Walker
For Medicine and Society: Approaches to Moral Reflection
Aristotle: 384-322 BCE
A student of Plato for 20 years in the Academy and teacher of Alexander the Great,
Aristotle was a key founding figure of Westen philosophy with influences on modern
logic, science, theology and ethics,
Known especially for his logical system (Aristotelian logic), his works related to
biological and physical science (and causation), his metaphysical works, and his ethical
system in the Nicomachean Ethies* and other works. Aristotle also wrote extensively on
many other subjects including politics, art, and psychology (or the ‘sou!’).
Aristotle's ethical system is a prime example of virtue ethics, but another important type
of virtue ethics is stoicism, Stoicism and Aristotelian virtue ethics differ primarily in so
far as stoics did not see any necessary connection between achieving virtue and human
happiness. While Aristotle agrees that one needs a bit of luck to attain human happiness,
he also sees this as, in one sense, the goal of virtue.
Immanuel Kant: 1724-1804
Kant was a highly influential German philosopher whose work is critical to areas of
modern philosophy such as metaphysics, epistemology, ethics, and aesthetics.
Kant is particularly well known for his three critiques: Critique of Pure Reason, Critique
cof Practical Reason, and Critique of Judgment. In the first critique he deals with the
structure of reason and what we can know. In the second critique, he lays out his more
complete view of ethics (for which the Groundwork of the Metaphysic of Morals* lays
the foundation). The third critique deals with the foundations of aesthetics.
Itis common to think of Kant’s ethics as the prime example of deontological (or duty-
based) cthies, however, other systems of moral thought such as Divine Command Theory
(and related particular systems of rules such as the Ten Commandments) are also
deontological.
John Stuart Mil
1806-1873
Mill was a British philosopher influenced early on by the works of Jeremy Bentham, &
key carly figure in utilitarianism, Mill was also influenced in his more mature
philosophical views by Harriet Taylor as seen in particular on his work on the
‘Subjugation of Women. While his two best known philosophical works are On Liberty,
which deals with social and political philosophy, and Uiilitarianism* he also wrote on
economics, and religionFrom the outset utilitarianism has been a reform oriented moral philosophy. It provides
not simply a theoretical view of morality, but a foundation for social and political change
in favor of conditions that improve human welfare. Utilitarianism is commonly appealed
to as the prime example of a consequentialist moral theory, however other conseqentialist
moral theories inelude perfectionism according to which the goal of morality is to strive
to attain human perfection of character in a well-lived life. Aspects of virtue ethies are
perfectionist as is Nietzsche’ s moral philosophy.