Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Temperature Dependency of Wave Propagation Velocity in MV Power Cable
Temperature Dependency of Wave Propagation Velocity in MV Power Cable
Abstract: Propagation velocity of high frequency signals, e.g. from partial discharge, is a
vital parameter for time domain power cable diagnostic techniques. The propagation
velocity is mainly dependent on the permittivity of the insulation material, which can be
affected by external parameters like temperature or water ingress. This paper focuses on
the influence of temperature on the propagation velocity in medium voltage (MV) cables.
Laboratory scale tests are performed for both PILC and XLPE cable. Test results show
that the high frequency signal propagation velocity for XLPE will increase with the
temperature rise while PILC has opposite behaviour. The variation of propagation velocity
of XLPE is confirmed by data of a power cable subjected to strong load cycling monitored
over eight months.
1861
OF5-01
Amplitude [V]
labeled as T1 and T2. Letters A-G indicate the 0
reflection points of TDR measurements shown 37.3C,27.0C
later in Figure 3. Figure 2 shows the connector -0.05 48.7C,31.8C
types. Connector type 3 was improvised for the -0.1
present measurements. The cable earth screen
connections were realized with short wires parallel -0.15
to the connectors for all types. -0.2
0.95 1 1.05 1.1
2.2 Test results Time [s]
Amplitude [V]
between coaxial cable and power cable (A), the 5
cable connectors (B-F) and the open far end (G). 0.2 14.4C,12.0C
Reflection C (from connector type 1), E (from 20.4C,17.0C
connector type 2) and G (from open end) are 0 27.6C,21.9C
zoomed in and shown in Figure 4. It is qualitatively 37.3C,27.0C
observed that with the increase of temperature, the 48.7C,31.8C
propagation time decreases, indicating that the -0.2
propagation velocity has increased. 1.3 1.35 1.4 1.45 1.5
Time [s]
(c)
10 10.8C,9.0C
8 20.8C,17.4C Figure 4: (a) depicts reflection C from connector 1;
30.9 C,23.4 C (b) shows reflection E from connector 2 and (c)
Amplitude [V]
1862
OF5-01
midpoint of the insulation, Table 1. The outdoor reflection from the far end. This might be caused
temperature is used since the propagation time by the indoor and outdoor temperature difference
between the connector 1 and open far end will be and lower signal to noise ratio. Directly past this
used for analysis in order to exclude the indoor peak, structures arise which travelled additional
and outdoor temperature difference. Tjx is the length along a not heated part. Later also the
jacket temperature of the XLPE cable, and Tdx is heated part is included resulting in a steeper time
the temperature at the middle of insulation of the shift again.
XLPE cable; t is the heating time according to
Figure 5.
0 12
1
-2 2 10
15
3
-4 8
4
amplitude [V]
-6 6
10 -8 4
T [C]
-10 2
5 -12 0
-14 -2
-16 -4
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5
0 time [s]
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3
t [h]
Figure 6: Time shift of reflection patterns of XLPE
Figure 5: Derived temperature difference between cable at different temperatures
the midpoint of XLPE insulation and the outer
jacket surface for single core XLPE cable 3 LABORATORY TEST ON PILC CABLE
1863
OF5-01
Amplitude [V]
0.6 PILC:23.5C XLPE:24.0C
result is shown in Figure 8. In the pattern, the
injected pulse is located around 2.1 s. The first 0.4
PILC:28.1C XLPE:24.9C
reflection near 2.6 s is from the coaxial cable PILC:33.1C XLPE:25.8C
connection to the power cable; the reflection 0.2 PILC:38.2C XLPE:26.1C
around 4.1 s arises from the transition joint, and PILC:43.0C XLPE:27.3C
the reflection around 5 s from the open end. The 0
PILC:48.1C XLPE:28.8C
later reflections are secondary or higher order 4.85 4.9 4.95 5 5.05 5.1 5.15
reflections. The transition joint reflection and the far Time [s]
end reflection are depicted enlarged in Figure 9. It
is observed that with the increase of temperature, (b)
the propagation time increases, indicating a lower
propagation velocity, which is opposite to the Figure 9: (a) enlargement of reflection from PILC
observations for XLPE insulation. to XLPE transition joint; (b) enlargement of
reflection from open end
6 PILC:23.5C XLPE:24.0C
3.3 Analysis
PILC:28.1C XLPE:24.9C
4
PILC:33.1 C XLPE:25.8 C Insulation temperature conversion: Applying a
PILC:38.2C XLPE:26.1C similar approach as for the XLPE cable heating
PILC:43.0C XLPE:27.3C test, the temperature difference between the
Amplitude [V]
2
PILC:48.1C XLPE:28.8C insulation midpoint and jacket of PILC cable is
shown in Figure 10. The measured outer jacket
0 temperature for PILC cable is converted to
temperature at the midpoint of the paper insulation
-2 as shown in Table 2.
-4 2.5
0 2 4 6 8 10
Time [s]
2
Figure 8: Reflection patterns at different
temperatures; the legend indicates first the indoor
1.5
temperature, next the outdoor temperature
T [C]
1
PILC:23.5C XLPE:24.0C
PILC:28.1 C XLPE:24.9 C
0 0.5
PILC:33.1C XLPE:25.8C
-0.1 PILC:38.2C XLPE:26.1C
Amplitude [V]
PILC:43.0C XLPE:27.3C
0
-0.2
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3
PILC:48.1C XLPE:28.8C t [h]
-0.3
Figure 10: Derived temperature difference
-0.4 between the midpoint of paper insulation and the
-0.5 outer jacket surface for the three-core PILC cable
4.05 4.1 4.15 4.2 4.25
Time [s] Table 2: Middle of insulation temperature for PILC
(a)
Ref. 1 2 3 4 5
1864
OF5-01
Figure 11 for five measurements. The time shift of the PILC cable is affected more by temperature.
increases with propagation time and temperature Also this figure suggests that the variation is not
difference. The steep rise observed directly after linear and becomes more pronounced at higher
the reflection from the injection cable is caused by temperatures.
the time window beginning to cover the reflection
from the PILC to XLPE transition point, which gives
2.5
a clear shift. The increase in time delay directly -XLPE
after the first reflection is where the heated cable PILC
starts. 2
1.5
amplitude [V]
50 0 0
0 5 10 15 20 25
temperature difference [ C]
00:40
0 0 0 0 0
0
1 8: 25:0 0 5: 05:0 1 6: 10:0 0 5: 35:0
28
29
01
03
05
6-
7-
7-
7-
-0
-0
-0
-0
-0
s]
10
10
10
10
10
31.7 31.8
Propagation time [
31.6
31.6
31.5
31.4 31.4
28
29
01
03
05
6-
7-
7-
7-
-0
-0
-0
-0
01-08
10
10
10
10
10
Figure 13: Propagation time and load of XLPE cable for year and week cycle
1865
OF5-01
1866