Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Search For FDA Guidance Documents - The Sourcing and Processing of Gelatin To Reduce The Potential Risk Posed by Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy (BSE
Search For FDA Guidance Documents - The Sourcing and Processing of Gelatin To Reduce The Potential Risk Posed by Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy (BSE
htm
Introduction - FDA has adopted Good Guidance Practices (GGPs), which set forth the
agency's policies and procedures for the development, issuance, and use of guidance
documents (62 FR 8961, February 27, 1997). This guidance is issued as Level 1
guidance consistent with GGPs. The agency is soliciting public comment but is
implementing this guidance immediately because of public health concerns related to
the use of gelatin. This guidance document represents the agency's current thinking
on reducing the potential risk of transmission of BSE related to the use of gelatin in
FDA-regulated products for human use. It does not create or confer any rights for or
on any person and does not operate to bind FDA or the public. An alternative
approach may be used if such approach satisfies the requirements of the applicable
statutes, regulations, or both.
Purpose - This guidance document addresses the safety of gelatin as it relates to the
potential risk posed by BSE in FDA-regulated products for human use. It is intended
to provide guidance to industry concerning the sourcing and processing of gelatin
used in FDA-regulated products. In developing this proposed guidance, FDA
considered various information, including the conclusions of the Transmissible
Spongiform Encephalopathies (TSEs) Advisory Committee in a meeting on April
23-24, 1997. The committee reviewed data on the sourcing and processing of
materials used to make gelatin as well as data from an experimental study on the
effect of gelatin processing on the infectivity of a spongiform agent.
Background - Over the last several years, FDA has provided guidance to
manufacturers and importers of FDA-regulated products regarding products
1 of 12 03/03/2017 16:36
Search for FDA Guidance Documents > The Sourcing and Processing ... https://www.fda.gov/RegulatoryInformation/Guidances/ucm125182.htm
The British BSE epidemic is thought to have resulted from the practice of adding
rendered animal tissue to cattle feed. Early on, some evidence suggested the
potential for cross-species transmission of TSEs (rare, fatal neurological diseases
such as scrapie in sheep and Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease in humans). Although it was
not known whether BSE could be transmitted from contaminated cattle to humans,
FDA believed it prudent to alert manufacturers to this potential risk. Since 1992, FDA
has sent a number of letters to manufacturers of FDA-regulated products providing
guidance on the use of bovine materials from BSE countries (see Appendix A for a
chronology of FDA's guidance to the industry).
Recent Review of Gelatin Guidance - In 1996, FDA decided to review its previous
guidance on the use of gelatin because of new information suggesting that BSE may
be transmissible to humans and because of updated data from the study on the effect
of gelatin processing on infectivity.
During the April 1997 meeting of the TSE advisory committee, information on industry
practices and the results of the research study were presented. The study involved
mouse brain tissue that had been infected with scrapie (as a BSE model).1 The tissue
was treated with lime or with acid according to gelatin manufacturing conditions.
Neither the acid nor the lime treatment completely inactivated the infectious agent. A
second infectivity study is due to be completed in late 1997 or early 1998.
The advisory committee members stated opinions on questions raised by FDA and
were polled on their answers to the final question, "Does current scientific evidence
justify continuing to exempt gelatin from restrictions recommended by FDA for other
bovine-derived materials from BSE countries?" Ten of the 14 members responded
"no"or a "qualified no"to this question (see Appendix B for a summary of the advisory
committee meeting).
2 of 12 03/03/2017 16:36
Search for FDA Guidance Documents > The Sourcing and Processing ... https://www.fda.gov/RegulatoryInformation/Guidances/ucm125182.htm
acceptability of gelatin for use in FDA-regulated products intended for human use:
1. In order to ensure that all parties in the distribution chain take appropriate
responsibility, importers, manufacturers, and suppliers should determine the
tissue, species, and country source of all materials to be used in processing
gelatin for human use.
2. Bones and hides from cattle that shows signs of neurological disease, from any
source country, should not be used as raw material for the manufacture of
gelatin.
3. Gelatin produced from bones and hides obtained from cattle residing in, or
originating from, countries reporting BSE or from countries that do not meet the
latest BSE-related standards of the Office International des Epizooties (OIE)2
(see Appendix C) should not be used either in injectable, ophthalmic, or
implanted FDA-regulated products, or in their manufacture.
4. At this time, there does not appear to be a basis for objection to the use of gelatin
in FDA-regulated products for oral consumption and cosmetic use by humans
when the gelatin is produced from bones obtained from cattle residing in, or
originating from, BSE countries, if the cattle come from BSE-free herds and if the
slaughterhouse removes the heads, spines, and spinal cords directly after
slaughter. Nor does there appear to be a basis for objection to gelatin for oral
consumption and cosmetic use which is produced from bones from countries
which have not reported BSE but which fail to meet OIE standards if the
slaughterhouse removes the heads, spine, and spinal cords after slaughter.
Gelatin processors should ensure that slaughterhouses that supply bovine bones
for gelatin production remove heads, spines, and spinal cords as the first
procedure following slaughter.
5. At this time, there does not appear to be a basis for objection to the use of gelatin
produced from bovine hides, from any source country, in FDA-regulated products
for oral consumption and cosmetic use by humans use if processors ensure that
the bovine hides have not been contaminated with brain, spinal cord, or ocular
tissues of cattle residing in, or originating from, BSE countries and if they exclude
hides from cattle that have signs of neurological disease (see #2).
6. At this time, there does not appear to be a basis for objection to the use of gelatin
produced from bovine hides and bones in FDA-regulated products for human use
if the gelatin is produced from U.S.-derived raw materials or from cattle born,
raised, and slaughtered in other countries that have no reported BSE cases and
that meet OIE BSE standards.
7. At this time, there does not appear to be a basis for objection to the use of gelatin
produced from porcine skins, from any source country, in FDA-regulated
products for human use. Processors should ensure that gelatin made from
porcine skins is not cross-contaminated with bovine materials originating from
BSE countries or from countries that do not meet OIE standards.
APPENDIX A
CHRONOLOGY OF FDA'S BSE-RELATED GUIDANCE/REGULATION
3 of 12 03/03/2017 16:36
Search for FDA Guidance Documents > The Sourcing and Processing ... https://www.fda.gov/RegulatoryInformation/Guidances/ucm125182.htm
any bovine or ovine material (generally neural or glandular) used in their products.
FDA also suggested that each manufacturer develop a plan "to assure, with a high
degree of certainty,"that such materials are not from BSE-countries, as identified
by the U.S. Department of Agriculture's Animal and Plant Health Inspection
Service, or from scrapie-infected sheep flocks, either foreign or domestic (9 CFR
94.18).
In a December 17, 1993, letter to manufacturers of drugs, biologics, and medical
devices, FDA recommended against the use of bovine-derived materials from
cattle which have resided in, or originated from, BSE countries (59 FR 44592) .
FDA recommended that manufacturers: a) identify bovine-derived materials in the
product and identify all countries where the animals used to produce the material
have lived; b) maintain traceable records for each lot of bovine material and for
each lot of FDA-regulated product using these materials; c) document the country
of origin of the live animal source of any bovine-derived materials used in the
manufacture of the regulated product; and d) maintain copies of the record
identified above for FDA-regulated products manufactured using bovine-derived
materials at foreign sites or by the foreign manufacturers.
On July 1, 1994, Ms. Linda Suydam, then Interim Deputy Commissioner for
Operations, sent letters to counsel representing the Gelatin Manufacturers
Association (GMA) and the Gelatin Manufacturers of America (GMIA) which stated
that, after reviewing available scientific information, "FDA does not object to the
use of bovine-derived materials from BSE-countries in the manufacture of
pharmaceutical grade gelatin at this time."The agency also stated that, "We
continue to consider it prudent, however, to obtain such materials from non
BSE-countries whenever practical, and to maintain records as to the sources of the
bovine materials used to manufacture pharmaceutical grade gelatin."
FDA published a notice in the Federal Register of August 29, 1994, entitled,
"Bovine-Derived Materials; Agency Letters to Manufacturers of FDA-regulated
Products"(59 FR 44592). The notice published letters to Manufacturers of Dietary
Supplements (November 9, 1992), Manufacturers of FDA-Regulated Products
(December 17, 1993), Manufacturers of FDA-regulated Products for Animals
(August 17, 1994), and to Manufacturers and Importers of Dietary Supplements
and of Cosmetics (August 17, 1994). The letter to manufacturers and importers of
dietary supplements and cosmetics stated, "The FDA is recommending that firms
that manufacture or import dietary supplements and cosmetics containing specific
bovine tissues...ensure that such tissues do not come from cattle born, raised, or
slaughtered in countries where bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) exists
(BSE-countries)."The Agency also stated, "At this time, FDA is not extending the
recommendation in this letter to dairy products and gelatin, because available
evidence does not suggest transmission via these foods."
In October 19, 1995, FDA issued Import Alert 17-04 (replacing the 1992 Import
Bulletin and revising an alert issued July 18, 1995) calling for the detention, without
examination, of bulk shipments of high-risk bovine tissues and tissue-derived
ingredients from the United Kingdom, France, Ireland, Oman, Switzerland, and
Portugal.
In March 1996, the British government announced that new information from the
Spongiform Encephalopathy Advisory Committee (SEAC) suggested a possible
relationship between BSE and 10 cases of a newly identified form of CJD.4 On
May 9, 1996, FDA sent letters to inform the industry of the announcement by the
British government and to reiterate the Agency's concerns on this issue. In these
4 of 12 03/03/2017 16:36
Search for FDA Guidance Documents > The Sourcing and Processing ... https://www.fda.gov/RegulatoryInformation/Guidances/ucm125182.htm
letters, FDA strongly reiterated its recommendations that firms that manufacture or
import FDA-regulated products take whatever steps necessary to assure
themselves and the public that bovine-derived ingredients do not come from cattle,
born, raised, or slaughtered in countries that have reported BSE.
In May 21, 1996, letters to counsel to the GMA and GMIA, Dr. Michael A.
Friedman, Deputy Commissioner for Operations stated that, "Although we continue
to review scientific information on animal and human transmissible spongiform
encephalopathies related to FDA-regulated products, we have no new knowledge,
at this time, to cause us to change our position on gelatin as stated in those
letters." However, FDA staff began review of final data from the mouse study
whose preliminary data FDA had reviewed in deciding that gelatin from BSE
countries was acceptable in FDA-regulated products.
On June 5, 1997, FDA published in the Federal Register a document entitled,
"Substances Prohibited From Use in Animal Food or Feed; Animal Proteins
Prohibited in Ruminant Feed; Final Rule (62 FR 30936). This final rule excludes
domestic gelatin from the definition of animal proteins prohibited in ruminant feed.
In fact, U.S. manufacturers do not add gelatin--a poor source of protein--as a
protein supplement to animal feed. (Imported gelatin and other bovine-derived
products from BSE countries intended for animal use are banned by
USDA/APHIS).
APPENDIX B
SUMMARY OF TSE ADVISORY COMMITTEE MEETING
On April 23-24, 1997, FDA held a public meeting of the Transmissible Spongiform
Encephalopathies Advisory Committee to help FDA assess the safety of imported and
domestic gelatin and gelatin by-products in FDA-regulated products with regard to the
risk posed by bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE). Following presentations on
gelatin sourcing and processing, risk assessment, process validation, and BSE's
infectivity, panel members were asked the following:
5 of 12 03/03/2017 16:36
Search for FDA Guidance Documents > The Sourcing and Processing ... https://www.fda.gov/RegulatoryInformation/Guidances/ucm125182.htm
APPENDIX C
International Animal Health Code
Special Edition 1997
Chapter 3.2.13.
Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy
(BSE)
Article 3.2.13.1.
The BSE status of a country can only be determined by continuous surveillance and
monitoring. The minimum requirements for effective surveillance are:
6 of 12 03/03/2017 16:36
Search for FDA Guidance Documents > The Sourcing and Processing ... https://www.fda.gov/RegulatoryInformation/Guidances/ucm125182.htm
Article 3.2.13.2.
3. a. there has been no clinical case of BSE, the disease is notifiable, and an
effective and continuous surveillance and monitoring system is practised, as
described in Article 3.2.13.1. point 3) and 4); or
b. all cases of BSE have been clearly demonstrated to originate directly from
importation of live cattle originating from BSE infected countries, provided
that the disease is made notifiable and suspect animals are slaughtered,
investigated and, if disease is confirmed, completely destroyed and an
effective and continuous surveillance and monitoring system is practised, as
described in Article 3.2.13.1. points 3) and 4); or
c. BSE has been eradicated (under study).
Article 3.2.13.3.
Article 3.2.13.4.
When importing from countries with low incidence of BSE, Veterinary Administrations
7 of 12 03/03/2017 16:36
Search for FDA Guidance Documents > The Sourcing and Processing ... https://www.fda.gov/RegulatoryInformation/Guidances/ucm125182.htm
should require:
for cattle
Article 3.2.13.5.
for cattle
1. either were born after the date on which an effective ban on the use of ruminant
meat-and-bone meal in feed for ruminants has been effectively enforced; or
2. were born, raised and had remained in a herd in which no case of BSE had ever
been confirmed, and which contains only cattle born on the farm or coming from
a herd of equal status; and
3. have never been fed ruminant meat-and-bone meal.
Article 3.2.13.6.
for fresh meat (bone-in or deboned) and meat products from cattle
8 of 12 03/03/2017 16:36
Search for FDA Guidance Documents > The Sourcing and Processing ... https://www.fda.gov/RegulatoryInformation/Guidances/ucm125182.htm
5. the meat products do not contain brain, eyes, spinal cord or distal ileum from
cattle over six months of age which were born before the date on which the feed
ban referred to in paragraph 5) of Article 3.2.13.4. was effectively enforced.
Article 3.2.13.7.
When importing from countries with high incidence of BSE, Veterinary Administration
should require:
1. the tissues listed in Article 3.2.13.12. are removed from all cattle at slaughter and
destroyed;
2. the cattle from which the meat originates:
a. were born after the date on which a ban on the use of ruminant
meat-and-bone meal in feed for ruminants has been effectively enforced; or
b. were born and had only been kept in herds in which no case of BSE had
been recorded; and
c. have never been fed ruminant meat-and-bone meal.
Article 3.2.13.8.
Article 3.2.13.9.
9 of 12 03/03/2017 16:36
Search for FDA Guidance Documents > The Sourcing and Processing ... https://www.fda.gov/RegulatoryInformation/Guidances/ucm125182.htm
Article 3.2.13.10.
Article 3.2.13.11.
Meat-and-bone meal containing any ruminant protein which originates from countries
with a high incidence of BSE, should not be traded between countries.
Meat-and-bone meal containing any ruminant protein which originates from countries
with a low incidence of BSE, should not be traded between countries for use in
ruminant feed. For other uses, it should have been processed in plants which are
approved and regularly controlled by the Veterinary Administration following validation
that each plant can achieve the processing parameters described in Appendix
4.3.3.1.
Article 3.2.13.12.
Bovine brains, eyes, spinal cord, tonsils, thymus, spleen and distal ileum (tissues
under study) and protein products derived from them from cattle over six months of
age originating from countries with a high incidence of BSE should not be traded
between countries.
Bovine brains, eyes, spinal cord and distal ileum (tissues under study) and protein
products derived from them from cattle over six months of age which originate from
countries with a low incidence of BSE and were born before the date on which the
feed ban referred to in point 5) of Article 3.2.13.4. was effectively enforced, should not
be traded between countries, unless they comply with the provisions of Article
3.2.13.11.
Article 3.2.13.13.
10 of 12 03/03/2017 16:36
Search for FDA Guidance Documents > The Sourcing and Processing ... https://www.fda.gov/RegulatoryInformation/Guidances/ucm125182.htm
Careful selection of source materials is the best way to ensure maximum safety of
ingredients or reagents of bovine origin used in the manufacture of medicinal
products.
Countries wishing to import bovine materials for such purposes should therefore
consider the following factors:
1. the BSE status of the country and herd(s) where the animals have been kept, as
determined under the provisions of Article 3.2.13.1. and Article 3.2.13.2.;
2. the age of the donor animals;
3. the tissues required and whether or not they will be pooled samples or derived
from a single animal.
Additional factors may be considered in assessing the risk from BSE, i.e.:
1
Shrieber, R. 1997. Presentation to the FDA Transmissible Spongiform
Encephalopathy Advisory Committee, April 23, 1997. Transcript is available in hard
copy or on disk from Freedom of Information, HFI-35, Food and Drug Administration,
Rockville, MD 20857.
2
Office International des Epizooties. 1997. International Animal Health Code, Special
Edition, Chapter 3.2.13. pp. 267-274, Paris.
************
11 of 12 03/03/2017 16:36
Search for FDA Guidance Documents > The Sourcing and Processing ... https://www.fda.gov/RegulatoryInformation/Guidances/ucm125182.htm
12 of 12 03/03/2017 16:36