Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Migratory Neural Crest (Ectomesenchyme) Remnants Showing Ganglionic, Schwannian, Melanocytic and Rhabdornyoblastic Dzjerent Iat Ion
Migratory Neural Crest (Ectomesenchyme) Remnants Showing Ganglionic, Schwannian, Melanocytic and Rhabdornyoblastic Dzjerent Iat Ion
Migratory Neural Crest (Ectomesenchyme) Remnants Showing Ganglionic, Schwannian, Melanocytic and Rhabdornyoblastic Dzjerent Iat Ion
A case is reported in which a tumor containing elements of mature and immature ganglioneuroma, Schwannoma, clusters of apparently benign melanocytes
and embryonal rhabdomyosarcoma presented as a right-sided facial mass in a
six-month-old child. Different elements of the tumor were intimately intermingled without distinct borders. Embryogenesis of the tumor, which is
thought to arise from remnants of migratory neural crest cells (ectomesenchyme), showing multidirectional phenotypic expression is discussed. It was
felt that the lesion contributed additional evidence in support of pluripotentiality of the migratory neural crest derivatives, and their susceptibility to
mutagenic and oncogenic influences.
12,1B930931*37947
7931
were no enlarged lymph nodes present. Open incisional biopsy was performed and interpreted as embryonal rhabdomyosarcoma. Laboratory data, including liver function studies, liver and bone scans
and chest x-rays were normal. Facial films revealed
erosion of the right zygomatic -arch.
In late ~January 1975, an incomplete excision of
the tumor was performed. Following the debulking
procedure, the patient received 4,500 rads to the right
face over five weeks. At the same time, she was started
on triple chemotherapy consisting of vincristine, actinomycin D, and Cytoxan.
In September 1975, eight months later, residual
mass with possible enlargement was noted. For this
reason, repeat excision was performed as a second
2486
ECTOMESENCHYMOMA
Karcioglu, Someren and Mathes
No. 6
PATHOLOGY
Gross
Initial biopsy material consisted of three,
small, grayish-white tissue fragments measuring
F I G . 2. Embryonal
rhabdomyoblasts
and
ganglion cells of varying
maturity
scattered
among spindle nerve
sheath elements. (H & E
X 126.)
2487
Microscopic
All tissues were fixed in 10% formalin and
then processed in the usual manner. Sections
were stained with hemotoxylin and eosin, Massons trichrome, PTAH, Wilders reticulin, cresyl violet, luxol fast blue and Bodian techniques,
and Fontana stain for melanin.
Review of the initial biopsy material revealed
intermingling of embryonal rhabdomosarcomatous and immature ganglioneuromatous elements. Ganglion cells displaying various degrees
of maturity were intimately mixed with undifferentiated and poorly differentiated small spindle
2488
CANCERJUne
Vol. 39
1977
FIG.3. Higher magnification showing the rhabdomyoblasts and ganglion cells of varying
maturity. Contiguity of
different cell types of the
tumor are clearly seen.
(H & E, X 320.)
FIG. 4. Round (A, above), tapered (B), and cross striated (C), embryonal rhabdomyoblasts seen in
different portions of the tumor. (H & E, X 2120.)
2490
CANCER
June 1977
VOl. 39
FIG.5. Ganglion cells surrounded by groups of spindle shaped Schwann cell elements. (H & E X 663.)
shaped cells, and ovoid to round rhabdomyoblasts bearing dense hypereosinophilic cytoplasm and small dense nuclei (Figs. 2,3). In
addition to the striking intimate admixture of
different cell types, transitional cell forms were
also identified. Embryonal rhabdomyoblasts
showed varying degrees of differentiation including round or globoid, granular, tapered or
tadpole, bipolar and cross striated forms and
rare non-striated large strap-like cells (Figs.
4A,B,C.; Fig. 7) All rhabdomyoblasts showed
bright red staining cytoplasms with Massons
trichrome stain, and cytoplasmic cross striations, when present, were easily demonstrable in
H&E, Massons trichrome and PTAH stains.
Ganglion cells were also of varying maturity,
round or oval, with vesicular, often excentric
nucleus and prominent nucleolus and with
abundant eosinophilic cytoplasm containing
Nissl substance (Figs. 5, 7). Scattered multi or
binucleated ganglion cells were also seen. Cresyl
violet stains further emphasized the well demarcated Nissl substance in many of the ganglion
cells (Fig. 6A). The lesion showed areas of necrosis.
The material removed during the first attempt
to excision revealed essentially similar histopathology. It was highly cellular. Embryonal rhabdomyoblasts and ganglion cells of varying maturity were scattered among waves of spindle
elements of what appear to be nerve sheath origin, and undifferentiated small dark cells (Fig.
7). Wilders reticulin stain showed fine reticulin
network and Massons trichrome stain revealed
absence of collagen fibers in this portion of the
specimen. Mitoses were scattered throughout.
The final surgical specimen revealed rather
different and somewhat variable histopathologic
picture. Major portion of this specimen consisted of areas of mature and focally immature
ganglioneuroma showing Schwann cell cords,
arranged in interlacing fascicles. The fascicles in
FIG. 6, (A, top) Well demarcated Nissl substance of the mature ganglion cells of the tumor. (Cresyl
violet X 1061), (B, bottom) Individual ganglion cells with emerging axons. (Bodian stain X 1061.)
2492
C A N C E R J1977
U~~
VOl. 39
FIG. 7. A strap shaped cross striated embryonal rhabdomyoblast and neoplastic ganglion cells among
spindle shaped Schwann cells of the tumor. (H & E X 2120.)
DISCUSSION
Rhabdomyosarcoma occurring as a component of primary neural tumors is rare but
ECTOMESENCHYMOMA
Karcioglu, Someren and Mathes
No. 6
2493
FIG. 8. An area of tumor showing neoplastic ganglion cells surrounded by fine neurofibrils, groups of
melanocytes and spindle nerve sheath elements. (H & E, X 265.)
''
'sZ4
2494
CANCER
June 1977
Vol. 39
No. 6
ECTOMESENCHYMOMA
Karcioglu, Someren and Mathes
1691691*~20941~42
2495
trensic stimuli in order to express the odontoblastic and skeletal phenotypes. The trunk crest
on the other hand seems to lack this competence
to respond to the appropriate developmental
stimuli to produce skeletal elements. 20*41
Most of the embryologic experiments which
provided the above data on potentialities of
neural crest, however, have been carried out in
lower vertebrates, and there seems to be no direct evidence that the ectomesenchyme exists in
humans. One line of supportive evidence would
be the identification of ectomesenchymal tumors
in man. O n the basis of existing embryologic
evidence, it is quite reasonable to postulate that
the tumor reported here originated from the
remnants of migratory neural crest derivatives
(ectomesenchyme). It is not surprising to see the
coexistence of ganglion cells, Schwann cells, pigment cells and rhabdomyoblasts in a single tumor mass, as all these components, including
mesenchyme, are neural crest phenotypes (Fig.
10). We are in agreement with Holiman, et al.
and Naka et al. that their cases, as well as the
case which is being reported here, offer direct
support for the concept that estomesenchyme
exists in human embryo. 10*91
We know from the experimental studies that
the neural crest cells are initially developmentally labile and become progressively restricted
during their development. We do not know,
however, when and under what conditions stabile and determinable changes occur in an individual crest cell, and what the role of environment is in affecting the course of cellular
differentiation. The general feeling is that only if
sister subclones originally derived from neural
crest can be made to express different crest phenotypes under different culture conditions, the
direct evidence for the multipotentiality of crest
cells and specific role of the environment in promoting phenotypic expressions will be at
hand.
We feel that the group of tumors under discussion that contain different neural crest phenotypes including mesenchymal derivatives, in
various combination, all arise from the remnants
of migratory neural crest cells and therefore are
ectomesenchymal in origin. Their occurrence at
various locations in the body and at different age
groups emphasizes the far flung distribution of
these migratory neural crest elements throughout the body, and their latent multipotentiality
which, under certain conditions, might give rise
to tumors with unusual multidirectional phenotypic expression.
2496
CANCER
June 1977
Vol. 39
REFERENCES
1. Bednar, B.: Storiform neurofibromas of the skin, pigmented and non-pigmented. Cancer 10368-376, 1957.
2. Bofin, P. T., and Ebels, E. : A case of medullomyoblastoma. Acta Neuropathol. 2:309-311, 1963.
3. Bolande, R. P.: The neurocristopathies. ffurn. Paihol.
5:409-429, 1974.
4. Boyd, J. D.: lhe embryology and comparative anatomy of the melanocyte. I n Progress in the Biological Sciences
in Relation to Dermatology. London, Cambridge University
Press, 1960; pp. 3-14,
5. Rrizzie, K. K.:Histogenesis of the supporting tissues in
the spinal and sympathetic trunk ganglia in the chick. 3.
ihrnp. ~%Ur0l. 91 :129, 1937.
6. Cowell, L. A., and Weston, J. A. : An analysis of melanogenesis in cultured chick embryo spinal ganglia. Dev. B i d .
22:670, 1970.
7. DAgostino, A. N., Soule, E. H., and .Miller, R. H.:
Sarcomas of the peripheral nerves and somatic soft tissues
associated with multiple neurofibromatosis. Cancer
16:1015-1027, 1963.
8. Dick, J. C., Ritchie, G. M., and Thompson, H.: Histological differentiation between pheochromocytoma and
melanoma of the suprarenal gland. J . Clin. Pathol. 8:89-95,
1955.
9. DuShane, G. P. : The development of pigment cells in
vertebrates. Special Ab.Acad. Sci. 4:1-14, 194R
10. Ewing, J . : Neoplastic Diseases. Philadelphia, W. B.
Sanders Co., 1919; 213.
11. Fu, Yao-Shi, Kaye, G. I . , and Lattes, R . : Primary
malignant melanocytic tumors of sympathetic ganglia with
ultrastructural study of one. Cancer 36:2029-2041, 1975.
12. Goldman, R. L.: Gliomyosarcoma of the cerebrum;
report of a unique case, Am. J . Clin. Pathol. 52:741-744, 1969,
13. Hamilton, W. J., and Massman, H. W.: Human embryology. The Williams and Wilkins Co., 1972, p. 446.
14. Harkin, .I. C., and Heed, I<. J : Tumors of the peripheral nervous system. I n Atlas of Tumor Pathology, Fasc.
3. Washington, 11.C.. Armed Forces Institute of Pathology,
1969, p. 124.
IS. Harrison, R. G . :Die Neurolleiste. Ana!. An<. 85:4-30,
1937.
16. Harrison, K. G . : Neuroblast versus sheath cell in the
dcveloprnent of peripheral nerves. ,7. Comp. h u r o l . 37:123194, 1924, 1925.
17. tlarvey, S., and Burr, H.: Ilevelopment of the meninges. Arch. .Wewid. f y h i n t r . 15:545-567, 1926.
18. Holtfelter, ,I.: Mesrnchyme and epithelia in inductive
and morphogenetic processes. frt Epithelial-hIesrnchymal
Interaction. K. Fleischmaycr and K E. Billingham, Eds.
Baltimore, Williams and Wilkins Co., 1968, pp. 1-30.
19. Holiman, .J. L., and Kosenblum, W. I.: Gangliorhabdomyosarcoma-a
tumor of ectomesenchyme. 3.
.V~urusurg. 34:417-422, 1971.
20. Hdrstadius, S. 0 . :The Neural Crest. Its Properties
amd Derivatives in the Light of Experimental Kesearch.
New York, Hafner Publishing Co., 1969.
21. Ingraham, F. D., and Bailey, 0.T.: Cystic teratomas
and teratoid tumors of the central nervous system in infancy
and children. .7. Xeurosurg 3 5 1 1-532, 1946.
22. Kellert, E., and Woodruff, R.: Pigmented ganglionic
tumor of the thorax. ~:onCer9:300-305, 1957.
23. Kernohan, J. W., and Uihlein, A.: Sarcomas of the
Brain. Springfield, Ill., Charles C Thomas, 1962; pp 44-62.
24. Kniseley, K. M., and Baggenstoss, A. E.: Primary
melanoma of the adrenal gland. Arch. Pathol. 42345-349,
1946.