Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Thermal Degradation of Amines For CO2 Capture
Thermal Degradation of Amines For CO2 Capture
com
Introduction
Amine scrubbing with thermal regeneration will be an
important technology for CO2 capture from fossil fuel
combustion to manage global climate change [1]. In this
process (Figure 1), CO2 is absorbed in a countercurrent
contactor at 4070 8C. The solvent is heated to 100
150 8C and stripped with steam to produce pure CO2.
For geologic storage the CO2 is further compressed to
150 bar.
To minimize energy consumption, the amine solvent
should have a large operating CO2 capacity, fast CO2
absorption kinetics, and a high heat of CO2 absorption
[2]. If the amine is resistant to thermal degradation, the
stripper can be operated at greater temperature and
pressure to further reduce compression work and capital
costs. Excessive thermal degradation must be avoided to
www.sciencedirect.com
minimize the economic loss of amine and the environmental impact of the degradation products.
In CO2 capture from coal-fired power plants by amine
absorption/stripping, amine losses can occur by five
mechanisms [3]. Nonionic amines with a finite vapor
pressure can vaporize into the flue gas. Flue gas typically
contains 35% oxygen that can oxidize the amine in the
absorber packing or absorber sump at 4070 8C or at 100
145 8C in the hot solution leaving the crossexchanger.
Oxygen is rapidly removed at the top of the stripper and
should not cause oxidation there. Thermal degradation
occurs at the greatest rate at 120150 8C in the liquid
hold-up of the stripper sump and reboiler.
This paper will review work published from 2009 to 2011
on the thermal degradation of amines in this process. A
previous review of this topic was prepared in 2001 [4].
Figure 1
Amine
volatility
Oxidation
dissolved oxygen
solubility
lean amine
CO2
100 150 C
1 10 atm
Heat X
ABS
STR
40 65 C
Flue Gas In
~5 % O2
Reb
12 % CO2
rich amine
Oxidation kinetics
Thermal
degradation
Current Opinion in Chemical Engineering
Table 1
Degradation temperature giving k1 = 2.9 10S8 sS1 of selected amines.
Abbrev
Amine
Structure(s)
Stripper T (8C)
Ref.
N,N0 -diMEDA
104
[11]
Diethylenetriamine
DETA
108, 118
[6,15]
N-(2-Hydroxyethyl)ethylenediamine
HEEDA
114
[15]
3-(Methylamino)propylamine
MAPA
114
[6,11]
Ethylenediamine
EDA
117128
[7,15,23]
103, 105
[11,15]
N-Methylethanolamine
MAE
102, 105
[6,11,14]
2-Piperidinemethanol
2-PM
109
[6]
Monoethanolamine
MEA
111125
[6]
2-Piperidineethanol
2-PE
127
[7]
3-Amino-1-propanol
3a1p
126,127
[6,15]
2-Amino-2-methyl-1-propanol
AMP
[6,11,15]
115
[11]
N,N-Dimethylethanolamine
DMAE
118
[11]
N-(2-Aminoethyl)piperazine
AEP
121
[6]
N,N-Dimethylethanolamine
DMMEA
122
[15]
N-Methyldiethanolamine
MDEA
119129
[3,6,11,15,22]
N-(2-Hydroxyethyl)piperazine
HEP
130
[6]
1-Methylpiperazine
1-MPZ
150
[7]
132
[6]
2-MPZ
151
[7]
Hexamethylenediamine
HMDA
160
[7]
Piperazine
PZ
162
[7]
104
[6]
www.sciencedirect.com
Table 1 (Continued )
Abbrev
Amine
Structure(s)
Stripper T (8C)
Ref.
Monoethanolamine/DGA1
MEA/DGA1
112
[6]
N-Methyldiethanolamine/PZ
MDEA/PZ
120, 143
[3]
Monoethanolamine/AMP
MEA/AMP
123
[6]
Piperazine/AMP
PZ/AMP
134
[7]
Piperazine/1,4-dimethylpiperazine/1-MPZ PZ/1,4-DMPZ/1-MPZ
156160
[7]
Piperazine/2-methylpiperazine
155
[7]
PZ/2-MPZ
HO
NH
NH2 + CO2
HO
This reaction is reversible, especially at greater temperature [7] (S Freeman, GT Rochelle, Thermal degradation
of aqueous piperazine for CO2 capture: 2: Product types and
generation rates, IECR, unpublished data). However, the
equilibrium concentration of the cyclic urea is substantial
and represents an unacceptable loss of active amine.
Structures containing secondary N degrade to the urea at
lower T (methylaminopropanolamine (MAPA), dietheylenetriamine (DETA), HEEDA).
It is possible that the cyclic ureas act as intermediates in
further oligomerization with the production of ammonia
and other fragments. For example, HEEDA may react with
HEI to produce ammonia and hydroxyethyldiethylenetriamine.
Simple ureas are also produced reversibly from amines
that are resistant to other degradation mechanisms. Diglycolamine1 (DGA1) is known to produce the urea, which
can be reversibly decomposed by reclaiming at elevated
temperature with low CO2 loading [17]. It is possible this
urea is an intermediate in the thermal degradation of
DGA to produce morpholine.
Carbamate polymerization
Primary and secondary alkanolamines with two or three
carbons between the N and oxygen degrade by reversibly
NH + H2O
O
www.sciencedirect.com
O
HO
NH2
NH
HO
NH
NH2
Because the equilibrium concentration of the oxazolidinone will be greater, greater CO2 loading accelerates
carbamate polymerization. Table 1 shows that secondary
amines degrade most readily (diethanolamine (DEA),
105 8C; MAE, 102 8C). Even the hindered alkanolamines
are not resistant to this mechanism. Both aminomethylpropanol (AMP) (126 8C) and 2-PE degrade (127 8C) with
the production of the expected dimer. The severely
hindered N-tertbutylethanolamine still degrades about
half as fast as AMP [15]. If the alkanolamine has more
than 3 carbons between the alcohol and the amine, it will
degrade by another, usually more resistant, mechanism.
DGA (with 5 atoms between the amine and the alcohol)
degrades at 132 8C.
CO2
HO
HO
N
H3C
NH
OH + HO
HO
OH + HO
H3C
+
OH H2O
NH
OH
OH
CH3
www.sciencedirect.com
CH3
CH3
CH3
+
CH3
HO
NH CH3 +
HO
OH
HN
H
H
HN
NH
NH
N
HN
NH
AEAEPZ
Hexamethylenediamine (HMDA) is resistant to degradation and degrades by ring closing to make piperidine
and ammonia [7,15].
NH +
O
NH
HN
HO
N
NH O
NH + HO
HN
N
+ HO
NH
+
NH2
OH
OH
NH2
+ H+
from the CO2 and not from C in the PZ. Closmann [3]
also observed formate/formamide formation in the thermal degradation of MDEA and MDEA/PZ. The mechanism is not understood but probably requires oxidation
of a C on the amine and reduction of the CO2 in a
carbamate to the respective amide or formate. The
analytical methods for oxidation products of PZ are
known to be incomplete and could easily miss an
important oxidation product.
Freeman [7] also established that the formate and its
respective amide are in equilibrium at 150 8C in less than
a week. The equilibrium in loaded PZ provides about
equal amount of formate and amide.
Alkanolamines thermally degrade by carbamate polymerization at a rate that limits stripper operation to 100
130 8C.
A few amines degrade in the absence of CO2. EideHaugmo [15] found three propanediamines with
>20% degradation at 135 8C for 5 weeks without CO2:
(MAPA),
N-[33-amino-1-methylaminopropane
(dimethylamino)propyl]-N,N-dimethyl-1,3-propanediamine (TMBPA), and 3-aminopropanol. It may be that
these molecules participate in reversible addition to a
heteroconjugated double bond.
Internal urea formation limits ethane and propane diamines to 100120 8C.
Tertiary amines thermally degrade by transalkylation and
elimination at 120140 8C.
Acknowledgements
LePaumier [14] observed significant loss of 2-methylaminoethanol in the absence of CO2, with more loss in a
metal reactor than in a glass reactor.
This review is based in large part on the work of former PhD students
supported by the Luminant Carbon Management Program at the University
of Texas at Austin: Jason Davis, Stephanie Freeman, and Fred Closmann.
2.
3.
4.
Rochelle GT: Research needs for CO2 capture from flue gas by
aqueous absorption/stripping. DE-AF26-99FT01029; 2011.
5.
6.
Conclusions
Thermal degradation limits the maximum T/P and therefore the energy performance of the stripper.
www.sciencedirect.com
7.
9.
11. Lepaumier H, Picq D, Carrette P-L: New amines for CO2 capture.
I. Mechanisms of amine degradation in the presence of CO2.
Ind Eng Chem Res 2009, 48:9061-9067.
Lepaumier presents results on thermal degradation of 12 amines, including a series of substituted ethylenediamines and several consistent
mechanisms/pathways to describe expected products.
18. Polderman LD, Dillon CP, Steele AB: Why MEA solution breaks
down in gas-treating service. Oil Gas J 1955, 54:180-183.
21. Bedell SA, Worley CM, Al-Horr RS, McCrery DA: Quaternaries as
intermediates in the thermal and oxidative degradation of
alkanolamines. Ind Eng Chem Res 2011, 49:7147-7151.
www.sciencedirect.com