Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Survey of Hospital Emergency Department Administrators 2010
Survey of Hospital Emergency Department Administrators 2010
IN THIS REPORT:
INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................. 3
METHODOLOGY ................................................................................................. 4
SUMMARY STATEMENT ..................................................................................... 4
KEY FINDINGS OF THE SURVEY ................................................................... 5-13
TRENDS AND OBSERVATIONS ................................................................... 14-16
CONCLUSION .................................................................................................... 17
INTRODUCTION
BY UPHOLDING THE
PATIENTS
METHODOLOGY
Throughout June, July and August of 2010, Schumacher Groups 2010 Survey of Emergency
Department Administrators was sent by mail to approximately 6,075 hospital emergency
department administrators/managers in 50 states. Of those mailed, approximately 4,049 also
received the survey via email.
Six hundred and three completed surveys were received by September, 2010, yielding a
response rate of 10%.
SUMMARY STATEMENT
Schumacher Groups 2010 Survey of Emergency Department Administrators suggests that
health reform, though providing medical insurance to over 30 million previously uninsured
patients, will not decrease patient visits to hospital emergency departments. Indeed, most
hospital emergency department administrators indicated the reverse will be true and that
patient volume at their facilities will increase as health reform is implemented. The majority
believe their emergency departments will see more patients unable to access primary care and
specialists post-reform than they did prior to reform. Most emergency department
administrators also believe that lack of physician specialists available to cover the emergency
department poses risks to emergency department patients a very significant risk in some
cases.
While most hospitals have invested in electronic medical records (EMR) in their emergency
departments, the majority of emergency department administrators indicated that to date the
investment has not been worth the cost. Of the various concerns facing emergency department
administrators over the next 12 months, reimbursement issues are deemed the most
important, followed by health reform.
The great majority of emergency department administrators indicated their facilities are at
times unable to transfer mental/behavioral health patients to inpatient facilities in a timely
manner. This poses risks to patients and underlines a growing crisis in mental healthcare in
which hospital emergency departments must house mental health patients who have few or
no inpatient options.
36%
51-100
17%
100-200
19%
201 or more
28%
51-100
17%
28%
100-200
19%
3%
3%
3%
3%
2%
2%
2%
2%
2%
2%
NE
WI
AR
MD
OR
WA
CO
TN
AZ
MT
2%
2%
2%
1%
1%
1%
1%
1%
1%
1%
NM
SD
UT
NH
SC
VA
WY
MA
CT
ID
1%
1%
1%
1%
1%
1%
1%
1%
1%
1%
MS
WV
ND
ME
HI
NV
RI
1%
1%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
3. How many patients do you see in your Emergency Department per year?
0-9,000
24%
9,001-16,000
23%
16,001-20,000
7%
20,001-40,000
23%
23%
0-9,000
23%
24%
23%
7%
23%
9,001-16,000
16,001-20,000
20,001-40,000
4. Consider the new health care reform law. How do you believe reform will affect
patient volume at your ED?
66%
5%
17%
Unsure
12%
Volume will
increase
12%
Volume will
decrease
17%
5%
66%
Volume will
remain the same
Unsure
5. How do you believe health reform will affect quality of care delivered by your ED?
Quality of care will
improve
Quality of care will decline
Quality of care will
remain the same
Unsure
9%
10%
17% 9%
10%
64%
17%
64%
Unsure
6.
26%
11-20%
33%
21-30%
26%
31-40%
7%
41-50%
3%
51-60%
2%
61-70%
1%
71-80%
1%
81-90%
<1%
71-80% Uninsured
1%
81-90% Uninsured
N/A
0-10% Uninsured
11-20% Uninsured
3%
7%
21-30% Uninsured
26%
31-40% Uninsured
41-50% Uninsured
26%
33%
51-60% Uninsured
61-70% Uninsured
N/A
7. How do you believe this number will change as health reform is implemented?
Will see more uninsured patients in our ED
22%
43%
19%
22%
19%
16%
43%
Fewer uninsured
patients in our ED
No change in number of
uninsured patients in ED
Unsure
8. A recent study suggests that uninsured patients DO NOT use the ER more than
insured patients. Do you agree or disagree?
Agree
30%
Disagree
70%
30%
70%
Agree
Disagree
9. How do you believe health reform will affect your facilitys ability to find physicians
for the ED?
ED physicians will be harder to find
39%
2%
ED physicians will be
harder to find
45%
14%
14%
39%
45%
2%
ED physicians will be
easier to find
No change in our ability
to find ED physicians
Unsure
10. How will health reform affect staffing of mid-level practitioners (NPs and PAs) in your
ED?
Will increase our use of mid-levels
50%
34%
Unsure
16%
16%
<1%
50%
34%
11. Some patients come to the ED because they cannot access PRIMARY CARE physicians
in a timely manner. How do you believe health reform will affect this trend at your
ED?
We will see more
patients who cannot access
primary care physicians
We will see fewer
patients who cannot access
primary care physicians
There will be no change
Unsure
64%
8%
7%
21%
21%
7%
64%
8%
Unsure
12. Some patients come to the ED because they cannot access SPECIALIST physicians in a
timely manner. How do you believe health reform will affect this trend at your ED?
We will see more
patients who cannot access
specialist physicians
We will see fewer
patients who cannot access
specialist physicians
There will be no change
55%
Unsure
10%
10%
3%
32%
55%
32%
3%
Unsure
13. Rate the level of risk that lack of specialty coverage poses to patients in your ED.
Very significant risk
12%
Significant risk
26%
Moderate risk
36%
Minimal risk
22%
No risk
4%12%
Significant risk
26%
4%
Moderate risk
Minimal risk
36%
No risk
14. Which types of specialist coverage is in the shortest supply at your facility? Pick
TWO ONLY.
Orthopedic surgeons
19%
Orthopedic surgeons
Neurosurgeons
18%
Neurosurgeons
Neurologists
17%
Cardiologists
11%
General surgeons
9%
Otolaryngologists
9%
Other
7%
Cardiovascular surgeons
5%
6%
Neurologists
5%6% 19%
7%
9%
18%
9%
11% 17%
Cardiologists
General surgeons
Otolaryngologists
Other
Cardiovascular surgeons
None, all coverage needs met
Yes
36%
No
64%
36%
64%
Yes
No
16. If yes, with the implementation of health reform, do you expect to pay specialist
physicians more, less or the same amount to cover your ED?
More
52%
Less
3%
The same
45%
More
45%
52%
Less
The same
3%
17. Under health reform, where do you anticipate reimbursement to your ED is heading
for the following payors?
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
Reimbursement will
increase
Will decrease
Medicaid
5%
75%
20%
Medicare
12%
74%
14%
6%
70%
24%
Commercial insurance
18. Has your hospital invested in electronic medical records within the ED?
Yes
73%
No
27%
27%
Yes
73%
No
19. If yes, has your return on investment TO THIS DATE been worth the cost?
Yes
44%
No
56%
56%
44%
Yes
No
20. Do you believe your return on EMR investment will EVENTUALLY be worth the cost?
Yes
76%
No
24%
24%
Yes
No
76%
10
21. Please indicate whether you agree or disagree with the following statements
regarding the impact of EMR within your ED.
33%
Disagree
67%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
0%
20%
60%
Disagree
40%
72%
Disagree
28%
40%
60%
80%
31%
Disagree
69%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
33%
Disagree
67%
22. Are there times when your facility is UNABLE to transfer mental/behavioral patients
to inpatient facilities in a timely manner?
We are often unable
to do so
We are sometimes
unable to do so
We are rarely unable
to do so
We are always able
to transfer mental/behavioral
patients in a timely manner
56%
We are often unable to do so
30%
11%
3%
3%
11%
30%
11
23. What are the LONGEST boarding times for mental/behavioral patients at your
facility?
12 hours or less
29%
24 hours
30%
2 days
20%
5 days
11%
>1 week
10%
12 hours or less
10%
11%
29%
24 hours
2 days
20%
5 days
30%
>1 week
24. Is patient care ever compromised at your facility due to delays in transferring
mental/behavioral patients to inpatient facilities?
Yes, for mental patients only
32%
28%
No
40%
32%
40%
28%
No
25. How would you rank the following concerns/priorities facing your ED in the next
12 months?
Most
important
72%
Somewhat
Least
25%
3%
78%
19%
3%
Health reform
43%
48%
9%
35%
45%
20%
Uncompensated care
34%
44%
22%
30%
46%
24%
Overcrowding of ED
36%
37%
27%
35%
36%
29%
EMR implementation
28%
37%
35%
Shortage of ED physicians
25%
39%
36%
ED physician competence
34%
34%
32%
18%
36%
46%
12
Lack of
specialty
physician
coverage
Poor public
EMR
Overcrowding
Shortage of ED physician
image of the implementati
of ED
ED physicians competence
department
on
EMTALA
compliance
investigation
Most important
72%
78%
43%
35%
34%
30%
36%
35%
28%
25%
34%
18%
Somewhat
25%
19%
48%
45%
44%
46%
37%
36%
37%
39%
34%
36%
Least
3%
3%
9%
20%
22%
24%
27%
29%
35%
36%
32%
46%
26. If you were seriously hurt and had a variety of options to choose from, would you
go to your own hospitals ED, or would you choose to go elsewhere in hopes of
obtaining better care?
93%
7%
7%
Would choose my
hospitals ED
93%
Would go elsewhere
13
Most ED administrators (64%) said their facilities will see more patients who cannot access
primary care physicians in a timely manner due to health reform, while over half (55%) said their
facilities will see more patients who cannot see a specialist in a timely manner due to health
reform. As a consequence, the survey suggests some ED administrators believe demand for ED
physicians will increase and recruiting ED physicians will be more difficult. Thirty-nine percent
of those surveyed said finding physicians for the ED will be harder due to health reform, while
only 2% said finding physicians for the ED will be easier. In response, many administrators (50%)
said that they will increase the use of mid-level practitioners such as physician assistants and
nurse practitioners at their facilities.
*Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
**Boston Globe, April 24, 2009
14
Uncompensated care
was ranked as most
important or somewhat
important by more
respondents than any
other factor.
16
CONCLUSION
For more information about this survey or about Schumacher Group, contact:
17