Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Generator Sizing
Generator Sizing
Generator Sizing
Power Quality
Julian Wiatr
WP Poland Krakow
julianwiatr@wp.pl
Power Quality
Power Quality
www.leonardo-energy.org
1. INTRODUCTION
Prior to designing a power supply system for a building or other structure,
a designer shall carry out a detailed analysis concerning the requirements
for reliability of power supply of loads to be installed in the designed
building or facility.
Diverse requirements concerning reliability of supply have enforced
classification of loads into power supply categories defined according to
the criteria accepted in power management:
- Power supply category III loads upon which an arbitrary long
interruption of supply has no adverse effects,
- Power supply category II loads upon which a short supply
interruption (up to several minutes) interruption of supply has no adverse
effects,
- Power supply category I loads upon which even a short interruption
of supply may bring about hazard for human life or substantial material
losses due to e.g. interruption of production process.
The example of a building where all categories of supply can be found is
shown in figure 1.
Emergency & Uninterruptible Power Supplies for Buildings & Other Structures
- sizing the source power
www.leonardo-energy.org
2. MOTOR-GENERATOR SETS
A motor-generator set is a commonly used source of emergency power
supply for buildings and other structures. Its basic components are:
internal combustion engine converts fuel chemical energy into
mechanical energy
generator converts mechanical energy into electric energy
rotational speed governor
generator voltage regulator
generator field controller
control system
starting system
switchgear.
Power Quality
www.leonardo-energy.org
G3
G4
G1
G2
Generating sets are also categorized according to their starting time, i.e.
the time that elapses from the instant of voltage loss in a power network to
the instant the voltage is applied from the generating set: (i) long duration
voltage loss; (ii) short duration voltage loss, and (iii) without voltage loss.
Generating sets with long duration voltage loss
emergency power supply systems. Such sets are
self-starting and shutdown systems. Upon loss
network a remote control system activates the
4
Emergency & Uninterruptible Power Supplies for Buildings & Other Structures
- sizing the source power
www.leonardo-energy.org
U
n
i G1
Frequency drop
2.5
1.5
0.5
+18
+12
+10
-15
-10
-7
Transient
frequency
deviation
on loss of
load (100%)
on application of step
load
10
51)
2.5
+35
+25
+20
-25
-20
-15
10
Transient
voltage
deviation
on loss of
load (100%)
on application of step
load
Parameters
values by
agreement
between
manufacturer and
customer
Power Quality
www.leonardo-energy.org
the loss of voltage in the power network and the availability of the
emergency power usually does not exceed 1 minute. After the voltage
recovery in the power network the automatic stand-by switching system
switches to the main supply without stopping the generating set. After the
switchover the generating set is run idle for about next 3 minutes for
cooling the generator.
Figure 2 shows diagram of a generating set with short starting time
In normal conditions the electric synchronous motor (1) draws energy from
power network and drives the generator (2) and flywheel (3). The clutch
(4) is disengaged. The generator is running idly. Upon loss of voltage in
the power network the switch Q1 closes and the clutch (4) is automatically
engaged. Kinetic energy stored in the flywheel is used for starting the
internal combustion engine (5), which within a short time begins to drive
the generator. Applying the voltage from the generator switches
automatically the Q2 switch to emergency power supply and energizes the
loads.
Normally the time of power supply disruption does not exceed 2 seconds.
Emergency & Uninterruptible Power Supplies for Buildings & Other Structures
- sizing the source power
www.leonardo-energy.org
Power Quality
www.leonardo-energy.org
radiator. That solution not only allows the heat produced by the generating
set to be removed from the room but also provides combustion air.
Figure 5 shows the correct, typical arrangement of a generating set room.
The drawing provides example dimensions and distances for installation
of the generating set installation with rated power 60-80 kVA.
PZ = k Z Pi
(1)
i =1
where:
Pi
Emergency & Uninterruptible Power Supplies for Buildings & Other Structures
- sizing the source power
www.leonardo-energy.org
i =1
i =1
QZ = k Z tg i Pi = k Z
1
1 Pi
cos 2 i
(2)
where:
QZ
PZ
(3)
PZ2 + QZ2
(4)
p=
cos Z
cosnG
(5)
9
Power Quality
www.leonardo-energy.org
The required minimum active power of the generating set shall satisfy the
inequality:
PG min
PZ
p
(6)
The utilization factor p, calculated from the formula (5) shall be inserted to
the formula (6). If p 1, the value 1 has be taken in the formula (6). The
value of power factor cos nG shall be taken according to the generating
set specification. In case the information on rated power factor is not
available, the value cos nG = 0.8 should be taken. The generating set
apparent power shall satisfy the inequality:
S nG
PG min
cos z
(7)
10
Emergency & Uninterruptible Power Supplies for Buildings & Other Structures
- sizing the source power
www.leonardo-energy.org
Where the generating set is intended to supply electric motors its power
should be sized considering the motors' starting currents which shall not
exceed the generator rated current, taking into account permissible
temporary overload specified in the manufacturer's data.
Non-linear loads draw distorted currents and, consequently, distort the
source current. This distortion results in the presence of harmonics and
interharmonics (also subharmonics) in the supply network and final
circuits, which, generally are shifted in phase with respect to the voltage.
In the effect of harmonics, apart of the active and reactive power, also the
deformation power V appears in the system; hence the apparent power
cannot be determined as the product of fundamental harmonic voltage
and current. The value of deformation power V depends on the current
and voltage distortion level, i.e. on the harmonic content and, in polyphase
circuits, also on the asymmetry level.
In asymmetric loads the power factor cos is not the same in all phases. It
can be different in each phase depending on the active and reactive
power load in a given phase. A detrimental effect of asymmetric loading is
the voltage increase above the nominal value in the least-loaded phase.
Since the estimation of the additional power resulting from asymmetric
loading is difficult, the design should ensure the asymmetry of loads
supplied from the emergency generating set will not exceed 20%,
according to manufacturers' recommendation.
The apparent power of a non-linear load can be found from the relation:
(8)
S 2 = P2 + Q2 + V 2
P = U k I k cos k
k =1
(9)
Q = U k I k sin k
k =1
(10)
S = P2 + Q2
(11)
11
Power Quality
www.leonardo-energy.org
Fig. 6. Power tetrahedron for a system with distorted voltage and current
waveforms
cos =
P
S
(12)
P I1
P
=
=
2
S
I
P + Q2
P
3U n
2
k
k =0
12
(13)
Emergency & Uninterruptible Power Supplies for Buildings & Other Structures
- sizing the source power
www.leonardo-energy.org
where the angle k is the phase shift of the k-th order harmonic voltage
and current, sin k = 1 cos 2 k .
The nominal current of a three-phase load that draws a distorted current
can be found from the formula:
In =
Pn
3U n cos
(14)
It follows from relations (13) and (14) that with the load's steady state
current equal to its nominal value IN and increased distortion of the actual
current, the active power the given equipment can be loaded with, should
be reduced below its rated value.
Therefore non-linear loads drawing distorted current from the generator
reduce the generating set active power utilization. The generator's power
shall be increased in order to meet the power demand of such loads.
The generator's minimum active power required to meet the power
demand of these loads should be determined from the formula:
PG min
PZ
pW
where: p
Pz
(15)
the utilization factor calculated from the formula (5) [-],
active power demanded by loads to be supplied from the
emergency power supply system [kW]
100
)2
100 + THDi %
13
Power Quality
www.leonardo-energy.org
The generating set power should be determined from the formula (7).
Total harmonic distortion THDi% can be found from the formula:
THDi =
(I
k =2
I1
)2
100%
(16)
W
0.95
0.91
0.86
0.83
0.76
0.70
0.60
0.51
14
Emergency & Uninterruptible Power Supplies for Buildings & Other Structures
- sizing the source power
www.leonardo-energy.org
S nUPS P Z2 +QZ2
PZ = k z
i =1
Pi
Wi
(18)
Motors' starting currents and distorted currents shall be taken into account
when sizing the UPS output power to ensure its correct operation. A UPS
of insufficient output power, supplying electric motors, will in response to
load increase automatically switch to external bypass and therefore cut off
the uninterruptible power supply function 2.
Also the rated crest factor, which is the ratio between the load's
instantaneous peak current and the rms current value, shall be considered
when selecting a UPS system. For the currently manufactured UPS units
the crest factor value is normally 3. If the crest factor of a current drown
from the UPS exceeds its rated value, the UPS operation can be impaired,
leading even to its shutdown.
_________________________
1
The apparent power determined from the formula (17) refers to the UPS rated power is
15
Power Quality
www.leonardo-energy.org
Since the UPS shall be able to deliver the demanded active power PZ
and demanded reactive power Q Z , thus if it operates at a lower power
factor cos Z < cos nG , the utilization of the UPS's active power
decreases due to limited capability of the inverter semiconductor
switches.
The UPS relative loading with active power can be described by the
utilization factor:
p=
cosZ
cosnUPS
(19)
The UPS required minimum active power must satisfy the inequality:
PUPS min
PZ
p
(20)
The utilization factor p, calculated from the formula (19) shall be inserted
to the formula (20). If p 1, in the formula (20) the value 1 has been
taken. The power factor value cos nUPS shall be taken according to the
UPS specification. If information on the rated power factor is not available,
cos nUPS = 0.8 should be taken for transformer UPS, or cos nUPS = 0.9
for transformer-less UPS power supplies incorporating IGBT inverters.
The UPS apparent power shall satisfy the inequality:
SnUPS
PUPS min
cos nUPS
(21)
cos Z
16
Emergency & Uninterruptible Power Supplies for Buildings & Other Structures
- sizing the source power
www.leonardo-energy.org
17
Power Quality
www.leonardo-energy.org
(22)
PB = 52I
(23)
(24)
(25)
PwejSTK = PC + PB
I =
N=
I ncT p
T
(26)
PweSTK
P1
(27)
______________________________
3
18
Emergency & Uninterruptible Power Supplies for Buildings & Other Structures
- sizing the source power
www.leonardo-energy.org
(28)
'
PwejSTK
N ' P1 = ( N + 1) P1
Where :
'
PwejSTK
- input active power of telecom power plant [W]
PwejSTK - input active power of telecom power plant necessary to cover the
loads' power demand [W]
PC
PB
P1
Inc
Tp
Unc
19
Power Quality
www.leonardo-energy.org
PUPSwe
The telecom power plant input power, which has to be known in order to
balance the supplied building power demand, shall be computed from the
following formulas:
PwejSTK = (
'
PwyjSTK
QwejSTK = P
'
wyjSTK
+ PB )
1
W
tg wejSTK
(29)
'
S wejSTK = ( PwyjSTK
) 2 + (QwejSTK ) 2
Where :
tg wejSTK =
cos wejSTK
QwejSTK
cos wejST K
2
When the telecom power plant is supplied from a generating set, it should
be borne in mind that generator's long-duration operation at full loading
20
Emergency & Uninterruptible Power Supplies for Buildings & Other Structures
- sizing the source power
www.leonardo-energy.org
and THDi getting close to 8%, may result in premature wear of the
generator unless its power is not oversized.
A long-duration operation under the generator full load should, therefore,
be avoided.
21
Power Quality
www.leonardo-energy.org
(30)
PII
PUPSwe =
PUPSwy
PB PUPSwy 0.25PUPSwy
=
+
W
W
W
(31)
If the genset is specifically designed to supply non-linear loads the degree of its
oversizing can be lower; it should, however, be agreed with a manufacturer.
22
Emergency & Uninterruptible Power Supplies for Buildings & Other Structures
- sizing the source power
www.leonardo-energy.org
EXAMPLE 1
Size the power of a generating set intended for emergency power supply of the below given loads:
three squirrel cage induction motors with ratings: PNS=7.5 kW; kr = 6; cosj = 0.8; h=0.8; UN =3x400V; sN
= 5%; kMr = 2.3
UPS with ratings: PN = 15 kW; cosj = 0.95; THDi = 8%; UN =3x400/230 V; h=0.9
lighting loads of total power P=5 kW; cosj =0.7 and UN =230V (the loads are grouped symmetrically ensuring equal load in each phase).
The rated power of a single motor:
PNS
IN =
3U n cos
75000
= 15.04 A
3 400 0.8 0.9
I r = k r I N = 6 15.04 = 90.24 A
It is a large current and should be limited. One of the methods is the use of a star/delta starter that reduces
the starting current about 3 times. Thus:
IrY = I r = 90.24 = 30.08 A
Due to the large starting current of a single motor, simultaneous start of all motors shall be prevented by
means of a control system. Thus, assuming sequential motors starting, the peak power is:
cos r = cos
1 sN
M rw
0,90 2,30
+ 0.025k r ) = 0.80
(
0,025 6) = 0.40
kr
1 0,05 6
Pszs =
3U N IrY
Qszs=
3U N IrY cos r
1 + 2 PNS
1
cos 2
1 =
1
1
1 + 2 7500
1 30.33 k var
2
0.40
0.82
100
100 2
)2 = (
) 0.86
W =(
100 + THDi %
100 + 8
PwejUPS =
PwyjUPS
W
QwejUPS = PwejUPS
0,25PwyjUPS
W
1
cos wejUPS
2
15000
0.25 15000
+
23740 W
0.86 0.90
0.86
1 = 23740
1
1 = 7.80 k var
0.952
23
Power Quality
www.leonardo-energy.org
Qz = 30.33 + 7.80 +
tg z =
Qz 43.23
=
= 0.86
Pz 52.08
cos z =
p=
1
tg z + 1
2
1
= 0.76
0.862 + 1
cos z 0.76
=
= 0.95
cos nG 0.80
Pz 52.80
=
= 55.58 kW
p
0.95
P
55.58
SG G min =
= 73.14 kVA
cos z 0.76
PG min
On the basis of the manufacturer's catalogue the above conditions are met by the generating set
with rated power 80 kVA.
Emergency & Uninterruptible Power Supplies for Buildings & Other Structures
- sizing the source power
www.leonardo-energy.org
be supplied from the power network (heaters, phase detector, etc). These
circuits should be provided with the overload and electric shock protection
and be arranged the in TN-S system.
25
Power Quality
www.leonardo-energy.org
Fig. 10. Diagram of the emergency power supply system supplying dedicated
circuits
1 - Automatic standby switching system; 2 - Capacitor banks
Emergency & Uninterruptible Power Supplies for Buildings & Other Structures
- sizing the source power
www.leonardo-energy.org
27
Power Quality
www.leonardo-energy.org
Fig. 12. An emergency power system with two generating sets supplying
separate sections of the main switchboard 1 - Capacitor banks;
Fig. 13. An emergency power system with several generating sets intended for
parallel operation
28
Emergency & Uninterruptible Power Supplies for Buildings & Other Structures
- sizing the source power
www.leonardo-energy.org
REFERENCES
1. ISO 85281: Reciprocating internal combustion engine driven
alternating current generating sets - Part 1: Application, ratings and
performance.
2. ISO 8528-5: Reciprocating internal combustion engine driven
alternating current generating sets - Part 5: Generating sets.
29