Project Title:

Section: Team:

Team Member Weight Unacceptable

0
Design objectives, plans,
principles, and timetable
either not presented or
very poorly presented
Team Leader 3

Key aspects of equipment

Experimental Engineer
not presented; no
experimental design
presented; technical
procedures pooly
3 presented or not
presented

Design basis not

Design Engineer
presented or incorrect;
Mistakes in theory; theory
incomplete, poorly
organized
3

Comments
 Purdue University
Chemical Engineering Laboratory
CHE 435 2016
Preparation Conference Assessment
Project #____

Date:

Reviewer:

Marginal Acceptable Good

1 2.5 4
Either design objectives, Some aspect of the Design objectives, plans,
plans, principles, or design objectives, plans, timetable, and plans
timetable missing timetable, or principles is presented adequately
unclear

Either the equipment Equipment description, Equipment description,

description, technical technical procedures, and technical procedures, and
procedures, or experimental design are experimental design are
experimental design is adequate adequate and explained
inadequate well

Design basis incomplete; Preliminary design Preliminary design

no preliminary design presented; requisite
presented performance criteria
identified; no or little
guidance provided for
experimental program
presented; requisite
performance criteria
identified; adequate
guidance provided for
experimental program
Good Excellent Points
4 5
Design and experimental
objectives are clear, project
plans, timetable, and
principles are presented
well

Equipment description,
technical procedures, and
experimental design are
completely explained and
interpreted

Preliminary design
presented very well;
requisite performance
criteria identified and
excellent guidance
provided for experimental
program