Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Benchmarking Presentations
Benchmarking Presentations
9/27/05
Workshop Objectives
Main points of this workshop
Benchmarking is harder than most assume
Some data is available (how to find it and
how to use it)
The good and bad news about external
benchmarking tools
Reality check on internal benchmarking
(energy accounting) tools
How to help your customers
9/27/05
Presentation Outline
What Is Benchmarking and What Is It Good For?
(Or Why Are We All Sitting Here?)
External Benchmarking Data
External Benchmarking Tools
Industrial Benchmarking
Internal Benchmarking (Energy Accounting) Tools
Tips for Your Customers: How to Benchmark
9/27/05
9/27/05
9/27/05
9/27/05
9/27/05
Energy
accounting
Statistical
analysis
Monitor performance
Source: Platts
9
9/27/05
10
9/27/05
Presentation Outline
What Is Benchmarking and What Is It Good For?
(Or Why Are We All Sitting Here?)
External Benchmarking Data
External Benchmarking Tools
Industrial Benchmarking
Internal Benchmarking (Energy Accounting) Tools
Tips for Your Customers: How to Benchmark
11
9/27/05
12
9/27/05
13
9/27/05
14
9/27/05
15
9/27/05
16
9/27/05
17
9/27/05
18
9/27/05
19
9/27/05
20
9/27/05
10
21
9/27/05
22
9/27/05
11
23
9/27/05
24
9/27/05
12
Detailed tables
More detailed data
Requires more time and familiarity
9/27/05
26
9/27/05
13
9/27/05
28
9/27/05
14
www.oee.nrcan.gc.ca/corporate/statistics/neud/dpa/
data_e/cibeus_description.cfm?attr=0
29
9/27/05
30
9/27/05
15
9/27/05
Presentation Outline
What Is Benchmarking and What Is It Good For?
(Or Why Are We All Sitting Here?)
External Benchmarking Data
External Benchmarking Tools
Industrial Benchmarking
Internal Benchmarking (Energy Accounting) Tools
Tips for Your Customers: How to Benchmark
32
9/27/05
16
33
9/27/05
9/27/05
17
35
9/27/05
36
9/27/05
18
37
9/27/05
9/27/05
19
39
9/27/05
40
9/27/05
20
41
9/27/05
42
9/27/05
21
43
9/27/05
Source: LBNL
44
9/27/05
22
45
9/27/05
46
9/27/05
23
47
9/27/05
Source: LBNL
48
9/27/05
24
Source: LBNL
49
9/27/05
50
9/27/05
25
51
9/27/05
Source: Kilojolts
52
9/27/05
26
Presentation Outline
What Is Benchmarking and What Is It Good For?
(Or Why Are We All Sitting Here?)
External Benchmarking Data
External Benchmarking Tools
Industrial Benchmarking
Internal Benchmarking (Energy Accounting) Tools
Tips for Your Customers: How to Benchmark
53
9/27/05
54
9/27/05
27
Benchmarking for
Large C&I Facility Energy Use
External Benchmarking Data and Tools:
Industrial
Neil Kolwey
E SOURCE Research Manager
September 27, 2005
18th Annual E SOURCE Forum
2005 Platts, a Division of The McGraw-Hill Companies
9/27/05
9/27/05
9/27/05
9/27/05
Weaknesses
MECs provides no measure of total energy
use per unit of output
1998 data is most recent
Data quality problems, gaps
Data for specific sectors is limited
9/27/05
Lighting
8%
Other
7%
HVAC
9%
Process
cooling
8%
Machine
drive
52%
Process
heating
16%
9/27/05
Other
12%
HVAC
15%
Boiler fuel
50%
Process
heating
23%
Source: EIA, from http://www.eia.doe.gov/emeu/mecs/contents.html
8
9/27/05
9/27/05
Weaknesses
Energy use for a specific facility depends on specific
processes, products made, and on outdoor temperature
(to a smaller extent)
ASM offers no way to adjust for these variables in order to
produce meaningful comparisons to the sectorwide average
10
9/27/05
Total energy
costsfuels
and electricity
(million $)
Total value
of shipments
(million $)
Polystyrene foam
products (32614)
114
200
6,647
185
511
4,361
589
1,158
7,550
543
845
14, 653
Industrial sector
11
9/27/05
12
9/27/05
13
9/27/05
14
9/27/05
Weaknesses
Only available for a few sectors
Somewhat complicated to use
15
9/27/05
Breweries
Cement mfg.
Petroleum refining
Corn refining
Pharmaceutical mfg.
See http://www.energystar.gov/index.cfm?c=in_focus.bus_industries_focus
16
9/27/05
How to use
Facilities enter data on annual energy use, total
production, product mix, and other metrics
Output is percentile ranking of facility compared
with other companies in sector (75th percentile
or above is considered efficient)
17
9/27/05
Internal Benchmarking
Comparing energy use per unit output for
similar facilities within the same company
Works if company has several facilities making
the same product (beer, cement)
Consider energy accounting tools
More-sophisticated analysis is possible on
site-specific basis
Some tools work well with submetering and
interval data
18
9/27/05
1Q01 energy
costs
2Q01 energy
costs
3Q01 energy
costs
4Q01 energy
costs
YTD energy
costs
(million $)
Baltimore
1.37
0.38
0.39
0.35
0.25
1.37
Cartersville
0.62
0.18
0.15
0.19
0.14
0.66
Edgewater
0.38
0.05
0.09
0.07
0.09
0.30
Chicago
2.58
0.78
0.59
0.76
0.66
2.79
Total
4.94
1.39
1.22
1.37
1.14
5.11
Facility
19
9/27/05
Industrial Summary
Industrial facilities are hard to compare
External benchmarking data is limited
Basic internal benchmarking can be useful
Dont forget analysis and tracking of energy use
at the facility level
20
9/27/05
10
21
9/27/05
11
Benchmarking for
Large C&I Facility Energy Use
Commercial & Industrial Benchmarking
Tools and Tips
Gwen Farnsworth
E SOURCE Research Manager
September 27, 2005
18th Annual E SOURCE Forum
2005 Platts, a Division of The McGraw-Hill Companies
Presentation Outline
What Is Benchmarking and What Is It Good For?
(Or Why Are We All Sitting Here?)
External Benchmarking Data
External Benchmarking Tools
Industrial Benchmarking
Internal Benchmarking (Energy Accounting)
Tools
Tips for Your Customers: How to Benchmark
2
9/27/05
9/27/05
9/27/05
9/27/05
9/27/05
9/27/05
9/27/05
9/27/05
10
9/27/05
11
9/27/05
12
9/27/05
13
9/27/05
Source: Kilojolts
14
9/27/05
Source: Kilojolts
15
9/27/05
9/27/05
17
9/27/05
9/27/05
Source: SMR
19
9/27/05
20
9/27/05
10
9/27/05
9/27/05
11
23
9/27/05
24
9/27/05
12
9/27/05
Source: Itron
26
9/27/05
13
Source: EnVinta
27
9/27/05
Source: SMR
28
9/27/05
14
29
9/27/05
Source: EnVinta
30
9/27/05
15
Source: SMR
31
9/27/05
Source: SMR
32
9/27/05
16
Source: Kilojolts
33
9/27/05
34
9/27/05
17
Source: SMR
35
9/27/05
Source: SMR
36
9/27/05
18
Source: SMR
37
9/27/05
Source: EnVinta
38
9/27/05
19
39
9/27/05
9/27/05
20
9/27/05
Source: EnVinta
42
9/27/05
21
Source: Itron
43
9/27/05
Source: SMR
44
9/27/05
22
Presentation Outline
What Is Benchmarking and What Is It Good For?
(Or Why Are We All Sitting Here?)
External Benchmarking Data
External Benchmarking Tools
Industrial Benchmarking
Internal Benchmarking (Energy Accounting) Tools
Tips for Your Customers: How to Benchmark
45
9/27/05
How to Benchmark
1. Gather the data for each site
Total usage and demand
Expenditures
Normalization factors (square footage,
occupancy, revenue, production)
46
9/27/05
23
47
9/27/05
9/27/05
24
49
9/27/05
7. Take action
50
9/27/05
Desktop audits
Walk-through and full-building audits
Commissioning
Retrofit and operational plans
Recognize and reward good performers
Confidential: Not for distribution outside subscribing organization
25
51
9/27/05
52
9/27/05
26
Energy metric
Compare daily energy use to
benchmarks
Monthly
Quarterly Annually
a
Source: Platts; adapted from LBNL- 54862
53
9/27/05
54
9/27/05
27
Neil Kolwey
E SOURCE Research Manager
Tel 720-548-5741
E-mail neil_kolwey@platts.com
55
9/27/05
28