Professional Documents
Culture Documents
428
428
Author
Md. Tarikul Islam
Supervisor
Mr. Hans Lind
III
Foreword
Assistance and cooperation of different people in different stages of my
thesis preparation helped me to add more beauties to the report. At the
event of the report submission I sincerely remember all of them and
express my gratitude to them.
At the very beginning I would like remember all the blue collar job holders
in different real estate companies in Dhaka, Bangladesh for their valuable
time to me. Discussions with them provided me a lot of qualitative inputs
that has been added in the report. I am also sincerely grateful to my
friends who helped me to collect the primary data in Bangladesh.
Credit also goes to my peers and teachers at real estate department at
KTH. They always extended their big hands to me in my journey to study
in KTH. They also helped me to be introduced with lots of new aspects of
real estate business operations.
Finally I express my deep gratitude to my supervisor, Mr. Hans Lind for
his patience and flexible thinking. Without the flexibility that he has given
me it would not be possible for me to finish my research works.
Table of Contents
Sequence Number
Topic
Abstract
1.0.
2.0.
3.0.
4.0.
5.0.
II
Introduction
1.1. Background and relevance of the research: The Context
1.2. Problem definition, aim, and the added value of the
research
1.3. Research Question & the scope of the research
1.4. Theoretical frameworks and the structure of the research
1.5. Methodology
1.6. Chapter Summary
This
2.1.
2.2.
2.3.
2.4.
2.5.
Page
is Bangladesh
History of Bangladesh
Geography of Bangladesh
Demographical data of Bangladesh
Economy of Bangladesh
Chapter Summary
01
01
02
03
03
04
05
06
07
09
12
13
16
16
17
19
20
21
23
23
23
24
27
28
30
34
Actors Analysis
4.1. Major Actors in the real estate industry in Bangladesh
4.2. Summary of Actors Analysis
35
38
39
41
41
43
43
43
5.3.
6.0.
7.0.
8.0.
9.0.
10.0.
11.0.
Market Analysis
6.1. Introduction to the five forces model of Porter
6.1.1. Bargaining power of suppliers (Real Estate
Firms)
6.1.2. Bargaining power of buyers
6.1.3. Threat of new entrants
6.1.4. Threat of substitutes
6.1.5. Rivalry among existing firms
6.2. Applying Porters Model to the Real Estate Market in
Bangladesh
6.2.1. Bargaining power of suppliers (Real Estate
Firms)
6.2.2. Bargaining power of buyers
6.2.3. Threat of new entrants
6.2.4. Threat of substitutes
6.2.5. Rivalry among existing firms
6.3. Introducing government in the Porter model
6.4. Summary of Market Analysis
Vale
7.1.
7.2.
7.3.
Chain Analysis
Concept of Value Chain
Applying the concept to the reality
Chapter Summary
44
45
45
46
47
48
49
50
52
52
53
53
56
59
60
62
64
65
67
68
69
Effects Analysis
8.1. Different Types of effects
8.1.1. Direct effects
8.1.2. Indirect effects
8.1.3. External effects
8.2. Summary of effects analysis
70
70
71
71
72
Segregation Analysis
9.1. Defining Segregation
9.2. Reasons of Housing Segregation
9.3. Types of segregations in Bangladesh
9.4. Consequences of segregation
9.5. Summary of Segregation analysis
73
73
74
77
79
80
81
83
84
85
Concluded Part
11.1. Conclusion
86
11.2.
11.3.
12.0.
Recommendations
Future Research
88
89
Appended Part
12.1. References
12.2. Appendix
Table of figures
No
2.1.
2.2.
2.3.
2.4.
2.5.
3.1.
3.2.
3.3.
3.4.
3.5.
3.6.
3.7.
3.8.
3.9.
3.10.
5.1.
6.1.
6.2.
7.1.
10.1.
10.2.
10.3.
10.4.
Title
Bangladesh in the Indian Sub Continent
Districts Of Bangladesh
Divisional Cities & City Corporations
Population at different ages
Sector Wise Contributions to GDP
Divisional Cities & City Corporations
Location of Barisal in Bangladesh map
Rajshahi in the map of Bangladesh
Sylhet in the map of Bangladesh
Khulna in the map of Bangladesh
Chittagong in the map of Bangladesh
Dhaka in the map of Bangladesh
Dhaka City Map Showing Different Market Segments
Dhaka city and its outskirts
Neighbouring Districts of Dhaka
Decision Making Process
Porters Five Forces Model
Porter Model Including Government as the sixth factor
Porter Value Chain Model
Sampling of Population
House Ownerships in Bangladesh
Stages of real estate business in Bangladesh
Most valued attributes
Page
05
06
07
08
10
13
16
18
19
20
21
23
29
31
33
40
48
65
67
80
81
82
83
Table of Tables
No
2.1.
2.2.
2.3.
2.4.
3.1.
10.1.
10.2.
Title
Religion Statistics in Bangladesh
Sector wise employment
Remittance flow to Bangladesh
Major economic data of Bangladesh
Total population in different city corporations
Factors affecting real estate business in Bangladesh
Customers satisfaction of real estate products
Page
09
10
11
12
25
82
84
1.0. Introduction
This chapter starts with a discussion on the relevance and background of
the research (1.1) to provide a clear understanding about the research.
After the background an elaboration is given on the problem definition,
the aim and the added value of the research (1.2). The research question
and the scope of the research that sets the boundary of the research are
discussed too (1.3). Then after that a brief discussion is given on the
theoretical framework and the approach to the research (1.4). Finally
there is a summary for this part (1.6).
1.1. Background and relevance of the research: The Context
Bangladesh is a small country with a very low per capita income. Here
people still struggle for the basic needs fulfillment. When still lots of
people struggle to have a minimum shelter, real estate products that is
assumed to be very expensive, is kind of extra luxury to the majority of
the mass population. However, real estate sector has been developed and
it is growing with a good pace along with a gradual increase of its
contribution in total GDP. Investments in this sector have been increasing
over time and competition has becoming sharper because of the increased
number of firms as well as stakeholders awareness. Government is trying
to build a proper framework for this business sector.
People who are in the high income brackets are the main customers of
these real estate products. But day by day involvements of the middle
class in the society is increasing. In this circumstance, government is
trying to involve low income people too by suggesting the real estate
companies to plan for housing for these people. As the involvement
increases question of quality and satisfaction also comes to the scenario.
The background of this research is those factors which lead the
development of the real estate business in Bangladesh along with an
analysis of the market. At the same time how people think about the
quality of the real estate products are also considered.
1.2. Problem definition, aim, and the added value of the research
This research is basically a descriptive one with some characteristics of
normative research focusing on the development of the real estate sector
in Bangladesh. At the same time current business condition has been
covered too along with a presentation of customers viewpoints on real
estate business in Bangladesh i.e. what customers think about different
aspects like quality of real estate products. Therefore the research is
aimed at discussing the factors that contributed to the development of the
real estate business in Bangladesh and how the market is performing
now. It also focuses on various affects of the real estate business in
Real estate market is linked with the whole economy. It can affect the
economy to some extent while economic ups & downs also affect it. At the
same time government plays an important role by different policies and
regulations. So its a large area to cover. But in this research the author
does not cover all. Therefore the scope of the research is the following.
Included are:
Dhaka city and its outskirts get the most importance, as this
is the main area where real estate firms are acting.
Excluded are:
it also talks about the current market functions and the affects of the real
estate business in Bangladesh. Also it talks about the possibilities about
the times to come.
Sources of Data: Both primary and secondary have been used to
prepare the report.
Primary Data: Primary data comes from the interviewing
people through questionnaire and the informal interviews with
the real estate professionals and experts in Bangladesh. The
author is from Bangladesh and his personal observation,
living, and discussion with the professionals are other main
sources of primary data.
In fact six divisional cities got the status of the city corporations and
based on these cities urbanizations is growing up in Bangladesh. People
like to move to the city areas from the rural areas due to the more
facilities in daily life in the city areas. These facilities include availability of
better transportations, access to gas & electricity, access to better
accommodations, job opportunities etc.
& 138.6 million in 2004 & 2005 respectively. The annual growth
rate was 1.42% (BBS, 2007) in both 2004 and 2005.
80+
75 - 79
70 - 74
65 - 69
60 - 64
55 - 59
50 - 54
45 - 49
40 - 44
35 - 39
30 - 34
25 - 29
20 - 24
15 - 19
10 - 14
05 - 09
00 - 04
14
12
10
10
12
14
In 2004 & 2005 this ratio was 105.2 & 105.0 respectively while the
expectation for 2006-20011 is 106.0 (BBS 2007).
Census 81
86.65
12.13
0.62
0.31
0.29
Census 91
Census 01
88.31
10.52
0.58
0.33
0.26
89.58
9.34
0.62
0.31
0.15
1995-96
1999-00
2002-03
19.8
6.1
3.7
2.5
22.9
6.7
4.3
3.0
5.1
1.1
2.7
1.5
Trade
Balance ($m)
Years
200001
-2011
200102
-1768
200203
-2215
200304
-2319
200405
-3297
200506
-2879
Table shows the employment by major industries thats is not necessarily the total
labor force.
10
Still the export amount is increasing over the years. In 2006, countrys
total export was 10.5 billion US$ which is 21.6% higher than previous
year. The main item of export is readymade garments, which contributes
75.0% of the total export earnings. EU, USA and Canada are the major
markets for the exporting products. Earlier Bangladesh could export jute
& jute made products and tea to some countries in a large quantity. But
gradually garments sector were getting more and more attention and for
the last couple of years this sector dominates the scenario.
Another most important aspect of Bangladesh economy is remittance.
Lots of Bangladeshi people working abroad send money to their
belongings in the country that with the multiplier affects help the total
economy in greater details. At the same time total amount of remittances
is also increasing day by day for which now a day its commonly believed
that remittance is the backbone of the Bangladesh economy.
Table-2.3: Remittance flow to Bangladesh
Year
2002-03
Number of Employed
Persons
241425
Remittance (Million
USD)
3061.97
2003-04
272633
337.97
2004-05
251699
3848.29
2005-06
286381
4801.88
46.3 millions are the available total labor force while the total employed labor force is
44.3 millions.
11
2003-04
2004-05
200506
3329.73
6.27
24628
418
3707.07
5.96
27061
441
4157.28
6.63
29995
447
21.04
26.60
52.36
20.14
27.22
52.63
8.36
19.61
27.91
52.48
8.04
5.83%
6.48%
7.17%
12
13
The major part of the preference of rural people comes from their
observation of the houses in neighborhood and in the city areas. When
they visit the city areas they get new ideas about housing and try to
implement those ideas in their own house building activities.
Another question might arise about the differences among the cities
based on real estate firming activities-Why there are differences among
cities? In fact development of the real estate business activities in a
particular area depends on a lots of things and the whole process is much
more complex in a country like Bangladesh where
As a result, when a farmer decides about the use of his/her lands, he/she
has to think a lot because of the potential losses arising from the
opportunity costs. But the reality is little bit more difficult in Bangladesh.
Here some people have lands as the only source of income. So when they
decide upon the use of lands they cant think it much really because this
is the only option they have.
14
Its surprising but true. However the good thing is that Government have
started to think about the issues and they are focusing on a formal policy
about the real estate business in Bangladesh. At the first step few weeks
back Bangladesh government suggested the real estate firms to think
about the housing for middle class and poor people considering their
affordability. Bangladesh Bank, the central bank of Bangladesh, also
declared a decrease in the interest rate on housing loans. It also said that
gradually it will make the housing finance related issues more flexible.
Availability of relevant financial services as well as access to those
financial services by the mass people is one of the most important issues
in case of real estate business development in Bangladesh. Banks, except
a couple of banks, dont provide housing loans and those which provide
housing loans have strict conditions. These banks charge higher interest
15
rates for housing loans and they sometimes want the loan backed by
something i.e. property as mortgage, which is difficult for a good number
of people. Banks try to explain the situation saying that the scope of real
estate activities is pretty narrow in Bangladesh and they always carry the
potential credit risks coming from the borrowers.
In addition to that there are other factors which we might say common
factors around the world that can affect the real estate activities in a
particular region. These factors includes but not limited to the followings.
16
One of the major characteristics of the Barisal city is that there are lots of
students staying in this city. It has the best and most famous university
college of the southern region of Bangladesh named B. M. College. Almost
thirty thousands students study in this college. In addition to that the city
has six other colleges and one medical college along with lots of other
educational institutions like Textile College, polytechnic institutions etc. A
large number of students come from outside of the Barisal city and the
educational institutions cant provide accommodation to all students.
Therefore students stay in mess or rented apartments. But the condition
of messes are not really good and its pretty difficult to rent apartments as
the landlords dont like to rent their houses to students. So there is
always a need of new apartments for students and it could be one of the
best opportunities for the real estate business firms to penetrate in near
future.
3.2.2. Rajshahi: The education city of Bangladesh
Rajshahi division includes sixteen districts of the northern region of
Bangladesh. In addition to the Rajshahi city corporation, Rangpur and
Bogra are another two mentionable towns from this division. These two
towns get attraction due to the bulky development activities in these
towns in different times. Rangpur came to focus for the huge
infrastructure development by that time government in 80s to 90s and
Bogra had lots of development activities in the last couples of years. Both
cities have lots of educational institutions including medical colleges.
The total population of Rajshahi city is 447031 (BBS, 2006) that are
pretty much low compared to other densely populated cities in the
country. But this city is pretty much important for the country because of
the following two roles.
17
The population density is not that high and therefore land is not yet
scarce.
Most of the lands are being used as the input of agriculture. So
people live in self made houses normally.
The growth of urbanization is very low in these areas.
Majority of the population are poor in these regions and they dont
afford the expensive houses. As a result real estate business firms
are not pretty much interested in those areas.
But there are great potential for the real estate business in these areas
especially in Rajshahi city. This could be a great market for the firms
which can offer houses for middle and low income people.
As mentioned earlier, Rajshahi is the education city of Bangladesh. So
there are lots of students coming from all over the country stay here for
educational and job purposes. They require houses, but they dont afford
expensive housing. So if any company can offer housing for medium
income and low income people, it might gain from the market
substantially. Students especially can be a very good target market and it
should be profitable business venture. Students are pretty large in
numbers and they come each year. Another fact to consider is the time
period. A company even can think relatively long term. A student in a
university stays minimum five years in the city for completing graduation
only. If he goes for master or PhD then it takes much longer time.
18
19
from Sylhet region. One has to be able to speak in Sylheti, the dialect in
Sylhet.
Most of the developers and builders who are doing real estate business
here are from Sylhet which limits the scope for others to enter into this
area. At the same time some migrated Bangladeshis from London invest
in the real estate sector in this market and they are pretty much favored
by the local people. So this market has narrow offers for the firms not
owned by the people of Sylhet or not originated from Sylhet.
3.2.4. Khulna: Industrial Zone of Bangladesh
Khulna is the second most important industrial zone of Bangladesh and it
is situated in the south west part of the country. The city has the third
largest amount of population among the cities and there are lots of
industrial units in this area. People from Khulna sometimes claim that
they have a kind of multicultural environment in the city as people from
different parts of the country came and settled here. But they still have
their own cultures.
The city has large amounts of educational institutions including couples of
universities, medical colleges, engineering universities, polytechnic college
etc. But except the public university, engineering university, and the
medical college no other educational institute attracts students those are
not from Khulna region. So there are not that much students looking for
housing here. At the same time universities offer large scale
accommodations for the students. So though there are lots of educational
institutes in the city, students cant be a logical target market.
20
Its worthy to mention here that all the real estate firms that function
here are of small and medium size. They normally operate outside of the
city corporation. Therefore now-a-days experts put the question on
whether or not these small and medium firms will be able to meet the
increasing housing demand in Khulna city arising from rapid
urbanizations.
3.2.5. Chittagong: The largest industrial zone of Bangladesh
Chittagong is the main industrial city of Bangladesh and its in the second
position among cities based on total population. In Chittagong people
speak in a different dialect and they have their own culture. The level of
education was not much good until the last couple of years. Though the
city has the second largest population, real estate business is not yet
seen that much in this region. It might happen as because the level of
land scarcity is low till now.
21
jobs from different other regions of Bangladesh. These jobs are mostly
low paid jobs like jobs in the garments sector. As a result people always
look for the cheaper houses and they go out of the city area to live. But
its also true that there is a significant amount of population in the city
who has above average annual income and affords luxury houses. These
people are the basic target here in Chittagong market for the real estate
firms and therefore there are couples of companies are working here in
the real estate sector. Initially there were some small and medium size
firms, but now almost all the big firms that mainly operates in Dhaka
region, focus on Chittagong market. Some have already started housing
projects here.
In Chittagong division, Bangladesh has two beaches among which one is
Coxs Bazaar, the largest beach in the world. Coxs Bazaar is pretty much
attractive for the real estate companies especially for the commercial real
estate developers because of the large scale tourism activities in this area
around the year. In peak season the demand for residence becomes so
high that one has to book hotel or rest house well before one plan to go
there. At that time price is also very high i.e. almost double or triple of
that in off peak season.
Some large real estate firms operate in this area mainly to build hotels,
restaurants, and rest houses. There are also demand for residential
houses as some rich people of the country like to have houses here in
case they want to visit the city & beach sometimes. Recent data shows
that some five stars and four stars hotels have already been built in Coxs
bazaar and these are near to the beach. But the demand for residence is
still increasing which means that this market still have large potential. In
reality the market now looks for the quality services and therefore it
provides ample opportunities to them who can build the houses or
restaurants or hotels with quality through maintaining some pre-defined
standards.
Another unique characteristic of this division is that one significant part of
the division is hilly. Normally tribal people live in these hilly areas and
they build their own houses though the houses are not of quality at all. In
fact one might argue that they live in hills not in houses.
Therefore chances for the real estate companies in this region are mainly
oriented to the high income people. Thats what happening here in reality
too. Some small scale real estate firming is seen in the area named
Khulshi, an area that is pretty close to the city centre. Its said that elites
of the city has moved to this area in course of time. One of the major
features of this area is that it has beautiful landscapes and proper
arrangement of security, a primary concern for the people in this area.
22
In future it is hoped that real estate firms attention will be moved from
Dhaka to Chittagong to meet the rising demand of housing in this area. It
should be mentioned here that the demand rises normally because of the
high pace of industrialization in this area.
3.2.6. Dhaka: The Capital of Bangladesh
Dhaka city, the capital city of Bangladesh from Dhaka division, is the main
area of real estate business in Bangladesh till now. The city is expanding
day by day in every direction it can and this expansion generates the
opportunities for the real estate business sector. In Dhaka the population
density is pretty high and its still increasing. People from rural areas and
the outskirts of Dhaka city come to the city everyday which makes an
enormous traffic in the city per day. All the major government offices and
diplomatic offices are also in Dhaka that made the country centrally
administered followed by an increase in the daily traffic to the city.
3.2.6.1. Brief History of Dhaka
The city which was born during the Moghul Empire and grown with the
British rule, has experienced a lots of ups and downs of history. But after
the expiry of British rule in 1947, when Bangladesh has been separated
from Pakistan in 1971, Dhaka city got the most attentions as the
powerhouse of the country. Rapid development and growth was found in
every sector. But gradually the city was lacking proper management and
from the late 90s of 20th Century its growth and latter development is
marked with sheer lack of proper and far-reaching planning.
23
24
2001
2006
Dhaka
Chittagong
Khulna
Rajshahi
Sylhet
Barisal
5333571
2023489
770498
388811
263197
192810
6479751
2438403
830454
447031
394119
205166
26
Complimentary services:
garbage disposal, central
services, roof top facilities,
developers. It reduces the
liked it much.
27
28
29
30
31
Another very important place under Savar police station is Ashulia. This is
a place where people come to spend some of their free times when they
become bored in Dhaka city. This is kind of recreational spot in the
vicinity of Dhaka city for the people in Dhaka and its outskirts. There are
two amusement parks here and the spot is very close to the Dhaka
airport and another famous residential area Uttara. Also its very close to
the Dhaka Export Processing Zone (DEPZ), the industrial park where lots
of people works in different foreign companies. So the place holds a
strategic importance for which it has been targeted by the real estate
developers in the last couples of years. But as there were some conflicts
on the issues like real estate firms are not considering the importance of
recreation for the urban people, the construction activities have not been
started until the last two years. Now there are lots of construction
activities are found here and the areas close to the airport. These
constructions includes a range of housing projects starting from houses
for medium income people to houses for the highest income level people
in the country.
Close to Ashulia there is another place which is called Tongi under the
district of Gazipur. But now its difficult to understand whether its a part
of Dhaka city or a part of Gazipur district because of rapid urbanization in
this area. There are lots of real estate activities in this area and real
estate developers are already pretty much inside of the Gazipur district.
The main reason of this large scale real estate activities is once again the
improvement of the communication systems in between the districts.
People now can come to Dhaka from Gazipur very easily for jobs and can
go back after the job period. The same holds for the people in Dhaka who
go to Gazipur for jobs.
In the east part of the city all the areas got huge pace of urbanization in
the last couples of years and lots of real estate firms are working there to
meet the rising demand for houses in the areas like Demra, Jatrabari etc.
The focus of the real estate firms is no more limited in these areas; rather
they are already inside of the border districts like Narayanganj and
Munshiganj. Though in Munshiganj they started newly, the town areas of
Narayanganaj is almost like another region of Dhaka with lots of real
estate activities. This happened once again due to the rapid urbanizations
and developments of communication systems in between the districts.
Narayanganj is only 30-40 minutes away by bus or 20-25 minutes away
by train. Therefore jobholders come to Dhaka in the morning and get
back home in the evening very easily.
32
33
34
Therefore in bad time of real estate business when small firms were
getting out of the scenario, large firms survive and they lead the market
eventually.
Again individual real estate firms are in the supply side and have large
influence on demand/supply mechanism in the market to determine the
35
price of the real estate products. But pricing depends on lots of other
factors too like land price, land value, interest rate etc.
Customers: Customers are on the remaining side i.e. demand side of the
market. Customers preferences, affordability, income range, tastes etc.
influence the demand and supply of the real estate products in the
market. The main aim of the customers is to buy houses with the highest
possible quality at a given budget.
How customers can influence the market is somehow limited to the
different aspects like available substitutes, emergency etc.
Architects: These are the professionals who transfer lots of imaginations
in reality for both developers and customers. They play a crucial role in
designing and construction phases of houses. To get permission from the
government authority to construct buildings, firms have to submit the
design done by architects. The aim of architects is to secure job and earn
money from designing and consultancy.
The influence of architects is limited by their goodwill, experiences,
success stories, educational background etc. More and more architects
are being produced in the country and they enter in the job market. But
the major problem is the work field for them is limited to the situations
where the laws are strict. Therefore one might argue that architects are
not the critical factor in case of real estate business in Bangladesh.
Financial Intermediaries: This group includes mainly banks. But there
are some other sources also. For example, pension funds, insurance
companies, individual savers etc. Though almost all banks have some
offers for the customers in case of real estate buying, there are some
specialized banks for the financing of real estate products. But its claimed
that the offers from other banks are not lucrative as they dont finance
the big purchase and the offers from the specialized banks are pretty
much expensive due to the high interest of the banks.
Central bank also plays a crucial role here. It controls the ups and downs
of interest rate in the market and therefore due to the negative price
elasticity, demand for the real estate products goes down.
One of the major concerns in finance is the accessibility of mass
population in house financing services provided by the banks or other
institutions. In Bangladesh this is really a big problem because
36
Therefore these are some issues that central bank cant control and its a
continuous drawback for the growth of the real estate business in
Bangladesh.
Government & Government Units: Government is the ultimate role
player in any kind of business in Bangladesh through laws and
regulations. Though government interference is considered as an unfair
event in terms of free market economy concept, some markets require
government hand for the proper functioning. Real estate business in
Bangladesh is one like that.
However, in this sector there is not yet any regulatory framework.
Therefore builders do whatever they find good for them. It continued for
the long time and now all are in a mess. Though government is willing to
fix the problems, its pretty difficult and in some cases they are too late to
react. For example, due to the random construction the traffic system of
Dhaka city has been broken down since the last couples of years. Initially
government was not careful. Now though they are caring for it, fixing the
whole issue is beyond their means due to high level of costs.
In addition to government there are various units of government who
plays crucial role in the real estate business.
37
38
Defining the problem: What is the real problem to solve? Here one
identifies the goals and objectives one wants to achieve by solving
the problem.
Developing criteria: One has to be sure about the attributes one
would like to see in the objective. These attributes are used to
evaluate criteria. Therefore one has to develop the set of attributes
in such a way so that they do represent their wish in the objectives.
Available alternatives: In this step one determines what are the
available alternatives one can consider to gain the desired goal.
Evaluation of alternatives: In this step one compares the
alternatives in light of the pre determined attributes. One can
39
Selecting the final one: After evaluation one is now up with the so
called scorecard of different alternatives when they are compared
against the pre determined attributes. One therefore selects the
best alternative to implement based on the scores in the scorecard.
Implementation: In this step one implements the selected
alternative to solve the problem and to gain the predefined
objectives.
Feedback & Control: This is the last stage in the process. Here one
collects feedback to know the success or failure stories of the
implemented solution. If needed one takes the action to adjust the
solution to the situation.
40
the buyers in
want to buy a
to think ahead.
an easy task at
Initially buyers think that they want to have an own house. Then they
think about money and try to manage the monetary investments. So
there is an information search here about how much money one needs to
invest in order to have a house. But this information search is not that
deep and buyers sometimes make some inquiries with the real estate
firms or they try to learn from the neighbors about their experience of
buying houses.
Based on the information they gathered on monetary investment required
they start trading off. Here they try to decide what kinds of housing they
afford to buy or what kind of houses they should buy for themselves.
They want to maximize their preference within the available budgets.
There are three major ways one can meet the demand of houses. They
are described bellow.
41
Buy house: In this case one buys the whole house either
from the real estate firms or from an existing owner who sells
the house. In any case its very expensive and it does not
provide much financing flexibility. Real estate firms provide
some financing flexibilities like installment payments, but still
its pretty expensive because of high monthly installments
and huge down payments at the beginning.
Normally high income people afford it. The final outcome is a
ready house for the buyers. Buyers do not need to manage
any construction activities and therefore no complexities of
managing stakeholders like engineers, architects, developer,
brick company, and cement company etc.
Buy Plot: Some real estate firms develop lands and sell those
developed lands to the buyers. Buyers modify if needed and
build houses according to their own preferences. This is
relatively cheap initially but one has to spend much later on
when one starts constructing houses.
In this case one has to manage all the stakeholders which in
other cases managed by the real estate firms. Therefore this
option produces lots of complexities a buyer has to manage to
have the own house. The final outcome in this case is the land
to construct houses rather than a ready house. Buyers have
the flexibilities in financing as they can pay the money in
installments and the down payment is relatively low.
There is a variety here. One can buy lands from other parties
like individual landowners rather than real estate firms to
construct houses. It works as an alternative to the buyers
when they dont get any real estate firms offering the product
they would like to buy.
Buy Apartment/Flat: Flat as widely said in Bangladesh
rather than apartment is the most common solution to the
buyers of real estate products due to different reasons. First
buyers get the flexibilities in financing as they can pay the
money by installments. Sometimes real estate firms help the
buyers to get access to the financing services available. Again
as money is paid according to the predefined schedules, one
can plan long term which is helpful to accommodate any
changes.
Secondly here one gets ready house to live in. So one does
not need to handle with the complexities with the
stakeholders. Thirdly buyers have voice over the construction
42
43
44
Experts mark this aspect normal in Bangladesh and they say its not that
complicated. In their opinions buyers put most of their emphasis on costs
and therefore they dont bother as long as they are convinced that
quality/standard well represent the costs.
So costs benefits analysis comes to the scenario. But in Bangladesh its
not common except the commercial real estate products. In case of
residential real estate products, buyers buy them not with the intention of
making profits from them. Rather they buy them in order to live and
emotion is pretty much attached to it. So they dont go for the cost
benefit analysis normally. But buyers are careful to be sure that the
property deserves the particular amount of investment considering the
properties of it and the market condition.
5.2.6. Selecting the Alternative
In this stage buyers pick up the one they think goes best with their
intention. In the previous stage buyers get a scorecard that represent the
worthiness of the possible alternatives to satisfy a particular need. Based
on that scorecard buyers select the one with the wish to implement. As a
general rule, buyers select the one that produce the highest score. But
reality becomes different when buyers add the qualitative judgment with
the quantitative scorecard. Like the previous steps emotion once again
plays a vital role here.
5.2.7. Implementation
Buyers are almost done in the process of buying house. They have
already decided about category and alternative they do want. So they
contact the supplier and make the contracts that explain among others
total amount to pay, the payment schedules, attributes of the houses,
delivery date, quality aspects etc.
One has to be very much careful when one make contracts to be safe
from any kind of frauds that might arise later on. It has been claimed that
frauds in the Bangladesh market has been rising in the last couple of
years.
After the delivery of the houses one gets the chance to compare the
promised features with the delivered features. Any discrepancies can be
settled by proper communication with the real estate firms.
One of the mentionable issue in this stage is the post purchase switching.
If after the delivery one does not like the products, one might switch to
the alternative. But this is very expensive. Thats why except some high
income people no one makes post purchase switching. Post purchase
45
switching might require one to sell the current houses which might incur
loss or gains for the seller.
Loss might come up because of costs of transactions, time, and other
administrative activities. Gains are also possible as because the property
values normally increase rather than decrease especially in the urban
areas.
5.3 Summary of the analysis (Decision Making Process)
Understanding buyers decision making process is important for any
company especially to put the right product at the right place at the right
time at right price. This all four right determines the success of the
company.
In case of Bangladesh real estate sector marketing carries an enormous
importance at the initial stage of decision making when one search for
information and try to compare different alternatives. If a company can
provide the required information at this stage properly company can gain
the attentions of the potential buyers. Purchase decision depends on the
companys performance in the later stages.
But in the later stages when buyers are about to make the decision they
dont depend on information about the company only. Rather they like to
see the real works, quality of the works, and companys total offer among
other factors.
So one has to be very careful about the contents of information one
provides to the potential buyers or existing buyers at different stages. For
example one should not provide the same information package to the
buyer who is in the initial stage of decision making process and the buyer
who is in the last step of decision making process. In the first step buyers
are looking for the information about the offers, the companies who make
the offers, and different attributes of the products etc. But in the last step
buyers might look for the information about the price of per square feet or
the cement the company is using or the length of balcony etc. So one has
to understand the buying process to design the proper strategy at
different stages in order to gain attentions of the target market followed
by contracts with them.
Experts argue that success depends on the micro level analysis of the
different stages in the decision making process of the buyers because
buyers are also varied substantially in different aspects.
46
47
49
50
Switching costs for buyers: High switching costs can reduce the
buyers intention to switch which fade the profit potential for a new
entrant.
51
52
53
54
55
In case of post purchase switching, its really expensive for all the
groups in the market. The reason is that one has to go through all
the steps i.e. information gathering, evaluating alternatives,
deciding for one etc. again to buy another house. But in reality still
switching happens mainly by the high income groups.
6.2.2. Bargaining power of buyers
Bargaining power of buyers that arises from different factors is the ability
to force prices down, bargaining for higher quality or more service, and
playing competitors against each other. The parameters of this force are
described bellow.
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
But once the company invests a lot in the factors of production like
labor and land, practically its pretty difficult for the firm to leave the
market. If the company leaves, company looses not only the
investment but also the potential profits.
So its not common that firms investing huge amount of money
leaves the market. In reality big firms that are operating in the
market, they do invest in real estate in order to diversify their
portfolio of investments.
6.3. Introducing government in the Porter model
Government can influence the real estate business activities to a large
extent through different policies of government. One of them could be the
interest rate change by the central bank. Real estate activities have an
inverse relationship with the interest rate changes. So interest rate ups
and downs can influence the access of people to the financing services
available in the country followed by the change in demand of real estate
products in the market. In Bangladesh, recently central bank has
announced that it will make the real estate financing issues more flexible.
Therefore stakeholders are expecting some positive affects of this
announcement in the real estate activities in Bangladesh.
Government can influence the flow of financing to a certain sector by
advising the financing institutions not to finance to a certain sector or the
reverse. It reduces/increases not only the money flow to the sector but
also the sectoral activities because of demand supply mechanism in the
market.
Government has lots of other ways to influence the sector. For example,
government can make strict laws and regulations about the real estate
operations in Bangladesh. Then it will be difficult for lots of business firms
especially the small and medium firms to operate in the market. They will
face difficulties to get the permission from the relevant authorities to start
their operations as only few firms are maintaining quality in Bangladesh
market.
In addition to that government can affect the sector by changing the tax
rates or by changing the land laws or by changing the construction laws
or combination of all these. In Bangladesh the sector currently lacks
proper framework where it can perform better. Random and indiscipline
constructions thats are now in operation will ultimately work as a big
negative factor for the city planners may be ten (10) years on from now.
64
66
67
Service: Its all about post sell service to keep the beneficial
relationship with the buyers
The main theme of the model is that firms ensure the efficiency in
performing primary activities that are the triggers of firms profits with
the help of support activities.
7.2. Applying the concept to the reality
Here the author applies the concept of value chain model to the
Bangladesh real estate business sector to find out where does the values
come from. At the same time it will show what are the most important
activities in the values chain for the sector.
In Bangladesh inbound logistics and marketing & sales are the two most
important activities in the value chain in case of primary activities.
68
Though value comes from all the activities in the chain, these two have
more influence compared to others. In inbound logistics, one of the most
critical things is the acquisition of lands for construction. Price of land
sometimes is the triggering point for the potential profits of any firm from
a certain projects. Therefore timing of land acquisition and the location of
land are very important.
Once one has the lands and all other inputs to construct the houses one
has to inform the potential buyers about their products. As real estate
business is a bit different and investors pay the money beforehand,
marketing plays the most important role in the initial stage, as this is the
mostly used way of communication with the target market. In Bangladesh
very few companies has the brand loyalty from buyers and therefore
buyers like to see all the details before making any decision. This is point
where marketing creates value for the companies.
In case of other activities very few firms could earn the customers
satisfaction while others still lack of it because of the following things.
69
70
71
72
73
individuals etc. Lets have a look some of those factors which influence the
housing segregation in Bangladesh.
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
Number
57
63
94
68
90
34
38
67
71
53
56
Percentage
57%
63%
94%
68%
90%
34%
38%
67%
71%
53%
56%
82
Total percentage is more than 100% because respondents could select more than one
option
83
Quality
Post purchase care
Financing terms
Luxury aspects
Time to hand over
Very Happy
Happy
~~
19%
11%
2%
~~
29%
40%
33%
45%
10%
Somehow Need
Happy
Modifications
52%
33%
56%
52%
87%
19%
8%
~~
1%
3%
84
In reality what happens is that when there are some lands eligible to
construct multi storied housing project in the city, companies try to
convince the land owner by offering him/her some advantage package.
But questions come up because this package is not sufficient and even
companies force the land owners to adjust the package offer negatively in
the post construction phase. Some land owners are so simple that they
cant understand the complexities of the tricks companies play with them
and finally get high level of dissatisfaction.
Therefore 87% of the total respondents think government should come up
with proper regulations to set up an exact framework for the sector so
that all the efforts of the sector go in favor of the welfare of the country
and society. They think demand supply mechanism is not a proper way in
Bangladesh market till now because supply is less than demand and
demand is increasing day by day in the Bangladesh market and
developers just exploit the pace of demand not the social welfare.
They also argue that if demand supply mechanism would be good enough
then the city would not be so vulnerable to the earthquakes. It has been
claimed for a long time that an earthquake with the medium level
intensity can destroy the majority of the buildings in Dhaka city. Old city
area is the most vulnerable to the earthquakes.
Experts also argue that Bangladesh market is not yet ready for the
demand supply mechanism to decide everything due to various reasons.
Some of them are undue influences by some big companies to modify the
way of business in the sector, less awareness of the mass people,
corruptions in the administration, and demand is far more than the supply
etc. They argue that due to the above mentioned reasons the condition of
Dhaka city is miserable now. If government would be taking care of it well
before rather than today, Dhaka could be a very good place to live.
Therefore they suggest to the Bangladesh government to think not only
about Dhaka city but also about other cities in the country for a better
Bangladesh.
10.5. Chapter Summary
Though land scarcity and the lack of social security has led Bangladesh to
have a formal real estate sector, most of the dwellers are not satisfied
with the products of the real estate companies for various reasons.
Among them less quality, high lead time, random constructions by the
real estate firms, and the profit orientations of the firms are mentionable.
Therefore they suggest government to come into the scenario to design a
proper framework with regulations if necessary within which real estate
firms will operate towards the better Bangladesh.
85
86
affiliated with REHAB. But only 10-15 large companies hold the 95% of
the total market share, which means that the market is pretty much
concentrated. However, the market is open to all investors to invest and
there is no entry barrier.
Residential real estate products dominate the market though there are
small scale commercial productions too. But its assumed that in near
future the scope for commercial real estate business will be expanded in
the other regions except Dhaka city.
Major players in the market: Real estate firms, customers, banks, and
government are the major role players in the real estate sector in
Bangladesh. Firms control the production while they have to be
dependent on the demand arising from customers. This demand is
affected by some other factors like price of lands, income level,
complexities in building houses, and population growth etc. among
others. Government as the chief commander of the country can influence
the whole market through different relevant policies, but there is not yet
anything like that from government.
Effects of real estate business: Though the sector has both positive
and negative effects, experts argue that it can be much better if
organized properly. Dhaka city as the victim of the indiscipline and
random developments by the real estate developers is suffering from
severe traffic jam and large scale pollutions.
Value chain and segregation: All the activities in the value chain add value
to the final products. However, acquisition of land and timing of
acquisition is very much value creating to the real estate developers. The
reason is that these two factors largely influence the profit margin from a
particular project.
Though most of the segregation is involuntary, resources scarcity
produces lots of by products which are pretty negative and taken by the
people as the effects of segregation. Among them crimes and lack of
proper educational services are mentionable.
Customers reaction: In reality customers are pushed to accept the
available offers in the market even though thats not the exact demand
from them. Therefore majority of the customers think that their
investments in the real estate products are not fully justified. They also
dont like the fact that the developers are caring for profits only rather
than total welfare.
Main research question: The answer of the main research question can
be get once one combines the answers of the above mentioned sub
questions. To meet the varied demand arising from the change in
87
88
One can go for further research with any of the mentioned areas. But as
par the author is concerned, preference goes to the Dhaka city and real
estate as portfolio diversifier.
89
90
Female
30-39
40-49
In your opinion whats the current phase of the Real Estate Sector is in now in
Bangladesh?
Introduction
Growth
Maturity
Decline
Property Ownership & Satisfaction
Do you own any property from any real estate company?
Yes
No
If no, do you think you can manage your property better than the companies?
Yes
No
If yes, what are the attribute(s) you have been considering most before purchase?
Overall quality
Luxury
Space
Location
Company (Brand Value of the company)
Ease of financing like instalment payments
Amenities of the property
Others: .
Did you visit any finished project of the company before purchase?
Yes
No
If yes, how it influenced your purchase decision?
To a large extent
Little bit
No influence at all
If no, then what attracted your to this company product(s)?
Company advertisements
Stories from others
You had no other way
Others: .
How satisfied you are with your product(s)?
Very Happy
Happy
Somehow
Happy
Need
Modifications
Quality
Post purchase care
Financing terms
Luxury Aspects
Time to hand over
How do your rank your company compared to others?
Among top five (05): 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
Among top ten (10): 6, 7, 8, 9, 10
Among the rest
What are the major things you want to change for your company?
..
..