Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Innovative Communication Audit - The Sojourn
Innovative Communication Audit - The Sojourn
The Sojourn
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Table of Contents
Executive Summary
Background 3
Purpose .. 3
Assumptions .. 4
Procedure and Participants 4
Methods ..... 5
Planning . 5
Results ... 5
Summary of Findings .... 6
Analysis of Responses .. 6
General Observations .. 13
Action Step Recommendations .. 15
Personal Reflections 17
Appendices
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Executive Summary
Background
The Sojourn is a student-run newspaper, specifically crafted for Indiana Wesleyan University
and the Marion community. A printed edition is released bi-weekly with online submissions
being uploaded to The Sojourns website frequently. Students write and take photographs for
many types of stories varying from campus news, Marion community news, sports,
A&E/features, and opinion pieces. The mission statement of The Sojourn is: "Providing
responsible, professional journalism to the students, faculty and staff of Indiana Wesleyan
University and its surrounding community in Marion, Indiana." This student-run newspaper is
one of the main sources for news on the Indiana Wesleyan campus.
Purpose
The main purpose of this study is to gather and analyze data based on various methods,
specifically focusing on how communication within the organization affects the organization as a
whole. This communication audit will focus on:
1. Finding and analyzing current communication strategies and operations within The
Sojourn
2. Identifying the effective communication processes within the organization
3. Identifying the ineffective communication processes within the organization
4. Offering recommended action steps and personal reflections that may improve
communication within the structure of the organization internally and externally
By developing the purpose of this study, it will allow The Sojourn to alter their communication
processes to assure a future of improved communication and overall organizational health.
Assumptions
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
The following are assumptions made in regards to The Sojourns internal communication:
1. The Sojourn has strongly implemented and highly practiced internal communication
channels.
2. There are communication barriers between different sections within the organization.
3. The organization operates with a hierarchical system.
4. Summer training is not effective for staff members.
Procedures and Participants
Throughout the semester, Innovative Communication used many procedures to gather the
required data. The participants varied throughout the collection of the data. We began by
observing the weekly meetings of The Sojourn. These observations were done for almost two
months. Next, we collected data using a survey. The Sojourn staff, and the lab and practicum
students, were the participants. The survey consisted of 56 questions, in which we received a
total of 14 responses. The third step that we took to gather our data was to conduct interviews.
For this section, a total of 6 interviews were conducted, lasting 30 to 45 minutes each. The
participants for this were the Co-Editors-in-Chief, Editors, a Staff Member, a Designer and the
Advertising Manager. Lastly, a focus group was used as the last step to gather data. This
consisted of nine questions and was directed to the Photographers and the Design Editor.
Method
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Multiple methods were used to examine The Sojourn for themes of effectiveness and areas for
improvement. Questions were prepared and observed through meeting observation notes,
surveys, interviews and focus groups, which can be found in the appendices.
Planning
Before beginning research, Innovative Communication received permission from The Sojourn to
begin the communication audit. A list of employees and lab and practicum students was
acquired for interview, survey and focus group purposes. Through a collaborative effort, those
conducting the audit created questions for surveys, interviews, and the focus group. Interviews
and focus groups were done in person, and the survey was distributed through e-mail. After the
results were analyzed from the interview, questions for the survey and focus groups were
formed. All results were analyzed looking for trends among responses given to the survey,
interviews, and the focus group.
Results
The 56-question survey generated 20 pages of data, and approximately 64 percent of The
Sojourns staff completed the survey. Seven interviews generated 30 pages of transcribed
information. The focus group generated two pages of transcribed information. With the results
from theses forms of data collection, Innovative Communication was able to detect certain
themes and actions within the organization. The information that was transcribed in the
interviews, focus group, and survey can be found in Appendices D, F, and G.
Summary of Findings
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
During our research, we found that members of The Sojourn desire better training and more
communication on expectations. The relational and internal communication channels are strong
within the organization. It is evident that after auditing The Sojourn, the staff members are
passionate and dedicated to their work. This allows for a pleasant work environment in which
students have the opportunity to grow and learn new skills. Innovative Communication was
pleasantly surprised with the internal communication existing within the organization and were
able recognize areas that could use improvement.
Analysis of Responses
Following is an analysis of the 12 interview questions asked by Innovative Communication to
members of The Sojourn. We conducted six interviews that included the Co-Editors-in-Chief,
Editors, Staff Writers, a Designer, and the Advertising Manager. Provided are corresponding
survey results. See the whole interview and complete survey results in the appendices.
1. How do you attribute to The Sojourns success?
Every person seems to feel they attribute to The Sojourns success in different ways. Some bring
good story ideas, some write or edit stories, and others provide photos to supplement the stories.
They all felt that they attributed by encouraging others through mentoring and helping others
find their potential.
64% of the survey participants agreed with the following statement: I am told how The
Sojourn is performing externally on a regular basis. 21% of the participants were
neutral and 7% disagreed.
43% of the survey participants agreed and 29% strongly agreed with the following
statement: I am told how The Sojourn is performing internally on a regular basis.
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
17% of the survey participants agreed and 21% strongly agreed with the following
statement: I pay attention during the budget meetings and give my input as much as
possible. 7% disagreed.
43% of the survey participants agreed and 21% strongly agreed with the following
statement: I feel motivated and self-disciplined to come to budget meetings with story
ideas. 21% said they were neutral and 14% said they disagreed.
64% of the survey participants agreed with the following statement: I am told how The
Sojourn is performing externally on a regular basis. 21% were neutral and 7%
disagreed.
43% of the survey participants agreed and 29% strongly agreed with the following
statement: I am told how The Sojourn is performing internally on a regular basis.
57% of the survey participants agreed with the following statement: I know what The
Sojourns mission statement and objectives are. 21% disagreed, 14% strongly agreed,
and 7% were neutral.
43% of the survey participants were neutral with the following statement: The words on
the wall of The Sojourn room have meaning to me. 36% agreed, 14% strongly agreed,
and 7% strongly disagreed.
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
43% of the survey participants were neutral and 43% agreed with the following
statement: The staff communicates efficiently outside of the budget meetings. 7%
strongly agreed and 7% disagreed.
57% of the survey participants disagree with the following statement: There are
barriers between me and the editors/co-editors-in-chief that prevent me from effectively
communicating with them. 21% of survey participants strongly disagree and 21% were
neutral.
64% of the survey participants strongly agreed and 29% agreed with the following
statement: The Co-Editors/Editors politely ask me to do things. 7% was neutral.
64% of the survey participants strongly agreed and 36% agreed with the following
statement: The Co-Editors/Editors are available for me to discuss my concerns or
suggestions.
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
50% of the survey participants agreed with the following statement: I am kept well
informed about changes that the others in the organization have made. 21% were
neutral, 21% disagreed, and 7% strongly agreed.
64% of the survey participants were neutral about the following statement: I have
regular meetings with my boss to discuss how I can improve and develop. 36%
disagreed, 14% agreed and 7% strongly agreed.
21% of the survey participants strongly agreed and 64% agree with the following
statement: The staff communicates efficiently at the budget meetings. 14% of the
participants were neutral.
7% of the survey participants strongly agreed and 43% agreed with the following
statement: The staff communicates efficiently outside of the budget meetings.. 43% of
the participants were neutral and 7% disagreed.
7. Who dont you communicate often enough with that would be beneficial?
The communication throughout the staff of The Sojourn seems to be beneficial to everyone and
members only communicate with those that are needed. While looking at the network analysis
Innovative Communication realized that staff members and practicum students all talk with a
wide range of people. The Photographers wished that they could talk with the Staff Writers more
often and visa verse. Also, those editing wished they could talk with those publishing more often.
21% of the survey participants strongly disagreed and 57% disagreed with the following
statement: There are barriers between me and the Editors/Co-Editors-in-Chief that
prevent me from effectively communicating with them. 21% of the participants were
neutral.
8. Please tell me about the meeting environment.
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Many participants described the meeting environment in a positive manner; fun, entertaining,
organized and productive. In regards to the production meetings, the participants described them
as cramped, long, and unproductive. A few of the participants stated it is because of the time they
have to produce the paper, 4:30 pm - 11:30 pm, which causes them to be more relaxed.
36% of the survey participants agreed and 7% strongly agreed with the following
statement: The layout of the room allows for open communication among staff
members. 21% of the participants were neutral, 29% disagreed, and 7% strongly
disagreed.
36% of the survey participants agreed and 7% strongly agreed with the following
statement: The layout of the room helps me pay attention during budget meetings. 21%
of the participants were neutral, 29% disagreed, and 7% strongly disagreed.
21% of the survey participants agreed and 43% were neutral with the following
statement: I prefer when the lights are off during the budget meeting because the
natural light makes us more productive. 21% of the participants disagreed, and 14%
strongly disagreed.
64% of the survey participants strongly agreed and 36% agreed with the following
statement: The Co-Editors/Editors are available for me to discuss my concerns or
suggestions.
29% of the survey participants strongly agree and 57% agree with the following
statement: Others listen to the story ideas I propose. 14% of the participants were
neutral.
36% of the survey participants strongly agree and 57% agree with the following
statement: I intently listen to the story ideas of my coworkers. 7% of the participants
were neutral.
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
50% of the survey participants strongly agree and 50% agree with the following
statement: I intently listen to the story ideas of those in authority at The Sojourn.
71% of the survey participants strongly agree and 21% agree with the following
statement: I feel comfortable asking my boss questions about the tasks I am assigned.
7% of the participants were neutral.
7% of the survey participants strongly agree and 14% agree with the following
statement: I have regular meetings with my boss to discuss how I can improve and
develop. 43% of the participants were neutral and 36% disagreed.
43% of survey participants agree and 43% strongly agree with the following statement:
I enjoy my job at the Sojourn. 14% of participants were neutral.
86% of the survey participants strongly agreed with the following statement: I believe
Adam Wren provides us with insightful information. 14% agree.
79% of survey participants strongly agreed and 21% agree with the following statement:
Having Adam Wren at the budget meetings is beneficial to The Sojourn.
86% of survey participants strongly agreed and 7% agreed with the following statement:
Having Adam Wren at the budget meetings is comfortable. Another 7% disagree.
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
12. If you were the editor here, what would you do differently?
Participants mentioned the need for stricter deadlines for stories. This way the production night
would not have to be so lengthy. It would also take away some of the pressure from the Editors.
43% of the survey participants agree with the following statement: There are strict
deadlines that we are able to follow or achieve. 29% of the participants were neutral
and 29% disagreed.
14% of the survey participants strongly agree and 57% agree with the following
statement: I always achieve my deadlines. 29% were neutral.
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
General Observations
1. Strong Communication Channels
Throughout the process of gathering data, Innovative Communication realized that The
Sojourns internal communication channels are successful. The members all agreed through
interviews, the survey, and the focus group that Google Drive was a great tool for the
organization. They also mentioned that the Facebook group is great for reminders, and texting is
successful when one-on-one communication is needed. Co-Editors-in-Chief are fast in
responding to texts, and members appreciate it. Innovative Communication would not suggest
changing any of these channels.
2. Professionalism
The Sojourn reaches its goal of presenting itself professionally to the community. They
do so by keeping an effective and up to date online presence. The editing process contributes to
the professional touch of the stories. During the interviews conducted, many expressed that an
organizational goal was to look like a professional newspaper. We believe that the Co-Editors-inChief communicate this well to the Writers and other staff members.
Their professionalism conveys a non-verbal message to those inside the organization as
well as those in the community who read the newspaper. The members in The Sojourn feel as if
they are held to a higher standard because of the level of sophistication that is expected of them.
Those in the community respect The Sojourn because of its presence. Academic advisors such as
Dr. King and Professor Wren improve the quality of story ideas and print/online presence with
their expertise and by providing feedback.
3. Training
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
One key theme throughout the process of the communication audit was the lack of
effective training for staff and practicum members in The Sojourn. In the written responses of the
survey as well as the interviews, Innovative Communication was notified that only the Staff
Writers receive training, and it only happens in the summer. Those who join later are not trained
properly. The designers had to learn the process on their own, and the second semester
Photographers were expected to know how to take photos for news-writing.
In one of the interviews, the interviewee stated that a key goal of the organization was to
train and mentor their members. This seems to be something that Editors desire, but not
something they hold of high importance. This miscommunication between members causes a
lack of expectation. Long-term, this will have a negative effect on the organization because the
untrained members must spend more time revising their work. This prevents the organization
from progressing forward.
Lab and practicum students especially need training and should be communicated to
more often because they could be the future of The Sojourn. These students may seek permanent
involvement with the organization if they have a positive experience and are well trained.
Unfortunately, they are unintentionally disregarded. The Editors expressed that they want to
mentor those who are inexperienced, but there is no program in place.
4. Internal Communication
Overall, The Sojourn staff communicates effectively within the organization. There are
two groups that should be interacting more: those editing should communicate with those
publishing and the Staff Writers should communicate with the Photographers. The students who
write and edit their stories often times miscommunicate with the Editors who publish the final
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
story. The communication could be more effective if done differently. Also, the Photographers
are not in communication with anyone other than the Design Editor. In the interviews, the Staff
Writers expressed that they would like Photographers to take certain pictures for their stories.
These two groups should have open communication with each other to increase effective work
flow.
Sojourn create a substantial training session at the beginning of the semester. We also
recommend that they implement a training session in the beginning of the spring semester if
there are new members. The sessions should break off for specific sections. The Editors should
create an instructional manual that includes rules of APA writing, and rules specific to The
Sojourn. The manual should include specific information for each position as well as tips and
various guidelines. They could also include how-tos and dos and don'ts of news-writing
and uploading stories and photos. These manuals should be handed out to every staff and nonstaff member of The Sojourn so that everyone is following the same rules.
The lab and practicum students should receive a special, more in-depth packet on how to
correctly write a news story. It would be beneficial to include a couple good examples. The
Editors should pay special attention to the lab and practicum students. We suggest that this be
done by implementing a mentorship program. There could be one meeting at the beginning of
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
each semester in which the lab and practicum students meet the Editors and Staff Writers. During
this meeting, mentors and mentees could be assigned.
2.
To improve communication between those editing and those publishing, the Co-Editors-
in-Chief should set a standard that every time someone changes a document, they let the other
one know right way. Innovative Communication recommends they do this through a text
message, since that is the fastest form of communication and seems to work well for the staff
members. A Facebook message or email would work as well. By doing this, there will be no
miscommunication on when the story is ready to be published.
To improve communication between the Photographers and the Staff Writers, we
recommend that every Staff Writer has every Photographers phone number. We also
recommend that they are Facebook friends and they have each others emails. The Staff Writers,
or Editors, should communicate with the Photographers before they write the story, telling them
what they would like the photos to capture. If the Staff Writer or Editor, whoever is writing the
story, does not contact the Photographer, it will be the Photographers job to then contact the
writer.
3.
is the implementation of substantial and more precise deadlines. If this were implemented, the
writers would feel a greater sense of urgency to get interviews, write their stories, and edit
them. Another benefit to this would be that the staff would develop a more self-disciplined
approach. It would also cause the Editors to respond with edits faster. Innovative
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Communication would recommend that they implement this new strategy at the beginning of the
each semester, that way this expectation is clearly communicated to members.
Personal Reflections
After analyzing the data obtained throughout the process, Innovative Communication has a few
recommendations that may not assist in communication, but will help the organization overall.
1. Explain the Term Budget Meeting
Many expressed within the survey and interviews that the term budget meeting is
confusing. They recommended that it be changed to pitch meeting or staff meeting.
However, there is significant meaning behind the word budget, so we do not recommend that
The Sojourn change the title. They should simply explain to the members what it means. By
doing this, the members will appreciate it more.
2. Update Facebook Page
While analyzing The Sojourns external communication channels, Innovative
Communicaion realized that the information on the Facebook page is outdated. The staff member
names need to be changed to the current students in these roles. Also, there is a mission
statement on the page. None of interviewees knew the mission statement of The Sojourn. We
recommend that the Co-Editors-in-Chief emphasize the mission statement to the members as
well as to the community. This may require that they create an internal mission statement that is
separate from the external mission statement.
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Appendix A
Organizational Chart
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Appendix B
Network Analysis
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Appendix C
Interview Template
Name:
What is your position with the Sojourn?
How do you attribute to the Sojourns success?
What are your organizations goals?
How are objectives determined?
How are employees trained on objectives?
In general, do you have the supplies you need to finish your work?
How do you approach it with your editors?
How are problems prevented through the Sojourn?
How do you receive information from your managers?
Is it affective?
Timely?
Do you have all the information you need?
How would you say to improve receiving that information?
How are you notified of articles that need to be written?
Are meeting times productive?
Please tell me about the meeting environment.
Is there availability to talk?
Are you presented with an itinerary prior to the meeting time?
How is conflict among the staff handled?
How do the managers handle conflict among staff?
Whos involved in reviewing the organizations performance?
Whos involved in improvement efforts?
How are employees made aware of improvement efforts and successes?
Whats the hardest thing about your job?
What are some things youd like to change about your job?
What resource would help you be more effective?
What should your editor know that he or she currently doesnt know?
If you were the editor-in-chief here, what would you do differently?
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Appendix D
Interview Transcripts
Co-Editor-in-Chief of The Sojourn
How do you attribute to the Sojourns success?
As editor in chief I help assign stories to people and edit for print, lot of
organizational work, on production nights basically put together the entire paper
Overlook a lot them
Every production day I contact the printer
What are your organizations goals?
Ummm
Our goals are to become
One is to get out the news on campus
Inform news on campus
Timely and professional; manner
Key goal is also to train our staff to help them become better writers
To prepare them for the processional world
How are objectives determined? Are employees informed about these objectives?
We do stress a lot about getting info out quickly, telling news as it is
Hard questions in interviews
Discuss all the time
We have not done too much of actually done
Also doing this for them to become better (stress helping them improve)
Not same mediocre work
What is your mission statement?
Hmmm.
The Sojourn does not really have an official mission statement
Do have something on the wall in the sojourn room
Lists
God First (sojourn is a ministry)
Objective they do have
Personal mission
The Sojourn is a reflection of Christ in many ways
Because He spoke the truth and pointed out the flaws of society and
culture
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Interview with Co-Editor-in-Chief of The Sojourn
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Then text
Do not use the calendar
Is it effective?
The methods are, a weakness would be (on his part, lazy at times) very
invested in The Sojourn over-all
Write will text, ready for edits, they have to remind him
Texting can be effective, have to be actually responding and acting
Reminders!
Could be better if used more frequently
Timely?
Phone calls and person are most timely
Guaranteed they get message
Dont assume people are free for a phone call
Do you generally receive all the information you need?
I think so
Are meeting times productive?
Yes, for the most part
Sometimes we talk about stories
Stories come from complaints about school, money
i.e. shower doors vs. curtains
Complaining where money is going
Tangents
In general people stay on task
Talking on the side?
A look makes them stop
Is time outside of the meetings productive?
Most experienced person on staff
Quite prepared, know what to expect
Less experience, different response
What way would you like to receive information?
Other people on staff
Sometimes I get info from co-editor (stipend) about another staff writer
ADVISORS, involved if needed
DEPARTMENT, they should defend
Top of student organization, year-round, expected more
Section Editors are equal (based on production, salary)
Staff Writers. Photographers
Staff Writers and Photographers
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Interview with an Editor at The Sojourn
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Training?
Two days before official move in, come Thursday, Friday and Saturday get
trained
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
We hope that some of the events that we cover that someone will read it and be a
good witness opportunity in a way or be inspired
How do you receive information from your editors?
Jared and Navar?
Dont have production night, every other night, editors meeting instead
Texting the biggest way-goes really well
2 is really nice, group message
Two people to be able to get a response from
Is it effective?
Yes, I think so
I really dont know what else you could do with that to make it better
Good idea to give cell phone numbers
Editing stories: google docs
i.e. Navar called on phone, going through story typing and
talking
Edit at exact some time without being together
New technology trends and want to use it to make communication
as best as it can be
Do you generally receive all the information you need?
Yes, I think so.
There have been a couple times confused
Why wasnt I told before?
Can be out of the loop, not a full time staff
Can be tough to relay information to each other
Are meeting times productive?
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Dr. King and Adam are there bug questions ask them there
Not too organized, does not need to be
Update, first year it is like we go to weeks without everyone meeting
If we have an problems how to work through and adjust that issue
Productions night
Pretty relaxed
More done quicker if faculty advisors were there
Need to be there?
Own newspaper without them there dont try to take control of it, do what
they want
In the office, eat food, edit the stories, put everything together
The end is stressful because they have to make sure it is good to go
Have to have it done that night for the lady who prints it our form
electronic form
Is there availability to talk openly and present ideas?
Yeah, for sure
I think feel comfortable, close
Issue, comfortable sharing it
Story ideas?
Sometimes I get a little nervous, do not like rejection
For the most part I do, worst part is that no one will pick it up
No one is mean or anything or talks down?
Nervous, dont know what thinking
Whats the hardest thing about your job?
To post stories as quickly as possible
Pretty busy
Just going to bed, oh wait, can you edit this story?
News section is biggest one, a lot of stories to edit
The thing, on own, there are times nothing to do then a lot to do
Making sure the stories are posted as quickly as possible and having the time to
do it
What are some things youd like to change about your position?
I dont really know
Cant really think of anything
Challenging, part of the job
What resource would help you be more effective?
Ummm, well, one thing would make my job easier
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
We post stories through WordPress (Facebook and twitter), only editors have
access to it
Sectional editors-post
Writers job to post the story they post it without permission.
Would be easier, a risk to take?
Make sure have pictures, sometimes try to get photos could be easier
Everyone had own WordPress account to post stories
What should your editors know that he or she currently doesnt know?
I think that meetings more productive and WordPress
Communication-not always aware
Always make sure everyone knows what is going on
Knows it is difficult
If you were the editor here, what would you do differently?
I think some of the ideas, would implement
I think I would
Be more pressing on people to get their stories done
Not on top
Not mean?
Its my newspaper, so
Not mean strict. Detail and deadline oriented
I have not been able to talk to people making up excuses?
Think if they came in knowing when they had to have it done by?
There are reasons why it doesnt work
People get a story dont know what happened with it.
News editor, communicate with them more. How is this
story coming along?
Not pushy, make sure doing it
Need to work on it
Scared they think she is being mean
Stories could be doing, they are lost, pick up another
story forget about them? Lost
Last year, timid as a writer What was happening? needed that push, would not want
to disappoint them. Accountability
Sophomore
Convergent Journalism
Either convergent or media com (broadcast)
Journalism print (all of it +writing)
Most go into writing
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Interview with an Editor of The Sojourn
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Please tell me about the meeting environment.
Budget
All get together, everyone, Co-Editors ask to pitch stories, Editors should
put for sure things on the doc
Good environment
Nice relaxed environment where I feel comfortable saying what I need to
say
Good way to make everyone feel comfortable
Some story ideas are going to be stupid story ideasit happens
Good risk-taking environment
Made it a safe place to pitch whatever may be a good story idea without
thinking it will be dumb
Production nights
Weird
All enclosed in the tiny closet room
Did not use to be that way, before room was changed in big computer
room
All at tables
At the beginning the year with them
Stay out when everyone else is in there
Close communication, close together makes communication better
Harder because need to edit
Needs open area not to be super cramped
Very fun atmosphere, joke around and stuff
Whats the hardest thing about your job?
Balance
Push the online first initiative
The Sojourn is still trying to figure out how to focus on it
Two years ago it was still the weekly prints
Story on Monday, done by Friday for publication to be published on Wednesday
Print to online
Just get it done as soon as you can
News is now bambambam
You can get your news right away
The Sojourn is working to be a part of the digital age
As soon as it happens
All writers and editors struggle with, not enough time, we are full time students
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Hard to be like I need to get this article done but have homework and stuff to
do
A part of organizations (extracurriculars) outside of sojourn
Figuring out that balance while still tiny to achieve what The Sojourn is wanting
to achieve
What are some things youd like to change about your job?
I started as a journalism major
Couple classes that they have to take
News editor sophomore year
Youngest News Editor they had had at The Sojourn- hard stories
Do not want someone that young to be the News Editor
Kind of found out why that wasI was good at my job, but it broke me a little bit
Would have changed to a writing major anyways
I was pushed to change my major
Controversial stories, could not mentally handle those more classes
media and ethics
Can be changed
Possible requirement for News Editor position: to take a media and ethics class
Went through a lot of moral issues in head, I would have been able to
handle a lot of those a lot better [with that class]
Did a good job, but it was hard
What resource would help you be more effective?
Ummm, I mean. So many things that could not a journalism major. Obviously
taking more journalism major classes as a source
A source, more individual mentor
It would be nice to have a personal mentor Adam [Wren] critiques as a whole
One-on-one mentor this is something you could work on
What the editors do for the practicum students, dont have them for selves
But there is so much improvement to do
Covered everything? Anything to add?
Navar was talking about have open office hours where people could come in
randomly and know he is there
For improvement and to talk it out
Good for The Sojourn: I dont know how practicum students take stories
I dont know how much they know or dont know
Nice to find some sort of way they could establish more of the mentorship
On google docs
Trying to do with practicum stories: highlight, comment
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Interview with Advertising Manager of The Sojourn
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
no idea
What are the Core Values of The Sojourn?
To communicate well
AE-entertainment too
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
professional business cards cant complain about- tough times and budget cuts
All issues
Dont have those up to date or current
Not avenues to make those
Done by designer (Garret Johnson)
Dont know who the head of The Sojourn is tough with the
budget
Talked about it with Brenda-helped with business cards, made some
Not professional grade not worth it to buy 300 for one semester
Same about advertising
What should your editor know that he or she currently doesnt know?
Hard because only here a semester
Almost feel bad asking for a lot of stuff
Hypothetically, here another year, for more graphical info to give out to possible
clients and professional business card to help sell ads
Would help in professionalism
If you were the manager here, what would you do differently?
My area is so limited
The Sojourn is about the articles, Im just doing the ads
Ad department- more professional things to go out on sales calls with
Set marketing strategy
Taught self all this
Have a standard protocol on how to do it
Kind of creating
List of prior buyers
Brenda has helped with everything
Build the system: trying to
Interview with Design Editor of The Sojourn
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
I think so
They always respond very quickly
Do you generally receive all the information you need?
In general or the editors?
General-yes, I would say sometimes I have to look up if we are covering
an event what time it is or where it is
Able to look up
Part of her job anyways? To provide that info for other
people
Editors
I do, but it is not timely
Information part,
IE infographic- find out production night what the
infographic needs to contain
A lot of times last minute
Depending on the type of information
Are meeting times productive?
Budget meetings are fairly productive
We do not get off topic too much
Production nights- a lot less productive
Have to do with the fact because we know they have so much time
4:30-11:30
No one feels the rush to be productive at the beginning
Shorter time? More beneficial, but the only thing is that worries me
is because people wait until production night to finish story
If they continue their same habits we would not get the paper
done
People would need to change their habits to make the paper happen
Editors meetings always productive
Adam Wren and King are always productive
Is time outside of the meetings productive?
yeah
How is communication outside of meeting times?
Umm, people usually respond very quickly
Text the editors- they all respond fast
E-mail the staff writers, usually very timely
Facebook message the photographers- group message
The least effective [it is] more effective to meet with them all
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Meeting time?
[We] dont, all so busy, all on Tuesday after budget meeting, cant
all have a time together in Tuesday (implement next year?)
Different channel per need
What way would you like to receive information?
Well, one thing I have asked the editors so many times to share google docs
(where the stories are)
I would have more information
Ask all the time to share me with the google docs, that is just not
something that comes to mind
Co-Editors-in-Chief, Tim shares regularly (sports editor), Navar
sometimes
Ask every meeting time (mainly need Lauren too)
Who do you communication with? Who dont you communicate with often enough that
would be beneficial?
Lauren (google docs)
Probably the photographers
Not talked to face to face, cannot come to budget meetings
Facebook, not hold them to responsibility of what they need
Staff Writers
Okay there, e-mail
Pretty good with Hannah
Please tell me about the meeting environment.
Its fun
They are very fun people
Want to make the meetings exciting and entertaining
But being an achievement, efficient person it is hard to have fun in an
environment to get things done
i.e. YouTube videos
Comes with Journalism mind frame people versus PR mind frame people
Is there availability to talk openly and present ideas?
Yeah
Jared and Navar are very good at inviting people to say what theyd like to say
Jared specifically is a very easy person to talk to
Will confront conflicts, do it very tactfully and respectfully
Are you presented with an itinerary prior to the meeting time? If so, is it effective?
I am presented with one
The budget (shared with everyone) before the meeting, the day or night before
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
I personally do not look at it, which I should ( I never have story ideas)
Jared also tells us the night before to come with one story or one phot that we
thought was very good
Chooses someone to pay attention and read the Sojourn
Whats the hardest thing about your job?
Yeah see below question
Thats not even in my job description barely
It is hard for me because the rest of my job is not as oriented around people, that
is very people focused
That part of the job is focused on whether or not people keep their end of the deal
Designer before struggles with the same thing
What are some things youd like to change about your job?
Ummm, mentioned before
Having somehow more authority over the photographers
Dont know if that is just me or cant meet one on one that is one thing I wish my
job
That is one thing I dislike about my job the most
What resource would help you be more effective?
(thought) no, not that I can think of
What should your Editor know that he or she currently doesnt know?
I dont think so
I pretty much tell them everything
If you were the editor here, what would you do differently?
If co-editor?
(thought)
I would set deadlines for stories and I would make everybody be done
editing completely before production night
Anything else?
Covered a good deal
Not her job: One thing I see
Lab and practicum students do not have training
Pretty much just thrown into newswriting
Hard to learn with no experience (could be improved)
Not enough training
Body as a whole is cared for, as individually not well-equipped
*The designers were not trained when coming into the job Jamie Burkholder to
teach the basics wish that were different for sure.
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
If I am leaving... when their new designer comes in next year, want to create a
new list of guidelines and train in design and export things like that. The staff
writers had training but we didnt
Interview with Staff Writer of The Sojourn
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Appendix E
Focus Group Template
1. Explain your participation at budget meetings. How involved are you, and how involved
do you feel you should be as a photographer?
2. Do you feel valued as a photographer working for the Sojourn? Explain why or why not.
3. Do you feel supported in the work you do? Explain why or why not.
4. Does Kelly make you feel included in the Sojourn as a whole? Explain why or why not.
5. How effective was your training process?
6. What can help you receive the proper training?
1. In your specific job area?
2. As an employee of the overall organization?
7. As a photographer, how often do you talk to the writers and editors? Why?
8. Have you witnessed moments when the staff has not worked well together? Explain.
9. Explain your communication channels within The Sojourn. Include what works well,
issues, and possible improvements.
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Appendix F
Focus Group Transcript
Explain your participation at budget meetings. How involved are you, and how
involved do you feel you should be as a photographer?
o We dont really do much, our job is to take pictures, we are not as creative to come up
with storieswe just sit there
o I dont write at all. I just take pictures. I like to hear what stories are being offered to
know what kind of pictures to take
o For me its important to be there just so I can tell the photographers what kind of
pictures to take, but I never come up with stories.
o I do feel valued, they didnt specifically name me but they mentioned they liked my
pictures. I do want direct recognition but my name is on the newspaper.
o I only get recognition if they bring up anything about the design layout. Adam will
give me direct recognition.
Explain your communication channels within The Sojourn. Include what works well,
issues, and possible improvements.
o I have never talked to a writer. (She just began this semester) My supervisor is
usually the one to communicate things to me. The writer tells my supervisor and then
she tells me. I should have more communication with the writes. My supervisor is
actually the one who informed me about the pictures for the kids. I was not allowed to
take a picture of their faces, and I wouldnt have known that unless she told me.
o Well that is part of my job I am getting paid for it.
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Have you witnessed moments when the staff has not worked well together? Explain.
o Last night we had an issue.
o One of The Sojourn members worked really hard to get us passes for Fusion and they
had gathered the writers. One of the photographers had talked previously about taking
pictures, I was not aware and neither were the other Editors-in-Chief of The Sojourn,
and so we gave it to Amanda because she has been taking great pictures and initiative.
I hadnt heard anything about the one photographer and so when I announced it to the
photographers she got really upset.
o We spoke about this before Christmas break and so I had just forgotten.
o I texted a Co-Editor-in-Chief and this went on for two hours. We ended up telling her
that if at any moment one of the editors agreed to give her the spot then it was hers,
but she declined.
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Appendix G
Survey Question and Responses
Demographic
1. What year are you in college (by year, not credit hour)?
Freshmen
Sophomore
Junior
Senior
Super Senior
29% (4)
29% (4)
14% (2)
29% (4)
0.0% (0)
2. How many semesters have you been involved with The Sojourn?
1
36% (5)
21% (3)
29% (4)
0.0% (0)
0.0% (0)
0.0% (0)
14%
(2)
0.0%(
0)
3. I am a...
Design/
Photographer
Editor
Staff Writer
Lab/Practicum
21% (3)
29% (4)
29% (4)
21% (3)
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
14% (2)
57% (8)
7% (1)
21% (3)
0.0% (0)
3.64
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
0.0% (0)
64% (9)
21% (3)
14% (2)
0.0% (0)
3.5
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
29% (4)
43% (6)
14% (2)
14% (2)
0.0% (0)
3.86
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
36% (5)
64% (9)
0.0% (0)
0.0% (0)
0.0% (0)
4.36
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
36% (5)
50% (7)
0.0% (0)
14% (2)
0.0% (0)
4.07
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
7. I think that The Sojourn should be more open to ideas and input from the student
body.
(i.e. story ideas, photographers, marketing, etc.)
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
0.0% (0)
29% (4)
64% (9)
14% (2)
0.0% (0)
3.21
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
7% (1)
64% (9)
14% (2)
14% (2)
0.0% (0)
2.8
9. In what ways could The Sojourn market itself better to Indiana Wesleyan University?
Refer to question 8.
Advertise positions in places like the Daily Developments or divisional emails. For example,
Brenda could send out an email drafted by an editor inviting anyone who is interested to our
first meeting.
Boost posts on FB
Get more involved with the people on campus
More publicity on the days the paper comes out
Perhaps posters around campus? Eye catching front pages.
We're doing everything we can--we've really gotten ourselves into the digital age of online
marketing with Facebook and Twitter and things.
Better social media interaction.
Make the paper edition of it more accessible
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
43% (6)
43% (6)
14% (2)
0.0% (0)
0.0% (0)
4.29
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
64% (9)
36% (5)
0.0% (0)
0.0% (0)
0.0% (0)
4.64
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
86% (12)
14% (2)
0.0% (0)
0.0% (0)
0.0% (0)
4.86
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
4. Have you witnessed moments when the staff hasnt worked well together? Explain.
Refer to question 3.
The only moments I have witnessed the staff not working well together is at production night.
Sometimes people leave the room and we do not know why they left or where they went. Other
than that, I have not seen conflict between staff members.
Just miscommunications, nothing with personality issues
Production nights do not use the staffers' time well, because many are ill-prepared, so those
that are prepared end up sitting around just doing homework.
No I have not.
no.
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
43% (6)
50% (7)
7% (1)
0.0% (0)
0.0% (0)
4.36
6. The Sojourn is easily accessible to people interested in joining The Sojourn from the
student body.
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
21% (3)
43% (6)
29% (4)
7% (1)
0.0% (0)
3.79
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
7. In what ways is The Sojourn not easily accessible to potential new staff?
Refer to question 6.
I feel like only communication majors attempt to be new staff members because they are the
only ones who are notified of the possibility. I think that holding a meeting at the beginning of
the semester welcoming anyone on campus interested would be a good idea (through daily
developments or divisional meetings) -- they could come to the meeting to be informed about
being a staff writer, photographer, or designer. All positions matter.
Some people didn't even know we had a school newspaper, so how would they know that there
is job openings?
I'm not sure if people know how to be a part of it
I think The Sojourn is very accessible to new staff. We're always wanting more staff members
and we're very good about nurturing those that come in very blind to how newspaper writing
works into well-written journalists.
I think a lot of people don't realize that anyone can potentially write for the Sojourn. I only
know this because I'm a journalism major.
N/A
I never knew how to get in contact with the sojourn before I took this class.
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
7% (1)
36% (5)
29% (4)
21% (3)
7% (1)
3.14
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
10. The words on the wall of The Sojourn room have meaning to me.
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
14% (2)
36% (5)
43% (6)
0.0% (0)
7% (1)
3.5
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Budget Meetings
1. I enjoy going to the budget meetings.
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
14% (2)
71% (10)
0.0% (0)
14% (2)
0.0% (0)
3.86
2. I pay attention during the budget meetings and give my input as much as possible.
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
21% (3)
71% (10)
0.0% (0)
7% (1)
0.0% (0)
4.07
3. I feel motivated and self-disciplined to come to budget meetings with story ideas.
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
21% (3)
43% (6)
21% (3)
14% (2)
0.0% (0)
3.71
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
36% (5)
57% (8)
7% (1)
0.0% (0)
0.0% (0)
4.29
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
29% (4)
57% (8)
14% (2)
0.0% (0)
0.0% (0)
4.14
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
36% (5)
57% (8)
7% (1)
0.0% (0)
0.0% (0)
4.29
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
50% (7)
50% (7)
0.0% (0)
0.0% (0)
0.0% (0)
4.5
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
79% (11)
21% (3)
0.0% (0)
0.0% (0)
0.0% (0)
4.79
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
86% (12)
14% (2)
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
0.0% (0)
0.0% (0)
0.0% (0)
4.86
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
86% (12)
7% (1)
0.0% (0)
7% (1)
0.0% (0)
4.71
12. The layout of the room allows for open communication among staff members.
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
7% (1)
36% (5)
21% (3)
29% (4)
7% (1)
3.07
13. The layout of the room helps me pay attention during budget meetings.
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
7% (1)
36% (5)
21% (3)
29% (4)
7% (1)
3.07
14. I prefer when the lights are off during the budget meetings because the natural light
makes us more productive.
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
0.0% (0)
21% (3)
43% (6)
21% (3)
14% (2)
2.71
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
15. The term budget meeting confused me when I joined The Sojourn.
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
36% (5)
36% (5)
21% (3)
7% (1)
0.0% (0)
4.0
16. If this concept of a budget meeting is confusing to you, what could make it more
clear?
Refer to question 15.
Staff Meeting
Planning meeting
Maybe story pitching but I think budget is fine
I do not think the name needs to be changed. It is confusing for a very short period of time and
then makes great sense. This question seems biased and is worded in a way that assumes
everyone being surveyed wants it changed, when that is not, in fact, true.
Just sojourn meeting would be acceptable.
It would be more clear if it were called a pitch meeting, but every newspaper in the world calls
meetings like these budget meetings. So I think they should just be thoroughly explained from
the beginning.
I just wasn't used to it being a budget meeting.
I was thinking finances when I first heard it.
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Communication
1. The staff communicates efficiently at the budget meetings.
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
21% (3)
64% (9)
14% (2)
0.0% (0)
0.0% (0)
4.07
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
7% (1)
43% (6)
43% (6)
7% (1)
0.0% (0)
3.5
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
0.0% (0)
0.0% (0)
21% (3)
57% (8)
21% (3)
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Sometimes the editors don't all communicate so I will get conflicting information.
5. Explain the channels most commonly used between staff members and how effective
you believe they are. Would you recommend something different?
(i.e. texting, emailing, Facebook messaging, etc.)
I most commonly text Jared and Navar. I most commonly Facebook message the photography
staff in a group message. I most commonly email staff writers with questions regarding their
stories-- I think they are effective
Usually texting and facebook
I think texting is very effective
Email and GoogleDocs
Facebook and texting seems to work fairly well. Depending on the person email isn't very
effective.
We communicate almost entirely by text messages and sometimes on Facebook. In reference
to editing stories, however, we use Google Docs and that is a very good channel for
communicating among the staff and the writers about the stories and the edits needing to be
made.
Texting is the most common, but everyone is usually pretty good about communicating that
way
Email works really well. I like it because if there are a lot of pointers given, I don't have to try
to remember everything. I simply refer to the e-mail.
Texting usually works
Email or Google Docs. No I would keep it the same.
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
6. What is the best thing The Sojourn does in regard to communication among staff?
The Facebook page is nice because it is once place where everyone will see the updates. I think
that could be used more to our advantage. I also think the fact that the staff uses Google Drive
is BRILLIANT and makes the "machine" work well.
We have a group on fb to keep information flowing
Shares all the phone numbers
Meets regularly in-person
Weekly meetings force people to actually get together and talk. I don't know how much people
would communicate otherwise.
We just love each other and give each other grace. I wish the editors-in-chief were harder on
the editors when they weren't doing their job, because sometimes they aren't aware of their
exact responsibilities and so I wish they were harder on the editors sometimes, but I think as a
staff we're very good to each other and very encouraging and inclusive.
They are good about updating the Facebook page and giving out good reminders throughout
the week
I like the use of Google documents that makes comments and other communication forms
available.
Telling us how we can better our writing.
7. I am kept well informed about changes that the others in the organization have made.
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
7% (1)
50% (7)
21% (3)
21% (3)
0.0% (0)
3.43
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
64% (9)
29% (4)
7% (1)
0.0% (0)
0.0% (0)
4.57
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
64% (9)
36% (5)
0.0% (0)
0.0% (0)
0.0% (0)
4.64
10. I feel comfortable asking my boss questions about the tasks I am assigned.
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
71% (10)
21% (3)
7% (1)
0.0% (0)
0.0% (0)
4.64
11. I have regular meetings with my boss to discuss how I can improve and develop
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
7% (1)
14% (2)
43% (6)
36% (5)
0.0% (0)
2.93
12. There are strict deadlines that we are able to follow or achieve.
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
0.0% (0)
43% (6)
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
29% (4)
29% (4)
0.0% (0)
3.14
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
14% (2)
57% (8)
29% (4)
0.0% (0)
0.0% (0)
3.86
14. What helps you meet your deadlines? What hinders you from meeting your
deadlines?
Refer to question 13.
As a designer, my deadline is the print edition. I always have this done in time. I have no other
deadlines, but I think maybe I should provide my photographers with deadlines because
sometimes they wait to put pictures up and then the pictures cannot be used.
Hinders: time between games and downloading photos
I like that the deadlines are more flexible because it lowers stress levels; however, I don't know
if it improves the overall quality of the paper.
Schoolwork hinders. Free time and discipline helps.
With this new online-first initiative, where we are really trying to get every story done as fast
as possible to put online instead of waiting for the print version, you no longer have a hard
deadline anymore, it's just "as soon as you can get it done" which is subjective. It's really just a
new mindset that people need to get into and while that's hard, it's achievable. I think the next
generation that grows up in the news industry will have any easier time with it, where as the
current staff was on when we were only worrying about the print issue and had hard deadlines,
so switching to the online-first mindset is more difficult for them, so we're trying to make sure
we instill the online-first mindset into the younger writers of The Sojourn.
It helps me to actually have a deadline or a time frame they would like the story done. Usually
what hinders me from my deadlines is trying to get interviews with my sources
I feel motivated to meet my deadlines because we work together as a team, and I don't want to
let my team down. Sometimes I can't meet deadlines because I have so many interviews to
conduct, but my editors are very understanding in this situation.
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
If I miss a deadline it is because I am on somebody else's time frame for a quote, interview, or
information. I usually inform the editor.
I didn't know we really had exact deadlines but getting in contact with sources sometimes
hinders that.
15. I am given credit and praise when I do good work or put in extra effort.
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
64% (9)
14% (2)
0.0% (0)
0.0% (0)
4.07
Strongly
Agree
21% (3)
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Rating
Average
7% (1)
50% (7)
36% (5)
7% (1)
0.0% (0)
3.57
17. What concerns or suggestions do you have about The Sojourn that you would like us
to bring up to the Co-Editors/Editors?
None
I wish the editors were told more clearly how to handle the practicum students. I think every
editor should make a packet for their writers about how to write for The Sojourn, because they
come in so blind and I think there's a really awesome opportunity for a great learning, mentormentee kind of relationship that isn't being fully taken advantage of. I personally love teaching
others. I like giving comments and feedback and helping others grow, and I don't always know
how the students are coming into The Sojourn as and what their background is, so I don't
always know the best way to help them. I had a great mentor as a freshman, his name was
Steven Porter, and he was very clear and hard on me, and I learned a lot, but I also had to selfteach a lot. I learned nothing from Dr. Huckins, The Sojourn advisor at the time. I created my
own Word document filled with all everything Steven told me. I took The Sojourn very
seriously. I looked up things in the AP Style handbook. I would like to be what Steven was to
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
18. Any final questions, comments, or issues would you like us to cover?
Nope!
Have a happy day! Love you!:)
Nope, I think the Sojourn editors are doing an excellent job.
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Appendix H
Meeting/Observation Notes
Budget Meeting 02/03/14
Environment
Lights off: creates a tired/ disinterested environment for all staff and lab/practicum
Seating: people who were in the center area were the only ones talking.
Others were paying attention, however they were also distracted by technology
(cell phones, laptops, computer desktops)
Solution (try to look for other meeting location or try to form a better seating
arrangement in the room)
Informal environment.
Coeditors
They too seemed tired and disinterested- this may also rub off on the staff
They were just reading off the to do list...try to create more dialogue among the staff
Many side conversations...they did not seem to notice this happening. This can distract
others who are trying to pay attention.
They should also meet with the new staff members to inform them of all the rules and
passes they get as a worker.
Adam
does his presence affect the flow of conversation among the staff and coeditors?
should he be right at the center next to the coeditors?
Possible suggestion: have him be there, but in a more secluded area...this will give the
coeditors a stronger sense of leadership.
Observations
"Budget Meeting"
-Not really discussing budget, rather debriefing, announcements, and story pitching
Should they change that?
The seating arrangements: Center area, seems to be only people talking. Others around
the room are not really talking.
Co-editors: disinterested and tired.. Are they just reading off list?
Chang seatinggood or bad idea
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Change location.a more discussion friendly location (look for other possible
meeting areas)
Side conversations
ComputersDo they distract or provide benefits
Informal environmenttowards the beginning of the meeting.
Many disengaged
Adam: disengageddoes his presence effect the flow of communication? Should be he
in the center of the room (next to editors)
Meeting with the new Staff writers.. just so they know about passes and other matters.
o
Production Night 02/04/15
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Budget Meeting 02/10/15
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Observations
Dr. King was present helpful? Just because of the event some of the students went to
Only one who spoke up on the outer perimeter often was Julie and shes quite bold at
speaking up
Editors-in-Chief spoke with Wren and King more than other writers good or bad thing?
Bounced ideas off of each other, everyone else just sat there. I mean, we all know how
much Dr. King likes to hear himself talk BUT
Brooke, who won the journalist of the week award took initiative to find a story
Got off subject once!
Wren and King talked to each other quite a bit
How many of these staffers are journalism or com majors?
Do these staffers know each other very well? Or, do they only see each other at budget
meetings?
Environment
Room half lit
Towards the end as they choose stories, everyone begins to get off topic
Journalism Conference
Share about the conference they went to
Navar went to some design sessions, wants to talk to Kelly and
Editing meeting- try to get in person every once in a while
Schedule time to be on Google Docs together (Mia and I both noticed)
Social Meeting Session- Series of tweets (1 out of 3) can be taken out of context
Different (New for the Meeting)
Everyone will have one thing from past 7 days of the Sojourn, (print or online) that they
liked
Random 5 at the beginning of the meeting
Navar and Jared will decide one person from the staff who will receive a prize that has
done something admirable for the Sojourn
Story Ideas
Staff/Faculty Email problems
Ice on sidewalks
Features of each dorm Done, will go up soon
World Changers Pt. 3 Political affiliations
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Downtown House Heard from housing but not much from there
Scripture supporting Gurgen World Vision Child
Bowman Time Capsule 5 alumni from 11 years ago, time capsule in the ceiling
South Pacific Thursday, Faculty Preview
Sit-com Preview After Spring Break
Who is Jessica Small?
Everyone thought it would be a fun story
New Mens Soccer Coach
Freshmen Curfew Long process to get it changed, decision maybe end of semester
Dr. King suggested Ideas on:
University Budget
Enrollment
Religion Freedom Bill
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Editorial Staff Meeting 02/11/15
Adam
Facetime, Skype, then phone call (not time efficient)
Dr. King
Talks a lot
Talks about editors needing to give deadlines for not just paper, but also digital.
Which we are and will cover in our Audit Survey
Towards the end Dr. King realized we were present; while the staff already
knew.
Goal: story a day vs. clumps (they get lost)
Lots of joking around
Talked about design
Think about design/photo from the very beginning
Lots of talking at once
Talked about Storify
Tweeting
Jared asked for feedback on his new idea
Budget Meeting 02/17/15
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Environment
Lights on where everyone was sitting
On topic for the most part, few people typing here and there while people are talking
about story ideas
Many people were involved with talking, although Navar and Jared did most of it and got
conversation going
As they went through the meeting, after all the story ideas, they continued to divide up
stories
Adam offers suggestions about Online Components, because its not been used
Last 8 minutes, everyone started to talk over everyone.
Announcements
Organizational Communication Survey
Heather, emergency surgery
Prayer for her as a whole
5 people to share:
Brooke E
Tim
Sarah
Mallory
Julie
5 people came prepared to share.
2 people of 2 have shared about the same person, so only three individual peoples pieces
Editors Award:
Becka Roth
Pictures about South Pacific, everyone loved
Stories:
Letter to the Editor about Presidential Running
Internet Outage and Learning Studio
SGA Debate
New LDR Class
Modernization of the Library
Love Rev Crema
Ted Talk & Tea
M. Anderson
A. Campbell
K. Hernandez
D. Radford
K. Reed
C. Weerheim
Other Ideas:
Fusion (Lecrae)
JK Comedy Show
Original Design
Observations:
Environment is better.
More communication among the team: sharing stories.
More encouragement to each other! Makes the environment much more pleasant.
More input during budget meetingsmore constructive conversations.
Couple of people still on Facebook and other pages and phones.
Dr. King was therepresents confusion as to who is in charge (Adam vs. King)