Professional Documents
Culture Documents
JSW Report PDF
JSW Report PDF
IN VARIOUS DIVISIONS
AND RISK ASSESSMENT
USING HIRAC TOOL IN
NEW METAL
GRANULATION UNIT
INTERNSHIP PROJECT
AT
INDEX
CERTIFICATE
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
8
9
10
13
14
15
16
18
20
22
27
32
35
35
36
39
40
3.1 OBJECTIVE
41
3.2 METHODOLOGY
41
42
45
46
48
50
51
4.1 OBJECTIVE
52
52
53
4.4 ANALSIS
57
61
4.6 RESULT
63
RE
CONCLUSION
64
REFERENCE
65
PICTURE
INDEX
16
18
20
22
24
25
27
27
28
29
30
32
33
33
34
37
37
47
49
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that the Project Work entitled HAZARD IDENTIFICATION IN VARIOUS
DIVISIONS AND RISK ASSESSMENT USING HIRAC TOOL IN NEW METAL GRANULATION
UNIT and submitted by SARATH KRISHNAN U, Roll No. R080215055 for the Summer Internship
(2016-17), embodies the bona fide work done by him under my supervision
Date: 25-06-2016
Place: Toranagallu
..
Signature of mentor
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I am very much thankful to almighty GOD that he has given me the opportunity to
stand here. I am also very much thankful to my respected teachers and parent for
their support, without their cooperation this training would not have been possible.
I would like to express deep gratitude to my esteemed guide Mr.FARHAN
AHMED, Deputy Manager Safety and Fire Services dept. for offering me an
opportunity to carry internship project at JSW Steel ltd from 1st JUNE 2016 to 30th
JUNE 2016 for their continuous support to complete the project successfully. And
also providing different ways to approach the project and for giving constructive
criticism in each and every Stage of the Project to accomplish my goal.
Last, but not the least, I thank all Safety Engineers and other employees of JSW,
Bellary for their constant support.
SECTION: 1
BRIEF INTRODUCTION
ABOUT JSW GROUP
and safety
management
in
our
Dr Vinod Nowal
Director & Chief Executive Officer
It was one of the first movers into the power sectors after the liberalization in the early 1990s.
JSW energy currently produces 3140 MW of power, with another 8630 MW capacity under
implementation and development. By managing its operations, enhancing social and economic
benefits, minimizing environmental impact and employing innovative technologies, it has
become a leading full-service integrated power company in the Indian Power Sector with its
presence across several states.
It is one of the leading private infrastructure companies in the country. It started its operations in
1999 and currently has employee strength of over 1200. It is dedicated to developing world class
airports, shipyards, townships, roads, and rail connectivity, inland waterways, water treatment
plants, SEZs, and other infrastructural facilities.
It is the investment arm of the JSW group. It was incorporated in 2001 as a public limited
company registered with the Reserve Bank of India and listed under BSE, NSE and Delhi Stock
Exchange. Its main business activities include management of consultancy services and also take
care of investments in shares, stocks and other securities in India and abroad.
JSW CEMENT
JSW cement utilizes the industrial by-products such as slag to make eco-friendly cement.
Focusing on its goal to make India self-reliant and considering the unprecedented growth in
infrastructure, JSW cement was established in 2009. Even after being one of the late entrants to
the industry, it has a total capacity to produce over 5.4 million tons per year and is in plans to
expand further. Its flagship plant in Nandyal uses world class technology to manufacture cement.
JSW cement produces three types of products: Portland Slag Cement (PSC), Ordinary Portland
Cement (OPC), and Ground Granulated Blast Furnace Slag Cement (GGBFS). Its major sales
areas are Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, Tamil Nadu, Kerala, Maharashtra and Goa.
JSW STEELS
As part of the US $18 billion O. P. Jindal Group, JSW Group has diversified interests in steel,
energy, minerals and mining, infrastructure, cement and information technology.[4] JSW's history
can be traced back to 1982, when the Jindal Group acquired Piramal Steel Limited, which
operated a mini steel mill at Tarapur in Maharashtra and renamed it as Jindal Iron and Steel
Company
The Group set up its first steel plant in 1982 at Vasind near Mumbai. Soon after, it acquired
Piramal Steel Ltd., which operated a mini steel mill at Tarapur in Maharashtra. The Jindals, who
had wide experience in the steel industry, renamed it as Jindal Iron and Steel Co. Ltd. (JISCO).
Jindal Vijayanagar Steel Ltd. (JVSL) was set up in 1994, with its plant located at Toranagallu in
the Bellary-Hoped area of Karnataka, the heart of the high-grade iron ore belt and spread over
3,700 acres (15 km2) of land. It is just 340 kilometres (210 mi) from Bangalore, and is well
connected with both the Goa and Chennai Port. In 2005, JISCO and JVSL merged to form JSW
Steel Ltd.
Indias largest producer of special steel in the long products category, JSW Steel Salem plant
mainly caters to the automotive sector. It is an environment friendly, zero effluent plant. JSW
acquired SISCOL in the year 2004, a sick unit at that time. Quick turnaround of the plant was
achieved by expanding capacity from 0.3 Mt to 1 Mt and switching over to value added products.
Located advantageously at just about 350 km from Chennai, the Salem plant has emerged as a
global steel hub for automobiles and auto components.
DOLVI (MAHARASHTRA)
The 3.3 MTPA integrated steel plant at Dolvi, Maharashtra majority stake acquired in 2010, is an
inherent part of JSW Steel. Located on the west coast of India, the plant has a jetty with a
capacity of 10 million tonnes per annum. This provides the unit with logistical advantages in
importing raw materials and savings on freight cost. The unit is well connected through rail, road
and sea and has given the JSW Steel a strategic presence in western India. The Dolvi plant caters
to several industries including automotive, projects and construction, machinery, LPG cylindermakers, cold rollers, oil and gas sector and consumer durables.
VASIND (MAHARASHTRA)
The Vasind plant focuses on JSW- branded high-end steel products. It sources HR Steel coils
from the Dolvi and Vijayanagar plants to manufacture value-added, branded steel products such
as galvanised steel, plain and corrugated products as well as colour-coated products. Started in
1982 with the commissioning of a 20 high cold rolling mill, it has now turned into a full-fledged
complex with cold rolling, hot rolling, galvanizing and colour coating facilities. Galvanised steel
from Vasind is a market leader in both domestic and international markets. The unit exports
mainly to the USA, Europe and Middle East Asia and South African Continent.The plant has a
total capacity of 0.45 MTPA in galvanised and cold-rolled products, 0.225 MTPA colour coated
products and hot-rolled plates manufacturing facility.
KALMESHWAR (MAHARASHTRA)
One of the downstream operations of JSW Steel is executed from Kalmeshwar. The plant
produces several branded products including JSW Vishwas, JSW Vishwas Plus, JSW Colouron
and JSW Colouron Plus. The products are sold to leading OEMs including Whirlpool, Haier,
Blue Star, Kirby, Pennar, Metal Kraft, Solidus, Tata BlueScope, Tata International, Fowler, BG
Shirke, Tata Marcopolo, BHEL, NTPC and Tiger Steel. It is also engaged in retail sales and
exports. A new cold rolling mill is being added to raise the existing production level to 0.60
MTPA.
SALEM
The Salem plant aims to develop the Kanjamalai, Kavuthimalai and Vediappanmalai iron ore
mines in Tamil Nadu on receipt of requisite approvals to improve raw material security. This will
facilitate expansion of production capacity to 2 MTPA. It will also allow the unit to diversify
into the production of value-added products such as annealed, drawn and peeled steel. The plant
is continuously working to develop special grades for critical automotive applications.
DOLVI
The Dolvi unit aims to increase its upstream capacities. Expansion projects include a 1 million
tons coke oven plant and, 4 million tons pellet plant. In the second phase, the unit will be
expanded by an additional 4 million tons capacity, which will include a sinter plant, a blast
furnace, slab caster, a hot strip mill, a coke oven and two power plants of 300 MW each.
Capacity(MTPA)
8.5
0.9
0.6
1
10
Slab: 10 MTPA
SECTION : 2
JSW STEEL PRODUCTION
PROCESS
JSW STEELS
UNIVERSITY OF PETROLEUM AND ENERGY STUDIES
Raw materials are received at north yard and south yard through rail and road
transport. After that it is stored at raw material handling plant. According to the
requirement raw material goes to further processing departments like coke oven, pellet
plant, sinter plant to prepare burden for blast furnace and corex for iron making.
Molten iron then goes to steel making shop. Here the carbon content and impurities are
reduced by flux addition and oxygen lancing. Final molten steel goes to casting shop;
here steel is casted into slabs and billets. These slabs and billets either goes to customer
directly or slab goes to strip making (HSM, CRM) and billet goes to wire rod
mill and bar rod mill. From here finished steel goes to
customer.
Material flow in steel production starts from RMHS. It receives raw material in adequate
quantity and allocate space for raw material stacking. Materials handled in RMHS are iron ore,
coke, lime-stone and dolomite.
Types of transportation modes:
Rail Wagon
Road trucks
Conveyor Belt
Wagon tippler:
To unload the rail wagon material. It holds the wagon and inverts it. The material falls on chain
linked conveyor belt and goes to storage area.
Stacker-Reclaimer:
It is a machine which with the help of conveyor belts makes piles of raw material and whenever
needed it reclaim material with the help of buckets attached to conveyor belt. Material falls on
another belt and is send to the other production sections
Barrel Reclaimer:
The piles made by TBS, barrel reclaimer collect it and send the material with the help of
conveyors.
21
Agglomeration unit consist of the sinter plant and the pellet plant. In these plant
the iron ore fines are agglomerated and theses agglomerated fines are feed to the
BLAST FURNACE and the COREX PLANTS
Agglomeration is the process of converting the fine iron ores to the form of lumps
Benefit of the agglomeration are that the fine materials are most efficient to
use in the corex and the blast furnace plant
This method is used to increase the production of blast furnace and also to
lower the cost of steel making.
Pellets are then fed to the blast furnace and COREX plant. Pellets are made
to give porosity in the burden of COREX and blast furnace
Preparation process:
DRYING OF IRON ORE FINES:
The iron ore fine coming from the RMHS contains the 8-12% moisture. It is dried into the dryer
fired with COREX gas and oxygen. At the one end of the drum COREX gas burner is attached
and at the other end induscive draft fan is attached which creates the negative draft inside the
drum. The dust laden hot air goes to cyclone separator and then to scrubber. Dust obtained from
cyclone goes to ball mill and slurry obtained from scrubber goes to settling tank.
BALL MILLING
The dried ore particle size then reduced by ball milling. In ball milling a drum is rotated at fixed
RPM. Inside the drum high chromium ball are there, due to their attrition the particle got break
and reduced in size. The dust coming from the ball mill is also recovered and scrubbed.
SCREENING
Then the pellet are screened with double deck rollers, first with 14mm size and second with 8mm
size. In this way pellet size between 8-14mm size (appropriate for COREX and BF feeding).
Further goes for heat treatment. Under and over sized pellets are send back as the raw for pellet
making.
INDURATION
Now to strengthen the pellets these are introduced to elevated temperature to remove moisture
and to create bonding between particles of raw materials. This section is divided into three parts
1. Drying zone 200-300C
2. Heating zone 300-1300C
SINTER PLANT
Sinter plant is a pre-processing unit for the Blast Furnace. To make ore burning easy and uniform
in BF by converting the rich iron ore fines into sinter.
It is to agglomerate the iron ore fines that have rich Fe content into lumps by adding
agglomerating agents such as dolomite and limestone and making the lumps more permeable.
Proportioning Bins
Calcined Lime
Mixing
Drum
To Micro
Pellet Plant
Sinter Cooler
Screening
Hearth Layer
Return Fines
Product Sinter
to Blast
RETURN FIN
HEARTH LAY
Nodulizi
COREX
1&2
BLAST
FURNCE
1&2
BF 3 & 4
MOLTEN IRON
Fig 5 : Combination diagram of molten iron
COREX TECHNOLOGY
The Corex process consists of two main parts a Reduction Shaft and Melter- Gasifier . The
main reagents for the Corex process are iron ore, noncoking coal, and oxygen.Unlike the Blast
furnace the Corex process does not use a hot blast of nitrogen, thereby greatly reducing
NOX gas
emissions, but instead uses oxygen. In addition, the Corex process can use iron
oxides containing up to 80% lump ore and uses non coking coal directly as a reducing agent.
Corex is a smelting reduction process combining a melter gasifier with a reduction shaft. The
process takes lump iron ore or pellets, non-coking coal, and oxygen as main inputs. Similar to
the blast furnace process, the reduction gas moves in counter flow to the descending burden in
the reduction shaft. Then, the reduced iron is discharged from the reduction shaft by
screw conveyors and transported via feed legs into the melter gasifier.
PROCESS STEPS
The burden first reduced by reducing gases like CO. Here the iron oxide gets changed
into iron but in solid form.
Then this reduced iron ore (sponge iron) is feed to melter gasifier shaft where coal is feed
and this coal produce heat to melt the iron ore.
The molten metal and slag is tapped out periodically. The slag goes to the slag
Granulation plant and molten iron is poured into transferring ladles.
BLAST FURNACE
The Blast Furnace is a huge steel stack lined with refractory bricks. Iron ore, coke and limestone
are into the top and preheated air is blown from the bottom. The blast furnaces reduce and
convert the iron oxides into hot metal.
30
through a tap hole. The tapping of iron and slag is the major factor permitting additional
materials to be charged at the furnace top.
This brief summary of the complex operations of a blast furnace is presented here to provide a
point of reference for the actual flow of operations. Very often, several blast furnaces may be
arranged in a single plant so that the most efficient possible use can be made of fuels, internal
rail facilities, etc.
CHARACTERISTIC OF JSW VIJAYANAGAR BLAST FURNANCE
The JSW steel Vijaynagar plant hold the largest blast furnace in India, it has 4 blast furnace which
produce
the molten
successfully. With an internal volume of over 4,019 cubic meters and a nominal annual capacity
of 2.8 million metric tons of iron, it is the largest blast furnace existing in India today. This
increases the production capacity of JSW Steel at Vijayanagar works to around seven million
metric tons of steel per year. A cyclone separator developed by Siemens VAI is being used for
the first time to clean the top gas in Toranagallu. This solution makes it possible to flexibly
control the efficiency of dedusting and, as a result, to maximize the recovery of dust containing
iron and avoid an excessive concentration of zinc or other heavy elements in the recycled dust.
SMS 1
STEEL
MAKING
SHOP
SMS 3
SMS 2
In this section the impurities of Si and P is removed. This is done by adding some fluxes and
oxygen gas. Average process time for each stage is 15-20mins 1200-1250o C => HMPT =>
1100-1150o C
Hot Metal De Sulfurization
This process is done to further reduce sulfur S from the hot metal. De-S Agent: Calcium Carbide
The de-sulphurised slag is skimmed off using Slag Raking machine.Mixer maintains
homogenized temperature and chemistry of hot metal from different iron making units. This Hot
Metal from the Mixer is transferred to the converter with the help of a charging ladle
In this section the impurities of Si and P is removed. This is done by adding some fluxes and
oxygen gas. Average process time for each stage is 15-20mins 1200-1250o C => HMPT =>
1100-1150o C
Billet Caster
Carbide
The de-sulphurised slag is skimmed off using Slag Raking machine.Mixer maintains
homogenized temperature and chemistry of hot metal from different iron making units. This Hot
Metal from the Mixer is transferred to the converter with the help of a charging ladle
Converting
Converting is the process of reducing the fixed carbon from the molten iron by lancing oxygen
gas. Carbon reacts with the oxygen and makes carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide gas. In this
stage the carbon percentage lowers down up to 0.2% from 0.4%. The convertor used is LD
Convertor named on the name of its inventor. The gas rich in CO gas is called LD gas.
To increases micro cleanliness and to remove nonmetallic inclusions ladle heating by graphite
electrode arching is done. In addition of it Ferro-alloying is done in this stage.
Fig 13 : Converter
HEATING
Slabs coming from the continuous casting section have to be heated up to 1280C to undergo hot
rolling. For this the slabs are heated into the furnace. This special type of furnace has four
section depending upon temperature.
RECAPORATIVE ZONE
In this section no burners are there some heating of the slab takes place due to the heat of next
zone. This type of heating is the preparation to introduce the slab in next zone at 1150C.
PRE-HEATING ZONE
HEATING ZONE
SOAKING ZONE
The temperature of this zone also at 1280C and in this section the slabs are kept to homogenize
the slab temperature.
PRIMARY DE-SCALING
The heated slab come out from the furnace and then through the help of rolling drums it goes
forward and pass through the water spray at 200 bar pressure. This is done to remove the oxide
layer.
ROUGH ROLLING
In this section the de-scaled slab comes and pressed under the rollers. The 220mm slab converted
into 27mm thickness sheet with same width with the help of 5 to 7 passes. At the time and place
of pressing the pressurized water spray is done to remove oxide scaling and to cool the rollers.
COILING BOX
After reducing the thickness the hot sheet is send to the coil box. Here the sheet is coiled. Here
the purpose of coiling is to homogenize the outer and inner temperature of the sheet because it
has to undergo further rolling to reduce the thickness.
FINISHING MILL
Here 6 mills are placed each having the distance between the rolls gradually decreasing one after
another. The sheet passes through these mills and the thickness is reduced up to 1.6 mm
depending on the demand of customer.
DOWN COILER
The final sheet is send to the coiler where it coiled and then placed on the transfer car which
transfers it to the coil yard. In coil yard intermediate storage, cooling, packing and numbering is
done.
because in the next step of rolling the chloride ions present on the surface will lead to cracking.
The clean strip is now subjected to rolling under twin stand 6 HI reversing mill. The thickness is
reduced with the help of continuous supply of emulsion of long chain fatty acids with DM water
(de mineralized water). This emulsion helps in cooling and lubricating of rolling joints.
ELECTROLYTIC CLEANING
In next step electrolytic cleaning is done to remove oil on the surface of the strip because in the
next step of annealing the oil residues will form soot. Electrolyte used is the solution of 2.5-3.5%
sodium hydroxide silicate in DM water. Then again rinsing is done with DM water to eliminate
the residual iron and oil concentration.
BATCH ANNEALING
During rolling crystal deformation and mechanical hardening take place. These reduce the sheets
yield strength and ultimate tensile strength and hence draw ability. To recover these properties
annealing is done on sheet. Annealing is the process to heat the metal below its liquids
temperature and hold it for some time to allow the microstructure reformation. Annealing is done
inside the annealing furnace. Before heating the furnace is purged with nitrogen gas up to
99.99% concentration. Then furnace is purged with hydrogen gas to produce reducing
atmosphere. These purging are done at 40C. After purging the furnace temperature is increased
up to 400C and then it is hold there for some time, it is called HEATING and then again
temperature is increased up to 650-700C and held there for some time this process is called
SOAKING. Then we do furnace cooling
In this mill the some mechanical hardening is done on the strip. It is done by subjecting the strip
under elongated condition with the help of rolls. In the rolls wet temper fluid is used which
should possess following qualities like anti-staining, lubrication and detergent effect. This oil is
for only one time use.
After all treatments the sheet is inspected at both sides and then coiled.
The coil is packed as a coil roll. Now it is ready to deliver to the customer.
BAR MILL
Following processes are done to change the shape of billet, reduce the diameter and further
elongation.
FURNACE CHARGING
DE-SCALING
To remove the scale of oxides from the surface of billet 230 bar pressurized water spray is
deployed.
ROLLING
According the desired final product subsequent rollings are done
COOLING
Cooling with water spray is done to cool down the work piece and equipments at the rate of 0.61.4C. Water sprays are attached after every rolling station. Sizing and measurement: on line
diameter measuring equipment is attached to the line with digital display boards showing
entering and outgoing diameter of object.
The wire coils in wire mill and bars are cooled down in air and then compacted and packed with
strapping machine. The final weights are measured and then send to the storage yard.
FINAL PRODUCTS
From wire mill: wire diameter range 5.2mm2.2mm Coil outside diameter 1200mm-1250mm
Coil inside diameter 750mm-850mm
from bar mill:
8-40mm TMT bar (structural steel)
SECTION 3
HAZARD
IDENTIFICATION IN
VARIOUS DIVISION
3.1 OBJECTIVE
Objective of project was to get introduced to and learn modern methods and technologies used in
Health Safety and Environment field in JSW Jindal steel
During the internship program I have taken the project to conduct the HAZARD
IDENTIFICATION OF VARIOUS DIVISIONS in the JSW steel plant. The areas visited during
the internship program are COREX, STEEL MAKING SHOP, COLD ROLL MILL, HOT
STRIP MILL.
In the internship program I have also take the risk assessment of the MGP Site using the
HIRAC Tool
3.2 METHODOLOGY
During the internship program the project taken up was having the theoretical methodology type.
It consist of visiting the various divisions in the plant and identifying the hazards associated with
the particular plant. Most of the hazards found in the divisions were having the control measure.
But though theoretical research , interaction and discussion further control measures were wound
which will increase the safety and the hazard.
The second phase of the internship project was the risk assessment using the HIRAC tool and the
division selected for this purpose was the MGP construction site. The risk assessment using
HIRAC was basically proactive approach in which many situations are analyzed and happens the
control measures are evaluated.
Further in the risk assessment also recommendations are provided which will increase the safety
and decrease the accidents.
Walk around your workplace and look at what could reasonably be expected to cause
harm safety.
Remember to think about long-term hazards to health (e.g. high levels of noise or
exposure to harmful substances) as well as safety hazards.
Some workers have particular requirements, eg new and young workers, new or
expectant mothers and people with disabilities may be at particular risk. Extra thought
will be needed for some hazards.
Members of the public, if they could be hurt by construction activities.
Try a less risky option (eg switch to using a less hazardous chemical).
Prevent access to the hazard (eg by guarding.
Issue personal protective equipment (eg clothing, footwear, goggles etc.).
POTENTIAL
HAZARD
CONCEQUENCE
RISK
CONTROL
MEASURES
Dust
Risk to life
Use appropriate
ppe while
working in the
dusty areas
Noise
Heat stress
a) Improper operation of
EOT cranes can result in
Falling of hot materials
on the surface.
4.
Falling of material
a) Risk to the life
b)
Can
cause
explosions
( molten metal and
and property
minute or large depending
slag)
upon the quantity of water
content
POTENTIAL
HAZARD
CONCEQUENCE
CURRENT
CONTROL
MEASURES
RECOMMENDED
CONTROL MEASURE
a) ambulance
and the medical
assistance.
Heat stees,heat
stroke
a) Chances of
workers falling in to
the open hot pit.
a) No control
measures are
adopted in this
hazard
a) Burns, fatality
and injury to the
workers, structures
and the machines
can be damaged
a) Basic
evacuation plan
is present along
with directing
the workers to
assemble in the
safe zone
a) Fatality and
injury
a) Fire
extinguishers
and fire hydrants
are present in
the working site.
a) use always
the co personal
monitor
Spillage of the
hot metal
Fire hazard
Gas leakage
a) Unconsciousness,
fatality
a) heat resistance
barricading can be used
b) working area can be
continuously supervised
a) Inspection during the
process,
b) Alertness, Regular
maintenance of the
equipment should be
carried out
POTENTIAL
HAZARD
Chemical
(Sulphuric Acid,
Hydrochloric
acid,Chlorine,N2
,NaOH, COREX
gas, Carbon
Monoxide)
CONCEQUENCE
RISK
CONTROL
MEASURES
Risk to life
Use appropriate
PPEs like
chemical suit ,
SCBA and gas
monitors while
working
b) If there is a leak,Vapor
cloud explosion & even
death.
a) Risk to ears
a) Can cause threshold
2
Noise
4.
Heat stress
Biological ( algae,
bacteria fungi)
a) Risk to life
and property
POTENTIAL
HAZARD
Pressurized steam,
Water
CONCEQUENCE
RISK
Risk to life
CONTROL
MEASURES
a) Use
appropriate
barrier while
working in steam
prone areas
b) Design the
equipment free
from steam
leakage
a) Risk to ears
a) Can cause threshold
2
Noise
4.
Heat stress
a) Risk to health
b) Risk to
equipment
a) Risk to life
and property
SECTION 4
RISK
ASSESMENT
OF NEW
METAL
GRANULE
PLANT
USING
HIRAC
TOOL
4.1 OBJECTIVE
The purpose of risk assessment is to provide a systematic and objective approach to assessing
hazards and their associated risks that will provide an objective measure of an identified hazard as
well as provide a method to control the risk. It is one of the general duties as prescribed under the
Occupational Safety and Health Act 1994 (Act 514) for the employer to provide a safe workplaces
to their employees and other related person.
In the JSW STEEL PLANT the HIRAC is carried out in the under construction metal
granulation plant.The existing control measure is identified and some efficient control measures
which can decrease the risk during the construction is recommended.
52
PURPOSE
OF
ASSESMENT
RISK
4.3BASIC
CONCEPTS
WHAT IS RISK?
Risk is something that we as individuals live with on a daily basis. People are constantly
making decisions based on risk. Simple decision in daily life such as driving,
crossing the road and money investment all imply an acceptance risk. Risk is the
combination of the likelihood and severity of a specified hazardous event occurring. In
mathematical term, risk can be calculated
by the
equatio
n:
Risk
Risk= = Likelihood x Severity
Likelihood*Severity
LIKELIHOOD OF AN OCCURRENCE
This value is based on the likelihood of an event occurring. You may ask the
question How many times has this event happened in the past?:
Assessing likelihood is based worker experience, analysis or measurement. Likelihood levels range from most
likely to inconceivable. For example, a small spill of bleach from a container when filling a spray
bottle is most likely to occur during every shift. Alternatively, a leak of diesel fuel from a secure holding tank
may be less probable. Table A indicates likelihood using the following values
SEVERITY OF HAZARD
Severity can be divided into five categories. Severity is based upon an increasing level of severity to an
individuals health, the environment, or to property. Table B indicates severity by using the following table:
RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk can be presented in variety of ways to communicate the results of analysis to make decision on risk control.
For risk analysis that uses likelihood and severity in qualitative method, presenting result in a risk matrix is a very
effective way of communicating the distribution of the risk throughout a plant and area in a workplace. Risk can be
calculated using the following formula:
L x S = Relative Risk
L = Likelihood
S = Severity
Table C
To use this matrix, first find the severity column that best describes the outcome of risk. Then follow the likelihood
row to find the description that best suits the likelihood that the severity will occur. The risk level is given in the
box where the row and column meet. The relative risk value can be used to prioritize necessary actions to
effectively manage work place hazards. Table D determines priority based on the following ranges:
Table D
Hazards assessed, as High Risk must have immediate actions, to resolve risk to life safety and or the
environment. Individuals responsible for required action, including follow up must be clearly identified. A further
detail risk assessment method may require such as quantitative risk assessment as means of determine suitable
controls measures.
ii.
iii.
b. by organization intending to continuously improve OSH Management System. It should be the duty of the
employer to assign a trained personnel to lead a team of employees associated with one particular process or
activity to conduct HIRAC.
Process of HIRAC
ii.
severity of hazard;
iii.
LOCATION: PLANT
CONSTRUCTION OF
METAL GRANULATION
AGENCY:GAMMON INDIA
LTD
ACTIVITY / HAZARD
IDENTIFIED
EVENT
DANGER EXISTING
PRESENT CONTROL
Material
Handling
Not wearing
adequate PPE
Workers sitting
on unstable
slopes
Transporting Unergonomic
Raw materials work conditions
Worker
behavior
Accidental
fall
RISK
RATING
ADDITIONAL
CONTROLS
RISK
RATING
Timely
L
replacement &
Effective monitori
Weekly Training L
and Awareness
program
Automation and L
worker rotation
Ineffective
monitoring
Ergonomic Inadequate
injuries and Devices
diseases
Injuries,
No controls
cuts and
bruises
Training and
Good House
Keeping
Accidental
fall
No warning
signs
No controls
Setting proper
enclosure and
correct Signs
Strictly Prohibit
use of mobile
phone
Ineffective
Supervision
Supervisors
are less in
number
Awareness
program and
implement
effective
supervision
Proactive
inspection and
maintenance
Incorrect tool No
selection
knowledge
on tool
selection
Improper
Bad method of
enclosure
enclosure
Maintenance
issue
Follow rules
only when
safety officer
present
Poor quality of
equipments
being used
Accidents
Accidents Ineffective
and
inspection
breakdown
4.6. RESULT
From the HIRAC analysis of the MGP Construction site and after calculating the Risk value, it
has been found that the Maintenance issue of the equipments is having the highest risk of
Medium level even after Control measures are implemented
The current control measures may not be sufficient if a major violation occur in the construction
site. If the recommended control measures are in cooperated in the system, accidents can
be prevented to larger extent.
Apart from this workers are to be given realtime hazard based training . Recommended control
measures will decrease the accident and damage.
CONCLUSION
The major hazards in a steel plant are Dust, Noise, Handling hazards of molten metal .But
predominantly the most hazardous of them are the accidents cause due to material handling and
Conveyor belts. In the Steel plant major number of Fatalities is due to working on Conveyor
belts. Working on heights and transfer of Material through equipments like Hydra, Loader JCB
etc.
The best way to reduce these type fatal is by giving proper training prior to the commencing of
the work and also to give defense driving training to the Drivers.
Hazards caused due to Conveyor Belts are the most predominant in the Steel Plants and new and
advance techniques are coming in to force to overcome these hazards in future in a steel Plant.
If the recommendation and the hazards identified in the some of the divisions are rectified the
accidents in the plant can be controlled and it can become the safest steel plant in INDIA to a
greater extent
REFERENCE
Hughes, N., Chou, E, Price, C.J and Lee, M.1999, Automating mechanical FMEA using
functional models, Proceeding of the Twelfth international Florida AI Research Society
Conference, (AAAI Press, Melno, CA), pp.394-398.
Shirouyehzad, H, Badakhsian, M, Dabestani, R,
Panjehfoulan, H. 2010 FMEA Analysis for Identification and Control of Failure preferences in
ERP Implementation, The journal of Mathematics and Computer Science, Vol.1 No.4 (2010)
pp.366-376.
Arabian-Hoseynabadi, H, Oraee, H, Tavner, P.j. 2010
Failure Modes and Effect Analysis (FMEA) for Wind Turbines, International Journal of
electrical power and energy system.32 (7), pp-817-824.
WEBSITES: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JSW_Steel_Ltd
http://www.slideshare.net/prasenjitdebdas/technology-strategy-jsw-steel
http://www.jsw.in/steel/steel-making-process
https://www.aist.org/AIST/aist/AIST/Publications/safety%20first/14_may_safety-first.pdf
http://esatjournals.org/Volumes/IJRET/2014V03/I23/IJRET20140323007.pdf
http://www.worldstainless.org/Files/issf/non-imagefiles/PDF/ISSF_Good_Safety_Practice_in_Stainless_Steel.pdf
http://docslide.us/technology/corex-process-in-iron-making.html
http://ec.europa.eu/energy/intelligent/projects/sites/iee-projects/files/projects