Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Christian Ed Jornal, 3rd Ser 9 Spring 2012, Supplement, P S-30-S-44
Christian Ed Jornal, 3rd Ser 9 Spring 2012, Supplement, P S-30-S-44
Opening Prayer
Lord,
We confess that spiritual transformation will not come to us be-
cause I am speaking, or because participants are listening. It comes as
we allow You to test us, probe us, nurture us.
We know that God is omnipresent and so we know You are here.
The question is whether we attend to Your knocking as You move
among us. You will teach us to the extent we open the door to You.
Even so, Lord Jesus, come.
Enter in and have your way in our thoughts, attitudes, and
actions.
In Your name we ask these things. Amen.
Introduction
I would like to thank Mark Maddix and the Board for their kind invita-
tion to speak this year. Eugene Peterson has given us a grand look at the role
of Scripture in spiritual formation. The task given me is to relate the theme to
the field of Christian Education, and especially to the Christian academy.
YOUNT: The Role of Scripture in Christian Education, Session I S-31
[Slide #13]
The criticism of Christian education is its potential for programming
without power, lessons without life change, activities without spiritual im-
pact, techniques without transformation, machinery without mission, telling
more than equipping, and sharing more than discipling. The truth is that
there is nothing we can do, humanly speaking, to insure spiritual transforma-
tion in our learners, for it is the Spirit who moves like the wind to quicken
hearts and renew minds. Whenever we place more emphasis on our educa-
tion programs, course syllabi, and instructional processes than on a mystical,
existential encounter with the Lord, God writes Ichabod! (1 Sam 4:21) over
our work. In that case, even the best of programs and processes die. Our plan-
ning ought to support rather than obstruct growth in the Lord.
Spiritual Formation pushes us toward an emphasis of the quickening of
the Holy Spirit that makes the process of education truly Christ-forming.
The field of Christian education, like seminary education in general, helps us
avoid the potholes in the road of spiritual growth. Helps us avoid mistakes
that hinder spiritual growth. Helps us proactively plan better approaches
to creating an environment in which spiritual formation occurs. In that
context, Scripture forms the structural steel for such attempts at program
engineering.
[Slide #14]
Consider a boy flying a kite. He holds the string anchoring the kite
against the wind, which lifts the kite into the air. Scripture is the String, the
Anchor, which holds the kite of spiritual growth firmly against the Wind. And
it is the Wind, the Spirit of God, which lifts the kite into the heavens. Both
String and Wind are necessary, for without the string, the kite merely flutters
and falls. And without the wind, the kite lays lifeless on the ground (Yount,
1979/1981).
[Slide #15]
How did God create us to learn of Him? What are the elements that de-
fine our learning and growth as divinely created human beings living in a ma-
terial world? How is Scripture the structural steel of the process? We begin at
the beginning, with God Himself.
[Slide #16]
Then God said, wLet us make man in our image . . . (Gen 1:26a).
So God created man in his own image . . . male and female he created
them . . . in His image (Gen 1:27).
S-36 Christian Education Journal
. . . the Lord God formed the man from the dust of the ground and
breathed into his nostrils the breath of life, and the man became a living be-
ing. Gen 2:7.
Our bodies are made up of cells, created for specific functions . . . blood,
bone, muscle, connective tissue, and a nervous system that ties all of the sub-
systems together in harmony.
[Slide #17]
The brain is also made of cells, but the cells of the brain, called neurons,
have the special ability, unlike any other cells in the body, to connect together
in networks more complex than we can imagine.
The brain is the materialistic anchor for all human thought, emotion,
will, language, religion, faith, and connection with God. Destroy the material
brain and we cease to exist in this material world.
[Slide #18]
The brain and body are co-dependent. Deprive the body of certain nutri-
ents, and brain function declines. Food, drink, and drugs have a direct impact
on brain functionin both good and bad ways. Room temperature, hydra-
tion and blood pH levels, hormones, and vitamin deficienciesthe state of
the body affects the brain.
In turn, the brain automatically monitors body stateshunger, thirst, fa-
tigueand controls the means by which proper states are maintained
breathing, digestion, body temperature, and every other function of our
bodies.
God created us as a materialistic brain-body interaction. This we share
with every other living creature.
[Slide #19]
But we also share some of the characteristics of God Himself. He made
us in His own image. God has a will. God thinks. He emotes. He acts. But He
has no brain. We have a brain, but we also think, emote, and act. We associate
higher-level functionsthe will, reason, emotion, and skillful actionto the
mind.
You notice in the diagram a black gap between brain and mind. This
gap is the unknown divide between neural events and mental events. Neural
events are electrical impulses firing across synapses (gaps) between dendrites
YOUNT: The Role o f Scripture in Christian Education, Session I S-37
(brain cell receivers) and axons (brain cell transmitters) according to the laws
of Newtonian physics. Mental events are conscious thoughts of self and the
world possess weight, volume or physical location. They are now believed to
occur in accordance with complex laws of probabilities described by quan-
turn physics which we will not take time to attempt to describe here.
[Slide #20]
Materialists equate the mind with the brain. They insist that the notion
of a mental reality, personal consciousnessseparate from the material
brainis fantasy. But the discoveries of the last 20 years has pushed even die-
hard scientists to admit that the brain operates in mind-like ways, beyond the
laws of biology. (I suppose this is as close as a scientist can come to saying
super-natural)
[Slide #21]
Remaining true to their wiring as materialists, they use terms like
epiphenomenalism (Robinson, 2011) and supervenience (Rickies, 2006) to
force mind-like realities, that is the mind is dependent on the physical brain,
to impose their mind into their self-imposed materialistic box.
[Slide #22]
Christian theologians and some philosophers, including the great
philosopher-psychologist William James of the late 1800s, see a distinction
between material brain and immaterial mind. In fact, James ideas, rejected by
Newtonian scientists, are being reconsidered from the perspective of quan-
turn mechanics. For us, the person is a living soul, a conscious mind, wrapped
in the dust of the ground for life in a material world, but who survives the
death of body and brain (Bulkeley, 2005).
[Slide #23]
Naturalistic scientists approach the gap from the material brain-side.
Philosophers and theologians approach the gap from the psychological and
spiritual mind-side. To this day, the gap has not been bridged in any mean-
ingful way. One thing is sure from recent scientific discoveries: a neural event
is not a mental event. The materialistic, deterministic, Newtonian view of the
brain, held as true for more than a hundred years, cannot survive contempo-
rary findings. The old wineskin of dogmatic materialism has been burst open
by the new wine of neuroscience, to which we turn our attention.
[Slide #24]
Just as we saw a reciprocal relationship between body and brain, we also
find a reciprocal relationship between brain and mind. The neural networks
of the brain 100 billion neurons and 1000 trillion connectionssupport all
human thought: language, personality, reason, and religion.
The established dogma of brain science for 100 years prior to the 1990s
declared that the brain is essentially fixed, like the circuit boards in an elec-
tronic calculator, by age 6. Further, that new brain cells are not created after
S-38 Christian Education Journal
that time, and finally that the mind as we commonly use the term does not
exist. Just fifteen years later, by the mid 2000s, all three of these scientific cer-
tainties had fallen in the face of overwhelming evidence.
First, brains are never fixed, but remain plasticthey continue to
rewire themselves as long as we live. This characteristic is called neuro-
plasticity.
Second, brain cells are created as long as we live, a characteristic called
neurogenesis.
Third, and most startling, is that the mechanism by which the brain is re-
wired is not genetic code, or hormones, but mental focus. We are not reli-
gious or heterosexual because of genetic code, as proclaimed by Time maga-
zine in 2004 (Kluger, Chu, Liston, Sieger, & Williams, 2004). Rather, our
brains automatically re-wire themselves to support whatever we give our at-
tention too. What we choose to do, choose to think, and choose to embrace,
we become (Shwartz & Begley, 2002; Yount, 2010). This tenet, established by
neuroscientists using sophisticated brain imaging technology, reflects
Solomons wisdom recorded 3000 years ago: for as [a man] thinks within
himself, so he is (Pr 23:7).
[Slide #25]
Researchers have found strong parallels between psychological states
(mind) and physical (brain) structures. The three higher order systems of ed-
ucational psychology are represented in brain circuitry, where we find physi-
cally separate networks for cognitive processes (memory, analysis, and rea-
soning), affective processes (emotions), and psychomotor skills.
Memories are not stored intact and unified, but are processed and dis-
tributed among rational, emotional, and physical areas of the brain. When we
remember, our brains reconstruct memories from these disparate areas.
That is why educators have long advocated, on the basis of classroom ex-
perience, hands-on projects (a physical component of learning) and a posi-
tive, personally affirming climate (an affective component of learning) as
powerful adjuncts to lecture, discussion, and Q&A (the cognitive component
to learning. This is true for all learners, but especially for children.
[Slide #26]
There is yet another domain of human nature, and that is the spiri-
tual. Just as there is a demarcation between brain (material) and mind (im-
material), so there is a demarcation between mind (natural) and spirit
(supernatural).
YOUNT: The Role o f Scripture in Christian Education, Session I S-39
[Slide #27]
I need to be careful here with definitions. Secular culture uses spiritual
to express deep emotional experiences, such as the breath-taking beauty of a
sunset or the deep solace one finds in music or poetry. Drug highs have been
described as spiritual experiences, as well as the euphoria experienced by long
distance runners. The former experiences are emotional, the latter physical,
but both create chemical reactions in the brain that produce a sense of
aboveness. This is a natural form of spirituality, which we might designate
with a lower case as. Doctoral students researching issues of spiritual growth
can be misled by psychological instruments that measure human spirituality,
because these tests usually target alittles forms.
When God breathed life into our flesh, we became a living soul
(KJV)or being (NIV)able to communicate with Him. God is Spirit,
and our relationship with Him is spirituala relationship that is above na-
ture, supernatural a reality unknown to natural man (1 Cor 2:14). It is this
capital S Spirit that we next turn our attention.
[Slide #28]
From the very beginning God spoke to the man and woman. Mind to
mind, and gave us commands and instructions concerning the kind of
unique mental focus He wanted us to have. He is jealous for us to have His
perspective, because only that moves us beyond mere biological existence in a
material world (bios) into his own quality of life (zoay).
The first commandment of the Golden Ten is to have no other gods but
the Lord God. When our focus is on Him and His Word, our brains re-wire
themselves to support the kinds of automatic responses that produce lives
above mere existence, lives with purpose and meaning beyond ourselves, lives
that continue beyond the death of our material brains.
[Slide #29]
Moses declared this focus millennia ago. Listen for the words that speak
of mental focus and attention: And now, O Israel, what does the Lord your
God ask of you but to fear the Lord your God (that is, to live in His presence
with holy reverence, Message), to walk in all his ways (that is, to live out
what He commands, Message), to love him, to serve the Lord your God with
all your heart (devotion) and with all your soul (life, strength), and to observe
(that isy put into action) the Lord's commands and decrees that I am giving
you today for your own good? (Dt 10:12-13, NIV).
Notice the key verbs: to fear, to walk, to love, to serve, to observe.
These words speak of mental focus and attention that leads to our own
good. This requires more than listening to sermons or lectures, more than
mere reading, more than memorizing words. It requires mental focus, atten-
tionwhat the Bible calls meditationon God and His Word and ways.
S-40 Christian Education Journal
The tangible result of this immaterial mental focus and supernatural spiritual
focus is a re-wiring of our material brains to think more effectively in parallel
with Gods intention.
Please take note of this: I am not equating brain re-wiring with our spir-
itual connection with God as some are doing today. Neurotheology is a new
field of study that attempts to redefine God and all religion as the product of
brain function. This is an untenable position since God exists apart from the
electro-chemical circuits inside our heads. We are His creation; He is not
ours. He made us to have relationship with Him. Part of His creative genius
has just recently come to light: He created us to re-wire our material brains in
line with His Word and will, and so live according to His ways in this material
world and in heaven after we die and beyond.
The coherent communication we receive from God is called revelation,
and the most intensive way we focus our attention on God is through prayer.
The Lord spoke, Mind to mind, and chosen writers recorded the
message.
Scripture defines itself, second, as . . .
[Slide #35]
Sacred. We do not have the freedom to make the Scripture broader (in-
eluding more than intended) or narrower (excluding what it does not ex-
pressly exclude).
Do not add to what I command you and do not subtract from it, but
keep the commands of the Lord your God that I give you. Deut 4:2
Every word of God is flawless; he is a shield to those who take refuge in
him. Do not add to his words, or he will rebuke you and prove you a liar.
Prov 30:5-6
Scripture defines itself, third, as . . .
[Slide #36]
Eternal truth.
Your Word, O Lord, is eternal; it stands firm in the heavens (Ps 119:89).
The word of God stands forever (Isa 40:8).
My words will never pass away (Mt 24:35).
But the word of the Lord stands forever (1 Pe 1:25).
Scripture defines itself, fourth, as . . .
[Slide #37]
Powerful in its influence.
I will make my words in your mouth a fire and these people the wood it
consumes. (Jer 5:14).
The gospel. . . is the power of God for salvation of everyone who be-
Heves (Rom 1:16).
For the word of God is living and active. Sharper than any double-edged
sword, it penetrates even to dividing soul and spirit, joints and marrow; it
judges the thoughts and attitudes of the heart. (Heb 4:12).
Scripture defines itself, fifth, as . . .
[Slide #38]
Written for a purpose. We return to Johns declaration of the purpose of
Scripture:
But these are written that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the
Son of God, and that by believing you may have life in his name ( Jn 20:31).
For everything that was written in the past was written to teach us, so
that through endurance and the encouragement of the Scriptures we might
have hope (Rom 15:4).
These things happened to them as examples and were written down as
warnings for us (1 Cor 10:11).
I write these things . . . so that you may know that you have eternal life
(1 Jn 5:13).
YOUNT: The Role o f Scripture in Christian Education, Session I S-43
[Slide #39]
The members of this organization who return year after year have a pas-
sion beyond teacher-telling and preacher-proclaiming. We have been called
to the systematic engagement of learners with Scripture, and through Scrip-
ture, to the One Scripture revealsengagement head, heart, and hand be-
cause God created us to focus on truth, zeal, and skill, and created our brains
to faithfully re-wire those areas with Him. It is He who transforms us as we
renew our minds in Him (Rom 12:2).
Further, we Christian educators in our various callings engage human
beings from birth to death, from cradle to grave, because the brain never
stops changing. We take Scripture seriously, because it is the voice of God,
codified in written form, speaking to every area of life.
This Scriptural focus applies not only to the content of our courses, but
to methodology as well. What good is it to understand Jesus command to
love your enemies when teachers publicly belittle a student who disagrees
with them? Of what value is an award-winning lecture on patience if lecturers
fuss and fume over the interruptions of students who have questions? There
is a great difference between teaching the Bible and teaching biblically, be-
tween believing the Bible, and living biblically.
Having said that, we also recognize that there is very little in Scripture
about sanitizing cribs, arranging preschool rooms, organizing childrens
camps, supervising youth mission trips, or advertising prayer breakfasts.
There is nothing in Scripture concerning the application of chi-square, or
how to learn a foreign language, or write a teaching plan or improve the effi-
ciency of a church office. For these areas of equipping, we draw on other
sources, sources that speak directly to who we are and how we learn.
[Slide #40]
We will discuss these sources tomorrow in a session entitled Christian
Education as Scriptural Lifer Because Christian education speaks to the whole
man, over the whole lifespan, we will use our diagram to suggest how discov-
eries from the sciences inform the process of helping learners to grow up
into Him, Who is the Head, even Christ (Eph 4:15). We will also discuss sev-
eral improper ways Scripture is usedways that relate more to personal
power than spiritual formation.
[Slide #41]
REFERENCES
Bulkeley, K. (2005) Soul, psyche, brain: New mind science. New York, NY: Palgrave
directions in the study o f religion and brain- Macmillian.
S-44 Christian Education Journal
Kluger, J., Chu, J., Liston, B, Sieger, M., and Yount, W.R. (1981). The disciplers handbook:
Williams, D. (2004, October 25). Religion: Is From transmitting lessons to transforming lives
God in our genes? Time Magazine. Retrieved in Sunday school 9th ed. Falls Church, VA:
from http://www.time.com/time/magazine Author.
/article/0,9171,995465, OO.html#ixzz 1k7ML6jqn
---------- (2010). Created to learn: A Christian
Newberg, A. & Waldman, M. (2010). How God teacher's introduction to educational psychol-
changes your brain: Breakthrough findings from ogy. 2nd. Ed. Nashville, TN: B & H Academic.
a leading neuroscientist. New York, NY: Ballen-
tine Books.
Rickies, D. (2006). Supervenience and deter- 1The diagrams which were used to illustrate
mination. In Internet Encyclopedia ofPhiloso- this presentation can be downloaded from
phy. Retrieved from http://www.iep.utm.edu the NAPCE website in the resources area.
/superven/. www.napce.org
As an ATLAS user, you may print, download, or send articles for individual use
according to fair use as defined by U.S. and international copyright law and as
otherwise authorized under your respective ATLAS subscriber agreement.
No content may be copied or emailed to multiple sites or publicly posted without the
copyright holder(sV express written permission. Any use, decompiling,
reproduction, or distribution of this journal in excess of fair use provisions may be a
violation of copyright law.
This journal is made available to you through the ATLAS collection with permission
from the copyright holder( s). The copyright holder for an entire issue of ajournai
typically is the journal owner, who also may own the copyright in each article. However,
for certain articles, the author of the article may maintain the copyright in the article.
Please contact the copyright holder(s) to request permission to use an article or specific
work for any use not covered by the fair use provisions of the copyright laws or covered
by your respective ATLAS subscriber agreement. For information regarding the
copyright holder(s), please refer to the copyright information in the journal, if available,
or contact ATLA to request contact information for the copyright holder(s).
About ATLAS:
The design and final form of this electronic document is the property of the American
Theological Library Association.