Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Edublogger Review: When Technology Doesn't Help
Edublogger Review: When Technology Doesn't Help
Edublogger Review
As a result, the library is far more expensive to run than it
A "mash-up" of postings from nine engaging educational once was. It isn’t doing anything wrong; it’s just doing what
and e-learning bloggers. it’s supposed to do. The problem is that the technological
advances it adopts -- each for good reason -- don’t, and won’t,
save money.
When Technology Doesn’t Help
Source: http://suburbdad.blogspot.com/2010/07/when-technology-doesnt- Something similar holds true in the health-related majors.
help.html As medicine has adopted more high-tech equipment and
By Dean Dad on July 14th, 2010 methods, we’ve had to adopt them, too, to train the students
Joshua Kim’s piece yesterday reminded me of a basic, but on them. But we don’t get any of the gains from that. We have
widely ignored, truth. to pay for it, but the productivity gains, if any, accrue to the
industry rather than to us. Worse, many of the purchases are
In most industries, new technology is adopted because it’s so complex and high-maintenance that they require dedicated
expected to lower costs and/or improve productivity (which staff, thereby adding higher labor costs to the equation.
lowers costs over time). It doesn’t always succeed, of course,
and the usual vagaries of faddism are certainly there. But by There are excellent societal reasons why that’s a good idea. I
and large, the point of adopting a new technology is to make like the idea of the rookie Nursing student making his first
the underlying business stronger. medical mistakes on simulators, rather than on people, for the
same reason that I like pilots to use flight simulators before
But that doesn’t apply in either higher education or health they first fly planes. Fewer casualties that way.
care. In both of those, institutions adopt technology to meet
rising expectations, whether it helps with cost or not. Much of But the college doesn’t capture the gains from that. It’s saddled
the time, it actually leads to increased costs. with the costs, heaven knows, but not with the other side of the
equation. And in an era of declining state support, there are
For example, take the typical college library. Libraries don’t only so many places to go to find the difference.
bring in much revenue on their own, if any; they’re pretty
pure ‘cost centers’ for most colleges. They’re central to the I agree that certain applications of technology can save colleges
educational mission of the college, to be sure; I’d suggest money, and that colleges should take those opportunities
that in the context of a commuter campus, that’s even more seriously. But to assume that it will only be deployed where it
true than elsewhere. But income is tied to credit hours, and saves money, or even that it will be a net financial gain, strikes
libraries don’t generate credit hours of their own. me as reaching. We train people on the latest stuff because we
have to, whether it saves money or not.
In the past, typical library costs included labor, acquisitions,
utilities, and not much else. Tables, desks, chairs, and carrels
could be expected to last decades (and judging by some
of the graffiti I saw at Flagship State, they did.) Yes, you Managing in Complexity
Source: http://www.jarche.com/2010/07/managing-in-complexity/
might find microfilm or microfiche, but even there the space
By Harold Jarche on July 14th, 2010
requirements were minimal and the purchases could last for
decades. (For younger readers: microfilm was sort of like
cassette tape...no, wait, you wouldn’t know that...it was sort
of like movies watched really slowly...no, not like dvd’s...ah,
screw it, I’m old.) It wasn’t at all rare for the highest-tech thing
in the library to be the coin-operated photocopier.
This image, from Cynthia Kurtz’s post, Confluence, clearly I’m involved in several discussions around how to use Wikis
shows the challenge we face in our networked organizations as part of learning solutions. I wanted to collect a few
competing and collaborating in complex adaptive systems. resources around this topic for use in these discussions. So,
of course, I went to eLearning Learning and I looked at Wiki,
Collaborative Learning with Wikis, Wikis and eLearning 2.0,
Wikis Corporate eLearning, Social Learning with Wikis, Wiki
Security and a few others. Here’s some of what I found:
2
July 14th, 2010 Published by: philosophyandrew
20. eLearning Tools - Wikis, Blogs and More- eLearning 45. SharePoint Social Learning Experience- eLearning
Technology, April 2, 2007 Technology, February 1, 2010
21. Wiki – Day 2 – How Wikis are Used- Engaged Learning, 46. Time for “new” training approaches- Daretoshare,
December 1, 2009 February 28, 2009
22. Wikis – Day 3 – Privacy & Adoption- Engaged Learning, 47. Checklist of Social Learning Strategies- Engaged
December 2, 2009 Learning, January 12, 2010
23. Wikis – Day 4 – Overcoming Bad Stigmas- Engaged 48. The Future Of Learning Design- The eLearning Coach,
Learning, December 3, 2009 November 23, 2009
24. Top 10 Ways Social Media Will Impact Employee 49. Wiki Owner- eLearning Technology, March 19, 2009
Development and Training in 2010- Learning Putty, 50. Social Learning Tools Should Not be Separate from
October 29, 2009 Enterprise 2.0- eLearning Technology, April 7, 2010
25. Conference Wiki Examples- eLearning Technology, 51. SharePoint 2007: Gateway Drug to Enterprise Social
November 25, 2008 Tools :: Personal InfoCloud, March 16, 2009
26. Use of Wikis as Compared to Other Tools- eLearning 52. Driving the Informal with the Formal, February 10, 2010
Technology, February 23, 2007
53. groundswell - confirming my e-Learning 2.0 ideas,
27. 22 Social Learning Strategy Questions to Answer Before August 27, 2008
Your Next Lesson- Learning Putty, July 1, 2010
54. TELUS Case Study - Using Sharepoint to embrace social
28. TCC09: Wikis that Work: Effective Wiki Practices for
computing and streamline formal learning , May 15, 2010
Virtual Learning Communities- Experiencing eLearning,
April 15, 2009 55. Driving Change: Selling SharePoint and Social Media
Inside the Enterprise, January 30, 2009
29. Wiki as repository for a virtual community- Joitske
Hulsebosch eLearning, January 21, 2009 56. How to Find the Right Wiki for Your Project or
Organization, February 15, 2009
30. How Wikipedia Works and Wikis in the Enterprise -
HBS- eLearning Technology, July 23, 2007 57. From formal courses to social learning- Learning
Conversations, November 26, 2009
31. Wikis - Public vs. Controlled - Why There's No eLearning
Wiki- eLearning Technology, September 14, 2006 58. Requirement to Social Learning Adoption #1 - Relative
Advantage- Engaged Learning, February 23, 2009
32. 10 Social Media Tools For Learning- The eLearning
Coach, November 16, 2009 59. Characteristics of Emergent Communities- Social
Enterprise Blog, April 14, 2009
33. Collaborative Learning Using Web 2.0 Tools - A
Summary- eLearning Technology, May 16, 2006 60. Promoting Social Learning- eLearning Blender, May 23,
2009
34. Benefits of Collaborative Learning- Dont Waste Your
Time, July 8, 2010
35. Enterprise 2.0 - Community Spaces can lead to Walled eLearning Technology
Gardens- Free as in Freedom, March 27, 2010 Subscribe to the Best of eLearning Learning for updates from
this blog and other eLearning blogs.
36. Examples of eLearning 2.0- eLearning Technology,
September 22, 2008
37. Collaborative Learning « Social Enterprise Blog, June 3, Massachusetts State Colleges
2009
Want University Status
38. A Learning Paradigm Shift: Cybergogy, April 9, 2010 Source: http://keptup.typepad.com/academic/2010/07/massachusetts-
state-colleges-want-university-status.html
39. Learning space mashups, July 13, 2009
By StevenB on July 14th, 2010
40. Case studies of corporate (social) learning, March 12,
2010 The Massachusetts House of Representatives voted 124 to
21 Thursday to allow the nine state colleges to rename
41. Using SharePoint- eLearning Technology, December 16, themselves universities. Supporters of the bill, which now
2008 goes to the Senate, say the change would allow schools to
42. SharePoint 2010: The New Employee Gateway?- earn more grants, draw more applicants, and make students
trainingwreck, January 23, 2010 more attractive to employers. Detractors say it would do
little to improve the quality of education and could be costly
43. Social Learning Strategies Checklist- Social Enterprise if professors ask for university pay. So far, 45 states have
Blog, January 11, 2010 transformed their state college systems into state university
44. Extending elearning?- Learnlets, November 30, 2008 systems. Read more at:
3
July 14th, 2010 Published by: philosophyandrew
http://www.boston.com/news/education/higher/ http://www.mercurynews.com/ci_15480908?
articles/2010/07/10/ IADID=Search-www.mercurynews.com-
whats_in_a_name_plenty_say_backers_of_renaming_state_colleges/
www.mercurynews.com&nclick_check=1
Good set of examples describing how to build a I feel D'Arch Norman's pain. "I was asked to turn in the iPhone
personal learning network (or environment, depending on last month. Due to the contract setup, it couldn't be cancelled
your point of view. Note to Miguel: something called right away, so I was able to borrow it for an additional month.
b.scorecardresearch.com is wrecking your page on my Firefox That month is up, so now I just finished nuking the iPhone
- and what are you doing running a tracking service like this again so I can turn it in. I've likely saved the University
anyways?). A search tells me that " scorecardresearch is part of hundreds of thousands of dollars by advocating and using
a larger organization, www.fullcirclestudies.com , and have a free and open source software for nearly a decade. But that
partner further up the food chain http://www.comscore.com/ $50/month will probably be what finally saves the University
." It has been hanging Firefox recently. Miguel Guhlin , from budgetary destruction. Phew. Disaster averted." I had a
Moving at the Speed of Creativity , July 13, 2010 6:00 p.m.. [ Blackberry - but apparently it was unreasonable for the NRC
Link ] [Tags: Networks , Research ] [ Previous ][ Next ] to allow its e-learning expert a mobile device. So they took
Comments it away, and I now learn about mobile learning by intuition.
D'Arcy Norman , D'Arcy Norman dot net , July 13, 2010
Comment 5:48 p.m.. [ Link ] [Tags: Online Learning , Open Source ] [
You are not logged in. [Login] Previous ][ Next ]
Comments
Title
Comment
Your comment:
You are not logged in. [Login]
Enter email to receive
replies: Title
Your comment:
Your comments always remain your property, but in posting
them here you agree to license under the same terms as this Enter email to receive
site ( Creative Commons ). If your comment is offensive it will replies:
be deleted.
Your comments always remain your property, but in posting
Automated Spam-checking is in effect. If you are a registered them here you agree to license under the same terms as this
user you may submit links and other HTML. Anonymous users site ( Creative Commons ). If your comment is offensive it will
cannot post links and will have their content screened - certain be deleted.
words are prohibited and your comment will be analyzed to
make sure it makes sense. Automated Spam-checking is in effect. If you are a registered
user you may submit links and other HTML. Anonymous users
cannot post links and will have their content screened - certain
At Stanford No One Wants To words are prohibited and your comment will be analyzed to
Leave make sure it makes sense.
Source: http://keptup.typepad.com/academic/2010/07/at-stanford-no-
one-wants-to-leave.html
By StevenB on July 14th, 2010
Don't Listen To Those Who
Many workers yearn for retirement — the goodbye parties, the Claim Not Everyone Needs A
golf course, maybe even a gold watch. But Stanford University College Education
has the opposite problem: Nobody wants to leave. Hoping to Source: http://keptup.typepad.com/academic/2010/07/dont-listen-to-
create more space for young scholars, Stanford has revamped those-who-claim-not-everyone-needs-a-college-education.html
its generous "Retirement Incentive Program" — for the second By StevenB on July 14th, 2010
time in a decade — to nudge more old-timers toward the door.
With the brightest students, best libraries and labs, and lighter For many young people, college aspiration is a powerful entry
teaching loads than at most state schools, professors at elite point for the American Dream. It's a goal that structures their
research universities have little reason to retire. Read more at: sense of themselves, and their vision of their future in our
society. But there's a movement afoot to discourage teens
from aspiring to higher education. Stoked by economists and
pundits tapping into the anti-intellectualism of our political
4
July 14th, 2010 Published by: philosophyandrew
culture, this movement says simply that college doesn't Ditto for the "teamwork" canard. One doesn't have to "beat"
pay. Proponents of this view note that college costs have other humans to learn teamwork. Teamwork can be learned --
skyrocketed, and they point to nationwide figures showing that and probably better learned -- in a coöperative environment.
a degree doesn't offer the salary premium it once did. But our The only competition humans should engage in is competition
goal should be to encourage more, not fewer, young people to against our own faults and follies. Strive to be better than one
aspire to higher education. Read more at: is, not better than someone else.
http://www.philly.com/dailynews/
opinion/20100708_College_education_doesn_t_pay__naysayers_claim.html#ixzz0tCnN6cVr
Watch sports videos you won't find anywhere else It is truly horrifying that we teach this aggressiveness to
children, and no surprise that later in life that aggressiveness
is often expressed in rioting, fist fights at games, and support
11 Models that are Better for military adventures (particularly the type where one uses
for Childhood Learning than overwhelming firepower to crush other human beings with
little or no threat to oneself).
Schools'
Source: http://www.downes.ca/cgi-bin/page.cgi?post=52866
July 14th, 2010 The third item with which I take issue, possibly, is the job.
It depends on what one means by a job. If one means taking
I like this list so much I'll just print the whole thing
on responsibility to accomplish something for the benefit of
- 11 Models that are Better for Childhood Learning than
humanity, then that is a wonderful calling. But if it means to
Schools': - Summer Camps: Be engaged outdoors, not coerced
insert oneself into the world of "work" -- that soul-numbing
indoors - Libraries/YMCA: Pick what interests you today -
activity in which one again learns one's "place" in the hierarchy
Internships/Volunteering: Spend time with smarter people
and to obey authority and compete with others for hoarded
and do meaningful work - Family Trips: Go on journeys with
resources and power -- then that is a terrible thing to do. Note
the people who matter most - Pick-up Sports: Experience
that when I say "for the benefit of humanity" I do not mean
existential play and find balance - Organized Sports Leagues:
that it cannot be for the benefit of one's self or one's group,
Raise your own game through competition - Meaningful Jobs:
but simply that it cannot be at the expense of others. The idea
Understand what work is - Self Study: To explore a passion
is not to reinforce tribalism, but to act locally in an effort to
- Tutor with small class or individual/ Music class: Learn at
contribute to the welfare of all.
the right pace - Community theater: A common goal for a
disparate group - Book clubs/ discussion groups: Learn to be
as well as learn to know Clark Aldrich , Unschooling Rules ,
Some will say that this is overreacting and that there are good
July 13, 2010 5:40 p.m.. [ Link ] [Tags: Schools , Gaming ] [
things that come from sports. That is fallacy. If I hand you
Previous ][ Next ]
a plate of food laced with pesticide, you cannot defend the
Comments food by saying that it is full of nutrients. The same plate sans
chas, July 13, 2010 7:38 p.m. pesticide offers the same benefits. There is nothing gained
by competitive sports that cannot be gained -- without the
In all, this is a good list. And so true. Schools, after all, are
detrimental effects -- in coöperative activities.
meant to teach conformity and obedience to authority, which
are antithetical to true learning. That is why the schools are
so bad. It's not a lack of control (or lack of money) that
Furthermore, it is also untrue that these issues are too small
makes them so -- it's the desire to break humans that creates
to be worth worrying about. "Oh, it's just a baseball game"
the resistance and, thus, the need for ever more stringent
does not justify competitive behaviors. All of the immense
discipline to overcome the child's innate sense of self worth.
and seemingly intractable problems faced by humanity are
Illich and others made that clear long ago.
immense and intractable precisely because they are not
addressed when they are small and tractable. You drive around
But there are two -- maybe three -- items on this list with
in your car polluting the environment and you think, "It's OK,
which I must take issue. The first two are the sports picks.
I'm only making short trips." But everyone else thinks the
The point of competitive sports is to teach people to act
same thing, and all those short trips add up to environmental
aggressively toward others (as long as there are "rules," of
catastrophe.
course -- just like we make rules for war, which makes war
more likely and more palatable), and to make themselves feel
better by making others feel worse. These skills will come
We have to make the connection very clearly between our
in very handy in the corporate world, where it's all about
everyday actions and the immense and very possibly fatal
hoarding resources and power at the expense of others. They
problems facing us. Everything we do counts, and every single
also make life easy for the government (essentially the same
action, no matter how small and seemingly unimportant, is
thing as the corporate world) by teaching martial attitudes
worth doing correctly. It is also true that the beliefs, habits,
and skills. Competition doesn't make winners, it makes losers.
desires, fears, etc. that we instill in ourselves early in life tend
Coöperate and everyone wins.
to shape the course of our entire lives. Just as an error of
a fraction of a degree at the source might mean missing the
target by 1000 miles, we must consider that every deviation
5
July 14th, 2010 Published by: philosophyandrew
at an early age holds the likelihood of missing the target by a overwhelming firepower to crush other human beings with
significant distance later in life. We should probably also think little or no threat to oneself).
much more carefully about what those targets are and should
be.
The third item with which I take issue, possibly, is the job.
It depends on what one means by a job. If one means taking
It is easy to dismiss the above -- to click away and forget what on responsibility to accomplish something for the benefit of
is written here. It is sad that we all know the truth -- that we humanity, then that is a wonderful calling. But if it means to
haven't much longer on this planet if we do not change our insert oneself into the world of "work" -- that soul-numbing
behaviors -- and yet we continue to do nothing, and to plan for activity in which one again learns one's "place" in the hierarchy
tomorrow and the next day as if they will come without fail and and to obey authority and compete with others for hoarded
be very similar to today. resources and power -- then that is a terrible thing to do. Note
that when I say "for the benefit of humanity" I do not mean
that it cannot be for the benefit of one's self or one's group,
In truth, the last generation of humans may already walk the but simply that it cannot be at the expense of others. The idea
earth. Can anything be more important than this? Should this is not to reinforce tribalism, but to act locally in an effort to
not be our highest priority, constantly in our awareness and contribute to the welfare of all.
shaping our every action? The problems seem insurmountable
when viewed en toto. The secret to success is to correct the
"little" things while they are still little. And to do so every single Some will say that this is overreacting and that there are good
time, with no excuses. [Comment] [Permalink] [Previous] things that come from sports. That is fallacy. If I hand you
[Next] a plate of food laced with pesticide, you cannot defend the
food by saying that it is full of nutrients. The same plate sans
chas, July 13, 2010 7:44 p.m.
pesticide offers the same benefits. There is nothing gained
In all, this is a good list. And so true. Schools, after all, are by competitive sports that cannot be gained -- without the
meant to teach conformity and obedience to authority, which detrimental effects -- in coöperative activities.
are antithetical to true learning. That is why the schools are
so bad. It's not a lack of control (or lack of money) that
makes them so -- it's the desire to break humans that creates Furthermore, it is also untrue that these issues are too small
the resistance and, thus, the need for ever more stringent to be worth worrying about. "Oh, it's just a baseball game"
discipline to overcome the child's innate sense of self worth. does not justify competitive behaviors. All of the immense
Illich and others made that clear long ago. and seemingly intractable problems faced by humanity are
immense and intractable precisely because they are not
But there are two -- maybe three -- items on this list with addressed when they are small and tractable. You drive around
which I must take issue. The first two are the sports picks. in your car polluting the environment and you think, "It's OK,
The point of competitive sports is to teach people to act I'm only making short trips." But everyone else thinks the
aggressively toward others (as long as there are "rules," of same thing, and all those short trips add up to environmental
course -- just like we make rules for war, which makes war catastrophe.
more likely and more palatable), and to make themselves feel
better by making others feel worse. These skills will come
in very handy in the corporate world, where it's all about We have to make the connection very clearly between our
hoarding resources and power at the expense of others. They everyday actions and the immense and very possibly fatal
also make life easy for the government (essentially the same problems facing us. Everything we do counts, and every single
thing as the corporate world) by teaching martial attitudes action, no matter how small and seemingly unimportant, is
and skills. Competition doesn't make winners, it makes losers. worth doing correctly. It is also true that the beliefs, habits,
Coöperate and everyone wins. desires, fears, etc. that we instill in ourselves early in life tend
to shape the course of our entire lives. Just as an error of
a fraction of a degree at the source might mean missing the
Ditto for the "teamwork" canard. One doesn't have to "beat" target by 1000 miles, we must consider that every deviation
other humans to learn teamwork. Teamwork can be learned -- at an early age holds the likelihood of missing the target by a
and probably better learned -- in a coöperative environment. significant distance later in life. We should probably also think
The only competition humans should engage in is competition much more carefully about what those targets are and should
against our own faults and follies. Strive to be better than one be.
is, not better than someone else.
7
July 14th, 2010 Published by: philosophyandrew
Your comment:
Partnership to Enhance the
Enter email to receive
replies: Discovery of Educational
Resources Using the Semantic
Your comments always remain your property, but in posting
them here you agree to license under the same terms as this Web
site ( Creative Commons ). If your comment is offensive it will Source: http://www.downes.ca/cgi-bin/page.cgi?post=52861
be deleted. July 14th, 2010
8
July 14th, 2010 Published by: philosophyandrew
GLRC was created by JES & Co. , which took over management
of the Gateway to Educational Materials (GEM) from the U.S. Know Where: Connectivism's
Department of Education and converted it into the Gateway to Challenges for Longlife
21st Century Skills . "Since its establishment in the early 1990s,
JES & Co. has led and managed The Achievement Standards Learning and Professional
Network (ASN), The Partnership for 21st Century Skills , The
Gateway to 21st Century Skills (formerly known as GEM), the
Training in a Network Society
Source: http://www.downes.ca/cgi-bin/page.cgi?post=52860
Dell Academy , the Intel Student Certification Program , and
July 14th, 2010
Microsoft's Partners in Learning ."
Interesting: Carla Maria Elias has created a 'Connectivism
Through these links I found iLearn Technology and, more Collage' combining images and video. The collage was created
importantly, the i:earn Technology Bloggers Alliance , a with Vuvox Collage , which I hadn't seen before now. Carla
collection of 48 educational technology bloggers. The 21st Maria Elias , elearning hoje , July 13, 2010 8:29 a.m.. [ Link ]
Century Skills bloggers - Peggy's Corner and Joann's Weekly [Tags: Connectivism , Video ] [ Previous ][ Next ]
Picks - have joined this 'alliance'. I've added all 48 to my Comments
aggregator. (This may not be new to you, but it's all new to me.)
Comment
I know people love public-private partnerships but I approach You are not logged in. [Login]
all this with some caution. Selecting a resource at random
(which I see after the fact was featured in Peggy's Corner) I Title
see that it's all about Peeps - the particular resource I looked
at was titled ' Explore Shadows ." The first link I licked in it - Your comment:
this one from WGBH , a PBS station in Boston - popped up a
Enter email to receive
marketing survey from some research company (I closed it by
replies:
instinct and now I can't get it back). There are recommended
books , and a Peep Event Kit . According to the credits the
original Peep cartoons were created by Canada's National Your comments always remain your property, but in posting
Film Board while PEEP and the Big Wide World was created them here you agree to license under the same terms as this
by Eggbox Media, LLC . If I followed another resource, would site ( Creative Commons ). If your comment is offensive it will
it be tied with another product line? be deleted.
Press Release , IMS , July 13, 2010 9:27 a.m.. [ Link ] [Tags:
Google , Canada , Research , Web Logs , Patents , Blogger Automated Spam-checking is in effect. If you are a registered
, Books , Marketing , Microsoft , Copyrights ] [ Previous ] user you may submit links and other HTML. Anonymous users
[ Next ] cannot post links and will have their content screened - certain
words are prohibited and your comment will be analyzed to
Comments make sure it makes sense.
Comment
You are not logged in. [Login]
Title
Your comment: