Federal District Judge Finds in favor of Abbott Labs Employee in HIV discrimination suit trial attorney raymond dieppa successful settlement employment gender discrimination fair labor
verdict trial attorney successful punitive
ray dieppa raymond dieppa partner ruling abbott labs abbott
Federal District Judge Finds in favor of Abbott Labs Employee in HIV discrimination suit trial attorney raymond dieppa successful settlement employment gender discrimination fair labor
verdict trial attorney successful punitive
ray dieppa raymond dieppa partner ruling abbott labs abbott
Federal District Judge Finds in favor of Abbott Labs Employee in HIV discrimination suit trial attorney raymond dieppa successful settlement employment gender discrimination fair labor
verdict trial attorney successful punitive
ray dieppa raymond dieppa partner ruling abbott labs abbott
s2aa016 Florida Supreme Court ejects arbitration in nursing home ijury case | Migr’ Herals
MIAML-DADE COUNTY — SEPTEMBER 22, 2016 3:06 PM
Florida Supreme Court rejects arbitration in
nursing-home injury case
BY JIM SAUNDERS.
News Service of Florida
TALLAHASSEE — With similar questions popping up across the state in recent years, the Florida
Supreme Court on Thursday said a lawsuit about injuries suffered by a nursing-home resident
should not be sent to arbitration.
phew miamiherale cominewstocalcommuritymiami-dadeartclo109464677 hint 18s2un016 Florida Supreme Court ejects arbitration in nursing home ijury case | Migr’ Herals
The Miami-Dade County case centered on a contract that was signed in 2009 by Juan Mendez Jr.
when his father, Juan Sr., was admitted to Hampton Court Nursing Center, the ruling said. Part of
the contract said legal disputes would be resolved in arbitration, rather than going to court and
potentially being decided by a jury.
But in 2011, the elder Mendez suffered an infection that required the removal of his left eye. The
son later filed a lawsuit against the nursing home in Miami-Dade County Circuit Court on his
father’s behalf, but the nursing home argued that the case should go to arbitration. The father
died in 2013, but the legal dispute continued.
A circuit judge and the 3rd District Court of Appeal agreed with the nursing home’s position that
the case should go to arbitration. But in a 5-2 decision Thursday, the Supreme Court said the
father could not be bound by an arbitration requirement that his son had signed without the
father’s agreement.
“We would never enforce an admission agreement if a nursing home obtained a resident's
signature by threatening the violent destruction of the resident’s property unless the resident
signed the agreement,” said the majority opinion, written by Justice James E.C. Perry and joined
by Chief Justice Jorge Labarga and justices Barbara Pariente, R. Fred Lewis and Peggy Quince. “If
‘we will not enforce a contract when a party agrees under threat or duress, then we should not
enforce a contract in the absence of the party’s agreement altogether.”
But justices Charles Canady and Ricky Polston wrote dissenting opinions, with Polston saying the
majority opinion “obliterates longstanding Florida contract law” related to such issues.
Polston cited part of the 3rd District Court of Appeal ruling that said the father “lacked the
capacity to give informed consent or make medical decisions” when admitted to the nursing
home. While the son did not have a power of attorney, he indicated in signing the admission
agreement that he was his father’s representative.
The majority’s decisis
by Hampton Court being denied arbitration with Juan Mendez Jr, the very person who signed the
contract at issue,” Polston argued in his dissent.
ion will allow courts to arbitrarily disavow arbitration clauses as occurs here
Perry, however, wrote that the majority found the “father’s mental capacity does not impact the
outcome of this case.”
“Any adult person — presumably including an individual affiliated with Hampton Court — could
have petitioned for a court to adjudicate the father incapacitated and appoint a guardian [under
state law],” Perry wrote. “An appointed guardian would have held the power to contract on the
phew miamiherale cominewstocalcommuritymiami-dadeartclo109464677 hint 20s2un016 Florida Supreme Court ejects arbitration innursinghome ijury case | Miami Herald
father’s behalf for his residency at Hampton Court. Hampton Court elected not to seek
appointment of a guardian, and we decline to use common law contract principles to conduct an
end-run around the Legislature’s comprehensive guardianship scheme.”
Appeals courts across the state in recent years have dealt with questions about the validity of
arbitration agreements that nursing-home residents or family members have signed at the time of
admission.
‘The cases have dealt with a variety of scenarios, but Perry's majority opinion said appeals courts
were divided in their handling of disputes involving facts similar to the Mendez case.
fyvyue
MORE MIAMI-DADE COUNTY
COMMENTS:
0. Comments Sort by Oldest
Add a comment.
Facebook Comments Phin
phew miamiherale cominewstocalcommuritymiami-dadeartclo109464677 hint