:

2007

2007

1.

1.1.

1.2.

2.

1..

11

2.

12

3.

13

1.

16

2.

3.

18

19

21

1.

21

2.

2.1.

24

2.2.;

25

2.3.

26

3.

29

4.

32

5.

33

1.,,

36

2.

37

39

2.

40

3.

:
1.

3.1.

3.2.

40

42

:44
1.(
)

45

2.

47

3.

49

4.(
)

50

1.

52

2.

53

3.

54

:,

1.

1.1.()

56

1.2.,(
)

57

1.3.

59

1.4.

59

2.

61

1.

63

2.

3.

64

65

67

,

. ,
, , ,
, ,
, .


. ,
,
,
. ,
,

.

,
. ,
,
,.

1.

1.1.

.

,

, 1. ,
,
.
2
3,

.
,4.
5...
.,

. JaegerWarner,,,,.293.
.,,2004,.11.
3 , (, ,
) , ,
, ,
:,,.
9, .,,
,,
,,,
, ,
,.
4JaegerWarner,..,.293.
2


5.
,,,
, , , , ,
,
. ,
, , ,
, 6.
5...
.,
,
.
,
,
5 . .. ,
.

,


,.,
,
, ,
7.
, Reinach8,

WestM.L.,,.,1999,.47.
Reinach Theodore, , ,
1999,.164.
7WestM.L,..,.48.
8.ReinachTheodore,..,167.
5
6

 ,

. West
,

9
,
.
,4
. ..
,
.
,,
,
.,
,
, ,
.


,
10.

WestM.L,..,.49.
Reinach(.ReinachTheodore,..,168)

, ,
,18...
.
9

10

1.2.

5 . ..

. , ,
,
.
,
[...]11.,
,
.
,
12.
,
, . ,
,
.

2.

(
)
,
. , ,
.

Marrou Henri Irenee, , .

,1961,.42.
12 [ , . ,
.] .
654ab.
11

.
, ,
. , ,
, . ,
,,
.
.
. , ,
,
.
13.
.

,,

,,
. ,
,
,Lippman14.

249d.
LippmanEdwardA.,MusicalThoughtinAncientGreece,NewYork1964,.75.

13
14

10

1..

15,

.

.
.

,
.
,
, .
,
,
, 16.
,
,
. 17.
18
, ,
.19

597598.
597e,[...][...].
17598b.
18[]598d.
19598d.
15
16

11

2.

,
20. ,

21.

()
,
22.,,
:
23,
24.,

25.

26.

. ,
, 27. Lippman

.BeardsleyMonroeC.,,1989,.28.
.BowmanWayneD.,PhilosophicalPerspectivesonMusic,NewYork1998,.26.
22,235d236c.
23 [ ,
],234b.
24,602b.
25603b.
2610be.
27,,..()
,2002,.938.
20
21

12

, 28. Beardsley
,
.
,
,
,.
, ,
29,(
) ,
30. ,
31.

3.

32.
, .
,
,
,
.

, ,

,
.
, , , . .
LippmanEdwardA.,..,.74.
.
30BeardsleyMonroeC.,..,.2829.
31 . , ,
,1986,.5476.
32597e.
28
29

13

 ,
. ,
,,33.

,,,

.

.
,
, .
,,,
,
34.
35,,,
,36.

.,
,
,,
37.,

38, ,

598d600b.
395c396a.
35397d.
36395c.
37396b.
38,669e670.
33
34

14

 ,
39.

,
,.
,
. 40,

, 41. ,
. , ,
.

[,
]
668c.
40 .

.
(),
,
,
,
.
41,..,.66.
39

15

1.

,

42. , ,
, Lippman : )

, )
,
)
43.

.
44,
45.
,
46. ,
47.

. Lippman Edward A., .., . 74. . . .,

,,1966,.107136.
43.LippmanEdwardA.,..,.73.
44.AndersonWarrenD.,EthosandeducationinGreekmusic,Massachusetts1968,.88.
45[]668b..
,..,.31.
46655d.
47656a.
42

16

48.

49.
.Beardsley
,
50,
. .
Jaeger,

51.,

52.
,
, ,
.
.,
53.
, ,
()
, ,
,,
54.,
.
, ,

655cd.
BowmanWayneD.,..,.35.
50BeardsleyMonroeC.,..,.39.
51JaegerWarner,..,.281.
52WestM.L,..,.342.
53326a.
5451d.
48
49

17

.

.

2.

55,
,

56. ,
,
. ,
57,58.

. .
59,owman.
,60,
61.

62.
,
,
,
,.
56JaegerWarner,..,.411,.81.
57501d.
58667c.
59BowmanWayneD.,..,.41.
60667c.
61LippmanEdwardA.,..,.33
62659d.
55

18

, 63.
,
. , ,
,
,64.
, :
,
, , ;65.
Beardsley
()[...]

.
[...]66.

3.

,
.
,
67,
68.
69,
802cd.
11a59e.
65 [

,,]667b.
66BeardsleyMonroeC.,..,.42.
67.LippmanEdwardA.,..,.50.
68.BowmanWayneD.,..,.44.
69503504.
63
64

19

,.
,
owman70.
, ,
71, ,
72.
,
73,


74.,,

.

,
(

, ,
75) , :
, ,
76,77.

BowmanWayneD.,..,.36.
149cd.
72155e156b.
73245a.
74BeardsleyMonroeC.,..,38.
75.LippmanEdwardA.,..,.56.
76.WestM.L.,o..,.45.
77.BowmanWayneD.,..,.19.
70
71

20

,,

78
, , ,
79,

. ,

,
80,.

1.

.
,
.
,
81.
, ,
82. ,

Elias
(.EliasJuliusA.,PlatosdefenceofPoetry,MacmillanPress,London1984,.13).
79 EricCsapo,ThePoliticsofthe
New Music, Murray Penelope, Wilson Peter, Music and the Muses, Oxford University
Press2004,.236.
80JaegerWarner,..,.279.
81..,..,.109.
82377bc.
78

21

 , 83
84.
, ,
,


85.
,
86, ,
, 87,
.
88,
89.

,
. , ,
, ,
. , ,
90. ,
,
. , ,
, ,
.

801cd.
378e.
85377de.
86379a.
87380ab.
88380cd.
89382e.
90387c.
83
84

22

 91. ,
92.
93.
,
, 94,
,
,
95.,
,
, 96,
,97.
,,
,
, ,
, ,
Beardsley98.

386388.
.,.1416.
93.BeardsleyMonroeC.,..,43.
94
,(...,
..,.108).
95398ab.(...,..,.108)
.
96 lias (. Elias Julius A.,
.., . 211212)
.
,
, .
,
,,.
97 . Elias Julius A., .., . 1. , .
.49.
98BeardsleyMonroeC.,..,.44.
91
92

23

2.
2.1.

99,

.

.

,.

,
,
.,,
. .
, , .


,

, [...]
100.,
,
,,
101. ,
,
.
,
(,),
.West(..,
. 242257), , ,
.
100399ab.
101399.
99

24

 , ,
,,102,
,
103.

2.2.;

.
. ,

104. owman

105, Reinach

,.,,
4 . .. ,
,
106.,
. ,
,107.

.
.
[,,,
,]188d.
103193de.
104.,,,..,1962,
.CVIV.
105.BowmanWayneD.,..,.22.
106.ReinachTheodore,..,.167.
107.AndersonWarrenD.,..,.96.,.804cd.
102

25

 ,
,
.

2.3.

,
. Lippman

,
108.

, :

,
(),
;
, 109.
, ,

,,,
(),
. , ,
Barker110, .
,

.LippmanEdwardA.,..,.7273.
.,..,.59.
110BarkerAndrew,GreekMusicalWritings,VolumeI,TheMusicianandhisArt,Cambridge1989,
.168.
108
109

26

 111
.
, (
)
112.
,,,
,.West
: , ,
,
.
,
113.

Barker

West,,
. , ,
,
.

, . ,
,
,
(
114).,
,

.WestM.L.,o..,.243BarkerAndrew,..,.165.
112 O
(
.1342ab).
113.WestM.L.,o..,.252.
114399d.
111

27

,115,
,
,
116 (
).
,
Anderson117
118, ,
, ,
.,

119.
,

.

.
, ,
,,,
, 120,
,

.WestM.L.,o..,.88.
399d.
117.AndersonWarrenD.,..,.90.
118.,..,.5960.
119.AndersonWarrenD.,..,.107.
120,
. . ,

,1821,.2446.
115
116

28

(),,
.

121 122,
(
). ,

.

3.

. , ,
,
: , 123.
,
,,
. , ,
. , , ,
, ,
124.
,
125.
,
.
.398e,399a.
.379a.
123 . ,
,1999.322,249250,6268.
124ReinachTheodore,..,.154.
125.,..,.6263.
121
122

29

 , , 126,
.

,127.

,
.

128,
.
:

129.

,,130,

,.
, ,
.
,,
,.
.


.
, , .

411ab.
,..,.64.
128764de.
129.,..,.44.
130.,..,.192196,161162.
126
127

30

,
131,.

, 132

:
,
.
.

. ,
, 133. ,

134.
Reinach135,(136
) ,
.
.

. ,
.


. , ,
812de.
.,..,.64.
133..2224.
134 399e.
, .
, ,
.
135.ReinachTheodore,..,.156.
136.,..,.66,95,97.
131
132

31

 ,
137.

4.

.
138.
139,

. ,
140.
141,,
,
, ,
.,142143.
, ,
144.

.,..,.7374,344345.
326b.
139,,430..
.
140,399e.
141(...,.117),
.
142()
143400b.()West(...,.252)
.
144669c.
137
138

32

5.

,
, . ,
.
145
,
146.

, .
,147.
148,

.,:)
,

[].654b.
669c.
147672e673a.
148
..

,
,,.,
(.JaegerWarner,..,.414,
.140).(.411a412a).
(88bc).,,
,:,
, ,
[
, ,

] ( 403d). Lippman
,

(.LippmanEdwardA.,..,.84).
145
146

33

)(),.

, ,
.
.
149.
,
150.

.)
,
) ,

. ,
,
.,

.
[...]
151.
,



795d796d.
813b,813e.
.
: . ,
, ,
(,.)
.
151[]815ab.
149
150

34

 . ,
. ,

,
,
.

.
. ,
, , ,
, ,
.

OLippman

152.
.


.
,
.

:
153.

.LippmanEdwardA.,..,.82.
814d816c.

152
153

35

1.,,

: ,
,154.
. ,
::,
. ,
.
, ,

155156157.
, ,
.
158.
,

.
.

.
654b.
156654e,672e,816a.
157816c.
158400a,400d.
154
155

36

2.

.
.
159 .
160
161. , ,
, ,
,
.

, ,

()

162.

.
.

.[...] ,
163,
.
.
,.

[
]670a.
160812d.
161
.
16251d.
163,..,.66.
159

37

.
,

164.
,
.,,,
,
.

.,..,.67.

164

38

1.

, , .
, 165.
.
,

, . ,
, , ,
,
,
.

166,.

:,

, ,
,
. , 7 . ..,
, , ,
167.

.,..,.69.
,..,.225.
167.,..,.224225.
165
166

39

,
168.

2.

, ,
, , ,
, , , .
, ,
169. , ,
,170.

3.
3.1.

.
,
171.

.ReinachTheodore,..,.170.
700ac.
170[]799e.
171424c.,.
,
,
,.
168
169

40

 172, ,
,
173.

174.

,,,

175. ,
.
176,
.


,
177. , ,
178 ,

,179,

.
180.
,
Beardsley181.

798e,816c,424b.
797c.
174.LippmanEdwardA.,..,.81,82.
175799ab.
176660d.
177800ab.
178[]801d.
179801cd.
180659d.
181.eardsleyMonroeC.,..,.44.
172
173

41

, 182

3.2.

:
. ,
183,
184

185, ,
186,,,
187.,
188,
, ,
.
,
,
.
,
, ,
,
..2223.
501e502a.
184700d.
185
.
,
.
.
186493d.
187670b.
188[]701a.
182
183

42

 ,
189.

,
190,
191.

,
, .
,
.

659bc.
659a.
191700c701a.
189
190

43

,
. ,
192,
193,
194,,,
,

, ,

195.
,
.
:.

196.

.BowmanWayneD.,..,.36.
.AndersonWarrenD.,..,.90.
194 . Dillon Ariel, Education in Platos republic, presented at the Santa Clara University
Student
Ethics
Research
Conference
May
26,
2004,
.
45.
(http://scu.edu/ethics/publications/submitted/dillon/education_plato_republic.html)
195..,..,.118.
196401d402a.
192
193

44

1. (
)

, ,

197,
.
, , 198.
,20.
.

,
199,

. ,
,
,
200.

, ,

,
, .
,
201.
, .

792e.
377ab.
199.MarrouHenriIrenee,..,.126.
200790de.
201793e794a.
197
198

45

 ,
.

. ,
,

202.

, , .
:
, 203.
,
,
.
.,,
,,
,
.,

.
, , ,
,5...,
,
,204.

796c.
809c.
204 . , ,
,2000,.6066.
202
203

46

205.
,
.

,
206.

.
:
,
207. ,
,
, 208. ,



209.

2.

,
.
[
]812e.
206812d813a.
207..3839.
208,533bc.
209412a.
205

47

,,,,

,,.
,,
,
210.
,
,
.

,
.

.
.,
,
211.

.
,
212.
,
213.

813cd.
802ad.
212811c812a.,.MarrouHenriIrenee,..,.120,
..,.58.
213 817 b.

(19d).
210
211

48

3.

.
214.
,
215.
216.
,

,.,,
,
. , ,
,
()
,
.,

217.
.

, :

[ , ]
804d.
215806a.
216813b,814a.
217451d..JaegerWarner,..,.309.
214

49

 ,
, ,
218. , ,
219, 220 ,
221.

4. (
)

,

, .
, ,
: , ,
222.

:,
,
.,
.
. .

802d803a.
176e,215c.
220(215c)

.
221347cd.
222 . , .., . 56, 145a,
318de.
218
219

50


223.

.,..,.56.

223

51

1.

.,
.
,
.
, ,
,
,
,.

. 224
,
.
225. ,
,
.226
,
.
.
227 ,

406a.
.,..,.74.
22688c.
22760e.
224
225

52

 228.
,
.
,
.

2.

,
,
229.
,
, .
.

.
,.
, .

,
.

Arthur Darack230,

.
().

61a.
.,..,.75.
230.AndersonWarrenD.,..,.252253,.69.
228
229

53

 ,
.
,,
. ,
.

.
,
.
.
,
231,,,.
232, ,
,.
, , ,
233,
, 234.

.

3.

: .
, .

,56a.
, , .,
.,.,,(.189190).

233248d.
234248e.
231
232

54

 , ,

,235.
, 236,

. ,

, .
,,
.

. , .., . 7778. .
,..,1986,.5476.
23680ab.
235

55

1.
1.1.()

.
. ,
.
.
. ,
.
.

237.

. , ,
,
.
. ,

.
,
.

.238.

.,..,.5455.
616c617b.

237
238

56

239.
,,

. , ,
, ,
,
240.

.
,
.
,
, .
.
(,
) (
, ),
:241.

1.2. , (
)

.,..,.4344.
[]37b.
241.BowmanWayneD.,..,.25.
239
240

57

,
. :
,.

. ,
.
.

242,

,,.
,
, ,
. , ,
, ,
243.

,
.

..

,,,

, ,
, .
, ()
, 244,
Bowman.

187a188a.
187ab.
244.BowmanWayneD.,..,.24.
242
243

58

1.3.

, , ,
. , ,
245,,
, . ,

.
246.

.
,
,
.
,
,.

1.4.

, ,

,
247.
.

215bc.
.BowmanWayneD.,..,.23.
247 . , .., . 87. Jaeger (. Jaeger Warner, .., . 413, . 111)
,
400b.
245
246

59

 ,
248 249 250,
.

Anderson251,

.

.,

, .
,
,
,.
,
,.

. ,
,
.,,,
,
.,,

, ,

252. ,
, .
197d,200a.
424c.
250180d.
251 . Anderson Warren D., The Importance of Damonian Theory in Platos Thought,
TransactionsandProceedingsoftheAmericanPhilologicalAssociation,1955,.89.
252.AndersonWarrenD...,.95.
248
249

60

253,

254.

2.

,
,
,,
.
255.
,,,
.

256,
. , ,
, 257.
, 258 259
, 260,
,

.AndersonWarrenD...,..9697,99102.
.
255.,..,.102,209.
256
,,,
,.
257.,..,.138.
258531b.
259531b,794e.
260794e.
253
254

61

 261. ,
,
( ,
262)
(
263).

,,,
Anderson264,
265.,
Beardsley,
( )
266.

.,..,.6162.
[]187b.
263[
]187c.
264.AndersonWarrenD.,EthosandeducationinGreekmusic,Massachusetts1968,.104.
265673cd.
266eardsleyMonroeC.,..,.26.
261
262

62

1.

267. , ,

. , ,
268,

. , ,
,.

,
.
.

. ,
(
),
.
,

, .
.
.
.
.,..,.49.
..54.

267
268

63

 .

.,,
,
,
.
,

269. ,
,
270. ,
271.

.
,.

.

2.

,,
, 272. ,
, ,

JaegerWarner,..,.285.
.eardsleyMonroeC.,..,.4445.
271.BowmanWayneD.,..,.20.
272 . Neff Karl, ,
,1985,.53.
269
270

64


.
,
,
, ,
273. ,
,
,,apriori.

.

274, Bowman.
,275,
18.,.

276,
Neff. ,
,

277.

3.

.BowmanWayneD.,..,.22.
.BowmanWayneD.,..,.20.
275.NeffKarl,..,.53.2.
276.NeffKarl,..,,1985,.53.
277.BowmanWayneD.,..,.40.
273
274

65

,

, ,
:.

, )
.278,
.

; Kivy: ,
[...]
,
.
[...]4000
.. ,
.

.[...],
279.

.ReinachTheodore,..,.189237
WestM.L.,o..,.349435.
279KivyPeter,NewessaysonMusicalUnderstanding,Oxford2001,.92.
278

66

, ,
..,

Platonis Opera, Recognovit, breviqve adnotatione critica instrvxit

IoannesBurnet,tomvsIV&V,OxfordClassicalTexts

Plato in twelve volumes, Euthyphro, Apology, Crito, Phaedo,

Phaedrus,withanEnglishtranslation,HaroldNorthFowler,Harvard
UniversityPress,London,1987

, , ,
. , . ,
,1958

,,,.
,.,,1939

, , ,
,.,.,.,

, , , ,
. , . , . , . ,

, , , ,
.,.,

, , , ,
.,.,.,

, ( ),
,14,,1992

, , , , ..
,.,,1962

67

, , , ,
,.,

, , , .
,..&,,1994

, , , , .
,.,.,

,,,,.,.
,.,

, , , , . , .
,,1995

, , , ,
.,.,.,

, , . , .
,.,

Anderson Warren D., Ethos and education in Greek music, Harvard

UniversityPress,CambridgeMassachusetts,1968

AndersonWarrenD.,TheImportanceofDamonianTheoryinPlatos
Thought, Transactions and Proceedings of the American Philological
Association,1955

. . (.), , . ...
,,2002

, ,
, . ,
,1986

Barker Andrew, GreekMusicalWritings,VolumeI,TheMusicianand his

Art,CambridgeUniversityPress,1989
68

Beardsley Monroe C., ,

& , . ,
,1989

Bowman Wayne D., Philosophical Perspectives on Music, Oxford

UniversityPress,NewYork,1998

Csapo Eric, The Politics of the New Music, Murray Penelope,

Wilson Peter, Music and the Muses, Oxford University Press, 2004, .
207248

. ., ,
,1966,.107136

Dillon Ariel, Education in Platos republic, presented at the Santa Clara

University Student Ethics Research Conference May 26, 2004.
(http://scu.edu/ethics/publications/submitted/dillon/education_plato_r
epublic.html)

EliasJuliusA.,PlatosdefenceofPoetry,MacmillanPress,London,1984.

Jaeger Warner, , , .
,,1971

, , . , ,
2005

, ,
,,,20022003

Kivy Peter, New essays on Musical Understanding, Clarendon Press,

Oxford,2001

Lippman Edward A., Musical Thought in Ancient Greece, Columbia

UniversityPress,NewYork,1964

Marrou Henri Irenee,

,.,,1961

,
,.,,1999
69

Murray Penelope, Wilson Peter, Music and the Muses, Oxford

UniversityPress,2004

Neff Karl, ,
,..,,1985

, ,
,,2000

Reinach Theodore, ,
,,1999

, ,
. . (.), , . ...
,,2002,.937954

WestM.L.,,,
.,,1999

,

,,1821

70