Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ethos June 2014 Far-Moving Tides of Sorrow and Memory
Ethos June 2014 Far-Moving Tides of Sorrow and Memory
James Fiford
Social Education Victoria
James is Executive Officer of Social Education Victoria.
He is currently writing a postgraduate thesis, employing
comparative methodology to examine Australian and
Canadian experiences on the Western Front in the First
World War and exploring the relationship between
the war and the creation of the respective national
identities.
A love of history and passion for touring the battlefields
of Gallipoli and the Western Front has seen me return
several times to both places over the past few years. My
most recent trip to the Western Front enabled me to fulfill
a dream of attending the Anzac Day Dawn Service at the
Australian National Memorial at Villers-Bretonneux, in
northern France. Sitting amidst the large crowd of fellow
travellers, watching images of Australian soldiers who
fought and died in this area nearly a hundred years ago
projected onto the memorial, was an incredibly poignant
moment. The temperature dropped quickly with the
approach of dawn, and although many sets of teeth were
starting to chatter, the beautiful vivid pink sunrise began to
spread from behind the memorial walls and warm us with
its glow. It was a wonderful service and the Department
of Veterans Affairs (DVA) is to be congratulated for their
planning.
With the official speeches over, and the traditional readings
and observances made, I, together with the thousands of
others who attended, slowly made our way to the exit of
the cemetery and awaited our transport for our onward
journey. This simple process was slow work, a result of the
size of the crowd, (and perhaps some less than smooth
work by the gendarmerie who were responsible for
overseeing the traffic), and took several hours! As I waited
patiently with the throng of Australians, French, New
Zealanders and British who comprised this large crowd, I
realised that, as important as these large scale acts of group
commemoration are to me, I also wanted to explore First
10
Whats off the track about this, you ask? Certainly there
are well-visited sites here not least the memorable Last
Post ceremony held daily at 8pm at the Menin Gate in
Ieper but the area offers other wonderful opportunities.
Well, rather than visit the region by way of a hasty one day
guided tour (where you see the main sights but miss out
on the context and deeper relationship with the place),
or in the company of a large group by way of a luxury
coach (where inevitably your ability to be reflective and
contemplative is reduced), I chose to explore by the most
mobile of means. What follows is a very short, eclectic
account of my recent experience cycling a section of the
Western Front battlefields around the beautiful town of
Ieper (Ypres). The route detailed here explores places that
formed part of the Ypres Salient in Flanders, including the
notorious campaign known as Passchendaele (or Third
Ypres) an event Winston Churchill labeled a forlorn
expenditure of valour and life without equal in futility
(Churchill, 1923).
It is hoped that some of the points of interest I discuss
here, together with my accompanying photos, can inspire
those with a similar passion to head over (either on a
personal pilgrimage or as part of an education group) and
experience something similar.
Left above > Part of the bunker system at the dressing station
where the Canadian John McCrae worked as a surgeon.
Left > Rifleman Valentine Joe Strudwick, was aged 15 when he
died on 14th January 1916. He was one of the youngest British
casualties to die in action in World War One and consequently is
one of the most visited and commemorated.
Above > The German war cemetery at Langemark, Belgium.
Photos > James Fiford
11
12
Left above > Between the crosses, row on row, that mark our
place - Tyne Cot cemetery, Belgium.
Top right > British surgeons at work in a bunker underneath
the hell of Passchendaele (museum display, Memorial Museum
Passchendaele 1917, Belgium).
Above right > Beautiful colours belie their deadly purpose. High
explosive, shrapnel and gas shells from the First World War.
(museum display, Memorial Museum Passchendaele 1917,
Belgium).
Photos > James Fiford
13
Left > View from the butte across the Buttes New British Cemetery
towards The New Zealand Memorial to the Missing, Polygon
Wood, Belgium.
Above > A tranquil woodland scene? The Caterpiller Crater, which
lies besides Hill 60, created by a massive mine on June 7, 1917,
Belgium.
Photos > James Fiford
14
15
References
Churchill, Winston (1927) The World Crisis, Vol.III.
Lake, Marilyn and Henry Reynolds with Mark McKenna
and Joy Damousi (2010) Whats wrong with Anzac? : the
militarisation of Australian history, University of New South
Wales Press Sydney.
Maccallum, Alexandra. (2010) Melbourne Historical
Journal, 2010, Vol. 38, p152-155, University of Melbourne,
Department of History.
McKernan, Michael (2010) The Broken Years: Australian
Soldiers in the Great War/Whats Wrong with Anzac: The
Militarisation of Australian History. Labour History; Nov
2010, Issue 99, p231-233.
Scates, Bruce et al, (2012) Anzac Day at Home and Abroad:
Towards a History of Australias National Day, History
Compass (online); July 2012, Volume 10, Issue 7, pages
523536.
Websites of interest
The Menin Gate, Ieper, Belgium., Photo > James Fiford
The ceremony is concluded by about 8:15pm, and visitors
can wander around the Gate and search for any names
of interest. Many shops in the town near the Gate remain
open immediately after the ceremony, and it can be a
good opportunity to source a souvenir or obtain a book
from one of the military bookshops. It would be remiss of
me to neglect to mention that dinner in the town market
square, perhaps at De Kollebloeme restaurant, is a must.
Unbeatable favourites include Flemish Stew and, when in
season, the stunning local specialty of moules marinire!
Thus ends this travelogue sojourn by bicycle across the
battlefields surrounding the Belgian town of Ieper. Whether
visiting for personal or educational reasons, I can highly
recommend taking the time out to explore this area a little
off the beaten track. There is certainly no better time
than over the next few years (with the centenary period
2014-2018) for a person to develop their understanding of
the conflict and the issues and debates that have stemmed
from it. There is much academic debate about the value in,
and even the danger of, the apparent Australian national
fixation with issues of Anzac and the First World War, but
for me much of this is background noise. Some academic
concerns are worthy of analysis, certainly, and no historian
16