Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Transcript of Responses at The Makati Business Club Forum
Transcript of Responses at The Makati Business Club Forum
Sen. Noynoy Aquino: Well sir I think you will agree with me that the » Tindahan Ni Noynoy
Undecided? tradition for the past congresses has been that the dominant party becomes
» Join A Group
the party to which the President belongs to. If I’m elected president, we
Let us help you decide already have our Liberal Party, we have our allies in other aggregations and
party-list groups but more importantly, the vast majority will always want to
» Yellow Army Badge
be siding with the administration, whoever it is, so cooperation with
congress doesn’t seem to be a problem at this point in time as we foresee.
Stay Connected
Question: South Africa, after apartheid, formed a Truth Commission. De
Klerk, Mandela, wound up winning the Nobel Prize. In South Korea, a similar Leave your email to receive our
search for the truth landed … in jail. Given the sustained unpopularity and Newsletters, get notified about site
perceived excesses of the present leadership, will there be priority given by developments, and keep up to date
your administration if you win, to ferret out truths about the GMA years? You on the latest news about Noynoy,
talk about Garcillano, you talk about Pidal, Peter Wallace and his Wallace the elections, and the issues that
11, ZTE and the like of transactions. What is your administration going to do face the nation.
in this regard?
Email Address:
Sen. Noynoy Aquino: The job of the Chief Executive is to enforce all of the
laws; recovery of ill-gotten wealth, if it exists, is not a proscribed activity,
meaning there are no time limits to it but it has to be a priority. I’ve already
made a public statement that I want closure on all of these issues if elected
president. That means that one of the four platforms, the top four in the
agenda is judicial reform. There has to be certainty of conviction and
punishment if you do commit crimes in this country.
A sad fact is that all of the cases that are filed by the prosecutors, only about
18% wind up as convictions. As you know our system says that a
prosecutor, before he introduces a case, should be convinced about the
validity of the case, the preponderance of evidence at present. But after
having undergone that process, it only results in 18% and those are official
statistics. 33% are dismissed; we lose all of these cases. Therefore,
adherence to the rule of law seems to be honored more in the breach. Now
so, in direct answer to your question, there have never been answers to all
of the issues that you have mentioned, be it Hello Garci, be it ZTE. For
instance in ZTE, there was a board meeting by the NEDA, there were
clear-cut instructions on sovereign guarantees on a BOT basis. This was
reversed. Those were orders of the head of NEDA and also who happens
concurrently to be the head of republic. Who can supersede the orders of
the president of this republic? That has to be settled. What are the
loopholes that were exploited so that the NBN-ZTE deal almost became the
nightmare? But fortunately the people rose up to oppose.
Again, let me reiterate, it will be one of the priorities that will happen within
the first 6 months; I guess within the first month we will already be tackling
all of these issues under the Department of Justice and to ferret out and
move the investigation, and if so warranted, to file the necessary charges.
Question: Will you or will you not form a Truth Commission?
Sen. Noynoy Aquino: In the Truth Commission, was something I’ve always
been studying ever since I became a congressman the first time in 1998. I
thought that the model and the idea of closure for a lot of things. One
question that I wasn’t able to answer then was, as you know, in South
Africa, a necessary component of availing of the privileges was to reveal
everything you knew about crimes that you had committed during the
apartheid regime, by both sides, which included very vivid descriptions of
various tortures employed. I was asking myself, in the Philippine context, if a
father were to revisit a crime committed to a child, who was tortured by
government forces in the martial law years, will that not in turn, foster a new
cycle of violence? I’ve never really been able to answer that question. But in
terms of reviewing this past decade and the lost opportunities in what are
the systemic loopholes that were exploited that got us to this point, yes, but
in terms of filing charges against those who are guilty of committing crimes
that I think should be left to the Department of Justice, in the very capable
hands of a very active and proactive Secretary of Justice, who I will not
name at this point in time lest he be persecuted for that.
Question: Over the last decade or so the Philippine economy has not done
well in manufacturing, it has not come out competitive in the world, and
agriculture has not developed as you mentioned the way it should, and the
country has moved more and more toward being a service industry, very
successfully in some cases, call centers, BPO, tourism beginning to pick up,
this is an area which I think there is a great potential for the Philippines. But
it requires one thing that the two other sectors don’t require, education. And
the educational system in the Philippines has deteriorated dramatically and
alarmingly. We only have a ten-year primary/secondary school system
where everywhere else in the world has 12. as you mentioned only 14%
graduate from college level. We don’t have enough classrooms, books full or
errors, all the things you know. What specific things will you do to correct
the situation? And where and how will you get the funds?
Sen. Noynoy Aquino: There are various solutions to the problem, and first
of all let me agree with you Mr. Juarez with all the things you’ve said
previously. What are solutions? How much will it cost to...there is an
estimated twenty to forty thousand classroom need in this country. If our
main focus will be to pump prime the economy and generate employment,
then we will build the schools.
Our experts tell us within a year, maximum of two years we can complete the
twenty to forty thousand, even at the cost of a million per classroom,
although at this point in time the average is at about 500,000, and where will
we get the money? As I’ve mentioned earlier, there are so much leakages in
our revenue collection efforts. The 150 billion, we can allocate a portion of
the 150 billion towards meeting at least part of the 40 billion necessary, if
pump-priming was the necessary goal.
On the other hand we want a more effective use of the resource, we can
contract private schools. I’m made to understand that middle-tier schools
have a tuition in the 5,000 to 8,000 bracket. What does that mean? For a
class size of 50, that translates into Php400,000 cost per classroom of 50.
When we build classrooms, the shell, the basic shell lacking, the chairs, the
blackboard, electricity, the books, the teachers, etc., just the basic shell is
already on average nation-wide Php500,000. So if we are to send these
children, there’s an existing program using a voucher system called “Gasbi.”
If we send these children to private schools but in a direct contracting basis
so that there are no abuses in the system, we can save about Php100,000
per classroom. That translates into, or we can utilize that resource into
supplemental feeding programs, into a better book development program,
into a scholarships for college, into scholarships for teachers, benefits, so
on and so forth.
So, the plan is, transform it from 10 to 12, there is a bridge program, it’s
already in the books, that’s why my theme is always “there are no secrets.”
The plan is a good plan, it’s already there, it’s really just a question of
implementing the same. Now, I think it is unfair for our students to, to expect
rather, our students to be able to absorb 12 years’ worth of education in a
10-year program, further compounded by the desire to be solving the
problems by saying we have no more classroom shortages, and this was
done basically by shifting. Shifting is making 2 or 3 classes utilize 1
classroom. And I would just like to emphasize because that really angers me
every time I think about it. You’re a Grade 1 student, which is the entry level,
in our public school system, you have a class supposedly for English, to
which Science and Health have been included. So, the child who probably
doesn’t understand English, is tasked to understand scientific concepts
taught in English and together with health. To further compound it, as if he
didn’t have enough problems, he’s given a textbook that has errors known
only to the teacher, who is in possession of teacher’s notes. The Grade 1
student, I think no, by the DepEd is expected to be able to discern what is
right and what is wrong at Grade 1, in a language he doesn’t understand.
Question: Mr. Senator, there are a couple of questions that deal with
governance issues, particularly corruption, and I’d like to read them and
maybe you can answer them as a whole. How will you handle the Lucio Tan
cases of tax evasion and the Marcos wealth? Second, you talk about how
different you will be from the present administration, what exactly will you do
to make GMA, FG and all pay for their crimes? What will you do with the
tong of all congressmen? There’s another one that has to do with
encouraging whistle-blowers. So maybe your strategy with dealing with
corruption?
Sen. Noynoy Aquino: Can I start with how do I deal with whistle-blowers?
It’s a sad fact no, I learned this close to about 3 decades ago, if you catch
somebody smuggling, you’re supposed to entitled to, I’m talking about at this
point in time, to a reward of 20% when you give information to catch the
smugglers. If you facilitate smuggling, I was told by my informants, you get a
10% fee. So I asked this person, why will you participate in something illegal
to get 10% when you can go legal? And point the authorities towards the
commission of this crime and get a double reward? And the simple answer
was: the 10% is kaliwaan, I get it right away, the 20% I will get when I retire
and probably 5 years after that. The explanation is you go through so many
processes, the seizing, the goods, for instance, of smuggling, the appeals
process, auctioning, etc., I don’t think it’s that difficult point for government to
advance this reward system to make it an effective reward system, point
one.
Now with regards to the Marcos and Lucio Tan cases, and these are
subjudice, I will be entering the situation, what, at the second or third
decade of litigation? One would hope that there is closure to all, even to
those issues. When you go into this country, you can expect adjudication of
cases to happen in a timely manner. One of the sad facts, and that’s why
judicial reform, again, our stake, has to be improved, is that on average we
understand that it takes 6 years to adjudicate a case. Again, it leads to, a
condition where it moves everybody not to follow the laws, and that has to
stop.
Question: The second questions asks what you will do come June 30,
2010 when we have no elected president and vice president…
Sen. Noynoy Aquino: Number one, the laws on succession are very clear.
But can I just tell you, instead of telling all of you our plans, people, let’s not
be naive no? There are talks that certain quarters want to exploit that
situation. There are talks of failure of elections or non-proclamation, no-el,
so on and so forth. Now, does it behoove me to reveal publicly the plans
that we are contemplating at this point in time, and to make our job of
preserving this democracy harder by telling our enemies precisely what we
will do. I think I will leave my plans close guarded at this point in time and we
assure you we are not babes in the woods, and we are ready, as much as
possible, we are getting all the necessary info, intelligence and alliances in
place, to forestall the grabbing of power by people with purely vested
self-interest.
Can I just add, sorry, this has to be really laid in the minds of everybody. We
in the Liberal Party say that we are espousing platform based, issue-based
politics. And I am very, very confident that even if I were not in the seat, this
occupation is fraught with dangers. I have in the person of my partner, Mar
Roxas, somebody who is exactly of like mind, somebody who will pick up if I
am unable to finish the job. Therefore, we can assure everybody that will
join us, there is a continuity of expectations that are realistic. This is not
person-based.
Sen. Noynoy Aquino:: Well, number one, I think I will be lying if I told you
that we will have comparable jobs within six years. That I think is an
impossibility. But there is I think an obtainable objective of having
compensation for people who have skills that have been improved. We can
get it to a certain level whereby the increase in wages—although not the
same as working abroad—together with the family being in tact, and
together with the idea of being a first-class citizen in your own country will
be enough to win people away from seeking the greener pasture elsewhere.
We believe that the people who have left and who are opting to leave,
primarily have no choice. They are political refugees, they are being forced,
not for improvement—where it was 20 years ago—but rather even just for
survival. And again you’re right. The opportunities have to exist here. Now,
when I go around the country, when I go around Metro Manila, the
opportunities are so abundant, and all it takes is to do the right thing. For
instance, in Surigao City, the table you’re using right now was about the
length of this fish—I don’t know what breed of fish that was. But that
particular stall in the public market in Surigao City had three of it. The next
stall had five of the same size. And the Media asked me in that point in
time—this was the senatorial campaign—“Can you raise it up for a photo
op?” And of course I’m very macho, and I proceeded to raise it by the head.
And the only thing I raised was the head. It was that heavy. And I was
saying: “How much would it cost to set up a blast freezing facility here? How
much would it cost to turn these things into steaks, train the people to
marinate it into that, and export it to countries like Japan or elsewhere,
where they’d be thanking us for sharing the bounty … ” Mar Roxas’s home
province of Capiz, you go to the beach at low tide, you have a rake, you
rake the sand, you get clams. In Metro Manila you get [the fry] of the clams.
Why can’t we even get it from Capiz to Metro Manila?
I’m sorry, sometimes I can’t stop, because really, the absurdity, the simplicity
of the solutions that are not being implemented really gets to me. The
fertilizer scam: The greatest sin is 723 million pesos at least could have
started a chain of improving productivity. And for those of you who are not
aware, when you plant rice in irrigated lands—and that was the hybrid rice
program, that was the fertilizer input program —you can double to quadruple
your income for our farmers, especially if it’s irrigated. You can have five
harvests in two years. But this current government made the program in
2004 and really turned it into a disaster. We had ten cropping cycles that we
lost an opportunity in. But the biggest sin is that even in investigating this
alleged crime took four years. That’s why I said ten harvests were lost. So,
again, from Masagana ’99 we had a hundred kabans per hectare.
Commercially we are already now growing 240 to 320 kabans per hectare. I
am told, but I’m still validating this, that UP LB and IRRI are even working
further than that. And again: a true fertilizer input program, adequate
monitoring, serious credit facilities, can undoubtedly at least make us
self-sufficient in rice. We teach agriculturists worldwide. At the end of the
day, we import food. That has to stop also.
Question: I think you will welcome this next question. It says: do you
already have enough money for the campaign?
Sen. Noynoy Aquino: I will be lying if I tell you we have enough money.
But, there is adequate … but of course, it makes the process that much
simpler. Can I just share with you this bit of information that was given to me
yesterday? I understand there was a tsinoy who went to our headquarters in
EDSA the other day. He proceeds to donate a certain amount of money, I
was not told how much, but he had a simple request. I’ll say it Tagalog
cause it really was… I really made my day that day. He said: “Ito yung pera,
bumili kayo ng commercial niyo. Naiinis na ko dito sa isang ‘to.” That by the
way is not a joke. It really did happen. At some point in time we will have to
report that contribution to Comelec. We’ll have all the details then. But it
really made my day.
Question: Two quick questions again, Mr Senator. What will be the roles of
your sister Kris and your uncle Peping if you become president? Can you
give us a specifically categorical answer on your stand on the Reproductive
Health Bill?
Sen. Noynoy Aquino: Kris I think will still be my fashion adviser, which
means if she does not like what I’m wearing, she will not keep quiet. I think
she even had this barong made. So if she complains I’ll tell her you’re the
one who designed it. And that will be the extent. Most of my sisters, and Kris
included—Kris is a very busy individual … Anything I ask her, I ask her to
attend some ribbon-cutting thing if I become president, that will be an
imposition on her time. The three are eagerly looking forward to regaining
their anonymity. In fact I’m not even sure if I celebrate my birthday, in the
period of incumbency, that they will be present, since it will be a Media
event. The role of my Tito Peping: I would be foolish not to seek his wisdom,
because of his experience; but at the same time, I will be the one holding the
fort. The buck really has to stop with me. I am responsible ultimately for all
my actions. Therefore any or all of my decisions will be based on discussion
with all the stakeholders as much as possible, but in the end of the day it will
be something I can live with in conscience, in what I believe is right
regardless on who propounded it.
Sen. Noynoy Aquino: Mrs Arroyo when she was my professor said that
there should be minimal government intervention (Questioner: “She’s got a
poor memory …”), because distortions are created in the marketplace. But
then again, given that … you know, it proceeds from a governance of
survival there’s no logic used except “will it help me retain power or not?”
Therefore every decision is faulted from the onset because of that
perception. We are hoping that we will get our mandate clear: clear and
clearly won, therefore we will have the confidence to embark and ask our
people. At this point in time we will have to sacrifice by X amount to get to
this level. We want to be transparent in all of the dealings. At the end of the
day I assume, god willing we have an intervention for instance in agriculture.
You had that 723 million debt really bought fertilizers that were correct. That
were delivered at a timely manner at an appropriate price. And perhaps
even the, as I mentioned, the purchasing aspect of it be reformed. Things
will work out on themselves because we made the right decisions on every
aspect. When I pass EDSA, and I guess everybody who passes … can I just
a question? When was the last time you remember EDSA as being a
smoothly paved road? And this is the premiere road of our National Capital
Region. I think most of you will say Highway 54, those who are honest. But
when we export our construction companies, our engineers, our designers
elsewhere, hindi ba world class? How many of you are aware that in this
recent tragedy in Haiti, there were so many Filipinos in a professional basis.
And I was surprised that even in Bermuda, the same situation holds:
Accountants, lawyers, etc. I always assumed that Bermuda, beneficiary of
the British Civil Service System, would have a very efficient bureaucracy,
and an efficient professional corps. But it turns out it is again it’s again
another area for Filipino expertise to shine. So again, they can do it there,
undoubtably they can do it better here, so long as the milieu is present that
opportunities for everybody are extant. Nobody is excluded, hence our
phrase is “Walang iwanan at walang maiiwan.”
Question: I was told that we have to wind this up after two final questions,
that I’d like to read. One is: “How will you handle the issue of pagbabago the
Filipino people dreamt and longed for” and “as a transformational president,
what key qualities would you bring to this task?”
Sen. Noynoy Aquino: Well, number one, you will have to lead by example.
I think in fairness to my mother, at the onset of her term she inherited a
government that was corrupt top to bottom, for the most part because the
top set the example. Something as cop on the street who was being bribed
for a minor traffic violation: he used to demand for his bribe. At the onset of
my mom’s term, the phrase was, “Teka, hindi ko hinihingi yan a. Binibigay
mo yan, pinipilit mo.” There was a recognition that that was wrong. And after
that, something as simple as … I complain about traffic, and Mar in I already
have an agreement. If we win, and if traffic isn’t solved, we’ll participate in
the traffic. We will not ask of anybody that which we are not ready to do
ourselves first. Hopefully we will not talk as much, because we are trying to
put a spin on something that is indefensible. And siguro the biggest ambition
is in the fourth year, it will just be Mar and I talking because everything is
working and it’s boring.