Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Tax Avoidance and Coporate Capital Structure (Cristine Harrington)
Tax Avoidance and Coporate Capital Structure (Cristine Harrington)
The Killer B involves the parent company giving its foreign subsidiary stock in exchange for cash. In the Deadly
D the parent buys a third company and then transfers ownership to the subsidiary, receiving cash from the subsidiary
su
equal to the purchase price. Both of these types of transactions are tax free. A more detailed explanation is
provided in Hicks and Sotos (2008).
2
The declaration of foreign earnings as permanently reinvested allows firms to manage earnings and
a avoid tax
payments. For permanently reinvested income, firms do not have to record income tax expense on the financial
statements or pay income taxes.
The firms in the Graham and Tucker (2006) sample have very large tax shelters on average (in excess of $1 billion
per year, or around 9% of total assets). Graham and Tucker have noted that the average tax shelter size is equivalent
to having assets supported by 90% debt with a 10% coupon.
t-1
t-5 income tax paid (TXPD)
t-1
t-5 pretax income (PI) special items (SPI)
(1)
The cash ETR is calculated over 55-year overlapping intervals beginning in 1989 and ending in
2007, producing ex ante cash ETRs from 1994 through 2008. For each 5-year
year interval, a
minimum of 3 years of both income tax paid and pretax income must be available.
available The
identification of ex ante tax avoiders follows Blaylock, et al. (2012). A cash ETR equal to or
less than zero is reset to 35% (the
the U.S. federal statutory rate
rate), and a cash ETR value exceeding
one is reset to 1. All firm years are sorted into quintiles of the cash ETR distribution.
distribution Minimal
data screens are applied prior to ranking the cash ETR
ETRs to help reduce misclassification of nonnon
tax avoiders. For any given year, a firm must have positive net sales (SALE),
SALE), positive total
assets (AT),, zero tax loss carryforwards (TLCF), positive pretax income (PI), and positive cash
tax paid (TXT). Firm years falling into the lowest quintile are assigned an
n ex ante tax avoider
indicator
ator variable equal to 1 (0 otherwise).
The cash ETR identifies tax avoidance for any reason
reason. In the context of the trade-off
trade
theory, leverage is expected to vary positively with the tax avoider indicator in the general crosscross
section (H1). At a refinancing
ncing point, ex ante tax avoidance is expected to positively influence
the likelihood of issuing debt (H2). Following a refinancing, ex ante tax avoiders are expected to
have higher leverage (H3). The results in Graham and Tucker (2006) and Wilson (2009) indicate
that abusive tax avoiders tend to have lower leverage and issue less debt, supporting
support
the
t-1
total tax expense (TXT) deferred tax expense (TXDI
TXDI
t-5 total
t-1
t-5 pretax income (PI) special items (SPI)
(4)
A firm must have a minimum of three years of observations to be included in the sample. The
same minimal screening (as described for the cash ETR) is applied to the data prior to ranking
firm yearss into quintiles of the current ETR distribution. Firm yearss in the lowest quintile of the
current ETR distribution are assigned a tax avoider indicator equal to 1 (0 otherwise).
otherwi
The regressions for the three hypotheses are repeated using the current ETR as an
alternative method of identifying tax avoidance and the results in Tables 2 and 3 are highly
robust to this alternative method.. In the cross-sectional regressions, the
he marginal effect of tax
avoidance on leverage remains small (coefficient estimates are around 0.03) but highly
significant (t-statistics
statistics range from 9.85 to 13.84). T
Tax avoidance remains a positive and weakly
6
Three methods are eliminated because these do not include deferral strategies. Two other methods are excluded
because these require hand collection of data. Three methods employing book
book-tax
tax differences are excluded because
of the difficulty (and duplicity) in separating tax avoiders from earnings managers.
% Tax avoiders
Market cap (t-1, millions U.S.)
% Sample with debt issues
Book leverage (t-1)
Market leverage (t-1)
Deviation from target
Operating ROA
ln(assets)
Market-to-book
R&D/sales
% Sample with missing R&D expense
PPE/assets
Z-score
% Z-score<1.81
Baa-Aaa yield spread
General sample
N=25,122
Standard
Mean
deviation
Refinancing sample
N=14,576
Standard
deviation
Mean
18.2%
$2,762
27.0%
18.7%
13.8%
-2.3%
16.4%
5.39
2.06
59.9%
42.4%
28.8%
6.44
8.1%
0.80
18.7%
$3,291
46.5%
21.0%
14.9%
-2.7%
17.0%
5.49
2.10
50.7%
44.2%
29.7%
5.98
8.1%
0.80
38.6%
$15,038
44.4%
17.4%
14.9%
9.6%
9.4%
1.93
1.87
1,252.1%
49.4%
21.9%
11.17
27.3%
0.21
39.0%
$17,256
49.9%
17.4%
14.7%
10.2%
9.1%
1.94
1.87
1,079.5%
49.7%
22.3%
9.86
27.3%
0.21
Tax avoiders
n1=2,724
49.8%
13.9%
21.9%
24.2%
15.4%
18.0%
6.15
13.0%
Non-tax avoiders
n2=11,852
45.7%
11.7%
20.8%
22.5%
14.8%
16.9%
5.94
7.0%
Difference in means
t-statistic
3.85
3.69
3.01
4.25
1.90
3.05
1.00
8.67
Intercept
General sample
N=25,122
(1)
(2)
LT book
LT market
leverage
leverage
8.686
8.208
(13.76)
(15.60)
Refinancing sample
N=14,576
(3)
(4)
(4
LT book
LT market
leverage
leverage
9.793
9.067
(11.10)
(12.68)
(12.68
Tax avoider
0.018
(6.65)
0.015
(6.25)
0.016
(4.32)
0.011
(3.46)
(3.46
Operating ROA
-0.166
(-5.96)
-0.252
(-8.25)
-0.215
(-4.70)
-0.328
0.328
(-7.93
7.93)
ln(assets)
0.014
(24.85)
0.005
(9.53)
0.009
(12.28)
0.001
(1.52)
(1.52
Market-to-book
-0.001
(-0.52)
-0.013
(-7.46)
0.000
(0.14)
-0.016
0.016
(-7.33
7.33)
R&D/sales
0.000
(-3.62)
0.000
(-5.57)
0.000
(-2.10)
0.000
(-3.16
3.16)
0.044
(19.24)
0.042
(20.44)
0.046
(14.71)
0.042
(15.41)
(15.41
PPE/assets
0.177
(24.29)
0.153
(23.04)
0.164
(16.40)
0.143
(15.98)
(15.98
Z-score
-0.003
(-3.25)
-0.001
(-1.18)
-0.003
(-2.67)
0.000
(-0.37
0.37)
-0.015
(-2.65)
0.008
(1.61)
-0.019
(-2.40)
0.009
(1.32)
(1.32
0.380
(28.71)
0.413
(32.30)
0.210
(12.35)
0.240
(14.93)
(14.93
Time trend
-0.004
(-13.51)
-0.004
(-15.26)
-0.005
(-10.83)
-0.004
0.004
(-12.34
12.34)
0.24
0.26
0.18
0.23
Adj. R2
Refinancing sample
N=14,576
Intercept
Tax avoider
Operating ROA
ln(assets)
Market-to-book
book
R&D/sales
Missing R&D dummy
PPE/assets
Z-score
Baa-Aaa
Aaa yield spread
Deviation from target
Firm effects
Time effects
Pseudo R2
Estimate
0.818
0.077
-2.113
-0.052
0.005
-0.002
0.159
1.236
-0.024
-1.010
-5.850
Yes
Yes
p-value
<.0001
0.0913
<.0001
<.0001
0.7894
0.5857
<.0001
<.0001
0.0311
<.0001
<.0001
0.11