Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Laporan Assesment City Tour Wil - Barat
Laporan Assesment City Tour Wil - Barat
Prepared by
Assesment Team
(Ferdinand Radawara, SST.Par, Fransiskus Dafro,A.Ma, Ferdinandus Watu, Irwan
Mahmud, Herman Y.Mau,SE, Dewi Tojania, A.Md.Par)
Facilitated by
Dewan Pimpinan Cabang Kabupaten Ende
Himpunan Pramuwisata Indonesia
(Indonesian Travel Guide Association)
March 2014
1
Introduction
The assessment report will present the information from data gathering and data analysis with
Strength, Weakness, Opportunities and Threat logic. The assessments on potential tourism
objects have two main components; on the one hand an on the job training for local
stakeholders as well as for staff of the local tourism authority and on the other hand a data
collection and analysis of potential tourism objects as base and reference date for the local
guide of Ende.
Course of action
The city tour assessment on West Side of Ende has been conducted with a local assessment
team. The assessments can be split in following steps:
Briefing
Identifying of local stakeholders, access opportunities and preparation of the data collection
(structured assessment form) and task force
Field work; data collection
The local assessment team is identifying key stakeholders at the object potentials,
opportunities, strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats for future tourism development
on the basis of a structured assessment form and task force.
Gathering data
The team is full filling and completing the data collected during the field assessment through
different sources.
Data analysis
Based on a SWOT analysis with specific lead question related on future tourism development
opportunities for the object. The local assessment team is identifying the main strengths,
opportunities, weaknesses and threat.
2
Irwan Mahmud HPI DPC Kab. Ende Member
Herman Y.Mau, SE HPI DPC Kab. Ende Member
Dewi Tojania, A.Md.Par HPI DPC Kab. Ende Member
4. Methods used to obtain assessment data (please tick on the appropriate box):
One on one interview
Self filled questionnaire
Group discussions
Own observation/experiences
Available documents
Other:
1. GENERAL INFORMATION
1. 1. Name of tourism object/attraction: Blue Stone Beach / Batu Hijau
1. 4 Contact persons of local authorities who could provide information about the object : -
2. OBJECT DESCRIPTION
2. 1. The object condition in general (first impression)
Tengkulese waterfall is surrounded by 25 hectares of ricefields and refreshing atmosphere.
Panorama of huge drops of water which signing the waterfall is as soon as the walking trip
started. Polite and smiling local people with paddy planting activity are easily to meet during the
trip to the waterfall. The waterfall is also quite accessible since theres path of irrigation channel
toward the object.
3
the waterfall, one flowing river called Cunca Lega also offers the swimming experiences with
very good temperature of water. As the water flowing out from the slits of the rocks, the water
will flow down through the cascading rivers pond toward far northern direction.
Do you know from your mother/father or grand mother / father anything about this object?
Before the irrigation was built, local people used waters from Cunca Lega to water their
ricefields.
Do you know what people (your mother/father or grand mother/father) did with this object?
Nothing
4
2.7. For tourism product development, what other tourism objects could be linked to this object?
Liang Bua archaeological site: After visiting Liang Bua, visitors can continue the trip to
Tengkulese which leads to east through Beokina village which took about 12,5 km or less than
an hour and then walk 2,5 km from Kampung Nanu to the waterfall.
2. 8. Availability of written information about the object: (brochure, banner, billboard, information
board, results of research, etc )
Type of information Available Not available
Brochure
Banner
Billboard
Information board
Results of research
Others (please specify)
3. ACSESSIBILITY
3. 1 Distance from district capital city (Ruteng) to Nanu 28 km, plus 2,5km to the waterfall and
river.
By bicycle
By motor bike
By four wheels car 2 hours
By truck/bus/wooden bus
By boat
By speed boat
Others (please specify)
3.3 Distance to the object without vehicle access (if any): 2,5 km
5
3.6 Trip route (main cities/villages) and road condition along the way from Labuan Ruteng to
tourist object:
From To Distance Road Condition
(name of main (KM) Asphalt Semi- Non- Small No
city or village) Asphalt Asphalt Road Road
Nanu (car park)- 2,5km/les
Tengkulese s than an
hour
Liang Bua-Nanu 15 km
Ruteng-Liang 13 km
Bua
3.7 Interesting places that could be visited/stopped by on the way to tourism object (beautiful
sceneries, restaurant, traditional village, local food/drink, local souvenir, art and cultural center,
historical places, historical buildings, community development projects, rest places)
3. 9 Level of difficulties to reach the object (Access from the starting point, road condition)
Access with Difficult Difficult in rainy Not difficult Remarks
season
Foot
Car
Motorbike
Boat
Others
4. OBJECT MANAGEMENT
4. 1 Facilities
6
Yes No
1. Rest room/toilet
2. Bath room
3. Information board
4. Brochure/leaflet
5. Resting area
6. Parking area/security
7. HP signal
8. Doctor/medical center/clinic Doctor Mario, Less
than 1 kilo from the
first point walk
9. Others: .....................................
4. 2 Object ownership
To whom this object belongs politically? (Please tick the appropriate box)
Local government
Local community
Local community leader
Local religion leader
Individual/private sector
Other:
To whom this object belongs traditionally? (Please tick the appropriate box)
Local government
Local community
Local community leader
Local religion leader
Private sector
Other:
.
4. 4 Local guide:
No. Qualification Remarks
1. Availability of local guide No
2. Number of guides Male...guides, femaleguides
3. English ability Very good/good/poor
4. Product knowledge about the Very good/good/poor
7
object
5. Educational back ground of the Elementary school/Junior - high
guide (in average) school/diploma/bachelor
What kind of work are you doing? What kind of work are the most people here doing?
Agricultural, rice farming and garden farming (coffee, clove, candlenut, vanilli, cacao, orange,
coconuts and banana
8
What product are you selling in the market? Where is the market?
Banana is the most commodities
Coffee, clove, vanilla and cacao are also among commodities which sold to Ruteng retailers.
5. 4. Special cultural performance performed by the local community (dance, songs, Ikat
waving, cooking, etc):
Name of event Type of tradition Special dates
5. 7 Knowledge of local people about the object (meaning of the object for local community)
Do local people often visit this object? Why? What are the locals doing there?
Local people from other kampong or village also likes to visit the object for refreshing
6 ENVIRONMENT
6.1 Land use in the area around the object
6.2 Landscape:
Type Intensity Remarks
Hilly High
9
Flat Medium Kampung Tebo
Rock formations High On the rivers (wae lega,
wae rengkas, and wae
nio)
River valleys High Wae Lega, Wae Rengkas,
and Wae Nio (Buar
Village)
Swamp Medium Ricefield
Water environment
Others,
Others..
6. 7. Waste management:
Cleanliness of the surrounding
The surrounding of the object is still clean and away from the littering behavior.
10
The environment support the livelihood activity, like the water supply needs to be maintained to
water the ricefields. It has been very dependable for the locals with the nature since their great
grandfathers time.
Others,
7. VISITORS
7. 1 Specific things that have to be prepared/brought along/done by visitors before or during the
visit: Drinking water, sun crme, sun glasses, hat, swimming material, etc.
Drinking water, sunglasses, trekking shoes, change clothes, binocular/telescope, meals/snack,
sun cream (sometime the weather is hot), better to prepare some tobacco for the locals.
7. 2 Things that are or should be forbidden for visitors to do during the visit:
It is forbidden to destroy anything surrounding the object, including destroying the farmland, do
not act violently, it is better to visit the Kampung Tebo for a permission.
7. 4 Visitor data:
No. Visitor data Remarks
1. Visitor record system not available
2. Majority of visitors Domestic/foreign visitors
3. Way of traveling of visitors (majority) Individual/group
4. Nationality of visitors (majority) ..
5. Name of travel agent that send
visitors (majority)
6. Average age of visitors
7. The favorite day (s) for visitors to ..
visit
8. The favorite month (s) for visitors to ..
visit
9. Number of visitors per year Year Domestic Foreigners
2005 ......visitors ..............visitors
2006 ............ visitors ............. visitors
2007 ............. visitors ............. visitors
11
2008 ............. visitors ............. visitors
2009 ............. visitors ............. visitors
10. General comments from visitors
(compliment or complaint)
11. General comments from travel agent Spectacular and outstanding object
(Compliment or complaint) (separate comment from a travel agent
person who visited the object before)
8. FIRST IMPRESSION
8. 1 Main strengths of the object:
Accessibility: the object is easily accessible by car or motorbike along through the asphalt road
from the city of Ruteng which take about about 28 km to the first point to walk. From the park
point in Nanu, visitors only need to walk about 2, 5 km which takes less than 1 hour, including
visiting RT/Kampung Tebo Atas, a small kampong near the waterfall.
Uniqueness: Roaring splashes sound of enormous amount of water dropping from the distance
and two levels of waterfall dominating the center of ricefield panorama is the reason why the
object becomes very unique. The falling waters from the two levels of waterfall are easily
noticed from the distance as the first minutes of walk toward the object is carried on. What
makes it easily seen from the distance is that the levels are approximately 100 meters and
gathered by greenish ricefields. Lucky the visitors if they visit the waterfall and when they walk
the irrigation channel, some farmers with their paddy planting activity in their ricefield will
decorate the nuance, moreover when they start to sing anonymous local songs from the
distance. The temperature of the objects region is also not quite cold however refreshing one.
The level two of the waterfalls pond is the most impressive spot to see and it is about how
interesting the magic colors of rainbow circling around the pond during the day. From the
waterfalls pond, visitors also can point their vision to whole things lying down like the big brown
12
stones shattered along the river of Wae Lega. Another interesting fact is that during the dry
season the water is not drastically slowing down, or the water discharge is still in large amount.
To change the view, visitors must hop from a stone to another which makes it a bit difficult to do
since of the slippery rocks. Flowing waters from the pond into the river of Wae Lega is a nice
visual effect as they flow across the slits of the brown rocks then coming down as the river
cascades. Several pools of the river also offer experience of swimming activities.
Tengkulese waterfall is still new for those locals living in the city of Ruteng, it means that its still
little of people knowing about the object.
Activities: Trekking to Tengkulese, starting from Nanu the place where the car usually parked
and starting point to walk, it will take only less than an hour. The trekking also can combined
with some visit to kampung Tebo where the nearest inhabitant living around the object. Visitors
can also drop by in a small hut where the local farmers usually take rest after whole day paddy
planting, this hut is right before the irrigation channel where leads to the waterfall.
Different path toward the waterfall also can be done than taking the irrigation channel path,
which is the first visit will lead to the river of Wae Lega to enjoy the panorama of the waterfall
from lower angle. From here visitors can start to swim on the cascading river with refreshing
water as well. After the swim visitors can climb up to the ricefield to reach the irrigation channel
toward the waterfall.
It is also potential to have more activities (extreme one) like canyoning from the top of the
waterfall into the bottom of the river of Cunca Lega, but this should be conduct in a special
assessment.
Facilities: there is no established facility as this object is still quite new for the Manggarai
tourism agency. No toilets, road signs, and cellular signal. It is also have to be thought that a
parking site for visitors as more marketing and promotions effect will soon full the object in the
future.
Culture: local people of Kampong Tebo cannot provide information whether they have some
cultural or traditional events during a year. From the interview to one of local people there,
current time, traditional performance like Caci whip fighting dance is mostly held in the city for
an event reason, and not in their own village. It is also found that they dont have any particular
traditional culinary to keep.
8. 3 Carrying Capacity
Impact of visitors to local economy development:
There is still no impact as this object is quite new. However, local kampong like Kampong Tebo
can provide coffee and drinks for visitors with good price in return.
13
None
Involvement and capacity building of local community in the tourism object management
(entrance guard/information center/ticket seller/guide/ food-drink-souvenir sellers, etc)
None
14
8. 5 Other comments and recommendations:
The SWOT analysis based on the data collection and other imputes gives an overview
of the main strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and treats. Out of these findings and
in close exchange with the local assessment team the recommendations have been
developed.
Other recommendations:
Accessibility: different route from other point to reach the top of the waterfall will also
be pleasant to have which means different trekking route through the dense forest
(observed from google earth). In this accessibility recommendation, a fix trekking path
toward the waterfall will be somewhat helpful to get saver path than stepping into the
slippery irrigation channel which potential landslide waits in the end before the waterfall.
And it also meant to keep the farmlands dike away from the over capacity of passing
tourists to the river of Wae Lega.
Activities: more developed activity than just a common trekking, but sometime for
canyoning from the top of the waterfall into the pond would be an interesting product
which required more focused assessment and test. Improvised activities like canyoning
or waterfall rapelling and waterfall hiking which would be the market for special interest
excursion or for those who love extreme adventure.
Facilities: signboards to point out directions, some warnings for those who enter the
channel path and the potential landslide. Local people can be taught how to prepare
decent food and drinks for visitors since theres no warung. If more developed, the
object will give more opportunities of activities and visitors can spend days to enjoy the
15
object and surrounding, so it will be better if local peoples house can be trained as
accommodation service.
Local community: as more activities will be identified in the future, local people
especially youngsters can be prepared as local guides.
Cultural: an art workshop or cultural group which can perform a traditional attraction to
visitors is also will be a complement part to have the object an integrated experience, in
this issue is how the visitors can interact with local community by their traditional
performance like Caci and Dundundake dance.
PICTURES
16