Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Bioreq v2.0
Bioreq v2.0
Bioreq v2.0
0
Table of Contents
Introduction............................................................................................................................................. 5
0.1 Background .................................................................................................................................... 5
0.2 Purpose and Scope ........................................................................................................................ 5
0.3 Audience ........................................................................................................................................ 5
0.4 Structure Overview........................................................................................................................ 6
0.5 Conventions ................................................................................................................................... 6
0.6 Works Consulted ........................................................................................................................... 6
0.7 Document Status ........................................................................................................................... 7
0.8 Adaptation ..................................................................................................................................... 7
1 Ethical Requirements ........................................................................................................................... 8
1.1. General ......................................................................................................................................... 8
1.2 Informed Consent.......................................................................................................................... 8
1.3 Anonymization ............................................................................................................................ 10
1.4 Independent Review ................................................................................................................... 11
1.5 Access to Biospecimens and Data ............................................................................................... 12
1.6 Intellectual Property .................................................................................................................... 13
2 Technical Requirements ..................................................................................................................... 14
2.1 Human factors ............................................................................................................................. 14
BIOBANK DIRECTOR....................................................................................................................... 14
STAFF ............................................................................................................................................. 14
TRAINING ....................................................................................................................................... 15
2.2 Accommodation and Environmental Conditions ........................................................................ 15
2.3 Safety ........................................................................................................................................... 16
BIOLOGICAL SAFETY ...................................................................................................................... 17
ELECTRICAL SAFETY ....................................................................................................................... 17
FIRE SAFETY ................................................................................................................................... 17
PHYSICAL SAFETY ........................................................................................................................... 18
CHEMICAL SAFETY ......................................................................................................................... 19
RADIOLOGICAL SAFETY.................................................................................................................. 19
SAFETY PROGRAMME AND ASSOCIATED TRAINING ..................................................................... 19
EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS ........................................................................................................ 19
2.4 Acquisition, Maintenance and Provision ..................................................................................... 19
SAMPLING ..................................................................................................................................... 20
HANDLING OF BIOLOGICAL SAMPLES ........................................................................................... 21
SUPPLY ........................................................................................................................................... 23
DOCUMENTATION OF RETRIEVAL ................................................................................................. 23
SHIPMENT...................................................................................................................................... 24
2.5 Validation/authentication Methods ............................................................................................ 25
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.
0.1 Background
International standards ISO 17025 and ISO 15189 cover the operation of laboratories; NCI and OECD
recommendations provide guidance for biological resource centres in general; ISBER best practices
and the Council of Europe recommendation REC(2006)4 concern the treatment of human biological
samples and research involving the use of such materials. However, no single document has
managed to cover the full range of research and operation activities at biorepositories. By integrating
the best practices included in the aforementioned international standards and regulations, this
Guideline provides a comprehensive aid in operating biobanks and conducting research which
involve the use of biospecimen.
In recent years there has been an increasing need to automate many of the error-prone and time-
consuming tasks such as inventory tracking, report generation, management of patient consent
forms etc. As a growing number of software products target biorepositories, it is crucial that
potential users have a standard against which to compare services. The lack of relevant ICT standards
also hinders the interoperability of cooperating institutions. Electronic health record standards are
not adequate in this respect since (1) they have a narrower scope, (2) the data management needs of
medical records and biological sample records are different, (3) they do not cover all the processes
that form an integral part of managing biological materials.
0.3 Audience
This Guideline is intended to be used by the following parties:
Biobank Directors and senior management;
Clinical workers;
Laboratory workers;
Researchers;
0.5 Conventions
The words MUST, MUST NOT, SHOULD, SHOULD NOT and MAY are to be interpreted as follows
(based on RFC2119):
MUST This word, or the terms "REQUIRED" or "SHALL", mean that the statement is an
absolute requirement of the Guideline.
MUST NOT This phrase means that the statement is an absolute prohibition of the Guideline.
SHOULD This word, or the adjective "RECOMMENDED", mean that there may exist valid
reasons in particular circumstances to ignore a particular item, but the full
implications must be understood and carefully weighed before choosing a different
course.
SHOULD NOT This phrase, or the phrase "NOT RECOMMENDED" mean that there may exist valid
reasons in particular circumstances when the particular behavior is acceptable or
even useful, but the full implications should be understood and the case carefully
weighed before implementing any behavior described with this label.
MAY This word, or the adjective "OPTIONAL", mean that an item is truly optional. In the
context of software system requirements, one vendor may choose to include the
item because a particular marketplace requires it or because the vendor feels that it
enhances the product while another vendor may omit the same item. An
implementation which does not include a particular option must be prepared to
interoperate with another implementation which does include the option and vice
versa.
0.8 Adaptation
Different countries may have differing traditions, views and regulatory demands for operating
biorepositories and conducting research which involves the use of biological materials. This guideline
should be complemented with national requirements; if conflicts exist between national regulations
and the recommendations of this guideline, national requirements should be adhered to.
This Guideline may also be extended and adapted to the needs of other kinds of biobanks by
introducing additional requirements.
Key discussions of ethics in human subjects research are found in the Declaration of Helsinki
adopted by the World Medical Association in 1964 and revised several times subsequently, most
recently in 2008 and the Belmont Report published by the US Department of Health and Human
Services in April 1979.
This chapter highlights the principles concerning informed consent and other biorepository-specific
issues.
1.1. General
The following requirements apply to all kinds of research conducted at biobanks.
Ref. Requirement Source
1.1.1 The principles of chapter VIII (confidentiality and right to information) of the REC(2006)4
Additional Protocol concerning biomedical research (CETS No. 195, 2005, Ch. VI Art.
Additional Protocol to the Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine, 25
concerning Biomedical Research, Strasbourg, 25.I.2005) should be applied to
any research project using biological materials and associated personal data.
1.1.2 Research should be: ISBER
(a) well designed; L1.000
(b) conducted by persons with appropriate expertise;
(c) lead to meaningful conclusions.
1.1.3 Every measure should be taken to reduce the risk and ensure that the risk ISBER
does not exceed the benefit of the expected finding. L1.000
1.1.4 Studies in animals should provide reason to believe that the study of ISBER
humans is needed and is the only way to get the necessary information. L1.000
1.1.5 Freely-given informed patient consent must be in place before research on ISBER
humans may be conducted. L1.000
1.1.6 The risks for the persons concerned and, where appropriate, for their family, REC(2006)4
related to research activities, in particular the risks to private life, should be Ch. II Art. 5
minimized, taking into account the nature of the research activity.
1.1.7 Those risks should not be disproportionate to the potential benefit of the REC(2006)4
research activities. Ch. II Art. 5
1.1.8 Appropriate measures should be taken, in the full range of research REC(2006)4
activities, to avoid discrimination against, or stigmatization of, a person, Ch. II Art. 6
family or group.
1.1.9 To protect the health information of patients, adhere to privacy laws with NCI Ch. III
respect to electronic information systems. Art. 1E.4
1.1.10 Institute the level of security appropriate to the type of biorepository and to NCI Ch. III
protect study participant privacy for the biospecimens stored in the Art. 2C.1
biorepository.
1.1.11 The collection, storage and use of human specimens and associated data ISBER
must be done in a way that respects the individual and maintains privacy L2.220
and confidentiality.
1.3 Anonymization
Anonymization is the process whereby identifying data are removed from biological sample records.
Biobanks have to distinguish between identifiable and non-identifiable biological materials:
1. Identifiable biological materials allow the identification of the persons concerned either
directly or through the use of a code. In the latter case, the user of the biological materials
may either:
a) Have access to the code: the materials are hereafter referred to as coded materials; or
b) Not have access to the code, which is under the control of a third party: the material are
hereafter referred to as linked anonymized materials
2. Non-identifiable biological materials are unlinked anonymized biological materials, which,
alone or in combination with associated data, do not allow, with reasonable efforts, the
identification of the persons concerned.
This section defines which data are to be treated as identifying, imposes restrictions on the access of
such data, and describes what processes can be employed to de-identify materials.(For detailed
definitions, see the Glossary.)
Ref. Requirement Source
1.3.1 Biological materials and associated data should be anonymized as far as REC(2006)4
appropriate to the research activities concerned. Ch. II Art.
8.1
1.3.2 Any use of biological materials and associated data in an identified, coded, REC(2006)4
Chapter 2: Technical Requirements describes factors which contribute to the correct and reliable
operation of biorepositories. More specifically, the requirements apply to the acquisition,
maintenance and provision of biological materials and validation/authentication actions.
The present model requirements do not prescribe the specifics of particular laboratory procedures;
rather, they articulate principles by which evidence-based standard operating procedures (SOPs) can
be developed.
Aside from the principles outlined in Part 2, national or institutional regulations may further control
the biorepository or laboratory operation; such directives should be always taken into consideration.
BIOBANK DIRECTOR
The Biobank Director is expected to meet the following requirements.
Ref. Requirement Source
2.1.1 The Biobank Director should be qualified by training and experience to fulfill ISBER
the scope of activities conducted by the biobank. B2.110
2.1.2 The Biobank Director should implement policies of the organization. ISBER
B2.120
2.1.3 The Biobank Director should be responsible for all operations, including ISBER
compliance with current and applicable regulations and ensure that B2.120
repository activities are in compliance with national, and local authorities.
2.1.4 The Biobank Director should construct and maintain a current organizational ISBER
chart that delineates the functional relationships within the biobank. B2.130
2.1.5 The Biobank Director should appoint and direct the members of the ISBER
supervisory and technical staff. B2.130
2.1.6 The Biobank Director should approve and maintain job descriptions and ISBER
document staff responsibilities. B2.130
2.1.7 The Biobank Director should be responsible for developing and reviewing ISBER
employee training programs. B2.130
2.1.8 The Biobank Director should ensure that there is an appropriate and ISBER
acceptable safety programme. B2.130
2.1.9 The Biobank Director may ensure that the biobank operates within budget. ISBER
B2.120
2.1.10 The Biobank Director may ensure that all patient consent forms are updated ISBER
annually to be in compliance with Institutional Review Board regulations and B2.120
serving as a liaison for the Institutional Review Board.
2.1.11 The Biobank Director may serve as a liaison for researchers, for hospital staff ISBER
(surgeons, nurses, operating room staff, pathologists, and residents), this B2.120
would include ensuring that patient issues are addressed and that biobank
staff are responding in an appropriate manner.
STAFF
Biobank staff members are expected to meet the following requirements.
Ref. Requirement Source
2.1.12 The biobank management must ensure the competence of all who operate ISO17025
specific equipment, perform acquisition, maintenance and provision of
TRAINING
Care must be taken to ensure the proper training of staff members in areas (1) prescribed by law
(e.g. safety) and (2) deemed necessary by management (e.g. how to operate specific equipment).
Ref. Requirement Source
2.1.20 The biobank must have a policy and procedures for identifying training ISO17025
needs and providing training of personnel (requirements for training in
biohazards, chemical hazards and radiological hazards are the most
demanding).
2.1.21 As part of the bloodborne pathogen training, staff members may get ISBER
hepatitis vaccines. G5.000
2.1.22 Training in each area of safety must be given to employees before they ISBER
begin their work. G5.000
2.1.23 The training must be updated yearly for all employees. ISBER
G5.000
2.1.24 Training must be lead by knowledgeable trainers in a language that is ISBER
appropriate for the employees being trained. G5.000
2.1.25 Records of employee training must be maintained for at least 3 years, ISBER
although this requirement may vary nationally. G5.000
2.1.26 Biobank staff who come in contact with patients also should be trained in ISBER
bioethical regulations regarding the disclosure of confidential patient G5.000
information to patients and others.
2.3 Safety
The operation of the biobank must be such as to ensure the protection of the staff, samples and
equipment against physical, chemical, biological, radiological and other potential types of hazards. In
this section, we cover the following safety policy areas:
biological safety;
electrical safety;
fire safety;
physical safety;
chemical safety;
radiological safety.
Guidance on how to prepare for potential emergency situations is also provided.
Ref. Requirement Source
2.3.1 The Director or other designated individual (this may be the CEO in some ISBER
private institutions) must have total responsibility for the safe operation of G4.000
all components of the institution.
2.3.2 The institution may establish a Safety Committee which is responsible for ISBER
the overall safety plan of the institution, and for periodic monitoring and G4.000
updating, of the plan.
2.3.3 The Safety Committee may appoint a Safety Officer to administer the safety ISBER
programme, monitor and maintain compliance with the programme, G4.000
evaluate incidents and injuries and recommend changes to the Safety
Committee, as needed.
2.3.4 There must be effective separation between neighbouring areas in which ISO17025
there are incompatible activities.
2.3.5 The activities that must be accommodated separately are as follows: OECD 5.1
(a) Receipt and storage of the initial sample;
(b) Preparation, handling and processing of samples;
(c) Biological material storage area and back-up or safety duplicate
collection;
(d) Supply, delivery/sales (kept separate from incoming accessions);
BIOLOGICAL SAFETY
Describes instructions on safe handling of biological materials, particularly infectious agents which
are classified on the basis of degree of risk to humans working with them.
Ref. Requirement Source
2.3.7 The safe operational level or safety limit for the resources available should OECD 5
be justified and documented and the biobank should not operate beyond
these limits.
2.3.8 Assuming that all human biospecimens are potentially infective and NCI Ch. III
biohazardous, biobanks must handle biospecimens according to, at a Art. 1D.1
minimum, Biosafety Level 2 (BSL2).
2.3.8 All human specimens and to a lesser extent animal specimens, whether ISBER
fixed, paraffin embedded, fresh frozen or freeze-dried should be considered G6.100
as biohazardous.
2.3.10 Buildings should be cleaned on a regular basis. OECD 5.4
2.3.11 Cleaning and decontamination procedures should be documented. OECD 5.4
2.3.12 Cleaning of organism containment areas and specialist equipment should be OECD 5.4
performed by authorised and trained staff using appropriate personal
protection equipment following documented.
2.3.13 Documentation must be prepared at all incidents where personnel are NCI Ch. III
exposed. Art. 1D.5
ELECTRICAL SAFETY
Electrical safety involves using safe practices when working with or near electricity or electrical
devices.
Ref. Requirement Source
2.3.14 Surge protectors are recommended for stand-alone freezers, if this is not ISBER
part of the building electrical infrastructure. G6.300
2.3.15 Computer systems and electronic systems, such as freezer controllers should ISBER
be protected by an uninterruptible power supply (UPS) system (motor D5.100
generator).
2.3.16 UPS, like a motor generator must have a fuel supply to run continuously for ISBER
a minimum of 48 hours and preferably a minimum of 72 hours, with an D5.200
ability to re-supply fuel storage supplies.
2.3.17 Pipeline natural gas supplied generator may serve as an unlimited source, ISBER
provided supply lines are not interrupted. D5.200
FIRE SAFETY
Fire safety is a group of equipment and/or behaviour designed to both reduce the risk of starting a
fire and reduce the risk of injury in the event of a fire.
PHYSICAL SAFETY
This subsection describes the responsibilities for site security and the procedures that must be
adopted to maintain the security and integrity of the exhibits, documents and other records and to
provide a secure working environment for the employees.
Ref. Requirement Source
2.3.28 The purpose of any biobank is the safekeeping of the materials. To that end ISBER
every biobank should employ basic security systems that must be monitored D4.100
and alarms responded to 24 hours per day, 7 days per week.
2.3.29 Response systems must be in place such that a responsible individual can ISBER
take the necessary action to respond to an alarm in a time frame that D4.100
prevents or minimizes loss or damage to the collection materials.
2.3.30 Systems should allow for calls to other key staff from a list of staff phone ISBER
numbers when the first individual fails to acknowledge the alarm. D4.100
2.3.31 Emergency contact numbers should be posted in prominent locations in the ISBER
biobank. D4.100
2.3.32 Care should be taken with the overall security of the workplace; this includes ISBER
limiting access to the workplace by unauthorized personnel. G6.500
2.3.33 Doors should be locked. ISBER
D4.300
2.3.34 Keys should be controlled, with a record maintained of each person having ISBER
access to the biobank. D4.300
2.3.35 Keys which cannot be readily duplicated are highly preferred. ISBER
D4.300
2.3.36 Freezers or environmental storage equipment that store valuable or ISBER
sensitive specimens should be individually locked. D4.300
CHEMICAL SAFETY
Chemical safety pertains specifically to protection against the toxic effects of chemicals that may
arise.
Ref. Requirement Source
2.3.38 Employers must develop a written chemical hygiene plan capable of ISBER
protecting employees from hazardous chemicals in the laboratory and G6.200
capable of keeping chemical exposures below the action level or in its
absence the Permissible Exposure Limit (PEL).
2.3.39 Organizations that fix tissues, for example for quality control, must follow ISBER
applicable areas of the Formaldehyde Standard. G6.200
RADIOLOGICAL SAFETY
Radiological safety protection of personnel against harmful effects of ionizing radiation by taking
steps to ensure that people will not receive excessive doses of radiation and by monitoring all
sources of radiation to which they may be exposed.
Ref. Requirement Source
2.3.40 For organizations needing a radiological safety plan, the personnel who ISBER
utilize or come into contact with radioactive material require training as well G6.600
as specific monitoring equipment as do radiological safety personnel.
EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS
Planning, exercising and education are necessary to achieve a state of readiness for disasters and
emergencies.
Ref. Requirement Source
2.3.43 The facility should have in place an emergency preparedness plan (facility ISBER
disaster plan NCI) that addresses a wide variety of unlikely, but possible E4.000
emergencies (based on a local area risk assessment NCI). This would
include such natural disasters as earthquakes, hurricanes, tornados, flood,
fire, terrorist activities or political demonstrations.
2.3.44 The plan should include appropriate measures to protect personnel and NCI Ch. III
equipment during a disaster. Art. 1C.6
SAMPLING
Sampling is a defined procedure whereby a part of a substance, material or product is taken to
provide for validation/authentication of a representative sample of the whole. Sampling may also be
required by the appropriate specification for which the substance, material or product is to be
validated/authenticated.
Ref. Requirement Source
2.4.6 The sample labels should include at least the batch date or number and the OECD 11.1
biobank accession number.
DOCUMENTATION OF RETRIEVAL
The following requirements describe the conditions of sample retrieval, both temporary and
permanent (e.g. transfer).
Ref. Requirement Source
2.4.42 Checklists and other forms are desirable to document the specimen retrieval ISBER
process including steps to confirm completeness of the process and steps K5.300
occurring after retrieval to document shipment and quality checks.
2.4.43 If specimens are to be shipped to an outside location, the recipient should ISBER
SHIPMENT
Biological samples may be transferred or shipped to other institutions. The biobank has to ensure
that transfer conditions (e.g. temperature) do not result in the degradation of the samples. Shipment
details and confirmation of receipt need to be archived for future reference.
Ref. Requirement Source
2.4.47 Each repository should maintain a shipment log to record the receipt and ISBER
dissemination of shipments sent from the repository. I4.000
2.4.48 The log may be computerized or it may be kept in a logbook. If ISBER
computerized, ideally it would be included in the functionality of the I4.000
inventory management system.
2.4.49 Each shipment entry should be given a unique shipment number. ISBER
I4.000
2.4.50 The log should track the following elements: ISBER
(a) Shipment/Invoice Number; I4.000
(b) recipient/source;
(c) date received or shipped;
(d) courier name and ID# for tracking package;
(e) sample description;
(f) number of samples received or sent;
(g) study name if available;
(h) study number if available;
(i) key investigator name(s);
(j) signature of individual receiving the specimen.
2.4.51 Adhere to biosafety, packaging, and shipping regulations. NCI Ch. III
Art. 1A.14
2.4.52 Air shipments should conform to International Air Transport Association ISBER
(IATA) standards. J1.000
2.4.53 Dry ice (solid carbon dioxide) and liquid nitrogen employed for frozen ISBER
shipments are hazardous materials, and appropriate labelling must be J1.000
included.
2.4.54 Specimens may be exposed to temperature fluctuations during transit. The ISBER
following are typical temperature conditions required for transport of J2.200
specimens and the insulation/refrigerant required to maintain that
temperature:
(a) ambient (20 to 30 C): insulated packaging to protect from extreme
heat/cold ambient conditions;
(b) refrigerated (2 to 8 C): gel packs designed for refrigerated
temperatures, conditioned at 15 C or phase change material rated
for refrigerated transport;
(c) frozen (-20 C): gel packs designed for frozen temperatures,
conditioned at or below 20C;
(d) frozen (-70 C): dry ice pellets or sheets;
2.6 Equipment
Biobanks need to be well-equipped in order to facilitate the proper maintenance of samples and for
providing an infrastructure necessary to performing sample-related actions (e.g. validation,
preparation). A piece of equipment is any device that provides a readout, data, or has a meter
movement. In this section, we present general requirements pertaining to the tracking, maintenance
and calibration of equipment. Since freezers and refrigerators are the primary storage units in a
biobank, requirements related to following freezer types are also addressed:
cryogenic freezers;
liquid nitrogen freezers;
mechanical freezers;
walk-in freezers and refrigerators.
Ref. Requirement Source
2.6.1 The biobank must be furnished with all items of acquisition, preparation and ISO17025
maintenance of biological samples and validation/authentication equipment 5.4.1
required for the correct performance of these activities (including
preparation, aliquoting, storage, sampling of validation/authentication
items, processing and analysis of validation/authentication data).
2.6.2 Each item of equipment and its software used for acquisition, maintenance ISO17025
and provision of biological materials and validation/authentication and
significant to the result must, when practicable, be uniquely identified.
2.6.3 Records must be maintained of each item of equipment and its software. ISO17025
The records shall include at least the following:
(a) the identity of the item of equipment and its software;
(b) the manufacturer's name, type identification, and serial number or
other unique identification;
(c) checks that equipment complies with the specification;
(d) the current location, where appropriate;
(e) the manufacturer's instructions, if available, or reference to their
location;
(f) dates, results and copies of reports and certificates of all
calibrations, adjustments, acceptance criteria, and the due date of
next calibration;
(g) the maintenance plan, where appropriate, and maintenance carried
out to date;
(h) any damage, malfunction, modification or repair to the equipment.
CALIBRATION
Calibration is the act of checking or adjusting the accuracy of a measuring instrument by comparison
with a standard. The following requirements apply to equipment which need calibration on a regular
basis.
Ref. Requirement Source
2.6.6 The biobank shall have an established programme and procedure for the ISO17025
calibration of its equipment.
2.6.7 The calibration programme should include a system for selecting, using, ISO17025
calibrating, checking, controlling and maintaining measurement standards,
reference materials used as measurement standards, and equipment used
to perform acquisition, maintenance and provision of biological materials
and validation/authentication.
2.6.8 Calibration should be done annually or per manufacturers ISBER
recommendation. E6.200
2.6.9 Calibration should be performed against standards. ISBER
E6.200
2.6.10 Calibration records should include the appropriate standard readings taken ISBER
both before and after calibration. E6.200
2.6.11 Whenever practicable, all equipment under the control of the biobank and ISO17025
requiring calibration must be labelled, coded or otherwise identified to
indicate the status of calibration, including the date when last calibrated and
the date or expiration criteria when recalibration is due.
REFRIGERATORS
The operation of refrigerators is expected to meet the following requirements.
Ref. Requirement Source
2.6.17 In refrigerator operation it should be ensured that the temperature is ISBER
maintained within the specified operating range, not just below a maximum E5.400
CRYOGENIC FREEZERS
The following rules must be in place if cryogenic freezers are employed in the biobank.
Ref. Requirement Source
2.6.20 Where liquid nitrogen (LN2) refrigeration is employed, an adequate supply ISBER
of refrigerant must be maintained. E5.210
2.6.21 For freezers filled from Dewars or supply tanks, a minimum three-day supply ISBER
of LN2 at normal usage and replenishment intervals should be maintained, E5.210
with the assumption that a re-supply is readily available.
2.6.22 The supply maintained on hand should be at least 20 % more than the ISBER
normal refill usage to allow for emergency situations. E5.210
2.6.23 Bulk supply systems should maintain a minimum supply of 20 % of the bulk ISBER
tank capacity, or greater than 3 days working capacity, assuming a ready re- E5.210
supply system.
2.6.24 Self Contained Breathing Apparatus (SCBAs or air packs) should be ISBER
available for use in the event of a white out condition in the biobank (in the E5.210
event of a blockage or overpressure event, a number of relief valves will
vent nearly simultaneously with a consequent visibility-drop to near zero
and the oxygen level in the area may become less than that necessary to
sustain life).
2.6.25 Personnel should receive training on the effective use of these units. ISBER
E5.210
2.6.26 In the event of an emergency staff should evacuate the facility immediately ISBER
and not return until the environment is safe. E5.210
MECHANICAL FREEZERS
Mechanical freezers are employed in a variety of storage temperature ranges, including -20, -40, -70
to -80C, and occasionally -140C.
Ref. Requirement Source
2.6.36 Because mechanical freezers are devices attached to commercial power ISBER
systems, a back-up power plan and an emergency response plan must be in E5.300
place.
2.6.37 Common practice is to set the alarm point at about 10C warmer than the ISBER
nominal operating temperature of the unit. E5.300
This chapter describes the requirements that apply to the operation of biobanks. It explains the tasks
and responsibilities of the management and staff, document handling procedures and general quality
control requirements.
3.2 Training
The biobank management is responsible for the adequate training of staff members.
Ref. Requirement Source
3.2.1. The biobank management must ensure the competence of all staff. ISO 17025
5.2.1.
3.2.2. The biobank must have a policy and procedures for identifying training ISO 17025
needs and providing training of personnel. 5.2.2.
3.2.3. Staff should be trained according to documented protocols in skills OECD 4.3
specific to the job and should receive training as new technologies or
practices are introduced.
3.2.4. As part of the bloodborne pathogen training, staff members may get ISBER
hepatitis vaccines. G5.000
3.2.5. When using staff who are undergoing training, appropriate supervision shall ISO 17025
be provided. 5.2.1.
Many of the time-consuming and error-prone tasks covered in previous chapters can be automated
by one or more software products; together these will be referred to as a Biobank Software System
(BSS). This part lists the requirements that Biobank Software Systems must fulfil.
The requirements in this chapter are based on MoReq2, a joint European specification of electronic
records management. Since records can describe any kind of entity from samples to equipment, a
records management specification is a sufficient basis of electronic sample management. MoReq2
requirements have been adapted to serve the needs of biobanks.
The requirements in Chapters 1-3 have been analysed and translated into software system
requirements so that the present chapter can be used on its own for BSS design purposes. From the
perspective of BSS vendors the rest of the guideline should be interpreted as a biobank domain
description.
Sections 4.1 and 4.2 help software analysts and engineers to design the data model of actual BSS
implementations. These sections cover metadata requirements and the outline of entity types
managed by a BSS.
The organization of the requirements in Sections 4.3-4.5 follows the natural order of general sample-
related processes as depicted in Fig. 1.
Section 4.6 outlines laboratory management features; as is the case with other sections of the
chapter, additional requirements may be introduced if required by the operating organization.
Requirements in Sections 4.7-10 are of a purely technical nature in terms that they are typical of any
software system, and are not strictly related to biobank-specific processes (e.g. user management,
search, log).
Section 4.11, Audit describes how the BSS supports biobank audits with features presented in earlier
parts of the guideline.
The non-functional requirements set out in Section 4.12 define system characteristics which
contribute to the success and long-term appeal of the BSS, e.g. performance, scalability. Security
measures are also addressed.
Section 4.13 provides guidance on the specifics of the hardware infrastructure supporting the BSS, on
user interface design considerations and on how to integrate the BSS with other type of software
applications.
Import Sample
from other collection
biobanks
2. Sample and
data management
Secure
Retrieval
storage
Data
publication Processing
Destruction,
Distribution
loss, using up
In addition to the requirements set out in this part, care must be taken to adhere to any national
regulations that may apply, including:
In technical terms, entity types define which metadata describe particular instances of that real-
world type. For example, a sample type may prescribe that the system has to associate a unique ID
and the date of creation with samples. An instance or specific occurrence of an entity type in the BSS
A tissue sample with the code AA1234 is an instance of a sample type, and has a corresponding
record in the BSS which includes information about the sample kind (i.e. tissue) and also contains a
reference (it may be the code AA1234) to help identify the sample in the real world.
Entity types managed by the BSS may be grouped into the following categories:
Samples;
Patients;
Procedures and protocols;
Documents;
Equipment;
Collection sites;
Storage units;
Users.
GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
The following requirements apply to all entity types managed by the BSS.
SAMPLES
The following requirements describe the specifics of sample types.
DOCUMENTS
The BSS should be prepared to manage documents associated with the operation of the biobank.
Documents include digitally scanned documents and documents created with specific software
products (e.g. text editors, spreadsheet editors, reporting systems etc.). Examples of documents
include but are not limited to surgical pathology reports, H&E slide of representative portion of the
tissue, clinical lab reports, signed patient consent forms, manuals, and material transfer agreements.
USERS
This section lists only the compulsory metadata associated with user records; for an in-depth
treatment of users, user roles and the BSS access control model see Section 4.7.
Ref. Requirement Source
4.2.28 The BSS must be able to store and manage user profile data, which includes
the following:
PROCEDURES
Records of procedures are also managed by the BSS. The following requirements specify the
management of procedure records.
Ref. Requirement Source
4.2.30 The BSS must support the management of information related to the OECD
following sample lifecycle processes:
(a) sample acquisition, including sample collection and receipt of
samples from other institutions;
(b) storage of samples and associated data;
(c) processing of samples;
(d) disposition and transfer or distribution of samples.
4.2.31 The BSS must provide built-in workflows for the management of sample
lifecycle processes.
4.2.32 The BSS may allow administrative roles to customize BSS workflows.
SAMPLE IMPORT
This section summarizes the requirements on recording information about the receipt of samples
from other institutions. For the import of sample data see Section 4.13, Data Export and Import.
SAMPLE VALIDATION/AUTHENTICATION
Sample validation or authentication is the process of confirming the identity of the biological
material by a competent person. Validation usually precedes the preservation of the sample. It is
desirable that the BSS should support sample validation by allowing users to enter the details of the
validation and generate validation reports.
STORAGE
Requirements on recording data (see Section 2.2) guarantee that the storage of sample records
adheres to privacy protection regulations. This section provides requirements that biobank software
systems must fulfil in order to track the physical location of samples, their storage conditions and
information about their movement.
DATA ACCESS
Access to records is subject to the following rules.
SAMPLE RETRIEVAL
Samples may be retrieved either temporarily, or permanently for transfer. The transfer of samples is
covered in Section 4.5. This section deals with requirements on sample retrieval requests and the
management of temporary retrievals.
DATA PUBLICATION
International regulations (e.g. NCI, OECD) demand that research data developed using biological
samples should be made available to the research community. This section suggests BSS functions
which support the publication of results.
A sample may get out of the scope of the biobank in one of the following ways:
SAMPLE RETENTION
The retention schedule defines how long samples and associated sample records have to be kept by
the BSS. Lack of resources (e.g. insufficient number of freezers) or other conditions (e.g. shelf life)
may require that samples should be destroyed or transferred to other institutions when their
predefined retention period expires. Sample records, however, must not necessarily be destroyed
with samples. It is preferable to keep sample records permanently unless regulations or transfer
agreements demand otherwise.
SAMPLE DESTRUCTION
In rare instances, samples must be destroyed (possible reasons include lack of storage capacity or
sample degradation). This section comprises requirements which address the following questions:
SAMPLE TRANSFER
This section covers requirements pertaining to the transfer of samples to other institutions, including
the selling of samples. The BSS is expected to support all the phases of sample transfer from
preparation through review to generating shipment logs.
Ref. Requirement Source
4.5.23 The BSS must keep record of all biological sample transfers. Records of OECD,
transfers must include the following data: ISBER
(a) shipment/invoice ID;
(b) list and number of samples to transfer;
(c) method of shipment;
(d) date of shipment;
(e) name and address of the receiving party;
(f) shipment receipt if recorded delivery, courier or similar shipping
mechanisms are used.
4.5.24 The BSS should present for inspection informed patient consents associated NCI,
with the samples that will be transferred to ensure that transfer is REC(2006)4
consistent with the consent and allowable use of materials.
4.5.25 The BSS should be able to store transfers agreements (Material Transfer
Agreements, Letter Agreements), and allow authorized users to associate
Instead of granting permissions to individual users, it is preferable to set up roles or user groups for
allocating permissions to users. When users are assigned to roles or groups, they get access to all the
entities and features that their roles or groups permit. Managing permissions at the group level is
more efficient and less error-prone than allocating the very same set of permissions to users who
perform similar tasks in the system; it also makes creating new users faster. Roles typically represent
jobs, e.g. Manager, Clinical Worker, Systems Operator, whereas optional user groups represent
departments or working groups.
It is acceptable for administrative roles to manage users, roles and user groups by means of separate
directory management software. Note, however, that administrative roles only implement, from a
system perspective, policy decisions taken by more senior management.
USER PROFILES
Every BSS user has a user profile which (1) identifies the user, and (2) defines the permissions the
user is granted in the system. Modifying profile permissions is the privilege of administrative roles.
CUSTOMER MANAGEMENT
Large organizations have an extensive customer base and demand basic customer relationship
management operations. Based on the type of access to the BSS, biobank customers may be grouped
into the following two classes:
(1) Subscribed customer: the customer gets a user account and access to a specified range of
BSS features;
(2) Non-subscribed contractual partner: the customer is not allowed to access the BSS but
stands in a contractual relation with the operating organization, e.g. sells biological
samples, provides statistical analysis, orders samples etc.
In an ideal case, the BSS is able to manage both classes of customers. However, it is also acceptable if
the BSS relies on a CRM product for customer management features.
4.8 Search
Search is the process of locating records and finding data within the BSS based on user-defined
criteria. In the BSS, search is the primary means of accessing records.
4.10 Printing
The biobank must provide printing facilities which allow users to obtain printed copies of printable
entities, their metadata, reports, and other administrative information.
4.11 Audit
The BSS must provide features which allow managers and auditors to monitor the BSS to ensure that
it is used appropriately. The BSS should provide a number of standard reports capable of being
configured by authorized users, and should be flexible to enable ad hoc reports to be produced on
demand. The amount and complexity of reporting will be determined by organisational features
including the number of ongoing researches, the amount and type of samples, and the user base. For
smaller institutions, it may also be acceptable to treat search results as reports.
user authentication;
log;
backup and recovery;
data validation;
encryption.
SECURITY: LOG
A log is a record of actions taken in the BSS. This includes actions taken by users or administrative
roles, or actions initiated automatically by the BSS. The log shows whether business rules are being
followed and ensures that unauthorised activity can be identified and traced.
The volume of log information can become large if all actions are recorded. Consequently,
management may decide that selected actions need not be included in the log, or earlier log entries
should be deleted on a regular basis. Another solution is to move the BSS log onto secure offline
storage periodically.
The requirements that follow are in line with OECD regulations, which state that the biobank
[system must] provide traceability of data through a history of modifications (OECD 8.1.).
Regular automated backup and recovery can be provided by the BSS, by the database management
system supporting the BSS, or by a reliable third party software product.
SECURITY: ENCRYPTION
Encryption is the process of applying a complex transformation to an electronic object so that it
cannot be presented by an application in a readable or understandable form unless the
corresponding decryption transformation is applied. This can be used to secure electronic objects, by
use of transformations which require the use of secure electronic key codes.
USABILITY
Usability or ease-of-use requirements specify how BSS functions should be made available to users so
that it could minimize the time spent on performing tasks in the system, and reduce the amount of
training required to be able to perform these tasks.
PERFORMANCE
The performance of the system comprises the response times of the BSS to user interactions given a
specific platform and workload. The requirements provided in this section are subject to change
depending on the organizations business needs. Measures in angle brackets (< and >) should be
replaced by exact numbers specified by the organization. Measures written without brackets must be
interpreted as is.
SCALABILITY
A system is scalable when it is able to maintain its expected performance under reasonably
increasing workload without significant changes or redevelopment. Scalability is a design time
consideration and should be addressed accordingly. Measures in angle brackets (< and >) should
be replaced by exact numbers specified by the operating organization.
To ensure the smooth communication of BSS instances, the BSS should follow transaction standards
and be able to export records into an open or a well-documented proprietary format. Although data
export is a mandatory feature, the ability to import data is not compulsory because of the
unpredictable diversity of import formats. Exporting records does not affect the samples in the
system, i.e. they remain unchanged.
AUTHENTICATION
The process by which biological materials are characterised up to a defined level using
appropriate technology to establish a conclusive basis for accepting the material as genuine.
Source: OECD
BIOLOGICAL MATERIAL
All materials listed below: culturable organisms (e.g. micro-organisms, plant, animal and
human cells), replicable parts of these (e.g. genomes, plasmids, viruses, cDNAs), viable but
not yet culturable organisms, cells and tissues, as well as data bases containing molecular,
physiological and structural information relevant to these collections and related
bioinformatics.
Source: OECD
BIOLOGICAL RESOURCE CENTER/BIOBANK
Essential part of the infrastructure underpinning biotechnology consisting of service
providers and repositories of the living cells, genomes of organisms, and information relating
to heredity and the functions of biological systems.
Source: OECD
IDENTIFIABLE BIOLOGICAL MATERIAL
Biological materials which, alone or in combination with associated data, allow the
identification of the persons concerned either directly or through the use of a code. In the
latter case, the user of the biological materials may either:
a) Have access to the code: the materials are hereafter referred to as coded materials;
or
b) Not have access to the code, which is under the control of a third party: the material
are hereafter referred to as linked anonymized materials.
Source: REC(2006)4
INFORMED CONSENT
A process by which information concerning the donation process is presented to the donor
or donors next-of-kin with an opportunity for them to ask questions, after which specific
approval is documented.
Source: ISBER
INSTITUTIONAL REVIEW BOARD (IRB)
Any board, committee, or other group formally designated by an institution to review
biomedical research involving humans as subjects, to approve the initiation of and conduct
periodic review of such research.
NON-IDENTIFIABLE BIOLOGICAL MATERIAL
Referred to as unlinked anonymized material, are those biological materials which, alone or
in combination with associated data, do not allow, with reasonable efforts, the identification
of the persons concerned.
Source: REC(2006)4
SAFETY