Journalism is one of the basic and important means of
communication. By journalism, we mean the collection and editing of
material of current interest Jor presentation through media or the editorial
or business management of an agency engaged in the collection and
dissemination of news. (1)
Journalism is actually the information, education and guidance, as
such information is one of the constituent parts of Journalism.
Journalism is a whole unit and full-fledgec social discipline and news is
the essence of Journalism, It stands for writing for the newspapers or
magazines. It is the communication of in“ormation through writings in
periodical newspaper (2)
According to the Chambers diction: -y, Journalism means, “the
collection and editing of material of current interest for presentation,
publication or broadcast” (3). Accordii g to New Gem Twentieth
1Century Dictionary, Journalism means “ the profession of conducting or
writing for Public Journals”(4)
The word “ Journalism” is derived trom “Journal” which means a
daily register or diary - book containing each. day’s business or
transactions (5). ‘The word Journal also connotes a newspaper published
every day or even lesser, magazine. ‘Thus Journalism means. the
communication of information regarding the events of a day through
written words, sounds or pictures. And a Journalist is a person employed
in writing for a newspaper or magazine (6),
The journalistic writing is, in fact, 4 contempora
report of the
changing scene in the society. It is mainly intended to inform the readers
regarding what is happening around them, ‘There is a big impact of
journalism and il can and afien does influence the course of events,
which are being reported, because, it sometimes brings public opinion in
focus and at other times even creates it, Thus the reports regarding
communal riots. workers’ demonstrations,
ising prices or a deteriorating
crime situation can spark a reaction among the citizens and force a
change in the local, state or national policies (7)
In the modern age, the press is called the “Fourth Estate(S). It
enjoys @ very important place in the socisty, The press protects the
ordinary citizens against the injustice and ty canny of the rulers. It is thevoice of the people and watchdog of their interes
in fact, the press
embodies the freedom of speech and expression of the Citizens (9).
JOURNALISM AND 19S ROLE IN SOCLAL CHANG
‘As we said earlier. the press plays a very important role in the
modern aye. A newspaper caters to the aecds of different readers by
publishing various types of news such as political, economic, social,
scientific and development ete. The press helps greatly in the formation
of the public opinion. Journalism, being x very effective tool ean play
effective role in bringing change in a society but before proceeding in
this regard, we must explain the term social change:
SOCIAL CHANG
No society in the world is completely static or totally changing
The phenomenon of the social change is as old as civilization itself (10).
‘The process of social chanye is universal aad it is working and would be
working in spite of the faw pace CH). The term “Social Change” is
relatively simple, although as a sociological concept it is especially
comprehensive. A social change is the difference in material objects and
the attitude of using such things along the time and space (12)
According to Merrifl, social change involves such ideas as interaction,movement, growth and function. He says “Social Change means that
large number of persons are engaging in activities that differ from those
in which they or their parents were engaged some times before (13),
There is no fixed pattern for the study of Social Change (14),
Nevertheless, certain theoretical descriptive and eyaluational aspects of
courses in social change have beeome taditional, The interest of a
Sociologist in the study of social change is lo observe fe
rms, speed (high
or Jow), cause (possible factors contributing to change), direction
(whether it is positive or negative}, contest (whether it is balanced or
imbalanced), source (origin), processes (course of action and pattern) and
resistance (factots working against the growth of social change)(15)
There is no single theory that could explain the most tedious and
complicated phenomenon of secial
nge. However, we can say that
Social change is a comples «nd complicated! phenomenon, Social change
means simply the process of becoming different in any sense (16)
Journalisnr-being a tool of mass communication can play the role
of a catalyst in the process of social change in any society. This role of
mass communication is normally divided into five main ar
(a) To
motivate (b) To inform (c) To educate (d) To change or effect the
behavior of the masses and last one is (e} fo act as a mitror to society
(17).Journalism can piay vital role in motivating its reader for any
targeted aim or change while making any motivating attempt, it must be
clear that target is based on facts and may have relevance with the
readers. For example use of mas
media, mainly radio and a newspaper,
in Tanzania to spread the concept of “Ujamaa” and thereby to generate
support for yrass-root development within the country was successful to
certain extent only because it evoked a resonant feeling among the
masses of Tanzania, Whereas in the case of Pakistan during the political
crises of 1969 and 1977 authoritarian governments attempted to ignore
massive and visible dissatisfaction while purveying an official line (18)
The information role of the journalisin is a function in which it can carry
words and pictures. The educational! role ef the journalism has probably
been the most widely publicized of
olentials. lis aim is not only to
spotlight the social, political and econom:e issue but also to educate,
inform and instruct the mass (19)
The potential of the newspapers to reach vast numbers of readers
has given birth to a certain mythology about the effectiveness of this
media in changing the behavior. There are various opinions about the
f
effectiveness of the Newspapers in alterin# opinions that have been
hurtured and therefor
ae very strongly heht by the receiving population
(20). It can be seen to have changed only those opinions and those modes
of behavior, which have been lightly held by the recipients of
5—_—
information, Also. it can be effectiv.iy employed to make slight
adjustments in the direction of action and thoughts of people. The use of
newspapers and radio provide examples of successful mass media
campaigns in the area of health educatio to alter behavior patterns. In
Trinidad and Tobago, a six-week campaign in 1964 utilized radio and
newspapers in an effort to reverse the deel ae in breast feedings (21)
The fib role for the journalism is one of a mirror that would
reflect the society it is part of. This rate, however, can be more of
activist than suggested by mirror analogy and it involves parallel
development of other social institutions (usiness, professional groups)
that would support this role (22)
The mirror effect works through informing “all” the members of
society of what is happening in their country and thereby creating a basis
for motivating them to participate in the development process be it
economic, political, social or cultural. This is not an easy task since it
Involves not only the participation of professionals in it but also the
movers and sha
kers in the parallel institutions, political, economic, social
and cultural who have to push their country constantly through the
Process of modernization towards an identified goal. The crucial element
in this role is to
6“Allow the print media to depict the soviely as it really is, rather
than, as it is perceived to be by a dominani proup or as this group would
like. il to be perceived” (23)
For example, in a country with sirong ethnic and linguistic diversity
national unity is the very fact that il is acknowledged through the print
media (24).
In brief, a newspaper caters to the needs of different readers by
publishing various types of news such as political, economic, social,
scientific, development ete (25)
SCOPE OF THE STUDY:
The scope of this research is to study the process of social change
and the role of Journalism (more specifically press) in the events, which
took place in the province of Sindh durivg the decade of 70s. The
prominent developments that shape the changes occurred during this
peridd are: -
(a) Approval of Sindhi Language Bill in 1972 by Sindh Assembly
whose approval caused widespread farguaye riots in the province
(b) Implementation of Quota system on the basis of the regional
disparities and backwardness. 1t was introduced in the year 1970
and it was given constitutional cover ii: 1973
(c) New Sindhi Middle Class who was making its presence felt and
struggling for the acceptance of its ro:e in the decade of 60s, now
7got significant standing and representation in federal and
provincial departments during the Bluitto regime.
(d) Centrifugal tendencies were also most expressive during this
period. Sindhi Nationalist’ Leader G.MSyed’s book “Why
Sindhudesh?” (Published in 1974) as well as the slogan of “Jeay
Sindhudesh” gained currency
(e) Z. A. Bhutto inwoduced land reforms in the decade of 70s.
(First attempt was made in 1977 and second announcement. was
made in 1977).
(f) Z.A. Bhutto was deposed in July 1977 and later hanged in 1979.
(g) Wide-ranging changes were seen in educational system. New
professional and Vocational Institutes and Universities were added.
(h) Process of Nationalization of Industrial and Financial Institutes
during Bhutto regime (1972-77) left their impact on rural Sindh.
‘There are number of reasons to study the process of social change
in Sindh in relation with Journalism.
(a) Sindh like other parts of the ccuntry is divided into rural and
urban population, but unfortunately, this bifurcation has turned into
ethnic dimension as well as, leading to conflicts. Major constituent
of rural Sindh population are local Sindhi whereas urban centers
are dominated by the community which migrated from India in
1947 i.e. Muhajits inter alia other cor munities
8(b) Journalism in Sindh is also divided on ethnic lines, Sindhi
Press largely supported the cause of rural Sindh, whereas Urdu
Press by and large reflected the concerns of their own Middle
Class.
(c) Policies adopted by Sindhi and Urdu Journalism resulted in
creation of doubts and biased feelings among both the
communities,
LITERATURE Ri
EVIEW:
Role of Journalism in shaping and focusing the important events of
the decade is the main emphasis of this sesearch that makes this work
different from carlier works taken on the subject, some of which are
compared below: -
Evolution and History of Sindhi_
Journalism, by Dr Aziz-ur-
a, a PhD. Thesis. ‘This thess evplains the history and
development of Sindhi Journalism. However, it lacks analytical approach
to the understanding of Sindh’s lagging ‘ehind in different fields like
economic, education, industrialization ete. The thesis is also silent about
the impact of Journalism on the Sindhi Society
In “Modern
nomy of Sindh,” (1981), Dr. Ishrat_Hussain
explains only the economic conditions of sindh, whereas this book tries
to look out all changes along with economi aspect.In “Today's Sindh”, Muhammad Mirza (1986), analyses the
grievances of the Sindhis in the historical perspective. He found the
sense of deprivation felt by Sindhis have -aken them to the extreme end
of isolation, and has pushed them away from the affairs of the country.
The theme of the book remains attached to the political clevelopments.
[In “Sindh-Voice of Silence”, Dr.Mubarak Ali (1992), a renowned
historian, studies the history of Sindh from a new and liberal angle. He
correctly pointed out the contradiction wethin the Sindhi Society. He
gave the account of the eniergence of Sindhi Nationalism and Sindhi
Middle Class ete. But the book did not explain the role of Sindhi Press in
the development and nourishment of these events
In “Ethnonational Moyements of Pasistan” ¢ 1988), Tahir Amin, a
Ph.D. thesis, analyses the rise and decline of Nationalist Movements in
Pakistan. He examined the cross border support the movement got and
threat to the country from them. He confines himself to the growth of
these movements and their capacity to bring about the disintegration to
the country. His work is silent about the role of the press in the entire
movement
SOURCE MATERIAL:
The period covered by this the
s is relatively recent (1970-80)
Due to the introduction of the One Unit in mid 50s and its continuation
for the next one and half decade, exetusive data for Sindh tarely exist.
loPrimary source material was Newspaper. periodicals and library books
Data provided by the various agencies government department and
independent associations was also relied upon, Interviews were another
means to obtain new thoughts about the development, which took place
decade and its relations with newspapers
during
addressed the role of Journalism in the process of social change
in rural Sindh in totality, including eeoomic growth, infrastructure
development, educational opportunities anJ political developments ete
While analyzing various developments in the field of education, it
has been attempted to explain whether new opportunities improved the
literacy rate in rural Sindh or it was only quantily change. Impact of
nationalization from the point of view of rural Sindh has been analyzed.
Agriculture is the backbone of the rural Sindh, Any change in the
agricultural setup, naturally, affects the life in rural Sindh. The role of
Journalism in the mechanization of agriculture and pattern of agricultural
products has also been examined, The role of Journalism in the
implementation of Land Reforms in true sense is also part of this work
One of the purposes of this research is not only to see the role of
Journal:
sm in various cha
nes took place in rural Sindh, but also to see
whether its role was positive or negative, Did it stay neutral or played a
Partial role in all these developments?RURAL SIND.
DEFINITION:-
Generally, population is divided it rural and urban centers on the
basis of several criteria, There is no standard definition of an urban place
(26). Despite the UNO’s recommendation that place with a compact
population of 20,000 or more inhabitants be regarded as urban and the
remaining as rural, countries have adopted their own operational
definitions. The United States of America for example defines an urban
place asa locality with a population of 25,000 or more and others as
rural, In Pakistan, the population censuses prior to 1981 have used a
definition of urban that includes all Municipalities, Civil Lines,
Cantonments and any other area inhabited by not less than 5000 persons
and consisting of continuous collection of houses (27). Some areas with
less than 5000 residents were also included among urban centers if they
possessed distinct urban characteristic (28)
This definition was again changed in the 1981 Census which
considered, in addition to the Cantonments, all Municipal Corporations,
Municipal Committees or Town Commiitiees as urban, if they were so
declared by the Provincial Government (29). But in the case of Sindh,
the concept of urban and tural Sindh has been misused in the prevailing
Political conditionsin this research we have consideied rural Sindh comprising all
those ateas, which were declared as rwal Sindh for the selection of
stitutes and served as basis for the
students in professional educational
recruitment in government jobs. Simply rural Sindh in the present study
comprises of all districts of Sindh excepi urban centers of Karachi,
Hyderabad and Suk’
During this decade, Sindh was divided into following districts,
brief introduction of these distziets is iver below: -
Most of this district was the part of urban
Sindh, except few villages of Sindhis and Balochis, which were
situated in the surrounding of the district. Most of the population
of this district was composed of people who migrated at the time of
partition. Most of them speak Urda, However, Gujrati, Maryati
ete. Is also spoken by a section of thos population, Literacy ratio of
this district was about 51% as per popubition of 1972 which raised
lo 55% as per census of 1981. This is considered as the Hub of
industries and backbone of the country’s finance. It was the
country’s only commercial seaport during the period.
2 UYDERABAD: — Hyderabad district during the decade
consists of the present day Hyderabad and Badin which was
later on craved out of it as a separate district. Hyderabad
City was declared as Urban S ndh, whereas remaining areas
“>
- 13were part of rural Sindh, {twas second big industrial area in
the Province after Karachi. Hyderabad City has the majority
of Urdu speaking people who migrated in 1947. The Sindhis
dominate rural areas. However, district Badin and other
fertile areas of distriets have strong pockets of Punjabi
Abadgar and retired Army officials, Literacy ratio of this
district was about 27% as per census of 1972 which
increased further one percent in the next census
Entire district Cf Thatta is part.of rural Sindh,
The rural inhabitants dominate it. There are a few industrial units
in Gharo and Sujawal, Literacy rao in the district was 20% as
per census of 1972 which decreased to 17% in the next census.
4. NAWABSHAH:- This distiet of Sindh has one of the best
agricultural lands in the province, Nawabshah City has mixed
population of Sindhis & Muhajirs. Sindhis dominated other
villages. A significant portion of agricuitural lands was allotted to
the Punjabi setticrs, M1 had fiteraey ratio of 22% according to the
1972 census, which increased by ane percent in the next census
Bigger feudal families like Jatois, Syeds and Jamalis are political
figures of the disirici. District is fi nous for its cotton production
and Sugar Canei
3 DADU: This district is pit of rural Sindh. It was
considered as bell of Nationalist forces. Sindh’s nationalist figure
G.M. Syed belongs to this area. Dom nating population of this area
is consisting of Sindhis. Literacy aio of the district was 24%
according to the 1972 census, which decreased to 21% in 1981. On
the one side dis known for its fertile lands like Mehar,
Radhan ete. whereas on the other side it has barren hilly ranges
like Kohistan and Fahnas ete.
6. THARPARKAR:- During the decade under consideration
this vast district was comprising of present day three districts i.e,
Mirpurkhas, Umerkot, and Tharpatl.ar. Desert areas of Umerkot
and Tharparkar have stationed majo:ity of Hindu population of the
province. Whereas cities and towns like Mirpurkhas, Juddu, Kot
Ghulam Muhammad, Tando Jan Muhammad and Digri ete have
strong pockets of Muhajits and Punjabi abadgars beside local
Sindhis. Except bigger cities literacy ratio is poor and area lacked
basic infrastructure, It was always: considered as a very sensitive
district being a border area, During he War of 1971 a large portion
of the district including important Cities like Nangarparkar,
Islamkot, Chachro etc. were captared by the Indian Army and
remained under their domination till the Simla accord was signed.
Therefore the Muslim population cI the captured areas migrated toother safe areas and Hindus le for India temporarily, Literacy
ratio of this district was 15% as per census of 1972, which
increased by one percent in the next decade.
7 SANGHAR: District Sangizar is adjacent to Mirpurkhas,
Nawabshah and Khairpur beside Sirdhis. {t has strong presence of
the Punjabi abadgars and cities fike Shahdadpur and Tando Adam
have a substantial Mubajir presence. Political arena is considered
to be dominated by the Hurs of Pir Pagara. Hindus constitute
about 20 percent of the total populition of the district. This area
has fertile fands of ta Khipro, Shahdapur, Shahpur ete. Cotton
and Sugareane are the main earniny: crops. Literacy ratio of this
district was 19% as per population census of 1972, which remained
stagnant in the next ten years,
SURIKUR:
Aller Karachi and Hyderabad, Sukkur is the
third important station of the prownee. it acts as a main trade
center for the upper Sindh. City population has strong presence of
Urdu speaking Muhajirs beside Sindiis, whereas rural areas are.
mostly Sindhis. Sukkur is part of uroan Sindh and remaining area
including Ubaro, Daharki, Ghotki, Mirpur Mathelo ete. are part of
rural areas. Government establishec a Cantonment area at Pano
Agil, fourth one in the province, «ter Karachi, Hyderabad and
Chor, despite strong protests of Sinchi Nationalist forces. Daharki
16f
see
and Mirpur Mathelo hrave stationed acca factories. Being situated at
the river bell and on the main Raibwey track (Rohri main Junction)
it enjoys multi dimensional benefits Literacy ratio of this district
was 26% as per census of 1972, which remained the same at the
end of the decade:
9. KHAIRPUR:- — Khairpur is the neighboring district of
Sukkur, ft was the capital of Khairpur Branch of Talpur rulers of
Sindh. This state joined Pakistan afier the partition and is now
inerged with the province of Sindh, During one unit it was third
division of the province along with Karachi and Hyderabad. This
district has fertile lands and is famous for Pirs, like Pir of Rani Pur
and Pir of Pagaro. This district has. alongwith the, Sindhis areas a
dominating population of Batochis, but now they consider
themselves a part of the Sindhi nation. The population of Shia sect
has strong concentration here. Disirict is famous for its Dates.
Literacy ratio of this district was 21%e as per population census of
1972 which remained almost stagnant in the next census carried
outin 1981
10, SHIKARPUR:- District Shikarpur has remained famous for
its trade and commerce even prior to Mughal rule in the sub-
continent. The Hindu population of the area, which migrated
in 1947, had developed its tinss with the Central Asia, Arabsand Europe. They had established educational institutes of
best quality. The Shaikh and Soomro families of the district
constitute major portion of the provincial bureaucracy of the
province. It remained the pari of the rural Sindh. Literacy
ratio of this distriet was 26% as per census of 1981. It was
part of Sukkur district in the year 1972,
i LARKANA:- The district is famous for political
leadership of the Bhuitos, Khoros and the Kazi families. Along
with local Sindhis Baluch tribes like Chandio, Magsi and Brohis
etc, have their considerable ratio in the disiriet population, During
the Bhuito government many facilities like Chandka Medical
College, Rato Dero Sugar Mill (although not feasible) were added
to the district. Due to (he histories! site of Moenjodaro, it is also
served by an Airport, Literacy ratic of this distriet was 27% as per
population census of 1972, whieh decreased to 22% as per next
population census report
iW JACOBS
This bordering district between Sindh and
Baluchistan, once called “upper.sindh Frontier District” was
named after Brig, Gen. Jolin ‘'acob, who acted as its political
Agent afler Sindh’s conquest in 1843. He developed this
district as a buffer estate beiween Baluchistan and British
India. The area has strong population of Baluch tribes like
18Khost
Jakhranis and Bijranis ete. Political leadership is in
the hands of these Baluch tribes. Mostly Baluch traditions
are followed in the district. {t is considered one of the most
backward districts of the province, it is the only area, which
had no industrial infrastructure previously, and neither it was
developed later on except few Rice Mills. Literacy ratio of
district, was 16% as per census of 1972, which
considerably decreased to 11% in the next population
census.
IvPOPULATION BY NUMBER OF LITERATE BY DISTRICT AND LITERACY RATIO.
IN SINDH, 1972 & 1984
4972 1981
JPROVINCEIDIT TOTAL | LITERATE TCITERACY| TOTAL
~TITERATE [LITERAG
STRICT |POPULATION| POPULATIO) RATIO. |PoPuLATICN|POPULATION| Ratio
(10 YEARS & [1 (10 YEARS | | (00 YEARS &
: ABOVE) |__ABOVE)
i 2 pS Tee eee 7
y | _9,589,444| 12,832,648| 4,036,304] 31.45)
i 470.388; 99.271! __ 634,011 137,353] 21.66]
5 464,256; 75,888 654,161 71,630] 10.94
i o29,e39[ 241,922] 724,590 190,868] 26.34
) ie 600,652] 130,382 27.71 740,179| 163,758] 22.121
: ee: 487,392 94,082] 612,878] 17.047] 19.24]
| i 718,932 114,034 1,020,671 167,436] 16.4]
L | 528,709| 128,078] 704,856 191,822| 21.53]
i 1,520,088] 410.436] 271,376,081 304,492/ 28.66)
p ee 458.243] 93.084 20.31 7.586] 88,512 17.78
E ei __| 15,008] 76,404 14.83]
; EN 854,312] 103,728) 22.7| 1,056,076 242,978| 23
t re 2876443] _1.318,507[ _51.2]__3.206,152[ 2,134,090] 55.04
| NOTE. Uiteracy is defined as the ability fo read with understanding short statement of every day
a of life to any language
TOTAL NUMBER OF LITERATE
Literagy is defined as the abitity to read with understanding shor statement of every day
Literacy Rati «100
Total Population (10 years & above)
Shirkarpur District is included in Sukkur District in 1972 Census,
SOURCE: District Census
1972 and 1981REFER
C
ol
04.
05.
06.
07
08,
09,
Mirza Muhammad Yousaf, —i:xploring Journalism, A-1
publications, Lahore, 1993, P-33,
Ibid
The Chambers Dictionary, Chambers Harrap Publishers Ltd.,
Edinburgh, 1997, p-904
New Gem Dictionary, Collins Clea’ Type Press, Oxford,1965, p-
281
Yousaf, op-cit
Oxford Dictionary, (third edition), Oxtord University Press,
Oxford, 1988, p-438
Prof. Muhammad Naseer, Qatal-Wa Gharat Ka Bazzar Aur Azad-i-
Izhar, /rftage, Itaqa publications, Karachi, December, 1989, p-82-
102
Dr. Mahdi Hassan, ‘The Fourth Esizie, /raqa, Intaqa publications,
Karachi, March 1995, p-54
Zamie Niazi, He Press in Chains, Royal Book Company, Karachi,
1993, p-131
Muhammad Iqbal, fitrocuction fo Sociology, Dogar publications,
Lahore, 1987, p-131K. Singh, Principles of Sociology, Prakashan Kandra, Lucknow,
1977, p-254
John F. Cuber, Sociology, Appleton Century Crofts, Newyork,
1955, p-139
13. FE, Merill, Society and Culture, Prentice-Hall Inc. Englewood,
Cliffs, N. J., 1957, p-469.
14, John Erie Nordskog, Social Change, McGraw- Hill Book
Company, New York, 1960, (Preface)
15: Naseem Bano, Social Change in Society, Sindhological Studies,
Institute of Sindhiology, Jamshoro, August, 2000, p-88
16. Eric, op cit, p-I.
17. Dean TJamison and Emile G.Mc Ananey, Radio for Education
and Development in John Eric (ed.), op-cit, p-7
18. Shuja Nawaz, Mass Media and Development in Shahid Javed
Burki and Robert Laporte Jr. (ed.), Pakistan's Development
Priorities, Oxford University Press, Karachi, 1986, p-326.
19. Shahwar Junaid, Communication Media and Statecraft SIC
Publishing Consultant Rawalpindi, 1988 p-5
20, Elhu! Jacques, propogandes or propozanda in John Erie (ed,) op cit,
p-87
21. Jamison, Emile, op cit.
22. Shuja Nawaz, op cit23.
24,
25.
26.
Junaid, op cit, p-14
Shuja Nawaz, op cit
Junaid, op cit, p-18.
Feroze Ahmed, Ethnicity amd Politics in’ Pakistan, Oxford
University Press, Karachi, 1999, p-i49.
Pakistan Statistical Year Book-1987, Federal Bureau of Statistics,
Karachi, p-635
Feroze, op cit
Ibid.