Download as doc, pdf, or txt
Download as doc, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 1

Are there significative differences in absorption of vibrations between cast iron and

ductile iron?
In grey iron the morphology of the graphite interrupts the matrix, in consequence, the
propagation of vibrations is reduced, however in ductile iron the spheroidal shape of the
graphite does not interrupt the matrix . i would like to know if; there are differences in
absorption of vibration in this materials?, and, if the behaviour of the materials is different;
there are significant differences?
Thanks
German Abate
Instituto Nacional de Tecnologia Industrial

My answer to your question will be counter intuitive. My experience is that of musical


metallic strings. The experiments we conducted show a reduction of the damping coefficient
when metallic strings are stretched on a bench with ad hoc sensors. For a string were never
tense, is measured at the time T0 the damping coefficient of each of its eigenmodes ; then we
repeat these measures over time, T1, T2, T3... We then noticed a decrease in the damping for
all eignemodes, then, after awhile, damping stop decrease, and it is at this time that musicians
feel that the string has reached its optimum qualities. The metal strings of iron, steel, brass,
copper ... all have the same behaviour. Strings are drawn stock passing through dies, which
means that the grains, closely bonded together, present a continuity for wave deformation
propagation ; the damping depends on the propagation of waves in the metal crystal. When
the string is stretched, it occurs then micro ruptures between grains which induce dislocations
in the macro structure of the metal. These dislocations have the effect to block the grains
between them and thus allow a reduction of the damping [1]. All this, the theory and the
calculaion are in the book by Claude Valette and Christian Cuesta, Mcanique de la corde
vibrante , dition Herms, Paris, 1993.
All this to say that I think the cast iron must have less damping than ductile iron. Indeed, the
iron is characterized by grains trapped by dislocations (that is why the iron is brittle,
breakable and non-ductile), while the soft ductile iron has a greater damping. Moreover the
musicians of harpsichord and piano forte of the beginning of the 19th century set up of iron
strings know that the strings spend several months before speaking
[1] C. Cuesta, C. Valette Evolution temporelle de la vibration des cordes de clavecin Acta
Acustica united with Acustica, Volume 66, Number 1, June 1988, pp. 37-45(9). Publisher: S.
Hirzel Verlag
Charles Besnainou

You might also like