Denver Journal - 2:0110 - Joshua

Seite 1

Search

Home About Us
Contact Us

Academics

Admissions

Alumni & Friends

Giving

News & Events

Denver Journal
An Online Review of Current Biblical and Theological Studies.

Publications

Students

Volume 2 - 1999
Editor: Richard S. Hess

Howard, David M., Jr. Joshua. The New American Commentary Volume 5. Nashville: Broadman & Holman, 1998. 464 pp.
Hardback. ISBN 0-8054-0105-0.
Howard has produced an important and helpful commentary on the book of Joshua. Readers who wish to understand
the meaning of this Old Testament book will be well served when they consult Howard's work. It provides a verse by verse
study of the book in what may well be the largest English language exegetical commentary available in recent years. All the
major theological and exegetical difficulties are discussed, often at some length either in the introduction or in the main body
of the commentary itself. Thus while noting the textual variants of the Dead Sea Scrolls in his introduction, Howard
consistently opts for the Massoretic Hebrew text over these and other versions. He accepts an early date for the exodus and
therefore places the events of Joshua c. 1400 B.C. The main text that we today call Joshua was written shortly after the
events described in it. Happily, Howard sees the initial activities and confessions of Joshua, Israel, and Rahab as positive.
Thus the spies of ch. 2 are basically faithful and not representatives of a degenerate Israel. Jericho's walls are probably the
Middle Bronze Age ones that should be redated to this period following the arguments of Bimson and Wood. Ai should
probably be relocated at another site than et-Tell, following the arguments of Livingstone. The "ban" required the destruction
of all Canaanites because of their idolatry, other sins, and rebellious attitude. It was just and appropriate due to the holiness
of God. Rahab and others could be saved from this destruction if they ceased to be Canaanites and converted to the
Israelite faith. Thus the fact that Israel did not kill Rahab and her family was not a violation of the "ban." Israel was unfaithful
in its failure to consult God before believing the Gibeonites' lie and making a treaty with them. However, their subsequent
southern and northern campaigns were blessed by God and therefore victorious. The land allotments are God's gift to Israel
as he owns the land. They reflect the unity of the entire nation as they all receive this blessing. The purpose of all the
specific detail is to demonstrate that these places were truly and historically given to the tribes. The final chapters are
concerned with farewells as Joshua presents a pastoral address in ch. 23 and then a report of a covenant renewal
(modelled on second millennium B.C. treaties) in ch. 24.
This is a useful and important commentary that a scholar, pastor, or student of the Bible could consult with profit.
Howard's particular strengths lie in his word studies of virtually all the significant theological and other vocabulary and
phrases in each text. He is constantly referring the reader to similar usages of words and concepts elsewhere in the Old
Testament, and especially in the Pentateuch. This commentary is also helpful at drawing the reader into a deeper
appreciation of many of the theological truths found here.
The reader will not find here certain other items. There is no extended analysis of sources and critical arguments for
the construction of the text. While these are acknowledged from time to time, the reader is instructed to look elsewhere for
this sort of thing. The Hebrew text is studied more from a vocabulary and grammatical perspective than from a literary one.
Thus the analysis of God's promise to Joshua in 1: 6-9 and of Rahab's confession in 2: 9-11 do not mention the envelope
structures in both texts which provide a balance of God's grace and Joshua's responsibility in the first passage, and
demonstrate the way in which God's historical acts of salvation form a key to Rahab's faith in the second. There is also an
absence of much discussion of the archaeological evidence from the period, that is beyond the obvious data used to
discuss the date of the exodus, the sites of Jericho and Ai (and some mention with reference to Hazor), and the Hittite treaty
structures for ch. 24. However, the massive amount of settlement evidence that has emerged in the past two decades is
hardly touched upon with reference to Israel's allotment. Nor are the literary comparisons with conquest accounts (Younger)
used for chs. 8-12 or those with reference to border descriptions, land grants, and place name lists (Hess) used for chs. 1321. In addition, no attempt is made to analyze the personal names (other than Joshua) or to locate the many place names in
reference to known archaeological sites (in this regard, Hannathon's location is well known [contra p. 369]). For this sort of
material and its substantial relevance for the exegetical and theological interpretation of the text, the reader will need to look
elsewhere.
In general the book is well presented and the format easy to read. However, why is it necessary to work through more
than twenty pages, including all of the abbreviations, before reaching the Contents page? Also, the following abbreviations
are not explained but occur in the text: DBH (p. 313), HALOT (passim), NIV (passim), NJPSV (p. 363), and NLT (p. 354).
Finally, why is et cetera always written out, instead of the common, etc.?

http://www.denverseminary.edu/dj/articles1999/0100/0110

09.03.2007 16:47:24

Denver Journal - 2:0110 - Joshua

Seite 2

These are quibbles, however. They are not meant to detract from the real value of this commentary which should
rightly find a place in the library of those who wish to preach and teach on this dramatic and "faith stirring" book of the Old
Testament.
Richard S. Hess
Professor of Old Testament
Denver Seminary
April 1999

Denver Journal Home

Copyright 1997-2006 Denver Seminary. 6399 South Santa Fe Drive, Littleton, CO, 80120. 303.761.2482 or 800.922.3040. info@denverseminary.edu

http://www.denverseminary.edu/dj/articles1999/0100/0110

09.03.2007 16:47:24