COURSE SYLLABUS

CIVIL PROCEDURE
Xavier University-Ateneo de Cagayan
Judge Jose L. Escobido
Villegas v Legazpi
I.

113 SCRA 39

JURISDICTION OF COURTS
What is jurisdiction
People v Mariano
Auyong Hian v CTA
Dacoycoy v IAC

What is exclusive jurisdiction

Ong v Parel
Supra
What is concurrent/coordinate jurisdiction
St. Anne Medical v Parel
176 SCRA 755
~Monseratt v
178 SCRA 153

71 SCRA 600
19 SCRA 10
195 SCRA 641

What is judicial power (Art VIII, Sec 1 of the 1987 Constiution)

Ruperto v Torres
100 Phil 1098

What is criminal, civil, territorial and extraterritorial

Vol 16 Corpus Juris 147

Distinguish jurisdiction and judicial power

What compels jurisdiction
Bacalso v Ramolete
21 SCRA 519
Zamora v CA
183 SCRA 279
El Banco v Palanca
37 Phil 921
De Jesus v Garcia
19 SCRA 554
Amigo v CA
GR 102383
Realty v CA
GR 117051
Phil Derby v CA*
GR 108115
Felipe v Leuterio*
91 Phil 482
Lions Club v Briones*
121 SCRA 621
Calimlim v Ramirez
118 SCRA 211
Malaluan v CA
232 SCRA 249
Tijam v Sibonghanoy
23 SCRA 29
Padre v CA
214 SCRA 448
~
214 SCRA 529

What is legal and equitable jurisdiction

Heirs of Soriano v CA
198 SCRA 549

Additional Cases (Jurisdiction by Estoppel)

Gonzaga v CA
GR 144025
Manila Bankers v
GR 139791
US v Canete
38 Phil 253

What is primary jurisdiction

Provident Farms v Bacalio
GR 92285
Industrial Enterprises v CA
184 SCRA 426
What is jurisdiction over subject matter
La Naval Drug Co v CA
GR 103200
Reyes v Diaz
73 Phil 484
Special/Limited Jurisdiction
Garcia v Sandiganbayan
GR 114135

Feb 26 1996
Jan 22 1996
Oct 27 1995

Errors of jurisdiction v errors of judgment

Day v RTC Zamboanga
191 SCRA 610

Dec 27 2002
Dec 12 2003

Mar 28 1994

Aug 31 1994

Oct 7 1994

To whom jurisdiction is vested

People v CFI Quezon
227 SCRA 457
What determines whether a court has jurisdiction over subject matter
Orosa v CA
193 SCRA 341
Sumulong v CA
232 SCRA 372
Bautista v
384 SCRA 553
What is jurisdiction over issue
Reyes v Diaz
Supra
Viajar v CA
168 SCRA 405
Sadal v Phil
186 SCRA 491
Jurisdiction over res
Rayray v Chae Kyung Lee
El Banco v Palanca

Jurisdiction v procedure
~Fule v CA
Manila Railroad v Atty Gen

74 SCRA 189
20 Phil 523

Jurisdiction v venue
Manila Railroad v Atty Gen
Dacoycoy v IAC

Supra
Supra

Doctrine of Hierarchy of Courts

Vergara v Suelto

156 SCRA 753

Doctrine on Judicial Instability

Algo v Habo

163 SCRA 237

Jurisdiction of SC (Art VIII, Sec 1,2,5 of the 1987 Constitution)

Schneckenburger v Moran
63 Phil. 249
Vergara
Supra
De Guzman v Sandiganbayan
GR 103276
Jan 11 1996
Ortigas & Co. Ltd v Velasco
GR 109645
Mar 4 1996
Manalo v Gloria
GR 106692
Sept 1 1994
Jurisdiction of CA (BP 129, Sec 9 as amended)
Domingo v CA
GR 102360
Morales v CA
GR 126623
Jurisdiction on RTC (BP 129, Sec 19 as amended)
De Jesus v Garcia
19 SCRA 554
Raymundo v CA
213 SCRA 457
Bembo v CA
GR 116845
~ v CA
193 SCRA 237
Suton v Baylon
199 SCRA 525
Ebria v CA
GR 117389
De Leon v CA
GR 96107
Mendoza v Te
GR 122646

Mar 20 1996
Dec 12 1997

Nov 29 1995
May 11 1995
Dec 19 1995
Mar 14 1997

Jurisdiction of Family Courts (RA 8369, Sec 5)

18 SCRA 450
Supra

What is jurisdiction over person

El Banco v Palanca
Supra
What is general jurisdiction
Deveza v Montecillo
27 SCRA 822
Lachenal v Salas
71 SCRA 262
What is original jurisdiction
Ong v Parel
156 SCRA 768
What is appellate jurisdiction

* read together

Jurisdiction v Exercise of Jurisdiction

Lamayan v Dela Cruz
40 SCRA 101
Dela Cruz v Iyak
134 SCRA 41

Jurisdiction of MTC (BP 129, Secs 33,34,35 as amended)

RCBC v Hon Islani
GR 117383
Mar 5 1995
Semirara v CA
GR 76031
Mar 31 1994
Concurrent Jurisdiction of SC, CA and RTC over petitions for
certiorari, mandamus, quo warranto
Art VIII, Sec 5 (1) of the 1987 Constitution
BP 129, Secs 9 and 21 as amended
Katarungang Pambarangay (LGC, Secs 399, 408, 409, 411, 412, 419)
~Domingo v
GR 173135
Bejer v CA
169 SCRA 566
Diu v CA
GR 115213
Dec 19 1995