6/4/2010 Baca Wins His Battle Against Term Limit…

Advertisement

YOU ARE HERE: LAT Hom e → Collections → Cour t Rulings

Ads by Google Los Angeles

Watch the AC360 Baca Wins His Battle Against Term Limits
Videos A judge sides with the sheriff's challenge of a 2002 voter-approved measure. The Board of
Where Truth Got in the Supervisors decides to not challenge the ruling.
Way of an Agenda.
FreedomMag.org/AC360_Videos Nov em ber 1 1 , 2004 | Jack Leonard, Tim es Staff Writer

In a victory for Los Angeles County Sheriff Lee Baca's fight against term limits, a Superior Court judge last month
Northern California struck down a voter-approved ballot measure and this week the county decided not to appeal.
Tours
Recommended Wine, The Board of Supervisors voted unanimously Tuesday against challenging the Oct. 4 ruling by Judge Andria K.
Bicycle, Balloon Hiking Richey. Richey ruled that county voters have no legal authority to impose term limits on the sheriff, whose office is
& Kayaking Tours. governed by the state Constitution.
w w w .WineCountrysBest.com
Ads by Google Advertisement

Yosemite
Meetings/Event
Evergreen Lodge:
Frommer's Favorite Watch the AC360 Videos
Idyllic setting.
Customized events.
Where Truth Got in the Way of an
w w w .evergreenlodge.com Agenda.
FreedomMag.org/AC360_Videos
Scientology Today
The Only Major
Religion To Emerge in
20th Century. Watch
Online Video
Scientology.org
The board's decision ends a three-year fight that Baca had waged against the measure, which would have limited the
county's sheriff to three four-year terms.
FIND MORE STORIES ABOUT

Court Rulings In the March 2002 election, voters overwhelmingly supported limits for the sheriff, assessor and district attorney,
approving the measure by 61%. In the same election, they approved a separate measure by 64% to limit the terms of
Los Angeles County Board Of
the county supervisors.
Superv isors

Term Lim its On Wednesday, Baca called the county's decision to end the legal fight a "prudent" action that avoids needless costs.

Lee Baca Although he is serving his second term as sheriff, the 2002 measure would have allowed him to run two more times
Los Angeles County -- Board Of because his first election took place before the term limits were approved.
Superv isors
"It wasn't necessarily for my peace of mind," Baca said. "It's very clear by the law that this cannot be done in the way
that it was done."

The approval of term limits for the county's sheriff was a significant break with tradition. Before Baca's first election
in 1998, only three men had served as sheriff since 1932.

An opponent of term limits for most political offices, Baca said that such restrictions were particularly damaging in
law enforcement.

"It does require expertise, specific to the functions of jails, court security, policing services," Baca said. "It isn't just a
job that anyone can jump into."

In the lawsuit, Baca's lawyers cited a 1979 appellate court decision in which justices upheld a decision that
overturned an amendment to San Diego County's charter that imposed term limits on its elected officials.

articles.latimes.com/2004/…/me-limits11 1/2
6/4/2010 Baca Wins His Battle Against Term Limit…
Since then, the Legislature has amended California law to allow voters to create term limits for county supervisors
but not for other county officials.

Richey's ruling only applies to the office of sheriff. But Krista MacNevin Jee, who represented Baca in the suit, said
the decision could be used to overturn term limits for the assessor and district attorney as well.

County Assessor Rick Auerbach, who is in his second term, said Wednesday that he would seek legal advice before
deciding whether to act, but said he supported overturning his office's term limits.

"I don't agree with term limits, certainly for the assessor," Auerbach said. "You want someone in that office who's a
good manager and not someone who's a good politician."

But Los Angeles County Dist. Atty. Steve Cooley said he had no plans to join efforts to overturn limits imposed on his
office.

"I don't think it has a practical effect on me," said Cooley, who was reelected to a second term in March. "I think what
Lee did was a matter of principle and he should be commended for that."

Jee, Baca's attorney, said that any effort to create term limits for sheriffs, district attorneys and assessors would
require a change in California law to allow county voters to decide the issue.

Ads by Google

Watch the AC360 Videos

Where Truth Got in the Way of an Agenda.
FreedomMag.org/AC360_Videos

Copy right 2 01 0 Los Angeles Tim es Index by Key wor d | Index by Date | Pr iv acy Policy | Term s of Ser v ice

articles.latimes.com/2004/…/me-limits11 2/2