Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Installation Tips For Reducing Gas Generator Set Maintenance Costs
Installation Tips For Reducing Gas Generator Set Maintenance Costs
Installation Tips For Reducing Gas Generator Set Maintenance Costs
CaterpillarInstallationTipsforReducingGasGeneratorSetM...OnlineCommunity
InstallationTipsforReducingGasGeneratorSetMaintenanc
eCosts
byNicholasKelsch(KelscNM)on
0929201012:23PM
Often,serviceabilitycanbeoverlookedwhendoingdetaileddesignworkforagasgensetinstallation.Herearesome
simpleideasforgaspowerplantdesignthathavethepotentialtoreducemaintenancecosts,increaseuptime,and
reduceoveralllifecyclecosts.
Askyourmanufacturerorsupplierifthesestrategiescanbeusedatyoursite,eitherbeforeoraftergensetinstallation.
1.Matchthecapacityofyourbulkoilstoragetanktothesizeoftheoildeliverytrucktoreducethecostofdeliveredoil.
2.Matchthesizeoftheoilmakeuptanktooilconsumption.Forexample,a1,600kWgensetcouldhaveapproximately
140gallonsofoilcapacitywithafillindicationat30gallonsbelowfull.Ifthemidlifeoilconsumptionis6.2gallonsaday,
youdtopoffevery45days.Byinstallinga150gallonlubeoilmakeuptank,theoiltopoffintervalwouldbemonthly,
savingtechnicianlabor.
3.Overheadliftingcapabilitycansavemoneybyreducinglaborhoursespeciallywhenitcomestolargergensets.
Usingthesameexampleasabove,overthecourseof20years,overhaulworkwillrequireanestimated1,500labor
hours.Anonsitehoistmightreducethelaborcommitmentbyupto20percent,or300hoursforoneengine.
4.PreinstallportsandsensorsforemissionsandO2readingsinyourexhaustpipingtoreducethetimeassociatedwith
takingreadings.
5.Meterandrecordthetotalcoolantdrainvolumewhenchangingcoolant.Usethisinformationtofilltheexactamount
everytime,preventingspills.
6.Installquickconnect/disconnectmechanismforfasteroilandfilterchanges.
7.Consideracompressedairenginestarterandhardwired24VDCconnectiontoremovethecostandhazardsof
batterymaintenance.
8.Besidesscheduledoilanalysis,agasfuelanalysispriortoinstallationprovidesabaselinesampleofyourfuel
compositionandcontaminants.Regulargassamplingmightalsobeincludedinamaintenanceprogram,particularlyfor
lowenergyapplicationssuchaslandfillorbiogasorifyourengineisexperiencingdetonation.
Thesearejusteightideasthatyoucanapplytoyourgasgensetinstallationtoextendgensetserviceabilityandreduce
costs.Thesesuggestionsmaynormaynotapplytoallinstallationsdependingonthesizeofgensetpackage,
application,hoursofoperation,etc.Also,thislistisfarfromcomplete.
Haveyouoryourserviceprovidertriedanyoftheabovesuggestions?Whatisyourexperience?
Whatareyourideastomakegensetservicemoreefficient?
Haveyoueverseenyourenginegointodetonation(knock)duetoachangeinfuelcomposition?
Howoftendoyoutestyourfuelcompositionandmakeengineadjustments?
Pleasepostyourthoughtsbelow.
Everyone'sTags: access accessability change consumption cost
ViewAll(9)
Comments
byjospoweron
1006201009:03AM
http://208.74.204.235/t5/blogs/blogarticleprintpage/blogid/EP_Blog/articleid/147
1/5
19/8/2015
CaterpillarInstallationTipsforReducingGasGeneratorSetM...OnlineCommunity
Loadtestingisanotherexpense.NewNFPArulesrequiremonthlyloadtestingforsomeinstallations.I'veheardofa
permanentlyinstalledloadtesterthatconnectstothegridanddoesn'tuseresistors.Isthiscosteffective(it'sdefinitely
green,sincethepowerisn'tbeingburnedinaresistor)
bymarkslumon
1006201011:11AM
Veryhelpfulpost.I'vealsoseensomesuccessfulcombustioncatalystsystemthatreducesfuelconsumptionandlower
emissionsindieselengines.
www.wpowerproducts.com
byrjhintzon
1006201011:18AM
Thisisareallyusefultopic,butIhavesomequestionsassomeonewhodealswithgeneratorsfromadistance,soto
speak,inadatacenterdesigncapacity.
IthoughtIunderstoodelementaryterminology,butapparentlynot.Inspeakingof"gas"gensets,Iassume,perhaps
wrongly,thatmostorallofthisappliestodieselfueledgensets,right?WhenIhear"gas,"Ithinknaturalgas,whichisafuel
choice,asIunderstandit,butthatisn'tthecontexthere.Theoverheadliftcapabilityisindependentoffuel,Iassume.
#1,Matchingsizeofoilstorage(fueloil,right?)totheoildeliverytruckwouldseemtobedependentonthesupplier,which
couldvarybycontract,Isuppose,unlessthere'sabestpractice,"onesizesfitsall"strategythatmostlyworks,regardlessof
whothesupplieris.Inatypicalinstallation,isthereapercentofcostaddonformatchingthesizeofoilstorage?Thatis,
perhapsmatchingsizeadds1%,or2%,orX%totheonetimeinstallationcost,orperhapsitdoesn'taddanything.
#2,Matchingsizeofmakeuptank:what'sthestrategyforgeneratorsusedforstandby?Usuallythere'slittleorno
consumption,exceptfortesting.However,inanoutagesituate,thegeneratorrunsessentiallyconstantly.
#3,Overheadlift:understandingthateverysiteissomewhatdifferent,howmuchdoesaddingoverheadlifttypicalladd?Is
this$1K,$10K,$25Kaddon?
#46:typicaladdoncost?
#7,addoncost?Whataredisadvantagestothis?
#8,typicaladdedcosts?
Thanksforstartingthistopicandanyclarifyinganswers.
bypumpprincesson
1006201011:58AM
InstallaprelubesystemoradcbackupprelubesystemfromVARNAProducts!
Moneysaving,increasingequipmentlifeandreliabilitysmiles2share)
byNicholasKelsch(KelscNM)on
1011201009:18AM
Responsestorjhintz'squestions:
IthoughtIunderstoodelementaryterminology,butapparentlynot.Inspeakingof"gas"gensets,Iassume,perhaps
wrongly,thatmostorallofthisappliestodieselfueledgensets,right?
Enginemanufacturersandgensetpackagescommonlyrefertodieselfueledgensetsasdieselgensets,and
gaseousfueledgensetsasgasgensets.
http://208.74.204.235/t5/blogs/blogarticleprintpage/blogid/EP_Blog/articleid/147
2/5
19/8/2015
CaterpillarInstallationTipsforReducingGasGeneratorSetM...OnlineCommunity
WhenIhear"gas,"Ithinknaturalgas,whichisafuelchoice,asIunderstandit,butthatisn'tthecontexthere.Theoverhead
liftcapabilityisindependentoffuel,Iassume.
Yes.Manyoftheserecommendationscouldapplytoeitherdieselorgasfuelgensets,buttheyaretargetedmore
towardsprimepowerorcontinuouspowerapplicationswheretheenginesarerunningthousandsofhoursperyear,
versus20100hoursperyearinthecaseofanemergencystandbyinstallation.
#1,Matchingsizeofoilstorage(fueloil,right?)totheoildeliverytruckwouldseemtobedependentonthesupplier,which
couldvarybycontract,Isuppose,unlessthere'sabestpractice,"onesizesfitsall"strategythatmostlyworks,regardlessof
whothesupplieris.Inatypicalinstallation,isthereapercentofcostaddonformatchingthesizeofoilstorage?Thatis,
perhapsmatchingsizeadds1%,or2%,orX%totheonetimeinstallationcost,orperhapsitdoesn'taddanything.
No.Theintentionherewastoreferencethelubricatingoilstorageforaprimepowerapplication.Thesepackages
consumeoilaspartofnormaloperation,andalsorequireregularoilchangesbasedonoperatinghours.Ifthetypical
primepowerdieselgensetrequiresoilchangesevery500hours,andagaspackagerequiresoilchangesevery
10002000hours,thenoilbecomesaveryregularconsumable.Oilchangequantitiesforlarger(>1000kW)genset
packagesoperatingcontinuouslyareinthehundredsofgallonsofoil,andoilconsumptionquantitiesareinthe
dozensofgallonsofoilperweek.
#2,Matchingsizeofmakeuptank:what'sthestrategyforgeneratorsusedforstandby?Usuallythere'slittleorno
consumption,exceptfortesting.However,inanoutagesituate,thegeneratorrunsessentiallyconstantly.
Nobenefitforstandbyoperation.
#3,Overheadlift:understandingthateverysiteissomewhatdifferent,howmuchdoesaddingoverheadlifttypicalladd?Is
this$1K,$10K,$25Kaddon?
Itisasignificantinvestmentthatwouldbeinthe10'softhousandsofdollars.Again,thisrecommendationwouldnot
applytostandbyapplicationswhereyourunverylimitedhoursperyear.
#46:typicaladdoncost?
#4Estimateafewhundreddollars,plusacouplehoursofservicelabor.
#5Noadditionalcostifconductedaspartofroutinemaintenance.
#6Estimateafewthousanddollarsforalarger(>1000kW)package
#7,addoncost?Whataredisadvantagestothis?
Assumecostsslightlyhigherthanthoseofanelectricstartsystem.Therearenosignificantdisadvantagesother
thantheneedtomonitorandperformmaintenanceonanairsystem.
#8,typicaladdedcosts?
Thesecanvarydependingontheanalysisproviderandthetypeoffuelanalysis.Estimateseveralhundredstoa
thousanddollars.
Greatfeedbackeveryone,keepitcoming.
Nick
bymikelon
1012201009:23PM
Beforeconstructionreviewdesignofpipingandsupportsystemswithserviceinmind.Thingslikehighpointventsandlow
pointdrainsseemssmall,butwhenyouspendhourstryingtoventacoolingsystemitreallywasn'tthatmuchextracost.
Pipesupportsalsoseemlikegoodideastomechanicalcontractoruntilatechnicianpointsoutitblocksaccesstoaservice
point.
Ongasengines.alwaysprovidefuelfilterswithgaugesformonitoring,"cleandry"gassuppliedbyutilitymaynotbeclean
anddry.Makesureanoperablevalvewithabilitytolockoutisinstalled,acheapplugvalvethatneedsa4footwrenchto
closewilllikelyendupbeingaproblem.
Makesurecoolingsystemhavepointstodrawcoolantsamplesandtoaddchemicals,primepowersystemsneedregular
coolingsystemmaintenance,evenwithELC.
Reviewaccess,lookatpipingrunsforcoolant,airandexhaust,seenlotsofsitesthatrequiredpartialdisassemblyof
exhaustsystemtopullpistonsandliners.Makesurespoolpiecesareinpipingthatwillneedremovalforservice,taking
downa20footsectionofpipefor3feetofaccesswillcostmanytimesoverinlifeofaplant.Samethingwithcoolantlines,
http://208.74.204.235/t5/blogs/blogarticleprintpage/blogid/EP_Blog/articleid/147
3/5
19/8/2015
CaterpillarInstallationTipsforReducingGasGeneratorSetM...OnlineCommunity
makesureapumpcanbeserviced,preferablywithoutdrainingentiresystembyproperuseofisolationvalves.
Ifyouaddahoist,makesureyouknowwhatit'sgoingtobeusedforandit'slimitations,a1000lbhoistwouldbegreatfor
mostpartsbutassuresomeonedownthelinedoesn'toverloaditanddostructuraldamageorhurtsomeone(seenthat
morethanonce).
Makesurethingslikeserviceair,waterandelectricaloutletsarenearwheretheworkgetsdone,notonlytheenginebut
thingslikeheatexchangersneedcleaningtoo.Addstimeandriskiftheservicetechhastorunacordorairline100'.
Goodworklightingimprovesrepairprocess,badlightinginvitessomethingbeingmissed.
Makesureaccessformajorrepairsisconsidered,likeaccesstosideofblockforbearinginspection/replacement.
Considersomeworstcasepossiblities,likegettingacrankout,howwillitbedoneandisthereroomforit?Samethingfor
thetailend,inaprimepowersitelikelyhoodoftailendneedingshopserviceishigh.Aretheconduitsnotintheway?
Canyougetitoutwithoutremovingentirepackage,etc.
Considerrelocatingjunctionboxes,gaugepanelsandsomesensorsawayfromserviceareasofengine,tryingtodoa
valveadjustmentaroundagaugepanelusuallyresultsinextratimeneeded,andinsomecasesamistakethatcancause
anenginefailure.Rememberthefactoryinstallstheseitemsclosetotheenginefortheirconvienence,notyours.
Considertheareaaroundtheenginefordealingwithremovedandnewparts,andpossibleriskstopersonelhandling
thoseparts,mosteverythingisheavy,somaybeabitofextraclearenceoranefforttomakesurethesurroundingareais
levelforsafeworkingisworthreview?Ioncehadadesignerarguethepointwithme,Igavehima50lbbagofsandand
toldhimtowalkaroundtheenginethenoutoftheenclosure,hegotthepoint.
ModerngasenginesrequireafairlylargeDCpowersourceforcontrolsandignition,sojusteliminatingstartingbatteries
maynotalwayseliminatetheneedforbatteriesatall.Airstartsystemshavetheirownissues,dependingonstarting
requirementsandambientconditions.FranklyI'vefoundlongtermmaintenancecostsforairstartsystemsmorethancosts
forDCsystemson3400and3500seriesengines.Goingtoturbinestartersisusuallybetterthanvanetype,butairstorage
andpipingstillanissue,asisthecompressor.FunnyhowmanyairstartersI'verebuiltovertheyearsbecausesomeone
didn'taddoiltothelubricator.
MakesureLockOutTagOutcanbesafelyandquicklydonewhenneeded,majorrepairsrequireassurancethatthe
enginecannotturnuncontrolled,meansthestartmethodneedsdisabledandthebreakerneedstoberackedoutor
isolated.Needtomakesurethedesignandoperatingproceduressupportdoingthisrightwhenneeded.Whatiscostof
havingunitdownandabunchoftechsstandingaroundbecausethebreakercan'tberackedoutduetomanypossible
reasons?Alsoknowwherecircuitsthatfeedheaters,pumpsandothersupportequipmentare,andhowtomakethemsafe
aswell.
bypervinon
1221201011:17AM
AllgreattipsNick,
ManyoftheLFGprojectsImanageddidn'thaverunningwateratthesites.Thiscanbeabigissuewithrespecttoservice
androutineoperations.Ialwayswonderedwhysomeonewouldgotoalltheexpenseofrentingportapottysandthelike
andnotconsiderinstallingalowcostitemlikeawatermain.Especiallywhenyouareconstanstlytrenchingandinstalling
plasticpipinginthelandfillitself.Gofigure.
byvondanikkenon
0130201310:13AM
Thisisanexcellentpost,installingthesecanbeapain,weatNationalPowerSupplyappreciatepostslikethissowecan
passthisvaluableinformationalongtoourcustomers.
byVincentScatenaon
0402201505:01PM
Thisisagoodarticle,thoughalsodependingonindustrytherearesomeothertricksonreducingmaintenancecosts.
Iknowinaggregate,andminingespecially,wellservicedandsealed"weatherprotection"andcontainerscandramatically
reducemaintenancebyreducingparticulates.IsawsomegoodoptionsonIndustrialMotorPower.
http://208.74.204.235/t5/blogs/blogarticleprintpage/blogid/EP_Blog/articleid/147
4/5
19/8/2015
CaterpillarInstallationTipsforReducingGasGeneratorSetM...OnlineCommunity
1 min to Spreed
http://208.74.204.235/t5/blogs/blogarticleprintpage/blogid/EP_Blog/articleid/147
5/5