Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Monitoring Report of Educational Initiative
Monitoring Report of Educational Initiative
OF
PROJECT
QUALITY EDUCATION TO DALIT, UNDER PRIVILEGED
AND MINORITY CHILDREN
IMPLEMENTED BY
Peoples Vigilance Committee on Human Rights, Jan
Mitra Nyas
FUNDED BY
Sir Dorabji Tata Trust
DECEMBER 2009
CONTENTS
Introduction 1
Programmes initiated
4
Impact 10
Potential Sustainability 11
Suggestive inputs 12
Annexture-1 : Abbreviations
13
Introduction:
There are 40 villages and 9 urban slums in the Varanasi district where
more than half of the population live below poverty line. The literacy
rate is nearly ten percent. Most children have either dropped out or
never enrolled. Many of them work as labourers and are earning
members of their family. Girl children have to take care of their
younger siblings and do not go to school. For families below poverty
line arranging sufficient resources for subsistence is such an uphill task
that they hardly take interest in the educational and developmental
needs of their kids.
Schools have their own set of problems. Issues like rigid curricula,
uninteresting and monotonous teaching not linked to daily life, de-
motivated teachers and first generation learners pose serious
challenges to meet demands of formal education system. Both the
government and the civil society groups face a serious challenge to;
Programmes initiated:
Pre-primary centers (PPC): There is one PPC for every group of 25-
30 children in the age-group of 3-6 years who are out of school. These
centres that aims to groom children for formal schooling. There are 15
such centres. Detail information about them are as follows:
Block Villages Distanc Total Total Total number of
covered e from no. no. of children
office of teacher
PPC s
Mal Femal Total
e e
Baragaon Belwa (nat 30-40 7 7 85 94 179
basti, patel km
Basti),
barai,
hamirapur,
dallipur,
bachaura
Baraikala
Harahua Nonari 2 2 35 19 54
(Puwari
Khurd)
Bhatpurwa
(Mushar
Basti)
Pindra Ramaipur, 2 2 24 19 43
Marashah
Takia
Chiraigao Rajapur 1 1 14 13 27
n
Nagar Sarang 3 3 61 47 108
nigam Talab
Doshipura
Dharkar
Basti
(Hukulganj
)
Total 15 15 411
Strategies :
Achievements:
Other achievements:
Twenty girls got the Rajdulari Balika scholarship from Raj Dulari
Foundation, Sweden and were enrolled in Sudhakar Mahila Inter-
College with efforts from PVCHR.
ANALYSIS :
Ask Dr Lenin about the project, he will simply quote, Robert Kennedy,
(1966), We all struggle to transcend the cruelties and the follies of
mankind. That struggle will not be won by standing aloof and pointing
a finger; it will be won by action, by those who commit their very
resource of mind and body to the education and improvement and help
of their fellow persons. PVCHR has gained immensely from several
initiatives it has undertaken in the form of grassroots campaign,
peoples advocacy both at the local and global level. It has successfully
created a model villages based on active democratic participation and
free from all kinds of torture. This project has brought almost all the
children within the age group of 3-6 to the PPC of the project areas.
The teachers have also made effort to take the children above six
years to the schools ensuring almost zero drop out. Both the drop out
and child labour are brought into the mainstream school system.
PVCHR/JMN has also helped the local girls to join the nearby Inter
College. 411 children from the age group of 3-6 belonging to the dalits
and adivasis have been enrolled in the 15 PPC against the target of
375. Beneficiaries include 544 children from 3 Madrasas. One centre is
entirely dedicated to focus on the Muslim child labours engaged in the
weaving industry. Six fellows have been engaged in thirty villages to
raise the bar of consciousness among the community members by
focusing on range of issues or facilities like the right to education, Mid
Day meal, Anganwadi, functioning of the village education committee.
The folk school initiative has broken cycle of censorship among the
marginalized. They later have realized that the difference between
suffering for generation and break free from the shackles of bondage is
the willingness to speak for ones right. Now, they are visiting the
school and demanding regular teaching and health facilities in the
village. They have also taken up issues like ration card, job card under
NREGA with the concerned authorities. For the first time, the Madrasas
under the project celebrated the Independence Day, indicating the
acceptance of liberal education and mainstreaming of the minority
community through this project intervention. Taking this favourable
environment, the project representatives have started discussing the
salient features of the Sachar Committee Report and the 15 Point
Programme of the Prime Minister for the betterment of minority
community. During interaction with some parents and teachers
representing the minority community, it was found that some parents,
against their traditional beliefs have started favouring education for
their girl child, believing that she might just be able to do something in
life. The biggest challenge for the teachers attached to the centers is
to organize parents-teachers meeting during the week-end. It is
advised that the teachers should not meet more than 4/5 parents and
tell them about the development about the child and more
enthusiastically about the girl child. This would bring huge
psychological impact on the whole family. What is also observed
among the teachers was lack of techniques in building personalized
relationship. The complex social relationship prevailing in the project
areas is always weighing on them. They are more concerned about the
fall out in case of any mistake/misunderstanding, which perhaps are
also affecting their creativity and desisting them to be self starter.
Impact:
The project, within six months of its inception has become an
instrument of desirable and positive social change. To contextualize
the problem, there was no facility of education for weavers
community, pre-dominantly, Muslims with only one literate in ten. Most
children were out of school; girls taking care of younger siblings and
boys engaged in child labour. Even there was bleak awareness about
education being a Fundamental Right for children aged 6-14 years.
Abject poverty and marginalization had hardly allowed parents to think
about the education of their children. The school system also had
many push factors like teacher-absenteeism, lack of quality education,
de-motivation of teachers to make education as interesting and
enjoyable process.
The strategy that made the difference were creating a demand for
education through Mahila Baithak, Kishori Baithak, Abhibhavak
Baithak, Bal Sabha, Bal Panchayat, etc., before the supply of
educational facilities. Active participation led to awareness and later
assertion for own rights.
Potential Sustainability:
Too early and too soon to talk about it. But, looking at the commitment
of the organisation and the community response, it is unlikely to
happen that this initiative would not be sustainable. The gradual
(perhaps forced) involvement of the state apparatus in this project
might consider it to support and at the same time showcase as an
example. The other scenario could be the willingness of the
organisation itself taking over the continuation of the initiative in case
they do not get sponsorship, precisely due to its long time involvement
for the empowerment of the dalits, other backward caste people,
minorities which has been internationally recognized. If the fund
disappears, which should not happen in this case, the high
motivational drive of the project holders will lead to a continued
activity but at a significantly lower level. The advocacy and the
empowerment work may not suffer at all but the function of the
centers may slip back to a very unstructured volunteer support
resulting in unequal progress among the centers. Given the progress
the project is making there are every reasons to believe that the
actions will remain sustainable. PVCHR/JMN filed a Public Interest
Litigation (PIL) in the Honorable High Court, Allahabad for opening the
primary school at Baghwanala. It also helped in constructing a school
building on the community with sponsorship from Remscheid through
Ms. Helma Ritscher, Chairperson, Indo- German Society of Remscheid,
Germany. The present initiative has mobilized the community to
demand ICDS centres from the government. Opening of one ICDS
centre in one part of Doshipur slum has motivated the project staff to
shift the PPC to another part of the same slum area so that more
children benefit.
Suggestive inputs:
Though within six month since its inception, the project has succeeded
in its endeavors, some suggestions may be delineated as below:
Annex-1
Abbreviations