Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Jose El-Amaya v. Eric Holder, JR., 4th Cir. (2014)
Jose El-Amaya v. Eric Holder, JR., 4th Cir. (2014)
Jose El-Amaya v. Eric Holder, JR., 4th Cir. (2014)
No. 13-1384
Submitted:
FLOYD,
Circuit
Decided:
Judges,
and
March 5, 2014
HAMILTON,
Senior
PER CURIAM:
Jose Armando Ab El-Amaya, a native and citizen of El
Salvador,
petitions
for
Appeals
(Board)
order
immigration
withholding
judges
of
review
the
dismissing
order
removal
of
denying
and
Board
of
Immigration
his
appeal
from
the
his
applications
for
protection
under
the
Convention
v.
(stating
Holder,
standard
668
F.3d
of
review
159,
165,
as
set
167
(4th
forth
See
Cir.
2012)
U.S.C.
in
Zelaya
Cir.
2011),
in
1252(b)(4)(D) (2012)).
Unfortunately
and
Lizama
v.
Holder,
for
629
El-Amaya,
F.3d
opposition
to
gangs
is
our
440,
decisions
447
(4th
amorphous
characteristic
social
group
fails
on
the
Zelaya,
Thus, this
particularity
ground,
(BIA
2008),
and
to
which
we
accord
deference.
See
See 8
U.S.C. 1252(b)(4)(D).
El-Amaya
next
argues
that,
taken
together,
his
dispense
contentions
with
are
oral
argument
adequately
because
presented
in
the
facts
and
the
materials
legal
before
this court and argument would not aid the decisional process.
PETITION DENIED