Professional Documents
Culture Documents
0126 Kochanek11
0126 Kochanek11
DOI 10.1007/s00134-006-0285-4 PE D I A T R I C O R I G I N A L
Kevin P. Morris
Robert J. Forsyth
Intracranial pressure complicating severe
Roger C. Parslow traumatic brain injury in children:
Robert C. Tasker
Carol A. Hawley monitoring and management
UK Paediatric Traumatic Brain
Injury Study Group
Paediatric Intensive Care Society
Study Group
Received: 23 July 2005 Abstract Objective: To identify (6% of cases); therefore cerebrospinal
Accepted: 20 June 2006 factors associated with the use of in- fluid drainage is seldom used as
Published online: 28 July 2006 tracranial pressure (ICP) monitoring a first-line therapy for raised ICP.
Springer-Verlag 2006 and to establish which ICP-targetted Jugular venous bulb oximetry (4%),
therapies are being used in children brain microdialysis (< 1%) and brain
This study was supported by grants from with severe traumatic brain injury tissue oxygen monitoring (< 1%)
the Paediatric Intensive Care Society,
Birmingham Childrens Hospital Research (TBI) in the United Kingdom. To are rarely used in current practice.
Foundation and the Warwick University evaluate current practice against re- Contrary to published guidelines,
Research and Teaching Development Fund. cently published guidelines. Design moderate to severe hyperventilation
K. P. Morris (u) and setting: Prospective data col- is being used without monitoring for
Diana Princess of Wales Childrens lection of clinical and demographic cerebral ischaemia. Conclusions:
Hospital, information from paediatric and adult There is an urgent need for greater
Steelhouse Lane, B4 6NH Birmingham, UK intensive care units in the UK and Ire- standardisation of practice across UK
e-mail: kevin.morris@bch.nhs.uk land admitting children (< 16 years) centres admitting children with severe
Tel.: +44-121-3339673 with TBI between February 2001 TBI.
Fax: +44-121-3339651 and August 2003. Results: Detailed
R. J. Forsyth clinical information was obtained for Keywords Traumatic brain injury
Sir James Spence Institute of Child Health, 501 children, with information on the Children Intensive care Intracranial
Royal Victoria Infirmary, Child Health, use of ICP monitoring available in pressure Treatment Monitoring
School of Clinical Medical Sciences,
445. ICP monitoring was used in only
NE1 4 lP Newcastle upon Tyne, UK
59% (75/127) of children presenting
R. C. Parslow with an emergency room Glasgow
Leeds Institute of Genetics, Health and Coma Scale of 8 or below. Large be-
Therapeutics, University of Leeds,
Paediatric Epidemiology Group, Centre for
tween centre variation was seen in the
Epidemiology and Biostatistics, use of ICP monitoring, independent
30 Hyde Terrace, LS2 9JT Leeds, UK of severity of injury. There were 86
children who received ICP-targetted
R. C. Tasker
Addenbrookes Hospital, Cambridge therapies without ICP monitoring.
University Clinical School, Wide between centre variation was
Hills Rd, CB2 2QQ Cambridge, UK found in the use of ICP-targetted
therapies and in general aspects of
C. A. Hawley
Warwick Medical School, University of management, such as fluid restric-
Warwick, Division of Health in the tion, the use of muscle relaxants and
Community, prophylactic anticonvulsants. Intra-
CV4 7AL Coventry, UK ventricular catheters are rarely placed
1607
Table 1 Random effects model for use of ICP monitoring (n = 331). Between centre variation in management of ICP
Glasgow Coma Score (GCS) refers to that measured in the accident and general management
and emergency department. Baseline categories for the analysis were
GCS 1315 and age 1014 years. In addition to the significance of
GCS, age and CT abnormality, a strong admitting centre effect was To allow for between-centre variation in the GCS thresh-
found ( = 0.293, likelihood ratio test p < 0.001, 2 = 37.8) (OR odds old for ICU admission this analysis was confined to severe
ratio, CI confidence interval) TBI cases in 12 centres admitting ten or more severe
cases and includes cases with and without ICP monitor-
OR p 95% CI ing (n = 168). Wide variation in every aspect of practice
GCS 8 4.67 0.000 2.0010.86 was evident (Fig. 1). Use of mannitol was recorded in 43%
GCS 912 2.20 0.09 0.885.49 (73/168) of cases, with considerable variation across cen-
GCS unrecordable 4.13 0.001 1.779.67 tres (range 777% of cases within each centre). Of these,
Age 1 year 0.08 0.001 0.020.36
Age 14 years 1.27 0.53 0.602.72 92% (155/168) were managed with some degree of hy-
Age 510 years 0.99 0.97 0.511.92 perventilation (range 50100% of cases within each cen-
Age > 14 years 0.62 0.47 0.172.24 tre), and 14% (24/168) barbiturate therapy (range 027%
CT abnormality 3.89 0.000 1.987.64 of cases within each centre). Fluid restriction was used in
Neurosurgical procedure 1.05 0.90 0.502.21 58% (98/168) of severe TBI cases, with considerable vari-
first 24 h
Pupil(s) unreactive 1.60 0.21 0.773.31 ation across centres (0100% of cases within each centre).
first 24 h The restriction was moderate (5175% of normal fluids) in
70% of these cases and severe (< 50% of normal fluids) in
30% of cases.
or showing obvious inconsistencies requiring referral back Acknowledgements. We are grateful to all the staff of PICUs who
to the investigator for clarification. A limitation of the completed data collection forms, to Dr. Kathy Rowan of ICNARC
study was that no attempt could be made to confirm the for supplying data on paediatric admissions to adult ICUs, and to
Naveed Hussain, Helen Sherry and Neil Hallworth for database de-
accuracy of the data by comparison with original case sign, data entry and preliminary data processing. The UK Paediatric
records, as this process is extremely expensive in time Traumatic Brain Injury Study Steering Group consists of: K. Morris
and personnel. In addition our findings relate to those (Chair), R. Appleton, M. Crouchman, R. Forsyth, C. Hawley,
cases in which a detailed clinical abstract was completed, M. Marsh, P. May, P. McKinney, J. Middleton, R. Parslow, J. Punt,
T. Ralph and R. Tasker. Participating centres and investigators were:
representing only 69% of the total cases admitted to Addenbrookes Hospital (R. Tasker), Alder Hey Childrens Hospital
participating units. Only two PICUs that admit children (R. Sarginson), Antrim Hospital (A. Ferguson), Beaumont Hospital,
with TBI did not participate in the study. We think it Dublin (E. Keane), Birmingham Childrens Hospital (K. Morris),
unlikely that inclusion of additional cases from these Bristol Childrens Hospital (J. Fraser), City General Hospital,
Stoke (J. Alexander), Derriford Hospital, Plymouth (S. Fergu-
centres would have altered the key conclusions of the son), Great Ormond St. Hospital (M. Kenny, D. Lutman), Guys
study. A further limitation of the study was the reliance on Hospital (A. Durward), Hull Royal Infirmary (H. Klonin), John
intermittent hourly recording of ICP to define a group with Radcliffe Hospital (A. Shefler, C. Killick), Kings College Hospital
raised ICP. It is conceivable that a number of additional (D. Prior, l. Edwards, Y. Egberongbe), Leeds General Infirmary
(T. Chater, M. Darowski), Leicester Royal Infirmary (P. Barry),
children experienced ICP readings above 20 mmHg that Queens Medical Centre, Nottingham (P. Khandelwal), James Cook
were not captured on the hourly chart recordings. University Hospital (A. Robinson), Newcastle General Hospital
(R. Forsyth), Royal Belfast Hospital for Sick Children (B. Taylor),
Royal Berkshire Hospital (A. Maunganidze), Royal Devon & Exeter
Hospital (J. Purday), Royal Hospital for Sick Children, Edinburgh
Conclusions (M. Lo, D. Simpson), Royal Hospital for Sick Children, Glasgow
(P. Cullen), Royal London Hospital (P. Withington), Royal Manch-
There is a need for greater standardisation of practice ester Childrens Hospital (D. Stewart, M. Samuels), Royal Preston
across UK centres admitting children with severe TBI. Hospital (P. Tomlin), Sandwell Hospital (J. Bellin), Sheffield
Less variation in management could have a beneficial Childrens Hospital (T. Ralph), Southampton General Hospital
(C. Boyles), Southern General Hospital, Glasgow (D. Snaddon,
effect on outcomes and would be essential, to reduce A. Wagstaff), St. Georges Hospital (S. Skellett), University Hospital
between centre heterogeneity, before embarking on of Wales (M. Gajraj), Walsgrave Hospital (M. Christie), Walton
multicentre trials. Centre for Neurosurgery (E. Wright).
References
1. Matta B, Menon D (1996) Severe 5. Parslow RC, Morris KP, Tasker RC, 9. Mendelow A, Rowan J, Murray L,
head injury in the United Kingdom Forsyth RJ, Hawley CA (2005) Epi- Kerr A (1983) A clinical comparison of
and Ireland: a survey of practice and demiology of traumatic brain injury in subdural screw pressure measurements
implications for management. Crit Care children receiving intensive care in the with ventricular pressure. J Neurosurg
Med 24:17431748 UK. Arch Dis Child 90:11821187 58:4550
2. Segal S, Gallagher AC, Shefler AG, 6. Bulger EM, Nathens AB, Rivara FP, 10. Raabe A, Totzauer R, Meyer O,
Crawford S, Richards P (2001) Moore M, MacKenzie EJ, Jurkovich GJ Stockel R, Hohrein D, Schoche J
Survey of the use of intracranial (2002) Management of severe head (1998) Reliability of epidural pressure
pressure monitoring in children in the injury: Institutional variations in care measurement in clinical practice:
United Kingdom. Intensive Care Med and effect on outcome. Crit Care Med behaviour of three modern sensors
27:236239 30:18701876 during simultaneous ipsilateral in-
3. Murray GD, Teasdale GM, Braak- 7. Tilford JM, Simpson PM, Yeh TS, traventricular or intraparenchymal
man R, Cohadon F, Dearden M, Lensing S, Aitken ME, Green JW, pressure measurement. Neurosurgery
Iannotti F, Karimi A, Lapierre F, Harr J, Fiser DH (2001) Variation 43:306311
Maas A, Ohman J, Persson L, Ser- in therapy and outcome for pediatric 11. Taylor A, Butt W, Rosenfeld J, Shann F,
vadei F, Stocchetti N, Trojanowski T, head trauma patients. Crit Care Med Ditchfield M, Lewis E, Klug G, Wal-
Unterberg A (1999) The European 29:10561061 lace D, Henning R, Tibballs J (2001)
Brain Injury Consortium survey of 8. Bullock R, Chesnut RM, Clifton G, A randomized trial of very early decom-
head injuries. Acta Neurochir (Wien) Ghajar J, Marion DW, Narayan RK, pressive craniectomy in children with
141:223236 Newell DW, Pitts LH, Rosner MJ, traumatic brain injury and sustained
4. Adelson PD, Bratton SL, Carney NA, Wilberger JW (2000) Guidelines for the intracranial hypertension. Child-s Nerv
Chesnut RM, du Coudray HE, Gold- management of severe traumatic brain Syst 17:154162
stein B, Kochanek PM, Miller HC, injury. J Neurotrauma 17:451553
Partington MD, Selden NR, War-
den CR, Wright DW (2003) Guidelines
for the acute medical management of
severe traumatic brain injury in infants,
children, and adolescents. Pediatr Crit
Care Med 4 [Suppl]:S1S71