Horm fh in en hin ce a ctr Bupa
Pepys yt a since mo of pinged mah
(Cc anaven dn erlang esac oe
‘Salty Ths ns try ive mega ram et
‘ emenec ened, aie Sea wit coy
Phy Th se wl enrages wats at su ne yf are
fer the nt cemuy, hah op fis he hse eth ey
Fn en inline Cad, ni Rr bla tho Sa
‘eye Tipe anb Rry) ht egnge with iy hese stn es
(peal he ing tangs sy nests wd eax es
int insecmeccon i nd ieee cer Sines fon mci
hs A ey tft sees wae bingo Eg em ferent
‘ls woh oie of he Engh peating wel we abo kona
‘cancers ey omen ies Sis mee
Seen 10 and bes, so eto ap vil ty ket cope)
Phil loess tioning wang pape
“logue tg heerlen Cones o Hemeetis Ses
ln gtr i doe elf cmap seal ements |
‘Sits vhmes tw ge aniseed far ohememcs rine whe
‘Sotcing te atta oo ay nena pect hemes nay.
“her wl eng we ha accepts a
ihc ong meno emer cng oie ead
‘ius henment) ano eres dale ns aus an dis All
ected marr wi ely pcre bal sconce
Merinfrmaton hot hse at haps nero 335
Scott Davidson * Mare-Antoine Vallée
Editors
Hermeneutics and
Phenomenology in Paul
Ricoeur
Between Text and Phenomenon
® SpringerDeguenent of Pgh (ibige Cant
ltteer Urey wal GE Cama
Contents
1 From Exists nd Phenomenon to Hermenetie
sr ny Apc th Onna Quon
Distancia and Epoch The Ieee of ser
‘on Riera Hermon.
ae Maco
‘Thinking the Fed with Pat Rice
Peet L_ Hermeneitc Phenomenlog fhe Sa
entity an Sethod: Pal Riceur's Conbaton
‘dt Contlovatioas
ora Genealogy of Selo: String from Poul Rice.
‘The Word of th Tet an he Work of Lies
Part IT Hermenatc Phenorensogy Trad,
Memory and History
Inventary Memory and Apprenticeship to Truth
Jeane Mate GagneSoc hin a mo st ine
‘eon vd on sy, Poy od Pernt Ranh TA).
Vi en 250 ing fn tin mrs
‘So ir Ae So ery ene.
wk Se ort Peep na
eta ee 1 Te ool gg dina ana Rc
‘inn Cn rere mn Pe St
ie te a2 Ne
‘Thinking the Flesh with Paul Ricoeur
Keyword Pal ico Phenomena + Hemme Bay «lsh
ul Rieu doled phenomenology shine y Ras nh 1950,
But whe sary psnamensopy war deslping soa in te dein of
Singtel igen anes Wh Met Poty—eace Ree
tok th p-aledagt on in be edepsted n tsomnl he
tmenclogy ner concen ar enchsely on samen of eet
[re re nowave oe cing rectns a Racor hil wags wih
‘mp eninatea ae wen inal permenant
‘Rrfemenac language loka testy wn of pesing ne
icons fra cra ermenain~detos which ight ing pt th
‘chins psy of embodiment (develope wits Hamer and Mares
ot) aa piso a retin (eng fo Hea nd Ge)
Risto ly “ign ily exenom Ae Tae wen on ie
‘wre il coe my eas eta Ww summary ats
Diagnostics ofthe Body
co’ min onion here comes in he am fre ipa ett of
Nem won pbnomenlog,Fedom and lane The oat andthe
Islip a 1980, 5 Ys ale The Phoneme of Pereton.
‘Tesectans i ueton se ell "Matton andthe Caer Tun
diy Spas an Life Scan Growth Geni Bh
Rltar tli hs wrk erp oa he “nara ogo” ding
on he phenomenon fhe come propre emacs He!
Sophy a, ee WE ia MA. 8A
Beitr re ay Hemsedal “Mera Poy) Gli Maton of neato, nd Maines Bis acl
ts of he oid spin (a fash, ert ab esse) re he ce
iter ropes on cnt he ay eles per een he Yl
1 al nny cen ann Sag wh
ern anger a opment of ety ta relic of exes
(Gc 190 80, Cat aes Os ena eight bewees
(test aatn exten sd (3) hing” oof imation, co
‘Eman vers Basson” the it actor of exsenislso
Atetenpaon beryl forthe afte by leds at elute oy
Ing coum,
ices pte challenging wis nes somthing tbe p=
omen sxpernced et sat eat rm bat, Bt ed
pers rom wit este. at Ric pcs agnosis
‘Te apn rl wih csi se nnn th Ca’ een
Baa docs Cyt sn gr canon apn a
SENG Aime nay want epee a
Seer ele ie SN
‘Atv and oat we thas comet fam he ott by 2 de of mu
inherent ference os sr and ue ae no prt eles
‘ett mays of ling” me een (sma) italy
‘ewan
mer hn on sto er ean of
nose by coeieess eon Bt dy operate ob ot bse
‘etne tenes Nerina! oe luce staan ese
ton wasting wae dels erm «tr echo. ete
Son bala pean “aba owas icon 198091. Otic
Pot ond even hain a-epons sie ie
Dopettn ete aber (ner 980-9) Tove feds de etme eg
‘lacmined by th, ne are conn dscrang betwen vets sl pe
‘tectoly exeiing nie etn elie espn "isa the i
(rot colin on emer tn ht can come move which nies
rth copeing en tthe en wh prefer df hnge ha ey
Tv ed our 190 9), As Cans tuners eerie of
nes hero and xin ate “nan capa of seg betwee sng
‘someting ee" (Roe 1950-93)
Nos thas vealed a rior spontaneity fh dy whe wl mics
viata nk olor” hve bteogendrel tu which lize
Feng Tein oy Tig sth igi source al bemene
Isis whn mks cursor smear ot i
CSET SIRNA hey eens tse
in sat eye wk ray whoa de has
see te ai ae ten
isa isc point at Riser ones he lel imagine
‘decreas aed anf wily. He eaplaes bow we magia ing =O
Gringch we cdo dati) a masters ating Ba he p>
‘limapnton' tt abot rejecting poses rom with 8 eg
Ios of edng thas ugh ofl sen quis oo tre
‘Trt Tecra inagintice ese idles an dei ley
‘upsice wich rina aden eoone ut aflesine and ete
Trap tie went shen raster ong asin. ald. “We mst
fot oe gt ofthe sense uy spate” sts Ren, ely
Iycr mining ar Sess ad sing btwn ge sd a
Wigs fveing mt" if ane ented soe 190-9 Vibes
Treating ssh oe mes ce Kt are at ies ees he
‘teton of sh Rlter sod Ws eaig ofthe by asi ell of
‘alton wh hs aon
“tals tal ava anog hrs eae wy tin et
Rabaeraream tft neste meson aye
steeds met mare mice me Fe
Sonam. ts tothe i Theta
cine emi Oe
itor spend tet hi pssmemloglal ans expr hs lame
forte sembly "oof rao. ute for nw tot tat
Istskchersepel gnc frst weigher eects
ie to
‘The Fextual Turn
Insp ot his promising ety igre of te body, hore Rios ws som
[ound tis ajtoy, Arde tex nt 1960s, we witness ar-
Pring Ibe petb) i seas hemenets x on od,
Tha plenomeolgy of afetv,cm he sher He nw aks bck on he wks
aphison sense caprec ar cep thee of “mtn, ie
ternal onasing thi wi here ate median of
une” ener 98 3, And eee commends eater Meson Ponty at
Sit homage or ving Hevoné il phwoensogy of incaanon”
towed psopy cf anguae a pled mem tance” a“efeston (Rise 199
roy epi whist
This eon betwee esha ets nee mo evident a ne 1964
soya Erinn, Eagan Here ase sks of sexi ey
‘Stanage sly opens wate cl) mec” of "ah
{hacen snd) he modasos of anunge mn imeprcation. Sin
ut "Seay e-metacins angge serosa po” er 1994.14
rn ou Concer care, cer eh le olen ec in
sed nytnopy sf ssumed te Soom of tse ee” 1 becomes
‘Slovan hat fsa bh laps of sdetandigd lopafnstunen
‘arent. “To ep of sexta” be cams" wt rma ieee
teeetog sch cmps haan xienc angst ite cee
1994 4 Ani es ats al, ian npr Soper nguisic
‘reson Ho nis langue” ais Rest. bt ot nf 5
‘Ermediined in tha mame st cn fe reabcbed er h™ Ce
tags) or "ectnig (ke perma) on oly “abo ep
“Kno mean of wht my eles emi” (Roar 1994 140) Let
teal ste oath to Sah” romp deer te oer of Tp
ay. when wo kelgs embrace they on how wt hy ae ing. hey
ov knw ty wath dot Know wha ey ring thy Sant
{Swat hy re ig Wha meaning Fs ee wih es the
towne cach far” (Rar 1934161) Sera ese dost a et
‘Sin kn meaning bet gies he impression haps in steko
war wesc conectons ae ago Butt aly ade, ras
‘Sows wth he moro if as "ou i sug, nes ee
thing nero, sc elo exw prt ns sty at an
‘ero ttm pron be lngs aus nth iver of Life—aehs
the tah of seme” (Rr TBE 1) Ba hs Rie FL ha lc
ies become ced cago yh at Aut snk thin
Tone soit se esi at Roba” pave Hence he erga of
The esning of hssuhmerl deed nee ao lags aces ww
{ers of mnt petipan tony ido oe eared ese Of
‘Sein mtn Tae i eat rte cos aly heres Stas
‘Sorc conclu ta th est mea ore eg feat
s rmeneults of ac ens which oad aod pena he rgoten word oF
oun sc The postin betron Aad et old not emo exp
‘SO Spe te on of men ht hr
3-16) A cretion wih me secs
ae entra tata tomes ita ao st
SSrSemhcatc nila teres se some apesenet oa
(he on nd, ean rating on he er orgni fting.To fon of
oan li ent & dao ogos an.
is was ot toe Rea’ ast ord the mater runt ees
te pene of renee of sh oats ast ar wk, Oneself
anne (1990) Inaseoton of al chapter eed “Ov ovn ody rte
a Rioer stim oho" eo Dtwee be sl awe wh
{ake scoot ow epee fae” iste 190: 319
‘Ach eas corned psy” whore hein pest
S'Saan nears ores How toa” enon nina nd
Tis ttarnss toto emer of Hees Leb ands eascnfece of
"Ts dacs of payers sas te xg en's owe
puitingtenoncolpil a bw cas we aly expec than bay ft
‘Bhatt mc "aby an tr Kirper anny ova (Li? Weve ah,
‘eget Rote Pa we tod exper of owe ined eto proves
wiv scise fur nol engin. Tis wt ges a eopre eoneicy
ad ncoring tse Pls lace whee we extn he wr a al
‘rng nd vling sho an peice and eer. Coin the >
‘Singlet of Mie de Bena with ie plonamenlge fhe op np in
sur ond Mice Hy, Rca shows ban steph acne "wre which
‘reflec, esr gs tet th exsence mh a
Shes theca some ha pes the res crayon’ ove exe
ieee cern of era exten (Roc 1990: 529) nth pos
‘pay and po -on' cw ye eed tobe ie mein ewe
‘helmumacy of th oan be nerf the mak” Risser 19032,
re Rout aes oe nsreng pst th Is i, 8 We MB EEE a
elcgger ato cts erste he pommel sect =
‘ete eel ot ecu hoe eas see
iene hrs nee
yc tye ope, et asone the rete only ofthe hI ster Hse wholes hee
Promising seco eB lost mak te ntpon feet
Aomenoog na ogy sf eames” (Rico 199092), Rieu fete
ei eta Hse fn flows. In th Caen Medion
TO yeas ater as Ire or of pence ha ged at ner
nue a "aig sajeiy. one ma fom fees of "owrac
‘mes, shin lence wis respect oh extra ody tos se by
ine oct mewenty olen) Reshepce ups reine abhop ancoans ater
‘el vers) calaing al obj pope It he pe of rrece o
odes bln tea asta of mes Abit isby ping os fo
ith ace tht we detest fa serge Bat he eee
Seep prot sha pti ferns Fs what oe ie
tnd mat ter, Closest ome sa are om me theca ine Things
otter eed mot srry, oe na eh A ef tn,
‘ou e's“ fo fing i reveled mot teal nthe ete of
{uct cowar190 20) I pseder sl ponds bth th a od to
ra Ind teen pees the very dincon Baten te wlnay a th
Snot" a his man” exlins Recreate
led with espe lint” (oer 180: 29) Ortop In are ch
cal page
Sorts erpeot ann orm toes B60 ans
‘Rss Sec et so ming fh ae pec
eee ea ae ea
‘ptonasnrmentt etn bg aa ee
Sire hehe mins weet dntt
hoy rnp pt oer eh cal "ate Reser uly Wy
“iene py taps eae ee oh
prea eran a!
‘Sein pet eee
Soret etc oepttannay ecm
Siu Rav ett mn pan eet
‘CS ae fonts nc os
sca corn aaa
toy it hits on a he car pee
Riser cons asuagy that Ash is he spe for sans on
oper tse Far evn theres the sang olde a Sn
iy en of owes Hse Saget the where fhe est wll
Freel Roar 990324) Tas pad oe at wanes ier che
“rat ropetons ns rua pnage fen Hash Meta here
Tecmo a bea pmo spt of imei) pr algo he
ct a el yen ya oni
‘yt recta npn he ON ie mwa a
‘ernest a on lle ou ea
Senger Seen ena pena ae
uso othe bio i rio sil tity manent sha
"pe igunis” wel of ean we ale nconst apes emacs
{tnd meas acon Bets ete th vane ets ia
"ioe dears fom Has In soci ode th eect wel rm the
“non-bjsvag pnerexpeens” of et Har wen fa ign
ttt fesh sot js nine at gal aly monger Doe La ak
[orper atone node ae sh pa oh ers moon oe ned >
enor soni bt ne ahora swith ers, And thea ak
Teharess othr a Trin retest ony ot tes of ay ee a
am) ata esi poor ay rede tosmenFrthe fehl aeat
Inthe wrk as atdy seg beso the dere at am yal sheath
mong aera el-vitanaer “i he appcenssn of 2 smn Me,
Wore oat fhe stor of neji tul unig sla i ho
Wey Rene 18025.
So Riu cos hs Nhl locate amy by obsering that wie
‘Huse engi primal of wv sh and he cet er
subjective lngape ecole ene twists Hae thot
he te han nw aterm, and ner oft aa ate a
‘ov anver te prox seed wp inte qoson: bow toad hat
shila)" Rie 1990-32 nab, Hane rad ala
‘osu forth be hs intimacy ol in be tlt of ne
om) an is epening ats the med hgh att fe) He i a
‘ama henomcotgy Bt ack cael hence Ony he rod
‘eau oot of esti lint btween es a wel
SDE See ecto meter ngaIn costing Hos impart Moree slo gt exer eee. And
‘isin acing Riese whore Levi sein nveing Bos oo ily
temas cttyng thecal as tho lyon mane
{psn eet he ile sel ne Grecton a nes of vere tance
‘cen which Fae tage Pah In cota oth Her a Line
‘night sy (oh Rusa gw thf Bosh nes ch te ost om
{agmcnlon and ovr colipe he Or sce eh 1 save Kon Pn
‘naam and pura And ee we ei, ly te reo hat We
‘rot combie sensi (lt) alana (ein an eral een
(Ee Te shin qt sd howto make ove of ene By aking Desh
inte wel,
Cetus Ir fo my Hes engage upon an nsbjve wr with
srs ed eae ith ht have Both nite ly me (La)
Sn phy ural ody smang terol (Kp). Tiss a complex
eigen) wey etn me wae
Feaycasts“Tosny tht my ee thy hi py Et toppers
{eit way oye er? Only Bah Frm) ato ore)
‘hn ploy tle fee aalogon i halal wane fer Desh Bs”
(cr 190 38). An thecal re tenons ht oe aimed
Nhe ru ange a fog 0 meg Reon he pare om one
‘amen whch icy rola ge. The tle veal 9 es
rnb! ny eos wlation dhoagh et an ays ey a
‘Seen Oop tinsel om. th te at ce to
immed evens ofthe ah ot minty present, bt nin
sprain Tho gc thar oer edged Bemce the eson a |
‘Speen and te spprecion of you expen” (eur 1980: 33) An
incr evened at a pista of ear Bay ove here fle ih ny
dy hres tie scr tice The alone psp hoe
‘ro eede anette ciple abet Tl scminibe ngos
We Never wl pang lw us ters he arr ha eats appesenation
om non (aod prsenaton Tho nates a ppreentatn, ee,
‘bins sir ad dyn I's e anne” Rise 130330
‘ts dal ty of es bshecar and tr tape in Rone ee
toe formal, tol a ner” And pest became fhe ee
(Ssonce of sey the wry bet four Bsh th mene mean
ttsay operate Psi whe pense acho ital cl fr mre
‘Whos leap ast sh fh teagh sn iment fas,
“oto Rexor il ele ett ha eps ho ti br a
‘oun ang ons pp ee Les peste
tac etree sores egy tee
‘tigen lyn ums hes ete
‘toa etn amen rr ra
sangre he program of psnomenalony in nerening te experince of
crosown a” Rice 190-35),
‘So nt drs lth en fr ths meni tosis twee self and
sai ey fine sehr wha eager nao my emblem
‘et why can sy“ The ane of ones ow" a
Snir" ayn har ian a he ee ine veh ners
‘eve fe thas a ts Ina va ht ea erik or et Rea
{990-35 Lam ald ye tor wh cones one aay ha Tox asi
1s to my inmarence Tc oly end by “ening” tir sexe i
‘maemo dance an dire Rite etal spent of sbarmene
{ie merpreing of he By by te aly ch peels the wok fines
‘hough oman sgn Horees tot apa! ation of udeaton
‘ich he meron a ety. meh a the reigns
[Ani be “Opie of sontimaton to fiche nading of iden los
innives, pr Resa "nese priori inom no Serve irene
{cea 198038) ens pc gana of canal herent ws
‘dsc, apo ince Cal mene dara ements”
"With il ion, lc eves sone his est ale aight
lowndingnontis of fatty Hectarts snl wy betwen Hasse’ ps
‘rg ofcana irmanese ns Levi’ of al anscondence, Whe
‘tere ised th monet sens ome othe tar ough mle),
fr ping, ppeseion the later esol th nave! of he eet
"emai Lv we he cher ger to frin ating aptre
span tha ot Oberon oral etry the exc of
{median "The Ofer abe ul em lon he same oven y
‘ih tenn aes fe oy Taliy” (Roce 1980: 66 Soi Masset
Bonenenclgy vn otis toma an case ofan epic fhe
‘ovhing an ritued by Dori in onlin Levins a oma
‘i ppt seme ote. Te in "vnig fhe einasn e,
‘Rosse prt "be so san eeh hese eng
‘sive Rou 380 37, Toe eso at sal emi, ee ee of
‘he Man of ice who ates but dent eh. Fo Use he m0
ty lation twee he re ffs ad ce. Nocoancin of
‘monn posh, No eta "No mile grand no wer, mere sen
‘heuer diye between the Same her” (ee 19089, Pain
Inte em he vnan ier prt mons bss ens,
‘ott hw And Kis aunt hs parxp se seuraon at
‘cmc at ema oct Ene A Ted
‘Sete me atest Ra
ip te Onan fend er eer Peary
‘Soho nd ed tu 0 “Daa Memento Here
ete ldo Wes Oa aeScr hermensti of ioe opens tt. "To mde pg othe
Same eno he Oe an the nema fhe ao he or ne Se
‘sated yt exchange of pro pronen yb sb)? ne
{Sot 39). And mus aot bse lsc aon cl nan re
‘ac cota vere Inston sms Ries“ itt ery a
* dlgse septs a eaion one suppose dsc etme te
‘prt Tan ching Ober” (Riser 190-99) And nt pos he
‘nt fel homens find he ja alin betwee te maven ne
toward oe andthe twas tance wich ow nly Wg te
ade ttweee Haw Levinas, ot an, by etsy, tn Met
Poyreerbl choir and Dod’ ese free?
“ase, sb yer a ans oping interopaons oe
akin ngage seeing aon? One nt ony of wes a Wg et
Spears et atten oe Ad whan of sees and esi st ie
‘re? One no sly of sta "udertndng” Bt ne pen
‘ion Thos dos te snp pheromone of tac et th et Some of
‘Bbspies Hecate simple ihe ot complex sith st hy
"Bue In poring such ust, Rc opee 8 oe whee pene ed
Demenets may crs inthe wing orf he leah He mas ow Deng
‘Baltes! we eis oe Sone
‘Bibliography
eine, Mri 4, ig Tat be a do
Part I
Hermeneutic Phenomenology of the Self