Professional Documents
Culture Documents
NI 539 - Spectral Fatigue Analysis Methodology For Ships and Offshore Units - 2008 - 07
NI 539 - Spectral Fatigue Analysis Methodology For Ships and Offshore Units - 2008 - 07
July 2008
Guidance Note
NI 539 DT R00 E
July 2008
2 Bureau Veritas July 2008
Section 1 Spectral Fatigue Analysis Methodology
for Ships and Offshore Units
1 General 5
1.1 Introduction
1.2 SFA process
1.3 Conditions of analysis
2 Encountered conditions 5
2.1 Wave scatter diagrams
2.2 Wave spectrum
2.3 Loading conditions
2.4 Wave headings
3 Hydrodynamic analysis 7
3.1 Introduction
3.2 Hydrodynamic model
3.3 Analysis
4 Global structural analysis 8
4.1 Modeling and boundary conditions
4.2 Loading
4.3 Analysis
5 Fine mesh analysis 8
5.1 Modeling and boundary conditions
5.2 Loading
5.3 Hot spot stress RAO
6 Spectral analysis 9
6.1 Response spectrum
6.2 Spectral moments
6.3 Damage calculation
1.1.2 In this note, the fluctuating loads studied for fatigue draught and loading condition
analysis are the wave-induced loads. wave heading.
1.2.2 A Spectral Fatigue Analysis includes the following 2.2.1 Each sea-state is described by a wave energy spectrum
steps, described in Fig 1: of appropriate shape for the voyage or site under consider-
ation (e.g. Pierson-Moskowitz, JONSWAP, Ochi Hubble).
Hydrodynamic analysis: external loads induced by the
waves on the ship structure or offshore unit as well as 2.2.2 To take account of confused short-crested seas, the
the resulting motions are determined by a hydrody- total wave energy spectrum may be split according to wave
namic analysis in frequency domain. direction as follow:
Structural analysis: loads are transferred to the structural S (, ) = S () G (, )
model. Global analysis on a full or partial structural Where S() is the wave spectrum and G(,) the directional
model, followed by a very fine mesh analysis provide spreading function, characterizing the directional distribu-
the RAOs of stresses (Response Amplitude Operators) at tion of the wave energy around the mean direction.
the location of interest.
Spectral analysis: the response spectrum at each location 2.3 Loading conditions
of interest is obtained by the technique of spectral analy-
sis. The short-term distribution of stresses is obtained by 2.3.1 Offshore units
statistics over short-term sea-states, headings and load- The loading conditions that may be considered for SFA of
ing conditions of the ship or offshore unit. Long-term dis- offshore units may be the ones described in NR445 Rules
tribution of stresses during the design lifetime is then for Offshore Units.
obtained by summation over the wave scatter diagrams.
Representative loading conditions of the loading/unloading
Fatigue damage: the fatigue damage is determined by sequences may be selected from the loading manual or
the Miner sum, either from the long-term distribution of from operating data. Each loading condition being charac-
stress ranges and appropriate S-N curve or by summa- terized by the levels in oil and water ballast tanks and the
tion of fatigue damage for each short-term response. associated draught.
(
$
$
)
* !
%&
$
$
'
2.3.2 Oil tankers For a trading ship or a spread moored unit, the range of
The loading conditions that may be considered for SFA of headings has to cover 360.
oil tankers are the full load and ballast conditions, as
described in IACS Common Structural Rules for Double When the offshore unit is turret moored, the wave headings
Hull Oil Tankers or NR467 Rules for Steel Ships as the case of interest can be generally taken in the range [-90, 90]
may be. from head sea. The range of wave headings may be deter-
mined more precisely by performing a heading study. In this
2.3.3 Bulk carriers case, the environmental conditions (wave current, wind) are
The loading conditions that may be considered for SFA of to be combined as described in NI493 Classification of
bulk carriers are the homogeneous, normal ballast, heavy Mooring Systems for Permanent Offshore Units, Appendix 2.
ballast and eventually alternate conditions (depending on
bulk carrier notation), as described in IACS Common Struc- When swell and wind seas are independant, both condi-
tural Rules for Bulk Carriers or NR467 Rules for Steel Ships tions are to be computed separately.
as the case may be.
2.4.2 A heading interval in the range of 15 to 22 will be
2.3.4 Other ships adequate to get accurate directional response using direc-
The loading conditions that may be considered for SFA of tional spectrum.
other ships are the ones described in NR467 Rules for Steel
Ships. The heading interval is often taken as 45, in relation with
commonly available directional information. This is how-
2.4 Wave headings ever not sufficient to catch the directional response of the
structure to waves (e.g. horizontal wave bending moment)
2.4.1 The range of headings to be considered depends on and precludes the use of directional spectrum to describe
the type of ship or offshore unit. waves.
3.2.1 General The motion analysis will account for such loads as the
external loads by incident and diffracted wave, the inertial
The model should take into account the following effects:
loads, the hydrodynamic added mass and damping loads
The ship or unit forms with appendices (e.g. skeg), if any and the hydrostatic restoring forces.
The weight distribution of the loading conditions
described in [3.2.2], including lightship distribution 3.3.2 Range of frequencies
The connections with the seabed if any. A range of wave frequencies of 0,1 to 1,5 rad/s is normally
sufficient.
For each loading condition, the hydrodynamic model is to
30 to 35 wave frequencies is adequate. 20 is a minimum.
be consistent with the loading manual in terms of mass dis-
tribution, inertia, trim, still water bending moments and A refinement around the ship resonance frequency is rec-
shear forces. ommended.
4 Global structural analysis 4.2.4 Internal tank pressure and cargo loads
The pressure in internal tank or cargo hold is deduced from
4.1 Modeling and boundary conditions the tank accelerations.
A quasi-static approximation may be used, under the
4.1.1 General assumption of small movements of the ship or offshore unit,
The structural model may be a full model, or includes sev- where the pressure is defined based on the intensity and
eral cargo holds (generally 3), centered on the area of inter- angular variations of the total acceleration, including gravity.
est for the fatigue analysis. Non-linearities induced by pressure distribution in internal
Attention is to be paid for the mesh on the waterline area, tank and cargo hold is to be avoided as fatigue calculation
for the considered loading conditions. In this area, the is performed in the frequency domain.
height of panels is to be reduced. A panel height equal to
4.2.5 Inertia loadings
ordinary stiffener spacing may be used.
The inertia loading is generated from the accelerations act-
4.1.2 Full model ing on the steel mass of the structure, and other masses.
In the case of a full model, modeling and boundary condi-
4.2.6 Hull girder loads for three holds models
tions are to be in accordance with NR467 Rules for Steel
Ships , Pt B, Ch 7, App 3, [2]. In the case of a three holds model, hull girder bending
moments and shear forces are to be determined to represent
4.1.3 Three holds model the ends of the model, and are used as boundary conditions.
In the case of a three holds model and depending on the
ship or unit type, modeling and boundary conditions are to 4.3 Analysis
be in accordance with:
4.3.1 When structural analysis takes into account still water
Rules for Offshore Units (NR445) and dynamic effects, an additional still water calculation is
CSR for Oil Tankers (NR523) to be performed for each loading condition.
CSR for Bulk Carriers (NR522)
4.3.2 The RAOs of displacements of the global calculation
Rules for Steel Ships (NR467). are extracted in the area of fatigue interest as boundary con-
ditions for the fine mesh analysis.
4.2 Loading
4.2.1 General
5 Fine mesh analysis
Wave pressures and inertia loads obtained from the hydro-
dynamic analysis are to be transferred from the hydrody- 5.1 Modeling and boundary conditions
namic model into the structural model. Hydrodynamic and
5.1.1 Depending on the ship or unit type, fine mesh model-
structural models have to be consistent, both in geometry
ing and boundary conditions are to be in accordance with:
and in the description of mass.
Rules for Offshore Units (NR445)
Under the assumptions of a linear spectral analysis, overall
CSR for Oil Tankers (NR523)
loading for each combination of frequency, wave heading
and loading is harmonic and can be described by real and CSR for Bulk Carriers (NR522)
imaginary parts. Rules for Steel Ships (NR467).
For each loading condition, this stress is to be deduced to the Mean zero-up-crossing period of the stress response:
real and imaginary hot spot stresses calculated for the differ-
m
ent load cases (combinations of frequency and heading). T z = 2 -------0
m2
5.3.3 On the free surface area, the hot spot stresses RAO
are to be corrected to take account of the intermittent wet- 6.2.2 In the case of a ship with an advance speed V, the
ting effect. spectral moments are given by:
The RAO correction may be based on an additional stress,
S ( ) d
n
function of an additional loading and combined with the Mn = e
S ( H s, T z, ) = H ( ) S ( Hs , T z )
2
6.3.2 Short-term damage for a single slope S-N
curve
H (,) is the stress range transfer function obtained for
For a single slope S-N curve, the damage corresponding to
each loading condition, whose values depend on the wave
one sea-state spectrum (Hs, Tz) is given as follow:
frequency and on the heading angle. It contains all the
D = ------------- ( 2 2m 0 ) ----- + 1
RAOs of stresses. T m m
K Tz 2
When directional spreading is considered according to
[2.2], the stress response is obtained as: where:
K,m : S-N curve parameters of the single slope S-N
S ( H s, T z, ) = H ( ) S ( Hs , T z ) G ( , )
2
curve
6.1.2 Mean stress effect T : Reference duration
The response spectrum may be corrected to take account of m0 : Spectral moment of order 0
the less damaging effect of the compressive part of the stress : Gamma function.
range, for each loading condition if any.
6.3.3 Short-term damage for a two slopes S-N curve
The correction requires the mean stress calculation at loca-
For a two slopes S-N curve, the damage corresponding to
tion of interest for each loading condition.
one sea-state spectrum (Hs, Tz) is given as follow:
Depending on the ship or unit type, Mean stress effect cor-
D = ------------- ( 2 2m 0 ) ----- + 1
T m m
rection may be carried out according to:
K Tz 2
Rules for Offshore Units (NR445)
where:
CSR for Oil Tankers (NR523)
: Coefficient taking account of the change of
CSR for Bulk Carriers (NR522) slope in the S-N curve, taken equal to:
Rules for Steel Ships (NR467).
m K m m m
1 + ----- ;A + ----- ( 2 2m0 ) 1 + ------ ;A
2 K 2
6.2 Spectral moments = --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1 + -----
m
6.2.1 The spectral moments of order n of the stress process 2
are given by: A : Coefficient taken equal to:
SQ 2
A = ------------------
S ( ) d
n
Mn = 2 2m
0
0
K, m : Parameters of the S-N curve above change of
Assuming that the stress process is stationary and Gaussian, slope
the statistical parameters of the stress process are obtained
from the spectral moments as follow: K, m : Parameters of the S-N curve below change of
slope
RMS (Root Mean Square):
T : Reference duration
RMS = m0 m0 : Spectral moment of order 0
where:
SQ : Stress range at change of slope on the S-N
curve. Pri : Joint-Probability of (Hs, Tz) of the considered
sea-state in the scatter diagram
6.3.4 Long-term damage Prj : Probability of occurence of each wave heading
The long-term damage is the sum of the short-term dam- Prk : Probability of occurence of the considered
ages, weighted by the probability of occurence of each loading condition
loading state, considering the number of stress cycles in this Dijk : Short-term damage calculated in [6.3.2] or
loading state. [6.3.3].