POLICE 5
North Yorkshire boors
SPECTOR Kanacker has been splashing
taxpayers’ cash with abandon in Yorkshire
=all in the cause of closing down free speech.
North Yorkshire Police (NYP) has just
‘spent an estimated £1m-plus on a series
of inconclusive cases aimed at gagging a
pensioner “citizen journalist” whose website
has published embarrassing but true stories
about local establishment figures, including,
police and councillors.
Many stories broken by Nigel Ward (pictured,
top) on the websites Real Whithy and North
Yorks Enquirer have been followed up by the
Eve and other publications. His scoops include
the indifference of police and council to the fact
‘that the late mayor of Scarborough and .
friend of Jimmy Savile, Peter Jaconelli,
was a predatory paedophile (Eye 1370);
that senior members of the North
Yorkshire National Park Authority who
happened to be landowners stood to make ~
millions if they passed an application for
a controversial potash mine in the park
(Eye 1334); and that prominent Tory
councillor and former North Yorkshire
police authority chair Jane Kenyon-
Miller (pictured, bottom) had a string of
undeclared business failures behind her
which left unpaid debts in Britain and the US.
(Eye 1318). Not to mention stories of councillors’
expenses fiddles and unpaid council taxes.
Clearly Ward had to be stopped. In 2013
Scarborough borough council’s chief legal
officer Lisa Dixon spoke about “closing down”
Real Whitby if the stream of “defamatory and
untrue” stories didn’t stop (Eve 1338). Trouble
was, they were all true, so a libel case wasn't an
option. The following year an attempt to smear
Ward as a benefits fraudster was given short
shrift by the Department for Work and Pensions
(Eye 1367) and Real Whithy came out of a BBC
investigation into its stories with flying colours.
An attempt was then made to bring criminal
charges of “harassment” against Ward and two
other Real Whitby contributors, Tim Hicks and
Peter Hofschr&er. The wrapping-up of the three
men’s cases was Ward's misfortune. While
there was never any serious case against him,
the position regarding Hicks and Hofschréer
was more complicated. Real Whitby had given
space to Hofschréer, who had an axe to grind
with York city council and the police over their
handling of a complicated family property
dispute and had made wild allegations of
corruption and collusion by the authorities.
Police launched an investigation, Operation
Rome, which lasted almost three years and
cost just shy of £410,000. Alas, the Crown
Prosecution Service twice refused to bring
criminal charges. No sooner was Rome closed
down than NYP embarked on a follow-up,
Operation Hyson, which eventually begat a
civil case for harassment which petered out at
Leeds county court at the end of July.
An initial list of nine claimants included three
serving senior NYP officers, Chief Constable
Dave Jones, his deputy Tim Madgwick and Chief
Supt Lisa Winward. But by the time the
case got to Leeds, only Kenyon-Miller
remained in the fight, and Ward was the
sole remaining defendant. Judgment had
been entered against Hofschréer last
‘November after he refused to take part
in proceedings, and a settlement was,
agreed in the case of Hicks last June,
whereby he undertook not to contact
members of the Hofschréer family and to
take down scores of online articles about
the property dispute. Military historian
Hofschréer, meanwhile, was convicted
on child pornography charges in July and
sentenced to 30 months in prison.
At the conclusion of the case, Nigel Ward
agreed not to write about Kenyon-Miller any
more as long as she remained out of public
office. No order for costs or damages was made
against him — and his costs, yet to be assessed,
will be by the claimants.
The decision to pursue the case and fund
it out of taxpayers’ money was taken by Chief
Constable Jones, according to the local police
and crime commissioner Julia Mulligan, even
though he was a party to the proceedings.
Knacker is shy about the cost of Operation
Hyson. It is hard to see that it could have cost
less than the £410,000 quoted for Rome. NYP.
admits that it spent more than £217,000 on.
external solicitors and barristers for Hyson.
So at a conservative estimate, a stretched
rural force appears to have spent well over
£1m funding futile cases in which senior
police officers and a former chair of the police
authority were claimants.
Evening all!
In the Back team on 020 7437 4017 or email: strobes@private-eye.co.uk