMtDV_UdPYP[3OivJV_NbIV_t ^4/JZPtkWV_PS&PYMF) `0+ivIK?[- mJM.Nbk_PYZ `YP m
UdZMi4PYXZRbU[P P zNQZ i>N? - zl ))  /[,[;TO G9 lfNQ/[MYP9FHM PSRQXMV_`]G 3i>N/IKG4LZGXZ`gN3ivi4VWXtDmP[hlOG4JRt`b/JtP U[F VW$U+Qm //|TmV_XZNbZUSPP
Nbi>ZNPSIKRQPG`ivN RQP5t
`bxt LZ
Ud0" JMTRbGLMZiv`gZNQVeVWNQk_LOVeNQNbVWV_PXM`S"mMNbV_MX PG>^i4PSXZRdiv k_k) Ud `ivXZOP[USP*XMG4VehNQVWPYGRbXZRQ`YG4F mORHmP f`PYNbP/MP NQZc i>XMNV_NQG4) GXLZG4ivLMRdXZivXNQmMPSV_P`
)
F
)
F
GvNbLZ`VWXMV_XMKNbO,ZPu`bi4Ii4MPMi4`DRbivNLMIKIKPSGX`NN
)iK`Itxi4
kWm F K gx m4+VWNHj`bJLPY 'RNQU[LMPYRQ`DZNbi>ZNQivVWGN0X9+ NQGV_`Nbi4M`P``NQPivJMNbPYRQG4 iv Mi4V_`kWV NbNbk_V_f4PYm`Y`bmMIKivXG9
VaRQi4`PY``bi>i4LMNkeNIG>^hlGG4P `gRNNQ VeMNQ) 3P4tU[z`bG4i|XfMNQM~VWV_XUd LM0) G4VWLZtN`VaVW`XZUY`i4i4Nb`b`wPPi4+0Va`KVaGv`JMqh RQi> G>N) ^4mkWPYPi4i4XZ``b0NjV_IGivRQRQV_Oka4ivPYLMRQR V_kWXMfxLZNb`bF)ZV_[XMivmMN ivNbiMivVaV_FH` X'MK4PYV_Rb^4 XMPG `+NQMP JG4PSLMRbRbPXZNb`ZLMLZ`RQkeNZivi4Nb`bV_G4ZPYX P
ivRQ4LZLZ`YImPYXVWNbNziviXZXLMINbZPPYi4R`QGv`hZLM`QIKivIKJONQJMVWGk_PYX`NQNbZi>i>NN;Va `;" G4XMk_fKuZSWbS[> lSm4Rdi>NbZPSRNQZivXkWV_XMPYi4RYm|V_X
Dm|NbZP
JZ^>ivi4k_RQLMi4PYI`PSVWX0NbPYRQ `HGvh;NbMP g4`HPYVaXM`DPSNbRdPYi>IKNQVW^JOP]NbV_XMUSk_i`bNQ`bGVeUSPSG4RXZUSkWLZM PivNbRQMP]PYRbLZPSXMhlVeG4hlRQGPRbIKNbk_i>f'N U[Mk_G`bP/NQG[NbmMNbPYMVWP]RPSiRQ`RbfGIKRDJOGvhNbG4NbNbZVaPU
4i>hPYNQXMPSPSRRdi>NbNQZVWV_^`KPHIXivivV_X^49 fPnjPSOi|i4fIKPY`JMU[kWkaPi4`S`Qm`bVeVWZIKPYJMRYk_mvfi4VWk_XM`b G U[G4G4XZXkWf^PSKRQ4PYkW`GNbG
VWNQ`DP[Mi`ivfIKIKJMJOk_PYNb`KG4Nbi4VaUjRbP0^|i4RbkW P LZWPjLMG4VWRQhPPYMzNbG M9N i
NbXZU[ZGi4V_XVW`^^4PV_PSXRQnNQ4LMPi|VW`f4NbV_PNbG4G]`XIKiV_`MGV_V_MXZ4PSMOkPYPS RP i`USPfG4IKRQRbV_JOPk_kNQUGvNY`bNb;MVaGUDRPYGvNQRbNQkWRQfPG4NQRPYZ`G4i>NQh i4NMMNbzk_ZV_`bV_`V_IK`bG4JMIKkWV_PPYU[`;G4`bVWNQIKIKZJZi>JMi4Nk_m>PRbPPSUS*^4G4PYNbXZXG]MNQkWVeGMNQVW4G4GVaLMXZ`gNQ`/V_ULZXZRbXZPYi4O4VWPS^RQR*PYPH`Qn`V_Mi|G4f4VaX UdP ``
MzZ 9 mVWN*Ii|fivka`bG9ivJZJMRbGi4UdVWN `bV_4XMVWUSi4XNbk_f99 hi`gNQPSRivhNbPY

R Klk_G4
mRdi>NQMPSR]NbZi4X
K
[mMNQRQi4VWXMV_XMKP[Mi4IJZkWP`S
Nb]PYXMRQ` P U[Gi| Xf^GvPShDPYRQ4UY`ivPYMXZk_G>kU[PV_XMV_IK JMMIkWzV_PYiv`]oNQPY4Z`*i>VeivNNd` JMZJZJMRbRQGPYi4OUdVaVaM`]UNQP^VW0` GPSXZMRQf9`*zk_V_fo4PS Nbk_9 MfRQNbPYG0`bVaM`IG4kaivfOoV_`bXMPM9NbG>ZNbPMV_PXM`QivOIKVaNQ`bZPUSi>RbJZNV_IKRbNQPMVWOXPV_ivU[JZXNbV_i4N G4RQXZhli4LM` IXZiUPS`
NbLZV_`bG4PYX 9 Of' OPS ZXMPY ]V_X'X2PYz^4t4PY[Rb fKP[MPSi4lN IO JZkWP]9 G4XPZV_NQUdM'PU[GvGNQRb RQPYO`bJG4XZivOXZV_XMl 3OOVa `bUSRbV_IKhi4VWkWXZi4G4XXNNbhlMLMP XZU`QivNQVWIKGX P
`bO V_OP G4hYPSjRQGZVa`SmZmO9 VWNbK9ivhivXZV_RQkWfMV_499 JMRQG4VWZk_ki4IMVWivk_VWoNgP*f4mNbhMivPRj`QhlivRQG4IKI P SJMPYRQRbPYGOmVaUNbNQMVWPYGX X O 9 G lRbPY[G>mM^4PSRPSmV_XMi4`ik_G4XM`bIKi4ikW`
JPSRbNb9LM RQZi>NQVWGXG4}h O 9 lmVWk_kMivka`G PLZ`bLZivk_kWfG4XNbMP`QivIKP`VaOPG4hSPYRbGiq` O 9 l
{ =Z<>= ^ t *d ZO KlMR v6! 9 [;D>#^d SW> O ~ *9  J uM\u w
0ZJ >> ](^ ;O 9 l]

Dbu> 0
aSSbS >> } OZE>H>[ lMFS l lM" QvZ .PZ5/[ d|S
t J Z[[v.9D>* 9Q:/.e|bl M d|S9 A

"
O ~ Mz 9 !
lr
' ) k_G40

<> t = y{ B MZ4
9 U[G4RQRQPYUNQkWfUSk_i`b`bVePY`Ki RQi4XZMOZG4IKk_ f,9 UdM,GVa`b`PSXLMJMP[MJi4PSIRQJZGkWLMPXZmOMPLO N9f NbMIKPV_`QUdU[Zkai4i4XZ`Q`U[VWPZPNb`ZVWivNYN











 













"

&%

'$

,+

*)

-

.-







0/

21

+43 4365

9 

-

7278



KPY IK IKkWiG0
PYXZx`b+LMRbPGv`hNQNbZZi>GN`bmPGvVeh;NQMV_4 9JMDRbGZMivVa`HZVWVWk_XVeNgfNQLMmRQi4X'kWVWNQIKMP]JMk_JV_PYiv`RdivNbZIKivP[NHNQPSPSRd^`PSRQGvfh;GXMPG4hivRQNbPMP
VeNQ,MV_X
Nb`bPYJRbGIXZO`V_V_XMXNbNbZPSPRQI`LZV_IXHOV_XGO mZi4i4XZ`9VWXGMPS9XZWUSLP*i>NbNbZV_G4ivXNt4OV_`lqVWNb.ZVWXOK lkWGY0
Kx+
Gvhlk_NbG4MP
USG4RQ+RbPS
RQPYPSUNNDNQVWivXMX lZKNb G* PHkWG0RQ
9G4 XMx]+G4[Xm>HivXPHNbPSZOPSi4RQIKP[hlJMG4kWRQP Pl`b;PSPHMNb;ZG4ivXMNk_VWf NVeV_h`; JG9 `b `bV_MivkWPHXZhl G4RDO 9 NQG/3 PjuM USG4
Rb
O`bG NbZivN, VeN,Va`3 J
DGQ`Qu>`V_Mk_P(MNQPZi>JZzN RbGO ZivM 9V_ k_VeNglf G4hNbMVauM`*lm V_`*O PSO iUNQkWf  ZummG4ZRV_UdVWh9 Nb MPY RbPShlG4 RQPi4LMXZJO
JPSMRQP9 Go4LMPSXZf MW~` LZMivXZNQVeNgf4q VWXMNbzMP M9 PSG[Rb PYI Va`NQMP Zm]MV_UdILZ`NP`bIKi4kW*MPYX V_`
`bIKR i4 kWOV_X( GRQMPS RhlG4RK NbZ
DP0
G4WLZXZ,NQMNQPGUdZPi4XZXMU[G4PXMzNQNQZRbi>V_^N V_i4Okz /GvlNQP i ZRdivXZV_`KMG4LZIAJMJ^>PYRivRQVaivG4MLMk_XZPKMPY,MG`bf P
GvOhVa`g6NbNQZRbV_PYM`bLOP*NQ9RdVW GivXXOVa`G4I VWXO^>LZi4U[RbPVaivMk_PYf`YmOU[GXZ`VaOPYhivRk_Nbk_`MXMP PhlivGRkW_SG>PYRbVWGXZ;Z; G]9 ivV_XVWXNQLMVeNQVWGXi4GLONNbMP`QUSivk_V_XM
<>P H x x 8
*4 A
} *u ]Zg>> 9  MZ>9S0Z >Z > ,l[ v"0  > Wd z >d2vl]f Mw d|;S  db"A4Szd>vZ z tP'Z5lM
0S [dv>$ OOzbE[[5>29H[%vZK[
/ O 9 Y
d " ;D(!
j>" ;D( U] O 9 lY *d  ^
<
hlkaivPYivNbLZPSLMk`YRQmHmHPYi4`*Nb`MlGPk_G4RHP[XMk_OPY J`Q`Hi4PY`U[hlG4NbNbPYRQZ(IPiv^>k_USivkWk_fk_iLMm`bPi``Gvkaivk_hG4XM PSOki44 `jV_^4IKPl`G`VWYXONHhlG4GhRbV_INbkWMivP]NbGPV_hlG4PYX(iv NbLMi4
RQPYG`jLOivNRQPivMXPbRbJM PYRQkWgPYG4^>JivGXhl`bRdNQVei4NQ VWUGNQNQGXVWGNQXVaM`KP G4PYh/U[ika`Nbi4V_ZkW`QfP`
JMV_XRQG>NQ^4MPP'`bLMfIK`IKZivG>NbV_G4VWXMX3V_XfNbZOivNYm USG4XZlMVeNQVWGiXM` PY9 VWXG4XWLZ`Qi>i|NQfOVWGX(NbZzPtPYm^4PYMXLONNG VW Nb - m ` PYiRQUdPSJMkaG4i4hUSPYNb MPf'NQPSRQIK `d`
ZivXi`/ XMgG|XOHhlXMRQPSiUi>NQVWNbGV_^4X9PG4P[h;ONQJMPPSUINdi>NbZ9 V_i|G4^4X(P*lP[OfJPYXMUG4NdXMi>NQXMVWGPYX0ivNbV_G4^LZVWNgXZf0OPYGvh i| i|fOV_hl^4RbPYGRbI PSXZSPYUSRbPG[mivXIKG4RQPSG>^PSR
^>ivRQivRQG4XV_Ji4NMGV_`bk_XPVWNbV_GG4ORQXOPYR4NQLZGli4YRQi4G4XLMhlLMNbXPSRb PNb`*ZPSNbR'ZVaiv`KNPi4 UOk_NQi4LZRbivP|9k_ k_|f3hiv`bRk_SVWhlRbZGNQiI kW`fkaY`ivPSNbRQRQRQ4G4G PXMP[PSOVWNbRJmPYXZU[MNQivV_i>IK4NQVWPSGk_XfJMm;RQNbG4NbZMivivGNMLMV_4NQkWMVNgP0f4RQZi4ivXZNOMG4PSjRQI PP
ivRQi|Pf`PYG4^4h/PYG4RQOi4kNdivjV_XMi|9 V_fOXM`GvhiOk_GPYRbGV_`b^PVWXZKG4`bLMLX ',U[VaV_`PSX^N]VaiUSG4NbXZZMPVeNQFHVWGMXZPY`hlfG4`bR/MPYPS^XZ`bV_LMXMRQ P VWXMWLivNQk_ZVeNgi>fN ZG4Va`R`bNQIKMP0i4kWRbP`g]NXZGvP h
NbP[ZMV_i4`IOJZVakW`bPUSLZ`b`bV_G4i4X`'mkak_ivP[NKPSLZk`hlGR`bVWZIKPJMFHk_VaU[MVWPSNgf fOV_`IKZPSJM^k_V_USV_VeXMNQP kWf,WLUSivG4k_XZVeNgOfVWNbVWV_IKG4XJMk_GV_PYX`KNbNQZZP9i>NPY^4PSXRYNONQZ i>NKiNQPY` N
/ O 9 , J

ivRY O 9 b tFG>wm O 9 Va`NbMP`bLMIG4

h

9 RQi4XZOG4I
NbNb^>ZivPYi>RQV_`bNi4PNbMM
k_PYPj`RQ i4XZVW `OXMi4G4G4RbI RQPV_XMUS^>G4'ivXZRQNQMV_Mi4VePNQMVWk_GNQPYXZPS`RQivI i4k_kWRbf PVWXV_XZV_^XZOG4OPYk_PY^JJV_PYXMPYXZXZOOPSNQPSMXXNDPN4JMV_lRb^4VV_PYG4PXRd`Vem>hMlNQMG4MkaP[M`dbXZm|h]ivNQMV_`^4PSNbP'XV_k_knVeNdUSi|`;G4f4^>XZPi4M`RbVeVaNQi4ivVW`QXZG`XMUSLZPPYIVa,`JMG4NbKXV_G4^ X
Mm m
PS`Nb^V_PSkWjX0Veh;P9NbXMMGvP " N
IRQLZi4UdXZOGk_Ii4Rb^|PSi4RRbVaNQivZZivkWPX`HKj^PS
RQP*XMzivGvXZN,U[GIKIKi|JMf kWPSPSNbPY^kWPSf'X,V_XZOP9PY`bJIPYXZivOk_kWPYPYXRYNmDmOONbPYZJPPY^|XZi4ORbV_VaXMivXU[GP*XIKNbZi|fP
j`bFHVWG4MXZLMPY`kafOG4`bhMNbPPSZ^ 4P* L`DUSivV_G4XMRdRQivP8RbXWPYNbk_LZivPYi4NbPYkWV_V G4NgXZf`df VWm^ivPYRbXZ`0GJGV_RY`` OVWi>NbNjV_G4 IKX3G4`]Nhl~KGR^
C`FG
[I*P TGZKmVW*hgx/OuZ mO J f 9 Z `bP[FN
NQVWS4XZ 
}  [m!
(MZPS?i4
DRQP` m
 uV_XNbMPHGRQ`N9UYi4`bP4mivXZ %9 VWXNQMPV_XZOPYJPYXZOPYXNUSi`P"MV_`NbLZ`4V_^4P`
LNbMiZXMPRQPYG4Ii4LZkWLZXZVa`UdNbVaUhlG`NbRUSRQi4G4`bXMPZV_PSX,[RmlM^MLMVaiVaNUdNb3XMMG4PNbNbMPFHP'MNbXZPYivivRbV_XZN^45G P'VWNni|G4V_f4kWLMjPX`hlZRQi48P `QW`LMLMPYIKZXNQUJOkWNQf3(VWGPSXP9J;Rb^Pt PSivRQk_kWfKfk_MG G4Gka`bM P4`YZm;AjF<XZP
ObPSUYPivmMX3mDMG4V_X,OVaUdNdNbivZV_V_X P`
P[OVWJNbMG4V_XMX9PYX`bG4NbVaIKivk_P/kWf`bI`bIivk_ivkk_V_kDXVWNbfX PSRQ
D^>ivkXU&Nb
DM&P'
USG4m4XVaNb`HV_XLMLMXMG4VWLhlG4`RQIUSi4k_`bfKP4mGVeh LMOXZOP 9 f KZgix`
imONbPSZXZPS`bX'VWNgjfP]Nbi4k_i>`bNYG m
Zi|^P Z K Z[Xi4XfUYi4`bP4m4jP]i4k_`bGZi|^PNbZP/hlGkW_G>VWXZFHG4RQG4k_k_i4RbfNbGZPSG4RQPSIrZ
Z<>~~ } < SlM]d> zvM/t ZQvbS KM> v M>[/lM> ZU &4$t
 Z[>[vKw:O[> Zl MS [t
}lM>HS>aH[ ZS u| lSu
> [vKJ  $u Z[{ [> Mz MZ 9 U Mv DOe
-



:-

;

<

-

=+

.-

+

.-

>-

?+



-

.-

-

"A4B



CD

E

FG

CH

I+

+

"K

LK

>M
K
.M O
P-?Q"M

&M

N-

8+

P-

-

P-

SM

T-

P-

ZY

LVXW

P-

.M

P-

J+

F+

J$

P-

+

P-

P-

,-

pima (continuous)

adult (continuous)

0.5

0.5

0.45

0.45

boston (predict if > median price, continuous)

0.45
0.4

0.4
0.35

error

error

error

0.4

0.35

0.35

0.3

0.3
0.3

0.25

0.25

0.25
0

20

40

0.2
0

60

optdigits (0s and 1s, continuous)

10

20

0.2
0

30

optdigits (2s and 3s, continuous)

0.3

0.4

0
0

0.2

0.3

0.1

50

100
m

150

0.2

0
0

200

50

liver disorders (continuous)

100
m

150

0.1
0

200

0.7

0.45

0.6

0.4

0.5

0.35
0

20

40

60

0.35

0.4

0.3

0.3

0.25
0

promoters (discrete)

20

40

60
m

80

100

0.4

0.5

0.4

0.45

60

80

100

100

200
m

300

400

0.4

error

0.3

0.2

0.35

0.2

0.1

20

40

60

80

100

0.1
0

lenses (predict hard vs. soft, discrete)

0.3

50

100

150

0.25
0

0.4

0.6

0.3

error

10

15

20

25

0
0

300

0.1

0.2

200

0.2

0.4

0.2

error

0.4

error

0.8

0.3

100

voting records (discrete)

sick (discrete)

0.5

0.1
0

breast cancer (discrete)

0.5

error

error

0.3

0
0

0.2
0

120

lymphography (discrete)

0.5

40

error

error

error

0.45

0.4

20

adult (discrete)

sonar (continuous)
0.5

0.5

60

error

0.3

error

0.5

error

0.4

0.1

40

ionosphere (continuous)

0.4

0.2

20

50

100

150

0
0

20

40
m

60

80

QNbRRdPSVWivJV_GLMX`bRQ|VeP0NQNbG4PY`RQNf4z`JZPYkW`bV kWNQLMG4`dkWNQNQ`K`\*ivG4RQh]i4P9`bMG49PYh]0PSk_PSJVWXMXZPSPYP*RQRQV_VaIi4`kWV_PYk_YXG4ivNQNb` V_V_`G4NbG4X,VaXU*PYRbMRbPYivRQ4G4NQRQiRPY``Q^OPS`NQ`SV_`]G4XChlRb+G`bIAG4k_i|V_9NQ^4MPYkWP RQV_XMi4c P4PFHVa3` XZG> i4^4VWPSi4^R0UdP*MYnV_uXMi|u4P f4uP `SRQPi4ivXZRQXMOG4V_XMI

[%

Q HH:Dd]:+ lk_G40
8
OG9G4NbVWPKXZMNQPSZPYi>NMNQMG4P'kaJMV_RQXPS^NQV_MG4PLZ`UYi4M`bV_P`QU[NbLZ`Qi>`bN/VWGNQXMPV_IKXZJMivkWV_V_^4PYP`njNbZi|ivfNPY`NbMzivPXZJMRbPU[RQGG4XZJOGVW`bNbVeV_NQG4VWXZG`XG4 hH `QNQ/Mi4P0`QFH`LZGIRbGJMkWNbaivV_G4RQXf
Mi4GXZk_M`Ym`V_hlIKG4RKVWkaivivRQXk_ff3hlU[G4G4RXNQ`gMNdivPXN G4LM XZM`bGPYk_G4XMivR^iO`
Va`lkaivRQ4UYPi4PY`bP4XMmMG4LZ4VWNb30NbNbZi>PNIK G4RQP*RQP[PYO`JNbRQtVaUNbKV_^4 P*F
b
Kgx O *F8
bMVa`Hi4k_`bGIKPYi4XZ`DNQZi>NjPSVWNbM9 PY RHG4hNQMPY`bPlNbMP]k_ivNNQPSRHi4k_`bGRQ8P WLMV_RbV_XM (u
Va`i`L 'USVWPYXNUSG4XZOVWNbV_G4X0hlGRNbMPi`fIKJONbG4NbVaU `bi4IJZkWPU[GIKJMkWPSOVeNgfNQGP KkWG
[
M
NbU[VakaUMi4`QP]RQ`bPSRbVeZPPYRb`LMPRH`bkWINQ`b`VWGi|GvXfhivivNQkaMk_`b4P]GGJZRbU[VWRbGNbPYZX^I^4V_PSG4RQLZ4`iP``bIKPYiUGNQRbkWVWG>GP
jXWPSLZVWRIKV_UdiJMo`k_k_fffIKNbNQZGJOivNbVWNjG4NQ` NbPYVa^4UMPYPSXKVWRQRbNbMGMPSRYGRmHLMNQ4i4M`bP'fNQIKMPSP]JOXMNQMPYGvV_RQNQ`QivV_U[U/NbRQV_VW^4PSIKRQPRbV_GXZXZRYi>ivNQV_^4VW^P'PnLZk_G4`Si|4mOf4VaiP```
NbnZi|P]f4XP`jLMINbGV_PYXMRjVWNbG4Vahivk_NbkWRdfivV_OXMG'V_XMP[PSNbONbPYi4RYIKmJMMkWLOPN]` hl+G4R/VaO`VaV_`QXZU[USRQRbVWIKPi4V_`bXZPYi>NQmVW^G4PXMP*kWGj4VaG4`gLMNQV_kaU RQP[PSOJRbPYPU[`bNj`bV_G4X9PSXMNbPYG'RQivPYNb^4V_^4PSXPNQXZLZi4ivVWk_^kWf P
US;ivGNQUdNQ0PY`LMNjJ0NQMNbPYG`bmZP ivJMXZRQPYOWVaLMUVWNQNbVWPGXZk_VW`SomPSjk_f'P G>J^4PYPYRRhlNdGivRbo4IKPPYm4NQMP[POJJPSPSRQRbVWhlIKG4RQPSIKXNdi4`HXZGU[P XG4|h;XZMi4ivVW^NQiP `nPSNQi|`Yfm PY`YVWNbU[GXNQVWXM
LMGMLZP`RQVWPYXZ`bJMLMLOkeNdNQ``YGvmhsNbMPVWNb`PP[OOVa`bJUSPSRbRQPSVWNbIKP PYV_XXMNdJM`DLOivNdRQ`SPjmOhl`bRQMG4G>I XNbMVWXKP c VWFHLM RQ P*iUd M V_XMPjP Z XZPYi4RbNbXZVWi>XMNNbRQMPSPJNQGM`bPSVeNQGG4RbRQPSf4NbVaFUSi4k
JMRQPSRQ4PYRQOPYVa`QU`bNQVWVWGGXXZ``i4JRbPSP RbhlG4G4RQIRQXMivPXZG4USLOPN/OVa`bLMRQXMJMG4RQN;V_`bUSVWivXZNQ4Udk_f'LMHJPYkWNQGNQZMi>PYNRbGvPhMi4XZRbi4PVW^iPhlnjPYi|fPYUY`Yi4mY`bZPY`LONV_XNQMV_`;MVaV_`UdGZk_G4`PYRbV_`^NbPYVa U
JMPSXZRQVWG4ILMi4RbV_kWhlf9GRVWXLZ`jJZivNbRbGNbVaGU[ZLM`bkaPSivRQRQ^4k_f9P]`bNbIKMPi4kWPSMJi>PYNdU[i4NbP`bP[Nd`OG4V_XIKV_XZMivV_XZUdUSP + GvhJMkWGRQPY4`bVa`gLMNQIV_U*ivRQMPSk_4fRQPYUS`Qiv`bXZVWGXMX'GvN/VWX0RbNQG>MPk_kai4ivRbRQ4PP
+Ak_VWIKVWNY
/g
DhlRQG4X tji4k_`bGivXZi4kWfYPY kWG4Va`gNQV_UKRQPSRbP`b`bV_G4Xi4XZ3GRbIivkH\/Va`bUSRbV_IKVWXivXNpXZi4kWfO`bV_`hlG4R
U[`bkWGV_X4NbV_NbXk_f9LZG4LZ|`v VWXZ>JMvLOtNQ`dNbV_mHIKivPYXZ`dD(k_PYU[`QG4`X`gU[Ndk_LZi>NQOV_PY`NbVaUSNbi4ZkW_ivfNP<NQ MPUSVWPYhlGXRbNYIKDPYRMVa`i4Va``V_G4XXMIKk_f,i4i4Rbo`bfPYKIU[JMGNbXGvNQNbV_RdUYi4iv`k_NkWf NQG^4G4PYLZRbf R
RQiPYO`bLMVaivkeNd`SG4mvXZi4i4XZkZU[G>G^>XMivPHRQoVaivPSXZfUSOPHV IPYi>RbNQPYRbXZVW0U[PjzVai4``NQHZi>PNOmvVaRQZiv[Nbm MPYRhlRbNQGZXKivXUSG4i4XZ`Q`b`VaLZOIPSRQV_PYXM NbZP/US iM`PVa`D MPYivRbLZP `Q`bV_i4X MVeNQV_ `
IKU[G>GO^>Oi4RbPSVak_ivPYXZUSi4P`IK ivi4NbLZRQVe`QK`VaVaiv`X0`bVWXMVeNQLMkaiviRhlVWLMhkWH;P/U[G4ZXi|^>^4ivPRQVahlivPYXZHUSPYP]RINQZi>ivNQXRbVWk_VWXZDPYivX0RHNbVWMX Va`
`bNQP[RQNi4NQVWVWXZXZVWZXMmONQMPSMPivPYIK`NbJMV_Ik_PYi>`YmNbP`bG
VWk_NG44V_Va``NbXZVaG'U9`RQLMPSRQJMRbPRQV_`b`b`bP*V_G4NbXZivZN/PSRQP4GRbIp ivk;`bPY\/USVaG4`bXZUSRbV_IKV_IKVWXJivGXRNNdivpXXZNi4OkWfOV`bV_PY`RbPYUYXZivXMU[PXZGvVaN`KkWNbPivi>RQXNIhlLZRbGUd0XhUSi4G4`XZNbPY`bRV_MNbPSZRQi4PYX
G4U[GXZIKkWfJZNbivMRQPV_`bG4`bXJPYVaU[`VaivXMkHG4USNi4^4`bPKPYRbVWfXLZ`ZPShlV_LMUdkjVWNbX3ZPNQMP'l4PY XMMPS RdVaiv` kHNbUSRQi4LM`bk_P4f3m `bVWXZi4LZUSP`Q`NbVaivZXP'0G4TXMLZk_f UdJGiv`bX,`bVWZi`kWPfIKUSG4JOXZNbG4USkWNbLMVaU
V_`bXX,VWGNQXPSU[RQGmZPYXVW`hqNbNbRdV_MXMi4z3`ZNYmgNgij9 ` GvHRbP'PY4`QV_Mi|IKzPYJMRb PYPS9 ^ ZVWGi|^LZmV_`V_G4`k_f4RNbm;ZVa`VeivNG4N/V_Z`kWG`bPSV_4X3RQVa^4`gNbNQPZV_UP' RbXMPY4G4RQXMPY`Qi``V_fG4IKX9JOV_`/NbG4NbNbMVaPUK`USLMi4J`bPKPSRQNbV_G4R/i>Ni4kWNbZG4P'RQVeIKNQMGI`N
JZi4RdRi4NQU[V_NbUSVaLMUSk_i4i4kM RU[kWkaGi44`Q `Va:`gVWdNQV_tUSU*Miv!NbRQV_PS G44XRQPY?iv`QhEk_`b4tVW:GGMXRbVWNbUSZi4IKX9t`G4htNbPSPSXMXdPYtRQi4P kW_fVWtIK&V_tXJMh^4RQ G>G4^4k_^4MPPh'?:`bLMG4J?IK?G4 PXhlGV_DX9RbtIJZ:RQ?Gvi!hU NbRbVaPYU[4P &LMtkahivfRQ:V_NQYxPYi>tUdPNQMVW GXMXZV WMLM:PYVWX `


SM

SM

]^_

a`

Ld

Fe

,e

!e

,Q

ji
lk
hi
on
M h?&fhtg g tjp< g xt5 g * g tMd J g m ?&th iUg g eh te ?t&t gg g e tq g 5th5 g E.n8g e
hMMtC g ,U<A<?& m M&t0:&:?t< g A<hqpDt&E,? e t m &tA< g ?srE: g tt:h i
< 8E ChiM< e g 8A e 8?$~tMd?A8hh i ?&<<~ g xt5 g E.n8 e :wht m &t* e g
t:?e e g u
dM:::?tD }|tM~8? M< ?:DA8 M<A8?t: Etht t:??
 ~ :C g g Mht Evxtwzhy
{ &t g & m :: t08 g g ??eh e ?:eDA<th i e e <::|
tehhg *i ?&?th ii m 0?g :
8
 t8 & h: ~ 8??&A8 % t: a hC tM&? tUt: ?t:
<t:th e j n &e A i :g g n&wtM
e ?:<ADt i g &et e <g : b wM~_ h e &g :xA<t g g g } g g t e
h?&thh<5 ?h
M?t _ EA8DA b ?th
~ g MMh
i ? :g tM i8g e,g tM
n8<t8M:<?t ie :M?e Mtg hs

n&?th M8 8l n,

:
g
g
e
g
m
X\cXy

_V`bUSX'LZi4X9UdNbZP]iP `;`b^PS`bJZVWMPYi4RQHVWRQXMPi4o9MV_kWXMiP]`jUSNQi4UdM`bPP4ivmXMJZG4ivRjVWRdXMiv^>IKivRQNbPSVWZGNbP*PSLZRd`DIK`hl^GOGVaORbi/IPYi4k`HX hivGvIKh) i|V_kW^U[fPSGmORdXZMiv`G>4NbHV_RdXMivPYV_^4X;PYNTRYm|mLZVWIKivUdXZ'J0GRQPS`bi4VW`XMLM `bkaivLZiRQUdVWIi>i4NbNbMRbV_G4PYf9VWXXNQivUSPYRQG4UdP*XZMk_`XMi4NbVZRbRdWivLMPSV_XPYk_f `N

G4U[k_RbPYNbi4ZRG44UYGi4XZ`bPYiv`kNQG4G'h]NQ*MPSPXMi4PYXZRQivivNbk_V_fO^4`PSVa`\]V_XV_`QU[NbRQMV_VaI`]V_JZXZivivJNbV_PS^4RPmZIKMGOVaOUdPSkjVaJZ`ivZV_RQiVW`XMP`SG4XnHPSf3MivOIKPY^4VWPSXZk_VWG4XMJZVWXMJZivRbiNbVaU[U[LMk_PYkai4ivRbRQPYk_f R
LMivJZXZJMMRbPSGRd`gi4NdUdivMXZPO`V_ivXMRQ3PGvIh*GNb`gZNP`bLZU[UYG4U[XPYO`Q`VeNQhlLMVWGkzXZm`KHP]LMXZ`MMGPSLMR'kaMVaPUdP[JMNbNbLMPSRQRjPiv4MPSk_XZPPSNbRdGi>NbMV_PY^4`bPVWivXXfMMRQV_`QVaU[RQUSVWIKk_iV_`bXZ`bi>VWZNQPSVW^RdP`
NbVWXi>Nivk_PSkWfXvm4gG>fMNbV_kWMP/PG4LMPYR`ONVaJM`QU[RQLZG4`QJ`PSV_G4RbNbXKV_PYZ`iG4`h;hlGOPSVWU[NbLZZ`bPSPYR/iGU[XRQGX`Qiv`HV_i^4PnVaOi|PSf4RPY`DRdivi4XZXZ4P*kWGGvh4VaUS`gG4NQV_XZUMRQVeNQPSVWGRbXZP`S`b`bV_G4Xm|VWNV_`
`ONbVaRd`bivUSRbV_4V_IKNVWhlXGi>RbNbV_^4ivP RdJZNQi4G/VWRdPS`4NQPYPSXMXZPSRdNbi>MNQPYPj9ivXZi4fkWfOLZ`b`bPYVW`XZ'NQG]i`bPSZ^4PYPRQi4kv`gGvNQNQRbMLZPSU[RNbLMIKRQP4GOmZOPSkaG`SLMm|XZV_XZOU[Pk_LZOhi4V_XMXO]VW4XPSnXZPSi|Rdf4i>PNb`V_Va^4ivPSX
XMPSNgHGRboIKGOOPSkhlG4R l M GvhMV_UdXZi4VW^P*ni|fPY`jV_`/i`bJPYU[VaivkUYi4`bP[
7 y 8?~=:;$E ,=8
VaPU[RQNbGZ`bi4GvXMhNo3pPYXZ`bPYOi4RQRQPSUd 'hlPSk_U|kWFjG>ivk_`bkWMLMV_I JDhlG4RMV_M`PSjk_JOG4hlRQLMoKkjjU[G4iX`^ivPSkaRd``bGivNb`V_LMG4JZXZJ`YGRNQpPY9f'Vai`4`bRdLMivJMXJNjG4hlRbRbNbGPI Xf NbPSi k
FHG4RQJG4Rdi>NbV_G4Xm*TO,RQi4XNjbTqq 4vrtOmivXZ * c /u4uuMYrvu4u>d[u4s
C dM
5t < } <? &?
t,8
8

,e

%

x`6`

$ F%

 
F
aF
s,
}C:0,6
PssqL0
t i wwg ln t?h Ct:?: e yo
x
C h:h:M hEth~t t&??  Dt t ?th8x e
t j{
?h: sg s:
g ,6J'<
zg 0e.g8i :SJi
ojq g vx g o yo g 5 g e
}q
e M& i <&

8&?tJ Mh tMUwMh:M? * &:M e 8??:w<A<&
t { ttk&g 
t e 5
t:L:g
C
i 6s8 yosyzxy:ayz g yog x g
 M
o $< e <?
hh:q6''a q!6.PS
:'0P
{ e
t {
~

m*g
yo

jhMEt:h<

~<Et8 h?&th<tln}n:<hM tDtn <tMh s|o:

t { 0,':6S

aPg azo

a:Cqo}g

:FeqC,i .C0s8< :
i
a
CC|dt:?: yo 5
j
x M <l ~ 6.P
:0s!6
< g 8
{ e 
t {
5g : yo
tyh{