Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Art of Grammar
The Art of Grammar
~rr^^c^-.^^t^
THE
GKAMMAR
DIONYSIOS THRAX
Translated from the Greek by
THOMAS DAVIDSON
{Reprinted
from
the
ST. LOUIS,
prhis famous little pamphlot. the first attempt at a systematic tiraminar made
the Western World, and for many ofoneratiuns a text-hook in the schools of
the Roman Empire, appears, 1 believe, now for the first time in Eno^jish. I'rett
nearly all that we know about the person of Dionysios is what we are told by
Suidas, who says:
"Dionysios the Alexandr'an. called the Thrncian from [the native country of]
his father Teros, was a disciple of Aristarchos, and a grammarian. He was a
public professor Qaooiartrnn-) in Rome in the time of Pompey the Great, and
vas preceptor to Tyramiion the Elder,
lie composed a very large numb-'r
of grammatical works, as well as set treatises and commentaries." Cf. Max
Miiller, Lectures on the Science of Language, 1st Ser., p. 1)0 (English ed.j; Lentz,
Herodiani Techuici ReliquicB, Prasf. [. clxvi.; Steinthal, Gesch. der Spruchw. bei
den Griechen und Roinern^ ]>p. 478, 568 sqq.
The Grammar of Dionysio< was first printed (I believe, though Lersch sa\s
''
zuletzt abgedruckt") in 1816. in linmanuel Bekker's Anecdota Grceca (pp. G2'Jfi43) along with the scholia of Cha'roboskos, Diomedes, Melampous, Porphyry,
and Stephanos (pp. <)47-!37'2).'riie genuineness and authenticityof the work have
been impugned, but have been defended by Lersch. Die Sprachphilosophie dnAlten. Pi. 11. pp. 64 sqq.. and are now i,''enerallj^ admitted. Cf. K. E. A. Schnn'dt,
Beitrlige zur Ge-schichte dev Gramniatik dea Gr. und des Lat., pp. i<l, 189. 21(), 519.
'J'o my very liteial translation I have added a few explanatory notes which
seemed necessary, and a number of references for the convenience of persons who
may wish to pursue the subject further. Tm^s^aiJor.]
ill
1.
Grammar
On Grammar.
(rpa/jL/iazixyj).
lusions
4.
5.
al-
{laropiac).
Discovery of Etymology.
accurate account of analogies.:}:
An
Prosody
diacritical
t Vid.
\
Here came
of the
first
tion of
in all that
i.
is
The whole
Grammar of Dionysios
Thrax.
6.
On-
2.
Reading
is
the no-
{avdyvayacc:).
Reading is the rendering of poetic or prose productions without stumbling or hesitancy. It must be done with due regard
to expression, prosody, and pauses. Through the expressionf
we
(dpezrj)
of the piece
and from
meaning intended
In this way we read tragedy heroically,
comedy conversationally, elegiacs thrillingly, epics sustainedly, lyric poetry musically, and dirges softly and plaintively.
Any reading done without due observance of these
rules degrades the merits of the poets and makes the habits
of readers ridiculous.
art of the reader;
be conveyed.
to
3.
On Tone
(t6uo(:).
On Punctuation
4.
(ffny/r^).^
There are three punctuation marks the full stop, the semicolon, and the comma.]! The full stop denotes that the sense
is complete
the semicolon is a sign of where to take breath
the comma shows that the sense is not yet complete, but that
something further must be added.
:
5.
(rcvc dca(pipEt
In time. At the
very short.
*
its
axqivq
u7iootcyii7j(;
pause
is
long, at the
of a piece
{Kpivei de
to,
Koti/jiaTa
f/
^Yl
KaKci-
ttoitjtov
comma,
poetical mer-
yap hv
n?j to
TOLOVTOvJ)
Expression {h-oapmtc)
Tone
is
fiifn/mr
or Imitation.
II
is
be seen that in practice Dionysios distinguishes only iv.'o punctuation marks, the onyftii iitrsn (semicolon) being really not one at all.
It will
Grammar of Dionysios
On Rhapsody
6.
Rhapsody
Thrax.
{pa^'wdta).
poem
a part of a
is
nite)
On Elements
7.
{(Tzo!-)^s7a).-\-
(ct>raf),
Homer:
vl'V
They
tain series
(arocy^o;:)
ev^em
(_(Tzocye7a)
ai.'Tuc.
from being in a
cer-
or arrangement.
Of
They
plete
sound
and
lo?ig,
ful^
r^
(2,
r,
((p(ouij)
co
They
y.
two are
cause,
Two
au.
tive to
a,
s,
o,
;y,
when placed
c,
They
co.
before
are subjunctive,
ao,
ac,
ec,
eo,
ulo-,
oc,
o,
and
as in fxma, apzuca,
diphthongs,
or
may
a:,
is
ou.
Consonants, ^, y, 3, ^,
are called consonants
because by themselves they have no sound, but produce a
sound only when they are combined with vowels. Of the
&,
X,
}.,
ft,
V,
c, -,
f>,
a, z,
(p,
of Greece,
letters are
y,
vol.
On
ii.
p. 141,
They
(p.
I.
(1026, b. 12);
sqq.
Bonitz, Aristotelis
fT7o/ t'f/oi',
as
sq.
meaning
Grammar of Dionysios
Thrax.
^,
r,
^,
~, ^,
^,
<p,
They
X-
more disagreeable
are
in
= voiceless).
rouffh, &,
<p,
[-i,
X',
TT
tp
to ~
y to
/>
to r
d?JA
auzty b
Ac
uou euspyia
vy^a'
(fad-\ ol
odpa
'
Oouaaz'jc,-
</>
Four are uncJiangeaUe. They are called unchangeable because they do not change in the futures of verbs or the inflections of nouns. They are likewise called liquids. The final
elements of masculine nouns, in the nominative case, singu-
number, are
lar
fJdpc^^
UeXoci)
five, v, ?, p, a,
as Mo'jaa, "EUvfj,
neuters, six,
a,
KXetd), yaXcdcou,
v,
c,
Some add
dop'j.
p, a,
also
o,
u,
of plurals, four,
c,
8.
Syllable
Indoger.
is
S/>f., pp.
c,
as
tj,
iXc^,
as dppa,
as in
-^,
(Pdlvtz,
co,
e, to,
cplkoc,
0^ Syllables
v,
prjzr^p, Size:;,
q,
Niazujp,
p, a,
InXXaip',
<p,
of
The
final
<p'dco;
{au)laSai).X
54 sqq. et passim; Curtius, GrundzUge der griech BiymoloTMuWer,"Lectures, 2d Series, Lect. III.
Max
Jicou,
as
^A,
Or diphthong,
und Rom.,
evidently.
6 (1093a 20);
Kiihner,
Aus/uht.
p. 254.
^'
composed
Improperly we sj^eak
Kdj), l^ou:.
of a single vowel, as
a,
/}.
9.
A long
nature and live by position^: by nature, when it is repreor when one of the
sented by the long elements, as -^/>coc
or when it
doubtful elements is assumed as long, as ^'Aoyj^
contains one of the diphthongs, as Aio.!;\ by position, either
when it ends in two consonants, as liX:: or when a short or
shortenedf vowel is followed by two consonants, as d^?'oc
or when it ends in a single consonant and the next syllable
or when it is followed by
begins with a consonant, as ioyov
or when it ends in a double
a double consonant, as i?w
consonant, as <2-ac.
10.
On Short Syllables
syllable
becomes short
^i>i(po::
it
it
con-
has a
l'A(>r^z.X
On_^Common Syllables
{xoix^al
auXlaQal).
as
Ot'7/
aoi
a'lTLTj
taoi'
whereof the
by
when
or when
syllable
in a long
or
ou/la6ai).
{?.i>o.yiai
in twoVaj^s, either
11.
itself
latter is
-dsoi
vi
iioi
alrioi t'taiv
a mute, as
Position
(i?t'CTi(,),
6' ol'K
t'/.a'&tv
laxi/ Tr/vovra
-t/)
i/irri/c.
mean, as
is
generally sup-
(c/
).
is
long.
t
t)
A short
assumed
vowel
is
either
or o; a shortened vowel
is
a doubtful
as short.
/iiai(p6vE,
rEixeanr/J/ra.
vowel
(a,
/,
Grammar of
12.
A Word is
On the Word
(U^cz).
On the Sentence
13.
Dionysios Thrax.
(/o^-oc).!
is
14.
On the Noun
{ovoiia).
Noun is a declinable part of speech, signifying something either concrete or abstract (concrete, as stone; abstract,
common or proper (common, as man, horse
as education)
proper, as Socrates, Plato). It has five accidents genders,
species, forms, numbers, and cases.
There are three Genders, the masculine, the feminine, and
the neuter. Some add to these two more, the common and
the epicene
common, as man, horse; epicene, as swallow,
;
eagle.
There are two Species bf nouns, the primitive and the deA primitive noun is one which is said according to
original imposition, as yrj (earth) a derivative noun is one
which derives its origin from another noun, as yoctjco^ (earthborn). There are seven classes of derivatives: Patronymics,
Possessives, Comparatives, Diminutives, Nominals, Superlatives, and Verbals. A Patronymic is properly a noun formed
from the name of a father, improperly a noun formed from
the name of another ancestor, e.g., Achilleus is called both
rivative.
rum
{De
is
who made
speech.
Aristotle
(De
Interp., cap.
ii.)
says
"A
noun
is
is
separately
Orammar
of Dionysios TTirax.
names
the
Homer forms no
of mothers,
A Possessive
species of patronym-
is
d^oTspo::, ^pa3uTspo(:
one in co) pure, as ^ehloju, xa?Mu)i^;
one in atou, as xpeiaauiv^ r^aaoyv. A Superlative is a noun used
to express the superiority, of one individual over many in
a comparison. There are two forms of it, one in raroc, as
and one in <rroc, as [xijcazoi:^ dpcazo^. A
bqbxaxo^i^ ^paduzazo^
Diminutive is a noun expressing a diminution of the primitive word without comparison, as avd^pcuTtiaxoi; (mannikin),
Xi&a^ (stonelet), pecpaxuXhov (stripling). A Nominal is a word
formed alongside a noun, or as from a noun, as Theon, Tryphon. A Verbal is a noun derived from a verb, as Philemon,
as
Noemon.
There are three Forms of nouns, simple, compound, and
simple, as Memnon; compound, as Agasuper-compound
memnon super-compound, as Agamemnonides, Philippides.
Of compounds there are four kinds V. those compounded of
two complete words, as Cheirisophos 2. those compounded
of two incomplete words, as Sophokles 3. those compounded of an incomplete and a complete word, as Philodemos
and 4. those compounded of a complete word and an incom-
plete, as Perikles.
There are three Numbers, singular, dual, and plural sinrcb 'Oprjpio (both Homers);
There are some singular desigplural, as "Opqpoi (Homers).
nations used of plural objects, as <?^//oc (people;, x*^i'^^ (chorus); and plural designations used of singular and dual
;
Grammar of Dionysios
10
objects
of singular, as
"
A^v(u,
6rj6ac
TTirax.
(Athens, Thebes)
of
There are
allocutive.
indefinite,
anapho-
* VeviKi],
did.
Vid.
on no account
Max
to
Categ., cap.
v.
i.
to that
name
common name,
but
Grammar of Dlonyslos
11
Tlirax.
it
called
Dionym)
(crowd).
genus
is
An
Ordinal
is
A Verb
is
On the Verb
{^r^pia).*
iii.) says:
"A Verb is that which adds a timewhich no part separately signifies anything, and which is always
Harris, Herasserted of something else." Cf. Schmidt, Beitrage, pp. 344 sqq.
specification, of
mes^
Book
T.
cap. 6.
Grammar
12
of Dionysioh Thrax.
respective relations
the Present
is
On Conjugation
16.
to the Future.
{au!:uxia).
Conjugation is the consecutive inflection of Verbs. Of Barytone Verbs there are six conjugations, of which the First
by ^,
by
characterized
is
xoTirto
the Second
the Third
by
(^
or
<J(T,
by
as
d,
;-,
&,
or
ippdf^co,
unchangeables,
I,
p.,
^,
z,
r,
or
tt,
;f,
or
as
tit,
zr,
waaco, dpuaaco
v,
p,
as
TtdXXo),
the Fifth
vkpco
the Fourth
by
the four
17.
On Circumflexed Verbs
{TzspcaTKopspo).
by
the diphthong
* A<di^(T<f, the
er,
as
voco,
voeTc;,
voti
stupidity rendered
the Second
by Vox
(voice).
by
Grammar of Dionysios
the diphthong
as
or,
as
</,
Soa::,
6oa (the
and the
On VekBS
18.
Of Verbs ending
in
{to.
}ii
/xc).
see:
is
Tliird
^f)Uao1z^ "^(madl.
-j^puaio,
the First
6oib,
pronounced)
13
TJirax.
first
which
of the Circumfiexed
On the
19.
Tirjjvvo)^
Ti-fjyvuiu.
Participle
{fiEzoy^/j).
On the Article
{dp^pov).
An
Article is a declinable part of speech prefixed or subjoined to the various cases of nouns, taking, when prefixed,
the form
6,
accidents:
three, as b
and,
when
izocqiriz^
Tcoiqaci;,
to Tioiqpa.
three:
Singular,
The Cases
Z(jj,
z6v,
(Z;
-q,
z-q^,
21.
z^, zqu,
co
It
o'c.f
has three
The Genders
The Numbers
as
6,
are
;J,
o,
are
are
ro;
zoo,
On the Pronoun
{dvza)voiiia.)X
A Pronoun is
a word assumed instead of a noun, and indicating definite persons. It has six accidents Person, Gender, Number, Case, Form, and Species.
:
was not subscribed till the twelfth century of our era. Vid. Kiihner, AusGram, der Gr. Sfr., vol. i. p. 59, note (2d edit.) Choeroboskos {Bekker,
Anec. Gr<Eca, vol. p. 1186) says: "It must be understood that grammarians,
whose attention is directed to pronunciation, say that the is unpronounced
*
*
*
*
but musicians,
or
when it is found with (follows) a long,
* It
fiihr.
?/,
who
(.,
it is
cap. V.
Orammar of Dionysios
14
On
22.
The Persons
Thrax.
Primitive Pronouns.
of the Primitive
Pronouns are
i/ioc,
oc.
<7oc,
cvm, ao^
those
t\
The Genders
of
The Numbers
TO kfiov.
Ifi-q^
Dual,
i/><oC)
Singular,
Gipelz'. those
Dual, Ifuo^ aco^ &\
Plural, //o/, aoi^ oT. The Cases of the Primitives are Direct,
iyd)^ o\j^ ;'; Generic, i/^oD, aou^ oD
Dative, ^jioi^ aoi^ ol\ Accusative, i/ii, as, e; Vocative, au
those of the Derivatives are
<TL,
cj'c/j,
f';
a(pioc\
i^o)i\
of the Derivatives
Plural,
Singular,
i/-oc,
ofiei(;^
'y/-^c,
ooz-,
o'c
i//oc,
'yos,
are two
ou;
i/ioD,
^'c;
Forms
<ToD,
0L>
^/^^,
<p
(^(pi
^/'^^i
^^^i
'^^-
Simple,
There
ifioh^ aoi),
Compound, i/Jtauzob, aauToo, kauzou. There are two Speinasmuch as some are Primitive, as iyco, au, and others
cies,
c\
23.
On
Prepositions
{Tipo&tacz):-''
A Preposition is
nepc,
d/jt<fc,
area,
uno, uTvip.
24.
An Adverb
or
added
others
Some
to
On the Adverb
Compound Simple,
as nd^ac
* Lersch,
t Lersch,
{i7icpp7^pa).j-
Compound, as
vov, zoze,
aMn;
Tipo-KaXac.
to these
we
passim ; Steinthal, 671 sqq. Harris, Hermes, Bk. II. cap. iii.
passim; Steinthal, 672; Harris, Hermes, Bk. I. cap. xi. Schmidt,
15
Thrax.
;.a?,
some, quality, as
some, quantity, as
some, number, as <?rc, T^pk, rerpdxcc:
^orpudov, ayeXr^dov
z^C, fj-upcdxt::
Some
indicate mamner, as
bhyd-
Tzokkdxic:,
some, place,
Tzaizai.^
erative, as
(Tziou
vjy' ;
some are
some express
siasm, as
ebdl^
ratification, as drjXadij
r.Xeo-
eudv.
25.
On
Con.tunctions
{auvdeapo^).'^-
A Conjunction is
der and filling up the hiatuses of speech.
or-
Of conjunctions,
some are copulative, some disjunctive, some conjunctive,
some prjeter-conjunctive, some causative, some dubitative,
come conclusive, and some expletive. Copulative Conjunctions are those which bind together a discourse which fiows
on indefinitely
dzdp, auzdp^
fjzoc.
they are these, piv^ di, ri, xal, dUd, /}//iv, /}(5i,
Disjunctive Conjunctions are those which
bind "the phrase more firmly together, and disjoin the facts
expressed they are these, q^ yjzoc, /}i. Conjunctive Conjunctions are those which do not indicate any actual existence,
but signify sequence they are these, ec, ecTzep, ecdij, ecdrjzsp.
The PrcBter-conjiuictives are those which, along with actual
existence, show also order they are these, i^rer, irrscTzep, ineedrj,
:
* Aristotle,
Hermes, Bk.
II.
cap.
ii.
Lersch, fasshn
Harris.
16
Grammar of Dionysios
Thrax.
//7:3yc,
optoc;.
PA
3q87
G7MM
187M
C.l
ROBA
TORONTO LIBRARY