Press Release

September 6, 2016

Murder charges against Reginald Collins dismissed

Charges of Open Murder, Felon in Possession of a Firearm, Felony Firearm, and Habitual Offender
supplemental charges against Reginald Collins are now dismissed.
The case originated when Richard Street was found dead in the backyard of 1250 Union Street in the
City of Benton Harbor on the morning of December 9, 2014. Street had one gunshot wound to back
of the head.
Neighbors reported hearing gun shots the previous evening varying anywhere from 8:30 pm to 10:00
pm. A witness, Timothy Lofton, after repeated interviews finally told investigators he was a witness
to the homicide and said he saw Reginald Collins shoot Street while Lofton was driving through the
alley behind 1250 Union Street. There were some inconsistencies in Lofton's statement, but
prosecutors felt his eyewitness account could overcome those issues.
Cell telephone records were accumulated from a number of phones including Collins, Street and
Lofton for the evening of December 8. That data and graphically integrated maps made it originally
appear Collins was in South Bend (by virtue of a cell call) at 7:44 pm, 1 hour and 38 minutes before
a cell phone call from Lofton to Street which was within moments of when Lofton says Collins shot
Street, being 9:22 pm. Certainly, Collins could travel the 35 miles in that 1 hour and 38 minutes.
In preparation for trial scheduled to begin September 20, review of this cell tower data with experts
revealed that, though the tower was in the Eastern time zone (South Bend), it is tied to a server in
Illinois, being in the Central time zone. This means that Collins would have been in South Bend at
8:44 leaving only 38 minutes to drive 35 miles. While the US 31 By-pass would permit speeds over
70 mph, there is considerable city street driving required at both ends. Test driving revealed little
opportunity to complete the travel in the allotted time.
With the state of the original evidence with which the prosecution was originally prepared to go to
trial, this new analysis of the cell tower data has created doubt such that prosecutors believe a jury
could rationally conclude there is reasonable doubt as to Collins guilt. Therefore, dismissal is now
required.
The dismissal is without prejudice which means charges can be brought against Collins at a later
date. Collins will likely be transported to Georgia where there is a probation violation warrant for
him on a drug charge.

Press release available at County Web site:

http://www.berriencounty.org/ProsecutingAttorney/pressreleases